Bored is fine

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 53 min

You leave the house at ten past eight. Before the door has closed, the headphones are in and the podcast is on, the history one or the news one or whatever's next in the queue. The walk to the car takes four minutes. At the car the podcast moves to the speakers. At work, while the kettle boils, the headphones go back in for the two minutes it takes. At the post office the phone is out before you've joined the queue.

In the evening the radio goes on as you come in and stays on while you cook, though you couldn't say afterwards what was on it. There's a speaker in the shower. In bed there's an audiobook set to stop after thirty minutes, and you're asleep before it does, and if you wake at three you put it on again.

Not one minute of that day had nothing coming in. Try to remember the last day that did. You'll probably go back to spring, or a power cut, or being ill.

Nobody decided this. Each fill made sense on its own, and over time the fill became what quiet is for, so a minute without it now feels like a minute with something wrong.

The habit makes sense from the inside. The fill is pleasant, some of it is worth hearing, and the quiet really is uncomfortable, in a way that's been measured. But I think the discomfort belongs to the first few minutes and says little about quiet itself. Boredom is a signal with a job to do, and the fill switches it off without doing the job. And some things only happen in a mind with nothing put into it. Ideas finishing. The day getting sorted. Noticing where you are. Those have been going missing for a while. What I'll suggest is small. One stretch of your day is quiet, gaps under five minutes stay empty, and whatever else you put on, you choose.

You don't have to give up podcasts, radio or television, or meditate, or sit in silence for an hour.

Three cautions, and they matter. If quiet brings dread rather than restlessness, or racing thoughts, or thoughts that frighten you, that isn't the itch I'm describing, and this isn't the answer. Talk to a GP, or in England refer yourself to NHS talking therapies. The fill may have been doing a job that needs a better tool. If you have tinnitus, background sound is part of how many people manage it, and nothing here asks you to remove it. Follow the NHS guidance on tinnitus over anything I say. And if every minute is filled because the empty ones have been low for a fortnight or more, that's a change in your health, and a GP should hear about it.

Tomorrow, keep a list of every quiet minute that could have been. The walk, the kettle, the queue, the shower, the drive, the last stretch in bed. Next to each, write what went into it. At the end of the day, count the ones that stayed empty. For most people the count is zero.

The first five minutes

The case for the fill is a good one, and the people who fill every minute are usually the curious ones.

  • It's pleasant. A good podcast is good company, and music in the shower is one of the small joys of a morning.
  • It's learning. You know more about the Byzantine Empire than you did a year ago.
  • It's efficient. Four minutes to the car would otherwise be wasted.
  • Silence is awkward, even alone.
  • Left alone, the mind goes to bad places.

The needs under these are real, and most of the fill gets to stay. What the default costs is something only quiet provides, and the discomfort it protects you from turns out to be smaller and shorter than it feels.

Start with the belief that's true. Silence is uncomfortable.

In 2014 Timothy Wilson and colleagues ran eleven studies in which people sat alone in a room for six to fifteen minutes with nothing to do but think. Most didn't enjoy it. Given the choice, they preferred dull activities to their own thoughts. In one study a good proportion chose to give themselves a mild electric shock rather than sit there, including people who'd said earlier that they'd pay to avoid it.

So the itch is real, and feeling it isn't weakness. A walk to the car with no podcast produces a small version of the same thing.

Look at what the study measured, though. Six to fifteen minutes, in a bare room, with instructions to entertain yourself with your thoughts and nothing else. That's the itch at its worst, the first minutes of quiet in a strange setting. The study stopped before anyone found out what comes after the itch. If you've filled every minute for years, so have you.

"My mind goes to bad places." It does. Matthew Killingsworth and Daniel Gilbert, in 2010, used a phone app to ask thousands of people at random moments what they were doing, what they were thinking about and how they felt. Minds were elsewhere almost half the time, and people whose minds were wandering were on average less happy, whatever they were doing. A wandering mind, their title said, is an unhappy mind. I'll take that as honest evidence against me.

But look at what's in the bad places. The meeting. The unanswered email. The worry about your mother. That's the day and the week turning up to be dealt with, in the first slot all day when attention was free. The fill doesn't remove them. It postpones them, to three in the morning, when the audiobook has stopped and there's nothing left to postpone with. That's why three in the morning is where a lot of filled lives do their thinking.

There's a difference worth noticing between going over the same scene again with nothing new in it, and the drift. In the drift the meeting gets filed, the email gets a first sentence, and the worry about your mother turns into a plan to ring her. It feels unpleasant the way sorting does. The fill has stood between you and the sorting for long enough that the pile has grown.

Some people use the fill for nerves. The podcast on the way to work keeps the dread about the day at bay, the radio keeps worry out of the evening, the audiobook is the difference between sleep and lying there with your heart going. There are two versions of this. In the ordinary one, the fill ends the itch, and ending something unpleasant feels like calm. In my observation the itch, stayed with, turns into the drift, and the drift is calmer than the fill, because the mind is doing what it does when nothing comes in, rather than being held off something. The fill is calm with a lid on.

The second version is different. If what the quiet lets in is dread, or a racing heart, or thoughts you'd rather not have, the fill has been doing a job that matters. Don't take it away from a mind that's using it to stay level. See a GP, or refer yourself to NHS talking therapies, and leave the podcast on until then.

How do you tell which you've got? Notice what the quiet holds at minute five. Restlessness that's fading, and a thought about the email, is the itch. Something that's climbing, which you'd call fear rather than boredom, is the second kind, and the method waits.

"I've tried it and it was awful." Probably you tried fifteen minutes, cold, after years of fill, which is Wilson's experiment without the shock, and it went the way the study predicted. In my experience the itch is loudest for the first two or three minutes and quieter by five, and by ten something else has usually turned up, a thought that finishes or a thing you notice. You've only ever had the first five. So start smaller. Four minutes to the car, once a day. You'll be at the car before the itch gets going.

A field never left fallow

"I'm learning something." This is the belief that makes the fill feel like a virtue, and the answer is to separate the input from what happens to it afterwards.

Benjamin Baird and colleagues, in 2012, gave people a creative problem, then a break, then the problem again. During the break some did a demanding task, some an undemanding one, some rested and some had no break at all. The people given the undemanding task, the one that let their minds wander, improved most on the problems they'd already seen. That was more than the ones who rested, and more than the ones who worked hard at something else. The undemanding stretch was where the incubation happened.

Now think of your week. An hour on the Byzantine Empire, excellent, and then the next episode started, then the radio, then the audiobook. There was never an undemanding stretch for the hour to do anything in. Ask yourself what you remember from last month's episodes. In my experience it's mostly the feeling of having learned something, and not much of the something.

A field that's never left fallow takes seed every season and yields less each year.

Someone who hears one episode and then walks in quiet has learned more from it than someone who hears three, because the episode had somewhere to go.

"It's just background." Erin Westgate and Timothy Wilson set out a model of boredom in 2018. Boredom, in their account, is what you feel when your attention isn't engaged in something you value, and that can happen in two ways. There may be too little to engage with, or too much, or something too demanding, so attention can't settle. What follows is my reading of the model, not something it found. The hum seems to me to be the second kind. A voice talking in the kitchen pulls at the part of the mind that processes speech whether you've decided to listen or not, and a television in the corner pulls the eyes. You aren't attending to the hum, but it's tugging at you all evening in small pieces. It would explain something filled people often describe, which is being tired in the evening in a way that doesn't match what they did, in a house where something's always on.

"I'd be bored." Yes, for a few minutes.

John Eastwood and colleagues, in 2012, defined boredom in a way most researchers in the field now work from. It's the unpleasant experience of wanting to engage in satisfying activity and being unable to. Your attention won't settle on anything inside or outside your head, you know it won't, and you blame the situation. That's the itch, in a laboratory's language.

Shane Bench and Heather Lench, in 2013, asked what boredom is for. Drawing on the evidence, they argued it's a signal. When what you're doing has stopped being worthwhile, boredom makes carrying on unpleasant, pulls your attention away, and makes you readier to look for something else.

So boredom is pointing somewhere. The fill answers it by switching it off. The podcast goes in, attention settles on the podcast, and the boredom stops. Whatever it was pointing at, the unwritten thing, the friend you haven't rung, the weekend you haven't planned, is still there, with nothing pointing at it any more. You know you're restless. You never find out what about, because the fill arrives before the restlessness has had time to become specific.

"Boredom is a waste of time." Sandi Mann and Rebekah Cadman, in 2014, had people do something boring first, copying or reading numbers from a phone directory, and then come up with uses for a pair of plastic cups. The bored people came up with more ideas. In the second study, the boring reading task helped more than the boring writing one, and the researchers suggested that daydreaming, which reading leaves more room for, might be the link. They were small studies, eighty and ninety people, and I'd hold the numbers loosely. The direction fits Baird's. The solution to the problem at work, the sentence for the difficult email, the decision about the house, none of these turn up during a podcast. They turn up in the shower, on the walk, in the queue, exactly the minutes the fill has taken. People who've filled every minute for years say they've stopped having ideas and wonder if they're getting older. They've got fuller.

"I don't have time to do nothing." The walk to the car takes four minutes with a podcast and four without. The fill doesn't save time. It decides what the time is spent on. The person walking without a podcast is noticing the street, letting the meeting file itself, finding the first line of the email. If you're truly too busy for that, your day needs sorting more than most, and the sorting happens on the pavement or it happens at three in the morning.

"The phone's the problem, not the podcast." The phone is worse in some ways. Dora and colleagues, in 2021, had eighty-three PhD students rate their tiredness and boredom every hour while their phone use was logged. People were more likely to pick up the phone when tired or bored, and reported more tiredness and boredom afterwards. That's a small exploratory study about phones, and I wouldn't carry it over to podcasts. What the two share is simpler. Both go into a quiet minute by default and take the attention the quiet would have had. The podcast is better company and harder to question, because it feels like a virtue, and so nobody asks what the history is pushing out.

"It's company." Loneliness is real, and the fill covers it. But a podcast host can't hear you. They don't ask about your day or notice when you go quiet. You can fill a house with voices and go a week without a conversation, and not feel the gap, because the voices sound like the thing that's missing. Compare a walk with a podcast to a walk with a friend. The second is slower and has pauses in it, and you arrive knowing something about a person who knows something about you. The first arrives knowing something about the Byzantine Empire. The quiet was what would have sent you to ring someone.

"Everyone's got headphones in." They have, and that tells you what's normal, not what it costs. The children are learning it too. A child in a waiting room with a screen learns that a quiet minute is something to fill, at the age when what a minute is for gets decided. Children used to be bored, and out of the long afternoons came the games and the drawings and the walk to a friend's house. That push toward something new is exactly what Bench and Lench describe. If you want one reason to leave the walk empty that has nothing to do with you, a child who sees a parent walk with nothing in their ears learns that it can be done.

"I need it to fall asleep." If every waking minute has been filled, the mind reaches bedtime with a whole day unfiled. The filing starts at the pillow, it feels like racing, and the audiobook goes on to stop it. Some people do sleep better with sound, though, and if the audiobook works, keep it. Make it a chapter you want to hear, on a timer, and give the day a quiet stretch earlier so the pillow isn't the first one.

Here's what goes missing.

  • The thought that finishes. You've had the beginnings of a hundred ideas this year and the end of very few.
  • The street. The house being painted, the neighbour you'd have said hello to, the light on the church at a quarter to eight. The NHS lists paying attention to the present moment among its steps to mental wellbeing.
  • The decision that turns up in the shower, already made.
  • The day itself. A day sorted in the drift is one you can remember. Filled days run together, and people say the year has gone fast.
  • The remark your child made in the car, over the radio, which wasn't heard and won't be repeated.
  • How you are. Tired, hungry, flat, fine. If you're never in quiet, you find out at three in the morning, or at the doctor's.
  • The taste for quiet. After years of fill, the quiet has come to feel strange, and the preference for noise feels like a fact about you. It's a fact about the last few years, and it can turn round in weeks.
  • Rest. The fill is input, and a day of unbroken input has no rest in it, whatever the sofa says.

Headphones in the bag

Pick one stretch of your day. The walk to the car, the shower, the kettle and the ten minutes around it, the drive home. Choose the one that's easiest to leave empty, because the first week is about finding out that quiet ends and nothing bad happens in it. For most people it's the walk. It has a beginning and an end, and legs to keep the itch company.

Nothing on. That means no quieter music and no calmer podcast. Headphones in the bag, radio off, phone in your pocket with the screen dark. Keep the stretch its natural length. If the walk is four minutes, it's four. You aren't building endurance. An empty four minutes does in a small way what an empty forty would, and four is the one you'll repeat tomorrow.

Expect the itch. In the first week it'll take most of the walk and you'll reach the car twitchy. That's fine. The itch is being allowed to happen and end, and each time it ends, the next one is shorter.

Then let the drift go where it goes. Don't steer it, and don't try to think about nothing. It'll go to the meeting and the email and your mother, which is the sorting, and if it wanders somewhere useless it'll come back. Once, on the walk, look at the street. A house, a tree, a person you've walked past with a podcast on for a year.

Do that one stretch, daily, for a fortnight before you change anything else. If the only stretch you have is two minutes to the bus, it's two minutes.

Then the small ones. The queue, the lift, the kettle, the platform, the car park. Gaps under five minutes stay empty. Three minutes of a podcast in a queue is three minutes you'll have to rewind. Three minutes of nothing is long enough for the thought you started in the shower to finish.

Keep the headphones in the bag, not your coat pocket. The pocket is where the default lives, because headphones in a pocket reach your ears without a decision. The bag puts a step in the way, and the step is where you decide. Walk into the kitchen and leave the radio off. In a queue, keep the phone dark and look at the shop. This is what minutes were for before there was anything to put in them. And you'll find the small ones easier than the big one, since the itch in a two-minute wait barely has time to start, and there are twenty of them a day.

Everything else can stay, on one condition. You choose it.

A chosen listen is a podcast you want, at a time you picked, with your attention on it, sitting down or on a longer walk set aside for it. Turn off autoplay so the episode ends and the next one doesn't start by itself. The quiet minute after it is where the episode gets to turn into a thought. Put the radio on for a programme and off when it ends, and cook in the quiet. A television you sit down to watch is a chosen thing. A television on in the corner while the evening goes on around it is the hum. Music can be either, and the test is whether you'd notice if it stopped.

Before anything goes on, ask one question. Am I choosing this, or is this the default? If you're choosing it, enjoy it. If it's the default, leave the minute empty and see what turns up. Most people find that about a third of what they used to put on was chosen. They miss the other two-thirds less than they feared and enjoy the third more.

So here's the decision. One stretch of my day is quiet, gaps under five minutes stay empty, and everything else I put on, I choose.

Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran reviewed ninety-four studies in 2006 of plans made in the form "when this happens, I'll do that". People who plan this way follow through much more often than people who only hold the intention. So write three.

  • When I leave the house for the car, I'll leave the headphones in my bag and walk with nothing on.
  • When I join a queue or wait for anything under five minutes, I'll keep the phone in my pocket and look at where I am.
  • When I reach for the radio or a podcast, I'll ask whether I'm choosing it, and if I'm not, I'll leave the minute empty.

A few places need a line each.

A forty-minute commute is long enough for both. Try the first half quiet and the second half a chosen listen. Music that carries you through a run is chosen, and I'd keep it, though one run a week with nothing on has a rhythm of its own. The washing up, the ironing and the garden are exactly the undemanding tasks Baird's study was about, so try a week of washing up in quiet and see what arrives. In the car with the radio off, children talk, and a parent can hear them. It's one of the few places they'll tell you things.

If you have tinnitus, the NHS says not to have total silence, that soft music or sounds can distract from it, and that loud background noise can make it worse. The quiet stretch isn't for you, and the sound you keep on is treatment. Tinnitus UK has a free helpline on 0800 018 0527. Follow the NHS guidance rather than this.

If what arrives in the quiet is dread, thoughts racing too fast to follow, thoughts that frighten you, or a low mood that's been there most of the day for a fortnight, that isn't the itch. See a GP, or in England refer yourself to NHS talking therapies. What I'm offering is for ordinary minds meeting ordinary quiet, and it isn't a treatment for anything.

And if every quiet minute has felt intolerable for as long as you can remember, alongside lifelong restlessness, distraction and trouble finishing things, the NHS pages on attention deficit hyperactivity disorder describe that pattern, and a GP can arrange an assessment. Smaller stretches may still help. But the itch is a different size for you, and I won't pretend otherwise.

The friend in the car park

What I'd expect, though it's a guess and not a finding, is that the first three days the walk to the car will be four twitchy minutes and you'll arrive feeling deprived. By the end of the first week the itch will be shorter, and you'll have noticed the street once and been surprised. In the second week a thought that's been half-formed for a month will finish on the walk. By the third week the kitchen will be quiet by default. You'll listen to fewer podcasts and remember more of them.

Then a tired morning, a new episode out, and the headphones in your coat pocket where they used to live. The walk has a podcast in it before you've thought. You notice at the car.

That's one filled walk. Last month every walk was filled.

Take them out when you notice, at the car or halfway down the road. Half a walk in quiet is half a walk's worth of drift. What you need is the noticing, and you noticed.

Then find what got through. Headphones in the pocket go back in the bag tonight. A new episode you were excited about becomes a chosen listen, sitting down this evening, with an end. A bad morning that wanted company probably wanted a person, and the quiet walk is where you'd have worked out who.

Don't keep a streak of empty days. Count quiet stretches. The fill will take a walk now and then for the rest of your life, and each time you'll notice sooner.

Some months on, you leave the house at ten past eight with the headphones in the bag. The walk to the car is four minutes of street. The house on the corner had scaffolding on Tuesday, and today it's gone. Somewhere around the second lamp post, the thing about the email finishes. You've had the first half for a week, and the second half arrives on the pavement, whole.

Last night you listened to one podcast at the kitchen table with a cup of tea, the whole episode, and when it ended the next one didn't start. You sat for a minute with it in your head. You can still tell someone what it was about, which you couldn't have said of any of them a year ago.

In the car the radio's off, and your daughter tells you about something at school she wouldn't have mentioned over a programme. You hear it and ask a question.

On Thursday, in the car park, you were properly bored for a minute, itch and all. You stood there and let it be. After a minute it turned into a thought about the friend you haven't rung since spring, and you rang her that evening.

Tomorrow, leave the headphones in the bag, walk to the car with nothing on, and look at the street.