Breakfast isn't the problem

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 53 min

It's Sunday night. The weekend went the way weekends go, and now you're on the sofa with your phone, and the app is downloaded. Tomorrow it starts. No bread, or nothing after seven, or a shake at lunch. You feel something close to relief, because the last few weeks have been a mess and this puts a shape on the next ones.

Monday is good. Tuesday is good. Wednesday you're hungry by four, but you hold.

Thursday there's an open box of biscuits on the desk at work, and at half past three you have one. Then, because you've had one, the day has gone, so you have three more, and at home there's the thing you said you wouldn't have, and you have that too, because Thursday is finished anyway. Friday is a takeaway and the word "Monday". The weekend is what it would have been without the diet, plus a feeling. On Monday you don't start. A fortnight later, on a Sunday night, there's a new app.

How many of these have there been? Most people who stop to count find dozens over a few years. They'd never added them up, because each one felt like a separate event with its own separate failure, and each time the blame landed in the same place.

They aren't separate. It's one thing happening over and over, and it has a shape. A fresh start with rules in it. A first break, the Thursday biscuit. The write-off, which is what you say after the biscuit, that the day's ruined or the week's gone. The blame, greedy, weak, hopeless. Then the next fresh start.

The diets ended the same way every time because that's how diets end. Restriction sets up its own collapse. And the way out is small. You stop starting diets. You eat three ordinary meals a day and don't skip, and when you've eaten more than you meant to, the next meal is an ordinary meal.

I take no position on whether you should lose weight. That's between you, your body and, if you want one, your GP. What I'll argue is that the cycle doesn't get you there, and that it costs you a good deal on the way.

Four cautions, and please read them. If your eating involves large amounts with a feeling of losing control, or making yourself sick, or going long stretches without food on purpose, or if food and your body take up most of your thinking most of the day, that isn't the habit I'm writing about. It may be an eating disorder, which is an illness with good treatment. The charity Beat and your GP are the places to start, and they're used to being asked. If a clinician has put you on a diet, or you take medication for weight, follow them. If you've been told to lose weight for a medical reason, the part about the cycle still applies, and the NHS route comes later. In England you can refer yourself to NHS weight management services without seeing a GP first. And if you're pregnant or under eighteen, this isn't written for you. Talk to your midwife or your GP.

One thing before you go on. On the back of an envelope, list every diet you can remember starting in the last three years. Next to each, roughly how long it lasted and how it ended. Not why. How. The biscuit, the birthday, the holiday, the bad week. Keep the envelope. It's the most useful document you'll look at today, and you wrote it years ago without noticing.

The best night of the week

Sunday night is the best night of the cycle. Everything is ahead of you and none of it has gone wrong yet.

The fresh start gives you real things, and you're not a fool for reaching for it. The first week goes well. The scale drops by several pounds, and it hardly matters to the feeling that most of that is water. A week with rules in it is a week where you know what to do at every meal, with no deciding and no negotiating. After a fortnight of drift, it says that you decide what goes in. And when you'd like something about your body or your eating to be different, a plan is the only tool anyone has offered you. The magazines, the apps, the January adverts and the office all hand you the same thing. Picking it up is just taking what's on the table.

Those needs are real. Structure, hope, being in charge, doing something about a thing that bothers you. The trouble is that the fresh start meets them for a fortnight and then hands you the write-off and the blame, and the blame is what makes the next fresh start feel necessary.

The belief the cycle runs on is that you didn't hold. Other people hold. Next time you'll have more discipline.

Look at the envelope. I'd expect it to read like one story. A biscuit, a birthday, a bad day, a meal out. Different rules, different lengths, the same ending at roughly the same point. If discipline were what decided it, you'd expect some variety, a few ended by weakness, a few by bad luck, one or two still going. Identical endings are the signature of a design.

In 1975 Peter Herman and Deborah Mack gave people a milkshake or two and then a taste test where they could eat as much as they liked. People who didn't diet ate less after the bigger milkshake, as you'd expect. People who scored high on what the researchers called restraint, the habit of dieting and watching what they eat, ate more. Having broken their rule, they carried on. The word for that is the one you'd use on Thursday afternoon. Might as well.

Herman and Janet Polivy later set out the case that dieting causes the overeating it's meant to prevent, and that one finding carries most of it. A person who isn't dieting eats the biscuit and stops, because a biscuit is a biscuit. A person on a diet eats the biscuit and it becomes a write-off, because the biscuit broke something. So the discipline you'd need next time is the discipline never to break a rule once, for the rest of your life, in a world with biscuits in it. Nobody has that. When a bridge built for a load it can't carry falls down, nobody blames the traffic.

Then there's the planning, the part you'd defend most. The shopping, the clear fridge. It feels like getting ready.

In 2002 Dax Urbszat, Herman and Polivy told some people they'd be dieting for the coming week and told others nothing. Then, straight away, before any diet had begun, everyone did a taste test. For people who didn't usually diet, the news made no difference. Among restrained eaters, the ones who'd been told a diet was coming ate significantly more than the ones who hadn't. Merely planning to diet made them eat.

So what is your Sunday night? For most people it's a last supper. The takeaway, the rest of the wine, the thing you won't be allowed from tomorrow, eaten because it won't be allowed. That's the diet's first effect, arriving a day early, just as it did in the laboratory. Planning meals is fine, and there's a shopping list coming later. Planning restriction is what runs the wrong way.

"Last time was the wrong plan." The shakes were unrealistic, the points were fiddly, the fasting made you dizzy. This one is sensible.

The rules on the envelope are all different, though, and the endings are all the same. If the rules were the problem, changing them would have changed the ending by now. The problem is having rules at all. Whatever a diet forbids, it's a list of things you're not allowed, and Herman and Mack's finding is about what not-allowed does to people who diet.

In 2007 Traci Mann and colleagues went through the long-term studies of calorie-restricting diets and concluded that dieting doesn't work as a treatment for obesity. Between a third and two-thirds of dieters ended up heavier than before, and the authors argued the true figure is probably worse, because people who'd regained tended to drop out. It's a review that argues a position. The direction isn't really in dispute.

So when the new plan says it's different, ask what it forbids. If it forbids anything, it's already on the envelope under another name.

A body that wants it back

"But it worked. I lost a stone."

That's true, and it deserves a fair answer. You've lost weight on diets more than once, which tells you that losing was never the hard part. You've done it a dozen times. The goal was to have lost it for good, and on that measure the envelope shows a dozen results.

James Anderson and colleagues, in 2001, pooled twenty-nine American studies of structured weight-loss programmes that followed people for at least two years. Five years after finishing, the average participant was still about three kilograms lighter, a little over three per cent of their starting weight. So diets aren't a total failure. But a few pounds isn't the stone, and the people who drop out of weight-loss follow-up aren't usually the ones doing well, so even that figure may flatter them. The loss and the regain are one process with two halves. You called the first half success and the second half your failure. I'd call them both the diet.

The wedding diet is at least honest about ending. The photos are taken, the rules come off, and the fortnight after is the fortnight after any diet, only faster. On the day itself it gives you someone who's been hungry for six weeks at a party with a buffet. If you want to look well at the wedding, sleep, wear something you like, and eat breakfast.

Now the part people blame themselves for most. You lose the weight, and you assume keeping it off is a matter of not being silly afterwards.

Priya Sumithran and colleagues, in 2011, put fifty overweight or obese people on a ten-week very low energy diet. They lost about thirteen and a half kilograms each, over two stone. The researchers measured the hormones that regulate appetite and asked people how hungry they were, at the start, at ten weeks, and a year later. At ten weeks the hormones that signal fullness had fallen, the one that signals hunger had risen, and people said they felt hungrier. The question was whether that would settle. At sixty-two weeks most of the hormones were still shifted, and so was the hunger. A year after losing the weight, the body was still, measurably, asking for it back.

So the hunger isn't in your head. It's in your blood, and the weight loss put it there.

The rules add their own load. Janet Tomiyama, Mann and colleagues assigned a hundred and twenty-one women for three weeks to restrict their calories, or track them, or both, or neither. Restricting raised cortisol, a stress hormone. Tracking raised how stressed people said they felt.

Now look at Thursday again. A person whose hunger has been raised by weight loss and whose stress has been raised by the rules, and who's been told that the hunger doesn't count, sits at a desk with an open box of biscuits. That's a hungry, stressed person meeting a biscuit. Nobody is sitting a test of character.

The fear that keeps all this going is that without diets you'll just keep gaining. The evidence leans the other way. It's observational, so I'll be careful with it. Kirsi Pietiläinen and colleagues followed over four thousand Finnish twins from sixteen to twenty-five. Those who'd dieted were more likely to be overweight at twenty-five, and in identical pairs where one twin had dieted and the other hadn't, the dieting twin ended up a little heavier. The authors' reading was that dieting mostly reflects a tendency to gain weight, and that dieting itself may add a little on top. A five-year study of American teenagers by Dianne Neumark-Sztainer and colleagues points the same way, though some of those teenagers used severe methods. Dieting, followed forward in time, goes with more weight. You've run this test on yourself a dozen times. Were the dieting years years of losing?

Then the blame. Greedy, weak, no willpower. You've said it on so many Fridays that the repetition starts to feel like proof.

Put it next to what happened. Restraint makes a break lead to more eating. Planning makes you eat on Sunday. Weight loss raises hunger for a year. Restriction raises cortisol. Then a biscuit arrives. Eating it and four more is the diet's effects turning up in the order the research predicts, and greed is the name the diet gives its own consequences so that you'll start another one.

That's the job the blame does. If Thursday was your fault, the answer is to try harder, and trying harder means a new plan, and the new plan is Sunday night's relief. Someone who saw that Thursday was the diet's fault wouldn't need a better diet. They'd stop having them.

Often the word has a history. It was said to you, or about you, at a table when you were small, and it came with a look. The diet didn't invent it. It found it there and gave it a Friday to be said on. Run the friend test once. A friend tells you she was on a diet, had a biscuit on Thursday and ate the rest of the box. You wouldn't call her greedy. You'd say something about the diet. Say that to yourself.

And the weight? You may want it to change, and that's fair. But the weight and the cycle are separate problems, and you've been treating the second as the cure for the first. If you'd like to lose weight, the NHS route is the opposite of a fresh start, and it comes with the method below. If your weight is a medical question, or it goes with diabetes, joint problems, breathlessness or anything else you've been told about, the GP is the first conversation, before any plan off the internet.

Meanwhile, most of the bill never shows up on the scales.

  • A dozen Fridays a year of calling yourself names, for a decade.
  • Fortnights of raised stress, repeated for years.
  • Food on your mind most of the day, because forbidden things take up room.
  • Apps, shakes, and special foods going off in the fridge in week two.
  • Meals that were either compliance or eaten fast with a feeling. Neither was dinner.
  • A partner who asks whether it's a diet week before suggesting a restaurant, and a child at the table on Friday learning what eating is.

The quietest cost lands on appetite. Someone who's never dieted eats when hungry and stops when satisfied, without thinking about it. A diet replaces that with rules, and when the plan ends, appetite doesn't snap back. What fills the gap is the absence of rules. You eat because nothing forbids it, and that's the fortnight after every diet, until a new plan arrives to fix it. After years of this, people say they don't know when they're hungry, and they're right, because the signal has been talked over for a decade. It's a default, though. Defaults come back once whatever was overriding them stops.

That was a biscuit

Go back to Thursday at half past three. The biscuit isn't where the diet ends. Eighty-odd calories, gone in a minute, and if that were all, the diet would still be running on Friday. What ends it is the sentence after. "Well, that's today gone."

That sentence treats the day as the unit, as if one biscuit spoils it the way a drop of ink spoils a glass of water. A day is a series of meals, and a biscuit at half past three has no bearing on dinner at seven unless you decide it has. Anyone who isn't dieting knows this without being told. They have the biscuit, then dinner, and the two never touch.

So one slip doesn't ruin the day. One slip plus the write-off does. You supply the write-off, and you can stop supplying it. If you take that one habit and nothing else, the cycle can't run, because it needs the write-off to get from the first break to the blame.

"I know what to eat. I just don't do it."

You do know. Picture a friend coming to stay for a week. You'd make breakfast, lunch and dinner, mostly ordinary food, some vegetables, a pudding now and then. You wouldn't weigh or count or forbid anything, and nobody would call it a diet. That knowledge is real and you have it. Rules are something else. "No bread" and "twelve hundred a day" don't come from what you know about feeding a friend. They come from a plan built for fast loss, and failing to follow them is what everyone does with rules.

Under that sits a fear. Without rules, you'd eat everything.

Look at when the free-for-all actually happens. It comes after a diet ends, in the half of the cycle that follows restriction. You've never seen your eating after a month with no restriction, because there hasn't been one. The free-for-all is what you're like after rules.

What holds eating together is structure. Three meals at roughly regular times says when and leaves out what, and since it forbids nothing, there's nothing to break. And the cupboard? You've had dinner at seven, of a size that satisfied you, and a person who's eaten dinner wants a biscuit or two. The biscuits aren't going anywhere either. Nobody's about to take them away, and a biscuit that isn't about to be forbidden is one you can leave. What empties a packet is a rule due to be enforced from Monday.

January is the hardest test. The office fills with people comparing apps, and your sister rings with the name of a plan. Keep the company. Eat lunch with the people on the plan, be pleased for them, and eat an ordinary lunch. "I'm not doing one this year" is a full sentence, and if someone asks why, "I've done enough of them" is another. If January's diet worked, nobody would need next January's.

Here is the decision. I'd like it to be one sentence you can keep.

I don't start diets. I eat three ordinary meals a day and I don't skip. When I've eaten more than I meant to, the next meal is an ordinary meal.

The ordinary week looks like this.

  • Breakfast, lunch and dinner at roughly the same times each day. The NHS says don't skip meals, because skipping leads to snacking. If you're not hungry at breakfast, have something small.
  • What you'd feed a friend. That's all the content there is.
  • Nothing banned. A forbidden food is a rule, and a rule is what sets up the write-off. Biscuits exist. They get eaten sometimes, as biscuits, and then dinner happens.
  • Don't finish the plate if you're full. Save the rest for tomorrow.
  • Do the week's shopping from a list written when you're not hungry. That's the good half of Sunday night, planning food without planning restriction.
  • No target, no count, no weigh-in, and no day of the week to start on.

If you want to lose weight, the NHS route sits on top of this. Half a kilogram to a kilogram a week, not more. Move for a hundred and fifty minutes a week, in short sessions if you like. Swap sugary drinks for water. Tell someone you trust what you're doing, so a bad day has a person in it instead of a write-off. In England you can refer yourself to NHS weight management services, or ask at your surgery. All of it is slow, and none of it is a fresh start. Stop the cycle first and let the direction come after.

Expect three uneven weeks. Your body has been restricted a dozen times and hasn't yet believed it won't be again, so some meals will be big. Let them be, and have the next one at the usual time.

After a slip of any size, the response is the same. Don't write the day off. If you catch yourself saying it's gone, the answer is "it's a biscuit". Don't plan a fresh start, because nothing stopped, and tomorrow is an ordinary day that needs no planning. Don't compensate. A skipped or shrunken dinner is a restriction, and restriction is what turns a biscuit into a box. Have the dinner you'd have had. If it helps to have words, use these. "That was a biscuit. Dinner's at seven."

The big slip, an evening or a weekend with a lot in it, gets exactly the same answer, and there it matters more. Breakfast on Monday, at the usual time and the usual size. Last time, your body learned that a big weekend leads to restriction, so it ate ahead. This time it learns that a big weekend leads to breakfast.

Put the scales away as your measure. Count fresh starts instead, and aim for zero, a number you control completely. Weight swings by a couple of pounds a day with water and salt, so a daily weigh-in is a daily verdict drawn from noise, and a bad number on Thursday morning is a fine excuse for the afternoon biscuit to become a write-off. Once a fortnight shows a trend, and never is a respectable choice.

Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran, in 2006, reviewed ninety-four studies of plans made in the form "when this happens, I'll do that". People who plan that way follow through much more often than people who only hold the intention. So write three.

  • When I feel the pull to plan a new diet, I'll write down what I'm going to eat for the next three meals and nothing else.
  • When I've eaten something I hadn't meant to, I'll say "that was a biscuit, dinner's at seven" and have dinner at seven.
  • When I've had a big weekend, I'll eat breakfast on Monday at the usual time and the usual size.

What I'd expect, and this is my expectation and not a finding, is something like this. The first Sunday without a plan feels like doing nothing about something, and the feeling passes by Tuesday. Around week three a biscuit happens, you say the sentence and have dinner, and on Friday you notice there was no Friday. By week six most people find food takes up less of the day, meals have a size, and hungry and enough have started turning up as feelings again. The scales might hold, or drift down slowly, or not, and I'm making no promise about them. The envelope will have stopped growing.

Wednesday, with lunch

It'll happen. A bad fortnight, a photo, a remark, a January, and you're on day three of a plan with an app on your phone, and the thought arrives that none of this took.

It took. The cycle ran for years and it ran once more, and you caught it on day three, earlier than you've ever caught it. Last year, day three was a good day on a diet. This year it's the moment you see the envelope.

Stop the plan, not yourself. Delete the app or close the notebook, and have lunch, the one you'd make for a friend, with no last supper and nothing smaller to be safe. Every diet on the envelope ended with a break and a blame. This one ends in the middle of a Wednesday, with a sandwich.

Then work out what set it off. If it was a number on the scales, the scales go away for a month. If it was a remark, go back to the friend test. If it was a fortnight of eating that felt like a flood, remember that the flood follows restriction, and you'd been restricting.

Don't keep a streak of diet-free months for a fresh start to break. Count meals that were meals. The envelope gets one more line, "ended Wednesday lunchtime, with lunch", and that's a different envelope from the one you started with.

A few situations need their own word.

  • If a doctor, dietitian or nurse has given you an eating plan for a medical reason, follow it. A plan from someone who knows your health, with follow-up, isn't the cycle. The cycle is a plan from a website, alone, with a Monday.
  • If you're prescribed weight-loss medication, take it as prescribed and talk to the prescriber about eating. Don't stop it because of anything you've read here.
  • The cycle and an eating disorder can look alike from inside. If the signs in the cautions at the start fit you, please talk to a GP or to Beat. The ordinary week may be part of recovery, but with someone qualified helping.
  • If there's a teenager in your house talking about a fresh start, the most useful thing you can do is live the ordinary week in front of them, and see the GP if what you're seeing looks like the point above.
  • If you live with someone in the cycle, you can't stop their fresh starts. You can decline to join them, keep three meals happening in the house, and be the person who says "it's a biscuit" and means it.
  • If you're pregnant, talk to your midwife about eating.

It's a Tuesday, some months on. There was no Sunday night this week, and there hasn't been one for a while. You noticed that a few weeks ago and then stopped noticing, which is how it should be. Breakfast was breakfast. Lunch was a sandwich, an apple and the second half of a conversation. At half past three there's a box of biscuits open on the desk, and you have one, and it's a biscuit, and you go back to what you were doing. At seven there's dinner, the usual size, and afterwards a bit of the chocolate that's been in the cupboard for a week, because you fancied some. There's some left.

Your sister rang last week with the name of a plan. You were glad for her, and said you'd done enough of them, and she laughed.

The envelope is in the kitchen drawer. The last line on it is from February.

The next time you eat something you hadn't meant to, say "that was a biscuit", and have the next meal at the usual time and the usual size.