Drink the water

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 48 min

Seven o'clock, a coffee. The first one is the good one. Ten o'clock, at your desk, another, because someone's going to the machine and it would be odd not to. Lunch is a sandwich at the desk, and if there's a drink it's a can of something, or nothing, because getting up is a thing. Two o'clock, a biscuit from the tin, because there's a tin.

Three o'clock, a headache. Dull, at the front, with a heaviness that makes the screen harder to read than it was at eleven. You go for a third coffee, and it helps for twenty minutes, and then it doesn't. Four o'clock, another biscuit. Half five, home, and the first thing you drink that isn't coffee is a glass of wine or a cup of tea. When you go to the loo before bed, what's in the bowl is dark yellow.

That's a day of about a litre of fluid, most of it coffee, and one of those days is nothing. The trouble is that it's every day. The headache at three has turned up so often it's become "my afternoon headache", a fact about you instead of a thing with a cause. The flatness is the post-lunch dip, which everyone gets. The biscuits are a separate problem. So is the coffee.

Here's what I'm going to argue. The habit makes sense from the inside. Water is dull, thirst is quiet and easy to talk over, coffee is what the day has to hand, and the flat feeling at three doesn't say what it is. But the gap matters more than it looks. In laboratory studies, losing as little as one or two per cent of the body's water made people more tired, more headachy, less able to concentrate and lower in mood, while barely touching how well they could think. Thirst runs steadily all day, but most of what people drink is drunk around meals. And the coffee and biscuit at three relieve a state that a glass of water would have dealt with, which is why they keep being needed. The practical part is small. A glass of water with every hot drink and every meal, a glass first when the afternoon goes flat, and a look at the colour of your pee once a day.

I won't tell you to give up coffee, carry a two-litre bottle, or drink eight glasses. The NHS says six to eight cups or glasses of fluid a day, that tea and coffee count, and that pale yellow pee is the sign you're getting enough. I'm not going to add to that.

Three cautions. If you've been sick or had diarrhoea, or you've been in the heat, or you feel dizzy when you stand up and it doesn't pass, that's dehydration, and the NHS says to ask for an urgent GP appointment or call 111. There's a fuller list near the end. If you have a heart or kidney condition and you've been told to limit how much you drink, follow that advice and not mine. And thirst gets less reliable with age, so if you're older, or looking after someone who is, there's a part for you too.

Before you go on, write down everything you drank yesterday, with rough amounts and times. Coffee, tea, cans, the glass with dinner, the wine. Next to the list, write what colour your pee was the last time you looked. Change nothing yet. Most people find the list is shorter than they thought, it stops earlier in the day than they thought, and the second question is harder to answer than it should be.

The quiet signal

Nobody decides to spend the day dry. It goes dry for reasons that are each perfectly sensible.

  • Water is dull. Coffee has a smell and a ritual and a warm cup and, if you're honest, a lift. Nobody looks forward to a glass of water at their desk.
  • Thirst is quiet. Hunger growls and makes the sandwich shop visible from across the road. Thirst sits at a low level and waits.
  • Coffee is what's there. The person going to the café asks what you want, and nobody offers water.
  • The flat hour has no label. It feels like tiredness or a sugar dip, so you reach for whatever fixes those.
  • The loo. Drink more and you'll go more, in meetings, on the train, at night. People rarely say this one out loud, and they act on it constantly.

Any plan that ignores these, two litres a day and a bottle everywhere, fails on the first busy Tuesday. So the plan here doesn't ask you to want water, hear thirst better or stop drinking coffee. It attaches the water to things you already do.

"I'm not thirsty, so I'm fine."

It's a fair belief. Thirst is what the body has for the job. Fiona McKiernan, Jenny Houchins and Richard Mattes collected hourly ratings of hunger and thirst from fifty adults for a week, along with what they ate and drank. Hunger came in two clear waves a day. Thirst was stronger than hunger and roughly level all day, and about three quarters of all fluid was drunk around meals. So thirst is there between meals, at a steady level, which is exactly the kind of signal you stop hearing, like the hum of a fridge. Hunger interrupts. Thirst waits.

And "not thirsty" doesn't mean fine. Nathalie Pross and colleagues had twenty healthy women go without fluid for about twenty-four hours in a controlled setting. More thirst and darker pee were among the earliest signs, well before anything showed in the blood. So even if you've learned to talk over the first signal, the second is still there in the bowl.

Some people really do have a weak signal, and it weakens with age. But I'd guess that for most adults under sixty, "I'm never thirsty" means "I've never listened". Learning to hear a quiet, steady signal over a busy day is a skill most people won't learn and shouldn't need. Stop relying on it and drink on a schedule your day already has.

"Coffee counts, so I'm fine." Half right, and the right half matters. The NHS says water, lower-fat milk and sugar-free drinks, tea and coffee included, all count. Sophie Killer, Andrew Blannin and Asker Jeukendrup took fifty men who normally drank three to six cups of coffee a day and had them drink either four cups of coffee or the same amount of water each day for three days. Total body water didn't differ, and nor did twenty-four-hour pee volume or the blood markers. If you drink coffee regularly, a cup of coffee is a cup of fluid.

The trouble is what comes after eleven. In that day at the start, it was a can at lunch and a third coffee at three. Four cups at most, most of them before mid-morning. The coffee counts. It stops early, because you drink it for the lift, and when you stop wanting the lift, nothing takes its place. If you're someone who really drinks six or seven mugs of tea through the day, you may be fine already. Check you're one of them and not one of the people who think they are and had two.

You might believe the opposite, that coffee dries you out. Maughan and Griffin reviewed this in 2003. Large single doses, roughly two or three cups at once, do raise pee output for a while, but mainly in people who've had no caffeine for days or weeks. Regular drinkers develop a strong tolerance. And the Killer study is the direct test. If you drink coffee every day, it isn't drying you out. The NHS dehydration page does say to avoid caffeine and alcohol when you have symptoms of dehydration, and that's right too, for someone already short of fluid from heat or illness. On an ordinary day, the coffee counts. Its real cost is the caffeine at three o'clock and what that does to the night. Water has no cut-off time.

"I'd never manage eight glasses."

Then good news. Heinz Valtin, a kidney physiologist, went looking for where the eight-glasses rule came from. He searched the literature and asked specialists in thirst and drinking, and found no scientific studies supporting it. He found surveys suggesting such large amounts weren't needed, and studies showing caffeinated drinks could be counted. His review came out in 2002. The rule has outlived it comfortably.

What the NHS says now is smaller. Six to eight cups or glasses of fluid a day, tea and coffee included, more if you're pregnant, in the heat, active for long periods or ill. Drink enough that your pee is a clear pale yellow. That last line is the one to keep, because it swaps counting for looking. A number tells you what you should have done. The colour tells you where you are. If you're at six already and pale, you're fine, and you can give this to someone else. If you're at three, mostly before eleven, and dark, then the gap is three ordinary drinks.

I think the eight-glasses rule did harm by setting a bar high enough that most people gave up on the whole idea, and by leaving out the drinks people actually drink.

What three o'clock is made of

The afternoon is partly just like that. There's a natural dip in alertness early in the afternoon whether you've drunk anything or not, and blaming it all on water would be dishonest.

But look at what mild dehydration does on its own. Lawrence Armstrong, Matthew Ganio and colleagues had twenty-five young women spend three eight-hour days in a laboratory. On two days, exercise made them mildly dehydrated, losing on average about one and a third per cent of body mass in water. On the third they were kept hydrated. When dry, they felt less vigorous and more tired, their mood was worse, tasks and concentrating felt harder, and they got headaches. Most measures of how well they actually thought weren't affected. In a companion study, Ganio, Armstrong and colleagues did the same with twenty-six young men at about one and a half per cent. Fatigue and tension rose at rest, and two measures of attention and working memory got slightly worse.

For someone weighing seventy kilograms, one and a half per cent is about a litre. That's a plausible gap by three o'clock for someone who's had two coffees and a can since seven, especially in a warm office. I want to be careful. Those studies dried people out with exercise, nobody has measured your Tuesday, and the desk-day comparison is my reasoning. What they show is that this level of dryness is enough, by itself, to produce tiredness, headache, poor concentration and low mood while leaving your ability to think mostly alone.

That's the flat hour, described from outside.

The biscuit at two and the biscuit at four feel like hunger. There's a popular line that hunger is often thirst in disguise. I won't use it, because I haven't found good evidence for it in that form. What the hourly ratings do show is that hunger comes in waves around meal times, and two and four o'clock sit between them. So what's there is more likely the steady thirst plus the flat hour. The feeling is general, heavy, dull, wanting something, and your mind supplies the label with the nearest remedy. In an office with a biscuit tin, that's "peckish". Next to a coffee machine, it's "tired". Nobody has ever told you that dryness feels like this, and there's no water in sight, so the label is never "dry".

There's a small, separate finding. Elizabeth Dennis, Kevin Davy and colleagues had forty-eight overweight adults aged fifty-five to seventy-five follow a reduced-calorie diet for twelve weeks, half of them drinking half a litre of water before each main meal. The water group lost about two kilograms more. A review by Rebecca Muckelbauer and colleagues found the same pattern in people dieting, and no consistent effect in people who weren't. This isn't about weight. I mention it only because water at meals seems to do something.

"Water doesn't actually do anything. I've drunk a glass and felt nothing."

That comparison is rigged against the water. Coffee starts something you can feel within twenty minutes. Water stops something, and you can't feel a headache not arriving. Caroline Edmonds and colleagues tried to catch the effect anyway. They gave forty-seven adults either water or nothing, and told half of them that water would help their thinking. Twenty and forty minutes later, the ones who'd drunk water felt less thirsty and did better on a simple attention test, whatever they'd been told to expect. Memory span and reaction time didn't change. Natalie Masento and colleagues, reviewing the field in 2014, concluded that some aspects of thinking and mood do respond to water, and pointed out that studies measure things inconsistently and often don't measure hydration properly. I'd call the effect real, modest, and mostly about attention and mood. It won't make you cleverer.

So don't judge the water by how it feels going down. Judge it by your afternoons a fortnight later.

Now the bill, which arrives in small pieces and never gets added up. The headache most afternoons, which may have another cause, but if it comes when you've drunk nothing since ten, suspect the obvious one first. An hour or two of every working day spent heavier than it needs to be. A worse mood, which the people around you share. And the night. If the first real drink of the day is wine at six, or a big glass of water at ten because you suddenly feel it, you get the loo visits at two in the morning.

Then there's the stand-in. The third coffee does help. So does the biscuit. The coffee lifts alertness for a while, whatever caused the low. The biscuit gives you something to do with your hands and a small pleasure. Neither touches the dryness. The coffee brings a cup of fluid with it and the biscuit brings nothing. So an hour later the lift has gone, the dryness is where it was, and you're back at the flat hour, wanting something, with the tin still there. That's my interpretation, but I think the loop is plain. The stand-in relieves the symptom and leaves the state alone, so the symptom comes back and the stand-in is needed again. That's how a biscuit at two becomes one at four.

A glass by the kettle

Every time you have a hot drink or a meal, have a glass of water with it.

When you make or fetch the coffee at seven and at ten, fill a glass at the same time, and it goes where the coffee goes. Drink it before, during or after. At a café, ask for a glass of water with the coffee, which any café will give you. If someone's fetching, they can fetch a water too. Two coffees become four drinks, and the morning is done without anyone feeling thirsty.

At meals, a glass on the table at breakfast, lunch and dinner. On the desk if you eat at the desk. A bottle in the other hand if lunch is a sandwich on the move. Most people already drink something with meals, and three quarters of fluid was drunk around them in that week of hourly ratings. This just makes sure the something is there and isn't a can of sugar.

Two hot drinks and three meals gives five glasses, plus the two coffees, so seven drinks. That's inside the six to eight, and you haven't done anything except pour.

Now the objections that would stop this on a Tuesday.

You don't like the taste. Plenty of people don't. Hard tap water tastes of something, warm bottled water tastes of the bottle, and to someone raised on squash, plain water is a punishment. It doesn't have to be water. The NHS suggests sparkling water, no-added-sugar squash, or a slice of lemon or lime. A mug of tea next to the coffee is fine. Two limits. Juice and smoothies count, but the NHS says keep them to one small glass a day with a meal, and drinks high in sugar shouldn't be a habit, because of teeth and calories. And all-tea runs into caffeine in the evening. Dullness, though, is fine. The glass isn't meant to be looked forward to. It's meant to be there.

You'd be in the loo all day. For a while, yes, and I won't pretend otherwise. Erica Perrier and colleagues pooled data from two hundred and thirty-eight adults and found that lightening twenty-four-hour pee by two shades on the standard chart went with about a litre more fluid a day, and about a litre more pee. What goes in comes out. Timing softens it. Most extra visits come from what you drank in the previous two or three hours, so water at breakfast, mid-morning, lunch and mid-afternoon means visits during the day, when there's a loo. If nights worry you, make the dinner glass the last one, and let a hot drink at nine go without a partner. I think that's the one adjustment most people need and don't make, and it's why they give up. In my observation the first week is the worst it gets, and it settles somewhat, though never back to where it was. If you're a teacher, a driver, or on a till, move the glasses to the breaks you have. A glass at each break still beats nothing after eleven. A minute in a room with a door, against the afternoon.

You haven't time to think about it. Good, because there's nothing to think about. Apps and bottles with hours printed down the side ask you to drink at times chosen by a clock, so every reminder is an interruption and gets dismissed. The pair uses the stops your day already makes. The only friction is fetching a glass, so remove that once. One glass at the kettle, one at your desk, one at the table, left out for good.

It's a fad. The two-litre bottles with encouraging phrases printed on the side are marketing, and the sensible sceptic is half right. Barry Popkin, Kristen D'Anci and Irwin Rosenberg reviewed water and health in 2010 and said plainly that there are big gaps in knowledge about how much people need, no long-term randomised trials, and little to support precise targets. Electrolyte sachets are for people who've been sweating for hours. But the fad grew around a small, dull truth. Mild dryness makes people tired and headachy, and drinking enough to keep your pee pale stops it. All that needs is a glass by the kettle.

The flat hour needs one more move, because that's where the stand-in lives.

Somewhere after lunch you'll feel the heaviness, the dull head, the urge to go to the machine or the tin. You already notice that moment, because it's the one you act on. Before anything else, drink a glass of water. You can get up and fetch it, which is the same walk you were about to make. Then give it ten minutes and carry on with what you were doing. If you still want the coffee after that, have the coffee. Same with the biscuit. Nothing's banned. Only the order changes. My guess is that on a fair number of afternoons you'll forget the coffee, and on the rest you'll have it and the afternoon will still be better, because the coffee only has to do its own job. If you get a flat hour at eleven too, same again.

Ten minutes sounds an age when you're heavy and the tin is open. You were going to spend four minutes walking to the machine and waiting for it.

Then once a day, look at the colour of your pee. Pale, you're fine. Dark yellow and strong-smelling is on the NHS list of dehydration signs, and means you need more today. Skip first thing in the morning, when it's dark for everyone. Mid-afternoon tells you about the working day. If it's dark at three, that's the flat hour telling you what it is. The colour moves quickly with what you drink, which makes it an honest gauge. It isn't a diagnosis, though. Some vitamins, foods and medicines change the colour, and if it's dark while you're drinking well, or a colour that isn't yellow at all, that's a question for a GP. For the first fortnight, write down pale or dark each afternoon, next to yesterday's list.

The rule in one sentence. I have a glass of water with every hot drink and every meal, and at the flat hour I have a glass first and wait ten minutes before anything else.

Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran's analysis of ninety-four studies found that plans in the form "when X, I'll do Y" had a medium-to-large effect on whether people did what they meant to. So write three.

  • When I make or fetch a hot drink, I fill a glass of water and it goes where the cup goes.
  • When food is in front of me, there's a glass on the table before I start.
  • When the flat hour comes and I feel the reach for the machine or the tin, I drink a glass of water and give it ten minutes.

What I'd expect, and the rule hasn't been tested as a package, is a first week of more loo visits and a glass that feels like an instruction. By the second week, fewer visits and the glass appearing without thought at least half the time. Somewhere in the second or third week, an afternoon when you reach four o'clock and realise the headache didn't come.

Decide now, while it's clear. At three o'clock the tin is open and the flat hour is making the case for the biscuit.

Pale at four

This is for an ordinary adult on an ordinary day. Here's what the NHS says for the rest.

On hot days, during long exercise, and when you're ill or recovering, you need more. Water is the best way to replace sweat. If you've been sick or had diarrhoea, you may need salts and sugars too, and a pharmacist can recommend an oral rehydration solution. On those days drink beyond the pair, and avoid caffeine and alcohol while you have symptoms.

Ask for an urgent GP appointment or call 111 if you're unusually tired, if you feel dizzy when you stand up and it doesn't go away, if your pee is dark yellow or you're peeing less than normal, or if you're breathing quickly or have a fast heart rate. Call 999 or go to A&E if there are signs of dehydration together with cold skin, blue, grey, pale or blotchy skin or lips, difficulty breathing, confusion or unusual sleepiness. That's dehydration, and a glass of water isn't the answer.

Thirst fades with age. Phillips, Rolls and colleagues kept seven healthy men aged sixty-seven to seventy-five, and seven aged twenty to thirty-one, without water for twenty-four hours. The older men felt less thirsty and drank less afterwards, though their blood showed a bigger shortfall. The NHS counts older adults among those most at risk. For an older relative, make sure they drink at mealtimes, make drinking sociable, offer food with water in it like soup, melon and jelly, and keep a drink within reach at all times. If you're the older adult, the pair matters more for you than for anyone, because your quiet signal has got quieter.

In pregnancy and breastfeeding you need more fluid, the NHS says, and caffeine in pregnancy should stay under two hundred milligrams a day. The pair works, with the hot drinks counted.

Some people with heart failure or kidney disease are told by their doctors to restrict fluid. If that's you, your doctor's advice wins, and the pair isn't for you unless they say so.

Diabetes and diuretics both make dehydration more likely. The rule still applies and the pale check matters more. Dark pee with thirst and tiredness is a conversation for a GP.

And if you've done all this for a month, your pee is pale, and the headache and flatness are still there most days, water wasn't the cause. Look at sleep, caffeine timing and eyesight, and if none of those explains it, see a GP. A glass of water is one cheap thing to try first.

The day will go dry again. A week of travel, a run of early meetings, a cold, and on a Thursday you notice the glass hasn't been by the cup since Monday and the headache is back at three.

A week off isn't the habit gone. Phillippa Lally and colleagues followed ninety-six people building a daily habit and found that missing one opportunity didn't materially affect how it formed. A few days off sets you back a little, not to zero, and the glass is still by the kettle.

Don't turn it into a project. Buying the bottle with the hours on it and forcing down two litres on Friday is the fad, and it fails the following Tuesday. Next hot drink, a glass. Next meal, a glass. Nothing to make up. Then find the cause, which is usually small. The loo, so the last glass moves earlier. The fetching, so the glasses go back where they live. Somewhere with no water in sight, so ask, because it's always there and free. A dark afternoon after a dry week is information, and the answer to it is the next glass.

Seven o'clock, a coffee and a glass of water next to it, drunk while the coffee cools. Ten o'clock, someone's going to the machine, and you say coffee and a water, and they bring both because it's normal now. Lunch at the desk, and the glass is there, because it always is. Half past two, the heaviness. You feel the reach, drink the glass that's there, and give it ten minutes. Three o'clock arrives and it's just three o'clock. At four you notice there wasn't a headache, the tin is still shut, and when you go to the loo, it's pale.

The coffee's still there, and so is the lift if you want it. What's gone is the dry stretch from eleven to six.

Get a glass, fill it, and put it where you make your hot drinks. Leave it there. Next time you make a cup, fill the glass too.