The 20-minute version
It's ten to four on a Wednesday afternoon. You're working at the kitchen table, as you do two days a week, and an email has come in from a client. It's polite and it's unhappy, and it asks why something wasn't done that you thought had been. You read it twice. Your stomach tightens. You start a reply and stop.
Then you're at the fridge. You didn't decide to go. You cut a few slices of cheese and eat them with crackers, standing at the worktop, looking at nothing. It takes about four minutes. You have a couple more crackers because the packet's open, and you go back to the table.
The email is still there, exactly as unhappy as it was.
The only things that have changed are that it's five to four, you're slightly full, and there's a small extra weight in your chest that wasn't there before, which is the knowledge that you've done it again. At half past nine that evening, an hour and a half after dinner, with nothing on and your partner out, it'll be a bag of crisps. On Sunday, after a phone call with your mother that went the way those calls go, it was two rounds of toast and peanut butter at the counter with the phone still warm in your other hand.
None of it is much food. It isn't a binge. It's a handful of visits a day with a pattern. Something is felt, food follows, and the feeling stays. You've tried to stop for years, mostly with willpower, and that hasn't worked, which is one more thing to feel bad about while eating.
This makes sense from the inside, and I'll start there. Food is close, quick, private and pleasant, and for as long as it takes to eat, it does take the edge off. Then I'll argue that it can't do the job you've given it. A feeling has its own causes and its own clock, and a plate of cheese and crackers touches neither. What you get is a short break with a snack attached, and you could have had the break without the snack. The practical part is simple to state. When you want to eat and you aren't hungry, you stop long enough to name what you're feeling and answer that. When you are hungry, you eat.
This isn't a diet, and it makes no promise about your weight. It never asks you to go hungry. Food is for enjoying, and nothing here bans any of it.
Four cautions, and please read them.
If you regularly eat a large amount of food in a short time and feel unable to stop, often alone and fast, and feel disgusted or ashamed afterwards, that may be binge eating disorder. The NHS says it's a serious condition that most people recover from with the right treatment, and advises seeing a GP as soon as you can. You can also ring the eating disorders charity Beat, whose adult helpline is 0808 801 0677. What follows isn't a treatment for it.
If you have, or have had, any eating disorder, including restricting what you eat or making yourself sick, talk to whoever treats you before trying any of this. It assumes someone who eats regular meals and wants to stop the extra visits, and it may not suit you.
If the feeling that keeps sending you to the kitchen is low mood, and it's been there most of the day for a couple of weeks or more, that may be depression. See a GP. The habit may still be worth working on, but not instead of that.
And if you take medicines that change your appetite, or have a condition such as diabetes that needs a particular pattern of eating, nothing here overrides what the people treating you have said.
Before reading on, and without changing anything, try this for a week. Each time you eat outside a meal, write down what you ate, how hungry you were out of ten, and what you were feeling in the minute before. If you don't know the feeling, write "don't know". At the end of the week, look at the hunger column.
Credit for the calm
The fridge is eight steps away.
That's most of its appeal. It's the one comfort in the house that's always in stock, needs nobody else and costs nothing at the moment of use. A friend might be busy, and a walk needs a coat. It's private, so nobody has to know you were struggling. You didn't ring anyone in tears, you ate some crackers. Standing at the fridge is a break that doesn't look like one. Many people were given something nice when they fell over as children, kindly meant, and the link is still there. And when a feeling arrives with nothing obvious to do about it, going to the kitchen is at least an action.
So the visit is after relief, a pause and comfort. All reasonable. It delivers them badly, and the first thing standing in the way is a label.
You may call yourself an emotional eater. You've done the online quiz, or said it about yourself at dinner with a small laugh. Psychologists have measured emotional eating for decades with questionnaires asking whether you eat more when you're anxious or lonely. The odd thing is what happens when high scorers are put in a bad mood and offered food. Peggy Bongers and Anita Jansen reviewed those studies and found that, again and again, self-described emotional eaters didn't eat more when upset than anyone else. A high score, they suggested, may reflect worry about eating, or a sense of it being out of control, or a habit of explaining overeating by pointing to feelings.
Catharine Evers and colleagues pooled fifty-six experiments and found the same. A bad mood didn't increase eating in people who called themselves emotional eaters. It did increase eating in one group, and I'll come back to them, because I think they're the most useful finding here.
The visits are real. You've got a week's notes to prove it. But the label does work of its own. If you believe feelings make you eat, a feeling arriving will seem like an instruction. In another study Bongers and colleagues found that people who ate more after a bad mood also ate more after a good mood, and after simply being shown food. Feeling bad was one cue among several. So drop the label. You're someone who has learned to answer certain moments with food, and between the moment and the fridge there's a gap.
"But food calms me down."
It does something. Michael Macht, reviewing how emotions affect eating, lists eating to regulate an emotion as one of the ways they do it. Food of the kind you reach for is pleasant, and pleasure crowds out a feeling while it lasts. The questions are how long that is, and what the feeling is doing meanwhile.
Feelings run on their own clocks. Philippe Verduyn and colleagues had people record episodes of fear, anger, joy, gratitude and sadness day by day. A feeling lasted longer when the situation mattered, when it started strong, and when its cause kept coming back, in reality or in the person's thoughts. Nothing on that list is touched by cheese. The email matters exactly as much after the crackers, and going back to read it again is what brings the feeling back.
Then the relief. Heather Scherschel Wagner and colleagues made people feel low with sad films and then gave some of them their own favourite comfort food, some an equally liked food that wasn't a comfort food, some a plain food, and some nothing at all. Everyone's mood recovered, by about the same amount, in all four groups. The comfort food did no better than nothing. The authors' phrase is that people give comfort food credit for a recovery that would have happened anyway.
Go back to ten to four. The dread peaked when you read the email and had begun to fall before you reached the fridge, because that's what feelings do. The crackers arrived on the way down and took the credit. If you'd stood at the worktop for four minutes and eaten nothing, you'd have felt about the same at five to four. You'd have missed the first cracker, which I don't deny is a pleasure. You'd also have missed the weight in your chest afterwards.
What the feeling wanted
Look at your hunger column. My guess is that it's full of twos and threes.
Sometimes you really are hungry, and then you should eat, properly, whatever the time. The habit is eating without hunger, for some other reason. So it helps to tell them apart, and what follows is my own description, not a clinical test. Hunger builds slowly and grows if you ignore it. The pull arrives all at once, usually within a minute of something happening. Hunger is felt in the stomach as emptiness, sometimes as low energy or a slight headache. The pull is felt in the mouth and the mind as wanting. Hunger accepts most things, and the pull wants one thing, usually rich or salty or sweet. Hunger goes away when you eat and stays away. The pull can come back in half an hour, because whatever it was about hasn't moved.
That gives you a test. Would an apple do? If yes, you're probably hungry, so eat, and it doesn't have to be an apple. If the answer is a firm no, it has to be the cheese, then it's the pull.
If your column is full of sevens and eights, your meals may not be feeding you. It's common, in my observation, for people who eat a lot between meals to eat rather little at them, to make up for it. That produces real hunger at four, answered with crackers, which spoils dinner, which leaves real hunger at nine.
Once hunger is set aside, the pull has a few common reasons.
Stress is the most respectable. You've had a day, and the body seems to be asking for fuel. Arthur Stone and Kelly Brownell had a hundred and fifty-eight adults keep daily diaries for eighty-four days, and on stressful days people were much more likely to eat less than usual than more. Stress doesn't, as a rule, make bodies hungry. Tanja Adam and Elissa Epel describe a narrower pathway, in which stress raises cortisol and, with the brain's reward system, increases the drive for rich food, and eating it seems to damp the stress response for a while. So the pull under stress is real and gives short relief. It does nothing about the stress. At ten to four you'd had lunch at one. What you were short of was a break, and some way to stop the email sitting on your chest. Food meets the first badly and the second not at all.
Boredom is the half past nine one. Andrew Moynihan and colleagues found people ate more on days they felt more bored, and that a boring task increased the wish to snack. Remco Havermans and colleagues had people watch the same short clip over and over for an hour. Bored, they ate more chocolate. In a parallel experiment, bored people were also more willing to give themselves mild electric shocks. The authors' conclusion is that bored people want anything at all to happen, and crisps are just the nearest thing that isn't a shock. In Moynihan's work bored people also ate more of a healthy food that had been made interesting, and no more of a dull one. The boredom was looking for an event, and events can happen without a kitchen.
Sunday was different. You felt small and sad and slightly furious, there was nobody in the house, and you wanted something warm and kind. I'll be gentle here, because this is where the visit comes closest to doing something real. Toast is warm and smells of childhood, and when you're sad and alone that isn't nothing. But comfort from a person is mostly company. Someone notices, sits with you, and the feeling has somewhere to go. Toast is company for as long as it takes to eat. And if Verduyn is right that sadness lasts longer when its cause keeps returning to mind, the self-reproach afterwards may bring it back. I'm reading the study a little beyond its findings there, but it matches what people notice. Sunday's toast didn't end Sunday's feeling. It gave it a second course.
A fair objection comes next. You're at the kitchen table from half eight to six, and nobody would blink at four minutes in the kitchen, while a walk at ten to four or ten minutes in the garden would feel like skiving. The visit is the only break that comes with permission.
You need the break. But the break and the food have welded together, and the break is doing the work. The relief at the fridge is the relief of standing up and being somewhere other than the email for four minutes. Try it. Walk to the kitchen, put the kettle on, look out of the window while it boils, make tea, walk back. That's the same break, minus the food and the regret. If the kettle feels like cheating, that's the weld. Most of the permission problem is in your head, and if you work at home nobody minds at all. And if your day is so packed that the fridge really is the only escape, the day is the problem, and that may be a conversation with an employer or a family.
Underneath all of these sits one belief. I can't just sit there feeling it.
Look at what the alternative actually is. A few minutes, and most of the feelings that send you to the kitchen aren't large. The email is a nuisance. Boredom is mild by definition. Even the Sunday sadness is a familiar, medium-sized thing you've survived every fortnight for years. They peak and fall, and you've been eating on the way down.
Now look at what pushing a feeling away does. Catharine Evers, Floor Stok and Denise de Ridder induced bad feelings in people and told some of them to suppress the feeling, some to think about the situation differently, and some nothing. Then they offered food. The suppressors ate more, especially comfort food. The feeling didn't drive the extra eating. The pushing down did. It's a small set of laboratory studies, but you may recognise it. The visit is a response to the effort of not having the feeling.
So turn towards it instead, for a moment, and name it. "That's dread about the email." "That's boredom." "That's Mum." Naming doesn't make it go away, and isn't meant to. It makes it a known thing of a known size. It's dread. You've had dread before. It's uncomfortable and it isn't dangerous, and it's already fading.
No more Mondays
"Well, that's today gone."
That sentence turns up after the crackers, and it causes more visits than any feeling does. The day's spoiled, so you may as well finish the packet, and tomorrow you'll be careful.
What happened was a snack. The day had lunch in it and will have dinner, and it isn't measurably different from a day without the crackers. The sentence comes from a rule that a good day is one with no visits. Under that rule one visit makes the day bad, and once it's bad further visits cost nothing. It's the logic of dropping one plate and deciding to drop the rest of the set. Without the rule, one visit is one visit, and the second is a separate decision.
Tatjana van Strien and colleagues followed nearly six hundred parents for five years and found, in the mothers, a chain from low mood to emotional eating to weight gain. That's one study, about weight, which isn't the point here. I mention it for the shape. Feeling bad leads to the visit, the visit leads to feeling bad about yourself, and round it goes. That last link is the one you can break, because it's made of a sentence. Replace it with "I wasn't hungry and I ate. What was I feeling?" No verdict. The visit becomes information, and dinner is at seven as it was going to be. Nothing is made up for and nothing is skipped.
This will feel like letting yourself off. But the harsh version has never once produced a good day. It has produced hundreds of ruined ones.
Every few weeks the bad feeling builds into a resolution. From Monday, nothing between meals. Perhaps a proper diet this time. You feel better the moment you decide, it holds for a few days, and then a Wednesday email arrives.
Remember the one group in Evers' fifty-six experiments whose eating did go up with a bad mood. It was people restraining their eating, trying to eat less than they wanted. The people whose feelings most reliably sent them to food were the people on a diet. A rule about food takes effort, a bad feeling uses up the effort, the rule breaks, and the plate-dropping follows. Monday also usually means smaller meals, which adds real hunger to the pull.
So I'll offer the opposite of a diet, which is permission. Nothing is banned. Meals are eaten in full, sitting down, until you've had enough. If you love cheese, have it with lunch. The only change is that when the pull arrives without hunger, you ask what's going on before you answer it with food. A feeling can't break that, because there's no rule to break. If you eat the crackers anyway, you've broken nothing. You've collected some information.
Some visits have no feeling worth naming. The crisps are in the cupboard you open for tea bags, it's half past nine, and that's all. For those, change the route. Keep anything you like in the house, just not in the way. Fruit on the table, biscuits in a cupboard you don't pass. Sit with your back to the fridge on work-from-home days. If you've eaten crisps on the sofa at half nine for a year, the sofa at half nine has become a cue, and a few evenings there with a cup of tea and no crisps will weaken it. Moving a bowl won't touch the Wednesday email, though. Those visits would find food in any cupboard.
Here's the method for those.
When the pull arrives, notice it. That's the hardest part, because the habit has run without notice for years. The moment you catch yourself standing up or opening a cupboard is the moment. Then do the ask.
- Check for hunger. Would an apple do? If yes, eat.
- If not, ask "What's actually going on?" and answer in a word or two. Bored, stressed, sad, angry, tired, lonely, worried, flat. "Tired" is more common than people expect.
- Name the cause if you can. "Stressed, the email." "Sad, Mum." If you can't, "Don't know, but not hungry" still does the job.
- Write it down, with the time. After a fortnight most people find it's two or three feelings at two or three times of day, which is a much smaller problem than "I'm an emotional eater".
Then answer the feeling. Food fits everything, which is why it fits nothing.
- Stressed wants a short break and then the thing. Four minutes at the kettle or the end of the road, then the first sentence of the reply.
- Bored wants something to happen that's more interesting than crisps, which sets the bar low. Keep a list on the fridge door, where you'll be standing. A call, the guitar, a crossword, a bath, bed with a book. The phone won't do it. You'll be bored again in six minutes.
- Sad wants company. Ring someone and say "That call with Mum was awful, have you got ten minutes?" If there's nobody, warmth and rest, a blanket and a familiar film.
- Angry wants movement. Twenty minutes outside, fast.
- Tired wants rest. In the evening the visit is often the body asking for bed. Go up an hour earlier.
- Lonely wants a person, in any form available.
- Worried wants a step, or a decision to leave it till morning. Write it down with one thing you could do tomorrow.
- Flat or don't know wants the kettle. A hot drink is a small event that gives the hands something to do. Milk and sugar if you take them.
None of it is heroic, and it may only half work. A half-working answer that leaves you clean beats one that doesn't work and leaves you full.
Then give it ten minutes before you decide anything about food. The pull comes at ten to four. Not hungry. Stressed, the email. You put the kettle on, stand at the window while it boils, make the tea, and write the first sentence of the reply. At about eight minutes past, look at the pull. In my observation it's usually smaller, sometimes gone. At ten past, decide. If you still want the crackers, have them, on a plate, sitting down, with attention, and write down that you did. That's a decision made with information, which is the opposite of the habit. The ten minutes are only for the pull. If you're hungry, there's no waiting.
And eat properly when you are hungry, which is the half that matters most. Regular meals, until you're comfortable, with the foods the pull likes included. A food allowed at meals loses most of its charge between them. Sit down, because a meal you notice keeps you fed longer than one eaten standing, and visits happen at the counter. A snack at four when you're really hungry is a small meal, and fine.
The decision, in your own words if you like.
I eat when I'm hungry, and when I want to eat and I'm not, I name the feeling and answer that instead.
Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran pooled ninety-four tests of plans in the form "when X happens, I'll do Y" and found they make people more likely to follow through. Three are worth writing down.
- When I find myself at the fridge without having decided to go, I'll put the kettle on and ask what's going on.
- When I catch "well, the day's ruined", I'll replace it with "I wasn't hungry and I ate. What was I feeling?"
- When something upsetting happens, I'll go outside for four minutes before I go into the kitchen.
Wednesday again
In the first week you'll do the ask and go to the fridge anyway, often. That's fine. A visit with a label on it is already a different thing.
There'll be a Wednesday when you're at the fridge before the ask gets a chance. Afterwards, write it down. "Wasn't hungry, ate, feeling was dread." The next visit is a separate decision, and dinner is at seven, unchanged.
Some times need their own word.
- Evenings after everyone's in bed are the commonest and hardest. Decide at dinner what the evening's own thing will be, so the sofa isn't empty when you reach it, and go to bed when you're tired.
- Before a period, in pregnancy or illness, appetite really changes. If you're hungrier, eat more. That's hunger, and the rule says eat.
- When someone offers cake, say yes if you're hungry or it's an occasion. If not, "No thanks, I'm fine" needs no reason.
- With children watching, "I'm cross about that email, I'm going round the block" teaches them something. When they're upset, comfort them with company, so the link you're undoing doesn't get built in them.
If the ask ever turns into a reason not to eat when you're hungry, or you find yourself delaying meals or thinking about food all day, stop, eat, and talk to someone. This is on the side of eating. And if eating feels out of control, large amounts, fast, alone, with disgust afterwards, see a GP as soon as you can. The NHS says the main treatments are guided self-help and cognitive behavioural therapy, and that most people recover with the right support. Beat's adult helpline is 0808 801 0677. If low mood has been there most of the day for more than two weeks, see a GP about that.
It's ten to four on a Wednesday, some months on, and an email has come in from a client. Polite, unhappy. Your stomach tightens, and the thought of cheese arrives with it, and this time you see them arrive together. You're not hungry. Lunch was at one and it was a proper lunch, with the cheese in it. Stress, the email.
You put the kettle on and stand on the back step while it boils. It's cold. The neighbour's cat is on the fence. You come in, make the tea, and write the first sentence of the reply. "Thanks for flagging this, and I'm sorry it's caused a problem." It's eight minutes past. The email is still unhappy, but the tight thing has loosened, and the cheese hasn't crossed your mind since the cat.
At ten past you check, out of habit. You could have the crackers. You don't want them.
It took a while. In the second week the notebook showed stress at four and tiredness at half past nine and almost nothing else. In the third week you went to bed at ten instead of eating crisps and found you'd been tired, not bored, for about a year. There have been visits since. A bad Sunday when you named it, rang your sister, and still had the toast afterwards, sitting down, with butter, as a decision.
Meals taste better, because you arrive at them hungry. You still have feelings at about the rate you always did. You know most of their names now.
Next time you're in the kitchen without having decided to go, put the kettle on, and while it boils, ask what's actually going on. Then see what the feeling does in ten minutes without help.