Everyone was looking at their own shoes

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 51 min

There's a café with a window table free. You want the window table. You've got a book, forty minutes and a coffee you've already paid for, and the table is over there, past six other tables with people at them. You stand with the cup and look at the route. You'd have to walk past the couple, and the man with the laptop, and the two women laughing at something, and then sit down on your own in the window, where the street can see you too. You take a table by the wall instead. It's fine. You didn't want the window that much.

Or it's a bar, your friends are at the far end, and between you and them is the whole length of the room, and you know exactly how you walk when you're being watched, which is badly. Or it's a meeting, and you've made your point four times in your head, and by the time there's a gap someone else has made it, worse, and everyone nodded. Or it's the kerb by the bus stop, where your foot went sideways and you did a small, ridiculous hop, and your face stays hot all afternoon.

This is about the feeling that a room of strangers has turned to look at you, and is noticing your clothes, your walk, that you're on your own, the mark on your jumper, and filing it all away. I'll call that feeling the beam.

It makes sense from the inside. People do look at other people. You've looked at someone's shoes on a train. Most of us carry a few times when we really were looked at, a school corridor, a presentation that went wrong, a remark about a coat, and the audience is partly built from those. And the beam arrives in the body, as heat in the face and a sudden awareness of your own hands. A feeling with a pulse in it doesn't seem like an estimate. It seems like a report.

It's an estimate, though, and a bad one. There's about thirty years of research comparing how much people think others notice them with how much others actually do, and the gap is large and runs one way. People notice you less than you think, remember less, and judge you more gently, because they're busy doing what you're doing, which is watching themselves. You can check this in any room in about a minute.

None of this means you should stop caring what people think. That's most of what makes people bearable to be around. It's about the audience that isn't there.

Some cautions. If the feeling stops you doing everyday things, if you avoid shops or phone calls or eating with other people, or it's been like that for months, the NHS describes that as social anxiety. It says it's common and treatable and that a GP is the person to see, and you can also refer yourself to an NHS talking therapies service without going through a GP. This can sit beside that. It can't replace it. If people really do look at you, because of a visible difference, a disability, a wheelchair or your skin, some of what follows applies and some doesn't, and I won't tell you it's all in your head. There's a part near the end for you. And if your trouble is getting to the room at all, that's a related habit. This starts once you're through the door.

Next time the beam comes on, try this first. Ask yourself how many people in the room noticed you, and say the number. Then look around slowly and count how many are actually looking at you right now, and how many are looking at a phone, a coffee, a friend, or their own shoes.

Half the room

The number that comes to you is high. Half the room. Most of it. It arrives without being worked out, which is part of why it feels right.

In 2000, Thomas Gilovich, Victoria Medvec and Kenneth Savitsky published a set of studies on that number, and called what they found the spotlight effect. They had students put on a T-shirt with a large picture of a singer chosen to be embarrassing, and walk into a room where other students were already working. Afterwards, wearers guessed how many people in the room could say who was on the shirt. Then the room was asked. Wearers expected about forty-six per cent to have noticed. About twenty-three per cent had. Roughly double.

Their explanation is the one everything here leans on. You start from your own experience, which is rich, because you've been thinking about the shirt since you put it on. Then you adjust for the fact that other people haven't. You do adjust, just not enough, because you can't feel how little the shirt means to someone reading. The number in your head is your own attention, scaled down a bit and handed to the room.

"Fine, but they heard what I said."

The same paper had a study on that too. After a group discussion, people overestimated how much their own contributions had stood out to the others, good ones and bad ones alike. The remark you were pleased with registered less than you thought, and so did the one you'd like back. Everyone in a meeting is composing their own point, or worrying they haven't got one, or replaying what they said ten minutes ago. The silence after your joke was six people each deciding whether to laugh and checking whether anyone else had. It took about a second. It felt like a minute because you told the joke. Because the gap held for good remarks as well, saying less won't fix it. The room just didn't keep a transcript.

Then there's memory. Say somebody did see the hop.

Daniel Levin, Daniel Simons, Bonnie Angelone and Christopher Chabris followed up an odd earlier finding. If a stranger stops you to ask directions and is swapped for a different stranger while something briefly blocks your view, a good number of people carry on the conversation without noticing. They found the same thing across several situations. A lot of people don't hold enough of a stranger's face to notice when it's been replaced mid-sentence, and that's someone they're talking to. The person at the next table in the café gave you a fraction of that. They saw movement, saw a person do a small hop, and went back to their phone. Carrying your mark around for a week would take a kind of memory people don't have for strangers.

The heaviest version is that they came to a view. Kenneth Savitsky, Nicholas Epley and Thomas Gilovich ran four studies on whether others judge us as harshly as we think. People who imagined a social blunder, or actually failed at a task in front of others, expected to be judged more harshly than they were. They were fixed on their own misfortune, while onlookers weighed the situation, the pressure, and the fact that anyone might have done the same. In a follow-up the same authors found that onlookers soften when they can easily imagine being in your place, and that people under the beam forget this. They called it empathy neglect. You forget that the person watching you trip has tripped.

Which leaves the objection that keeps the whole audience alive. Maybe they don't notice much, but you do. You notice the person who trips, the person eating alone, the coat that doesn't go. You're a watcher, so the room must be full of watchers.

Erica Boothby, Margaret Clark and John Bargh ran six studies on exactly that belief and named it the invisibility cloak illusion. People believe they observe others more than others observe them, strangers and friends alike. It isn't explained by a general sense of being above average, and it isn't explained by thinking you simply have more thoughts than other people. Everyone thinks they're the watcher. On average that can't be true, since every act of watching has someone being watched. You're watched about as much as you watch, which isn't much.

So turn it round. Picture the last stranger you saw trip on a kerb. Picture their face, what you concluded about them, and how long you held the thought.

You can't. You had half a thought and were back in your own head within seconds.

The numb lip

You can feel them looking. Nobody blushes at nothing.

After the dentist you've probably had a numb lip and been sure it was hanging, visibly, for everyone to see, then checked in a shop window and found your face looked exactly as usual. The numbness was real. The hanging wasn't.

Gilovich, Savitsky and Medvec called the general version of this the illusion of transparency. People believe their inner states leak out more than they do. People telling lies thought the lies were easier to spot than they were, and people hiding disgust at a drink thought the disgust showed more than it did. What you feel from inside is vivid, so you assume it's showing at the same strength. Warren Mansell and David Clark found that people high in social anxiety seemed to use their own bodily sensations, the heart and the heat, to judge how anxious they looked and how well they'd come across. They overestimated the first and underestimated the second. That was the anxious end, but the mechanism is ordinary. The body gets used as a mirror, and it's a bad one.

The mark works the same way. The stain on the jumper, the haircut that went shorter than you asked, the shoes that are wrong for the room. It's the most visible thing about you to you, because you've been looking at it all morning. Nobody else has that history with it. To see that a haircut is new you need the before, and the room hasn't got it. When Nicholas Epley and colleagues looked at how people work out what others see, they found that people start from what they see themselves and adjust in steps, stopping at the first answer that seems plausible. After a morning looking at the mark, the first plausible answer is a room that sees it too. In one of Boothby's studies, getting people to focus on a feature of their own appearance made them more sure others were looking at that feature, without changing the fact that, overall, they were less observed than they believed.

Suppose someone does notice, though. The person at the next table sees you properly, on your own with a book by the window. Is that the bad outcome?

Most noticing is just noticing. And where people have paid you real attention, it tends to go better than you think. Boothby and colleagues found that after conversations, people underestimated how much the other person had liked them and enjoyed their company. It held for strangers in a lab, for students getting to know their housemates, and for members of the public at a workshop, and among the students it lasted for months. That's conversation, which is more than a glance across a café, so I'm stretching it. Think of the last time you really noticed someone in a room. Sometimes it was a small unkindness. Mostly it was a flicker of interest, the person with the good coat, the person laughing at their book. You are sometimes, to someone else, the person laughing at their book.

Eating alone gets a verdict of its own. Rebecca Ratner and Rebecca Hamilton found that people hold back from enjoyable things in public on their own, the cinema or a restaurant, because they expect others to conclude they've got nobody. They also found people overestimated how much their own enjoyment depended on having company. When the outing looked more purposeful, or fewer people were expected to see, interest in going alone went up. Those were consumer choices and your café is my extension, but the block they found was the imagined room.

Dan, an invented example, eats at the Italian place near his flat on a Thursday because his flatmate's away. He sits with a book and spends the first ten minutes with the beam on, sure the waiter has clocked him as someone with nobody. By the main course he's stopped noticing, because the book's good and so is the food. Afterwards the only person in the restaurant he can describe is the waiter. He'd go again.

"Confident people don't feel this." The spotlight studies used ordinary students, whoever turned up, and the effect showed across them. So the person who strolls to the bar like they own it would overestimate the headcount in a T-shirt too. That's my reading of who was tested, not a separate finding. What looks like confidence from outside is mostly a description of where someone's attention is. The person crossing the bar easily is looking at their friends at the far end, or thinking about what to order. You, on the same walk, are watching your own walk. The difference is where you're pointing, and that can change on the spot.

"It's just how I am." Partly fair. At the clinical end, reviews by Jane Spurr and Lusia Stopa, and by Susan Bögels and Warren Mansell, describe attention turned inward as one of the things that keeps social anxiety going. It brings negative thoughts closer, gets in the way of what you're doing, and stops you seeing whatever might contradict the fear. But look at what the mechanism is. It's attention, and even there it's described as something that can move. In the ordinary middle, where I'm assuming most readers are, it moves with a nudge.

The run-up feels sensible. Walk the route in your head, say the sentence four times, check the jumper twice. I think it does the opposite. It's an hour of attention spent on yourself before you arrive, and it paints a detailed picture of you walking, as seen from outside, which is a view you don't have. The people in the T-shirt study had thought about the shirt for a few minutes. You've been thinking about your walk since lunch. That's my reading of it, not a finding. Prepare the thing itself. If you have a point, know it in one sentence and know what you want to happen after it. If you're going to the café, know what you'll read. Then your attention goes to the task, out in the room.

And then the way home. The hop is now a fall, and the short silence is now a long one. It presents itself as a fair report, the one you were too flustered to write at the time. But you have the moment and nothing else, while the onlooker had the moment plus the pavement plus their own afternoon, and gave it about a second. You're giving it the whole bus ride. Answer it with numbers. What was the headcount, what did you actually see when you looked, and can you picture a single face? If you can't picture theirs, they can't picture yours.

None of this costs much on any one day. Over a year it's the window table that's always someone else's, the class you didn't join, the point you didn't make until people assumed you hadn't got points, the film you didn't see alone, the dance at the wedding. Under all of it is attention. In the café you went to for the coffee and the book, part of you was monitoring your own arms.

The room pays too. With your attention on your walk across the bar, it isn't on your friends, or on the person at the next table who looked up and half-smiled. And a person whose attention is turned inward looks, from outside, slightly absent and hard to catch the eye of. You've probably sat with someone like that and thought they didn't want to talk to you. That's what the beam makes of the person under it.

From the ceiling

Take the café and look at it from the ceiling.

The couple are halfway through deciding whether to go to his mother's on Sunday. The man with the laptop is on a call with his camera off, trying to look as if he's typing. The two women are laughing at a message one of them got. Three people are alone with their phones, and one has a book.

You walk in. The couple don't look up, because the mother question is live. The man with the laptop sees movement, his eyes flick, and he's back on the call. One of the women glances over because you passed close to her bag, sees a person, and turns back. The other never looked. The people with phones are with their phones. The one with the book might notice you, and she's the one you'd have minded least.

And every one of them is under their own beam. The laptop man is sure the room can tell he isn't typing. One of the women thinks her laugh was too loud. The woman with the book is wondering whether sitting alone with a book looks affected. Each of them is the main event of their own afternoon and a passing shape in everyone else's. It's like worrying that a cinema audience is watching you when they're all watching the film.

So the method is a count.

  • Before you go in, or as the beam comes on, make the headcount. Pick a number for how many people have noticed you or will notice the mark, and say it or write it down. Don't skip this. If you don't fix the estimate first, you'll quietly adjust it afterwards and learn nothing.
  • Then look properly, one person at a time, and put each into one of two columns. Looking at me. Looking at something else, a phone, a friend, a screen, food, a window, their own hands. Be honest both ways. If someone is looking at you, count them.
  • Write both numbers down. The difference is the size of the audience that wasn't there.
  • Do it for a fortnight in different rooms. The café, the bus, the meeting, the gym, a queue. A note on your phone is enough.

I'd expect the headcount to come down by itself after a few days, because it's hard to keep guessing half the room when the count keeps saying one, or none. You're measuring the beam until the estimate corrects.

The count will sometimes find someone looking. Someone looks at anyone who moves, and the question was always whether the room does. And for the minute you're counting, your attention is out on the room. You can't count shoes and monitor your own arms at the same time.

The second check happens at home. Tonight, try to picture three strangers you saw today, on the bus, in the shop, on the pavement, clearly enough to describe their face and clothes and what they were doing. Most people manage one, vaguely. You spent the day in rooms full of people and you've kept almost none of them. That's how much they kept of you. For a day, notice each time your eyes rest on a stranger, for how long, and what you conclude. I'd expect a second or two and nothing much. Once you've watched yourself watching, the idea that everyone else watches more gets hard to hold.

The third is to do one thing. Sit at the window table. Go to the class. Make the point in the meeting without the run-up. Wear the jumper. Eat at the Italian place on a Thursday. One of them, this week, the one you'd most like back.

Do it with the numbers. Headcount before, a count at some point during, and three facts after. Who looked, for how long, and what you did. If you can't name a face from the room, write that down, because it's the most useful of the three. The day after, ask whether the coffee was worse for the window or the meal for the empty chair. If it was, you've learned something real about yourself that has nothing to do with an audience. If it wasn't, the thing you'd been avoiding for the room's sake was fine.

If even one ordinary thing in public feels far beyond you, go back to the caution at the start. A GP is a better next step than a jumper.

So the rule is this. When I feel the beam, I count the shoes.

It's about the second after the heat reaches your face. Before, you looked down, walked faster, watched your arms and started the replay early. Now you make the headcount, look, and count. Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran found that plans in the form "when this happens, I'll do that" work more reliably than an intention alone, so write three. When I walk in and the beam comes on, I'll pick a number and count. When I catch myself in a run-up, I'll write the one point I want to make and stop rehearsing. When the replay starts on the way home, I'll say both numbers out loud and leave it there.

The first few counts will feel absurd. You're standing in a café looking at people, and the beam insists this makes it worse. It doesn't, because nobody notices you doing it. After a week the headcount arrives lower. After a fortnight, in some rooms, the beam doesn't come on at all, and you only realise afterwards. In some rooms, meetings especially, it still will, and the rule doesn't need it to stop. Phillippa Lally and colleagues found that new habits take weeks to become automatic and that a missed day doesn't set them back much. This is a response to a feeling, so I'm borrowing loosely, but it'll be deliberate for a while, and then one day you'll count without deciding to.

When the beam comes back

Some rooms aren't the ordinary room.

  • If people really do look at you, because of a visible difference, a disability, a wheelchair, or a skin colour that's rare where you live, the count will sometimes find them looking, and that isn't in your head. Strangers who look still don't keep you, and mostly don't judge the way you fear. The count still tells you who, when the beam says everyone. The charity Changing Faces exists for people with a visible difference, and I'll point you there instead of pretending this covers it.
  • In a small town people do know you and will mention the haircut. They're still mostly thinking about themselves, and what they say to you is a sentence, not a verdict.
  • At work people notice and remember, and the point matters. Prepare the point, not the delivery. Count a meeting once and you'll see six people looking at the slides or their own notes.
  • If it's your teenager, don't tell them nobody's looking, because at school some people are. Give them the two numbers and let them do the count.
  • If you learned the watching somewhere, a corridor, a parent, a house where every move was commented on, the count gives you today's room, which isn't that one. If the old room is still loud, that's something to take to a GP or a therapist.
  • Online there's no room to count. The numbers on a post aren't the number of people who thought about it, and the people looking are busy watching themselves too.
  • When your child shouts in a shop or your partner dances at a wedding and the heat is in your face, it all applies one seat along. The room noticed for a second, kept nothing, and has a child who shouts too.
  • If you worry about everyday things like meeting strangers, phone calls, eating with company or shopping, and feel watched and judged all the time, and it's affecting your life, the NHS says to see a GP, or refer yourself to an NHS talking therapies service. This isn't the treatment.

It will come back. You'll have a fortnight of lower headcounts and a window table, and then a bad meeting or a kerb, and the beam at full strength all the way home, and the thought that you've gone backwards and this is how you are after all.

One bad Tuesday isn't the audience back. The counts you did are still true. The rooms you counted still had almost nobody in them looking at you, and a day without counting doesn't change that.

Ask which belief came back. Usually it's the headcount, high and unchallenged because you didn't stop to count. Sometimes it's the replay running on the way home, or the sense that this time they really did judge, and the answer to that is the same as before, that you can't picture a single face.

Then count late. How many people can you actually recall looking at you? Write the number down. It's nearly always lower than the one that's been running all afternoon. Count on time in the next room. The beam comes back for everyone. Now you've got something to do when it does.

It's the same café a few weeks on, and the window table's free. You've got the coffee and the book. You look at the route, past the couple and the laptop and the two women, and the heat starts. You make the headcount, and it's two, lower than it used to be. Then you look. The couple are talking. The laptop man is on a call. One of the women glances at you because you passed her bag and is back with her friend before you've finished the thought. The count is one, for a second.

You sit at the window. For a minute the beam's still faintly on, so you count the street, people walking past looking at their phones and the pavement. Then the book's good, you forget about your arms, and forty minutes go. On the way home there's nothing to replay. What you can recall of the room is the coffee, the chapter and the woman's bag.

This week, walk into one room where the beam comes on, make the headcount, and count the shoes.