Feeling fine isn't the test

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 52 min

There's a packet of blood pressure tablets in the kitchen drawer. It was a month's supply, dispensed in March. You took them every morning for the first fortnight, then a weekend away broke the run, and after that they were most mornings, and now they're something you notice when you're looking for the batteries. You felt nothing when you started them and you feel nothing now. There's a check-up you've been meaning to book, and part of the reason you haven't is that you'd have to explain the packet.

Elsewhere in the house there's a preventer inhaler that only comes out when your chest is tight, which the leaflet says isn't what it's for. There's an antidepressant you've been halving for six weeks because you feel so much better, and you haven't mentioned it at the surgery. There's a strip of antibiotics with three left, from a chest infection that cleared on day four.

Nobody decides any of this. It happens in the gap between a prescription and a life. Sometimes it's a stop, because you feel better, or you feel fine, or you never felt anything and can't see what the tablet's for. Sometimes it's a fade, from every day to most days to whenever you find the packet.

My argument is that the feeling you're judging by is the wrong instrument. For some medicines you feel fine because you're taking them. For others you'd feel exactly the same with or without them, until something serious happens. And for a short course, feeling better on day four says nothing about what the prescriber meant by day seven. So the method is simple to say. Take it the way the prescription says, and if you want to change that, stop it, or you've been skipping it, the next step is a conversation with the prescriber or a pharmacist. A quiet decision on your own isn't the next step.

I'll never tell you to stop a medicine, take less, or take more. I won't tell you your prescription was right, either. That's for the prescriber, and the point is that it should be settled there, not by the drawer.

Before you go on, find every medicine you've been prescribed and count what's left against the date it was dispensed. Don't take anything, don't throw anything away, and don't feel anything about it yet. Just write down the gap between what should be gone and what is.

Three cautions. If you take a medicine for a mental health condition and you've been thinking about stopping, the NHS says not to stop suddenly or without talking to your doctor first, because stopping can bring withdrawal symptoms, and some of them look like the illness coming back. If you or someone you know is in a mental health crisis, the NHS has urgent help, and you don't need to finish reading first. If you've been skipping a medicine for days or weeks and you're about to restart it, ring a pharmacist first, because some medicines are restarted differently after a gap and a pharmacist can tell you in a minute. And if you're not taking a medicine because you can't afford it, can't get to the pharmacy, or can't manage the number of tablets, that's no habit and no fault of yours, and I'll say who can help.

The wrong instrument

Nobody stops a medicine for no reason.

You feel better, and carrying on feels like wearing a plaster after the cut has healed. Or you've felt fine throughout, and a tablet for a thing you can't feel is hard to believe in. You missed a week and nothing happened. You don't like the idea of depending on a chemical. The side effects are real and the illness is invisible. The doctor was brisk and never said what would happen if you didn't take it.

Those are honest reasons, and research on what people believe about their medicines finds the same two forces in most of them. In a study of 324 patients with long-term conditions, Horne and Weinman found that most believed their medicine was necessary, but over a third also had strong concerns about it, mostly about dependence or long-term effects. Where concerns outweighed necessity, people took less. A later review of 94 studies and more than 25,000 patients found the pattern held. Nobody in those studies was careless. They were weighing something, using the only instrument they had, which was how they felt.

Take "I feel better, so it's done its job". It's the most natural belief here, and for a lot of medicines it's exactly backwards.

Some medicines work by holding a condition down. A preventer inhaler keeps the airways from becoming inflamed, and the lack of symptoms is the inhaler at work. The NHS says you'll usually carry on an antidepressant for at least six months after you feel better. Levothyroxine for an underactive thyroid replaces a hormone your body isn't making, and the NHS says you'll usually take it for the rest of your life to stop the symptoms coming back. For all of these, "I feel better" and "it's working right now" are the same sentence.

The trouble is that the feeling doesn't tell you which kind of medicine you're on. When a painkiller clears a headache, the medicine has finished, and that's the model most of us carry because it's the one we use most. A study of 405 adults with asthma found preventer use ran at about half of what was prescribed, and each 25 percent increase in time spent without it doubled the rate of hospital admission for asthma. Those people hadn't ignored symptoms. They'd stopped because they didn't have any.

Then there are the silent ones. High blood pressure, the NHS says, doesn't usually cause any symptoms. You felt fine before the diagnosis, you feel fine on the tablet, and you'd feel fine for years off it. None of those three feelings tells you anything about your arteries.

A study of 4,783 people on a once-a-day blood pressure tablet, with doses recorded electronically, found about half had stopped within a year. Those still taking it missed about one dose in ten, and nearly half had at least one run of three or more missed days a year. Nothing told them to take it and nothing told them they'd stopped. A review of 44 studies with nearly two million people found that those who took heart and blood pressure medicines well had lower rates of heart attack, stroke and death, and the researchers put around nine percent of cardiovascular events in Europe down to poor adherence alone.

Those numbers need a caution, since you'd find it anyway. In 2006 Simpson and colleagues pooled 21 studies and found that people who reliably took a placebo also died less often than people who didn't. Taking your tablets well tends to go with doing other healthy things, and part of the benefit in those studies comes from that. Researchers call it the healthy adherer effect. It doesn't rescue the drawer. The benefit of the tablet itself was shown in the trials that compared it with placebo, and neither finding is an argument for taking it on Tuesdays.

"I missed a few days and nothing happened" feels like an experiment with a result. It had no readout. For the silent ones there was never going to be a signal. For the holding ones, the effect often outlasts the last dose by days or weeks, because airways take time to become inflamed and an antidepressant doesn't stop working the next morning. Five quiet days are what you'd get from a tablet doing everything and from one doing nothing.

And there's a quieter risk. Blaschke and colleagues, reviewing decades of recorded dosing, noted that on-and-off taking can do harm of its own, through rebound effects when a drug stops and repeated first-dose effects when it restarts. As I read it, for some medicines the stop-start pattern is worse than either taking it steadily or stopping properly. Which medicines is exactly what a pharmacist knows and a feeling doesn't.

If you want a real result, use a real instrument. The NHS says many pharmacies will check your blood pressure for free if you're over forty, and a GP may ask you to use a home monitor for a few days. Levothyroxine comes with regular blood tests. A peak flow meter tells you how your airways are doing before your chest does. Once you have a number, the tablet stops being an act of faith. You take it and the reading comes down.

An experiment on one body

"I don't want to depend on it."

This is one of the two big concerns in Horne and Weinman's study, and the word carries a smell from elsewhere, from alcohol and nicotine and tablets people can't come off. But it's doing two jobs. Addiction means a substance has changed what your body expects until the substance is the problem. Needing a medicine is different. Someone with an underactive thyroid depends on levothyroxine the way a short-sighted person depends on glasses. Taking the glasses off doesn't prove independence. It proves the eyes were short-sighted all along.

There's a real version of the worry. Some medicines, antidepressants most clearly, do cause withdrawal symptoms, which is why the NHS says to reduce them gradually with a doctor. That's an argument for a planned stop. If anything, the person who takes the tablet every day and reviews it once a year with the prescriber is less dependent on it than the person who takes it on and off and never asks. The first has a decision. The second has a drawer.

"I'd rather not put chemicals in my body" is held sincerely, and the wish behind it is a wish for health. But the condition is chemical too. High cholesterol is a substance in your blood, and an underactive thyroid is a shortage of a hormone. And this preference is a good reason to talk, because prescribers hear it every day. The NHS statins page lists other medicines for people who can't or won't take one, and its blood pressure page puts lifestyle changes before tablets. What you can't find out from the drawer is whether your case is one where that's safe. A quiet stop turns a real preference into an unmonitored experiment on the one body you've got.

Side effects are the same. Sometimes they are worse than the illness, in the sense that you feel them and you don't feel the illness. Aching legs from a statin are a daily cost against a benefit measured in decades. But the NHS says that if you think a statin is causing side effects, you should talk to a doctor, who may prescribe a different one or change the dose, and there are several statins to choose from. Many antidepressant side effects ease after a couple of weeks, and if they don't, the doctor can discuss other options. Most of levothyroxine's side effects come from too high a dose and improve when it's changed. The side effect is information. Stop without saying anything and your record shows someone on a statin who's doing fine. You can also report a suspected side effect through the Yellow Card scheme, so it's counted somewhere other than your kitchen.

Then the fade. "I take it when I remember."

If that's you, you're in large company. The Cochrane review of ways to improve adherence opens by noting that people prescribed a medicine typically take only about half their doses. That isn't much comfort, but it does show the fade is a design problem more than a flaw in you. A daily tablet has nothing to attach to. It produces no feeling when you take it and none when you miss it, and it competes with a morning full of things that do. A review of 771 trials found modest effects overall, and the approaches that worked best were built on habit and routine, while information and persuasion did less. Knowing more about your tablet doesn't get it taken. A fixed place in a fixed minute of the day does, more often.

The antidepressant needs slowing down for, because the NHS is unusually direct. Carry on for at least six months after you feel better. Talk to your doctor if you want to stop. Don't stop suddenly or without talking to your doctor first.

The reason is withdrawal. The NHS lists headaches, feeling sick, sweating, dizziness, sleep problems and strange dreams, feeling restless or anxious or tearful, and sensations like an electric shock in the head. Some people get none. For some they're severe, start weeks or months later, and last for months. A 2024 review of 79 studies covering 21,002 patients put the rate of at least one symptom at about 31 percent after stopping an antidepressant, against about 17 percent after stopping a placebo, and severe symptoms at about three percent against under one. An earlier review of 24 studies found higher rates. They disagree on the size and agree it happens.

Here's the part that defeats the feeling test. Some withdrawal symptoms can feel like your condition coming back. Stop at three months, feel dreadful a week later, and you can't tell from the inside whether it's withdrawal or relapse. Horowitz and Taylor argued in 2019 that short tapers of two to four weeks showed little benefit over stopping outright, and that slower ones over months, down to very small doses, did better. The NHS now says a plan will usually run over several weeks or months, and that it can be slowed down, or you can go back up a step and try again later. A quiet stop has none of those options. It has a bad week and a guess.

Asthma is the cleanest case of a holding medicine. The reliever is for when you get symptoms. The preventer is for every day, to stop them happening, and the NHS says you shouldn't be given a blue reliever to use on its own. Some people now have one inhaler that does both, and its instructions come with it. With two inhalers, using the preventer only when your chest is tight turns it into a poor second reliever. In that study of 405 adults, the researchers estimated that about 60 percent of the asthma admissions wouldn't have happened with no gaps in preventer use. A well-controlled chest feels like it doesn't need anything, because of the preventer. Stop, and it feels the same for days or weeks while inflammation builds, until a cold or a cat arrives. The NHS says needing your reliever more often is a reason to see a GP, and that you should have an asthma check-up at least once a year.

Antibiotics are different, and the advice has changed. For years the rule was always finish the course. In 2017 a group of infection specialists led by Martin Llewelyn argued in the BMJ that the rule wasn't well supported. Spellberg and Rice counted more than 45 randomised trials comparing shorter courses with traditional ones and found no difference in cure rates. So courses are getting shorter, by design, at the prescriber's end. That doesn't mean stop when you feel better. The NHS says to take antibiotics as directed on the packet or leaflet, or as your GP or pharmacist told you. Feeling better and being clear of the infection aren't the same event. If you'd like to stop, ask the surgery or a pharmacist, and if the answer is yes, it comes from someone who knows which infection it was.

The other risk is the leftovers. A review of 46 studies found about 29 percent of people later used leftover antibiotics, for the next sore throat or the next child, which means the wrong drug at the wrong dose for something nobody diagnosed. The NHS says unwanted medicines go back to the pharmacy. Not the bin or the toilet, and not the drawer.

Ten minutes and a screen

Imagine a GP with ten minutes and a screen.

The screen says you've been on a blood pressure tablet since March. Today's reading is high. The screen's version is that the tablet isn't working, so the sensible next step is a higher dose, or a second tablet, or a different one. The true version is that the tablet's been in a drawer since April and today's reading is simply your blood pressure. Ten minutes go on the wrong problem, and you leave with a prescription you didn't need, while the packet stays where it was.

That's the cost the feeling test hides best. It doesn't land on you in the moment. It lands on every decision made about you afterwards, because the prescriber is steering by a map that says you're taking the tablets.

The quiet half-tablet does the same, with more harm. Levothyroxine is set by blood tests. Take half and the test comes back low, the prescriber raises the dose, you take half of that, and the next test is read against a dose you're not on. And it isn't always deliberate. Research on self-reported adherence finds people tend to overestimate how well they take their medicines. When the nurse asks "and you're taking the tablets all right?" and you say yes, you're doing what most people do. Half a tablet is often the right dose, too. Doses come in steps and strengths, and a prescriber who hears "the full dose makes me dizzy" will often say let's try half. The compromise is fine. Making it in secret breaks the system.

Only telling the truth fixes the map. "I stopped because they made me dizzy" is a ten-minute problem with a known solution. "The tablets aren't working" can be a year of rising doses. Nobody in a surgery is surprised by a drawer. What they can't work with is a drawer they don't know about.

So here's the method. Any change to a prescribed medicine, whether stopping it, cutting it, restarting it after a gap, or admitting you've drifted, starts with telling the prescriber or a pharmacist.

Start with a pharmacist for most things. The NHS says pharmacists can advise on how to use your medicine and on worries about side effects, and can refer you to a GP if they can't help. There's no appointment and no ten-minute limit. For stopping an antidepressant, or anything involving a dose change, it's the prescriber. When you're first prescribed a medicine, the NHS says a pharmacist may be able to give you up to three appointments, in person or by phone, to answer questions and check it's right for you.

Lead with the fact, in one sentence, before any apology.

  • "I've been taking these about four days a week since the spring."
  • "I stopped these in May because they made my legs ache."
  • "I've been halving the dose for six weeks and I feel fine."
  • "I'd like to come off this and I want to do it properly."

Then ask what it's for, what happens if you don't take it, how long it's for, and what to do if you miss one. Add a fifth question of your own. What would tell us it's working? For the holding ones the answer will be a feeling. For the silent ones it'll be a number.

Mostly you'll get a change, to the tablet, the dose, the time of day or the plan. Sometimes you'll get "yes, you can stop, done this way". Sometimes it's a no, with a reason, and the reason is what you were missing. Do it this week, since the annual review is the appointment the drawer has been making you avoid.

The fade needs a different fix, and resolve isn't it.

Tie the dose to something you already do every day without deciding to, like the kettle in the morning or brushing your teeth. Put the packet where that happens, so you see it at the moment, unless the leaflet says it must be kept somewhere particular, away from children or heat. Then make a missed dose visible. A weekly organiser with a compartment per day turns "did I take it?" from a memory question into a glance, and pharmacies sell them for a few pounds. Some will even fill it for you. If it's twice a day, the second dose gets its own event, like the evening meal or locking the front door, because nothing happens "twelve hours later". The levothyroxine page asks you to take it at the same time each day, with an extra rule about an empty stomach, which is the kind of detail the leaflet holds.

Expect the habit to take weeks. In a study of 96 volunteers forming a daily habit, the behaviour became automatic gradually over weeks to months, and one missed day didn't set it back.

When you do miss a dose, the NHS advice for most medicines is short. Check the leaflet, and if you're unsure, ask a pharmacist. Usually you take it when you remember, unless it's nearly time for the next one, in which case you skip the missed one. Never take a double dose to make up for it. It feels like paying back what's owed, but your body doesn't keep a ledger, and two doses close together put more of the drug in you than the prescriber meant.

The decision fits in a sentence. I take it the way the prescription says, and any change starts with a conversation, not a quiet stop.

Research on carrying out intentions finds that plans tied to a specific moment work better than intentions alone, so here are three.

  • When I feel better and think about stopping, I ring the pharmacy or surgery before I skip a dose, and say what I'm thinking.
  • When I notice a side effect, I write down what it is and when it started, tell a pharmacist or the prescriber that week, and keep taking the medicine until they say otherwise, unless the leaflet says to stop and get help.
  • When I find I've missed a dose, I do what the leaflet says, never double up, and if the organiser shows more than a couple of empty days, I ring a pharmacist before restarting.

The first conversation is the hardest, and it takes about four minutes.

The packet, counted

A fortnight's holiday with the packet left at home is the commonest way a fade starts. Count out the days before you go and put them with the passport. If you're already back and the packet hasn't been touched in two weeks, ring a pharmacist before restarting. For most medicines they'll just say start again.

The first month of a new medicine is where most quiet stops happen, because side effects arrive before the benefit and there's no habit yet. Use those pharmacist appointments in the first week.

On six tablets a day, the fade is about the pile as much as any one tablet. Ask a pharmacist to review them all together. Sometimes doses can be lined up, a twice-a-day can become once, or a tablet you've taken for years turns out to be one nobody would start you on now.

If cost is why you're not collecting a prescription, say so at the pharmacy. There are ways to pay less for regular prescriptions in England and some people pay nothing, and the pharmacist can tell you which apply. Your prescriber needs to know too, because they may be able to change what's prescribed. If you keep running out because the repeat wasn't ordered, order it when you open the last strip.

For children, the missed-dose rules above are for adults. The NHS says to talk to a doctor or pharmacist about a child's missed dose, and points to the Medicines for Children website.

And if you're missing doses because you can't keep track of the days, or because you're low most of the day most days, or because the tablets bring on something closer to dread than boredom, that's not a problem a hook can fix. The NHS says to see a GP. Mention the medicine in the same visit.

You'll probably stop again at some point. Six good weeks, then a bad month, and the organiser has been full since the tenth.

If it's been more than a few days, ring a pharmacist before you restart. Then tell the prescriber. "I stopped again in August" is the whole sentence, and it's no harder the second time. A lapse you mention gives them something to work with. A lapse you hide gives them five more months of the wrong map. Then look at which belief did it. Feeling fine needs a number. Feeling better raises the question of whether it's a holding medicine. With side effects, there's probably a conversation you still haven't had. A fade means the hook failed, and the fix is a better hook or a more visible packet.

Taking tablets badly is what most people do, half the time. The ones who look good at it have a hook and a pharmacist they talk to, and both can be set up again on a Tuesday.

Go back to the drawer. The count you made at the start is still true, and nothing here has changed the number of tablets in the packet.

Take the packet, and anything else you counted, to a pharmacy this week, and say it. "I've been prescribed these, I've been taking them about half the time, and I'd like to know what to do." You'll get one of a few answers. Take them, and here's how to make it easier. Stop them, and here's how. See the prescriber, and here's what to tell them.

Any of those beats the drawer.