Get it looked at

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 51 min

It's a Tuesday morning in September, and you're getting out of the shower. In the mirror you catch sight of the mole on your left shoulder. You've had it as long as you can remember. In March, drying yourself after a swim, you thought it looked different, a bit bigger perhaps, darker on one side than the other. You twisted round to look and thought, "I should get that looked at."

That was six months ago.

Is it bigger than in March? You can't tell, because you've no photograph to compare. It might be exactly the same. You pull your shirt on, and as the collar goes over the mole the thought goes with it. You'll ring the surgery this week, when things calm down.

You've had that thought perhaps thirty times since March, and each time another thought followed quickly, then a small relief. It's probably nothing, you've had it for ever. Ringing at eight means half an hour on hold. They're run off their feet and you'd feel a fool going in with a mole. Work is mad this month. Under all of them is one that never quite gets put into words. What if it isn't nothing?

Most days you don't think about it at all. Then once every week or two it turns up uninvited, with a headline, or a colleague's story about a friend's diagnosis, or at ten past three in the morning for no reason at all. At ten past three it doesn't feel like nothing. You lie there and promise you'll ring in the morning. In the morning it's light, and it's probably nothing again.

Yours may be a lump, a cough that's gone on too long, a tooth that twinges with cold drinks. It might be an envelope. The bowel screening kit in the bathroom cabinet since June, the smear test letter, the dentist you last saw when your youngest was at primary school.

The pattern is usually the same, and this is my own observation. It begins with a true thought, "I should get that looked at", which you've never disagreed with. A reason arrives within seconds, always a respectable one. You're busy, or the surgery is, or it's probably nothing. The reason is never "I'm frightened". A small relief follows. And the thought comes back.

My argument is that putting it off makes sense from the inside, because not knowing feels safer than knowing, and researchers have found that feeling in every group they've studied. The safety is an illusion, though. The appointment doesn't change what's there. Most things people put off turn out to be nothing, so the usual reward for going is relief, and for the few that are something, earlier is nearly always better. Then there's a simple rule and a way of making the call.

This isn't medical advice. I'm not a doctor and I can't tell you what your symptom means. What I can do is help you get it in front of someone who can.

Three cautions.

  • If something is happening right now that might be an emergency, don't book an appointment and don't keep reading. The NHS says to call 999 for sudden chest pain that doesn't go away, chest pain that spreads to your arm, neck, jaw, stomach or back, or chest pain with sweating, sickness, light-headedness or shortness of breath. If you're not sure how urgent something is, NHS 111 will tell you where to go.
  • If your trouble is the opposite, this isn't written for you. Some people worry about their health constantly, check their bodies often and go back to the doctor again and again for reassurance that doesn't last. The NHS calls that health anxiety, and being told to get things looked at would make it worse. There's more on where to get help near the end.
  • The services I describe are those in England. Screening ages, booking and costs differ in Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland and elsewhere.

If you're willing, make a list now of everything outstanding, the things noticed and not checked, the overdue appointments, the unanswered invitations, each with roughly how long it's been. You don't have to act on it yet. I'd guess the oldest has been there longer than you'd have said.

As far as I know

If you've put something off for six months you're in large company, and you're not being stupid.

When Jennifer Taber and colleagues asked 1,369 Americans why they avoided medical care, a third gave reasons that included fear, embarrassment and dread. A review by Lucy Smith, Catherine Pope and Johannes Botha pulled together 32 studies of the gap between noticing a symptom and seeing a doctor, across at least twenty cancers, and the stories were strikingly alike. People explained symptoms away as age, a pulled muscle, something they'd eaten. And they feared the consultation, partly from embarrassment, because the symptom seemed too trivial or involved a private part of the body, and partly from fear of cancer itself.

I'd put it as fear of bad news, which is the deepest and least often said aloud, fear of being a nuisance, fear of the procedure, and hassle. Under them are needs nobody should be ashamed of. The question is whether putting it off serves any of them.

Start with the belief at the centre, the one that's hardly ever said because it falls apart once you say it. While nobody has examined the mole, I'm a healthy person with a mole. If I go, I might come out as a person with skin cancer. So the appointment is where the danger lies.

The appointment doesn't put anything into the mole. Whatever it is, it was that in March and it's been that every day since. If it's harmless, you've spent six months uneasy about a harmless thing. If it isn't, it's had six months with a free hand. A doctor's look changes what you know about the mole, and nothing about the mole itself. Not checking the forecast doesn't keep the rain away. You're just out without a coat when it comes.

Alexander Persoskie and colleagues found a telling pattern in a national American sample. Among people aged fifty and over, worry about cancer went with avoiding the doctor, but only in people who also thought their chance of having cancer was high. The researchers' reading is that worry sends people towards information they expect to reassure them, and away from information they expect to confirm what they fear. So the avoidance grows with the suspicion. If you went to the dentist quicker than you've gone about the mole, that fits. You've stayed away longest from what frightens you most.

The safe feeling rests on being able to say, truthfully, "as far as I know, I'm fine". The words "as far as I know" are doing all the work, and the putting off keeps them true by keeping you ignorant. Your body isn't affected by what you know.

"It's probably nothing." Of all the reasons, this one is most often right. Most moles are harmless, and the NHS says moles are usually nothing to worry about unless they change size, shape or colour. It says most breast lumps are harmless too, and that when a GP refers someone to a breast clinic the tests usually show the lump isn't cancer.

The voice is right about the odds. It goes wrong in the conclusion, "so I needn't go". If it's probably nothing, the likeliest outcome of the appointment is good news. You walk in with a worry and walk out without it. Six months of unease, gone in ten minutes.

There are two kinds of relief here, and this is my own reasoning. The "probably nothing" kind, as you pull your shirt on, lasts until the next headline. It needs renewing every week or two, and each renewal is a little less convincing, because part of you notices how often you need it. The kind a doctor gives you comes from someone who knows and has looked, and it lasts. Lay it out branch by branch.

  • If it's nothing, going gets you lasting relief. Not going gets you cheap, short relief and a continuing low dread.
  • If it's something, going gets you an earlier start. Not going gets you a later one.

I can't find the branch where putting it off comes out ahead. The NHS also thinks a breast lump is probably nothing, and still says to always get one checked.

That leaves the fear underneath. "If it's bad, I'd rather not know." It's one of the most reasonable fears a person can have, and the part of you that holds it is trying to protect you. The protection only works, though, if bad news is equally bad whenever it arrives.

Cancer Research UK publishes survival by stage at diagnosis, using NHS data for England from 2016 to 2020. For bowel cancer, about 91 per cent of people diagnosed at the earliest stage survive five years or more, against about 11 per cent at the latest. For breast cancer in women it's 98 per cent against 27.

Those figures are easy to misuse. They don't mean one person who waits six months moves from the first group to the last. Cancers grow at different speeds, and an earlier find gets a head start on the five-year clock. A large review by Neal and colleagues found the 209 studies on delay too varied for firm overall conclusions. For several cancers, including breast, bowel, head and neck, testicular and melanoma, more of them found that shorter times to diagnosis went with better outcomes, and the reviewers judged it reasonable to assume faster diagnosis benefits patients, by varying amounts. And once a cancer has been found, Timothy Hanna and colleagues found across 34 studies that each four-week delay to surgery was associated with a 6 to 8 per cent rise in the risk of death. That's a different wait, and it suggests time matters in weeks.

I give those numbers once and won't repeat them. If fear were enough to get you to the doctor, you'd have gone in March. They're here because they answer the question. "I'd rather not know" assumes knowing later costs the same as knowing now, and it doesn't. The size of bad news isn't fixed, and you have some say in when you hear it.

Most of what people fear isn't cancer anyway. The twinging tooth needs a dull twenty-minute filling, and left three more years it may need a root canal. High blood pressure found at a health check can be treated with a daily tablet, and left unfound it can lead to a stroke. For most conditions, seeing someone early is how the bad world is kept small.

Somebody else's job

In Britain, the next reason carries special weight. The surgery is stretched and everyone knows it. Taking a slot for something that's probably nothing feels selfish.

Susanne Cromme, Katriina Whitaker and colleagues interviewed 62 people in England aged fifty and over who'd reported a possible warning sign of cancer and still had it three months later. The worry about wasting the GP's time came up again and again, stronger when people could see the pressure for themselves or had once met a dismissive GP. What eased it included a friendly GP, and the view that deciding what's trivial is the doctor's job.

That last view is right, and I'd put it more strongly. Nobody can tell a harmless mole from a harmful one in the bathroom mirror. "I don't want to waste their time with something trivial" carries a hidden claim that you've already worked out it's trivial. You haven't. If you had, it wouldn't visit you at ten past three. Sorting the trivial from the serious is the work. From the doctor's side the expensive patient is the one who brings the mole after two years, when it needs surgery and months of treatment.

There are lighter ways in, too. A pharmacist can look at a good many minor things and tell you whether you need a doctor, with no appointment. NHS 111, by phone or online, asks you questions and tells you what level of care you need. And many surgeries now have an online form where you describe the problem, and someone there decides whether and how soon you need to be seen. If you dread taking a slot, that's ideal. The surgery makes the very decision you didn't trust yourself to make.

If the thing is somewhere private, doctors and nurses examine such things many times a week, and what feels mortifying to you is routine to them. The way through is usually one awkward sentence. "I've got a problem that's a bit embarrassing to talk about." Clinicians hear it often and know how to make the next minute easy.

Then there's the chair.

For some people the fear is less about the news than the experience. The drill, the speculum, the needle, the scanner that feels like a tunnel. Fear of dental treatment is among the commonest fears there is, and it's been studied well. Jason Armfield, Judy Stewart and John Spencer surveyed 6,112 Australians and found every link of a vicious cycle. People with more dental fear went less often, had worse oral health and more need for treatment, and when they did go it was more often because something hurt.

Trace it through. Fear keeps you away, small problems grow, and when pain finally forces you in, the visit means more drilling and more injections than a check-up would have. That confirms the fear, and you stay away longer. Someone who goes every year mostly has check-ups and the odd small filling. Someone who goes once in five years, in agony, has root canals and extractions. Your fear is an accurate report of your experience, and the avoidance is what made the experience so bad.

The cycle runs the other way too. One ordinary appointment, even with a filling or two, starts replacing the bad memories with a duller one. The NHS says the gap between check-ups can be anywhere from three months to two years depending on your teeth and gums, so the every-six-months standard you've been failing may not apply to you. Its advice for the appointment is to tell your dental team you're anxious. A dentist who knows will usually go slower and agree a signal for you to stop, which takes away much of the helplessness. For a smear test you can ask for a smaller instrument, a different position, a longer appointment or a friend in the room. Tell the person taking blood if needles are the problem. An appointment that's bearable is one you'll come back for.

If the fear is so severe you can't even make the call without panic, it may be a phobia, and phobias respond well to treatment. A GP or the NHS talking therapies service can help. Getting help with the fear counts as getting the thing looked at.

Meanwhile the putting off charges you, even when the thing is nothing. You pay in dread, many times the discomfort of the appointment, in instalments. You check it yourself in the mirror or online at midnight, which brings the anxiety of medical attention with none of the benefit. And shame builds, until there's a second thing to avoid, the doctor asking how long it's been like this. "I've left this longer than I should have" covers it.

Four minutes

Here's a finding that changes what the task is.

Charlotte Vrinten, Jo Waller, Christian von Wagner and Jane Wardle surveyed nearly 8,000 people in a British bowel screening trial about three kinds of cancer fear, then checked clinic records to see who actually turned up. Fearing cancer more than other diseases, and worrying about it often, more than doubled the odds that people intended to be screened. Neither made any difference to whether they attended. The third kind, finding thoughts about cancer uncomfortable, didn't lower intentions at all. It lowered attendance.

So the people who stayed away weren't unworried. They meant to go and couldn't bear to think about it. Intending takes a moment. Attending means holding the subject in mind long enough to read the letter, make the arrangements and get there. I think that's the putting off exactly. You've intended to go for six months, and each time the thought comes you move off it within seconds, using a respectable reason. Nothing gets booked, because booking means staying with the thought for the four minutes it takes.

You don't need to become less afraid. You may have good reason to be. You need to stay with the thought for four minutes.

Jennifer Howell and James Shepperd found something that may help. People who filled in a risk calculator for a medical condition, invented though they didn't know it, were less likely to avoid seeing their result if they'd first spent a moment reflecting on something they valued about themselves or their lives. The idea is that threatening news is easier to face when your sense of yourself feels secure. These were laboratory studies, and carrying them over to a phone call is my step.

The same flinch explains the envelope in the cabinet. In England, bowel screening is a kit you do at home every two years from 50 to 74. Cervical screening is every five years from 25 to 64. There's breast screening, and the NHS Health Check for heart and stroke risk between 40 and 74.

Screening isn't a pure good. Every test produces some false alarms, which mean anxious weeks and further tests for people who turn out fine, and some programmes find slow-growing conditions that would never have caused trouble. That's why the invitations come with information about benefits and risks, and why they're a choice. A person who reads the leaflet and decides a test isn't for them has made a decision, and I've no quarrel with it.

The kit in the cabinet is different. Nobody read the leaflet. It went in the cabinet because opening it meant thinking about bowel cancer for ten minutes. A decision has been made, since the test isn't happening, and nobody made it. So open the envelope, read it, ring the number on the letter if you have questions, and decide. If yes, do it this week. If no, throw the letter away with a clear mind. The one thing not to do is carry on as you are, with neither the test nor any peace about it.

As for hassle, it's real. The eight o'clock queue, the hunt for an NHS dentist, time off work. It's also the most respectable reason, because "you can't get an appointment" never mentions fear. Ask for a routine appointment, which many surgeries book a week or more ahead. For a mole you've had six months, three weeks is fine. Use the online form if your surgery has one. Ring round dental practices and ask about waiting lists, and if you're in dental pain, NHS 111 can direct you to urgent care. "I've got a medical appointment" is a complete sentence at work. And the harder it is to get seen, the sooner you need to join the queue.

Now the call itself, and here the evidence is good. Paschal Sheeran and Sheina Orbell worked with 114 women in rural England who were due for cervical screening and equally motivated to go. Half were also asked to write down when, where and how they'd make the appointment. Of those who didn't, 69 per cent attended. Of those who did, 92 per cent. Same intentions, same fears, one sentence.

So write the sentence. "Tomorrow at ten past eight, at the kitchen table, I'll ring the surgery on my mobile and ask for a routine appointment about a mole." A time, a place, a method. Or "Tonight at nine, on the laptop, I'll fill in the surgery's form."

When the time comes, take two minutes first. Think of who you're doing this for, your children, the partner who's asked three times, your next thirty years. You're reminding yourself your life is large and this is a small errand on its behalf. Then dial while that's still in your mind.

The call can be short. "Hello, I'd like to book a routine appointment. I've got a mole that's changed and I'd like it looked at." Take the date offered. If ringing is beyond you, use the form, go to the desk, or have someone sit beside you while you dial.

At the appointment, write down beforehand what you noticed and when, because people go blank in consulting rooms. Say the main thing first. Say the fear aloud, "I'm worried this might be skin cancer", because if you don't, the doctor may reassure you about something you weren't worried about. Before you leave, know what happens next. You can bring someone, and ask for a chaperone for intimate examinations.

Then the rule, which goes with the catching. When I catch myself putting it off, I book it that day. You can't stop "it's probably nothing" from following "I should get that looked at". That sequence will keep running. What you can do is hear it, and from now on the respectable reason, arriving within seconds, is the signal to book.

  • Clear the list. Order it with changes in your body first, then overdue check-ups, then invitations. Book the first today and one a week after that. Anything that worries you a lot goes first.
  • After that, the rule handles new things. Booking means that by the end of the day it's in somebody else's hands, whether by phone, form, pharmacist or 111.
  • Book the next dentist or optician appointment before you leave the last, so there's no fresh decision for the putting off to get into.
  • Open screening letters the day they come and decide within the week.

A few if-then plans help, of the kind Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran found make people a good deal more likely to follow through across 94 tests. When I hear myself say "it's probably nothing", I'll say "then it'll be a quick appointment" and book it. When I catch myself checking it in the mirror or online, I'll close the browser and write my booking sentence. When a letter from the NHS arrives, I'll open it before I take my coat off.

A forty-second look

The first call will be unpleasant for about four minutes. The relief afterwards is usually immediate and bigger than expected, though nothing has been examined. I can't tell you everything will be fine. I can say the not knowing will end.

Some of what follows is harder.

There may be a wait for results, a referral, a scan or a biopsy. A referral isn't a diagnosis. Doctors refer when they can't be sure, a low bar on purpose, and the NHS says breast clinic tests usually show a lump isn't cancer. This wait has an end date, and you aren't carrying it alone. If it's hard to bear, tell someone close and tell your GP. If you've heard nothing by when you were told, ring and ask, because letters do go astray.

Sometimes it is something. If that happens, I'm sorry, and I won't offer cheer you haven't asked for. Going when you did was the best move available. Try not to blame yourself for the months before. Nearly everybody delays, and hindsight makes signs look clearer than they were. Your clinical team, your GP and the cancer charities offer support for the fear as well as the illness.

If you feel brushed off, and a problem persists, changes or gets worse after you've been told it's nothing, go back. You can see a different doctor and say, "I came about this two months ago and it hasn't gone away, and I'm still worried." Every surgery has a complaints process, and you're entitled to a second opinion.

Some things shouldn't be booked at all. The chest pain symptoms at the start mean 999. For anything else sudden or severe, or if you're unsure, use 111. That isn't wasting anyone's time.

And if you recognise the opposite pattern, the NHS describes health anxiety as spending so much time worrying that you're ill, or going to get ill, that it starts to take over your life. Its signs include constantly checking your body, always seeking reassurance, and worrying that doctors or tests have missed something. For that, "get it looked at" makes things worse. A GP or the NHS talking therapies service can help, and the NHS page on health anxiety has self-help steps. The treatment involves less checking.

You'll put something off again. When you catch it, book it that day and don't spend time scolding yourself for the fortnight. If it's someone you love who's putting it off, nagging tends to harden it. "Would it help if I sat with you while you rang?" works better.

Here's how Tuesday might go. I've given it the likeliest ending, which isn't the only one.

You step out of the shower and see the mole, and the thoughts run as they always have. Probably nothing. The surgery's run off its feet. This time you hear them arrive, and you know what they mean.

At the kitchen table you write on the back of an envelope. "Today, 8.10, at this table, I ring the surgery and ask for a routine appointment about a mole." You think for a minute about your daughter's wedding next summer and the walking holiday you keep promising yourself. At ten past eight you ring. Fourteen minutes on hold, during which you unload the dishwasher. They offer a week on Thursday at ten to nine, and you take it. You put the phone down feeling lighter, which surprises you. The mole is exactly what it was at eight o'clock. For the first time since March, it's somebody else's job.

A week on Thursday you say, "I first noticed it looked different in March. I'm worried it might be skin cancer." The doctor looks through a small lens under a bright light for perhaps forty seconds, asks a couple of questions, and says she's not concerned. It's a harmless kind. She takes a photograph for your record, so there's something to compare with, and says to come back if it changes. You're out by five past nine.

Six months of ten past threes, for a forty-second look.

Sometimes the doctor will say, "I'd like someone else to look at that," and then you'll be glad you didn't wait until Christmas. Much more often, months of dread end in a short conversation in a small room.

So take the item at the top of your list and write the sentence, with when, where and how. Then, at the time you've written down, make the call.