Go to bed cross if you have to
The 20-minute version
It starts at ten past ten, over the dishwasher. One of you stacked it and the other restacked it, and there was a remark, and a remark back.
By half past ten it's about how you never listen. By eleven it's about their mother, and by half past eleven it's about the thing from March. At ten past midnight one of you says "let's just go to bed", and the other says "no, we're sorting this", because you don't go to bed on an argument. That's the rule. Your parents said it, and the rows you've left overnight have always been worse for it. Or you think they have.
At one in the morning you're both still on the sofa. The same three things have been said eleven times each, with less accuracy and more heat every round, and something got said at half past twelve that neither of you meant and both of you will remember. Eventually one of you cries or one of you gives in, and you go up, and the alarm is at half past six. The next day you're both wrecked and short with each other and with the children, and the dishwasher is still stacked wrong.
That's invented, but I'd guess yours is close.
Here's my case. The habit makes sense from the inside. The old rule sounds like wisdom, leaving a row unfinished feels like abandoning it, and you can't imagine sleeping with it unsettled. But the late hour is the worst hour of the day to settle anything. Mood falls through the waking day, short sleep makes people quicker to react badly to anything negative, and the same three points go round at one in the morning without moving, because the part of you that could move them has already clocked off. Sleep doesn't let a row fester, either. It works on it, and the morning version is smaller and truer. So the practical answer is this. After ten, you don't settle arguments. Either of you can call a truce, you name a time tomorrow, and you go to bed cross if you have to.
None of that means avoiding conflict or swallowing things. The row matters, which is exactly why it deserves the two of you at eight in the morning and not the two of you at one.
Two cautions. If the late arguments come with contempt, threats or fear, or one of you isn't free to leave the room, that isn't a habit and a method won't hold it. The National Domestic Abuse Helpline is free and open day and night on 0808 2000 247. And if the rows sit on top of a low mood in either of you, low most of the day for a fortnight, that's a conversation for a GP, and the rows will be easier once it's had.
Before anything changes, keep a list for a month. Every argument that starts after nine in the evening, with the time it started, the time it ended, whether anything was settled, and one word for the next day. Most couples who do this find the settled column says no all the way down.
The worst hour
Never go to bed on an argument. It assumes a settlement is there to be had at midnight if you only keep going. It isn't, and the reason can be measured.
Scott Golder and Michael Macy, in 2011, analysed millions of public messages posted through the day by people in dozens of countries and traced how their emotional tone moved with the clock. The pattern was the same everywhere. People wake in a good mood, and it deteriorates as the day goes on, with a small lift in the evening and then a decline toward night. The researchers said this fitted the effects of sleep and the body clock. It's social media data and it's about mood in general, not rows. But it puts the late hour at the low point of most people's waking day, and that's where the old rule sends you to do the hardest thing a couple does.
The people who handed you the rule meant never leave things unmended, and that part's right. They just picked the wrong hour.
"If we stop now, it'll fester."
Matthew Walker and Els van der Helm, in a 2009 review, drew together research on what sleep does to emotion. Their model is that sleep is a stage of emotional life and not a pause in it. During sleep, especially the dreaming phase, the brain reprocesses the day's emotional experiences, and the effect is to bring the next day's reactivity back into range. What was raw in the evening is still remembered in the morning, with less charge on it. They titled the paper "Overnight therapy?", question mark included, and I'd keep the question mark, because it's a model. Its direction is the opposite of festering, though.
Picture the two mornings. In one you settled it at one, meaning somebody gave in, and you wake after five hours with an agreement you can't quite remember making and a sentence from half past twelve still hanging in the room. In the other you stopped at half past ten, slept seven hours, and wake with the row smaller and a time at eight to finish it. In my observation, and that's all it is, the first morning is worse. What festers is a row with no time to come back to. Give it a time and it's parked, and parked things wait.
"I can't sleep until it's sorted."
What's keeping you awake isn't that the row is unsettled. It's that it's live. Two people still talking and still escalating at eleven have bodies at full stretch, and a body doesn't stand down on command just because someone gave in at one. Marie Vandekerckhove and Raymond Cluydts, in a 2010 review, described the loop. Emotional stress in the day affects sleep that night, and lost sleep makes people more sensitive to stressful events the next day. A row at one in the morning is the first half of that loop feeding the second, which feeds tomorrow night's row.
A truce is what lets you sleep. Both of you have agreed to stop, there's a time attached, and the row is still open but no longer live. You can lie next to an open row, cross, and sleep. Most couples who try it are surprised how quickly they drop off, because what kept them up was that nobody had stopped.
"We're both adults. We can talk it through."
Clare Anderson and Charlotte Platten, in 2011, kept people awake for one night and then tested how they responded to negative things. After one sleepless night, people were more impulsive with negative stimuli. They failed more often to hold back a response, and when they got it wrong, they got it wrong faster. William Killgore, in a 2010 review of what sleep loss does to thinking, found some kinds of reasoning hold up fairly well while the flexible, creative thinking that depends on the front of the brain degrades. A 2007 paper by Seung-Schik Yoo, Matthew Walker and colleagues has a title that sums it up, a disconnect between the prefrontal cortex and the amygdala without sleep. In ordinary words, the brakes come off the part of you that reacts.
You haven't been up all night at eleven. But you've been up since half past six, you're in the low hour, and the row has been running for an hour, and those findings describe which way things move as sleep runs short. They don't mark a line you're safely behind. The two of you on the sofa at one have the same values and the same love as the two of you at eight, with less of the equipment for using either. The flexible thinking that finds a third option goes first. The holding back that stops the sentence about their mother goes next.
"We used to talk till three and it was fine."
You did. Twenty-four, the kitchen floor, two in the morning, one of the best conversations of your life. But you weren't settling a row about a dishwasher then. You were finding out about each other, nobody was defending a position, and nobody had a thing from March. Loosened brakes are bad at holding back a sharp sentence and rather good at saying a true thing you'd have been shy of at noon. At twenty-four the true things were the point. Now the true thing at half past twelve is about their mother. And the morning then was a lecture you could skip, not an alarm, two children and a job. The late hour is good for talking. It was never good for settling.
Laps
Write down what was said at eleven and what was said at half past twelve. The words will be almost the same. The tone won't.
That's the circuit. The dishwasher, the listening, the mother, said by each of you in turn in slightly different words with slightly more heat, for two hours. It doesn't approach an end. It has laps. You can feel it from the inside if you look for it, the sense at half past twelve that you've already said this, it isn't landing, and the only thing left is to say it louder.
It goes round because of what tiredness takes first. The part of you that could take the three points and find a fourth, the "actually, I think what's really bothering me is", is the flexible part, and it's gone by midnight. What's left can restate, and restating is all a circuit is made of.
"It's not really about the dishwasher, though. Midnight is where we finally get to the real thing."
I agree it isn't about the dishwasher. Midnight is where you lose it. The dishwasher becomes the listening, which becomes the mother, which becomes March, and that feels like going deeper when it's really going wider. Each new subject arrives because a tired brain can't hold the last one. By one you have five subjects and no depth on any of them, and the real thing is buried under four other rows. Check your list. If a row ends on a bigger subject than it started with, it drifted. A row that finds the real thing gets narrower and ends on one quiet sentence you both recognise.
"I think I was cross about the dishwasher because I felt like I'd done everything else that day too."
That's the fourth point. People say it at eight, over coffee, after a night's sleep has worked on it. At midnight the same person says "and another thing".
Then there's the shame of stopping. Couples who are all right, the feeling goes, don't need to go to bed cross. Look at what the settlement at one usually is. One of you gave in, or one of you cried and the other stopped, or you both said "fine" and went up. Those are endings produced by exhaustion, and they haven't settled the dishwasher or March. The couple who can say "we're both too tired for this, eight o'clock", go up cross and be at the table at eight are doing something harder and more competent. Cross is a state two people who love each other can be in on a Tuesday night. It isn't a verdict on the marriage.
The fear underneath is often about the other person. Say "let's stop", and they'll hear that you don't care enough to finish. But caring at eleven looks like saying the same thing a fourth time with more edge to someone who's stopped hearing it. There's a sentence that says what you mean. "I care about this too much to do it tired." And what the other person wants at eleven is to be heard, which a truce called properly can give them. "I've heard what you're saying and I want to answer it properly, and I can't at this hour."
If the old rule has run in your house for years, though, "let's stop" may always have meant "I'm done". And in some houses it's always the same person who lets it go.
Andrew Christensen and Christopher Heavey, in 1990, described a pattern they called demand and withdraw. One partner presses with requests and complaints, and the other pulls back into silence or defensiveness. Whoever wanted the change pressed, and whoever was being asked to change withdrew. Withdrawing leaves the argument with no agreement and no time to return, and the person pressing is left pushing at nothing, which feels like being abandoned. The silent treatment, the sofa without a word, the "fine" and the turned back are all withdrawals, and the old rule was right to fear them.
A truce differs in two ways. Both of you know it's happening and why. And it has a time on it. "Eight o'clock" is what tells the person who was pressing that the argument has been parked and they'll be heard with a rested head.
The time is also the answer to the strongest objection, the one that's simply true. "Last time we slept on it we never came back to it." Rows slept on with no plan do get dropped. Morning comes, nobody wants to be the one who reopens it, and it goes on the pile that the next row is really about. With a named time, raising it in the morning reopens nothing. You're keeping an appointment. "It's eight. Shall we?" If you've slept on rows and lost them, you did the hard half. The appointment was missing.
"Sleeping on it never solves anything."
Rested people solve arguments, and sleep is what makes them rested. Eli Finkel and colleagues, in 2013, found that couples who spent twenty-one minutes over a year writing about their conflicts from the view of a neutral third party who wanted the best for both of them stopped showing the decline in marital quality that other couples showed, and the mechanism was less distress about conflict. That outsider's view needs exactly the flexible perspective-taking that sleep loss erodes. At eight you can take it. At midnight you can only take your own seat.
"The morning's too busy."
Brant Hasler and Wendy Troxel, in 2010, followed twenty-nine couples for a week with sleep monitors and daily reports. For the men, a better night's sleep predicted less negative interaction with their partner the next day. For the women, less negative interaction during the day predicted better sleep that night, for them and for their partner. It's a small study and I'd hold it loosely. The direction is that sleep and how a couple gets on feed each other, and the morning after a truce is the one point in that loop where you're on the good side of it. The morning is too busy for three hours. Ten minutes is all a dishwasher row needs when both of you can think.
The bill, briefly.
- Five hours' sleep instead of seven, after three hours at full stretch, when the NHS says adults need seven to nine.
- A next day of two tired people being short with each other, which makes the next row.
- Whatever got said at half past twelve, which wasn't meant, will be remembered, and turns up in the next row as evidence.
- The children, because walls are thin and children sleep lightly, and a child who hears the sofa at midnight learns that grown-ups don't stop.
- Only ever having the everything row, and never the ten-minute one about the dishwasher that would have fixed the dishwasher.
Couples who move their rows to the morning often say they'd thought they were bad at arguing. They'd only ever been arguing at one in the morning.
Eight o'clock, kitchen table
Agree it on a good day. A Sunday, with tea. Not during a row, because at eleven nobody agrees to anything.
The two of you decide that after ten o'clock either of you can call a truce, and a truce means the row stops and a time gets named. Then practise the sentence. "I care about this too much to do it tired. Eight o'clock." Your own version works if it has three things in it, that the row matters, that the hour is wrong, and a time. It'll feel absurd on the Sunday. At eleven it'll be there when nothing else is.
Some rules for the truce, agreed on the same Sunday.
- Either of you can call it, and the other honours it. It belongs to the agreement, not to whoever wants to stop.
- No last word. The row stops where it is, mid-sentence if need be. The one who calls it doesn't get one more point, and the one who hears it doesn't get to answer. Whatever was going to be said goes on the note.
- Calling it isn't winning, and neither is being on the end of it. Nothing has been conceded or settled.
- The first one will probably be refused with "no, we're sorting this". Say the sentence again and stand up. The person refusing is the one who'll be at the table at eight, and that's when they'll see what it's for.
Then the time. A real one, never just "tomorrow". "Eight, at the table, before the school run." "Half past eight tomorrow evening, before the television." "On the walk after drop-off." Before the low hour comes round again. Say how long, too. Ten minutes is enough for most rows when two people can think, and a ten-minute appointment is one you can keep. If it needs more, you'll know by the end and can book more. Have it at the kitchen table or wherever you talk best, with daylight and coffee, and never on the sofa the row was on.
Before bed, whoever called the truce writes one line on paper and leaves it by the kettle. The subject, not the case for their side. "Dishwasher, and feeling like I do everything." Writing one line forces a subject, and the subject is usually nearer the truth than anything the sofa would have produced in two hours. It also stops the morning from opening with an argument about what the argument was.
Then go up together. Sleep in the same bed, cross, and here's why. You've both agreed to stop and neither of you has won, and lying in one bed is the physical form of that agreement. It says that cross is a state the two of you can be in together. The sofa says the argument has become a division, and leaves one of you alone with the row at one in the morning, running the circuit with nobody even there to interrupt it. There are households where the same bed isn't the right answer, and I'll come to them.
Phones go downstairs or face down. A message sent at half past eleven is the half-past-twelve sentence with a timestamp on it.
If anything is said, say it once. "We're not finished and that's fine. Eight o'clock." Then lie there. A body takes a while to stand down after a row, so give it twenty minutes and breathe out slowly a few times. Your mind will drift back to the row, and that's fine. Remember the note and the time and let it run down. If sleep won't come for a while, that's the body still standing down, and it gets quicker with each truce. If a hand finds a hand in the night, that isn't the settlement. It means you're still the two of you, cross, which was always allowed.
In the morning, either of you opens it. "It's eight. Shall we?" Treat the first few as you'd treat a hospital appointment. Be there. Have the ten minutes. If the row has shrunk overnight to nothing, which happens, say so and have the coffee anyway, because being there is what's being learned. A month of kept eight o'clocks is what turns "let's stop" from something your partner dreads into something they trust.
The decision, made together on that Sunday. After ten, we don't settle arguments. Either of us can call a truce, we name a time tomorrow, and we go to bed cross if we have to.
Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran reviewed ninety-four studies in 2006 of plans made in the form "when this happens, I'll do that". People who planned that way followed through much more often than people who only held the intention. So write three, together.
When a disagreement is still going at half past ten, one of us will say "I care about this too much to do it tired, eight o'clock", and both of us will stop.
When we've called a truce, whoever called it will write one line about what it was about and leave it by the kettle.
When it's the resume time, whoever's there first will say "shall we?" and we'll have ten minutes at the table.
This part is my expectation, not a finding. The first truce will be resisted, usually by whoever needed it most, and they'll be at the table at eight surprised how small the row has got. The first night cross will be a poor night for both of you and still better than the sofa. The first resume time will be short and awkward and may end with "I don't even know why I was so cross". By the third truce the sentence comes out on its own at half past ten, from whichever of you spots the circuit first, and the other says "fine, eight". By a month, a fair number of the rows turn out at eight to have been about being tired, which is the one row the morning always wins.
Two in the morning, in July
It'll happen. A row with something real in it, a night when neither of you called it, the old rule back in the room because it's had years there. It's two in the morning, nothing is settled, and the alarm is at half past six.
Call the truce late. It works at two as well as at half past ten. Then up, same bed, note by the kettle, and the resume time is still the resume time.
Then find out what got through. If it was "it'll fester", because this one felt bigger, notice at eight whether it did. If it was the other person's hurt face when you reached for the sentence, use the version with the caring in it. If neither of you had the sentence ready because the Sunday agreement had faded, have the Sunday conversation again this weekend. Don't count nights without a sofa. Count resume times kept, and notice that the morning after a two o'clock is worse than the morning after a truce.
Some things need their own handling.
Big things, like money, a move, a child or whether to stay together, need the truce more, not less. A big thing decided at one in the morning has been decided by the tired version of you both. The resume time might be Saturday morning with two hours set aside, and that's fine. It just isn't midnight.
If the same row comes back every fortnight, the note will show it, because it'll say the same thing each time. That row needs a longer conversation at a chosen hour, and possibly a third person. Relate is the best-known UK provider of couples counselling, and going admits nothing except that the dishwasher row has run for a year.
If one of you calls the truce and the other keeps refusing it, the Sunday agreement isn't being honoured, and the truce turns into a withdrawal whether anyone means it to or not. Go back to the Sunday conversation about the rule itself. If it can't be agreed, the pattern is bigger than a method, and a counsellor is the right third seat. If the refusal comes with any of what I'm about to name, it isn't a refusal.
Some couples sleep apart for reasons that have nothing to do with rows, such as snoring, shifts or a baby. The truce and the resume time work just the same. What matters is that a row isn't what put one of you on the sofa.
Children hear. A child who hears "eight o'clock" and a door closing learns that adults can be cross and stop and sort it in the morning, which most children never see. If they ask the next day whether you were arguing, the answer is yes, and we've sorted it.
And if the late rows come with contempt, names, threats or things thrown, or one of you is frightened of the other or can't leave the room or the house, please ring the National Domestic Abuse Helpline on 0808 2000 247, free, at any hour, and don't try to apply a method to something a method can't hold. If either of you sleeps badly whether or not there's been a row, the NHS insomnia pages say when to see a GP.
Some months on, it starts at ten past ten, over the dishwasher.
There's a remark and a remark back, and by half past ten it's heading for the listening and the mother. Then one of you, whoever noticed the circuit first, says "I care about this too much to do it tired. Eight o'clock." The other says "fine, eight", because you agreed it on a Sunday in the spring and you've both kept enough eight o'clocks by now to know what it means.
The note by the kettle says "dishwasher, and feeling like nobody notices what I do". You go up together, cross. One of you says "we're not finished and that's fine", the other says "I know", and at some point a foot finds a foot, and you both sleep.
At eight, with coffee, one of you says "shall we?" The other reads the note and says "yes, that's it, isn't it, that's what it was." The fourth point arrives. One of you did everything that week and felt invisible, and the other hadn't seen it and says so. The dishwasher gets a new rule neither of you cares about, and it's done by ten past eight, and the children come down.
There was a two in the morning in July, over something real. You called the truce late and kept the eight, and it was the worst morning of the month and the best argument of the year.
This Sunday, with tea, agree with the person you live with that after ten either of you can say "eight o'clock" and both of you will stop.