It doesn't need an answer tonight

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 58 min

It's ten past nine. You're on the sofa with the second half of something on, and the phone on the arm of the chair lights up. A buzz, and the top of a message. It's from Priya, about the slide deck for Thursday. "Quick one, do we have the updated numbers for slide 8 or should I use the old ones?" You look at it for a second and you know you could leave it. Then you pick it up, because you know the answer and it'll take a minute, and you type "Use the new ones, they're in the shared folder, file ending v3". You put the phone down. It's fourteen minutes past nine, the programme has moved on without you, and you're not quite sure what happened in it.

On Sunday afternoon there's another. "No rush, but when you get a sec could you look at the draft?" You open it anyway, because you're holding the phone and the attachment is right there. You send three comments. You've been at work for twenty minutes, and the person who sent it is at a garden centre.

And then there's the one in bed, with the light off and the phone lighting the ceiling.

This is about answering work messages outside working hours, not because the job needs you to, but because a message arrived and answering is what you do with messages. You've probably noticed that they keep arriving at those hours. You may not have connected that with the answering.

The fast reply makes sense from the inside, and I'll be fair to it. But most of what it seems to give you rests on a misreading. The person who sends a non-urgent email in the evening usually expects a slower answer than you assume. The harm from evening email seems to come from feeling you're meant to watch for it, more than from the minutes spent. And every quick reply teaches the sender when to expect you next time, so the expectation you resent is one you've been building. Because you built it, you can take it down, and none of that needs your employer's permission.

None of this means caring less about your job. Doing the work and being available for it are different things, and they're paid differently.

Some cautions. If your job has a genuine on-call duty, a rota or a phone that rings for real emergencies, I'm not telling you to ignore it, and further on there's a way to keep the emergency route open while closing the ordinary one. If your employer punishes you for not replying at night, with warnings, lost shifts or a boss who says so, that isn't a habit and I can't fix it. ACAS gives free advice on unreasonable demands and bullying at work, and its pages on work-related stress name too many or conflicting demands as something an employer is meant to manage. And if the buzz brings dread more than habit, and the dread has been with you most days for weeks, and you're sleeping badly or not at all, the NHS says to see a GP. That's a bigger problem than this one.

If your trouble is thinking about work at home, the meeting replayed on the drive back, that's a related habit. This is about the reply.

Before you go on, keep a list for a week. Every time you answer a work message outside your hours, note the time, who it was from, what it was, and whether it needed an answer before morning. Be honest about that last column.

Nobody was waiting

Priya wasn't waiting. She'd already decided to use the old numbers if she didn't hear back.

You replied anyway, because a reliable person replies quickly. But reliability is doing what you said you'd do, by when you said you'd do it. A colleague who always delivers on Thursday when they said Thursday is reliable. One who answers at ten at night and then misses Thursday isn't. Speed gets mistaken for reliability because speed shows tonight and reliability takes weeks to show.

Laura Giurge and Vanessa Bohns ran eight pre-registered studies with just over four thousand people, all about non-urgent work emails sent outside normal hours. They found what they call the email urgency bias. People receiving such an email assumed the sender wanted a faster reply than the sender, asked separately, actually did. It held for evenings and weekends. It held even for emails plainly marked as not urgent. In one study it was larger outside working hours than within them, which is the wrong way round, since the email that arrives at nine at night is the one least likely to need an answer and the one you most feel you must answer. And it wasn't harmless. Among public sector employees, those who overestimated what was expected of them reported more stress and lower wellbeing.

Now look at your list. If your week was like most people's, the column that says whether it needed an answer before morning is mostly no. The calendar change didn't. The draft didn't. Slide 8 didn't, because Priya had a fallback and said so.

The Sunday "no rush" is the clearest case of all. Someone told you in writing not to hurry, and you hurried. If you'd asked them on Monday whether they wanted comments on Sunday, they'd have said no, and possibly sorry.

Here's a question to ask before the next reply. Would the sender be surprised to hear from you tonight? If they'd be surprised, they weren't waiting.

"But if I don't reply, it looks like I'm not coping." A reply at ten past nine tells Priya one fact, which is that at ten past nine you're reading work messages. That's about your availability. Your ability shows up in the deck on Thursday.

Melissa Mazmanian, Wanda Orlikowski and JoAnne Yates studied professionals who used mobile email and described what they called the autonomy paradox. Each person chose to check and answer everywhere and saw it as freedom. But each person's availability raised what everyone else expected, until the group had a norm of constant connection nobody had voted for and everyone was keeping up. The people who most resented being always reachable were the ones holding the standard in place. In a group like that, a slow reply stands out, and standing out feels like failing. The group's speed is a habit it's teaching itself, and you're one of the teachers.

The manager who sends at ten seems to settle it. Daantje Derks and colleagues followed a hundred employees over four working days and found that using a smartphone for work in the evening went with more interference between work and home, more so where colleagues and supervisors were seen to expect availability. So a manager's habits do shape the norm. But sending isn't expecting. She sends at ten because ten is when she clears her inbox, or the children are finally asleep, or she's on a train. If you asked, she might well say she'd rather you didn't reply, because then she feels she has to answer back and two people are working at ten. Until you've asked, you're guessing, and you're guessing in the direction that costs you most.

I'll concede something on "someone else will answer first". Giurge and Bohns note that workplaces increasingly treat response speed as a sign of hard work. If your manager keeps a mental list of who answered the Sunday email, that has a value where you work, and it would be dishonest to pretend otherwise. But speed is noticed in the moment and forgotten by Wednesday. The person who answered at ten on Sunday got a flicker. The person whose deck was good on Thursday got the project. And the colleague who wins the race has taught the thread they're available at ten, and signed up for the next one. If you're junior, or your next contract depends on being seen, hold all this more lightly. Be reliably quick inside a generous window, say seven till seven, and reliably absent outside it.

Then there's flexibility. You leave at four for the school run, so answering at nine feels like your side of the deal. Who did you make the deal with? Nobody wrote it down. Your manager never said you could leave at four if you answered at nine. You inferred the second half and have been paying a bill nobody sent. And the two halves aren't the same size. Leaving at four is a bounded adjustment. Answering at nine is open-ended availability, and it serves the sender, who gets to ask whatever occurs to them whenever it does.

There's a fairer trade. If you leave at four, work from eight to nine in the evening on purpose, with a start and a finish, and answer Priya then. That's an hour moved. Take flexibility in blocks. Nobody ever offered you an open tap.

Posted at the door

The reply takes two minutes. That part is true. The accounting is wrong.

Liuba Belkin, William Becker and Samantha Conroy surveyed 570 working adults about out-of-hours email. What predicted their exhaustion and their trouble switching off wasn't how long they spent on email after hours. It was whether they felt expected to monitor it. In three further studies, Becker and colleagues found that the expectation of keeping an eye on email in your own time produced anxiety, which went with worse health and more conflict at home. Part of your attention is on the phone all evening, whether or not anything arrives.

So you aren't paying for two minutes. You're paying for three hours of half-watching.

Ruben Cambier and colleagues found something related among 849 Belgian nurses. Those who felt pressure to answer personal messages quickly made more slips at work, but only when the phone was in their pocket. With it put away, the pressure didn't turn into errors. That's the workday, and personal messages, and the leap to your sofa is mine. But a phone that might ask something of you is doing something to you before it asks.

And "quicker to deal with it now" falls apart the moment you look at what happens next. You answer Priya. Priya, also on her sofa, is now in the deck and thinks of the next question, which arrives at twenty-five past nine. By ten you've had four exchanges about something due on Thursday. A reply is an invitation to reply. The question is gone, but the deck is in your head for the rest of the evening, along with the version numbers and a faint sense of whether Priya sounded worried. What you'd have carried by not answering was one unread message. What you carry by answering is the work.

"I'd rather know than wonder." The wonder is real. Martin Pielot and Luz Rello had thirty volunteers switch off all notifications for a day. They felt less distracted and got more done, and some also felt anxious, because they couldn't be as responsive as they believed others expected. But checking only treats the wonder for a while. You check, there's nothing, you're relieved, and twenty minutes later it's back, because the check told you about twenty minutes ago. Each relief is shorter. Nicholas Fitz and colleagues gave 237 people either normal notifications, none, or batches three times a day. The batched group felt more attentive, less stressed and more in control. The group with none at all did less well, with more anxiety. The wonder settles when it knows there's a next time.

Even the nod counts. "Seen, will look tomorrow" says that at ten past nine you read the message, understood it and typed. The content says tomorrow. The timestamp says tonight, and the timestamp is what teaches. You've also opened it, so the deck is in the room, and you've invited "great, thanks, no rush", which is another buzz. A nod is better than a full answer while you're changing. It's a stage on the way.

Now look at it from Priya's side, because that's where the habit lives.

She sent a question at nine, half expecting to use the old numbers. An answer came at fourteen minutes past. She didn't consciously note it, but something in her updated. Next Tuesday, at nine, with a different question, she sends it a little more readily, because last time it worked. The Tuesday after, she sends one she'd otherwise have saved for the morning. She isn't being pushy. You taught her that nine is a time you answer, and she learned it. So has your manager, and the three people on the project, and the client. And so have you, because every reply confirmed that the evening is a time you work, and the wonder grew on that.

A dog learns that the doorbell means someone's coming. Nobody teaches it on purpose. The bell and the arrival just come together often enough.

I should be careful here. No study I've found measures whether replying faster makes other people send more messages out of hours. What's been measured is receivers misjudging what senders expect, and individual availability raising the group's norm. That your reply is what teaches them is my reading of the two together. But if the expectation was taught, it can be untaught. People who send at nine because you answered at nine will, once you start answering at eight in the morning, send at eight in the morning. Nobody needs telling off. They need a few weeks of the new lesson. The quick reply doesn't keep up with an expectation. It's where the expectation comes from.

Then the costs. Larissa Barber and Alecia Santuzzi named workplace telepressure, a preoccupation with messages and an urge to answer fast, and found that people high in it reported more burnout, more sick days, worse sleep and more email answering. Later surveys linked it to worse balance between work and life, much of it through being unable to detach and losing control of free time. The phone lighting the ceiling at eleven is a work event happening in bed. And Marcus Butts, Becker and Wendy Boswell, studying 341 adults over a week, found that out-of-hours messages made people angry when the tone was negative, which you'd expect, and also when they simply took time. A perfectly polite request that needed twenty minutes on Sunday produced anger, and the anger carried through into conflict at home. These are surveys, and people who feel telepressure may differ in ways they can't see. But none found the fast reply doing anyone any good.

The people at home pay as well. In Becker's study of 138 couples, partners of people expected to monitor email reported worse health and lower satisfaction with the relationship. They weren't getting any messages. They were living with someone who was. The conversation pauses for the phone and picks up a beat late. "No rush" turns into twenty minutes of comments while someone waits to go out. A child talking about their day to a parent whose phone just buzzed learns what competes with them.

And the work doesn't gain. A reply at ten past nine is written on a small screen without the file open, so it's short and slightly wrong, and at eight there's a correction. Sandra Ohly and Alessa Latour surveyed 1,714 people and found that evening work on the phone went with a worse mood, especially for those who did it because they felt they had to. When Gloria Mark and colleagues took email away from thirteen office workers for five days, they switched between windows less, stayed on tasks longer and had lower stress on heart-rate monitors. It's a tiny study. But tomorrow's work is being done by someone who never quite stopped.

The sign on the door

A shop has its opening hours on the door. Nobody stands outside at nine at night feeling let down. They read the sign and come back in the morning.

Write down two times. That's your window, the hours in which a message sent to you gets a reply. It's separate from the hours you work, which may be longer or a different shape. It's the same every working day and it has an edge. "Roughly office hours" isn't a window. "Eight to six" is. If you work flexibly the window still stays fixed, because it's a promise to other people. If you've moved an hour to the evening on purpose, that hour can be in it on the days it happens, as long as you say so. Weekends are closed. A message that arrives on Saturday gets answered on Monday morning, and the person who wrote "no rush" gets exactly what they asked for.

The edge has to hold. After it, the buzz gets no reply, no nod and no look until the morning. A window that bends whenever a message looks important is the habit you already have.

Then say it out loud, because a window in your head is only a resolution. The line can be three sentences. "From next week I'll be answering messages between eight and six. Anything that lands outside that, I'll pick up first thing. If something's genuinely urgent, ring me." It states the window, tells the sender their message is safe, and opens what I'll call the other door, the route that stays open for real emergencies.

  • Your manager hears it first, in person or on a call, because it's a conversation. Ask instead of announcing. "I've been answering messages in the evenings and I'd like to stop. Is there anything you actually need from me after six?" Most say no. Some say "only if the sky's falling", which is the other door. A few say yes and mean it, and then at least you know.
  • The three or four people you work with most hear it next.
  • Clients get it in your email signature.
  • Priya gets it lightly, in the next thread. "By the way, I'm keeping evenings clear now, so you'll hear from me in the morning."

You can also teach from the sending side. In Giurge and Bohns' last study, adding "This is not an urgent matter so you can get to it whenever you can" to a non-urgent email shrank the receiver's overestimate. Put something like it on your own emails.

Now the phone, which is where the decision gets tested at ten past nine. The idea is that the buzz never reaches you outside the window, so you're spared hearing it and having to resist it. Your phone almost certainly has a setting that silences notifications on a schedule and lets chosen people through. Set the schedule to the window's edges and put the work apps in the silenced group. It takes about ten minutes.

Make the other door a phone call, which is harder to send idly and easier to notice. Tell your manager and the two or three people who might really need you that a call will ring through after six. If it rings at nine, it's an emergency and you'll deal with it. If it never rings, you've learned how many emergencies there were. Without that door, you're relying on nothing going wrong. With it, you're relying on people to ring when something does.

If you'd rather look once than never, put one look at the end of the window, at six, deal with what's urgent, and let the schedule take over. A look you chose, at a fixed time, is one you can stop.

And move where the phone sleeps. Off the bedside table, into the kitchen. If it's your alarm, buy an alarm. Of everything here, this is the change people resist most.

The rule fits in one line. I answer work messages inside the window, I've said what the window is, and the phone can't ask me anything outside it.

Then make a few plans in the form "when this happens, I'll do that". Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran pooled 94 studies of plans like these and found people who make them are considerably more likely to follow through than people who just intend to, because the plan names the moment.

  • When it's six and I'm about to stop, I look at the inbox once, deal with what's urgent, and let the schedule start.
  • When I catch myself wondering what's in there, I say "it's in the kitchen, and the other door's open" and go back to what I was doing.
  • When a message reaches me anyway, I don't reply and I don't nod. I answer it at the morning edge.

The first evening the wonder will be loud. The phone is in the kitchen, you know there's something in it, and part of you is in the kitchen too. That doesn't mean the window's wrong. It's new. By the fourth or fifth evening it's quieter, because you've had four mornings of finding that nothing in there needed you last night.

Somewhere in the first fortnight there'll be a small consequence. Someone had to wait, or someone used the old numbers. Look at its size, because that's what you were spending every evening to avoid. And somewhere else in the fortnight the other door won't ring. It won't ring all fortnight. By the second week Priya sends her question at half past eight in the morning. The thread that had four exchanges at night has one with the file open.

Pielot and Rello went back to their volunteers two years later. About half of those who'd meant to change how they handled notifications were still doing it. That's a good rate, and it's also a warning that the other half drifted.

Eleven o'clock again

The ordinary rule needs a gate in some jobs, and a different approach in others.

  • If your boss sends at ten and writes "no need to reply", believe her. If she does expect a reply and says so, ask what specifically she needs after six, because it usually comes down to one kind of thing, and that becomes the other door. If it really is everything, enforced with consequences, that's an on-call duty that isn't paid as one, and ACAS can tell you what's reasonable.
  • If you're the one sending at ten, you're teaching faster than anyone, because what supervisors seem to expect is what turned evening phone use into interference in Derks' study. Write at ten if that's when you write, and schedule it to send at eight in the morning. Say the window out loud for your team, because they're less able to say it to you.
  • If you're on a rota, the rota is the other door. The usual problem is that the on-call channel and the ordinary inbox are the same thing, so keep them apart. Off the rota means off the ordinary channel too.
  • If half your team is eight hours behind, move the window, don't stretch it. A fixed hour at nine in the evening on the days they need it is a window. "Whenever they're awake" isn't.
  • If you're a freelancer, the line is your terms of business. A client who insists on evening replies is telling you what the job costs, and you can price it or decline it.
  • If your best ideas come at eleven, write them at eleven. Save them as a draft or schedule them for the morning.
  • The family chat works the same way. Say so once, lightly, and answer in the morning. Families adjust faster than offices.

It'll happen. A hard Thursday, a message that looked bigger than it was, and you answered it at eleven in bed, on the phone you brought up "just for the alarm".

One reply isn't the habit back. Phillippa Lally and colleagues found that people building a daily habit could miss a day without much effect, and I'd treat a missed evening the same way. The people you work with have had weeks of the new lesson and won't unlearn it from one message. So don't decide that the window doesn't suit someone like you. Ask which belief did it. "It's only two minutes." "They're waiting." The wonder, with the phone upstairs. Usually the answer is the phone. If it had been in the kitchen, you wouldn't have seen the message.

If the sender writes back at seven the next morning, answer at the morning edge like any other day. If they write back at eleven the next night, they're testing whether the rule held. You pass by not answering. Don't keep a tally of good and bad evenings either. People notice the pattern, and the pattern is what you do most nights.

If the eleven o'clock reply happened because the work really is too much and it isn't going away, the window won't cure that. That's about your hours and what's being demanded of you, and ACAS can help there.

It's ten past nine on a Tuesday, three months on. You're on the sofa with the second half of something. The phone is in the kitchen on a schedule that started at six, and you don't know whether anything's in it, and you notice that you don't know, and then the programme takes you back.

At half past eight the next morning, Priya's question about slide 8 is there, sent at twenty past eight. You answer it with the folder open, in one message, and that's the thread. Your manager's email from ten last night says "no need to reply", and you read it at your desk with a coffee, which is how it was meant to be read. The other door hasn't rung once. The deck goes out on Thursday.

If you've done nothing yet, do one thing tonight. Put the phone in the kitchen at six and leave it there. Tomorrow morning, look at what came in and ask which of it needed you last night.