Nothing gets solved at three in the morning

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 58 min

It's seven minutes past three on a Wednesday morning. You know this because you looked at the clock.

You woke for no clear reason, and for a moment your mind was blank and comfortable. Then, as if someone had been waiting for you to surface, the first item arrived. The roofer's quote is four thousand eight hundred pounds and you've got about half of that. You start doing sums. If you cancelled the holiday you'd save twelve hundred, and if you sold the car you might save more, but then how would you get your mother to her appointments? Her hip operation is in three weeks and you haven't sorted out who's staying with her the first few nights. Your sister won't offer. She never does. Then the email to your manager with the missing attachment, and your son saying lightly that nobody picked him for the team at break.

By half past four you've decided several things. The car has to go. Your mother will have to move in. Your job isn't safe, and you're failing as a parent. You drop off a little before six, and the alarm goes at ten to seven.

At twenty to eight you sit at the kitchen table with a cup of tea and a piece of paper, and it takes about twenty minutes. The roofer can be asked about paying in two stages, and if he won't, the leak is slow and can wait until spring. You'll ring your sister tonight and ask her straight out to do the first two nights. You send the attachment with a one-line apology, and at nine your manager replies "Thanks!" and nothing else. You'll ask your son about break time on the walk to school.

Same problems, same facts. At half past four they added up to rearranging your whole life. At the kitchen table they were four errands.

I'll call the session that follows a waking the night shift. It starts by itself, moves from a roof to your whole competence as an adult without finishing anything, and produces verdicts and no actions.

My argument is that the night shift makes sense from the inside, and that three in the morning is still the worst hour of the twenty-four for this kind of work. The way out is to give your problems ten minutes in the evening and your best hour in the day, and to learn a short routine for the night that doesn't involve solving anything. It isn't a treatment for insomnia, though some of it overlaps with what sleep clinics teach.

Four cautions, and please don't skip them.

  • If you've had trouble sleeping for months, or it's making it hard to cope during the day, the NHS advice is to see a GP. There's an effective treatment, described near the end.
  • Some night waking has a physical cause. If anyone has noticed your breathing stopping and starting while you sleep, or you gasp or choke in your sleep and you're always very tired by day, the NHS says to see a GP, because those are the main symptoms of sleep apnoea. Pain, night sweats, a bladder that wakes you several times and some medicines can break sleep too. Don't stop or change a prescribed medicine without talking to whoever prescribed it.
  • The NHS lists waking very early and being unable to get back to sleep among the symptoms of depression. If that's your pattern and your mood has been low for weeks, please see a GP.
  • If the thoughts that come in the night include thoughts of ending your life, get help straight away. In England that means NHS 111, or 999 if you're in immediate danger, and you don't need to wait for the morning.

One small exercise. Next time it happens, write down in the morning the verdicts you reached in the night. At midday, mark each as still true, partly true or not true. A week of that will tell you more than I can.

The worst hour for the job

None of this makes you a worrier. The night shift pulls at anybody, for good reasons.

  • The problems are real. The roof does leak, so telling yourself not to be silly doesn't help.
  • It's the first quiet you've had all day. Nobody wants anything from you at three.
  • It feels responsible. Lying in the dark refusing to think about a problem seems like negligence, and the people who do the night shift are very often the ones holding things together by day.
  • It feels like a good use of dead time.
  • It makes a promise, that if you can just get this one thing straight, your mind will let you sleep.

Allison Harvey, a psychologist who studies sleep, has argued that one thing keeping night worry going is the belief that worrying in bed is useful. Her account is a theory about insomnia, but it carries over.

Start with the waking itself, because many people add alarm before the thinking even begins. "Oh no, not again. Why can't I sleep like a normal person?" That thought alone can start the shift.

Waking in the night is normal. Sleep moves through lighter and deeper stages in cycles, with brief surfacings between them, and wakings become more frequent and noticeable as people get older. In the early 1990s the sleep researcher Thomas Wehr had healthy volunteers spend fourteen hours of every twenty-four in darkness, roughly a winter night without artificial light. Their sleep spread out and usually divided into two blocks with one to three hours awake in between. The historian Roger Ekirch later argued, from diaries and court records, that people in pre-industrial Britain spoke of a "first sleep" and a "second sleep" and thought nothing of waking between them. Niall Boyce has disputed how general that was, and Ekirch stands by his case. Either way, a waking in the night is a poor sign that something has gone wrong with you.

Between surfacing and the first problem there's a gap of a few seconds. If you fill it with alarm, you've supplied the jolt the shift needs. If you fill it with "I'm awake, that happens", the door to sleep is still open. And lying still in the dark with a quiet mind is rest of a kind. Lying still while doing your household accounts is work.

Now the thinking. A silent house seems a good place for it. The trouble is what you're thinking with.

Mood runs on a daily rhythm, much as body temperature does. Diane Boivin and colleagues had 24 healthy young volunteers live for weeks on artificial days of twenty-eight or thirty hours, which pulled their sleep out of step with their body clocks and let the researchers separate tiredness from what time the body thought it was. Mood varied significantly with the body clock, even in people equally rested.

Andrew Tubbs and colleagues pulled the later research together in a 2022 review called "The Mind After Midnight". They report that positive mood peaks during the day and hits its lowest point between about one and four in the morning, while negative mood holds steady and then rises sharply in that same trough. They gather evidence that the brain's planning and judging functions, the ones that weigh risks and keep things in proportion, are impaired during wakefulness in the biological night, while the threat-detecting systems are more active. They suggest the combination pushes a person towards the negative, giving it too much weight, and ruminating. The authors present this as a hypothesis that needs direct testing, though its separate strands are well supported.

So look at what the night shift does. It takes your hardest problems to the one period of the day when you feel worst, your sense of threat is loudest, and the part of you that says "hang on, it isn't that bad" is least available. Then it tries to reach conclusions.

"But it really is that bad," says a voice at a quarter to four. "I'm seeing clearly for once."

A mood doesn't present itself as a mood. When your outlook darkens, you experience the world as having got worse. The bill looks bigger and your sister looks more selfish, and a low mood is very good at finding evidence. At half past four you could list ten reasons your job is at risk, and the reasons it isn't don't come to mind. By day you see your problems along with your resources, the people who'd help and the things you've got through before. At night you see the problems and lose sight of the resources. The feeling of honesty is part of the effect.

Look at the verdicts by noon. The car was never part of the problem. Your mother needs someone for a few nights, which is a different thing from moving in. Nothing new is known about your job except a cheerful "Thanks!". One remark from a nine-year-old is worth a conversation, and that's all. Night verdicts are bigger, more general and more final than the facts allow. Be wary of the ones about people. By day you'd remember that your sister drove two hundred miles when your father was ill.

So take a flat rule, and don't argue it out each night. Verdicts reached between midnight and breakfast don't count. They might occasionally be right, and you'll find out in the morning. Until then they have the status of something said with a fever. If the night throws up something true you'd been avoiding, it will still be true at eight, when you can act on it.

Two hours, no output

Test the night shift the way you'd test any work, by what it produced.

Solving a practical problem means getting the facts, working out the options, choosing one and acting. At three in the morning the roofer is asleep and the bank statement is downstairs, so you work from memory and pessimistic guesses. Your options are what a tired, low mind can come up with lying down, which is selling the car. The obvious one, asking the roofer, never occurred to you. Ordinary ideas like that come from a mind in ordinary working order. And acting is impossible. So the shift can't get past the first stage, and it goes round. "But what if he won't take instalments?" leads nowhere except back to the top, and every circuit feels like progress because you're thinking hard.

Nothing is written down, so by morning you remember the mood and hardly any of the content.

The night session lasted nearly three hours and produced four verdicts, all wrong. The kitchen table took twenty minutes and produced four actions, all done that day. You weren't cleverer at the table. You had a pen, a phone and daylight, and the rest of the world was awake.

Some people do get good ideas in the night. Those arrive unbidden, from a loose, wandering mind, and one line on a pad will hold them.

Then there's the promise, that once you've worked it out you'll sleep. It fails twice. There's always another item, because anyone with a job, a family and a house has an endless supply, and settling the roof only moves you on to your mother's hip. And thinking hard is exactly what keeps a person awake. Harvey's model describes the loop. Worried thinking in bed raises your heartbeat and tenses your shoulders, that state makes you watchful for threats, including the threat of not sleeping, and that feeds more worried thinking. You're trying to get to sleep by doing the thing most likely to stop you. At night you can think about a problem but you can't deal with it, so the relief never comes.

So you try to stop thinking. "Stop it. Don't think about the roof. Go to sleep."

The roof is back within seconds. Pushing a thought away tends to keep it close, since part of you has to keep checking for it, though research has found that effect smaller than first reported. Allison Harvey and Suzanna Payne gave 41 people with insomnia different instructions for a night. Those told to occupy themselves with a specific, engaging piece of imagery, chosen and worked out in advance, fell asleep faster than those given no instruction, and their thoughts in bed were less frequent and less distressing. It's one small study of one night. It points somewhere usable, though. You can't empty your mind by ordering it to be empty, but you can give it something absorbing to do.

And sleep isn't something you can do. Colin Espie and colleagues argue that normal sleep is largely automatic, so it's easily disrupted by attention and effort. It's like a name on the tip of your tongue, which arrives once you stop straining. The NHS advice is the same in plainer words. If you're lying awake, try not to force it.

Then there's the clock. It tells you it's seven minutes past three, a fact you can do nothing with, and starts the arithmetic. "If I get to sleep in the next quarter of an hour I'll have three and a half hours. I've got the budget meeting at ten." Twenty minutes later you check again. Each look delivers fresh bad news and adds a new problem, not sleeping, that gets worse every time. Its verdict, that tomorrow is ruined, is as unreliable as the rest. The NHS recommends keeping clocks out of view.

Turn the clock to the wall. If it's your alarm, it'll still go off. If you wake and it's dark, the time is night.

The phone is worse. It's a clock, so it starts the arithmetic, and its light tells your body it's day. It's also a door to every problem you have. People pick it up "just to check the time" and forty minutes later they're reading about interest rates. Charge it out of reach, preferably outside the bedroom, and buy a basic alarm clock. If you need to be reachable at night, leave it across the room with the ringer up.

Add up what the shift costs. A ten-minute waking becomes two hours. The next day you're flatter and more anxious, which is what Cara Palmer and colleagues found reliably across 154 experiments on sleep loss and emotion, so your problems now face a less capable you. Now and then a night verdict gets acted on, as a resignation email at five. Your bed comes to mean wrestling, which is why some people doze on the sofa at nine and then lie wide awake the moment they get into bed. And several nights a week you're shown the worst version of your life at the hour your judgment is weakest, and some of it sticks.

In return you get a feeling of responsibility, which lasts exactly as long as the shift.

The handover

The problems are real. I'm not going to tell you to think of a beach.

Look at an ordinary day from your mind's point of view. The morning rush, then work, then cooking and children and clearing, then a screen, then bed. At no point did you sit for ten minutes and ask what's outstanding and what you're going to do about it. The roof and your mother and your son were waiting all day for a turn. At three in the morning nothing else is competing, so they get one. Seen that way, the night shift is a necessary job, the review of open problems, being done at the only time you've left free for it.

Colleen Carney and William Waters tested this with 33 students who reported insomnia. For five nights, in the early evening, one group wrote down the problems likely to bother them that night along with a possible next step for each. The other group wrote down their worries and filled in questionnaires about them. The next-step group reported less mental arousal in bed than the comparison group, and less than they'd had before. It was small and short. Still, both groups had listed their worries, and only the group that added a next step had quieter nights.

Michael Scullin and colleagues had 57 healthy young adults write for five minutes before lights out. Those who wrote a to-do list fell asleep significantly faster than those who wrote about things already done. That was one night, at bedtime and not at three, so I wouldn't rest much on it. Separate research on unfinished goals found that a specific plan quiets the intrusions even before the goal is met. And the NHS suggests that if you often worry in bed, you write a list of what you need to do the next day before you go to sleep.

Your mind raises problems at night because it has no assurance they'll be dealt with otherwise. So give it one, every evening.

Here's how. I call it the handover, because it's what a shift worker does before going home.

Do it in the early evening, an hour or two before bed, at the same time each day and attached to something that already happens, like clearing the table. Sit at a table with a pen and a notebook, outside the bedroom. Use paper, because the phone has everything else on it.

Draw a line down the middle of the page. On the left, one line for each thing on your mind, anything unresolved, nagging or likely to turn up at three. Be specific. "Money" isn't an item. "Roofer's quote, four thousand eight hundred" is. On the right, against each, write the next physical action and when you'll take it. Leave solutions out of it. "Ring roofer Thursday lunch, ask about staged payment." "Ask Jo tonight about the first two nights with Mum."

If you're waiting on something, write what and when. "Restructure. Nothing to do until the 14th." That's a decision too. Others have no step at all, like "what if the economy gets worse" or "am I a good enough parent". Write "no step" against them. It does some good to see in daylight that a thing taking up forty minutes a night has nothing on the right-hand side.

On an ordinary evening the left might read roof quote, Mum's first nights home, attachment to manager, Sam and break time, restructure, MOT. The right reads ring roofer Thursday lunch, ask Jo tonight, sent and done, ask Sam on the walk, nothing until the 14th, book online Saturday. Six lines, three of them finished within a day.

Then close the book and say, if it helps, "That's handed over."

If something needs real thought, a job decision or a tangled money question, the next step is an appointment with yourself at your best time of day. "Saturday, 10 a.m., kitchen table, one hour, mortgage options." That's the quiet the night seemed to offer, at an hour when your judgment works. If the handover regularly takes much longer than ten minutes, you've started solving. Stop, and give that item its own session. If you miss an evening, do it the next day.

Last, put a small pad and a pencil on the bedside table.

Seven minutes past three again

You'll still wake. Here's what to do.

  • Don't look at the clock. It's facing the wall, and your phone is in another room.
  • When the first problem arrives, name it. "That's the three o'clock mind." It will insist that tonight is different. It always does.
  • Answer it once, truthfully. "It's on the list. I'm ringing the roofer on Thursday." Don't defend the plan, because defending it is the first stage of a shift. If the thought returns, give it the same sentence.
  • If something new comes up, write one line on the pad without turning on the main light. "MOT." That removes the mind's best argument for keeping you awake, which is that you'll forget it. One line, no notes.
  • Give your mind somewhere to go. Choose it in daylight, something absorbing, pleasant and unconnected to your life. A house you knew as a child, walked room by room. A favourite walk, stile by stile. A garden you'll never plant. Detail matters more than subject. When you drift back to the roof, return to the hallway without fuss. Drifting is often how sleep arrives.
  • Let your body rest. Let your shoulders and jaw go slack, breathe a little slower, and stop trying to sleep. You're resting, which is true and worth having.
  • If it isn't working and you're getting frustrated, get up. The NHS says that if you're still awake after around twenty minutes, sit somewhere comfortable, do something relaxing, and go back to bed when you feel sleepy. Keep the light low. Read a few pages of something dull, and leave the phone, the post and the notebook alone. If you're unsteady on your feet at night, use a light you can reach from bed and take your time, because not falling matters more than any of this.

People resist getting up most, and I think it does the most. It breaks the link between bed and wrestling, and the shift finds it hard to carry on in a chair with a book about canals.

If you share a bed, explain this in daylight, and don't talk problems over together at three. In the morning, deal with whatever's on the pad, or put it in that evening's handover. The pad works only if your mind learns that what goes on it gets done.

Judge a night by whether a shift happened. Forty minutes awake, resting in a childhood kitchen, is a success.

So here's the decision. I don't work on problems between bedtime and breakfast. They get ten minutes in the evening and my best hour in the day. Anything concluded in the night gets a second look after breakfast before it counts, and nothing gets acted on before then, so no emails, no messages and no decisions.

Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran pooled 94 tests of "when this, then that" plans and found they made people a good deal more likely to follow through. When a problem arrives in the night, I'll say "three o'clock mind, it's on the list" and go to the house. When I catch myself doing sleep sums, I'll say "it's night" and go to the house. When I'm lying there getting frustrated, I'll get up and read until I'm sleepy.

The handover tends to help within the first week. The night routine is slower, and for a fortnight you'll often be ten minutes into a shift before you notice. I can't promise you'll sleep through. You may wake at night for the rest of your life, as people always have. What can change is what follows.

Some nights need more than this. If a baby, a sick child or an on-call job wakes you, you can't avoid that. Deal with the baby, then use the routine when you're back in bed. If you work nights, the same rules apply to whatever hours you sleep, and be wary of big decisions in the last hours of a shift. In the first weeks after a bereavement, a break-up or a diagnosis, I wouldn't ask anyone to label thoughts and visit a childhood house. Keep to the gentler parts. No clock, no verdicts before breakfast, get up if bed is unbearable, and tell your GP if the broken nights go on for many weeks.

If the same stepless worry fills your nights and the handover doesn't touch it, it may be anxiety running by day too, and that responds to treatment. In England you can refer yourself to NHS talking therapies without seeing a GP first. If you've had trouble sleeping for months, or it's making your days hard to cope with, see a GP. The treatment with the best evidence is cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia. James Trauer and colleagues pooled 20 trials with 1,162 people, who afterwards fell asleep about 19 minutes faster and spent about 26 minutes less awake in the night, and the gains seemed to last. It includes a structured programme for your hours in bed, which works best with guidance. The NHS says it may be offered face to face or online, and that sleeping pills are now rarely prescribed for insomnia, and then only briefly.

Snoring with pauses in breathing, gasping or choking, and heavy daytime tiredness need a GP, as do night sweats, which the NHS lists among the symptoms of the menopause and perimenopause, and pain or a bladder that wakes you. A drink helps you drop off and tends to wake you later. Irshaad Ebrahim and colleagues found alcohol deepened the first half of the night and disrupted the second. The NHS suggests no alcohol, tea or coffee for at least six hours before bed.

The hours after midnight are when mood is lowest and self-control weakest, so thoughts of being a burden or of ending things can be at their most persuasive then. Treat them as the verdict most worth distrusting. Get up, turn on a light, and contact someone. NHS 111 answers at any hour, or 999 if you're in immediate danger. You don't need to be sure it's serious. Tell your GP in the daytime too.

There'll be a bad week, with a deadline or a family worry, when you skip the handover and find yourself doing sums at four. It doesn't undo anything. Do the handover tomorrow evening and turn the clock back to the wall.

Some months on, you wake in the dark, with no idea of the time. The boiler arrives, and a new one would cost thousands. "Three o'clock mind. It's on the list. The engineer's coming on Tuesday." Last night at ten past seven you wrote "Boiler noise" on the left and "Engineer Tues 9 to 1, wait for his verdict" on the right. Your mind asks what happens if he says it's finished. You give the same answer.

Your niece's birthday surfaces. You write "Ellie card" on the pad, eyes half shut, and put the pencil down.

Then you go to your grandmother's house, in through the back door as you always did. The mat, the row of wellingtons, the oilcloth on the kitchen table, the tin with a coach and horses on the lid. You've got as far as the dresser drawers when you notice you've drifted back to the boiler, so you return to the drawers. In the second one there were always rubber bands and a ball of string.

You don't remember the hall.

Tonight, do the first handover. Ten minutes at a table, a line down the middle of the page. Then turn the clock to the wall and put a pad and a pencil by the bed.