The 20-minute version
It's ten past five on a Tuesday. You lean back from the screen and take stock.
The report for Thursday is open at the third paragraph of the second section, which is where it was at twenty to ten this morning. You've been back to it four times. Each time you reread the last paragraph to find your place, changed a word or two, began a sentence, and then something arrived. In drafts there's an email to a supplier that you stopped to look up a figure and never went back to. The month's reconciliation is done down to row forty of ninety. The expenses form has one of its three sections filled in. On the monitor there's a sticky note in your own writing that says "Ring Dave back??", and you can't remember what Dave wanted.
You haven't stopped all day. You ate at the desk, answered every message within minutes, joined two calls and helped a colleague with a formula. Anyone watching would have seen eight hours of hard work. You can't name one thing that's finished, and the laptop is coming home with you.
Saturday has its own version. You started hanging the washing, broke off to answer the school about the trip, got the drill out for the shelf, then made lunch because everyone was hungry. At four o'clock there's a basket of damp clothes, a shelf leaning against the wall with two holes drilled, and an unsent reply on your phone.
That's the habit. Six things in progress, nothing finished, and a tiredness the day's output can't explain.
It makes sense from the inside, and that's where I'll start. Then I'll argue that you were never doing several things at once. You were switching, each switch costs more than it seems, and the feeling of a busy day is a poor guide to what got done. The method is simple. You pick one thing, work on it to a stopping point you've named in advance, and leave yourself a note before you touch anything else.
Nothing here says you should ignore your colleagues or turn off the radio while you cook.
Two cautions. Some people find it unusually hard to stay with one task for reasons that aren't habit. The NHS describes ADHD in adults as a condition where the brain works differently, with signs that include being easily distracted, finding it hard to organise your time and finding it hard to finish tasks, and it says the symptoms usually start before the age of twelve. If that sounds like your whole life and not only your recent working habits, and it's affecting your work or relationships, the NHS advice is to see a GP. What follows may still help, but it's no substitute for an assessment.
And if your workload is truly more than one person can do, no method will fix that. This can help you work better within your hours. It shouldn't be used to squeeze more out of someone who's already overloaded, by you or by your employer.
Try one thing before reading on. Tomorrow, keep a sheet of paper beside you and make a mark every time you move from one task to another. At the end of the day, count the marks. Then write down what you finished, meaning sent or filed or handed over, as opposed to worked on. If the list is long and the count is low, you may not need any of this. If the count is over forty and the list is short, read on.
The thread you were holding
The juggling has good reasons behind it.
Work arrives through several channels at once, and nobody sends you the day in a tidy queue. A colleague who replies in two minutes is thought helpful, and a report written well doesn't get noticed in the same way. Some tasks have natural waits, and it's sensible to pick something up in the gap so long as you come back. And two hours on a reconciliation is dull, so a message arrives as a small relief.
Some doubling-up costs nothing. When one of two activities needs no attention, like the washing machine running while you cook, or music while you paint a wall, there's little or no cost, and none of this is aimed at it.
So the habit is trying to keep you up with everything, make you look reliable, and give you a break from the hard task. All reasonable. It just does them badly.
Try writing the next sentence of the report and the next sentence of the supplier email at the same moment. You can't. You'll do one, then the other. For tasks that need your attention, what feels like doing two things at once is rapid alternation, and the only real questions are how often you change and what each change costs.
Psychologists call this task switching. In the experiments people move between very simple tasks, such as odd or even for a number and vowel or consonant for a letter, and they're reliably slower and usually less accurate just after a switch. Rubinstein, Meyer and Evans found that the cost grew as the rules of the tasks got more complex. A switch means loading the rules of the new task and dropping the old ones.
Their tasks took a second or two. The rules for your report include its argument so far, who it's for, the point you were building towards and the three figures you had in mind. Loading that takes minutes. It's the rereading you did four times today.
Driving shows how little attention can be shared. David Strayer and colleagues put people in a driving simulator, some of them on the phone. The phone users braked more slowly and had more collisions, hands-free or not. In the UK hands-free use is legal. In the simulator it was no safer.
A glance still seems harmless. The damage comes when you turn back.
Erik Altmann, Gregory Trafton and David Hambrick gave people a task with several steps that had to be done in order, and interrupted them now and then, very briefly. Interruptions averaging under three seconds doubled the rate at which people lost their place and did the wrong step next. About four and a half seconds tripled it. Their other errors didn't increase. The interruptions had knocked out the one thing the task depended on, which was knowing where you were.
A report depends on the same thing. At any moment you're holding a thread, what you've just said and what comes next and where the paragraph is heading, and none of it is on the screen. It took you several minutes to build. Three seconds on a message about parking permits will drop it, and when you look back the words are there and the thread has gone, so you reread from the top of the section. That's the restart. On complex work I'd guess it runs to several minutes, though you can time your own.
Two more costs ride along. Sophie Leroy, who studies organisations, named one attention residue, meaning that part of your attention stays behind with the task you left, as her finding is generally described. The other is the detour. Gloria Mark and her colleagues shadowed office workers and found that interrupted work usually did get picked up again the same day, but with more than two other activities in between on average. You look away for one thing and come back after three.
Perhaps you're the exception. You've been told in appraisals that you keep plates spinning.
David Sanbonmatsu, David Strayer and colleagues at the University of Utah measured the same people three ways. How much they multitasked, how good they thought they were at it, and how good they actually were on a demanding test. The heaviest multitaskers tended to be the worst at it, and most people rated themselves well above their real ability. Heavy multitasking also went with impulsiveness and a weaker ability to block out distractions, which led the authors to suggest that many people juggle because they find it hard to stay on one thing.
I think the self-assessment goes wrong because the costs are hidden from the person paying them. The restart doesn't feel like a cost. It feels like writing the report. What you do feel is the juggling, which is lively and feels competent.
A few people really are exceptions. When Jason Watson and Strayer tested two hundred drivers on a hard memory task, five showed no decline. That's odds of forty to one against, and the people surest they're exceptions are, if anything, less likely to be.
Which brings us back to ten past five. You were tired, and tiredness usually means work was done. Gloria Mark, Daniela Gudith and Ulrich Klocke had people do an office task with and without interruptions. The interrupted ones finished faster, with no loss of quality, because they sped up to compensate, and they reported more stress, frustration, time pressure and effort. Your tiredness is real, and a good part of it came from the switching.
Zheng Wang and John Tchernev followed students who multitasked to get more done. It didn't get more done, but it left them feeling good, which the researchers suggest is why the habit lasts. Sixty small replies a day each pay a little. The report pays nothing until it's finished, and on a juggled day it never is.
So keep a better record than the feeling. At the end of each day, write down what you finished. "Worked on the report" doesn't count. "Sent section two to Priya for comment" does.
The last fifty messages
Open your inbox and look at the last fifty messages you received. For each one, ask what would have happened if you'd replied ninety minutes later than you did.
For most of them, nothing.
The sender fired it off and moved on. A handful were urgent, and you could usually tell which. For most office work the belief that you must answer straight away is stronger than the facts, and some of it you built yourself. Reply in two minutes for long enough and people learn to expect it, and then their expectation seems to justify the habit that trained it. A few weeks of different behaviour retrains it.
Kostadin Kushlev and Elizabeth Dunn asked 124 adults to spend one week checking email only three times a day and another week checking as often as they liked. In the limited week they reported less daily stress. You'd think the unchecked inbox would be the stressful part. In this study the constant checking was.
If your manager really does expect instant replies, a silent rebellion won't help. Have the conversation. "I'm trying to protect a couple of hours each morning for the report. If something's urgent, ring me." Most managers, asked directly, would rather have the report on time.
Some of the switching is engineered. A preview slides into the corner of the screen with the first eight words of a message, and three seconds is enough to lose the thread. You didn't decide to read it. Your eyes went to the movement, which is what eyes do. The defaults were set to get messages seen quickly, with no thought for Thursday's deadline.
Defaults take minutes to change and then keep working by themselves. Turn off the email preview, the sound and the unread count. Set chat to do-not-disturb during a stretch, letting particular people through so the urgent route stays open. On your phone, turn off everything except calls and perhaps family.
Don't go all the way to nothing, though. Nicholas Fitz and colleagues had 237 people receive their phone notifications as usual, in three batches a day, or not at all. The batched group did best on the researchers' wellbeing measures. The group with none felt more anxious about missing things, which is how people end up checking by hand.
And even with every setting changed, you'd still switch, because plenty of switches start with your own thought. The tools got the habit going. It runs without them now.
Meetings are where people juggle most confidently. Camera off, clearing email while someone presents. You can't follow a spoken argument and compose a sentence at the same moment, so the meeting becomes a murmur until your own name brings you to the surface. Faria Sana, Tina Weston and Nicholas Cepeda found that students who did unrelated laptop tasks during a lecture scored lower on a test about it afterwards, and so did students who could merely see their screens. If you can clear your inbox through an hour's meeting and miss nothing that matters, you weren't needed there, so ask for the notes next time. If you are needed, close the laptop. And on a phone call, the person at the other end can hear the typing in your slightly late "mm".
Now the switches that are entirely yours.
You're on the hard paragraph. The staffing figures are in front of you and you don't know what you think about them. The sentence won't come. There's a small strain behind your eyes, and under it a quieter doubt about whether you can do this at all. Then you remember the expenses form. It's a real task and it's overdue, and opening it would count as work. So you open it. The strain stops at once, and you feel busy and a little virtuous, and the report sits where it was until after lunch.
That's the pattern of any habit that ends a bad feeling quickly, and it grows stronger the same way. For a day or two, add a note to your tally sheet about what was happening in the minute before each switch. My own observation, which isn't a study, is that a large share turn out to be yours, clustered at moments like that one.
The stuck point is where the work is. The easy paragraphs would have written themselves. The hard one is hard because it's where you decide what you think, and that decision is what the reader needs from you. It's also where the thread is most tangled, so leaving then buys the most expensive restart, and you come back cold and likely to leave again.
A walk to the kettle after forty minutes of going in circles can loosen a problem, because you do nothing much and come straight back. Escaping into another task after ninety seconds, for an hour, is a different thing.
So when you feel the pull, stay five more minutes. Write a bad version of the sentence. Or write "what I'm trying to say here is" and finish it. Most stuck points give way within five minutes of staying, and the pull to leave is strongest just before they do.
Boredom drives the rest. Tam and Inzlicht ran seven studies in which people could switch freely between videos, and switching to escape boredom made them more bored and less attentive. A video isn't a spreadsheet, but their explanation carries. Absorption takes time to build, and each switch resets it. If you always leave during a task's dull first ten minutes, you never get past them.
Variety between stretches is fine. Hopping every few minutes is what builds the pile. And some tasks are dull all the way through. An expenses form done in one sitting is twenty dull minutes. Spread across six visits, you start it six times and it's on your mind all day.
A line before you leave
Suppose you have three tasks, each needing two hours, and six hours to do them in.
Do them in order and they're finished at hours two, four and six. Rotate them half an hour at a time and they're finished at five, five and a half and six. Same total, but two of the three arrived hours later. And that assumes switching is free. Add a dozen restarts and the rotation no longer fits in six hours. If the day ends at hour five, the person working in order has two finished tasks and one untouched. The person rotating has three unfinished.
Most tasks pay out only at the end. Half a report can't be read, and a shelf with two holes drilled holds no books.
Open tasks also take up room in your head. E. J. Masicampo and Roy Baumeister gave people a goal, left it unfinished, and set them something unrelated to do. The unfinished goal kept intruding, with stray thoughts while they read and worse results on a word puzzle. That's why "Ring Dave back??" floats up while you're writing about budgets. The same studies found the way out. When people made a specific plan for the unfinished goal, saying when and how they'd do it, the intrusions stopped, as though the goal were done. The mind seems to need to know that an open item is taken care of, and a concrete plan is enough.
And the head holds very little. Nelson Cowan reviewed the evidence and argued that, with simple items in the laboratory, people can keep about three to five things actively in mind. A juggled morning asks you to hold seven, none of them simple, so some get dropped and rebuilt, sometimes wrong. Paper doesn't forget and doesn't interrupt. In my observation the people who stay calm under heavy workloads don't have bigger memories. They write everything down and stop thinking about it.
So here's the method. Start each morning before the inbox.
- Write the pile down. Every open task, including the half-written email and "Ring Dave back". It usually comes to between eight and twenty items.
- Ask two questions of each one. What happens if this isn't done today, and who's waiting for it? Most items get "nothing much" and "nobody yet". Two or three have real answers.
- Pick by consequence. A colleague's third reminder is loud and Thursday's report is silent until Thursday. Choose the one where not doing it costs most, which is usually the one that needs sustained thought.
- Give it your first ninety minutes, before you open the inbox. If the inbox gets them, the report gets the leftovers in fragments.
- Keep no more than three things open. A fourth waits until one is finished or deliberately dropped.
- Put the two-minute jobs, Dave probably among them, into one half-hour stretch of their own.
- Cross off what's never going to happen, on purpose, and tell whoever needs telling. A dropped task is finished.
- Write the one thing on paper in front of you. "Report, section two, to the end of the costs paragraph." It sounds childish. When you look up twenty minutes later and wonder what you were doing, the paper tells you.
Then work on it in a stretch. Name the stopping point before you start, either a point in the task or a length of time, and somewhere between twenty-five and fifty minutes suits most people. Knowing there's an end makes the pull to switch much easier to refuse. Close the inbox, which means closed and not minimised, put the phone face down or in a drawer, and close the tabs that belong to other work.
Thoughts about other tasks will arrive. Write three words on a capture sheet beside you, "Chase supplier re March", and go back. Many self-made switches start with a good thought you were afraid of losing.
When you stop, for any reason, write a parking note. One line saying where you are and what comes next. "Costs para done. Next, pull Q2 figure from Sam's sheet, then start risks." It takes fifteen seconds. Sophie Leroy and Theresa Glomb found that when people were interrupted and expected to be short of time on return, their attention stayed stuck on the old task and they did worse on the new one, and a brief plan for returning removed the problem. Your note does two jobs. It lets your mind let go, the way Masicampo and Baumeister's plans did, and it shortens the restart because the thread is written down.
When a colleague appears, "Can I come and find you in twenty minutes?" is nearly always acceptable. If it can't wait, say "Give me ten seconds", write the note, and give them your full attention. Deal with messages two to four times a day as a task of their own, and tell people to ring if something's urgent. In the first week, once an hour is still far better than continuously. If a task pauses for an export, park it and take something small off the capture sheet. Between stretches, get up and look out of a window. Scrolling your phone is another task.
If your job is mostly interruptions, as it is on a reception desk, a ward or a support line, the difficulty is real and isn't a failing of yours. The damage falls on whatever project work is mixed in, like the rota or the monthly report. Separate the two in time if you possibly can. Forty-five minutes a day with the door shut, or cover traded with a colleague, will move project work further than a whole fragmented day. When you're on the desk, be on the desk. Use parking notes more than anyone. And if the role gives you no protected time and still expects thoughtful project work, that's a contradiction built into the job, worth raising with whoever designed it.
Home works the same way. Household jobs done one at a time leave only one mess at once, and the drill comes out once. Start the washing machine first, since that's the good kind of doubling-up. With small children you're in the receptionist's position, so save anything that needs sustained thought for nap time or the evening. When your partner is telling you about their day, or your child wants to show you something, put the phone in another room. It takes about ten minutes, and they can tell the difference.
Now the decision. Put it in your own words if you like.
I pick one thing, I work on it until a stopping point I've named, and I write a parking note before I touch anything else.
It helps to plan the moments when the old habit will try to restart. Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran pooled ninety-four tests of plans in the form "when X happens, I'll do Y" and found they make people more likely to follow through, because the decision is made before the difficult moment arrives. Three are worth writing down.
- When I think of another task mid-stretch, I'll write three words on the capture sheet and carry on.
- When I get stuck and feel the pull to check something, I'll stay five more minutes and write a bad version of the next sentence.
- When someone interrupts me, I'll write my parking note before I turn to them.
I'd expect the first week to feel slow and slightly irresponsible. You'll be sure disasters are piling up in the closed inbox, and mostly they won't be. The pull to switch should be strong for some days and then fade, without disappearing. One or two people will remark that you took an hour to reply.
Nine things open at four
You'll have a day when you look up at four o'clock and find nine things open, the inbox in charge and the report untouched.
It doesn't prove the method doesn't suit you. Stop. Write down the pile and pick one. Do a single stretch before you go home, so the day ends with one thing finished. Then look at what set it off, which is usually a bad night's sleep, a task you were dreading, or a morning that started in the inbox.
Other hard cases come round often enough to plan for.
- In an open-plan office, headphones are widely read as "don't disturb", even with nothing playing. Book a room for your first stretch, or propose quiet morning hours.
- If your manager won't budge on instant replies, shorten the stretches. Twenty-five minutes protected and five minutes of replies is still responsive by any reasonable standard.
- With several bosses, your morning list is the evidence. "I have these five things from three people. Which would you like first?"
- When everything really is urgent, as on a deadline day or in a family emergency, you'll juggle, and that's fine. Urgent things still go faster one after another than all at once, even at ten minutes each, so write the order down.
- When a task is too big to finish, finish a piece of it. A section, a draft or a decision can be handed over, and it stops taking up room in your head.
If it's always been like this, since childhood, across school, work and home, and it has cost you, go back to the first caution. The NHS advice is to see a GP about an ADHD assessment. Waits can be long. Meanwhile, written lists, one visible task, parking notes and a cleared desk are the kind of external supports often recommended, because they take over some of the work attention finds hard.
And if you've worked in stretches for a month, your finished lists are long and you're still drowning, then the workload is the problem. Take the lists to your manager.
It's ten past five on a Tuesday, some weeks on.
Beside the keyboard is this morning's list of nine items. Four are crossed through, one says "dropped", three have parking notes, and one waits for tomorrow. The report went to Priya at ten to twelve. You started it at nine, before the inbox, and at twenty to ten you hit the staffing paragraph and didn't know what you thought. The pull to check was strong. You wrote, "What I'm trying to say here is that the saving depends on not replacing Tom," and that turned out to be the paragraph.
At ten there were thirty-one messages. One was mildly urgent, and that sender had rung, as you'd asked. You answered the lot in thirty-five minutes.
The tally sheet has fourteen marks. On the first day it had fifty-three.
The capture sheet says "Dave??" so you ring him, last thing. It takes four minutes. He wanted to know about parking permits.
You're tired, and you know what you did today. The laptop stays in the office. At home the washing machine runs while you cook, and after dinner your daughter wants to show you something she's made. Your phone is on the hall shelf, and you go and look.
If you've changed nothing yet, try it tomorrow. Before you open your inbox, write down the one thing, name the stopping point and work on it for twenty-five minutes. Then write down where you got to.