The 20-minute version
It's a Tuesday night, ten to eleven. You're in bed with the light off, and the muscle in your left calf is twitching. It's a small flutter under the skin, a few seconds at a time, and it's been doing it on and off since the weekend.
You pick up the phone and type "calf muscle twitching". The first result is from the NHS. It says twitches are common and very rarely a sign of anything serious, and that they're often linked to stress, tiredness and caffeine. You had three coffees today, and you've been sleeping badly for a fortnight.
It's a full explanation, and you don't take it.
You scroll down to the section headed "Conditions that can cause a twitch", then go back to the results and open the next one, and the one after. By twenty past eleven you've learned the name of a rare disease of the nerves. By midnight you're on a forum for people who have it, reading a post by a man whose first sign was a twitch in his calf. At twenty to one you shut the bathroom door quietly and stand on tiptoe on your left leg to see whether it's weaker than your right. You can't tell. You try again, and it might be. You go back to bed, and each time the calf twitches your stomach turns over.
In the morning the fear has shrunk to a manageable size, and you feel slightly foolish. By Thursday night you're searching again.
Searching makes sense from the inside. It's quick and private, and it feels responsible. But a search can't examine you, so it can't tell you what you have, and it can't rule anything out. It calms you briefly, and then the worry comes back stronger. Left to itself, it tends to end at the frightening answer, for reasons that have little to do with your body. What I'll suggest in its place is simple. When a symptom worries you, you look once, at one trusted page, to find out what to do. Then you do it, and you put the search down.
There's no medical advice of my own here. I can't tell you whether your symptom matters, and I won't try. Every statement about health comes from the NHS or from a named study.
Four cautions.
- If you think you or someone else may be seriously ill or in danger right now, don't read this and don't search. Call 999. If you need help urgently and it isn't an emergency, call 111 or use 111 online.
- Nothing here is a reason to stay away from a doctor. The argument runs the other way. If a symptom is worrying you, a GP, a pharmacist or 111 is the right place to take it, and searching often delays that.
- If worries about your health have started to take over your life, that has a name, and it can be treated. The NHS describes health anxiety as spending so much time worrying that you're ill, or going to get ill, that it starts to take over your life. Its advice is to see a GP if your worries are preventing you from leading a normal life or if self-help isn't working. There's more on this near the end.
- If you live with a diagnosed condition, some of your looking up is part of managing it. This is about searching a new symptom, late, alone, until you're frightened.
Before reading on, open your browser history for the last month. Count the searches about symptoms and roughly how long each went on, and next to each write how you felt afterwards, in a word. If most say "relieved", searching may be working for you. If most say "worse", keep going.
Everything with those words in it
A search knows one thing about you, which is the words you typed.
It doesn't know your age, your family history or how much coffee you drank. It can't look at your calf, test your reflexes, or watch you walk. It doesn't know the twitch started the day after you moved a wardrobe. So all it can give you is every condition in which those words appear, and for almost any symptom that list is long, because bodies have only so many ways to signal trouble. Tiredness, headache, twitching and dizziness each sit on the lists of dozens of conditions, trivial to grave. The search can't tell you where on the list you are. That was the one thing you wanted.
Searching isn't stupid. It's immediate, when the surgery opens at eight and the phone is eighteen inches away. You don't have to say the fear aloud to anyone. You don't want to waste a doctor's time. And sometimes it works. The psychiatrists Vladan Starcevic and David Berle begin their writing on this habit by saying that looking for health information online is common and often useful. In a study led by Emily Doherty-Torstrick, people with low anxiety about illness recalled feeling relieved after searching. Those with high anxiety recalled feeling worse.
So the trouble is a particular way of searching, done late and alone, going past the first answer and carrying on until something alarming turns up.
Even tools built for the job struggle. Hannah Semigran and colleagues at Harvard fed forty-five patient cases with known diagnoses to twenty-three online symptom checkers, which ask you questions the way a search engine doesn't. The checkers put the correct diagnosis first in 34 per cent of attempts, and anywhere in their top twenty in 58 per cent. An open search and an hour of reading isn't likely to do better.
A doctor asks when it started, what makes it better or worse, what else you've noticed. She looks at the leg and may test its strength, which takes a minute and tells her more than a month of reading. And she has time on her side. "Come back if it's still there in two weeks" can sound like being fobbed off. It's a real test, because most harmless things will have gone by then.
You knew by five to eleven that twitches are very rarely serious. You kept reading because "very rarely" isn't "never", and the plan was to read about the serious causes, find they didn't fit, and sleep.
Ryen White and Eric Horvitz at Microsoft studied how that usually goes, using a large set of search logs and a survey of 515 people. They were looking at escalation, a search that starts with a common, probably harmless symptom and ends up reading about a rare and serious condition. Search engines, they found, have the potential to escalate medical concerns. Whether a search escalated depended partly on how much medical content people viewed and whether the pages used alarming terms, and partly on the person. The worry persisted afterwards, too, and broke into what people were doing on later days.
Why would a search lean that way? My own reasoning gives three suggestions.
- A serious disease has whole websites run by charities, hospitals and patient groups, each listing every early sign, including the common ones. A twitch caused by coffee has nothing of the kind. Nobody founds a charity for it.
- The man on the forum wrote a long post because it's the most important thing that ever happened to him. The thousands whose calves twitched for a week in a stressful month wrote nothing, because nothing happened.
- Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman showed that people judge how likely something is partly by how easily examples come to mind. One vivid story comes to mind far more easily than "very rarely a sign of anything serious".
And the plan was flawed from the start. Ruling something out takes evidence about your own body, such as strength that's normal on examination, a clear test, or a twitch that's gone within two weeks. A page can only tell you what the disease looks like. Almost any early symptom list looks a bit like almost anyone, so when you read in order to rule something out, you usually find something that seems to fit.
The dip
Sometimes a search does calm you. You find a page that says it's nothing and your shoulders drop. That relief is real, and it's what keeps the habit going. I'll call it the dip.
Lucock and colleagues followed sixty patients who'd had a camera examination of the stomach and been told by the consultant that nothing was seriously wrong. Everyone's worry fell sharply. Then the researchers checked back after a day, a week, a month and a year. Patients who'd scored high on health anxiety had their worry, and their belief that they were ill, come back significantly within twenty-four hours, and it stayed back for the whole year. A specialist had looked inside their stomachs and found nothing, and the relief lasted about a day.
A web page won't do better than that.
Here's how I understand what happens, and it's close to how clinicians who treat health anxiety describe it. A reassuring page brings your anxiety down, and your mind notes what did it. The next time anxiety rises, the urge to search is a little stronger. But the page couldn't examine you either, and you know that, so within hours a doubt arrives. Maybe it was a different kind of twitch. Maybe yours is the exception. The anxiety comes back, and what your mind reaches for is another search. Over weeks each dip gets shorter and takes more reading to get. Fam te Poel and colleagues, surveying more than five thousand people four times over, found initial evidence that more searching was followed by more health anxiety, which was followed by more searching.
When a doctor examines your leg and says it's fine, that's information about you. The dip from a page at midnight isn't, and it wears off.
At half past eleven you nearly stopped. The odds were heavily in your favour, but heavily isn't entirely, and the next page might settle it. So you opened it.
No page can hold what you're after. Doctors don't deal in certainty about a twitching calf. They deal in likelihoods, in watching, and in ruling things out step by step if they need to. "Very rarely a sign of anything serious" is as close to certain as an honest medical writer can get in a sentence. Thomas Fergus surveyed 512 healthy adults and found that for people who tolerated uncertainty well, searching had little connection to health anxiety. The less they could bear not knowing, the stronger the connection grew.
So how does the search end, if never in certainty? In my observation, at the frightening answer or at exhaustion, whichever comes first. The reassuring pages leave room for doubt, so you read on. The frightening page doesn't leave you wanting another page. That's how someone can spend an hour learning that a symptom is nearly always harmless and fall asleep convinced they're the exception. The stopping point has to be decided before you start.
"Better safe than sorry," you might say. I agree with the principle. Being safe with a symptom means getting it in front of someone who can assess it, at the right speed. The search comes before that or takes its place, and it can fail you in two ways. You can end up so frightened of something unlikely that you're scared to go. Or, less often noticed, you search in order to talk yourself out of going. You read until you find a harmless explanation that fits, and the lump or the bleeding or the cough goes unexamined for months. A search can't rule the worst in or out. Only the assessment makes you safer.
And the assessment is closer than it feels. A pharmacist can be asked without an appointment. 111, by phone or online, exists to tell you how quickly something needs seeing and by whom. Semigran's team found the symptom checkers' advice was generally cautious, sending people for care when looking after themselves would have been reasonable. The cautious route is already there, and it doesn't need an hour on a forum.
None of this means the symptom isn't real. The calf is twitching. Anyone could see it.
A real symptom can still be ordinary. Anne McAteer and colleagues at the University of Aberdeen asked adults across the UK about twenty-five symptoms over the previous two weeks. The average person had had between three and four. The commonest were feeling tired or run down, headaches and joint pain, and most never reached a doctor. A healthy body produces aches, flutters and twinges most of the time.
Worry adds its own. The NHS says anxiety can cause symptoms like headaches or a racing heartbeat, and that you may mistake these for signs of illness. Its page on twitching lists stress and anxiety first among the things twitches are often linked to, and adds that worrying can make a twitch worse. So Tuesday may have run like this. A stressful fortnight, poor sleep and three coffees produced a twitch. The search produced fear. The fear and the bad night produced more twitching on Wednesday, which looked like the disease progressing.
Checking does the same. Standing on tiptoe at twenty to one, frightened and tired, you were running a test you've no training to interpret, on a leg you'd never tested before. Any result would have worried you. Press a sore spot every day and you can keep it sore. Take your pulse when you're anxious and you'll find it fast.
After midnight
Look at your history again. Most of the long searches probably started after ten.
At night there's nothing to compete with a twitch, so you notice it. Nobody can be asked, either. The surgery's shut and your partner's asleep, and for a fluttering calf you wouldn't think of ringing 111, so the phone seems like the only thing open. And you're at your worst. A group of sleep researchers led by Tubbs has put forward what they call the mind after midnight hypothesis, drawing together evidence that positive mood is at its lowest in the small hours and negative mood peaks then, and that the kind of thinking you need to weigh evidence and stop yourself is impaired when you're awake at a time your body expects sleep. They offer it as a hypothesis, still to be tested.
So you decide what the twitch means at the hour when sensations seem strongest, your mood is lowest, your judgement is weakest, and the only source open is the one that leans towards alarm. By morning nothing about the twitch had changed, but you were a different reader of it.
The forums feel like where the truth is. Official pages say "usually" and "rarely" and tell you to see your GP. A forum has people describing what it felt like and what the doctors got wrong. The stories are mostly true. But a single case can't tell you your chances, and the dull official sentence is a summary of everyone who ever had the symptom. Everyone you meet on a forum for a disease has that disease. The people whose twitch came to nothing never joined. And you leave with new symptoms to watch for. You arrive with a twitch and leave knowing others had trouble with buttons, and anyone who watches their hands closely for a week will catch a fumble or two. Chat assistants share the search engine's basic limit, because they can't examine you, and they'll answer follow-up questions for as long as you keep asking.
Now suppose you do what I keep recommending. You see the GP. She tests the strength in both legs, taps your knees and ankles, and tells you it's a benign twitch, very common, likely to settle. You walk out feeling light. By the following evening you're searching how often doctors miss the disease.
The NHS lists worrying that a doctor or tests may have missed something among the signs of health anxiety. Doctors do sometimes miss things. If a symptom changes, gets worse, or goes on past the point the doctor said it would, going back is sensible. But the evening-after search has no new evidence. It can only raise the general possibility of error, which applies to every consultation anyone has ever had.
So before you leave the consulting room, ask two questions. "What should I look out for?" and "When should I come back if it hasn't settled?" Doctors call this safety netting. Write the answers down there and then. The next evening, when the thought comes that she missed something, check whether anything on that list has happened. If it has, ring the surgery in the morning. If it hasn't, the search has nothing to add.
It helps, too, to arrive prepared. A few lines on what you've noticed, when it started, what makes it better or worse, and what's changed lately, including sleep, stress, caffeine, new medicines and new exercise. Then the line people leave out from embarrassment. Say what you're afraid it might be. "I read that twitching can be a sign of a nerve disease, and I've frightened myself" tells the GP what you need, so she can examine for that and tell you what she found. What helps less is arriving with the diagnosis made and a list of tests.
For many people the habit has a starting point. A colleague went to the doctor with backache and was dead within the year. Your father ignored a cough. I won't argue with that experience. But what went wrong in those stories was nearly always delay, a symptom not taken to a doctor, or not taken back when it carried on. Reading at midnight wouldn't have changed it. An appointment made sooner might have. If a loss like that sits behind your searching, tell your GP. "My father died of lung cancer and I get very frightened about coughs" is useful to them. And grief can come out as worry about your own body, sometimes years later, which deserves proper help of its own.
Add up the hours from your history for the month and multiply by twelve. That's last year's reading about illnesses you don't have. Then count how many searches turned up something that needed treating. If any did, you'd have got there sooner and more calmly by ringing the surgery on the first day.
The one look
You'll still get symptoms, and some will need attention. So here's what to do with one. It's my arrangement of NHS advice, and nobody has tested it as a method.
- If it might be an emergency, don't look anything up. The NHS says 999 is for life-threatening emergencies like strokes and heart attacks. If you're not sure whether you need 999, it says to get help from NHS 111.
- Otherwise, look once, at one trusted page. In the UK that's the NHS website. Search the symptom with "NHS" after it and open that page only.
- Read for what to do. The page can tell you whether you need urgent help, should see a GP, or can wait until a date. For the calf, it says see a GP if the twitch lasts more than two weeks, or is in more than one place, or the area feels weak or stiff.
- Write the instruction and the date in your calendar. "Calf twitch. Started Saturday the 4th. See GP if still there on the 18th, or if it spreads, or if the leg feels weak." The date does the watching now.
- Close the page. Don't read the rare causes at the bottom, and don't go back to the results. If the page says see someone, book it at the next opportunity. If it says wait, wait.
- If you're unsure which applies, ask a person. A pharmacist, or 111 online. Both end with an instruction, which a second page won't.
- One look per symptom. Look again only if the symptom itself changes.
The page will seem too general. Your twitch is in the calf and sometimes the eyelid, or it's been eleven days and not fourteen. No page can speak to those details, and an examination is what they're for. If your case doesn't clearly fall under "wait", treat it as "ask a person". Outside the UK, pick your page now, while you're calm. It should be written for the public, reviewed by clinicians, tell you when to seek care, and have no forum attached.
This leaves you not knowing what the twitch is. It does. You'll know what to do about it and when, which is all the search ever gave you. Most of the time the symptom goes before the date arrives, and you never find out what it was.
The urge will still come at ten to eleven. It's a spike of anxiety with an action attached. Left alone, a spike rises, levels off and falls, and searching means you never find out that it would have fallen anyway.
So tell yourself you can search in twenty minutes if you still want to, and spend those twenty minutes on something that uses your hands or attention. The NHS suggests something similar, a walk or a call to a friend. At ten to eleven it might mean making a drink without caffeine in it and reading a chapter of a novel in another room. Keep a tally on a card, a mark for each search, each body check and each time you ask someone whether it looks all right, and try to bring the marks down gradually over a week. The NHS also suggests a two-column table, the worry on one side and a more balanced thought on the other. "I'm worried about these headaches." "Headaches can often be a sign of stress." It reminds you that the ordinary explanation exists. Charge the phone in the kitchen, so a search means walking through a cold house. And if your partner has become the person you ask, ask them to stop answering. They can say, "What did the page say to do, and have you done it?" Treat checking the same way. Once a week at a set time is plenty for nearly anything a page tells you to watch.
Put together, the rule is this. When a symptom worries me, I look once, at one trusted page, to find out what to do. Then I do it, and I put the search down. A new sensation noticed at night waits until morning, unless it could be an emergency.
Expect the first week or two to be harder than searching was. You'll lie there at eleven with the twitch and a date in the calendar, and it won't feel like enough. The urge generally weakens over a few weeks if you don't act on it, though I can't say how fast.
Some situations change the details.
- With a diagnosed condition, your trusted source may be your clinic's material, a specialist nurse's line or the charity for your condition. Ask your team which changes to ring about and which can wait for your review.
- For a child, the NHS says to call 111 if you need advice for a child under five. A parent's sense that a child isn't right should go to a person who can assess the child.
- In pregnancy, you have a midwife and a maternity unit with a phone number whose job includes these questions. Use it, and keep off pregnancy forums late at night.
- If someone you live with has this habit, answering for the fortieth time won't help, and nor will telling them not to be silly. Ask what the page said to do, and offer to sit with them while they book.
You'll slip. Something will scare you and an hour later you'll be on a forum with your heart pounding. Close the browser and put a mark on the card. In the morning, do the one look in daylight. It was probably tiredness, stress, or a phone that found its way back to the bedside.
If several of the NHS signs fit and they're affecting your life, see a GP. Those signs include constantly worrying about your health, frequently checking your body, always asking for reassurance, and obsessively looking at health information. In England you can also refer yourself to NHS talking therapies. The usual treatment is cognitive behavioural therapy, sometimes with medicine for anxiety. In a trial led by Peter Tyrer, 444 hospital outpatients with high health anxiety had either five to ten sessions of CBT adapted for it or standard care. A year on, about twice as many in the therapy group had reached normal levels, 14 per cent against 7, so it wasn't a cure for most, and the difference lasted two years. In a smaller trial reported by Jill Newby and Eoin McElroy, people with severe health anxiety who did an online CBT course cut their compulsive, distressing searching much more than a comparison group. Needing that help says nothing bad about you. And if the worry has tipped into despair, or you have thoughts of harming yourself, ask for an urgent GP appointment or call 111. Don't search it.
A Tuesday in early summer, ten to eleven, and there's a dull ache behind your right eye. The phone is in the kitchen. You notice the old pull, and you notice your jaw is tight, you spent nine hours at a screen, and you've had about a pint of water since breakfast. You drink a glass at the sink without touching the phone and go back to bed. Over breakfast you take your one look, write "See GP if still there Friday" in the calendar, and close the page. By Wednesday evening it's gone.
The card on the fridge has four marks on it for last month. In February it had thirty-one.
Tonight, put the charger in the kitchen before you go to bed.