The 20-minute version
It's Sunday evening. The proposal is due a week on Friday at five o'clock, and you've had the brief for three weeks.
There is a document. It has a title, your name and one heading that says "Background". You made it the day the brief arrived, in a burst of good intentions, and you've opened it four or five times since. Each time you read the heading, felt something you didn't stop to name, and found yourself doing something else. Once you reorganised the folder the document lives in.
You know how the next twelve days go. This week you'll think about it every day and do very little. Next weekend you'll plan to break the back of it and do an hour. On Wednesday the real fear arrives, the kind that sits in the stomach. On Thursday you'll work until two in the morning, astonished at how much you're getting done, and on Friday at ten to five you'll send it, with a paragraph you know is weak and a budget you didn't have time to check. Then relief, and a promise about next time.
And it will probably be fine. That's what makes the pattern so hard to shift. People think of you as capable, and you are. You may have a whole career built out of Thursday nights.
What nobody sees is twelve days of low dread, a weekend spoiled because the proposal was in the room with you, and the version you'd have written with three more days.
The pattern is selective. The things that wait are the things that count, where the result says something about you. I'll call that work that matters. You never chose to write the proposal on the last night, either. You chose, a dozen separate times, not to write it this afternoon, and each small choice handed a bigger one to the calendar.
And it turns on a moment. You open the document, or think about opening it, and something in you swerves. It takes a second or two. I'll call that the swerve, and most of what follows is about what happens inside it.
The most useful thing you can do about it is small and a bit undignified. Start early, and start badly, on purpose.
Two cautions. Putting things off can be part of something that deserves proper help. If you've lost interest and motivation across most of your life for weeks, that's among the signs of depression the NHS lists, and a GP should hear about it. If you've had trouble since childhood organising your time, finishing tasks and staying focused, everywhere and not only with work you dread, it's worth asking a GP about ADHD. If worry is running your days, that's treatable too. And if you're late because you've been given more than one person can do, the problem is the amount of work, and no change of habit will fix it. This is about the case where the time was there and you didn't use it.
This week, the next time you go to the work and swerve, don't fight it. Catch the feeling that came a second before and give it a rough name. Dread, boredom, confusion about where to begin, or a quick sinking thought that this won't be any good.
Relief this afternoon
Putting off the proposal pays you, and it pays at once.
You opened the document and felt something unpleasant. You drifted to your inbox and the feeling eased. That easing is the payment. It arrives within seconds and costs nothing you can see at the time. Fuschia Sirois and Timothy Pychyl argue that it has less to do with managing time than with managing mood. A task brings up a bad feeling, and avoiding the task repairs it quickly. The relief goes to you today, and the bill goes to the person you'll be a week on Thursday, whom we assume will somehow be better placed to cope.
There's a neat experiment behind this. Dianne Tice, Ellen Bratslavsky and Roy Baumeister put people in a bad mood and gave them time to prepare for a task, with pleasant distractions to hand. People in a bad mood spent more time on the distractions. But one group was led to believe their mood was fixed for now and nothing would shift it, and those people stopped putting the preparation off. If swerving couldn't make them feel better, they didn't bother. The swerve is an attempt to feel better. It has nothing to do with a shortage of effort.
So the relief is real. Tice and Baumeister also followed students through a term, and early on the ones who put things off reported less stress and less illness than the ones who got on with it. Late in the term they reported more of both, enough to come out sicker overall, and they got lower marks on every assignment.
Meanwhile the proposal is still there tomorrow, slightly worse, with a day less to do it in and a new layer of guilt on top of the original feeling. Tomorrow's swerve has more to swerve from. The habit feeds itself.
Delay isn't always this habit. If you're waiting for figures from someone, or the brief is about to change, that's a plan. A plan has a date in it and a reason you could say to a colleague without embarrassment. The habit has the word "later" and a feeling.
Then there's the belief that holds it all up. "I work best under pressure."
It deserves a hearing, because the last night is different. You sit down at eight and the swerve doesn't come. You make decisions fast, you stop rereading every sentence, and pages appear. Around midnight you may even enjoy it. Compared with the grey, distracted half-hours earlier in the month, it feels as if a different person is doing the work.
So what does the last night supply?
- It removes the choice. For three weeks every session began with "now or later", and later kept winning. On the last night there is no later.
- It quiets the judge. There's no time to wonder whether the opening is good enough, so you write an adequate sentence and move on.
- It shrinks the job. You can't do the ideal version, so you cut the section that needed more research.
- It settles the argument. Not doing the work has finally become more frightening than doing it.
None of the four is pressure. Pressure was only how they got delivered, and it's an expensive delivery. A fixed time removes the choice. Permission to be bad quiets the judge. A time limit shrinks the job. Each can be had on a quiet Tuesday.
You can get to the airport in forty minutes if you're about to miss the flight. That proves you can drive fast when frightened. It doesn't show that's how you drive best.
And "best" compared with what? If every important piece of work for ten years was done in the final stretch, you have no record at all of what you'd produce with a rough version on day two and ten days to improve it. The grey half-hours don't count as a test. In those you were trying to write the good version cold, with the judge wide awake, which is the hardest way to work I know.
There is research on the other side. In 2005 Chu and Choi described students they called active procrastinators, who choose to leave things late, like the pressure, hit their deadlines and do about as well as anyone. It's a single questionnaire study, but I don't doubt such people exist. Their description makes a good test. Did you decide to do this piece late, with a date in mind, and spend the waiting time untroubled? Were you satisfied with what you sent? Then leave a working arrangement alone. If the waiting was full of dread and the honest word for the result is "fine", you didn't choose the pressure. You ran out of alternatives.
What the deadline decides
A deadline is supposed to decide when the work gets handed over. Leave it until the deadline is the only thing making you work, and it decides a good deal more.
- The quality. Your first draft becomes your final draft. Much of what makes work good happens on the second pass, and people who start late hand in first drafts for a living. Often good first drafts, which is how the habit survives.
- The scope. The appendix with the costs gets cut at one in the morning by someone tired.
- What you learn. Finished early, work can be shown to a colleague who tells you the third section lost her. Over years that's a great deal of feedback you never got.
- Who else pays. The colleague who needed your part by Wednesday, and whoever lives with you.
- How the waiting feels. E.J. Masicampo and Roy Baumeister found that people reminded of an important unfinished goal had more intrusive thoughts while reading something unrelated. You know this from the inside. The proposal turns up in the middle of a film. The days you took off from it weren't off.
The work gets done and people are happy with it, probably. You've just never chosen any of that. The calendar chose.
Here's an odd thing about your day, though. A colleague asks you to look over their slides, and you do it within the hour. The expenses form gets filled in. Meanwhile the one piece of work that could affect your year sits untouched. If you simply couldn't get on with things, the slides would be waiting too.
The difference is what the result can say about you. Nobody's opinion of you hangs on an expenses form. The proposal will be read by people who'll form a view of how good you are, and worse, it'll be read by you. A piece of work that matters is a measurement, and the swerve is what you do when you'd rather not be measured today. That's why capable people with reputations to protect are so prone to it. Piers Steel, reviewing the research in 2007, found that two of the strongest predictors of putting a task off were how unpleasant it felt and how much the person doubted they could do it.
Now the uncomfortable part, and please don't turn it into a stick. Starting late doesn't only postpone the measurement. It spoils it in a way that protects you. If the one-night proposal is turned down, that says nothing about your ability. If it's accepted, you look better still. The real question, how good you are when you give something everything, never gets answered. Psychologists call this self-handicapping. It's like a runner who always turns up injured. His times never count against him. They never count for him either.
Nobody does this on purpose. The protection is a welcome side effect, and welcome side effects get repeated. If you think the task is simply boring, check it against the expenses form.
What the late start protects is an idea of how good you'd be with proper time. The price of keeping it is that you never find out.
Two more beliefs keep you waiting. The first is "I'll start when I'm ready". Thursday has nothing in it, so Thursday it is. Then a meeting lands, the clear day becomes a ragged afternoon, and you look for the next clear day.
I think this has things the wrong way round. Mood follows starting more often than it leads. On your last night, the focus arrived after you'd begun. The clarity you're waiting for is made by the work, because before there's a draft you have a fog, and twenty minutes of bad drafting turns fog into a short list. The budget depends on a question only finance can answer, and finance may take days, which is a practical reason to find that out in week one. And preparation done before the work has asked you anything is usually the swerve in respectable clothes.
"But my ideas need time to percolate." There's something in that. In 2009 Sio and Ormerod reviewed the experiments on incubation, where people set a problem aside and come back, and found it helped on average. It helped more when people had worked on the problem longer before the break. The mind goes on turning over a problem it has properly got hold of. If all you've done is read the brief and wince, it has nothing to turn over. So percolating is an argument for starting early. Make a rough attempt in week one, and your walks for the next ten days have something to work with.
The second belief is about size. On Sunday you tell yourself the proposal is "a couple of solid days". Roger Buehler, Dale Griffin and Michael Ross found that people underestimate how long their own tasks will take, because they build a story of how the work will go and explain their past overruns away. That time there was the office move. In one of their studies the bias disappeared when people were told to recall similar past tasks and connect them to the estimate. If your whole plan is to start at the last possible moment, the estimate is the plan, and when it's optimistic the overrun comes out of your sleep.
So think of your last three comparable pieces of work and ask how long they really took, in hours, including the night.
At the same time you overestimate how bad the work will feel. The dread is a forecast made from the worst moment, the blank page with the judge awake. Twenty minutes inside, it's a series of small problems, some dull and a few interesting. If you've ever thought at one in the morning "why didn't I do this earlier, it's not even that bad", you've held the evidence in your hands. Both errors are cured by fifteen minutes of contact with the real job.
Fifteen bad minutes
On the day a piece of work that matters arrives, spend fifteen minutes making a bad version of the whole thing. If it arrived a while ago, do it today.
Bad, on purpose. I mean clumsy sentences, guesses where facts should go, and SOMETHING ABOUT COSTS HERE in capitals. What you've been avoiding is judgement, and a version that's meant to be bad can't be judged a failure. For once the judge has nothing to say, and you didn't need one in the morning to arrange it.
The whole thing. For a proposal, every heading with one ugly sentence under each. For a talk, the six things you might say in the order you might say them. Covering the whole thing shows you the size and shape of the job, and stops you hiding in the one easy section.
The real thing, in the document that will eventually be sent. Reading doesn't count, and neither do notes about what it might cover. When the timer goes, is there more of the actual work in existence than before?
Fifteen minutes, with a timer. Dreading a quarter of an hour of deliberately poor typing is hard. When it goes you can stop, and I mean that.
On the day it arrives, before any guilt has built up, when a bad version looks like keenness.
Before you close the document, write one line at the top saying exactly what comes next. "Ask finance for last year's figures."
A decorator's first coat looks dreadful, patchy, with the old colour showing through. No decorator minds. It's there so the second coat has something to go on.
Here's why I think it works, though it's my reasoning and nobody has tested the package. It gives you on day one what the last night gave you, without the fear. It turns dread into a list of gaps you can send emails about, and starts the clock on other people's answers. And it changes the task from making something out of nothing in front of a judge to improving a bad proposal, which is editing, and most people find that far easier.
"It's wasted work." Some of it, but twelve days of dread cost more than fifteen minutes of sentences you later delete, and the structure tends to survive. "What if it shows I've got nothing to say?" Then you've learned it with eleven days left and not eleven hours.
If you have anything waiting, try it once before you read on.
The late start does have one real virtue. It caps the job. Begin two weeks early and the thing could take every evening for a fortnight. Parkinson joked in 1955 that work expands to fill the time available, and if you lean towards perfectionism, the deadline is the only thing that ever makes you stop. But it was making three decisions for you, and you can make all three yourself, in daylight.
- Decide the size. Some things need to be excellent, many need to be good, and some only need to exist. Ask what happens if this one is merely adequate. If the answer is "nothing much", it's a four-hour job. The rushed version was always a small version, and this time you pick what goes in it.
- Decide the hours. Take the honest estimate, put the sessions in the diary with end times, and stop at the end time. Stopping on time teaches you that starting is safe.
- Decide when it's done. Set your own finish a couple of days before the real one and promise the draft to a colleague or a friend. A date in someone else's diary is much harder to shift. That's my reasoning, with no trial behind it. You turn up for other people.
To the perfectionist I'd say only this. You already hand in work that's merely good, because a first draft written overnight can't be anything else. Starting early is the only arrangement with a second pass in it, so it's the only one where your standards ever get applied.
"I've always been like this." Perhaps it's a good story, the dissertation in four days, or a grim one. Either way it claims a trait, and a trait would show up everywhere. Yours shows up with work that measures you. My guess is you learned it early. A bright child can do homework on the bus and get good marks, and the lesson is that the last minute is enough. The work got bigger and the method never came up for review. Steel did find procrastination tied to impulsiveness and distractibility, so some people find this harder than others. A tendency still isn't a fate. It just means you need a method.
The grim version feels like honesty. The evidence runs the other way. Sirois found that people who procrastinate more tend to be harder on themselves and more stressed, though that can't show which causes which. Michael Wohl, Timothy Pychyl and Shannon Bennett followed 134 first-year students through two rounds of exams, and those who forgave themselves for putting off revision before the first round put off less before the second. It fits. If every thought of the proposal arrives with "and you're pathetic", there's more bad feeling to swerve from. You can think the late start was a mistake and skip the contempt, the way you would with a colleague. "You left it late, it was a rough week, so what's the plan for the next one?"
Then there's the work nobody is waiting for. A man fits kitchens for a firm and wants to work for himself. He needs photographs of his best jobs, a simple website, a word with an accountant and a set of prices. None of it is hard, and he's been meaning to do it for four years. He's never once been late on a job for the firm, because there's always a customer waiting. For this, nobody is.
Here the cost never arrives on a particular day. There's no Thursday night, only a fading intention, a sentence about getting to it when things calm down, and one day a birthday with a nought in it.
Things don't calm down. So it's fifteen minutes tonight. For the kitchen fitter, a page with four headings and one rough line under each, existing after four years of nothing. After that, this work needs what the world won't supply. Standing time in the week, small and fixed, Tuesday and Thursday from seven till eight. A person who expects a two-line update on Sundays. And stages someone sees, six photographs sent to your sister by the end of the month. Wanting it was never the missing piece. You really wanted to keep your job, and you still needed deadlines.
Fifteen minutes might also show you that you don't want the project after all. Let it go on purpose and enjoy the room it leaves.
The line at the top
All of it comes down to six small habits for work that matters.
- Start it badly on the day it arrives, or the next morning if that day is impossible.
- Leave yourself a next step. In the Masicampo and Baumeister studies, the intrusive thoughts from an unfinished goal stopped when people made a specific plan for it, a plan earnest enough that they later carried it out. A written next step with a booked time is that kind of plan. It's what lets you close the laptop and have your evening.
- Book the next session before you leave this one, with a start and an end, and put it in a "when, then" sentence, a form that has done well across a large body of research on following through. "When I sit down with my coffee on Tuesday morning, then I open the proposal and do the line at the top."
- Decide the size and the hours, from your record and not your hopes.
- Promise an early version to a real person, two or three days before the real date.
- Make the first five minutes of every session bad. The swerve doesn't retire after day one. It turns up at the start of sessions, especially after a gap or before a hard section.
You will still feel the swerve. When it comes, notice it, name it if you can, and remind yourself that what's being asked of you is five bad minutes. The feeling is a forecast about a big judged task, and that isn't the task in front of you. Start the timer. The feeling doesn't have to fade for you to type. It's an old habit firing, and I'd expect it to keep turning up for a good while, more weakly as your evidence builds.
The first bad start will feel silly. The second session is often harder, because the judge wakes up and reads the bad draft. Your job then is only to fix the worst thing in it. Around day five, ahead of schedule, the old system will tell you it's safe to stop until the panic. Keep the sessions. And finishing early will feel almost like cheating. It isn't.
It will still happen. A heavy month, a bad start that never got its second session, and you look up and it's Wednesday night again.
Skip the trial. "I've read all this and I've still done it" adds bad feeling to a task you're avoiding because of bad feeling. The method works with nine hours left too. Do fifteen bad minutes on the whole thing, because late-night panic pours everything into the first section and leaves the ending as a stub. Then improve the parts in order of importance, and decide out loud what this needs to be by five tomorrow. If it truly can't be done, ask for more time on Wednesday morning, when it's an ordinary professional act, and not at ten to five on Friday.
Afterwards, once you've slept, spend ten minutes finding the first point of failure. It's usually small. The brief arrived on a Friday afternoon and the day-one start never happened. Or there was no next step and the document went cold. Patch that joint. Don't count streaks, because a broken one makes you feel you're back at the beginning, and you aren't.
If after a fair try this isn't shifting, something else may be involved, and there's help for it. Talk to a GP if any of these apply.
- Your mood has been low for weeks, and you've lost interest and motivation across most of your life, not only at work. The NHS lists these among the symptoms of depression.
- You've always found it hard to organise your time and finish tasks, you're easily distracted and often lose things, everywhere, going back to childhood. The NHS lists these as signs of ADHD in adults, says symptoms usually start before the age of 12, and warns that waits for assessment can be long, which is a reason to start the conversation soon.
- Worry takes up a large part of most days.
- The putting off is threatening your job, your degree or your finances, whatever the cause.
In England you can refer yourself to NHS talking therapies for anxiety and depression without seeing a GP first. If you ever have thoughts of harming yourself, get urgent help the same day through NHS 111 or your GP, or 999 in an emergency. Procrastination itself responds to treatment as well. In a 2015 Swedish trial led by Rozental, an internet course based on cognitive behavioural therapy helped moderately, with between a quarter and two fifths of people improving in a clinically meaningful way. If you're a student, your university's study advisers and counselling service will have seen this before. If you're employed, I'd expect most managers to prefer a rough draft on Tuesday to a surprise on Friday.
So, Sunday evening again, three weeks after a different brief. You spent fifteen minutes on the Monday it came in, on a version so bad you'd have been mortified if anyone saw it. Under "Budget" it said NO IDEA, ASK FINANCE, so on Tuesday you asked, and the figures took eight days. On day six an idea about the second aim arrived on the walk to the station. On Wednesday a colleague read the draft and said the third section lost her, and there was time to fix it. You felt the swerve at the start of most sessions, and once it won for three days. The thing is nearly done, and it isn't in the room with you tonight.
Now set a timer for fifteen minutes. Open the real document, or create it, and write a bad version of the whole thing. Put one line at the top saying what comes next. Then close it, and have your evening.