Stop at the first one

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 53 min

It's half past eight and you're on the sofa with a programme on. You've had dinner. You fancy something, and there's a sharing bag of crisps in the cupboard, so you open it, and the first one is exactly what you wanted. Salt, crunch, the taste you'd been thinking about. You have another. Your hand goes to the bag and back, to the bag and back, and you aren't thinking about crisps any more, you're thinking about the programme, and then your hand goes in and finds nothing. You look down. It's the bottom.

A hundred and fifty grams. An hour ago you'd have said you wanted a handful, and you'd have meant it.

What happened between the handful and the bottom wasn't a decision. It was a hand, a bag and a screen, and it's happened three times this week. Or it's the sweets in the car door, opened at the lights and empty by the motorway. Or the tub of nuts on the counter you passed six times. The shape doesn't change. You intend a few, the container doesn't stop you, and the surprise at the end never quite stops being a surprise.

The habit makes sense from the inside. You like crisps, a few is a reasonable plan, and the bag is right there. My argument is that the plan never had a chance. People treat a unit as the right amount, and the packet is the unit, sized by someone who wasn't thinking about your evening. A bag hides how much has gone, so the only signal it ever sends is the bottom. A screen raises how much you eat, now and later. And the pleasure you opened the bag for sits in the first few and fades within minutes, so the run to the bottom spends most of the bag on crisps you don't taste. The answer is short. Put what you're going to eat in a bowl, put the packet away, and eat it without a screen.

You don't have to stop eating crisps, or sweets, or anything you like, and there's nothing to count. You change the unit so that "a few" is what you eat, and you look at them while you eat them.

One caution. If the amounts are large, if it comes with a feeling of losing control, and especially if it's followed by making yourself sick or by not eating for a stretch, that isn't the habit I'm writing about. It may be an eating disorder, which is an illness with good treatment, and the charity Beat and your GP are the places to start. This is about a sharing bag on a sofa.

Before you read on, keep a list for a week. Every packet you open, note what it was, roughly how big, whether a screen was on, and whether you reached the bottom. Change nothing yet. Most people find they reached the bottom nearly every time a screen was on and a sharing bag was open, and almost never when the snack was in a bowl. You'll believe it more in your own handwriting than in mine.

The bag is the amount

Start with the intention, because it's sincere and it fails every time, and the reason is one of the tidier findings in the psychology of eating.

In 2006 Andrew Geier, Paul Rozin and Gheorghe Doros described what they called unit bias, the tendency to treat one unit of something as the right amount, whatever size the unit is. They left food out in public places with a sign saying help yourself. Sweets with a small scoop one day and a large scoop another. Pretzels whole one day and halved the next. People took one scoop or one pretzel, so on the large-scoop and whole-pretzel days they took much more by weight. Nobody stopped them taking two small scoops. They didn't. One unit felt like the amount.

Open a sharing bag and the amount that feels right is the bag. You never decided that. It's what a unit does. "A few" was your intention, "the bag" was the unit's, and the unit was set by someone who wanted to sell a bigger bag. It works in reverse just as well. Put a handful in a bowl and the bowl becomes the amount, and you'd have to get up to have more, and mostly you won't. So the intention to have a few can't beat a bag. It beats a bowl easily, because the bowl is a few.

"But I eat until I've had enough." Think about what a bag tells you while you eat from it. It's opaque, held at an angle, and your hand goes in without your eyes. You can't see how much you've had or how much is left, until there's none. Eric Robinson and colleagues pooled twenty-four experiments in 2013 on how attention and memory affect eating, and one finding was exactly this. When people couldn't see how much they'd eaten, they ate moderately more. Their hunger hadn't changed. The signal that would have told them how far they'd got had gone.

After dinner there's no hunger signal to stop you either. The wanting that opened the bag was met by the first one, and after that nothing tells you anything except the bottom, which is why you reach it every time.

"It's only a small packet." Natalina Zlatevska and colleagues pooled the research on portion size in 2014. Doubling a portion raised how much people ate by about thirty-five per cent on average. The effect was strongest for snack foods, weaker when people paid more attention to the food, and flattened at very large sizes, so the difference between a small bag and a sharing bag matters far more than the difference between huge and enormous. A Cochrane review of seventy-two studies found the same direction. Larger portions, packages and tableware raise what people eat by a moderate amount. A single bag of crisps is about thirty grams. A sharing bag is about a hundred and fifty, five times as much, right in the steep part of the curve, and because the bag is the unit, you eat all of it.

"I was hungry." Perhaps, for the first one.

Here's what happens to the rest. In 1984 Barbara Rolls and colleagues gave people a four-course lunch, either the same food in every course or a different food in each, and people ate sixty per cent more when the courses varied, mostly in the third and fourth. As people ate a food, they rated it as less pleasant, while foods they hadn't eaten kept their appeal. The researchers called this sensory-specific satiety. You get full of a taste before you get full of food. In 1989 Marion Hetherington and colleagues timed it, and the biggest drop in how pleasant a food seemed came about two minutes after eating it. That's fast enough to be about the senses, not about food reaching your stomach.

A bag of crisps is one taste, repeated.

So the pleasure of crisps is front-loaded and short. Somewhere between the tenth and the twentieth, in my experience of asking people to notice, the crisps stop being different from one another and turn into a texture. By the fortieth you're doing something with your hand while watching television, and the something happens to involve crisps. The hunger, if there was any, stopped early. The hand kept going because the bag was there and the screen was on, and neither of those runs out until the bag does. The slightly sick feeling at the bottom comes from eating a hundred and forty things you didn't taste and getting nothing for them.

Fifteen seconds and a cereal bowl

"I wasn't paying attention." People say it as an apology. I'd say it as the mechanism.

Robinson's review had a second finding, and it was the biggest in the paper. People who ate while distracted, by a screen or a task, ate moderately more at the time. Then they ate more at the next meal too, by about twice that margin. The distraction seemed to stop the eating from registering, so the next meal was eaten as if the crisps hadn't happened. A smaller study points the same way. In 2006 Hetherington and colleagues gave thirty-seven people four lunches, and eating alone with the television on raised intake by fourteen per cent over eating alone without it. It's small and it's about lunch, but it agrees with the review. Attention is what would let you notice that the fifteenth crisp tastes of nothing and the bag feels lighter. Take it away and the hand just goes on.

It explains the strangest part of the run, too, which is that you don't remember eating the bag. Suzanne Higgs, in 2002, asked women to spend five minutes before a snack thinking about what they'd had for lunch. They ate less than women who'd thought about anything they liked. Being reminded of today's lunch cut what they ate, and being reminded of yesterday's didn't. Their hunger and fullness ratings were the same in every group. What changed the amount was whether recent eating was in mind. Crisps eaten with a screen on leave almost nothing in mind, and eating that isn't remembered doesn't count.

Then comes the verdict at the bottom. No willpower. Other people can have three and put the bag away.

Two findings say what willpower is up against. David Marchiori and colleagues, in 2014, had people imagine being served a small or large portion and say how much they'd eat. A large portion raised the answer and a small one lowered it. Telling half of them that the portion was random and meant nothing made no difference. This was imagined eating, so I wouldn't carry the numbers to the sofa, but the shape matters. The size of what's in front of you sets how much you'll eat, and knowing that doesn't undo it.

The second finding is the useful one. Amar Cheema and Dilip Soman, in 2008, gave people chocolates either in one quantity or divided into smaller units, and people ate less when the quantity was divided. The divisions, which they called partitions, worked by putting a decision in front of each step onward. The effect showed up in people who were trying to control their eating and vanished in people who weren't. Partitions are a tool for people who want to eat less than the bag. Which is you.

So the run is one person against a unit, an anchor and a distraction, all at once, with no information about how far they've got. Nearly everyone loses that, and losing it says nothing about character. The bowl wins because it splits one decision, opening the bag, into two. Fill the bowl, then decide whether to get up.

You'll have objections, and most of them are about the bowl.

"Once it's open it has to be finished." Open crisps do go soft overnight. Folded over with a clip on, they don't, or not by tomorrow evening when you'd have the next bowl. Sweets don't go stale at all, and nuts keep for weeks. Picture the trade honestly, too. A half bag in the cupboard, or a hundred and forty crisps you didn't want so the cupboard looks tidy. An open bag with a clip on it is just tomorrow's snack, already started.

"A bowl is fussy." Who's watching? It takes about fifteen seconds and a trip to the cupboard you were making anyway. Those fifteen seconds buy a decision point before the second handful, a clear view of how much is left, and a unit the size of a handful. A cereal bowl on the arm of the sofa isn't an event. It's what a snack looked like before sharing bags.

"I'm a grown adult, I'll eat what I want." Agreed. Look at who's been deciding, though. A bag size chosen in a meeting, a screen that was already on, and a hand. You wanted a few and ate a hundred and fifty grams. The bowl is the one moment in the evening when you set the amount yourself, in the light, before anything else has a say. Pour a handful, or pour three. Pour the whole bag if that's what you want tonight, and you'll be someone who chose the bag instead of someone who found the bottom.

"They're made to be eaten like that." They are. Unit bias doesn't care who set the unit, though. A manufacturer chose a hundred and fifty grams because larger units sell more. You can choose thirty, and the same bias will work for you exactly as hard as it worked for them. The bag even says "sharing" on it. Share it with tomorrow.

"I'll make up for it tomorrow." The promise made at the bottom of a bag is made by someone who feels a bit sick, and by half past eight tomorrow that person has gone and the one who fancies something is back. Worse, the promise closes the case, so you never look at the two things that would change tomorrow, which are the bag size and the screen. A clip on the bag and a bowl where you'll see it will still be there tomorrow evening. A promise won't.

Then the one I'd be gentlest with. "It's the only treat I get."

I believe you. The evening snack is one of the few small pleasures in a day full of things that aren't, and I'm not taking it. But look at where in the bag the treat actually is. The first ten crisps are the salt and the crunch and the taste you'd been thinking about since dinner. Crisp number eighty is something your hand did during the programme, and you couldn't describe it if asked. The run doesn't hold more treat than a bowl. It holds the same treat, the first handful, then a hundred and forty crisps of nothing, then a feeling at the bottom that's no treat at all. In my observation, people who eat crisps from a bowl, looking at them, enjoy crisps more. They finish wanting one more, which is how a treat is meant to leave you. If this is the only treat you get, that's the best reason to make it one.

"I can't stop halfway." You're right. Halfway through a bag, in the dark, with a screen on, has no markers, and expecting to stop there is expecting willpower to beat a unit. So don't stop halfway. Start with half. Make the decision once, at the cupboard, by pouring, before the screen is on and before you've tasted anything. After that there's no stopping left to do, because the bowl does it.

"I tried small bags and I just open two." Two small bags is sixty grams against the sharing bag's hundred and fifty. More to the point, between the bags there was a moment when you decided, and a moment like that never exists inside a sharing bag. Keep the multipack in the cupboard and take one bag out, so the second costs a walk. Cheema and Soman also found that partitions lose their grip once people get used to them, so mix it up. A small bag one night, a bowl the next.

What does the run cost? Less than a diet book would say and more than "it's just a snack". Turn your bag over and look at the number on it, then multiply by three a week. For sweets, the NHS says adults should have no more than thirty grams of free sugars a day, and a bag of sweets is mostly sugar. There's the feeling at the bottom, three evenings a week. There's the bargain of the big bag, which only works if it lasts five nights. A child on the same sofa learns that a bag is a unit and a screen is where you eat it. Oddly, the run also makes you want crisps more. It trains the hand and the hour, so by the next evening the hand and the hour are asking for it and the crisps are almost beside the point. And you've stopped tasting crisps. Ask yourself when you last ate one and thought how good it was. For most people who eat from the bag, it's the first one of each bag, if that, eaten while reaching for the remote.

Put it in a bowl, then look at it

When you open a packet, pour whatever you'd call a few into a bowl. A cereal bowl for crisps. A cup or a ramekin for sweets. A small dish for nuts. A serving bowl won't do, because a serving bowl is a bag with a rim. The bowl is the unit now, and the same bias that emptied the bag will empty the bowl and stop.

Clip the packet and put it back in the cupboard before you sit down. Leave it off the arm of the sofa and off the coffee table, with the cupboard door closed. A bag within reach is a run waiting for the bowl to end. A bag in the cupboard is a trip, and a trip is a decision.

You can have seconds. That's the rule that stops the bowl turning into a diet. If you finish and want more, get up and pour another bowl. Mostly you won't, because the wanting was met in the first handful and standing up is enough of a pause to notice. Nothing is locked and nothing is banned. There's just a step between you and the second bowl, which the bag never gave you.

Use a bowl you like. The chipped one at the back makes the snack feel like rationing. A bowl you'd be pleased to eat from makes it something you've done for yourself.

For the first week, change only that. Same snacks, a bowl every time, and keep the list going. At the end of the week, count the bottoms. I'd expect the count to be zero, which is a strange result for something you'd put down to willpower.

Next, the shop. A multipack of thirty-gram bags is the same crisps in handful-sized units. Open one, eat it, done. For once, unit bias is on your side. Buy sweets in small bags or individually wrapped, since a wrapper is a partition, and nuts in small pots rather than the tub. You'll pay a little more per gram and eat a great deal less per evening. Keep sharing bags for when there are four of you, in a bowl for the four. Walking past the sharing bag to the multipack takes about as long as reading this sentence.

Then the two minutes, which is the part that gives you the snack back.

Pour the bowl, sit down, and leave the programme off until the bowl is finished. It takes two or three minutes. Look at the first crisp before you eat it, taste it, and notice that it's good, because it is. Notice the fifth. Around the tenth, notice that the taste has started to flatten. That's sensory-specific satiety happening in your mouth, the signal the bag never let you hear, and it's telling you the treat is nearly done. Finish the bowl. There's nothing to prove by leaving some, since the bowl was the right amount. Then turn the programme on, with an empty bowl, a taste you remember, and a hand with nothing to do. You'll watch it as someone who's had a snack, not someone in the middle of one.

This isn't a mindfulness practice or a ritual. It's two minutes of eating crisps while looking at crisps, which is how everyone ate them before there was anything else to look at.

If the programme's already on and the household won't pause it, at least look down. Eat the first few with your eyes on the bowl and give the screen the rest. Half your attention is better than none, and the bowl still sets the amount.

So here's the decision. I put what I'm going to eat in a bowl, I put the packet away, and I eat it without a screen.

Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran reviewed ninety-four studies in 2006 of plans made in the form "when this happens, I'll do that". People who plan this way follow through much more often than people who only hold the intention. So write three.

  • When I open a packet, I'll pour a bowl, clip the packet and put it back in the cupboard before I sit down.
  • When I reach for a sharing bag in the shop, I'll pick up the multipack instead unless there are people to share with.
  • When I sit down with the bowl, I'll leave the screen off until it's empty.

A few packets need a line of their own.

At the cinema you're handed the largest unit of all, in the dark, with a screen the size of a wall. Buy the smallest size or bring a small bag, and eat it before the film starts, in the light, looking at it.

In the car, the bag in the door is the run with the road as the screen. Keep bags out of the door. If you want something for the drive, put one small bag on the passenger seat, and when it's gone it's gone.

With sweets, a bag can be most of a day's sugar. A cup or a small dish is the bowl, and individually wrapped ones bring their own partitions.

Nuts are healthy and come in tubs, and a tub of nuts is a sharing bag with a lid. A ramekin of something healthy is still the right amount.

For children, the multipack you buy for lunchboxes is the unit I'd recommend for you. Buy it for everyone. A child eating from a sharing bag in front of a screen is learning the run at the age when units get set.

Some evenings aren't a run so much as grazing, the cupboard visited six times between dinner and bed. The bowl handles one snack. The rest is the cupboard door, the clip and the bowl, and no resolutions.

If you reach for the packet because you're bored, flat, tense or sad, rather than because you fancy crisps, the bag is standing in for something else. The bowl still helps, though it won't be the whole answer.

And again, plainly. If it involves large amounts with a sense of losing control, especially if it's followed by making yourself sick, using laxatives, or going without food to make up for it, please talk to your GP or to Beat. That's an illness with treatment, and a cereal bowl isn't the treatment.

The clip on the next bag

I'd guess, and it's my expectation rather than a finding, that the first night the bowl will feel small and slightly ridiculous. You'll finish it and think about getting up for more, and in the first week about half the time you will. That's fine. Getting up is the partition working, and a second bowl is still smaller than the run. By the third night you'll notice the taste of the first crisp, and notice that you'd stopped noticing it. By the end of the week the seconds will mostly have stopped. By the third week the cupboard will hold small bags instead of a sharing bag, and you'll still fancy something at half past eight, and you'll have it. It'll taste of crisps.

Then a bad day comes. The bag's already open, the programme's already on, and your hand finds the bottom before you've thought of the bowl.

One bag isn't the week. Last month there were three bottoms a week and no bowls.

Skip the write-off. A run doesn't need a promise about tomorrow. It needs a clip on the next bag, tonight, and the bowl left on the counter where you'll see it. Tomorrow's snack goes in a bowl because the bowl is out.

The bottom tells you which part was missing, and each part takes a minute to fix.

  • A sharing bag still in the cupboard from before. Clear the big bags out this week.
  • The bag reached the room before the bowl did. Keep the bowl on the counter so it's the first thing you see.
  • The screen was on when you opened it. Open packets in the kitchen, where the bowls are.

Don't count nights without a bottom. Count bowls. One bottom in a fortnight of bowls is a fortnight unlike any before it.

It's half past eight, some months on. You fancy something. In the cupboard there's a multipack and a sharing bag with a clip on it from the weekend your sister came. You take a small bag, pour it into the cereal bowl that lives on the counter now, and sit down with the screen off.

The first one is exactly what you wanted. You notice it. The fifth is good. Around the tenth the taste goes flat, the way it does, and you notice that too, and finish the bowl, and don't want another, though the cupboard's right there. You turn the programme on. Your hand has nothing to do and doesn't mind.

The list is still on your phone, because it's become a small habit of its own. This week it has five bowls on it and no bottoms.

Your partner has started doing it too, without a word said. There's a second bowl on the counter and clips on bags you didn't clip, and the two of you sit with two small bowls and the screen off for a couple of minutes, which turns out to be the part of the evening when you talk.

Last week your daughter asked for a bowl as well. She's seven. She ate her crisps looking at them and told you which one was the best. You hadn't taught her that. She'd watched.

Tonight, when you open the packet, pour what you'd call a few into a cereal bowl, clip the packet, put it in the cupboard, and eat the bowl with the screen off.