Ten minutes counts

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 49 min

It's Tuesday, and the plan was the gym at six. The bag has been packed and sitting in the hall since Sunday night. You pay thirty-four pounds a month, and the plan is a good one. Tuesday, Thursday and Saturday morning, forty-five minutes each, a bit of everything.

The four o'clock meeting runs until ten past five. There's a problem on the trains. You get home at twenty to seven, and dinner has to be on the table by half past because someone has to be somewhere at eight. You stand in the hall and do the sum. Ten minutes each way to the gym, then changing, then a shower. That leaves perhaps fifteen minutes of actual exercise, twenty if you skip the shower and eat in your kit.

Fifteen minutes. You wouldn't even be warm.

You step over the bag and start the dinner. Thursday, then, and a full hour to make up for it. On Thursday it pours and you've a headache. On Saturday you sleep in, because it's been a long week, and by the time you're up there are errands. On Sunday night the bag is still in the hall and you look at it with a familiar mix of guilt and resolve. Next week, properly.

Look at what happened at twenty to seven. You had twenty-five free minutes in which you could have walked fast round the block, or gone up and down the stairs, or done something on the living-room floor. You never weighed twenty-five minutes of something against nothing. As you saw it, the choice was between a proper session and a failed one, and a failed one felt worse than none. So the week came to nought minutes. It had several slots of fifteen or twenty minutes in it. None of them was big enough to hold the thing you'd decided exercise had to be.

I'll call that line the threshold, the point below which exercise doesn't count in your head. For most people with this habit it sits around thirty minutes. A day when you meant to exercise and did none is a zero.

The alternative is never a shorter session. It's always nothing, and people who'd scoff at fifteen minutes of walking will spend the same fifteen minutes on their phone without a thought. Then comes the promise to make up for it with something longer, which raises the bar for next time.

My case runs in three steps. The threshold is understandable, because for years the official advice said exercise only counted in blocks of a certain length. The threshold is also wrong, and the advice has changed. The research of the last fifteen years is unusually clear that the biggest health gain on the whole scale comes from the step between nothing and a little. And one rule removes most of the zeros from a week. On any day when you can't do the full session, you do ten minutes, and it counts.

This isn't a training plan, and it doesn't argue against long sessions. If you like your forty-five minutes, keep them. I make no claims about weight at all.

Four cautions.

  • The NHS advises speaking to your GP first if you haven't exercised for some time, or if you have medical conditions or concerns, and making sure the activity and its intensity suit your fitness. That applies to ten minutes as much as to an hour.
  • If you get chest pain, stop. The NHS says to call 999 if you have sudden chest pain or discomfort that doesn't go away, pain that spreads to your arm, neck, jaw, stomach or back, or chest pain with sweating, sickness, light-headedness or shortness of breath. Chest pain that comes and goes still needs medical advice.
  • If you're pregnant, have recently had a baby, or live with a long-term condition or disability, the general message holds and the details differ. The NHS and the World Health Organization publish guidance for these groups, and your GP, midwife or physiotherapist can advise you.
  • If your difficulty runs the other way, this isn't for you. If you feel compelled to exercise, get anxious when you can't, or use exercise to make up for eating, please talk to a GP. The NHS lists exercising too much among the features of some eating disorders, and the charity Beat offers support.

Before you go on, if you're willing, look back over the last four weeks. Count the full sessions you planned and the ones you did. For each one you missed, ask whether you had ten free minutes at some point that day. You're finding out whether you were short of time, or only short of time for the full session.

The most valuable fifteen minutes

You didn't invent the threshold. You were told it, and by good authorities.

For a couple of decades public health guidelines said adults should get thirty minutes of moderate exercise on most days, built up in bouts if you liked, as long as each bout lasted at least ten minutes. Most people heard something simpler. Thirty minutes is the unit, and below some minimum it doesn't register. Add the gym lore about not burning fat until twenty minutes in, the feeling that real exercise leaves you red-faced and needing a shower, and the overhead of travelling and changing, and the threshold looks like common sense. Then there's the reason I respect most. You do things properly, and a ten-minute token feels like something people do so they can tell themselves they've exercised.

Under all of it sits a fair wish. You want the effort to be worth something. If short sessions really did nothing, skipping them would be the rational choice.

So do they?

Hannah Arem and colleagues pooled six large studies from the United States and Europe, covering 661,137 adults followed for a median of about fourteen years. They sorted people by how much leisure-time activity they reported, against the recommended minimum of 150 minutes a week at moderate intensity. People who met that minimum, or did up to twice as much, had a 31 per cent lower risk of dying during the study than people who did nothing. The group that matters here is the one below them. They did some activity, less than the minimum, and by the logic of the threshold were wasting their time. Their risk of dying was 20 per cent lower than the people who did nothing.

Put the numbers side by side. Going from nothing to something, though not enough, was associated with a 20 per cent reduction. Going all the way up to the guidelines added another 11 points. Three to five times the guidelines got people to 39 per cent. The first step, from zero to a little, was the largest single step on the whole scale.

In Taiwan, Chi Pang Wen and colleagues followed 416,175 people, and those who managed about fifteen minutes a day had a 14 per cent lower risk of death and a life expectancy about three years longer than the inactive. Self-reported exercise is unreliable, so Ulf Ekelund and colleagues combined eight studies in which 36,383 people wore movement monitors. Against the least active quarter, the next quarter up had about half the risk of death, and the top two did better again by much smaller steps. Activity of any intensity was associated with lower risk.

These are observational studies. People who are already ill move less, and people who exercise tend to eat better, smoke less and have more money. Researchers adjust as well as they can, and the true effect is probably smaller than the raw figures. What I'd rely on is the shape, which turns up in country after country. Steep at the bottom, flatter towards the top.

The threshold pictures exercise as a switch, with nothing below the line. The data look more like a dimmer, and most of the brightening comes in the first part of the turn.

Then there's the rule that it has to be in one go. As far as I can tell, the ten-minute bout came from the early trials, which only tested sessions of ten minutes and up. Shorter bouts hadn't failed. They hadn't been studied. When the United States updated its guidelines in 2018, John Jakicic and colleagues reviewed 29 studies and concluded that activity of any bout duration is associated with improved health outcomes, including lower mortality. In one of those studies, Pedro Saint-Maurice and colleagues counted the activity of 4,840 monitor-wearing adults three ways, every minute of it, only bouts of five minutes or more, and only bouts of ten or more. The associations with death over the next six and a half years were similar however the minutes were counted. People who got their activity in scraps did as well as people who got the same amount in blocks.

As I understand it, the bout requirement has since been dropped from American guidance, and the World Health Organization's 2020 guidelines left it out too. The WHO authors sum up their message as "some physical activity is better than none".

The research has since gone shorter still. Emmanuel Stamatakis and colleagues looked at 25,241 people in the UK Biobank who said they did no exercise or sport at all, and found brief bursts of vigorous activity in their ordinary days, such as running for a bus, taking the stairs fast or carrying heavy shopping up a hill. Those who managed three bursts a day had a 38 to 40 per cent lower risk of death over about seven years than those with none, from about four and a half minutes a day. People who can run for a bus are healthier to start with, so read that size with some scepticism.

But there's a small randomised experiment pointing the same way. Madison Jenkins and colleagues had sedentary young adults climb three flights of stairs briskly, three times a day, three days a week. After six weeks their aerobic fitness had improved compared with a group that did nothing. Twelve people in each group, a modest improvement, and the whole of the exercise was climbing sixty steps.

Minute nine

Back in the hall, there's a second voice. Even if fifteen minutes does something for the heart, it wouldn't make you feel any better tonight. You need the full forty-five for that.

Three researchers, Hansen, Stevens and Coast, tested it. People came in on four occasions and either rested or rode an exercise bike at a moderate pace for ten, twenty or thirty minutes, filling in a mood questionnaire before and after. Vigour went up and fatigue and negative mood went down, and those improvements were there after ten minutes. Past twenty, mood improved no further at all. It's one laboratory study and I wouldn't build a cathedral on it. It does match the last time you walked fast to the station because you were late, and arrived eight minutes later warm, awake and slightly cheered.

The next finding explains why the hall gets it wrong. Matthew Ruby, Elizabeth Dunn and colleagues ran four studies with 279 adults, and people consistently underestimated how much they'd enjoy a session they were about to do, whatever the kind. When you imagine a session, the beginning dominates the picture, and the beginning is the worst part. Stiff, cold, reluctant. The researchers call this forecasting myopia. When they got people to think about the middle, predicted enjoyment went up, and so did their intention to exercise.

So at twenty to seven your mind supplies a picture of you, cold and stiff, starting. It doesn't show you at minute nine, warmed up and breathing well, with the meeting finally out of your head. The no you get back is a forecast, and this kind of forecast is known to run gloomy. Sometimes you really are exhausted. The person in the hall just isn't well placed to tell. The reliable test is to begin, with leave to stop after ten minutes if it's as bad as you feared.

It also helps that it doesn't have to hurt. Panteleimon Ekkekakis and colleagues reviewed 33 studies on how people feel at different intensities. Below roughly the point where breathing gets laboured and talking gets hard, most people feel better during exercise than before it. Above it, nearly everyone feels worse, and worse the harder they push. They argue that how exercise felt last time steers whether you do it again, whatever your reasoning says. My inference is that the harder you've made your full sessions, the easier they are to cancel. Ten minutes at a pace where you can talk but couldn't sing, the NHS test for moderate intensity, sits comfortably below that line. Harder exercise gives more per minute, so if you enjoy working hard, work hard. It just isn't a requirement for it to count.

The overhead goes the same way once you notice it belongs to the gym. A brisk walk needs no kit and, unless it's a hot day, no shower. Stairs need nothing. Ten minutes of squats, press-ups against the kitchen counter and stepping on to the bottom stair needs a space the size of a rug and two minutes of overhead.

And then the most practical point I have. You have very few ninety-minute blocks in a week, and everything you want to do fights over them. You have a great many ten-minute slots. While the dinner's in the oven. After the school drop-off and before you need to be anywhere. The second half of lunch. The gap between work and the evening, the very gap you stood in on Tuesday and called useless. I know of no study that counts people's free slots, so count your own tomorrow, including the ones that go on your phone. I'd be surprised if you found fewer than four.

If you'd feel ridiculous power-walking in office shoes, nobody can tell a person walking briskly for exercise from one who's late for something. And the thirty-four pounds is spent whether you go or not. It shouldn't decide what counts.

That leaves the standard. You'd rather do nothing and be honest than do ten minutes and pretend. So take the standard at its word and see what it produces.

Two people with the same busy life. The first plans three forty-five-minute sessions a week. Most weeks aren't good ones, and being generous, the plan delivers about one session a week over a typical month. In a bad month it's one a fortnight, with stretches of nothing at all. The second person has no plan worth the name and walks briskly for ten minutes six days out of seven, because ten minutes nearly always fits. Sixty minutes a week, good months and bad.

That's arithmetic on an example, so put your own four weeks into it. For many readers it comes out the same. The person with the high standard does less exercise, often much less, and spends long stretches at the bottom of the curve while the other one stands on its steepest part all year. A rule that says "properly or not at all" reliably produces not at all. It's like refusing to put five pounds into savings because you can't spare five hundred. Whatever you think of the principle, the account stays empty.

Nobody chooses the standard as an excuse. It feels like rigour. And if being a person who exercises matters to you, that person is someone who moves their body most days, year after year, whatever their trainers cost.

"But I want to get fit." That's fair, and partly right. Ten minutes of walking won't get you through a ten-kilometre race or build much muscle, and Arem's data showed benefits rising well past the minimum. Performance needs proper training for months, and the full session is the right tool. The threshold habit gives you neither, though. It loses the health on every cancelled day, and one session a fortnight trains nobody.

So ten minutes is a floor with no ceiling. Do the full session on days that hold it. Ten minutes is for the other days, and it keeps the routine alive so a good week finds you continuing. It quite often turns into twenty-five once you're warm. That only works if the deal is honest. If you secretly expect thirty, the resistance at twenty to seven will be to thirty. Ten is enough, and you're allowed to stop.

Shoes by the door

Decide this now, and write it down somewhere you'll see it. On any day I meant to exercise and can't do the full session, I do ten minutes, and it counts.

That's the rule. It has five parts.

  • Keep the plan. If you have full sessions planned, they're still the intention. Nothing here asks you to aim lower on the days that go well.
  • Ten minutes is the floor. On a planned day, once the block of time has gone, the choice is between the full session and ten minutes. Nothing has dropped off the list for the day. Doing ten on unplanned days too is a bonus, and the rule doesn't require it.
  • Choose your three. One outdoors, one indoors, one with some strength in it. Write them down, so that at twenty to seven you're picking from a short menu and not designing a session.
  • Count minutes. At the end of the week add up every minute you moved, in any form. One gym visit and four ten-minute walks is eighty-five minutes. Under the old scoring that was a failed week, one out of three.
  • No making up. A missed day isn't a debt, and you don't owe a double session on Thursday.

The last one matters more than it looks, because zeros spread. Tuesday fails, the week is now flawed, and Thursday stops being part of a plan you were proud of and becomes a salvage job. "This week's a write-off. I'll start fresh on Monday." A fresh start is clean, and all it costs is the rest of the week. Dieting researchers describe something close to this, where one biscuit on a strict diet leads to eating far more, because the day's ruined anyway. Applying it to exercise is my parallel.

What I can cite is Phillippa Lally's study of 96 volunteers building new daily habits, things like a run before dinner. They tracked how automatic the behaviour felt for twelve weeks, and the time it took varied from 18 days to 254. Missing one opportunity did not materially affect the process. A missed day didn't send anyone back to the start, provided they carried on.

The damage from a missed Tuesday is whatever you lost that Tuesday. The rest comes from deciding a flawed week isn't worth continuing. And a ten-minute walk at twenty to seven means Tuesday was never a zero in the first place. It was a short day, the week stays intact, and Thursday arrives as part of something worth keeping. I suspect that's a good part of what the ten minutes is worth.

Small things with no place in the diary tend not to happen, so give the ten minutes a place. In Lally's study what made a behaviour automatic was repeating it in a consistent context, so attach it to something that already happens every day. Straight out after the first cup of tea. The second half of lunch, after you've eaten. The moment you get home, before the coat comes off, because once it's off you're in for the evening. While the dinner's in the oven. Or get off a stop early, and the ten minutes is built into a journey you were making anyway.

A few of my own suggestions. Keep walking shoes where your anchor is, by the front door or under the desk. Work out a route that takes five minutes out and five back, once, so you never have to think about it. Have a wet-weather option, the stairs or the living-room floor, because a plan built for dry days skips the wet ones. And keep the gym bag packed. The full session is still there for the days that can hold it.

One of your three should be strength. The NHS says adults should do strengthening activities that work all the major muscle groups on at least two days a week. In most heads that means a gym, a written programme and an hour. I haven't reviewed research on very short strength sessions, so I'll stick to the NHS guidance, which sets the bar lower. It counts carrying heavy shopping, digging, lifting children, push-ups, sit-ups and resistance bands, at home or in a gym, and gives one rule. Work the muscles to the point where you need a short rest before repeating.

Here's an example, untested and no prescription. Stand up from a chair and sit down again, slowly and without your hands, until your legs want a rest. Press-ups against the kitchen counter, or the wall, until your arms want a rest. Step up on to the bottom stair and down, leading with each leg in turn. Carry two full shopping bags up and down the hall. Rest between each, go round twice, and it's done in the time the potatoes take to boil. If you have doubts about your joints, back or blood pressure, check with a GP or physiotherapist first, and stop if something hurts in a sharp or worrying way.

Plans in the form "when this happens, I'll do that" have good support. Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran pooled 94 tests and found they made people a good deal more likely to follow through. Here are three to adapt.

When I see the full session can't happen today, I'll pick one of my three and start within five minutes.

When I hear myself think "it's not worth it for ten minutes", I'll put my shoes on.

When I've had a zero, or a week of them, the next session is today and it's ten minutes.

The second is the one that matters. "It's not worth it" has cancelled more of your exercise than any meeting or train. You can't stop it arriving. You can decide in advance what it means.

I can't promise an outcome. I'd expect the first few sessions to feel slightly silly, with you back in the house almost before you left it and a voice saying that didn't count. Within a couple of weeks I'd expect your weekly minutes to be higher than in a long time, and the full sessions a bit more frequent, because you're no longer starting from cold. What I'm fairly confident of is fewer zeros.

Tuesday again

Some weeks it won't go to plan, and a few situations bend the rule.

  • When you're ill, the floor doesn't apply. Fever, a chest infection, anything that's put you in bed, rest. I won't offer a rule about colds. Use your judgment, ask a pharmacist or GP if unsure, and when you're better start again with ten minutes and nothing to make up.
  • If something hurts in a way that isn't the ordinary ache of effort, don't push through it for the rule's sake. A bad knee may still allow the counter press-ups, and a sore shoulder won't stop you walking. A pain that persists needs a GP or physiotherapist. With a long-term condition, get advice on what's suitable and apply the rule to that.
  • Chest pain, pain spreading to the arm, jaw, neck or back, or chest discomfort with sweating, sickness, light-headedness or breathlessness means stop and call 999. Don't finish the ten minutes first.
  • On holiday your anchors vanish, so choose one for the trip. Ten minutes' walk from the hotel door and back before breakfast works almost anywhere.

Then there's the week that falls apart. A crisis at work, a sick child, a funeral, and nothing happens at all. That's life. The old habit waits for a clean Monday and a clear diary. The day you notice you've had a run of zeros is the day for ten minutes, even if it's Thursday evening and you're in your work clothes.

And some evenings "it's not worth it" will arrive and you'll agree with it and sit down. One evening means nothing, for the new habit as much as the old plan. Ask what happened. Were you hungry? Was it raining with no wet-weather option, or had you left it too late? Adjust, and do ten minutes tomorrow.

If after a few months ten minutes is all you ever do, that's a perfectly good outcome for health. If you want more, lengthen one or two sessions a week and leave the rest at ten, or try the NHS's nine-week Couch to 5K plan if you'd like to run. Keep the floor whatever you add.

If you can't face any exercise at all, and it comes with weeks of low mood, poor sleep and loss of interest in things, the obstacle may be depression. Please see a GP. And if your trouble is feeling driven to exercise too much, this advice isn't meant for you, and a GP or Beat is the place to go.

Now picture Tuesday once more. It's an example of how it might go, and I'm not promising it.

The meeting runs over and the trains are a mess, and you get home at twenty to seven with dinner due at half past. The sum runs by itself in the hall, as it always has. Ten minutes each way, changing, a shower, fifteen minutes left. It isn't worth it.

You hear that last sentence and you know what it means now.

You don't take your coat off. You change into the shoes by the door, put the oven on to warm and go back out. Left at the gate, five minutes out along the route you worked out a fortnight ago, fast enough that you could talk but wouldn't want to sing. For two minutes it's exactly as unappealing as you expected, legs heavy, the day still in your head. Somewhere around the post box that changes. By the turn you're warm, and on the way back you notice you've stopped thinking about the meeting. You're in at eight minutes to seven, a little out of breath, and you start the dinner.

Twelve minutes, on a day that would have been nought. On Thursday, when the time is there, you go to the gym, and it doesn't feel like starting again. By Sunday the week is one full session and three short ones, seventy-nine minutes. It isn't the week you planned, and it's far better than the one you'd have had.

So choose your three ten-minute options today, and put a pair of shoes by the door. The next time the full session falls through, go out and do the ten minutes. It counts.