The 20-minute version
It's five to eleven on a Thursday morning and you've just sent off the quarterly figures, which you'd been dreading since Monday. You're working from home. You put the kettle on and take the lid off the tin, an old one with a Highland cow on it that lives on the worktop by the kettle. Two chocolate digestives, because you've earned them. They're gone before the tea is cool enough to drink.
At quarter past three you hit the wall. The screen has gone grey and your eyelids are heavy. There's a chocolate bar in the desk drawer, bought for this purpose, and you eat it in four bites while reading an email. For ten minutes or so you feel brighter. By four you're yawning and thinking about another coffee.
At ten to nine your sister Claire rings about your mum. The carers have changed their hours again, and Claire thinks you should be doing more, and says so. Twenty-five minutes later you come off the phone wrung out and slightly in the wrong. You bring the tin to the sofa. One biscuit, then another. By the end of the programme you've had four, and you couldn't describe the taste of the last two.
On the way to bed you put the tin back by the kettle and feel a bit disgusted with yourself. Tomorrow you'll do better.
Tomorrow is Friday, and on Fridays someone always brings pastries in.
You'd say you have a sweet tooth. You might say you're addicted to sugar, and only half mean it as a joke, and that you've got no willpower. What you probably wouldn't say is that you employed sugar three times today to do three different jobs. A reward at eleven. A pick-me-up at quarter past three. A comfort at nine. It's worth asking how well it did them.
My answer is that it did all three badly, and I'll give you the evidence, including the part that's true, which is that a sweet thing does give you a small lift for a few minutes. Nothing here asks you to give up sugar, pudding, birthday cake or chocolate. I don't think sugar is poison. This isn't a diet book and I make no claims about your weight. The change I'll suggest is simple to say. You go on eating sweet things with meals, because you like them, and you stop employing them in between.
If you'd like to see your own pattern first, try this for three days. Change nothing, but each time you eat something sweet between meals, note the time and which job it was doing. An hour later, note how you feel. Most people find the same few times and reasons every day, and that the hour-later note is less cheerful than they expected.
Three cautions.
If you have diabetes and use sugar to treat low blood sugar, nothing here applies to that. The NHS advice for a hypo is to eat or drink something that raises your blood sugar quickly, such as a small glass of fruit juice or a few jelly babies, and that comes first. If you have diabetes of any kind, talk to your diabetes team before changing how you eat.
If your eating sometimes feels out of control, this may be more than a habit. The NHS describes the main symptom of binge eating disorder as eating a lot of food in a short time and not being able to stop when full. Other signs are eating when not hungry, eating alone or secretly, and feeling depressed, guilty, ashamed or disgusted afterwards. If that sounds like you, the NHS advice is to see a GP as soon as you can. If you have or have had any eating disorder, please take advice from whoever is treating you before following anything that sets rules about food. The charity Beat runs helplines.
And if you're going through something hard at the moment, a bereavement or an illness or a very bad stretch at work, this may not be the month to change anything. The tin will keep.
Three minutes
If you recognised that Thursday, you may be feeling weak. Look at the odds first.
You were born liking sweetness. Newborn babies respond to a sweet taste with what looks very like pleasure, and for most of human history sweetness marked food that was safe and rich in energy, such as ripe fruit and honey. That liking now lives in a world where sweetness is the cheapest taste going, on sale at every till. The NHS says most adults and children in the UK eat too much free sugar, meaning sugar added to food and drink plus the sugar in honey, syrups and fruit juice. That's the national condition.
Then there's what you were taught. Sweets were for being good at the dentist and for a good school report. When you fell over and cried, somebody gave you a biscuit. Sweets came out at birthdays and Christmas, the best days of the year. By the age of seven you'd had hundreds of lessons in a simple code in which sweet things mean you've done well, or that things will be all right. You still read that code fluently. Each of the three jobs grows out of a real need, for your effort to be acknowledged, for energy when you're tired, for soothing when you're hurt. Nobody should be ashamed of any of them. The question is whether the tin meets them.
Many people with this habit call themselves sugar addicts, and it matters whether that's true. If you believe it, you'll expect withdrawal and a lifetime of vigilance, and you'll think the only option is giving sugar up completely. You don't want to, so you'll do nothing.
Margaret Westwater, Paul Fletcher and Hisham Ziauddeen, researchers at Cambridge, reviewed the evidence in 2016, setting what's known about drug addiction alongside what's been found for sugar. They concluded there's little evidence to support sugar addiction in humans. People don't develop tolerance to sugar the way they do to a drug, and they don't go through a withdrawal syndrome when they stop.
The rat studies you may have read about are real. Rats did develop something that looked like bingeing on sugar, but only when they were given it on a restricted schedule, a limited period each day after hours of going without. Rats with sugar freely available didn't binge. The reviewers put the behaviour down to the on-and-off access itself.
Look at that pattern again, deprivation followed by access. It's what a person sets up when they swear off sugar on Monday, hold out until Thursday and then open the tin. That step is mine. If bans followed by collapses are part of your history, the bans may have been feeding the problem, which is one reason I won't ask you to ban anything.
What's left, I think, is two ordinary things. A liking you were born with, and habit in the plain sense. You've eaten a biscuit with your eleven o'clock tea so many times that the kettle calls it up without your deciding anything. The wanting is real when you've just put the phone down on your sister. But it comes from a cue and a memory, and those fade when they stop being rehearsed. The worst you'd face is a few weeks of reaching for something that isn't there, the way you reach for a light switch in a house you've moved out of.
Now the lift, which is real. Michael Macht and Jochen Mueller, psychologists at Würzburg, put volunteers in a sad, happy or neutral mood with film clips and then gave them either chocolate or water. In a low mood, the chocolate helped and the water didn't. Only chocolate that tasted good did it, so the lift comes from the pleasure of the taste.
They also timed it. The improvement was gone after three minutes.
That's one laboratory and one kind of chocolate, so don't hold me to the number. You can check the shape of it yourself, though. The pleasure of a biscuit is in the first bite or two. A minute after the last mouthful you're back where you were, with a slight wish for another. That's why one becomes two. The second delivers a little less, and by the fourth on the sofa you're chasing something the biscuits stopped providing two biscuits ago. A reward, a pick-me-up and a comfort are all meant to change how the next hour feels. The tool you've been using works for about as long as it takes the kettle to boil.
Three jobs, badly done
Quarter past three. Of the three jobs, the pick-me-up sounds the most scientific. Sugar is energy, your blood sugar is low, you top it up.
Researchers have tested this many times. Konstantinos Mantantzis and colleagues gathered 31 studies with 1,259 participants in which people were given carbohydrate, mostly sugar, or a sugar-free placebo, and then had their mood measured. They found no positive effect of the sugar on any aspect of mood at any time point. The effects they did find went the other way. Within the first hour, the people who'd had sugar were more tired and less alert than the placebo group. Their paper asked whether there was a sugar rush or a sugar crash, and they concluded the rush is a myth.
Robert Thayer's small experiment from the 1980s shows what that looks like in an ordinary day. Eighteen volunteers, on different days, either ate a chocolate bar or walked briskly for ten minutes when they wanted a boost. After the chocolate they felt more energetic at first, and an hour later they were more tired than before, and more tense. After the walk they had more energy and less tension, and still did two hours later.
So at quarter past three you eat the bar and feel brighter for a short while. By four you're lower than you started, and the dip feels like proof you needed sugar, so you look in the drawer again. The tiredness gets blamed on the afternoon or your age, because nobody connects four o'clock with what they ate at quarter past three. Sugar really is fuel for a runner two hours into a race. At a desk you had lunch two hours ago. The afternoon low has other sources, a poor night, a heavy lunch, a stuffy room, hours of sitting still, and sugar touches none of them.
Eleven o'clock is the job that feels most innocent. Rewarding yourself for hard work sounds like self-respect.
Cat Taylor, Thomas Webb and Paschal Sheeran, psychologists at Sheffield, studied the reasons people give for eating something they'd meant not to. Deserving it came first on their list of six. In a further experiment they quietly prompted some volunteers to think in terms of such justifications before a chocolate taste test, and the prompted volunteers ate more. The effect was strongest in the people with the firmest intentions to limit what they ate. Good intentions seem to create a need for a good reason, and "I've earned it" is the best one going.
Look at it as a pay deal. You're the worker, the employer and the judge, so everything qualifies, the figures and the dull meeting and the ironing. You've never once turned yourself down. The prize is a biscuit from a tin you could open at any time without doing the figures, which makes it a poor sort of prize. It only feels like one because of the childhood code, from when adults controlled the supply. And three days of dread went into those figures, marked by something finished before the tea had cooled. Finishing a hard thing feels good by itself, given a moment. The biscuit takes that moment. You go straight from pressing send to the kettle, and the small glow of having done it gets eaten with the digestive.
Nine o'clock is the hardest, because the feeling behind it is the most real. You were hurt and tired, and what's wrong with your mum's care can't be fixed tonight.
The evidence here is kinder than you'd expect. Heather Scherschel Wagner, Traci Mann and colleagues at the University of Minnesota asked volunteers to name their own comfort food, then showed them sad film clips in the laboratory. Afterwards, on different visits, people got their comfort food, or a food they liked just as much but didn't find comforting, or a neutral snack, or, in two of the experiments, nothing at all.
Their moods improved after the comfort food. They improved just as much after the other foods. And just as much after nothing.
The researchers' summary was that people may be giving comfort food credit for mood effects that would have happened anyway. A bad feeling starts to ease within minutes whatever you do, and whatever you happened to be doing gets the credit. For years that was eating biscuits, so you've a large store of memories in which you felt dreadful, opened the tin, and felt somewhat better. Every one of them is accurate. In none of them did the tin cause the recovery. What it did add was a second bad feeling by bedtime, and an evening in which you didn't tell anyone how the call had made you feel.
If you're upset most evenings, the biscuits aren't your main problem. If a low mood has lasted for weeks, take that to a GP.
Some of your notes may fit none of the jobs. Nine o'clock, the television on, something sweet because that's what happens at nine. David Neal, Wendy Wood and colleagues gave cinema-goers free popcorn, some fresh and some a week old and stale. People who rarely ate popcorn at the cinema left the stale stuff. People with a strong cinema popcorn habit ate just as much stale as fresh, and said afterwards they hadn't liked it. In a meeting room with music videos, the same habitual eaters left the stale popcorn alone, and in the cinema, simply eating with their other hand was enough to make the taste matter again. The habit ran only in the setting where it was built, which makes this kind the easiest to change. Have your pudding at the table before the sofa, so the sweet part of the evening has already happened. Give your hands a cup of tea or a crossword for the first couple of weeks. And expect the reach at nine o'clock for a while, like patting your pocket for keys you've already put down.
Half a metre of table
Each biscuit is small. Add them up once, without alarm.
The NHS advises adults to have no more than 30 grams of free sugars a day, roughly seven sugar cubes. Sugar inside whole fruit, vegetables and milk doesn't count, and the NHS says there's no need to cut down on those. A single can of cola can contain as much as nine cubes. Packet labels give sugar in grams, and a cube is about four. Six biscuits and a chocolate bar between meals, that Thursday, would surprise me if they came to less than the whole day's thirty grams, before the cereal and the yoghurt and the sauce on dinner. Drinks count the same way. Two sugars in each of six cups of tea is twelve spoonfuls. Fruit juice counts too, because juicing releases the sugars, and the NHS suggests no more than 150 millilitres of juice and smoothies a day, with a meal.
The NHS's reasons are undramatic. Too much sugar can make you gain weight and can cause tooth decay. The point about teeth bears directly on this habit, because how often matters as well as how much. Each time you eat something sugary, the bacteria on your teeth produce acid for a while. Sugar with a meal is one attack. Sugar at eleven, at quarter past three and at nine is three more. The NHS advice is to limit sugary food and drink to mealtimes, which happens to be the change that takes away the three jobs.
You might fear what's left. Elevenses with just tea, an afternoon with nothing to look forward to, an apple eaten with resentment.
Count the pleasure the current arrangement delivers. Two digestives eaten standing in a minute. A chocolate bar in four bites over an email. Two biscuits on the sofa you didn't taste. Seven sweet things that day, and perhaps two mouthfuls properly enjoyed. Now think of the last sweet thing you really enjoyed, a pudding in a restaurant or a friend's homemade cake. You were sitting down and paying attention, and you can remember it now, which you can't say of any biscuit from the tin this month.
Paul Wise and colleagues at the Monell Chemical Senses Center had one small group cut the sugar in their diet by 40 per cent for three months while another carried on. Each month both groups rated the sweetness of the same puddings. By the third month the low-sugar group rated them about 40 per cent sweeter. Only thirteen completed the diet, the effect showed in puddings and not drinks, and they didn't come to like sweet things less. So I can't promise you'll lose your taste for sugar. When you eat less of it, you seem to taste it more.
Then the willpower. If there are biscuits in the house, you'll eat them. You've tried and failed, and you've concluded the fault is yours.
Jennifer Hunter, Gareth Hollands, Theresa Marteau and a colleague at Cambridge sat volunteers at a table with a bowl of unhealthy snack on it, either twenty centimetres away or seventy. Same table, a slightly longer reach. In the larger experiment, with 246 people, about seven in ten took some when the bowl was near and under six in ten when it was far. A task designed to use up people's self-control made no difference to the result. Fifty centimetres changed what people ate, however much self-control they had to spare.
Your tin sits beside a kettle you visit eight times a day, at the exact moment you've stopped work and are waiting. You don't need to want a biscuit. You only need not to resist, eight times a day, and sooner or later you won't. Put the tin in a high cupboard behind the flour and most of those biscuits wouldn't survive the deciding. The urge itself is softer than it feels, too. Adrian Taylor and colleagues at Exeter found that a fifteen-minute brisk walk lowered regular chocolate eaters' urge for chocolate, and in a follow-up, people who'd walked first ate about half as much from a bowl beside their computer as people who'd rested. Most urges, left alone, are gone in about the time it takes to make tea.
So here's the rule.
I eat sweet things with a meal, because I like them. Between meals, the tin stays shut.
With a meal means breakfast, lunch or dinner. Pudding after dinner fits, and so do a couple of squares of chocolate at the end of lunch, or jam on your toast. A meal comes round at its usual time whatever kind of day you've had, so it can't be a reward or a comfort. Because I like them means you choose it and taste it, on a plate, sitting down. If you don't want pudding on a given day, don't have it.
Between meals, the jobs go elsewhere.
- When you finish something hard, stop for ten seconds and look at what you did. Tell someone. A message to a colleague saying the figures have gone makes the achievement exist outside your own head. Then take a proper break, tea drunk hot somewhere that isn't your desk. For a month-long project, choose a reward you wouldn't otherwise have, a long lunch with a friend or an afternoon off.
- When the wall arrives, walk briskly for ten minutes, or climb the stairs a few times. Drink water, open a window. If you're actually hungry, eat real food, such as fruit, nuts, cheese and an oatcake, or toast. Whole fruit is squarely within the rule. If the wall comes every day, look at your lunch, your sleep and whether you've moved since nine.
- When you're upset, remember the feeling will ease by itself. Make a hot drink and let it. Better still, tell someone what was said and how it felt. Once you're calmer, spend ten minutes on the thing itself, and write down what you'd like to say to Claire.
Hunger between meals gets real food, always. The rule never asks you to go hungry. Occasions are occasions. A birthday, Christmas, a friend who's baked a cake and cut you a slice. An occasion has a date and other people in it, and "it's Thursday and I've had a day" isn't one.
A lapse is just a biscuit. You'll be at the tin at nine one evening. Enjoy it, put the lid on and carry on at the next meal. Don't skip tomorrow's pudding to make up for it. Bans and collapses feed each other, and guilt is how the cycle restarts.
Move the tin somewhere inconvenient, and stop buying sweet things in advance for the jobs. The chocolate bar in the drawer was a decision made on a full stomach in the supermarket. The person who opens the drawer at quarter past three is only carrying it out.
Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran pooled 94 tests of "when this happens, I'll do that" plans and found they made people a good deal more likely to follow through. When I finish a piece of work and think I've earned something, I'll send one message and take my tea outside. When I hit the wall, I'll walk for ten minutes before I decide anything else. When I put the phone down upset, I'll put the kettle on and sit with the feeling until the tea is drunk.
My own expectation is that for two or three weeks you'll reach for the tin and find it gone, uncomfortable for a minute each time. The eleven o'clock reach fades first. The evening one takes longest. I can't tell you what will happen to your weight, and I'd rather you didn't make that the test.
Lemon tart
Some sugar isn't yours. It's offered. Your neighbour's plate of biscuits, a colleague's box of chocolates, a friend saying "go on, keep me company" over the dessert menu.
Your neighbour wants you to feel welcome. That's met by your sitting down, accepting the tea and staying half an hour. She isn't counting biscuits. "Not for me, thanks, but I'd love another cup of tea" accepts her hospitality in full. Have a phrase or two ready, since the awkwardness is mostly in hesitating. "I'm all right, thank you, I've not long eaten." "They look lovely, I'll take one for after lunch." Don't give a reason. Once you say you're cutting down, people start talking about your eating, and some take it as a comment on theirs. If your friend has baked a cake for your visit, eat a slice and enjoy it. Your mother-in-law's trifle is about her. If she presses fudge on you for the journey home, take it, because what she's offering is affection.
Office cake presents itself as an occasion and happens too often to be one. Join in for a named celebration and leave the everyday supply on the filing cabinet alone. If someone at home keeps the tin full, ask them only to keep it out of your way. Most partners don't mind a different cupboard.
A few other cases. If you do long or hard exercise, sugar during a long run or ride is fuel for working muscle and outside all this. If you work nights, bring real food for four in the morning, when the vending machine is the only thing open. If you're pregnant, follow your midwife's advice on eating. Sugar-free versions may spare your teeth, and the NHS does suggest sugar-free drinks as a swap, but they keep the jobs going with a different ingredient. Treat sweet-tasting things as sweet things for the rule. In a really bad stretch, the first weeks after a bereavement or while someone's in hospital, leave the rule alone and eat what gets you through.
If eating starts to feel out of control, or rules about food start to take over, stop here. Eating large amounts in secret, feeling unable to stop, or growing anxious and rigid about what you eat are reasons to see a GP. A stricter rule won't help. Beat's helplines are there for exactly this.
It's a Thursday some months on. At five to eleven you press send on the quarterly figures, lean back and look at the sent message for a moment. They were a pig this quarter, and they're done. You message your colleague Priya to say they've gone and you never want to see a pivot table again, and she sends back a row of clapping hands.
The Highland cow tin is in the cupboard over the fridge now, with shortbread in it for when your dad visits. For the first fortnight your hand went to the empty space by the kettle every time. It doesn't now. You take your tea out to the back step and drink it in the cold with your coat on.
At quarter past three the wall arrives, as it still does most days. You walk to the postbox and round by the park, twelve minutes, and when you sit back down the screen makes sense again. The drawer has pens in it.
At ten to nine Claire rings. The carers have changed the hours again, and she still thinks you should be doing more. You come off it wrung out, make a cup of tea and sit on the sofa feeling rotten. After a while you tell Rob what she said. He says Claire is frightened and it comes out as blame, which you knew, but it helps to hear. Then you write down two things you could offer to take on and one you're going to say no to. You'll ring her back on Saturday.
You did have pudding today. A slice of the lemon tart left from Sunday, after dinner, at the table, with a fork. It was sharp and sweet and very good, and you'll remember it.
Two weeks ago, after a dreadful day, you ate most of a packet of chocolate fingers in the car outside the supermarket. The next day you had breakfast, lunch and dinner as usual and didn't think much more about it.
Go and move the tin. Put it somewhere you'd need a chair to reach, and then put the kettle on.