The 20-minute version
It's twenty to seven on a Wednesday evening and the doorbell goes. You're on the sofa with your feet up. You put a hand on the arm, push, and make a noise as you stand, somewhere between a grunt and a sigh. You've been making it for a year or two without deciding to.
The first three steps are the odd ones. Your hips feel borrowed, your lower back has set in the shape of the sofa, and one knee takes a moment to agree to bend. By the front door you're walking normally. It's a parcel for next door. You take it in, go back and sit down.
You're fifty-four, and you have an explanation for this. You're getting older. Your father made exactly that noise getting out of his armchair at about your age. When your grandson Alfie wants you down on the floor with his train track, getting down is fine and getting up needs a hand on the coffee table. Around three every afternoon your energy goes, and you get through to five on tea and whatever's in the drawer.
Here's the rest of that Wednesday, which you haven't thought about because nothing in it was worth noticing. Thirty-five minutes in the car each way. The desk from half past eight until five, with a sandwich eaten there because there was a lot on, and a meeting from two until half past three. Perhaps forty minutes on your feet all day, for the kettle, the printer and the loo. Dinner at the table, then the sofa from seven. By bedtime that comes to a little over thirteen hours of sitting in a waking day of sixteen and a half. When the doorbell rang you'd been still since five, apart from the walk from the car to the house.
Nobody chose any of it. Each hour came attached to a drive, a job, a meal or a programme. The NHS says many adults in the UK sit for more than seven hours a day, so a high number makes you typical.
There's a woman at your work called Denise, who's sixty-one. She walks a circuit of the industrial estate every lunchtime in all weathers, and she takes the stairs. You've always filed her under "one of those people".
Before you read on, work out your own tally for an ordinary working day. Add up the car, the desk, the table and the sofa, and note the longest stretch you sat without standing. Most people find the total is two or three hours more than they'd have guessed.
My case is that a good share of what you're calling age is the effect of not moving. Age only runs one way. The effects of not moving can be reversed, and there's evidence for that at fifty and at ninety. The practical part is small. You get up every half hour, and you walk for ten minutes a day. Nothing here asks you to stop sitting. The trouble is long unbroken stretches, and days with almost nothing else in them.
Four cautions, and please don't skip them.
- If you haven't been active for some time, or you have a medical condition or any concerns, the NHS advice is to speak to a GP before you start exercising. Nothing here is strenuous, but the advice still applies, and a GP can tell you what suits your heart, your joints and your medicines.
- If you've been tired for a few weeks and don't know why, or it's affecting your daily life, see a GP. The same goes if you're tired and you've also lost weight, your mood has changed, or you've been told you gasp, snort or choke in your sleep. Tiredness has many causes, and I'm dealing with one.
- If you get chest pain, stop what you're doing. The NHS says to call 999 for sudden chest pain or discomfort that doesn't go away, pain that spreads to your arm, neck, jaw, stomach or back, or chest pain with sweating, sickness, light-headedness or shortness of breath.
- If you have ME, also called chronic fatigue syndrome, or you're living with long Covid, most of this doesn't apply to you. Your tiredness isn't the kind I'm describing, and pushing through it can make you worse. There's more on that near the end, along with a note for readers who use a wheelchair or can't stand.
Three weeks in bed
Part of the age story is true. Muscle gets harder to keep, recovery slows, and joints that have done fifty years of work show it. If I told you age had nothing to do with how you feel, you'd be right to stop reading.
The difficulty is that age and stillness arrived together, so there's been no way to tell them apart.
A small, famous study manages it. In the summer of 1966, researchers in Dallas put five healthy twenty-year-old men to bed for three weeks. They weren't ill. The point was to see what complete rest does to a fit young body, measured by maximal oxygen uptake, the most oxygen your body can use when it's working flat out. It dropped sharply. Thirty years later Darren McGuire, Benjamin Levine and colleagues found the same five men, now fifty, and measured them again. Three decades of ordinary adult life had taken 11 per cent off their 1966 level, less than the three weeks in bed had. The researchers' own summary was that three weeks of bed rest had a more profound effect on the men's physical work capacity than three decades of ageing. At sixty, the total decline over forty years had reached 27 per cent. The drop after the bed rest had been 26.
Forty years of living and three weeks of lying still came out about level.
It was five men, and bed rest is a far stronger dose of stillness than a desk job. Age did show in the numbers, especially after fifty. What the study shows is scale. People assume age is the big force and inactivity a minor one. In these men it ran the other way.
Older bodies respond just as fast. Patrick Kortebein and colleagues asked eleven healthy volunteers, average age sixty-seven, to stay in bed for ten days. Thigh strength fell by 13 per cent and aerobic capacity by 12. Afterwards, free to move as they liked, they moved less than before.
Here's how I read it. Your body maintains what gets used and lets go of what doesn't, the way a council cuts a bus route nobody rides. A thirteen-hour day isn't bed rest. It's a diluted version of the same instruction, given daily for years. So when you make that noise at twenty to seven, you're fifty-four, and you've also been still since five o'clock and largely still for years. You can't change the first. The second is, I think, the larger share, and it works in both directions. If you've ever had a fortnight far busier on your feet than usual, a walking holiday or a house move, you may remember three sore days and then a second week of feeling looser than you had in months. Age alone wouldn't have answered to a fortnight.
Then the tiredness. At half past five you're finished, and the obvious cure is to sit down. After a day laying paving slabs that would be exactly right. But your body sat all day. Your mind may have worked hard, but your legs have had about thirteen hours of rest already. An evening on the sofa after a desk day doesn't refresh you. You go to bed as flat as you were at six.
In the 1980s the psychologist Robert Thayer asked eighteen volunteers to try two things on different days. Some days they ate a chocolate bar. Other days they walked briskly for ten minutes. After the walk they reported more energy and less tension, still there two hours later. After the snack they felt a lift, and an hour on they were more tired and more tense than before.
It's a small study. Timothy Puetz and colleagues pooled trials that put inactive people on exercise programmes, and overall the exercisers reported more energy and less fatigue. In the trials with a placebo comparison, though, they did no better, so some of the lift may be expectation. The NHS lists not getting much exercise among the common causes of tiredness, alongside poor sleep and stress.
My way of putting it is that your sense of energy works less like a fuel gauge and more like a setting, adjusted to whatever's been asked of you lately. You feel tired, so you sit, so your body prepares for nothing, so you feel more tired, and after a few years the only explanation left is your age. Next time the slump arrives at three, walk briskly round the building for ten minutes before you reach for the drawer, and see how four o'clock feels.
The stiffness comes with a picture of joints as worn hinges. Test it against the front door. You stood up stiff and three steps later you were less stiff, and a worn hinge doesn't free up after three swings. Muscles held short across the front of your hips resist being lengthened in a hurry, a joint that hasn't moved for two hours is briefly less ready to, and it all reverses within a minute. Notice when yours is worst. First thing in the morning, after a long drive, at the end of a film. If stiffness tracked wear it would be worst after use. Yours is worst after stillness.
Arthritis is real, and osteoarthritis is common from middle age on. Even so, the NHS calls exercise one of the most important treatments for it, whatever your age or fitness. Nor has the chair wrecked your back. Darren Roffey and colleagues reviewed the research on sitting at work and low back pain and found strong and consistent evidence of no association. Your body has adapted to stillness, and objects for a moment when asked to move.
Some stiffness does need a doctor. See a GP about back pain that hasn't improved after a few weeks, stops you doing your day-to-day activities, or is worse at night, and about joints that are swollen, hot or red, or morning stiffness that lasts much longer than half an hour. Get urgent help if back pain comes with numbness or tingling around your genitals or bottom, loss of bladder or bowel control, or weakness or numbness in both legs. Ordinary sitting stiffness eases within a minute or two of moving about.
Anything that isn't the chair
You may have decided this isn't about you. You swim twice a week, or do parkrun on Saturdays.
You're far better off than someone who does nothing. The two things are just more separate than they look. In 2016 Ulf Ekelund and colleagues pooled studies that had followed more than a million people for up to eighteen years, knowing both how long each sat and how active they were. Activity did cancel out sitting, at a price. In the most active quarter, sitting more than eight hours a day carried no detectable extra risk of dying during the follow-up. But that quarter was doing about sixty to seventy-five minutes of moderate activity every day, four or five times what the guidelines ask. Below that, sitting mattered. People who moved least and sat more than eight hours had a death rate 59 per cent higher than those who sat little and moved a lot.
These are observational studies, so take the figures as the best estimate available. If you had to choose, moving a lot beats sitting little. Keep swimming.
The NHS draws the practical line. You can hit your weekly activity target and still be at risk of ill health if you spend the rest of the time sitting or lying down. Its guidelines ask for 150 minutes of moderate activity a week and, separately, for breaking up long periods of not moving. Tuesday's class doesn't reach back into Wednesday afternoon.
If you don't exercise at all, this next part is for you. The biggest gains are at the bottom.
Newer studies give people a motion sensor for a week, which records movement nobody would call exercise. Ekelund and colleagues pooled eight of them, more than 36,000 adults with an average age of about sixty-three. Over around six years, the second quarter by movement had about half the death rate of the least active quarter, and further steps up brought smaller gains. Illness makes people move less, which probably flatters the gap.
Amanda Paluch and colleagues pooled fifteen step-count studies of about 47,000 adults, noting there's little evidence behind the famous ten thousand. The quarter who walked least took about 3,500 steps a day. The next quarter took about 5,800 and had a death rate 40 per cent lower. That gap is roughly twenty-five minutes of walking spread across a day.
Emmanuel Stamatakis and colleagues studied more than 25,000 sensor-wearing adults who did no sport or exercise at all. Some still had short bursts of hard effort in ordinary life, taking stairs fast or hurrying for a bus. Those with three bursts a day, a minute or two each, had a death rate 38 to 40 per cent lower over seven years than those with none. None of them would have called themselves the exercising type.
For your body, the alternative to sitting is anything else. The NHS list of light activity for older adults includes getting up to make a cup of tea.
That leaves the part that sounds too small to matter, getting up for a minute or two every half hour. Here, for once, researchers could assign the movement and measure what it did.
David Dunstan and colleagues in Melbourne brought nineteen overweight adults aged forty-five to sixty-five into the laboratory on three separate days. On one day they sat for seven hours straight. On the other two they got up every twenty minutes and walked on a treadmill for two minutes, slowly one day and briskly the other. After two hours each had a sugary, fatty test drink, and the researchers tracked blood sugar and insulin for the next five. On the unbroken day blood sugar rose higher and stayed up longer. With breaks, the rise was about a quarter smaller, and the insulin needed to bring it down about a quarter lower. The slow walk did about as well as the brisk one.
Nineteen people, single days, nothing about heart attacks or lifespan. But two minutes of easy movement changed what their bodies did with sugar for hours. The usual explanation is that your largest muscles are in your legs and backside, and the chair switches them off. Idle muscle takes very little sugar from the blood.
Two minutes every half hour across a nine-hour working day is thirty-six minutes on your feet.
Every half hour
You keep two lists without writing them down. One holds what you do without thinking. The other holds what you've quietly stopped doing, and for some years items have been moving across. The stairs at the multi-storey became the lift. The far end of the car park became circling for a nearer space. The floor with Alfie became something you weigh up. Each went because it had got slightly uncomfortable, and each one dropped took away some of the movement that kept you able to do it. Further off, the strength you have at seventy-five and eighty decides whether you can get out of a chair alone and stay in your own home, and it's built or lost in the decades before.
When the Dallas researchers found their five men at fifty, they put them on six months of walking, jogging and cycling. Oxygen uptake rose by 14 per cent, back to where it had been before the bed rest. In the researchers' words, one hundred per cent of the decline in aerobic power over thirty years was reversed by six months of training. None regained his peak from twenty, because age had taken that. What came back was the loss that three decades of desk life had laid on top. Five men, so treat it as a demonstration.
It works far later than fifty. Maria Fiatarone and colleagues ran a trial in a nursing home with a hundred frail residents, average age eighty-seven, the oldest ninety-eight. Half did resistance training for their legs three times a week for ten weeks. Their strength more than doubled, an average gain of 113 per cent, against 3 per cent in the untrained group, and they began moving about more of their own accord. If muscle still answers at eighty-seven, it hasn't stopped answering at fifty-four.
The rule below is gentler than training, so this is my own expectation. Less stiffness on standing within a week or two. A softer afternoon slump over a few weeks. Over a few months, some things drifting back to the first list. It won't make you fit or change your weight, and I claim nothing about either.
Here's the rule.
I get up every half hour, and I walk for ten minutes every day.
- Every half hour means every half hour of sitting. Stand and move for a minute or two. Another room, a flight of stairs, the window and back. Then sit again if you like. The interval is my choice. Dunstan used twenty minutes, and nobody knows the ideal.
- Use a timer for the first fortnight, because nobody notices time passing in a chair. Restart it each time you sit. After a couple of weeks most people have a rough sense of it.
- The break only needs to be upright and moving. Slow did as well as brisk in Dunstan's laboratory.
- The ten-minute walk is separate, and brisk. Brisk means you could talk but not sing, which is the NHS test for moderate activity. After lunch or after dinner both suit it. If brisk is beyond you for now, walk at the pace you can manage and let it build.
- Evenings and weekends count.
- A missed break is just a missed break. You'll look up and find it's been an hour and a half. Stand up then. Don't make up for it, and don't write the day off.
Work is where most of the tally sits, and where getting up feels most like slacking. Sitting still at a screen is what diligence looks like in most offices, though the answer to a problem often turns up on the walk to the kettle.
The best evidence I know comes from a large British trial. Charlotte Edwardson and colleagues worked with 756 desk-based council employees, with whole offices assigned by lot. Some got a programme to help people sit less, with coaching, prompts, and bins and printers moved further away. Some got that plus desks that could be raised for standing. The rest carried on. A year later the programme alone had cut sitting by about twenty-two minutes a day, and with the desks by just over an hour. Both groups reported small improvements in stress, wellbeing and vigour. The published summary mentions no harm to work performance, and no boost either.
Fit the breaks into what the work already contains.
- Take phone calls standing.
- Use a smaller mug. You'll refill it more often, and the refills will look after the other end of the process too.
- In a long meeting, say you'll stand at the back for a while because it helps your back. Somebody often joins you.
- Eat lunch away from your desk, even if it's ten minutes on a bench.
If your employer offers a standing desk, take it. In the Edwardson trial it roughly tripled the effect. But standing motionless for three hours swaps one fixed position for another, and buying one can feel like the job's done. The desk arrives, your feet hurt by Friday, and by the second month it's in the down position with a plant on it.
The evening is a different animal.
At work the phone goes and someone wants you in another room. On the sofa the remote, your drink and your phone are all in reach, one episode runs into the next, and it all comes straight after the biggest meal of the day. In Ekelund's million-person data, three or more hours of television a day went with a higher death rate in every group but the most active. I'd hold that loosely, but dinner followed by three hours of stillness is a home version of Dunstan's worst condition. So keep the programmes and break the sit. Walk for ten minutes after dinner, before you sit down at all, because once you're down it's hard to get up. Stand between episodes. The countdown is there precisely so that you won't. Iron in front of the programme, which may be the only good thing anyone has said about ironing. And tell whoever you watch with, or your getting up will look like a comment on their choice of programme.
If you're retired, that evening may be your whole day. The NHS says people over sixty-five spend ten hours or more a day sitting or lying down. Without an office to interrupt you, the prompts have to come from you, from nine in the morning.
Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran pooled 94 tests of "when this happens, I'll do that" plans and found they made people a good deal more likely to follow through. Here are three to adapt. When the timer goes mid-task, I'll finish the sentence I'm on and stand. When I put my knife and fork down after dinner, I'll put my shoes on. When an episode ends, I'll stand before the next one starts.
Give the rule a month to settle, then add strength. The NHS asks adults of every age to do muscle-strengthening activities on at least two days a week, and strength decides the stairs, the floor and the shopping. You don't need a gym. The NHS website has routines that use your own body weight, and its list includes carrying heavy shopping and heavy gardening. If you haven't done anything like it for years, this is where the advice to talk to a GP first applies most.
Your calves and hips may ache a little in the first few days. It should be mild and gone within the week. Pain that's sharp or persists, or any of the warning signs above, is a reason to stop and get advice.
Wednesday again
Some days won't fit the rule, and some bodies need it changed.
If you drive for a living, the Highway Code recommends a break of at least fifteen minutes every two hours. Spend it on your feet, walking round the services. If your working day is in a cab, the edges of the day carry the weight, so walk at the start and end of a shift and keep the evening rule in full. If you work under a headset and a timer, stand for calls if the lead allows, spend every scheduled break on your feet, and consider asking a manager or union representative about sit-stand positions.
If you use a wheelchair or can't stand, what your body responds to is muscles working, and you can get that in a chair. The NHS publishes fitness advice for wheelchair users and a set of sitting exercises, and says its adult guidelines suit disabled adults. Break up long stillness with a couple of minutes of whatever movement is available to you. A physiotherapist can help you work out what.
If you have arthritis, short and gentle movement is about the easiest exercise there is. A GP or physiotherapist can advise, and in many areas you can refer yourself to NHS musculoskeletal services. Don't push through sharp pain.
If you have ME or long Covid, I'll repeat this because well-meaning people may press the rule on you. The NHS says graded exercise therapy, which raises activity step by step, is not recommended for people with ME. Its guidance is built around managing your energy with professionals who know the condition. Please follow that guidance.
With a heart condition, high blood pressure, diabetes or another long-term condition, ask your GP or specialist nurse first, because the details depend on your medicines. More activity can lower blood sugar if you take insulin or certain tablets. If you feel dizzy when you stand, stand slowly and pause, and mention it to a GP or pharmacist if it happens often, since medication is sometimes the cause. If you're pregnant, the NHS says its adult guidelines still apply, and your midwife can advise.
When you've got flu, rest. When work goes frantic and the rule falls apart for three days, start again at the next half hour. Nothing's lost that a week won't put back.
It's a Wednesday some months on, and the doorbell goes at twenty to seven.
You're not on the sofa. You got in at half past five, changed your shoes and walked round the block, which takes eleven minutes and has become the point where the working day ends. Now you're at the worktop slicing onions. From outside, the day looked much the same. Same drive, same desk. But you took two calls on your feet, and you had your sandwich on the bench by the car park with Denise, who turns out to be good company. At the two o'clock meeting you stood at the back, and the head of department came and stood next to you. Your tally would still come to about ten and a half hours. The longest sit was forty minutes. It used to be two and a half hours.
You walk to the door without noticing the walk. Another parcel for next door.
You're still fifty-four. Your left knee is still the less reliable one, and on Saturday you watched three episodes in a row before you remembered. The slump still visits at three. Now you take the stairs to the far printer, and by twenty past it's mostly gone.
But the noise has stopped, and you didn't notice it stop. On Sunday Alfie ran off to find the bridge piece for the train track, and you got up off the floor and followed him, and only afterwards realised you hadn't reached for the coffee table. Most of the aches you'd been reading as news about the years ahead were news about the last two hours.
If you've read this far sitting down, stand up. Walk to the furthest room of wherever you are, and back. Then set a timer for thirty minutes.