The 20-minute version
It's a Thursday. The meeting at three went badly, the train sat outside the station for twenty minutes, and you get in at ten to seven with your shoulders somewhere near your ears. Bag down, shoes off. You open the fridge, pour a glass of white wine and take the first mouthful standing at the counter.
You breathe out.
It's the first proper breath since about half past two. By the time the onions are in the pan the radio's on, and by the time you sit down to eat, the meeting has shrunk to something for tomorrow. If somebody told you the wine had done nothing, you'd think they'd never had a day like yours. You felt it work. It took one mouthful.
I'm not going to tell you that you imagined it. What interests me is the timing, because alcohol doesn't work that fast. In one small study, fifteen men drank beer, wine or vodka and tonic on an empty stomach, and their blood alcohol peaked at about 36 minutes for the vodka, 54 for the wine and 62 for the beer. With food it's slower still. Some alcohol reaches the blood within minutes, but nothing like enough to drop your shoulders at the first sip.
So something else did that. The front door shut behind you, your shoes came off, nobody in that kitchen can ask you for a revised forecast, and in the act of pouring you told yourself the working day was over. That last one does most of the work, I think. The pour is a small ceremony, your way of announcing that you're off duty, and your shoulders respond to the announcement. The wine reaches your bloodstream half an hour later, adds a mild sedation to someone who has already relaxed, and takes the credit for the lot.
The title overstates this, and I'd sooner say so now. Alcohol is a drug with real effects. "The drink did less of that than you think, and sent you part of the cost the next day" is more accurate. It wouldn't fit on a cover.
I won't ask you to stop before you've finished reading, or assume you'll never drink again. Where this goes is an experiment, a month without alcohol in which you do everything you'd normally drink for, and then a decision that's yours.
Three cautions first. The first matters most.
If your body has become dependent on alcohol, stopping suddenly can be dangerous. The NHS says withdrawal symptoms begin within 6 to 12 hours of the last drink. The milder ones include anxiety after waking, sweating, a tremor in the hands, a racing heartbeat, trouble sleeping, and feeling or being sick in the morning. If you get any of these when you go without, or you need a drink in the morning to feel steady, see your GP or a local alcohol service before you cut down or stop. They can arrange medicine that makes withdrawal safe. Hallucinations, confusion, severe shaking or a seizure are an emergency, and the NHS advice is to call 999. None of this was written as a treatment for dependence. Medical help comes first.
Alcohol interacts with a long list of medicines, so if you take anything regularly, ask your pharmacist where you stand. Nothing here is a reason to change or stop a prescribed medicine.
If you drink partly to manage anxiety or low mood, both are treatable and deserve better than wine. If you're pregnant or trying to be, the NHS advice is not to drink at all, and your midwife or GP can help if that's hard. A GP, an alcohol service, a support group and, for dependence, prescribed medicines can all be used alongside what follows.
The button at the crossing
Nobody keeps doing something for years that does nothing for them.
The glass seems to pay you in several ways. Relaxation first, the ten to seven glass. Confidence second, the sense that you're warmer company with a drink in you. Then fun, sleep, reward, belonging and taste. To test any of them, ask one question. What else changed when I picked up the glass? Whatever the answer covers belongs to the setting, and the glass has been taking it.
It gets away with it because it's in your hand, and because you have no comparison. If you've drunk at every wedding and every Friday since you were eighteen, you have no idea what you're like at a wedding without it. Every good evening of your adult life had a drink in it. So did every row in a taxi and every night you talked too much, and it never gets credited with those.
You know the costs, from money to the long-term risks the NHS lists, including liver disease, several cancers, and anxiety and depression. The quiet one is how it narrows an evening. After the second glass you won't drive anywhere or start anything that needs attention, and because it happens nightly it stops looking like a cost and starts looking like what evenings are.
Start with relaxation. Alcohol is a sedative, so the belief begins from something true. In 2019 a psychologist named Bresin pooled 52 laboratory studies in which people had alcohol or a placebo and then faced something stressful, often a speech to strangers. Those who'd had alcohol did feel less bad afterwards, by a small to moderate amount. Measured as the rise in distress from before to after, the difference wasn't statistically reliable, and he called the evidence mixed. In the kitchen the relief feels total and instant. In the lab, with the setting held equal, the drug's share is modest. My reading is that the gap is the setting. Nobody in a lab has just finished work.
The drug's part leans on what you're doing, too. In 1990 Claude Steele and Robert Josephs described alcohol myopia, a narrowing of attention to whatever's in front of you. With cooking or a film or company to absorb you, the narrowed attention goes there and the meeting fades. Alone at the table with the problem, it narrows onto the problem, and that's the evening the second glass makes things darker.
You may have tried a night without and felt twitchy. The ceremony was missing, you spent the evening watching yourself, and there may have been a rebound from the night before. One evening tells you as little as one night in a new bed.
What relaxes you at ten to seven is stopping. You need a way to stop, so keep the ceremony. It doesn't need alcohol in it, because the alcohol hadn't arrived yet when it worked. Try it tonight if you're drinking. Shoes off, something cold in a decent glass, sit down, radio on. Pour the wine ten minutes later if you still want it, and notice how much of the relaxation had already turned up.
Now a party.
A friend is turning forty in the function room above a pub. Sixty people, and you know four. You stand for a moment with that feeling of having too many arms. You go to the bar. Twenty minutes and one drink later you're talking to somebody's cousin about campervans and enjoying it.
In 2001 Abrams and colleagues had 61 people with diagnosed social phobia give a speech, have a drink, and give another. Some had alcohol, some a soft drink they knew was soft, and some a placebo they were told was alcoholic. Anxiety fell more with alcohol than with the soft drink. It also fell more with the placebo, and the authors concluded that drug and belief add together. Belief alone brought clinical anxiety down. Those people had the confidence in them already. They needed to think it had been supplied.
In 2013 Laurent Bègue and colleagues mixed up who got alcohol and who was told they had, then had everyone give a short speech and rate how attractive, bright and funny they'd been. People who believed they'd been drinking rated themselves higher, whatever was in the glass. Twenty-two independent judges watched the recordings, and the boost had no relation to how people had performed. Believing you'd had a drink made you feel funnier. It didn't make you funnier.
One study cuts against me. In 2012 Michael Sayette's team put 720 young social drinkers into groups of three strangers. The groups given alcohol smiled more genuinely and talked more easily than groups on a placebo or a known soft drink. Here the drug did something belief didn't. Yet asked afterwards how bonded they felt, the drinkers averaged 7.22 and the people who knew they were on cranberry juice averaged 7.07, too close to be reliable.
What you've been calling confidence looks to me like a quieter version of the voice that asks how you're coming across. The first twenty minutes of any party are the worst of it, for drinkers and drivers alike, and time and the drink arrive together. If every party since you were seventeen has started at the bar, you've never practised walking into a room without one. The skill is yours. You've been signing someone else's name on it.
You can still feel it working, of course. There's a warmth in the second glass no amount of taking your shoes off will produce. Alcohol sedates you, narrows your attention and loosens your judgement of yourself, and none of that is belief. But every item on that list is a reduction. The lowered self-monitoring that gets you talking to the cousin is the same one that has you telling the campervan story twice and makes a third drink look sensible.
And it shrinks. Tolerance means a smaller effect from the same amount after repeated use, and a 2021 review from the US National Institutes of Health called it a critical yet understudied factor in alcohol addiction. There was a time one glass made itself felt. If you drink most days, the warmth now arrives during the second, so the real part of the effect is smaller for you than for a friend who drinks twice a month. Yet the ten to seven glass works as well as it ever did. The setting and the belief were always doing that job, and they don't wear off.
Four in the morning
You surface at four with a dry mouth and a busy mind, turning over an email you haven't answered. You blame stress, or age, or the neighbour's security light. Hardly anyone lying awake at four thinks back to a glass of red at ten.
That glass is the one plenty of people would fight for. You have it, you get drowsy, you're gone in minutes.
In 2013 a team at the London Sleep Centre reviewed the studies of alcohol and sleep in healthy volunteers. At all doses it shortened the time to fall asleep and deepened the first half of the night. At all doses it also disrupted the second half, and at moderate and high doses there was less dreaming, or REM, sleep overall. You're awake for the part that helps. The cost lands when you're in no state to notice causes, and follows you home at ten to seven.
Without the nightcap you may lie awake at first. A few unsettled nights after stopping are commonly reported, though I haven't found a study that puts a number on it, and after years of a sedative you're out of practice at falling asleep unaided. If your sleep is still poor after several weeks without alcohol, see your GP, because something else is going on and it can usually be helped.
Then the day after an ordinary evening, two or three glasses, nothing anyone would remark on. You're a little tired. There's a faint unease with nothing to attach itself to, so it attaches itself to that email. If you noticed it at all, you'd call it Tuesday.
In 2000 Matt Kushner and two colleagues reviewed why anxiety and alcohol problems so often turn up together, and proposed, tentatively, that a drink's short-term relief and the longer-term anxiety from regular drinking can feed each other in a cycle. Their review concerned disorders and heavy use. Applying a fainter version to ordinary drinking is my interpretation. Give the brain a sedative every evening and it adjusts by turning itself up slightly. Researchers call this an opponent process. When the alcohol has gone, the turned-up setting lingers, and you feel it as edginess, light sleep and that unattached unease.
So you arrive in the kitchen carrying two things. One is the day. The other is what last night's wine left behind, which has been raising your idle speed since four. The glass settles both, the day takes the blame for all of it, and the glass gets the credit for fixing a tension it helped to make.
Your job is real, though. So are your children, your money and your mother's health, and stopping drinking won't make them go away. My claim is only that some of your evening tension is left over from the night before, and you can't tell how much while you're drinking most days. For a regular drinker who isn't dependent, I'd guess two or three weeks without would show you your own baseline. That's my estimate.
Some of what the glass is for is entirely legitimate. A line under the day. A reward for a day spent doing what other people wanted. Relief when things are bad. The trouble is having one supplier for all of it, and a supplier that takes a little off tomorrow. Split the jobs up. The line under the day is the ceremony, with anything cold in a good glass. The reward can be food you like, a bath, a programme saved for the purpose, or the good chair and twenty minutes in which nobody may speak to you. The glass is quicker than any of these and needs no planning. Convenience is a genuine advantage, and the only one I can find.
Relief is where the evidence turns sobering. In a large American survey of over 43,000 adults, re-interviewed three years later, Rosa Crum and colleagues found that people who drank to ease low mood had about three times the odds of becoming dependent. Using the same survey, Robinson and colleagues found that people with anxiety disorders who medicated themselves with alcohol or drugs had between two and a half and five times the odds of developing a substance problem. These studies are observational and can't prove cause, but the direction is consistent. Of all the reasons to drink, needing it is the one most strongly tied to trouble later.
If anxiety or low mood is what you've been treating with wine, both respond to proper treatment. Start with your GP. In England you can also refer yourself to NHS talking therapies without seeing a GP first, and social anxiety is on their list.
Lime and soda
The evenings at home are often the easy part. The hard part is other people.
- Being asked. It happens once, usually in the first ten minutes. "I'm having a month off." No apology, then ask them something about themselves. A long justification invites a debate. A glass with anything in it ends most of the interest before it starts.
- Being pushed. In my view, someone who badly needs you to drink is usually asking a question about their own drinking. You don't have to answer it.
- Rounds. "I'll get my own tonight." Or buy yours and include yourself at soft drink prices.
- Feeling awkward. Richard de Visser and colleagues followed 857 people who signed up for Dry January. Six months later they were drinking less and felt more able to turn a drink down, including those who hadn't finished the month. There was no comparison group, but it suggests refusing gets easier with practice.
- Boredom. Some evenings are dull without a drink, and if a night is only bearable after four pints, that tells you something about the night. You're allowed to leave. The evenings built on food and people you like turn out about the same, and you remember how they ended.
The hardest occasion might be your own sofa. If you and your partner share a bottle most nights, frame the month as an experiment about you. Don't ask them to join in, don't count their glasses, and keep sitting down together when the day's over. Expect some prickliness the first week. It usually passes once it's clear nobody's being judged.
"I'm someone who likes a drink" feels like character. It's history, picked up around eighteen, and the people worth keeping will adjust in about a fortnight. Alcohol-free beers and wines keep the ceremony going, though if you've been dependent, ask your alcohol service first, since opinions differ on whether they help or act as a reminder.
Then there are the best nights. The wedding where everybody danced until the lights came up. A bar on holiday that nobody can now find on a map.
You've had perhaps a thousand evenings with a drink in them, and five or ten were wonderful. The alcohol was much the same on all thousand. What differed was the people, the occasion, the music and nobody having to get up in the morning. Something present every time can't be what made a few of them special.
Drink adds one real thing. Steele and Josephs argued that it blocks what they called response conflict, the tug between an impulse and the reasons against it, so at the edge of the dance floor the fear of looking daft goes quiet. But I think much of the permission is an agreement in the room that "we'd had a few" covers dancing and telling friends you love them, and at midnight the driver and the pregnant bridesmaid are on the floor too, using the same licence without the drink.
And the last two hours of those nights are a smear of repeated conversations and a taxi. The nights you value most are the ones you keep least of. Go to the next big one sober and you'll see a point, often when the stories start repeating, where it stops being fun for anybody and carries on out of momentum. Stay for the dancing. Leave then.
Perhaps none of this is you. You don't drink for courage or to cope. You like a cold beer after mowing the lawn and a good red with a roast, the way you like cheese. I believe you, and pleasure is the credit I'd argue with least.
Watch where it sits, though. The first few mouthfuls are vivid. The second glass is fine. By the third you aren't tasting much, and you didn't choose it the way you chose the first. Someone with two drinks in them chose it, and wanting another seems to be one of the things a drink produces, though that's my observation and not a study. Give each glass a mark out of ten as you finish it this week. Most people find the marks fall fast, which makes regular drinking poor value even on its own terms. The person who has one good glass with Saturday dinner gets much of your week's pleasure, and feels it more.
Occasional drinking, for the taste, is a respectable place to end up. "One good glass" is harder to keep than "none tonight", though, because the first drink loosens the judgement meant to stop the second. And from inside a daily habit, "I just like it" and "I'm used to it" feel exactly the same.
Stabilisers off
Take a month without alcohol. During it, do every single thing you'd normally drink for.
The second sentence matters more. A child can't find out whether she can balance while the stabilisers are bolted on. Hide at home for a month and you'll test nothing and decide sober life is lonely. Go to the fortieth. Go to the pub on Friday. Cook at ten to seven with the radio on and something cold in a glass.
Cutting down won't do for this, because it leaves a glass in every situation and the credit never gets tested. A week is too short. The first week is the worst evidence you'll collect, with the cue going unanswered, sleep unsettled and you watching yourself throughout. A month holds several Fridays, an event or two and at least one properly bad day.
In 2018 a team at University College London followed 94 moderate to heavy drinkers who took a month off and 47 who didn't. The abstainers' insulin resistance fell by about a quarter, and their blood pressure and weight fell slightly. The others showed no change. People chose their own group, so it wasn't a randomised trial. None of this proves you'll feel better. It does remove the fear that the evidence points the other way.
Here's the plan. A few of its steps have research behind them, but the plan as a whole is mine and hasn't been tested as a package.
- Count. For one ordinary week, write down what you drink in units. A large glass of wine is 3, a pint of stronger lager is 3, and a bottle of wine at 13.5 per cent is 10. The NHS low-risk guidance is no more than 14 a week, spread over three or more days, with several drink-free days. A large glass every weeknight is 15 before the weekend.
- Check it's safe. If any of the withdrawal signs at the start are familiar, or your total is very high, talk to your GP or an alcohol service first. This isn't a formality.
- Pick a start date soon, in an ordinary month. If there's a wedding in it, good.
- Keep the ceremony. Buy what goes in the glass at ten to seven before day one. Tonic with ice and lime, a decent alcohol-free beer, a ginger beer with some bite. You're keeping the full stop and changing the ink.
- Write three plans. There's good evidence that a plan in the form "when X happens, then I'll do Y" gets carried out more often than a general intention. "When I get in from work, then I'll pour a tonic and sit down for ten minutes." "When someone offers me a drink, then I'll ask for a lime and soda." "When I've had a rotten day and want wine, then I'll walk round the block and decide when I get back."
- Tell the person you live with and a friend or two. It's harder for someone to press a glass on you when they already know.
- Line up help if you want it. You don't have to qualify as a problem. Drinkline is free and confidential on 0300 123 1110, and the NHS has a free app called Drink Free Days. A Cochrane review of 34 trials found that a brief conversation with a GP or nurse left people drinking about two and a half units a week less a year later.
When the urge comes, and it will, my understanding is that it rises and then falls if you do nothing about it, usually within the time it takes to do something else. You can have it without obeying it.
Keep short notes, because memory flatters whatever you already believed. In the first week and the fourth, note how you slept, your mood at eleven in the morning, and how wound up you were at ten to seven. After a party, note how long the stiff part lasted.
At the end, with a clear head, decide. You may not want it back. You may drink occasionally, in which case write the rules before the first drink. Treat the NHS guidance as a ceiling, keep most days drink-free, don't drink to cope, and settle the number before you start. Or the month may turn out much harder than you expected.
Day eleven. A dreadful week, and a glass of wine.
The thought that follows does more harm than the drink. "That's that ruined, may as well finish the bottle." The ten days still happened, and twenty are left. Stop at one if you can, at tonight if you can't. Tomorrow, work out which situation it was and which need, and whether the drink delivered what you expected. It's often flatter than the wanting promised. Write a new when-then plan for that moment and carry on the same day. Don't count streaks, which turn one drink into losing everything. Count drink-free days in the last thirty. Twenty-seven out of thirty is a very different month from your usual one.
If your limits keep slipping, that isn't weakness. "Regularly drinking more than you mean to" and "difficulty stopping or reducing, even if you want to" are the first two signs on the NHS list for alcohol-use disorder, a common condition with treatments. Those include talking therapies such as CBT, medical help with withdrawal, medicines like acamprosate and naltrexone, and groups such as AA and SMART Recovery. Going early is the sensible time to go.
Talk to your GP or an alcohol service if any of these apply.
- You get sweats, shaking, a racing heart, nausea or morning anxiety when you cut down. Get medical advice before reducing further. For hallucinations, confusion, severe shaking or a seizure, call 999.
- You need a drink in the morning, or to steady yourself.
- You regularly drink more than you meant to, despite serious attempts to change.
- Low mood or anxiety continues, or worsens, after several weeks without alcohol.
- Someone close to you is worried about your drinking.
- You're pregnant, or trying to be, and finding it hard to stop.
- You have thoughts of harming yourself. That needs help the same day, from your GP or NHS 111, or 999 if you're in immediate danger.
Same Thursday, a few months on. The meeting went badly again, because some meetings do. Bag down, shoes off, ice and tonic and lime in the good glass, first mouthful at the counter. You breathe out at exactly the moment you always did. The radio goes on and the onions go in.
You sleep through. On Saturday there's a party. You stand with too many arms for a while, as everybody does. Then someone introduces a cousin, there are campervans, and at eleven you drive four grateful people home.
Whether there was a glass of red with dinner is your business. What's different is that you chose it.
If you do one thing today, make it small. Count last week's units on the back of an envelope, or put a start date in your diary.