The good old days had problems too

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 54 min

There's a photograph on the fridge, or on your phone, of a summer. You're twenty-three, or thirty-one, or nine, and the light is doing something the light doesn't seem to do any more. Everyone in it is laughing, and two of them are dead now. You look at it while the kettle boils and feel warm, then sad, and then the sentence comes, quietly, in your own voice.

It'll never be like that again.

Sometimes it isn't a photograph. It's a song on the radio in the car, or a smell outside a bakery, or a news story about something that's changed. You say to the person next to you "it wasn't like this when we were young", and they agree, because they always agree, and the two of you spend a pleasant ten minutes in a decade neither of you can visit. You come out of it feeling that the present is a poor thin thing and getting thinner.

I'll call that moment the sigh. The years that glow are the good old days. The way memory hands them to you, with the problems taken out, is the golden version. The same years with the problems put back are the whole record.

Here's what I'm going to argue. The habit makes sense from the inside, and the past you remember is real, and going back to it does you some good. But the past you visit has been edited, by memory, which does this to everyone in ways that have been measured. The bad fades faster than the good. Old feelings get rewritten to match what you think now. Changes in you get read as changes in the world. So the present is being judged against a past that never existed in that form. The practical answer is to put the problems back, to visit the past on purpose and with an end, and to judge today from the same distance you judge nineteen ninety-six from. In twenty years today is going to glow too, and it would be a waste to find that out only then.

I won't ask you to stop loving what you loved, or to be cheerful about losses that are real. Some things were better. Some people are gone.

Two cautions. If the past feels like the only place where anything was good, and the present has been grey for most of the day, most days, for two weeks or more, that isn't a habit of mind. It may be depression, and the NHS says to see a GP. Please do. And if the good old days were good because of a person you've lost, some of what you're feeling is grief, which has its own shape and its own help. I'll come to that.

Before you go on, take a piece of paper and write down the good old days. The years, the place, the people. Then, for each one, write one thing that was wrong at the time, while you were living it. The thing you were worried about that summer. The job you were stuck in. The rent. The person who wasn't speaking to you. The relationship that was failing while the photo was taken. Take your time. It's hard, and there's a reason it's hard. Most people who do this find the problems were there, that they were serious, and that they'd forgotten them entirely.

The beach at full strength

Start with the belief that holds the rest up. The past didn't only seem better. It was better, and your memory is simply reporting the fact.

I want to be fair to that first, because the golden version is made of real things.

  • It happened. You were there, the friends were funny and the flat was yours.
  • The warmth you feel going back is as real as anything you feel today, and often stronger.
  • The present has real problems. You're older, some things hurt, prices are what they are.
  • Everyone agrees, and the nodding feels like evidence.
  • On a hard evening it's somewhere warm to go.
  • And the people in the photograph who aren't here any more are here in it.

Those are good needs. To feel your life has had good in it, to stay close to people you've lost, to make sense of change. I think the whole record meets every one of them better. Here's why.

Richard Walker, John Skowronski and Charles Thompson, in 2003, reviewed a body of research on how people remember their own lives. They found that people record more pleasant than unpleasant events to begin with. And they described what they called the fading affect bias. The feeling attached to an unpleasant memory fades faster than the feeling attached to a pleasant one. You still remember that the bad thing happened, but the sting goes out of it, while the good memories keep their warmth. In people who were mildly depressed, the review noted, the bias was disrupted and the bad didn't fade. So the fade is a healthy mind's way of carrying its own history. It just isn't accurate.

Now slow down and look at the summer in the photograph. It had a rent problem and a relationship problem and a job problem, and at the time they took up a fair amount of the summer. Twenty years on, the problems are still there if you go looking, which is why the exercise with the paper works. But the feeling has drained out of them. The beach hasn't drained at all. So when you go back you get the beach at full strength and the rent at nothing, and that isn't the summer. It's the summer after the fade. Then you come home to today, which has a beach in it somewhere and a rent problem too, and both are still hot because neither has had time to cool. A cooled past against a hot present. The past wins. It would win if the two years were identical.

"But I remember it clearly. I remember being happy."

Linda Levine, in 1997, studied people who'd supported a presidential candidate who suddenly pulled out of a race. She asked them how they felt at the time, and months later asked them to recall it. Their memories had shifted towards how they saw the candidate now. Loyal supporters remembered being less angry than they'd said. Those who'd fallen away remembered being angrier. It's one study of one event. But it sits with a lot of other research on memory, which treats remembering as rebuilding, done with what you know and feel today. So "I remember being happy in nineteen ninety-six" is partly a report and partly a construction, made by someone who already believes nineteen ninety-six was the good old days.

You can feel the seam sometimes. A diary from that year is startling to read, because the person writing it is worried about things you'd forgotten and doesn't seem to know they're living in the good old days. Or a friend who was there says "you hated that job", and you did, and you'd taken the hatred out.

Try writing a letter to yourself in nineteen ninety-six, telling them they're living in the good old days. I'd bet the reply is some version of "you must be joking", followed by a list.

Then there's the second half of the sigh, the part that does the damage. Nothing now will ever match it. That sounds like a forecast, but it's the same unfair comparison. The golden version is made of the peaks, the wedding, the beach, the night everyone stayed up. Today is a Tuesday with a work thing and a dentist and a slightly disappointing lunch, and it's being set against the best afternoon of a whole decade. The Tuesday from nineteen ninety-six that you don't remember, because it was a Tuesday, would have lost just as badly.

Run the fade forward. The dentist will go, and the work thing, and the lunch. Whatever was good in today will stay, even if you didn't notice it at the time because you were busy sighing. There will be a photograph from this year on a fridge in twenty thirty-six, and someone will look at it while the kettle boils, and the sentence will come. About now.

Who changed

Say "it was better then" in any pub in the country and heads will nod. Safer, kinder, simpler. Everything's got worse.

That's the wider form, the decline story, and it's about the world as well as your life. Richard Eibach, Lisa Libby and Thomas Gilovich, in 2003, looked at where it comes from. People who'd been through big personal changes, such as becoming a parent or a change in money, were more likely to say the world had changed too, in things like crime. In experiments, changing what people knew made them see change in the world that wasn't there. When the researchers pointed out to people that they themselves had changed, the sense that the world had changed shrank. Their conclusion was that changes in the self get mistaken for changes in the world, and that this helps produce the belief that society is in decline.

Here's a test. Pick a thing that's got worse and ask whether you've changed in a way that would make it look worse either way. The streets feel less safe. Were you walking them at midnight at twenty-five, and now at seven with a pram at forty? Music has got worse. Do you still listen the way you did at seventeen, all day, with nothing else to do? Sometimes the world really has changed. You'll be surprised how often the change is in the instrument.

The most common form of the story is that people were kinder then. Adam Mastroianni and Daniel Gilbert, in 2023, gathered survey data from around twelve and a half million people, in at least sixty countries, going back about seventy years. In every year, people said others were less kind and honest than they used to be. Then the researchers looked at how people rated their contemporaries in each of those years, and the ratings hadn't changed. The decline was reported continuously for seventy years and never showed up in measurements of the present. They proposed that two ordinary things cause it. We hear more about bad behaviour, because that's what gets reported, and the bad we heard about long ago has faded. When people were asked about people they knew well, the sense of decline shrank. Asked about the years before they were born, it disappeared. Nobody thinks morality collapsed between eighteen ninety and nineteen twenty. It always declined during their own lifetime, whenever that was.

The mechanism is their proposal, and I'd hold it loosely. The finding is harder to argue with.

Then there's "young people today". John Protzko and Jonathan Schooler, in 2019, ran five preregistered studies with nearly three and a half thousand American adults. Adults believed today's young people were worse. But people who scored high on respect for authority especially saw young people as disrespectful. People who scored high on intelligence tests saw them as less intelligent. Big readers saw them as reading less. Each person saw decline in the one trait where they themselves stood high. The researchers suggest we notice others' limits where we excel, and that we remember the young people of our own youth as being like us, because our friends were and everyone else has faded. The complaint, they note, has been made for millennia. If it were true, humanity would have run out of readers some time before the Romans. You were the young person of somebody's decline story, and here you are.

So why does everyone at the table agree? Because they're people roughly your age, whose bad memories have faded on roughly the same schedule, exposed to roughly the same bad news. Same instrument, same error. Agreement was total in every one of those seventy years. And "do you remember when" is mostly a way of being together, which is fine. It just isn't a survey.

"Things were simpler then." For you, yes, because you were twenty-three and the complexity was being held by someone else. Your parents had the mortgage. Your health was a thing you had. The people who were forty-five in nineteen ninety-six found it exactly as complicated as you find now, and they were sighing about nineteen seventy-one. Some simplicity was real. Fewer channels, fewer ways to be reached. But knowing more also makes the world look more complicated, and you know a great deal more than you did. The whole record of your simple summer has your parents at the kitchen table with the bank statements, in the same house, on the same day.

And if you call all this realism, look at what realism would ask. Both years on the table with everything in them. The golden version takes one year's problems out, leaves the other's in, and calls the result clear-eyed. The realistic person is the one who, when the pub agrees things have got worse, says "have they, though" and means it as a question.

Last, the sigh about age. You're forty-eight, or fifty-five, and the shape of life looks clear. It went up, it peaked, and now it goes down.

David Blanchflower and Andrew Oswald, in 2008, looked at wellbeing across the lifespan in data on around half a million people in America and Western Europe, using a method meant to separate age from generation. On average, they found a U. Wellbeing was relatively high in youth, fell through the thirties and forties to a low point in middle age, and rose again after. They found the same shape in seventy-two countries. Later researchers have argued about it, and your life is one life, not an average. I'm not promising you a happy old age. But the sigh draws a straight line down, and the best evidence on the average shape of a life doesn't draw that line. It draws a dip and a rise, and if you're forty-eight, the bottom of the dip is roughly where you're standing.

A poster of a summer

Some readers will say I've made a small thing into a large one. It's a bit of warmth on a cold evening. It's harmless.

Half right. It's better than harmless. Tim Wildschut, Constantine Sedikides, Jamie Arndt and Clay Routledge, in 2006, ran seven studies on nostalgia. What people go back to is mostly themselves with people they were close to. What sets it off is low mood, and loneliness in particular. And what it does, in their experiments, is make people feel more connected to others and better about themselves. Routledge and colleagues, in 2011, added that it raises the sense that life has meaning. I'd no more tell you to stop going back than tell you to stop seeing old friends.

But look at what the studies describe. Someone goes back, is warmed, and comes forward feeling more able to face the present. The sigh is the same trip with the opposite return. You come forward feeling the present is thin. The difference is what you carry back, and it's the difference between going to a funeral and living in the cemetery. Left alone, the golden version drifts towards the cemetery, because low mood sends you back, the sigh lowers your mood, and the lower mood sends you back again.

Grief is different, and I won't argue with it. If the good old days were good because of someone who's dead, going back is going to see them, and that ache is the shape the love takes now. Grief doesn't follow the fade. It can stay hot for years. The NHS pages on grief point to Cruse Bereavement Support, among others, and say to see a GP if you're feeling increasingly low or anxious, or if the low mood has lasted more than two weeks. Grief for someone long gone is still grief, and it's never too late to get help with it. Quite a few people who think they have a nostalgia habit have a grief they've had nowhere to put down.

Where grief and the golden version part company is this. Grief is about the person. The golden version is about the era, and it borrows the person to make its case. The whole decade gets their glow, and you end up missing a decade, vaguely, when you could be missing one person, clearly. Keep the person and let the era go. Miss them by name.

"If I let the golden version go, I lose the past." The opposite is closer to the truth.

Every time you go back and the problems aren't there, the year gets smoother. A summer with a hundred days in it becomes one afternoon, then an image, and the image gets thinner each time it's used. The friend on the beach was a person, with a money problem and an unrequited love and a habit of being late and a laugh you can still hear. The golden version kept the laugh and cut the rest, and what's left is a prop in your picture of your own youth. Your parents, who were tense about the car that summer, have become a calm warm presence in a kitchen. The visits turn into a ritual, the same three images and the same sigh, and you go back more and get less. Putting the problems back gives the summer its hundred days again. It gives you back the whole friend, and the whole friend is the one you miss.

The bill for living there arrives quietly.

  • The hours in nineteen ninety-six come out of the only year you can do anything in.
  • Your partner has been compared with the person you loved at twenty-three, who never left the toothpaste lid off because you never lived with them.
  • Your children hear that the good time was before they arrived.
  • Several small drops a day add up to a mood.
  • A person who believes the best is behind them stops starting things.

So, the first part of the method. Give each golden year a page. At the top, what you remember. Underneath, a problems column, and aim for five things. You'll get two easily. For the rest, go to the record, which the fade didn't make. Diaries, letters, old messages. The fifty photographs on the hard drive around the one on the fridge, with the bad haircut and the tired face and the flat that was smaller than you remember. Bank statements, which know what you were worried about better than memory does. Ask someone who was there, "what was going on for me that summer?" Some of what they say will be uncomfortable, and that's the whole record arriving.

Write the problems as they felt then. The job you hated turned out fine because you left it, so write the hating. And leave the beach at the top. The point is a page with the beach and the rent on it together, kept somewhere you can reach.

You'll need it, because the sigh runs on triggers. A song. A smell. Someone your age saying "do you remember". A young person doing something baffling. Being tired, or alone on a Sunday afternoon. When it arrives, ask one question. What was wrong that year? The song can keep playing. You can enjoy it while remembering it came out the year of the bad flat. And when "it'll never be like that again" comes, ask it for specifics. Like what? Warm, with friends, on a beach, with no responsibilities. Two of those are available this summer. The third wasn't as pleasant as it sounds, because no responsibilities meant no money.

Twenty years off

Go back on purpose.

A visit starts with a decision. You put the record on, get the album out, ring the friend who was there. Living there starts with a trigger and a drift. Take someone with you if you can, because Wildschut's group found nostalgia does its best work socially. "Let me tell you about that summer." Tell it with the rent in. "We were completely broke and Sam was in love with that awful man and we went to the beach anyway." It's a better story, and it gives Sam back.

Give the visit an end, when the record finishes or the story's told. If you're still there an hour later on the third replay of the same afternoon, you've stopped visiting. Then come back with one good thing about today. "That was a good summer, and this one has the allotment in it." That sentence, at the door, is the whole difference between a visit and living there. And if you notice you've drifted back on a grey Sunday without deciding to, that's information about the Sunday. The answer is often a person now, and the phone is closer than the album.

Then turn the argument round. This is the part most people find changes things.

Ask what this year will look like after the fade. The dentist will be gone. What's left? The child at this age, who won't be this age again. The friend you see on Thursdays. The kitchen you complain about, which in twenty thirty-six will be "the old kitchen" and missed. Write one line most days of the thing that will survive the fade, so that the whole record of now exists somewhere too. Once, on a quiet evening, write yourself a letter from twenty thirty-six looking back at this year as the good old days. Most people find it easy to write and hard to read.

When the sigh compares, make it fair. Tuesday against Tuesday, or best afternoon against best afternoon. Look at your partner from twenty years off too, as a person you were lucky to have, with faults that have faded and a laugh you can still hear. You can choose that distance tonight.

And say the sentence forwards. "It'll never be like this again." About today it's true, and it's a reason to be here.

To make it stick, decide in advance. Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran reviewed ninety-four studies in 2006 of plans in the form "when this happens, I'll do that", and people who planned that way followed through much more often than people who only held the intention. So write these down, or your own versions.

  • When the sigh arrives, I'll ask "what was wrong that year" and answer it before anything else.
  • When I notice I've gone back without deciding to, I'll say one good thing about today, then decide whether to stay.
  • When someone says "it was better then", I'll say "some of it was" and name one thing that wasn't.

What I'd expect, and this is my guess, not a finding, is that the problems column is hard to fill the first time and fills itself the second, because once one problem comes back the others follow. The first chosen visit with the whole record in it will be a better evening than the last twenty drifts. After a few weeks the question starts arriving with the sigh, on its own. The past won't glow any less. It'll glow the same and be bigger, and today will have started to glow a little, early, before the fade has had to do it for you.

Some cases need their own word. If the good old days are the years before your body changed, the comparison has something real in it, and a bad hip isn't a bias. The well years still had their own problems, and now still has good in it that the hip hasn't reached. If you had a job you loved and now have one you don't, put its problems back anyway, the boss and the commute and the Sunday-night feeling, and then ask what it had that this one lacks, specifically. That's a thing you can go and look for. A decade isn't. If you think the country has got worse, argue about one thing at a time, against the record. If a past relationship glows, remember the toothpaste lid. The person beside you is competing with a photograph, so put that old love's problems back with particular care. And if the present has been grey most of the day, most days, for two weeks or more, see a GP. The problems column can wait.

It'll happen anyway. A grey Sunday, a song, the album, and three hours later you surface with the sigh fully formed and the afternoon gone.

One Sunday isn't the habit back. The fade had twenty years to build the golden version and the page has had a month. Put one problem back, now, before the evening. Go to the page for the year you've been in, or make one, and write down one thing that was wrong. Then work out what set it off. If it was being alone, pick up the phone. If it was a song, ask the question sooner next time. Say one good thing about today, because the Sunday has an evening left in it. Don't count days without the sigh. Count visits you came back from.

Some years from now there's a photograph on a fridge. It's of a Tuesday this year, in the kitchen you complained about, with a child who was small then, and the light is doing something the light doesn't seem to do any more. You look at it while the kettle boils and the sentence starts to come. Then you remember. That Tuesday had a dentist in it. That year had the money worry and the friend who went quiet in the spring, and you spent whole evenings feeling the good years were behind you. So you say the other sentence. "That was a good year, and so's this one." Then you go and find whoever's in the house and tell them about the Tuesday, with the dentist left in.

Tonight, take the year that glows most and write down one thing that was wrong with it.