The lie-in costs more than it gives
The 20-minute version
It's Sunday night, twenty past eleven, and you're not asleep. You went up at half past ten because it's a school night, and the more you think about needing to sleep, the less it happens. You've checked the phone twice. You've done the arithmetic on how many hours you'll get if you drop off now, and done it again five minutes later with a smaller number.
At half past six the alarm goes off in what feels like the middle of the night. You get up thick and slow and slightly sick, and stay that way until about eleven. Monday is a day you get through.
Rewind to Friday. You'd had five nights of half past six and five days of work, you were running on coffee by Thursday afternoon, and the one thing you wanted was not to set the alarm. Saturday you woke at half past nine and lay there another half hour because you could. Saturday night ran late, since there was no reason it shouldn't. Sunday you woke at ten and felt properly rested for the first time all week, and had a slow breakfast, and it was lovely.
Then it was Sunday night and twenty past eleven.
By Wednesday you're right again. By Friday you're tired, the lie-in seems earned, and round it goes. I don't think you're lazy for sleeping in, and I don't think mornings are virtuous. My argument is that the lie-in gives you less than it seems to and costs more, and that the Monday feeling is largely made on Saturday morning. The fix isn't less sleep. It's getting up within an hour of your weekday time on both weekend days, getting outside into daylight soon after, and putting the extra sleep you need at the start of the night instead of the end of the morning.
Before you go on, write down roughly what time you got up and went to sleep on each of the last seven days. Look at the middle of your sleep on a weekday and the middle of it at the weekend. If the gap is more than an hour, this is about you.
Three cautions. If you do shift work, or you're up in the night with a baby or small child, or you care for someone who wakes, the rule here may not fit your week, and near the end I say what does. If you regularly find it hard to get to sleep or stay asleep, it's been going on for months, and it's affecting how you cope in the day, the NHS says to see a GP, because that's insomnia, and it has its own treatment. A regular wake time is part of that treatment but not the whole of it. And if you sleep late at weekends because you can't face getting up, and that's been true most days for a fortnight or more, the NHS says to see a GP about your mood. The weekend can wait until you have.
Two hours east
The lie-in isn't for nothing, so start with what it gives.
You're short of sleep by Friday, and sleeping longer is the obvious repair. You get to wake without a noise telling you to. For a lot of people, lying there at nine on a Saturday is the only hour of the week that belongs to them. And by Sunday lunchtime you feel like a person again. Those are real. The fifth thing is a belief, that Monday is bad because Monday is bad and the weekend was separate and good. That one's false, and most of what follows is about why.
Take catching up first, since the usual version of this argument overreaches. The shortfall is real. Hans Van Dongen and colleagues kept forty-eight healthy adults in a laboratory for two weeks on four, six or eight hours in bed a night. The people on six hours, an ordinary weekday amount, built up losses in attention and reaction time that by the end matched two nights with no sleep at all. They didn't feel it. Their own ratings of sleepiness levelled off after a few days while their performance kept falling. Feeling roughly fine on Thursday doesn't mean you are.
And the weekend does put some back. Christopher Depner, Kenneth Wright and colleagues gave healthy young adults five short nights, then two nights of sleeping as long as they liked, then two more short nights. Over the weekend they slept about an hour and ten minutes more than usual, and that's the part you feel on Sunday.
Then the week started again. In the short nights afterwards, their body clocks had shifted later, their evening eating and weight went back up, and their insulin sensitivity fell by between nine and twenty-seven per cent depending on the measure. That was no better, and by some measures worse, than a group who never got a weekend at all. The authors concluded that weekend recovery sleep isn't an effective way to prevent the metabolic effects of a repeatedly short week. It was a small study of healthy young people, so take the shape more than the numbers. The weekend put back an hour, failed to put back the week, and moved the clock.
Shingo Kitamura and colleagues found that even one hour of shortfall took about four days of extended sleep to recover. Two mornings can't do four days' work.
"It's only a couple of hours."
So is a flight from London to Athens. Your body clock runs on a cycle a little longer than a day and is held to twenty-four hours mainly by light, by when you see it and when you don't. Sleep late and you see morning light two or three hours later than usual, stay awake and lit up later into the evening, and the clock takes that as a signal to run later.
Yang, Spielman and colleagues tested exactly this. Ten healthy young adults had their sleep pushed two hours later on Friday and Saturday nights, to copy an ordinary weekend, and the rise of their melatonin, the body's own marker of when night begins, came about thirty-two minutes later afterwards. On Sunday night they took longer to fall asleep. On Monday morning they were sleepier. Stephanie Crowley and Mary Carskadon found a shift of about forty-five minutes in older teenagers over a weekend.
Now put yourself in bed on Sunday at half past ten. Your clock thinks it's ten, or a quarter to. You're being asked to sleep before your own night has started. And the alarm at half past six goes off at what your body counts as a quarter to six. The tiredness on Monday is that thirty or forty minutes out of step, on top of a short night, and it takes a couple of days of early mornings to pull back, which is why Wednesday is the first normal day.
Marc Wittmann, Till Roenneberg and colleagues named this social jet lag in 2006, and meant it literally. Jet lag is your body clock and the wall clock disagreeing, and it doesn't care whether an aeroplane or a duvet did it. They measured it as the gap between the middle of your sleep on work days and on free days, and in their survey of about five hundred people, most had some. Those with more reported worse sleep and lower wellbeing. A survey can't say which way the arrow points, and that's true of most of this research. It named the thing accurately, though.
Monday to Friday you live in one time zone. Friday night you fly two hours east without moving, and Sunday night you fly back. Nobody would expect to be sharp on Monday after that if it had involved an airport.
The weekend shift is smaller than a real flight, roughly a third to half of the two hours in those studies, which is why Monday is a bad morning and not a lost day. It's also why the cause is so easy to miss. Half an hour is enough to wreck Sunday night and small enough to blame on the job.
There's the Monday you'd have anyway, a workday after a rest, and there's the Monday you actually have, with your clock forty minutes out and a short night behind you. The first is a mood. The second is a physical state that feels like the first from the inside, which is how it hides. A thick head, slow thinking, faint nausea, the third coffee by ten, snapping at people who've done nothing. That's what a shifted clock feels like.
Everyone jokes about Mondays, and the joke makes it feel normal and shared, which is comforting. Lots of people have a bad Monday because lots of people sleep late at weekends. The ones with dogs and small children and early trains tend not to get the joke.
So try this, without changing anything yet. Rate how you feel at nine on Monday, out of ten, and again at nine on Wednesday. Do it for two weeks. Same emails, same desk, same people. If Wednesday keeps beating Monday by more than a point or two, the work isn't the reason.
The hour that belongs to you
The strongest objection isn't about sleep at all.
For many people the lie-in is seven hours of sleep and two hours of lying there, half awake, warm, nobody wanting anything. If you've got children it may be the only stretch of the week when you're off duty. Telling you to get up and go for a brisk walk at seven is the advice that gets books thrown across rooms.
So keep the hour and move it. What it needs is that nobody wants anything from you. It doesn't need to be at nine, or in the dark. It can be at seven, curtains open, in the same bed or a chair by the window, with the same book and the same nothing. Your clock needs light and an upright body near your weekday time. You need unclaimed time. Those were never in conflict. If getting up means being found and asked for things, say it out loud. "Saturday from seven to eight is mine, and I'm not to be asked for anything unless there's blood." Most households can grant that.
"I'm a night owl." People do differ, partly by genes, and late types had the most social jet lag in Wittmann's survey, because the weekday alarm hurts them most. That's also why the lie-in costs them most. A clock already inclined to run late gets pushed further, and Monday has further to drag it back.
And chronotype is less fixed than it feels. Kenneth Wright and colleagues took people camping for a week in summer with no electric light, and their clocks moved earlier, by about two hours on average. The late types moved most. Ellen Stothard and colleagues got about two thirds of that shift from a single weekend. My reading is that a good part of feeling like a night owl comes from modern light, dim days indoors and bright evenings, and it moves quickly when the light changes. Nobody's asking you to become a morning person. Only to have your clock in the same place on Monday as it was on Friday.
"But I feel great on a Sunday."
You do. Draw the week as a line. Friday evening low. Sunday afternoon high. Sunday night bad, Monday low, Tuesday middling, Wednesday fine, then a slow slide to Friday. The Sunday peak is paid for by the Monday trough. Part of the peak is your shifted clock, too. At three on Sunday afternoon you're in the middle of your new, later day, wide awake, so the same shift that's a tailwind on Sunday is a wall on Monday morning. A steady week sits a little below Sunday's high and a long way above Monday's low. I'd guess most people would trade the high for a Monday that felt like a Wednesday.
What harm can two mornings do? There are costs you don't feel, and they've been studied, so here they are with their limits. In large surveys, people with more social jet lag tended to have higher body mass index, and in a study of about four hundred and fifty midlife day workers, Patricia Wong and colleagues found a bigger weekday to weekend gap went with worse cholesterol, higher fasting insulin and more body fat, after allowing for sleep length and other factors. Other studies found links with higher resting heart rate and higher depression scores. Every one of those is a snapshot. They can't show the shift caused the numbers, and the authors say so. The Depner experiment is the one place the pattern was imposed and the metabolic cost followed, and it was small and short. I won't tell you the lie-in is making you ill. The pattern keeps bad company, and the Monday is probably not its only price.
Then there's the barracks objection. Getting up at the same time every day sounds grim.
Andrew Phillips and colleagues followed sixty-one undergraduates for a month. The irregular sleepers weren't sleeping less. They were sleeping at different times, and their clocks had drifted nearly three hours later than the regular sleepers', with their melatonin rising after midnight instead of around half past nine. The main driver was light. Irregular sleepers got less contrast between bright day and dark night, so the clock had less to hold on to and slid. What the clock wants is the same time, whatever the time happens to be.
A fixed wake time is one number, and everything after it is yours. Get up at seven on a Saturday and do nothing until noon if you like. Within a few weeks most people find they wake a few minutes before the alarm, weekends included. The thing you loved about the lie-in, waking on your own, turns out to be on offer seven days a week.
You might be wrecked the first Saturday you try it. That's the short week showing, the deficit the lie-in had been hiding. Hold the wake time and pay the debt from the other end, with an early night, and the second Saturday is easier and by the third or fourth the tiredness has mostly gone. A wrecked Saturday is a one-off. The wrecked Monday came every week.
And yes, the real engine is the short week. Sleep enough Monday to Friday and the lie-in loses most of its pull. But fixing weeknights means giving up the late evening that's often your only time of your own, which is hard. Fixing the weekend is one number and a walk, and a Monday that starts level gives you a week with two fewer bad days in it. Do the week afterwards, if you still need to, once you can see how much of the tiredness was hours and how much was drift.
Add up the part you can see. An hour or two awake on Sunday night, the night before the hardest morning. A Monday at six out of ten that could be an eight, and a Tuesday most of the way back. Call it a day and a half a week below your level, every week, for years. And a small identity grows around it, the person who's no good until Wednesday, with the mug and the third coffee. It turns a schedule into a character, and it's wrong.
Which leaves Sunday night, where people blame the wrong thing. Sleep needs a long enough stretch awake and a clock that says it's night. Woken at ten, you've been up twelve or thirteen hours by bedtime, and your clock is forty minutes late. You have neither. So you lie there, and the mind, handed an empty hour, fills it with Monday. Some of that is dread. A good deal of it is a body that isn't sleepy. Get up at seven on Sunday and by half past ten you've been awake fifteen and a half hours and your clock says night.
A lot of Sunday-night sleep problems are Sunday-morning problems.
Curtains first
Your clock is set by light. Light in the morning pulls it earlier and light in the evening pushes it later, and everything about weekend timing follows from that.
The camping studies show how big and fast the effect can be. So does a laboratory study by Victoria Revell, Helen Burgess, Charmane Eastman and colleagues, where bright light on waking, with the wake time moved an hour earlier each day, advanced people's clocks by about an hour and three quarters over three days. You don't need a lamp or a tent. You need to know the lever is real.
Here's the method, in three parts.
First, the daylight walk. Within an hour of getting up on Saturday and Sunday, go outside. Ten minutes does something and twenty is better. It doesn't need to be sunny, since an overcast morning outdoors is many times brighter than a lit kitchen, and it's your eyes doing the counting. Walk to a shop, stand in the garden with the coffee, take the dog or the child or the bins. Then do the other half on Friday and Saturday evenings. Fewer lights on after nine, the phone down earlier. Evening light is what tells the clock to run late.
Second, the window. Take your weekday wake time and add an hour. That's the latest you get up on both weekend days. If you're up at half past six in the week, you get up by half past seven on Saturday and Sunday. Inside the window, wake as you wake. Past it, get up. The NHS advice on sleep says the plainer version, which is to wake up and get out of bed at the same time every day and not sleep in after a bad night. I've allowed the hour because a rule with no give breaks on the first late Friday, and a broken rule gets dropped. Two hours is the habit under another name. If you're a late type and an hour feels brutal, use an hour and a half for a month, then tighten it.
Up means up. Feet on the floor, curtains open, out of the room. An hour lying awake in the dark is, to your clock, an hour more sleep. If you want the lying there, have it with the curtains open and the light on your face, and it counts.
Set an alarm if you need one, and don't be embarrassed. When you've woken before it three weekends running, try without. If you slide, put it back. The window holds on holidays and Boxing Day too, because the drift doesn't know it's Christmas, and the first Monday back after a fortnight of lie-ins is the worst Monday of the year.
Third, the early night. You still need the sleep. The lie-in was just putting it at the wrong end. On Friday, go to bed an hour before your weekday bedtime, in the dark, with the phone elsewhere. You've been awake sixteen hours, your clock says night, and you're short, so you'll sleep, and darkness at that hour tells the clock nothing new.
Saturday night is where the rule usually dies. Bed at one and up at half past seven on Sunday means you'll be exhausted, and by next week you'll have decided the window doesn't work. It works when the bedtime comes with it. Keep Saturday's bedtime within an hour of your weekday one, earlier if you're tired, and you'll wake inside the window without trying.
If Saturday afternoon finds you flagging, a nap of twenty to thirty minutes before three can take the edge off without touching the clock. Set an alarm, because a two-hour nap at four is a lie-in by another route. If you have real insomnia, the NHS says not to nap at all, and it's right, because the night needs that pressure.
The early nights are scaffolding. As the debt comes down, most people find within a month that they're going to bed at the usual time on Friday and Saturday and waking inside the window rested.
So here's the decision. I get up within an hour of my weekday wake time on Saturday and Sunday, I'm outside in daylight within an hour of getting up, and the extra sleep I need goes at the start of the night.
Plans of the "when this, then that" kind help, so the rule isn't decided fresh every Saturday and freshly lost.
- When the alarm goes at the end of the window and I want to roll over, I put my feet on the floor and open the curtains before I decide anything. The decision made lying in the dark is the wrong one.
- When it's Friday and I'm exhausted, I go to bed an hour early tonight instead of planning to sleep late tomorrow. The sleep is the same and the drift isn't.
- When it's Saturday evening and I'm not tired at eleven, I go up anyway with the lights low and something to read, because not being tired at eleven is the clock starting to slide.
My expectation, untested as a package, is that the first weekend is tired and that Sunday night and Monday are noticeably better than usual, which you'll be tempted to call coincidence. By the fourth weekend, Monday feels like a Wednesday. You haven't decided to sleep less. You've decided to sleep at the same time.
When you slept till eleven
Some weeks the rule doesn't fit as written.
If your week has nights in it, or rotates, there's no weekday wake time to anchor to, and social jet lag is your whole life rather than your weekend. Light when you want to be awake, darkness when you want to sleep, and consistency wherever you can get it still hold, but the schedule is a different problem, and if shifts are wrecking your sleep, talk to a GP.
If you're up at two and four and six with a baby, and a partner takes the early shift so you can sleep in, that's survival, and the sleep is worth more than the drift. Take it. The daylight walk still helps after a broken night. Come back to the window when the nights are reliably whole again.
Teenagers' clocks really do run later, and a teenager asleep until noon on Sunday is doing what their body asks. Morning light at the weekend helps them more than nagging does. The best thing the adult in the house can do is keep a steady wake time themselves.
After a big Friday out until two, the choice isn't the window or nothing. Get up by nine, go outside straight away, nap briefly in the early afternoon, have an early night, and hold the window properly on Sunday. One late night doesn't make a drift. One late night followed by two lie-ins does.
And sometimes it's more than the weekend. If you can't get to sleep or stay asleep most nights, for months, and it's making the day hard, see a GP. That's insomnia, and the NHS describes a specific talking treatment for it that a GP may refer you to. If you've felt low most of the day most days for two weeks or more, see a GP about your mood. And if you fall asleep in the day without meaning to, at the wheel or at your desk, see a GP this week, whatever your weekends look like.
Then there's the ordinary lapse. A month in, a bad week, a late Friday, and on Saturday you wake at eleven and lie there till half past. By Sunday the weekend has gone the old way, and Monday is the old Monday.
It means very little. Your clock moved forty minutes and will move back over two or three mornings of light. The month before isn't undone. In research on how habits form, a single missed day made no real difference to how the habit formed. Don't get up at five on Sunday to make amends, and don't cut sleep in the week to reset. Take the Monday, and get up inside the window next Saturday.
When you're rested, ask what let you back in. "I've earned it" after a hard week, when the earning was real and the lie-in was the wrong currency. Or a late Saturday that made Sunday's window impossible, which is the commonest way the rule gets lost, because people hold the morning and forget the night. That bad Monday is useful. A month ago you didn't know where Mondays came from.
It's Saturday and it's eight o'clock. You woke at twenty to, before the alarm you'd set anyway. The curtains are open and there's a coffee, and you're in the chair by the window reading something with no purpose. It's the hour that used to happen at ten with the curtains shut, and it's better, because you're awake for it.
At half past eight you go out. Round the block, to the bakery. It's grey, and that doesn't matter. Twenty minutes of grey daylight and the day is yours from nine, and it's long.
Saturday night you're tired at eleven, which surprises you. Sunday you wake at ten past seven. Same chair, same walk. Sunday night you're asleep by eleven, with no arithmetic and no phone.
Monday the alarm goes at half past six and it's just an alarm. You have one coffee, not three. The emails are the same emails, and it's a day. By Wednesday nobody at work has made the Monday joke at you, because you haven't looked like it.
This weekend, set the alarm for an hour after your weekday time, both mornings. When it goes, open the curtains before you decide anything.