The news will manage without you

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 53 min

It's ten past seven on a Monday morning and the alarm has just gone. Before your feet touch the floor you've picked up the phone, and before you've decided anything your thumb has opened the news. A missile strike on a city you couldn't have placed a year ago. A stabbing outside a nightclub two hundred miles away. A minister under pressure to resign. Economists warning about the winter.

You read the first few lines of each and put the phone down. You get up with a faint tightness in your chest, which you don't connect with anything.

At the kettle you look again. The minister story has a new headline saying the pressure is mounting. You look twice on the train, and at work there's a tab that stays open all day, which you glance at between tasks. At lunch, one opinion piece makes you angry and another makes you gloomy. The car radio gives you the headlines at five, half past five and six. The ten o'clock news tells you what you already know, with pictures. In bed you look once more, in case anything has happened since the television told you what had happened.

If you counted, it would come to something like twenty-five looks.

Your partner Jo said at dinner, "You've gone quiet again." You said you were fine. You were thinking about the winter.

Sunday had been a good day until about four. You'd been in the garden with the phone indoors. You came in for a cup of tea, picked it up, and within two minutes the afternoon felt different, though nothing in your life had changed and the garden hadn't either.

Your brother-in-law Neil doesn't look at the news during the week. He gets a weekly paper on Saturdays and reads it over the weekend with a pot of coffee. It's slightly annoying that when the family talks about the world, Neil tends to know more about it than you do.

I'm going to argue that checking all day makes you feel informed without informing you much, gives you a less accurate picture of your own risks, and raises your anxiety in ways that have been measured. The alternative is plain. You take in the news once a day, at a time and from a source you've chosen, and then you close it. The events are real, and caring about them is no mistake. Nor am I suggesting you ignore the news, because people who do that end up knowing less. The question is whether the twenty-fifth look of the day does anything for you or for anyone else.

For two days, keep a tally of every look, bulletins included. Each evening, write a few lines on what you learned that you didn't know the day before. Most people get a big tally and very few lines.

Three cautions.

If you feel anxious most days, find your worrying hard to control, and it's affecting your sleep, your work or your relationships, that may be more than a news habit. The NHS advice is to see a GP if you think you might have generalised anxiety disorder, and in England you can also refer yourself directly to an NHS talking therapies service. Cutting down on news may help, but it isn't a treatment.

If the news is about you, because you have family in a war zone or live where the floods are, you have real reasons to follow events closely. There's a note on that near the end.

And if your low mood or fear has reached the point where you've thought of harming yourself, please get help now. Call 111, or 999 in an emergency. The Samaritans are on 116 123 at any hour.

The rustle in the grass

People notice bad news more than good, and react to it more strongly. You can measure this in the body. Stuart Soroka, Patrick Fournier and Lilach Nir showed real television news stories to people in seventeen countries on six continents while recording their skin conductance and heart rate. On average, people reacted more strongly to negative stories than to positive ones, across very different cultures, though some individuals had the bias more strongly than others.

It's easy to guess why. Ignore a rustle in the grass that turns out to be nothing and you've lost a second. Ignore one that turns out to be a snake and you may have lost your life. You're descended from the people who looked.

Now the product. Claire Robertson and colleagues analysed a very large set of experiments run by a news website, which showed different headlines for the same story to different readers at random. There were about 105,000 headline variations and several hundred million views. For a headline of average length, each extra negative word raised the click rate by 2.3 per cent. Positive words lowered it. No conspiracy is needed. Editors pick what gets read, apps send what gets opened, and both are chosen, quite mechanically, by what frightens you. A newspaper had an end. A feed never does, and there's always a reason to look again.

Your own reasons are good ones. You want to understand the world and be safe in it, to do your part as a citizen, and to belong in the conversation. The question is whether checking serves any of them.

Start with being informed. By bedtime on Monday you'd looked twenty-five times. You knew there'd been a missile strike, which you knew at ten past seven, and that the minister was under pressure, which you also knew at ten past seven. The twenty-three looks in between delivered rewordings. The pressure was mounting, then growing, then colleagues were rallying round. Your grasp of why the strike happened, or what the minister was accused of, was about the same at bedtime as at breakfast.

That's what an update is. An event a few hours old is barely understood, and much of what's reported early turns out to be incomplete or wrong. Casualty figures change and motives are guessed and corrected. The hourly headline is the least checked, least digested form of news there is. It tells you something is happening. Explanation comes later, and at greater length.

Try this on Friday. Without looking anything up, write down what you remember of Monday's news, what's happened since, and why it matters. Most people who check constantly find it surprisingly hard. What's left is a general sense that things are bad.

By Saturday, Neil's paper has sorted the week. The stories that didn't matter have dropped away, and the ones that did have been explained, with background, by people who've had a few days to find out what happened. He spends perhaps two hours a week and gets an account with a beginning, a middle and some context. You spend an hour a day or more and get headlines. Homero Gil de Zúñiga and colleagues followed a panel of American adults and found that people who relied on news reaching them through their social feeds, without seeking it out, knew less about politics and fell further behind over time. You learn when you sit down intending to find something out, and much less when headlines simply pass in front of you, twice a day or twenty-five times.

Then safety. Some news carries an action. A weather warning for your area, a road closure on your route, a recall of something in your cupboard. You should have those, and they're a tiny share of what you see.

For the rest, think about how a story gets in. It gets in by being unusual. A stabbing two hundred miles away is reported because such things are rare. What's most likely to harm someone like you, heart disease, cancer, falls, road accidents close to home, happens every day, so it's never in the headlines. The news shows you vivid examples of rare dangers and almost none of the common ones, and your mind treats vivid as frequent.

The Crime Survey for England and Wales, which asks tens of thousands of people about their actual experience of crime, shows crime falling substantially from a peak in 1995. Throughout that fall, the same survey asked people whether crime in the country was going up or down. Year after year, most said up. The Office for National Statistics puts it bluntly. People's perceptions of crime at a national level don't typically match reality. But asked about their own local area, people's answers matched reality much better. Where people relied on their own eyes, they judged well. For the country, they relied on the news, and for twenty years they were wrong, always towards more fear.

If safety is what you're after, the dull sources serve you better. Your GP knows your real risks. The Met Office knows the weather.

And citizenship. A society works better when people understand the issues and notice when those in power misbehave, and if the alternative to checking were ignorance I'd tell you to carry on. But citizenship asks you to vote with a reasonable grasp of what the parties propose, to form views on large questions that change slowly, and perhaps to write to your MP or turn up at a local meeting. None of that is improved by the twenty-fourth look of the day. My own suspicion is that checking produces a feeling of participation, as if attention were a contribution, and that the feeling can stand in for action.

The residue

"It doesn't affect me." You've read bad news all your life. A headline about a distant war is sad, and then you get on with your day.

In the 1990s Johnston and Davey at the University of Sussex made three fourteen-minute news bulletins from real broadcast material, one negative, one positive and one neutral, and assigned volunteers to watch one. The negative bulletin left people more anxious and sadder, which is no surprise. The interesting part came next. Before and after, people were asked about a worry from their own life, nothing to do with the news. After the negative bulletin they were more inclined to catastrophise about their own worry, spinning it out towards worse and worse outcomes.

So a report about a war lowers your mood, and the lowered mood colours whatever else is on your mind. Your job, your health, the winter. That was the tightness in your chest on Monday morning.

Fourteen minutes is more than a glance. During the pandemic, Kathryn Buchanan and colleagues had people spend just two to four minutes on a social media feed of Covid news, or a short video about it. Those few minutes produced an immediate, measurable drop in positive mood, and in one study a drop in optimism too. A group shown stories of people being kind to each other during the pandemic had no drop.

Two to four minutes is about the length of one of your looks. You have twenty-five.

None of them ruins your day, which is why you don't notice. But they're spaced so the mood never quite recovers. People who say the news doesn't affect them are accurately reporting that they don't feel a strong emotion at a headline. The experiments don't measure strong emotions. They measure a small downward shift and a readiness to worry, which you'd notice in yourself about as much as the room getting slightly colder. You might only notice that you've gone quiet at dinner.

Much of what you read is reaction to news. The column, the furious thread, the clip of one politician attacking another. Steve Rathje, Jay Van Bavel and Sander van der Linden analysed 2.7 million posts from news organisations and American politicians on two large social networks. The strongest predictor of a post spreading was whether it was about the other side. Each extra word referring to the opposing group raised the odds of sharing by 67 per cent, several times the effect of negative language in general, and those posts mostly drew angry reactions.

So the opinion that reaches you has passed through a filter that favours anger at opponents, in the language of outrage, among people who already agree. The reasonable majority produce little that travels. If you know the other side mainly through its most enraging members, as relayed by your own, you'll conclude they're stupider and nastier than they are, and they'll conclude the same about you. The lunchtime column that made you angry took twenty minutes to read and cost you the first hour of the afternoon. Two or three commentators you trust, read at length once a week, including one you often disagree with, will tell you far more.

When something enormous happens, an attack or a war breaking out, following it hour by hour feels natural and even right.

In April 2013 two bombs went off at the finish line of the Boston Marathon. In the following weeks Alison Holman, Dana Rose Garfin and Roxane Cohen Silver surveyed nearly 4,700 Americans about symptoms of acute stress, such as intrusive thoughts and feeling on edge. They asked whether people had been directly exposed, by being there or being close to someone who was, and how many hours a day of bombing coverage they'd taken in that week. They also had measures of people's mental health from before the bombing.

People who'd taken in six or more hours a day of coverage reported higher acute stress than people who'd been directly exposed to the bombing itself.

That held after allowing for their earlier mental health. It's a survey, so it can't prove the coverage caused the stress, and the researchers think distressed people also sought out more coverage. A later study by the same group tracked more than four thousand people for three years. Heavy coverage of the bombing predicted more post-traumatic stress symptoms six months on, those predicted more worry about future events, and that worry predicted heavier viewing and more acute stress when the next atrocity came, the Orlando nightclub shooting in 2016. Following one event hour by hour seemed to leave people more vulnerable to the next.

Think what it involves. The worst thirty seconds of somebody's life, played forty times in a day, when someone who was really there saw it once. The most distressing material, at the time when it's least informative.

At the start of the Covid pandemic, the World Health Organization advised the public to minimise news that caused anxiety or distress, to seek information mainly to take practical steps, and to seek updates at specific times, once or twice a day. If that was enough for a pandemic that changed your daily life, it's enough for a crisis in a country you've never visited.

Turning it off can feel like a betrayal. People are living through a war, and the least you can do is watch.

Ask what your watching does for them. A family sheltering in a basement isn't made safer or less afraid by your sixth visit to the live page. Nobody in the story knows you're watching. What reaches people is money, time, votes and voices. A donation to an organisation working in the area. A standing order, which relief agencies can plan around. All of them cost time and attention, and an evening spent absorbing four crises leaves you drained, which in my view is a poor state for setting up a standing order. Someone who picks one or two causes and sticks with them for years does more good than someone who feels terrible about forty.

Haven't you heard

If you stopped checking, something would happen and you'd be the last to know.

List the news events of the last ten years that needed you, personally, to act within hours. A storm warning, perhaps, or a lockdown announcement, or a strike on your line. It's a short list, and every item on it would have reached you anyway, by a text from a friend, a word from a colleague or a government alert on your phone. That doesn't mean waiting for news to find you, which is how people end up knowing less. It means the single enormous event will reach you within the hour however little you check.

As for the social fear, picture it. A colleague says, "Did you see about the minister?" You say, "No, what's happened?" And they tell you, with some relish, because people enjoy being the one to tell. It's a better conversation than the one where you both already know and have nothing to exchange but sighs. Neil is sometimes the last to know by several days. He says "I haven't caught up with that yet, tell me", and people tell him.

Each look is nothing on its own. Thirty seconds at the kettle. So do the sum once. Twenty-five looks, some of thirty seconds, but a twenty-minute read at lunch and a half-hour bulletin at night. Somewhere between an hour and an hour and a half a day, which is seven to ten hours a week, a whole working day, spent on something you don't enjoy and learn little from. Neil's weekend read takes two.

Two of those looks matter more than the rest. The one before you're out of bed hands a missile strike and a stabbing to a mind that hasn't yet taken on the day, and sets the mood for the morning. The one last thing at night hands a final round of alarm to a mind trying to wind down. If you wake at three with a vague sense of threat, the look in bed may be part of the reason.

The looks run on cues. The phone in your hand, a pause, the kettle, the platform. You don't decide to check, any more than you decide to scratch an itch. That's good news, because habits that run on cues weaken quickly when the cues change.

What else does it cost?

Bryan McLaughlin and colleagues surveyed a national sample of American adults and identified a group whose news consumption they called problematic. These people were absorbed and preoccupied by it, checked compulsively, and found it interfering with their lives. They reported markedly worse mental and physical health, even after allowing for personality and for how much news they consumed overall. What mattered was the compulsion. It was a survey, so the arrow could run both ways, and Holman and Silver's work suggests it does.

Then there's the house. When you come to breakfast with the tightness in your chest, everyone at the table gets a quieter, tenser version of you, and Jo has probably wondered whether it's something she's done. "Have you seen what's happened?" is how a lot of bad news travels, because alarm wants company. Before you pass a headline on, ask whether the other person needs to know it, or whether you just need to say it. Children hear more than you think, and haven't an adult's sense of distance. A war two thousand miles away doesn't sound two thousand miles away to a child. They're better off hearing about frightening things from you, calmly, than from the television in the corner.

And there's hope. Forty pieces of bad news a day and almost no good news produce a settled view that everything is getting worse. Some things are. Others aren't. Over the last few decades deaths of children under five have fallen enormously worldwide, and so has extreme poverty, though progress on poverty has slowed lately. Those are among the biggest stories of our lifetimes, and they're almost never in the headlines, because nobody could put a date on them. I'm not saying the world is fine. You just can't assess it from a selection made by what frightens you.

Six o'clock

Here's the rule.

I take in the news once a day, at a time I've chosen, from a source that has an end. Then I close it.

  • Choose the time. One slot, twenty to thirty minutes. Avoid the first hour after waking and the last hour before bed. Early evening suits many people, and so does mid-morning.
  • Choose a source that ends. A radio or television bulletin, a newspaper, a daily newsletter, a programme of fixed length. A website front page can work if you read down it once and stop. Social media feeds and live pages don't qualify.
  • Then close it. Whatever happens in the next twenty-three hours, you'll hear about tomorrow, and if it's truly enormous someone will tell you.
  • Change the cues. Turn off every news notification on your phone. Move news apps off your home screen, or delete them and use the website at your appointment. Close the tab at work. Charge the phone outside the bedroom, and buy an alarm clock if you need one. If the car radio gives you headlines every half hour, switch to music or something recorded.
  • Keep the news you can act on. Weather warnings, travel disruption, school closures, government emergency alerts and council notices aren't checking. Set them up as specific alerts, apart from the news app.
  • For a major event, allow a second appointment, as the World Health Organization advised. Read a considered summary, and don't replay the footage.
  • Once a week, read at length. A weekly paper on Saturday, as Neil does, or two or three long articles saved during the week, on the few subjects you've chosen to follow properly. Now and then, read a book about one of them.

Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran pooled 94 tests of "when this happens, I'll do that" plans and found they made people a good deal more likely to follow through. When I pick up my phone in a spare moment and think of the news, I'll put it down and look at whatever's in front of me for ten seconds. When someone asks "have you seen what's happened?", I'll say "no, tell me", and I won't look it up afterwards. When a big story breaks and I want to follow it live, I'll wait for my appointment and read one full account.

The small empty moments will still come, at the kettle and on the platform. You don't have to fill them. A minute looking out of a train window does you no harm.

And pick one cause, find one organisation, and set up one regular gift of money or time. Then the wish to do something about the world has somewhere to go.

For the first week, by my estimate, your thumb will go to where the app was many times a day, a small itch that passes in seconds. Something will be happening, and you'll read about it at six. By the second or third week many people feel calmer in a way they hadn't expected, and realise the background dread had been there so long they'd stopped noticing it. You'll slip, probably during a big story. When you notice you've been on a live page for forty minutes, close it, and keep your appointment the next day.

If the news is about you, because your family is in the war zone or your town is the one flooding, following closely is reasonable. Use the most direct sources you have, official alerts, the relevant embassy or agency, the people on the ground you know, and set times for looking, even six a day, so there are also times when you aren't. People close to an event are the most exposed to the cycle the Boston researchers found. In a local emergency, follow the police, the council, the Met Office, the Environment Agency and the NHS, and turn on emergency alerts. For an election, an hour with the manifestos or a good summary helps you vote far more than the daily polls and rows. If the news is your job, do it at work and stop when work stops.

If you live alone and the news is company, music, drama, sport and audiobooks all put voices in the room without the dread, and a phone call does more for a quiet house than the news does. If a health story has you checking symptoms for hours, the NHS website or your GP will answer the practical question better than a headline. If someone you live with has the news on all day, ask for news-free times, meals and the bedroom. When children need to hear about something frightening, tell them yourself, briefly and calmly, in words that suit their age, and keep rolling coverage off when they're in the room.

If you've kept the rule for a month and you're still anxious most days, the news wasn't the main cause. See your GP, or refer yourself to NHS talking therapies.

It's a Monday some months on, and the alarm goes at ten past seven. It's a real alarm clock, a cheap one with a loud tick you've got used to. The phone is downstairs on the hall table. You lie there and think about the day, a meeting at ten you're slightly dreading, the dentist at four, dinner with Jo's sister. Your own life.

On the train you're reading a long book about the history of the region where the missile strike was. You started it because after a year of headlines you couldn't have explained the conflict to a twelve-year-old. You're two hundred pages in, and you could now.

At about eleven a colleague says, "Did you see the minister's gone?" You say, "No, has he? What happened in the end?" She tells you, with evident enjoyment. It's the best conversation you've had with her in weeks.

At six you put the radio on while you start the dinner. Half an hour. A correspondent who's followed the minister for months spends four minutes explaining why he went. When the programme ends you turn it off.

In the spring there was a terrible attack in a European city, and you spent most of an evening on a live page before you noticed the state you were in. You closed it. The next day one long account told you more than the whole evening had.

On Saturdays you read a weekly over a late breakfast, and you and Neil swap articles. A standing order goes every month to a medical charity in the region you're reading about.

A few weeks ago Jo said, "You're back." You asked what she meant. She said she wasn't sure, only that you'd been somewhere else for a couple of years and now you were here.

Turn off the news notifications on your phone now, all of them. Then decide what time tomorrow you'll sit down with the news, and what you'll read.