The next episode

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 53 min

It's half past nine. The kitchen's done, the children are down, and you've got an hour before bed. You put on the drama with the body in the lake, and you've said, to yourself or to the person beside you, one episode.

It's good. At quarter past ten the detective opens a door and sees something, the screen goes black, the credits start, and a small box in the corner says the next episode will play in five, four, three. You don't stop it. You didn't decide not to stop it either. By the time you've thought about it, the new episode is two minutes in, the thing behind the door has been explained, and there's a new thing. At eleven, the same. At twenty to midnight the third one ends and you switch off, because it's twenty to midnight, and you lie in bed with the lake in your head and the alarm set for seven.

Tomorrow you're flat. Not ruined. Just a bit short with someone at work, and you say you'll stop at one tonight. At half past nine you put it on.

That's invented, but I'd guess yours is close.

Here's the case I'll make. The habit makes sense from the inside, since the show is good, the evening is yours, and when the countdown appears, carrying on is easier than stopping. But you didn't decide to watch the next one. A countdown did. The cliffhanger at the end of each episode is built to produce a wanting that the next one settles in its first two minutes. Heavy viewing of episodes back to back goes with worse sleep, through a mind still running when your head hits the pillow, where ordinary viewing doesn't. And the credits used to be where you stopped, until autoplay took them away. The practical answer is to turn autoplay off, decide the number before the first episode, and stop at the credits.

You don't have to watch less television, give up the series you love, or feel bad about a Sunday afternoon on the sofa. The point is that you decide how many, instead of a timer in the corner of the screen.

Two cautions. If the television is on until midnight because the quiet after it is unbearable, or the day has nothing else in it, or your mood has been low most of the day for a fortnight, that isn't autoplay. See a GP. And if you sleep badly most nights whether or not the television is on, the NHS insomnia pages say when to see a GP, and they're worth reading alongside this.

One thing first. For a week, keep a list. Each night, write how many episodes you planned, how many you watched, what time the screen went off, and one word for how the morning felt. Change nothing. Most people find the planned column says one or two all week, the watched column says three, and the morning column has the same word all the way down.

Nobody pressed play

The third episode was never a decision.

Eric Johnson and Daniel Goldstein, in 2003, published a short paper in Science about defaults. They compared countries where people are organ donors unless they opt out with countries where people aren't donors unless they opt in. The donor rates were vastly different, and the people weren't. The default was. Where you had to act to become a donor, most people didn't. Where you had to act to stop being one, most people stayed. When people don't actively choose, the default chooses for them, even on decisions that matter enormously.

Now watch the countdown. Five, four, three. Do nothing and the next one plays. Doing nothing is the default, and doing nothing is what most people do. At quarter past ten on a sofa, with the remote on the far arm, you didn't choose another episode. You declined to interrupt something that was going to play it anyway. The first episode was a choice. The third was a countdown reaching zero with a person sitting in front of it.

Ten years ago the credits rolled, the screen went to a menu, and it stayed there. To watch the next episode you had to pick up the remote and choose it. The default was stopping, and most people, most nights, stopped. They weren't more disciplined than you. Think of a door that closes on its own unless someone holds it. Nobody walking through decides to close it, and it closes every time. Back then the door swung their way. Nothing about you has changed since then except which way the door swings.

"But I can stop whenever I want."

You can, the way everyone in the opt-in countries could have filled in the form. The ability isn't in question. What's changed is which side needs the act. Stopping used to need nothing, and now it needs a button, pressed in a five-second window, against a timer, at the moment the show has made you least willing to press it. The countdown doesn't have to be stronger than you. It only has to be placed where you're weakest and wait for you to do nothing.

Then there's the sentence. Just one more. You say it at quarter past ten and again at eleven, and each time it's true, because one more is one more.

Emily Walton-Pattison and colleagues, in 2018, surveyed eighty-six people about their binge watching over the previous week. They reported doing it on about one and a half days a week on average. Their intentions and their expectations of what watching would bring explained some of the variation. Three other things each explained more. How automatic the viewing was. How much they expected to regret it. And how much it got in the way of something else they meant to do. It's a small survey and I'd hold the numbers lightly, but the shape is clear. What people call one more episode runs on automaticity, comes with regret they can see coming, and collides with their other plans.

Look at your list. Planned, one. Watched, three. That's one pattern running every night, and "just one more" is what makes it feel like a fresh small choice each time. The "just" does work too. It shrinks the episode to forty-five minutes, hardly anything, and leaves out that it's the third and it's eleven o'clock.

Autoplay is on by default and the setting to turn it off is a few menus deep. That isn't an accident. Johnson and Goldstein's finding is that the side needing an act is the side fewer people reach. If autoplay were off unless you dug for it, most people would never see a countdown, and the services know that. It takes about two minutes per service to turn off. The weekend, where you were planning to do it, is where settings go to stay unchanged.

Then there's the door itself, and when the wanting arrived.

It wasn't there at half past nine. It arrived in the last two minutes of the episode, at minute forty-four, when the writers put the door there. The final scene was built to produce, in you, a need to see the next scene, and it produced it on schedule, and it felt like your own. It would have been produced in anyone sitting where you were. Then the next one starts, and within two minutes you know what was behind the door, and the need is gone. You're now watching an episode you hadn't planned, with the reason for watching it already spent. For forty-two minutes there's a story, which is fine, and then at minute forty-four there's another door. The wanting is built, settled and rebuilt on a cycle the length of an episode, and the countdown sits exactly where it peaks.

That's my reading of how episodes are made, not a finding from a study. I doubt anyone who writes them would dispute it. It works on everyone, and it's meant to.

So the need to know is real. It'll also be real tomorrow. The door will be there at half past nine tomorrow, and what's behind it won't have changed, and the two minutes that settle it will be just as satisfying. The answer doesn't go off overnight. The only difference is that tomorrow it comes at the start of your evening, when you have time, and not at the end, when you have an alarm.

"I'll just watch the first two minutes, to see."

Look at what's in those two minutes. The door opens and the answer comes, and then, in the same scene, a phone rings or a face changes or a car pulls up outside. The writers know the answer to a cliff is where a viewer might leave, so they put the next hook in the same breath. The peek is built to defeat exactly what you're using it for. In my observation, and it's only that, the two-minute peek ends at the credits of the episode it started, nearly every time. And if two minutes were enough, the cliff was only ever two minutes deep.

Finishing the series doesn't end it either. The drama has eight episodes, and the last one sets up the second series, which is waiting in the row underneath, and when that ends the service recommends something very like it with a door at the end of its first episode. Good series set up their next series. That's craft. But it means "I'll finish this and then stop" waits for an ending the catalogue is built never to provide. The stop has to come first, at the credits, and then the series gets finished at your pace. Even mid-episode is fine. The show resumes from the same second tomorrow.

The fear of missing out works the same way. Everyone at work is on episode six and you're on three. But the whole series is sitting on the service. There's no schedule any more, apart from the one the conversation in the kitchen supplies, and the people on episode six aren't ahead of you. They're just more tired. Say "I'm only on three, don't tell me" once and most people will hold off. If someone tells you anyway, you'll watch episode four regardless, because the door was never the point of a good drama. The story was, and it's still there.

Here's what three in a row does to a show you love. Try to remember what happened in episode two of the last series you finished. You probably know the story and not the episode, because the episodes went in as one long thing at the end of tired days.

Amit Kumar, Matthew Killingsworth and Thomas Gilovich, in 2014, ran four studies on anticipation and found that waiting for an experience was itself a pleasure, more so than waiting for a possession, and that the waiting was part of what the experience was worth. An episode is an experience. When episodes went out weekly, a cliff gave you seven days of wondering and theories and talk, and the answer landed on all of that. Now the wondering lasts five seconds.

You don't have to wait a week. One a night is enough. The door opens at quarter past ten, the credits roll, and you go to bed with it in your head. It's still there in the morning as a small pleasant question, and at half past nine you sit down knowing you're about to find out. People who try this say they'd forgotten how good the drama was.

Twenty to midnight

"It's relaxing."

The first episode was. Whether the third one was is a different question.

Liese Exelmans and Jan Van den Bulck, in 2017, surveyed four hundred and twenty-three adults aged eighteen to twenty-five about their viewing and their sleep. Four in five called themselves binge viewers. Those who binge viewed more often had poorer sleep, more fatigue and more symptoms of insomnia. Ordinary viewing wasn't linked to any of that. The researchers traced the link to what they called cognitive pre-sleep arousal, a mind still active when you lie down, and that arousal explained the whole of it. These were young adults and it was a survey, so it can't prove the viewing caused the bad sleep. The pattern is still the one to hold. Television on its own wasn't the problem. Several episodes in a row were, because a mind fed three cliffs in an evening doesn't switch off when the screen does.

Viola Granow and colleagues, in 2018, surveyed nearly five hundred people and found watching several episodes raised wellbeing when it felt like the viewer's own choice and didn't get in the way of anything. When it collided with things they meant to do and left them guilty, it lowered wellbeing. Same sofa, same hours. Whether it counted as rest depended on whether it was chosen and what it cost.

The third episode at twenty to midnight wasn't chosen, collided with bed, and left the lake running in your head.

"But I'm not tired."

At ten you were. At eleven, after the second credits, you feel alert, and alert people don't go to bed. Anne-Marie Chang and colleagues, in 2015, had people read before bed on some nights from a printed book and on others from a light-emitting e-reader. On the device nights they took longer to fall asleep, felt less sleepy in the evening, produced less melatonin, had their body clocks pushed later, and were less alert the next morning. That was e-readers, not televisions, so take it with that caution. The direction is what matters. A bright screen in the evening makes you feel less tired than you are, and a story full of doors adds a mind that's busy. The tiredness at ten was real. The second wind at eleven was made on the sofa. Ten o'clock you was right.

The same answer meets "I can't sleep straight after anyway". If you stop at quarter past ten you'll lie there, so you might as well watch another and go up when you're tired. But the arousal is the reason you lie there, and the third episode adds to it. What brings it down is twenty minutes of something that isn't a screen. A kettle, ten pages, the kitchen wiped, a conversation. Most people who try it find they're asleep by eleven within a week, and that "I can't sleep straight after" had really meant straight after three episodes.

"It's my time. I've earned it." The need for time that's yours is real and I won't argue with it. But half past nine and twenty to midnight are different hours. At half past nine you're awake, you chose the episode, and you're enjoying a good drama. At twenty to midnight you're tired, a countdown chose it, and you'll barely remember the last forty minutes. The first hour is what you earned. The overrun is what autoplay charged you, and the person paying is you at seven the next morning.

For couples, the sofa is the evening together. Look at what together means at twenty to midnight, though. Two people facing a screen, one of them asleep. The talking happened, if it happened, at the credits of the first episode, when someone said "what was behind the door?" and someone else said "I reckon it's the brother". Then the countdown hit zero and the next one started. The menu used to be where two tired people looked at each other and decided. Another one? Tea? Bed? Do you actually like this show? The menu is also where one of you can admit you're only watching the lake to keep the other company. The countdown never asks. Autoplay took that small nightly conversation, and some couples find it was what they'd been missing all along.

Then the quick ones.

  • "Everyone binges now." Four in five of Exelmans's young adults said so, and the same survey shows the heaviest viewers sleeping worst. Common and costless are different things. Binge was a word for drinking before the services adopted it, cheerfully, as a feature. Someone on a sofa at twenty to midnight isn't really bingeing anyway. They're watching the next one because it started.
  • "I've paid for it." Fourteen pounds a month, the same for one episode as for thirty. The extra episode costs no money, only sleep. And the catalogue can't be finished, so watching to get your money's worth never ends. Using it well means watching what you chose, at a pace you set, and remembering it.

The bill lands at seven the next morning. The NHS says adults need seven to nine hours, and a screen off at twenty to midnight with the alarm at seven is under that before you've even fallen asleep. Then the flat morning and the extra coffee. A plan broken every night, with the breaking foreseen at the countdown, which teaches you a little each night that your plans don't hold. Guilt as the first feeling of the day, attached to something that was meant to be rest. And whole evenings with only one thing in them, chosen by a timer. There's a quieter cost as well. Years of not pressing stop against a countdown is a thousand rehearsals of letting a default decide, and defaults are everywhere.

One, and then the kettle

Find the setting tonight, before the next episode.

It's usually under playback, account or preferences, called autoplay next episode or play next automatically or something close. Turn it off. Do the service you watch most first. The setting on the television may not carry over to the tablet, laptop or phone, so check each device you watch on. Most services also autoplay trailers when you hover over a title, usually in the same screen, so turn that off too. If a service won't let you, the remote goes on the far side of the room before you press play, so carrying on at least costs you a stand.

What comes back is the credits. An episode ends, the screen shows a menu, and nothing happens until you act. Stopping is the default again, and the default is where most people end up most nights.

Then decide the number before the first episode. One, or two. Say it aloud if someone's there. "One tonight." A plan made at half past nine is made by someone who isn't yet under a cliff, so write it in the planned column before you press play. The number can change by night, two on a Friday and one in the week, as long as it's set before the episode and never during the countdown. Fit the show to the number as well. A drama with a door at the end of every episode is a one-a-night show. A comedy whose episodes just end is a two-a-night show.

The stop is the credits of the last one you said. Not the first two minutes of the next.

When the door opens and the need arrives, ask one question. Will I still be able to find out tomorrow? The answer is always yes. Then stand up, screen off, kettle on. A stop with something after it holds far better than sitting in the menu with the remote in your hand.

If you watch with someone, say the number to them before the first one, not at the last credits when one of you is already reaching for the remote. Two people who've both said "one" are harder to move. If they want two and you want bed, you can watch one and go up. It gets easier after the first time.

Last, the evening around it. Pick the hour the evening ends by working back from your alarm and the seven to nine hours adults need, and treat that hour as fixed. With a seven o'clock alarm it's somewhere between ten and half past. If an episode is forty-five minutes and the end is half past ten, one episode starts by twenty to ten and two start before nine. When the last credits roll, the end of the day begins. Ten pages, a bath, the kitchen tidied, a conversation about the brother. Something that isn't a screen.

Some people don't overrun. They fall asleep in the second episode and wake at one with the menu glowing. Same habit, different ending. If you're asleep by the second, the tiredness at ten was telling the truth, so stop at one and go up awake.

The decision fits in a sentence. Autoplay is off, I decide the number before the first episode, and I stop at the credits.

Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran reviewed ninety-four studies in 2006 of plans in the form "when this happens, I'll do that", and found people who planned that way followed through much more often than people who only held the intention. So write three.

When I sit down to watch something, I'll say how many episodes before I press play.

When the last credits roll and I want to know what happens, I'll ask whether I can find out tomorrow, and stand up.

When the screen goes off, I'll put the kettle on and read for ten minutes before bed.

This part is my expectation and not a finding. The first night, the menu will appear where the countdown was and you'll feel a small absence. You'll sit a moment and then decide, and most nights it'll be bed, and quarter past ten will feel early. For a week the cliff will be loud, and standing up during it will feel like leaving a room mid-sentence. By the second week you'll have found out six or seven times that the door was still there in the morning. The mornings change first. Around the third week there's a Tuesday that isn't flat. The end time will feel like a child's bedtime for a while too. That's the second wind talking. Give it a few weeks and half past ten feels like the end of an evening, because it has become one.

A four on a Friday

It's a Friday that felt like a Saturday. There's a new series with a door at the end of every episode, and an update has quietly switched autoplay back on, and it's midnight and you've watched four.

Check the setting before you do anything else. Updates turn it back on more often than you'd think, and a countdown where there wasn't one is the first sign.

Then work out which cliff got through. If it was a series with harder doors than usual, the remote goes across the room for that one. If you sat down without saying a number, write it on the list before the first episode for a fortnight. If a partner wanted more and you went along, talk about it at a different hour.

A four is a night's sleep short and a flat Saturday morning. That's all of it. Last year it was every night and had no name. Don't count nights without an overrun. Count the mornings that weren't flat.

Weekends can have a bigger number when the alarm isn't at seven, and the end time moves with the morning. The rule is the same. The number is said before the first episode and the stop is the credits, because a Saturday that ends at two is a Sunday spent recovering.

A chosen binge is a different thing and this is all for it. A wet Sunday, a series you've been saving, four episodes and a pot of tea, decided at lunchtime by someone who wasn't under a cliff. Say four at lunch and stop at four. That's what the subscription is for, far more than twenty to midnight on a Tuesday.

Children can't be expected to stop against a countdown when adults can't. Lauren Hale and Stanford Guan, in 2015, reviewed sixty-seven studies of screens and sleep in school-aged children and teenagers, and ninety per cent found screen time linked with worse sleep, mainly shorter and later, though they were careful to say causation isn't proven. Autoplay off on every device a child uses is the biggest single thing you can do for their bedtime.

And if it was never really the countdown, if the television stays on because the quiet after it is hard to bear, or the day is something to be got to the end of, or your mood has been low most of the day for two weeks, then a GP is where to start. If the nights are bad with or without the screen, the NHS insomnia pages say when to go. Turning autoplay off won't hurt. It just isn't a treatment for either.

It's half past nine, some months on. You put on the new one, with the lighthouse, and say "one" to the person beside you, and they say "one" back. At quarter past ten the keeper finds the letter, the screen goes black, the credits start, and nothing happens. The menu sits there.

"It's the daughter," they say.

"It's not the daughter," you say, and you put the kettle on.

You read ten pages in bed with the letter at the back of your mind, and you're asleep by eleven. Somewhere in the afternoon, at work, you think about the letter and look forward to half past nine.

The list lives in the kitchen drawer now. Most nights the planned and watched columns say the same thing, and the morning column has a different word in it from the one it used to have.

Your daughter asked last month why the television stops now. You told her, and she rolled her eyes. On Thursday you heard her on the landing with her tablet, saying "one, and then bed" to herself, and you didn't say anything.

Tonight, before the episode, find the setting and turn autoplay off, and say how many before you press play.