The phone can wait

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 53 min

You go into the kitchen to make tea. You fill the kettle and switch it on, and it'll take about two minutes to boil. Somewhere in the first ten seconds your phone comes out of your pocket. You didn't decide to take it out. If someone had asked what you were about to look up, you wouldn't have had an answer.

Messages, nothing new since you looked in the hall. The news, a headline and half a paragraph. The app with the photos, where you thumb past a holiday, an advert for trainers and a dog. The kettle clicks off, and you carry on for another minute because you're halfway through a video of a man restoring a rusty vice. The tea is a bit stewed.

Nothing bad has happened.

That's what makes the habit hard to take seriously. No single reach costs anything you'd notice. It's only across the whole day that the pattern shows, in the lift, at the lights, in the queue at the chemist, in the car outside the school. Every gap got filled, and all with the same thing. By evening you haven't done anything strenuous and your head feels used. You've had a dozen little rests and you don't feel rested.

I'm not going to tell you to get rid of your phone, which is your map, your bank and the way your family reaches you, or that scrolling is rotting your brain. I don't think the evidence says that. My argument is narrower. Two different acts look the same from across the room.

The first I'll call an errand. You pick up the phone to do something you could name before you touched it. Check the train. Answer your sister. Pay the window cleaner. An errand has an end, and when the train time is on the screen it's over. I've no quarrel with errands, however many you run.

The second is a reach. You pick up the phone with nothing in mind. It starts from a gap, any short stretch in which nothing is required of you, and because it didn't begin with a purpose, nothing marks where it's finished. It stops when something outside stops it, the kettle or the lift doors or someone saying your name for the second time. Most people's reaches go round the same three or four places in the same order, and I'll call that the loop. You can go round it, find nothing new, and start again without noticing.

An errand can turn into a reach the moment it's done. You answer your sister, and since the phone's in your hand, off you go round the loop. The test is simple. Could you have said what you were picking it up for? And when that was done, did you put it down?

One caution. For most people the reach is a habit. For some the phone is doing a heavier job, covering low mood, loneliness, or anxiety that comes up whenever things go quiet, or it's the way into gambling, spending or pornography that has got out of hand. Those are different problems, and there's a note on where to take them near the end. If you take medication for mood or anxiety, nothing here is a reason to stop it or change the dose.

Tomorrow, keep a scrap of paper and a pen in your pocket. Each time you find the phone in your hand without an errand, make a mark. Don't try to reach less. Count the marks at the end of the day and keep the paper.

A more colourful report

Nobody does something eighty times a day for nothing.

The main payment is a way out of the empty moment. Standing in a kitchen for two minutes with nothing to do is mildly uncomfortable, about the size of an itch, and the phone removes the itch at once. There's also the chance of something nice, which you can't rule out without looking. There's the feeling of being in touch, and of being on top of things. And there's a way out of something hard, like a difficult email or a child explaining a game for the ninth minute.

Those are real. But four of them last about as long as the reach does. Feeling in touch isn't the same as having been in touch with anybody, and feeling on top of things fades within minutes, which is why you check again. Only the occasional nice thing leaves you with something, and it would still have been there at six o'clock.

The costs are undramatic, which is why nobody counts them. A filled gap is gone. The reach rarely stays the length of the gap, so the kettle takes two minutes and the reach takes six. It hands your mood to whatever happens to be there, a war, a former colleague's new kitchen, an email with "quick question" in the subject line.

The biggest cost is the one at the centre of the habit. It feels like a rest.

You've been concentrating for an hour, and five minutes with the phone feels like putting a weight down. You have stopped the tiring thing. But a tired mind recovers when it has less to process. Think about thirty seconds of the loop. A headline to react to. A photo of someone you know, setting off a small comparison whether you want it or not. An advert, which takes a tiny act of ignoring. A message, and a decision about whether to answer now or later. Each item is light, and they arrive several a minute, and taking them in and judging them is the same kind of work that tired you in the first place. It's like taking a break from reading reports by reading a different, more colourful report.

Two studies have tested this. Researchers at Rutgers gave 414 people a set of word puzzles. Partway through, some took a short break choosing items for a shopping list on a phone, a computer or paper, and some had no break. The paper and computer groups came back refreshed. The phone group solved far fewer puzzles than they did, and were no quicker than people who'd had no break at all. In the second study, researchers in the Netherlands followed 83 PhD students through real working days, logging every phone use and asking each hour how tired and bored they felt. People picked up the phone more when they were tired or bored, as you'd expect. Afterwards they felt more tired and more bored. The authors call this exploratory, since watching people can't prove cause. The two studies still point the same way, and so have your evenings.

"I enjoy it. Something funny on the sofa at nine makes me feel better." I believe you. Half an hour of things you like, chosen and sat down to, is entertainment, and that's a good thing. Just don't ask it to be rest. Real short rest is a few minutes in which less comes in. A window. A walk to the end of the corridor. Eyes shut on a train. None of it is exciting, which is the point.

"It's only a minute." Taken one at a time, that's right, and you don't get to take them one at a time. In a small British study, people guessed they picked up their phones about 37 times a day. A logging app recorded about 85, more than half of them under thirty seconds, and people's guesses bore no relation to their real counts. It was a small study. Whatever your tally says, the real figure is higher, because you only marked the ones you noticed. Most reaches happen below the level at which you decide anything.

And the minute often isn't one. While the kettle boils, the kettle interrupts it. On the sofa at ten past nine, nothing does, and you look up to find forty minutes gone.

Then there's what the minute does to the time around it. Sophie Leroy found that when people switch tasks, part of their attention stays behind with the first one, which she called attention residue. She studied switches between pieces of work, not phones, but a reach mid-task is a switch away and a switch back. When you return, part of your mind is still on the headline about interest rates. A day broken into eighty pieces is like reading a novel one page at a time, closing it and putting it back on the shelf between pages. You'd get through it, and wonder why reading had become such hard work.

The fridge door

Some reaches are checks. Someone may have replied. Something may have happened. It would only take a second, and then you could relax.

Sometimes there is something. The friend has said yes to Saturday. The school has rung. But mostly there's nothing, and now and then a real reward, and you can't predict which. A reward that comes every time builds a habit that fades fast when the reward stops. One that comes unpredictably builds a habit that survives long runs of nothing, so the empty checks keep it going. If you've opened the fridge, found nothing, and opened it again ten minutes later in case something had appeared, you know the shape. The fridge never rewards you. The phone occasionally does.

Does checking less just leave you anxious? In an experiment with 237 people, one group got phone notifications as normal, one in three batches a day, and one not at all. The batch group did best. They felt more attentive and productive, in a better mood and less stressed. The group with none got few of those gains and felt more anxious and more afraid of missing out. So the urge to check isn't foolish. People need to know that what's important will reach them, and cut off completely, the need goes unmet. What worked was information arriving on a schedule people could trust.

That suggests a split. A small class of things can't wait an hour, like a call from the school, a message from your partner, or whatever your job treats as urgent. Everything else can. Right now both come through one habit, so you check eighty times to be sure of the first class. If that class can reach you by making a noise, you don't need to go looking for it.

You're in a queue with four people ahead of you. There's a rack of cough sweets and the back of a man's coat, and in your pocket is everything ever written, filmed or sung. It seems perverse not to use it.

Queues are boring, and boredom is more unpleasant than people admit. In studies led by Timothy Wilson, people sat alone in a bare room with nothing to do but think, and most didn't enjoy it. In one, there was a button that gave a mild electric shock, which they'd all felt beforehand and said they'd pay to avoid. Left alone, 12 of the 18 men and 6 of the 24 women pressed it at least once. Wanting out of an empty moment is ordinary, and it was ordinary before phones.

The question is whether the phone cures it. The Dutch students were more bored after a reach, not less. And in experiments at the University of Toronto, people made to skip from one short video to the next ended up more bored than those who watched one thing through, even when they picked videos they liked, though the effect was less clear outside students and video. Enjoyment seems to come from being absorbed, and switching works against it. A reach in a two-minute gap is almost all switching. You sample six things in ninety seconds and none of them gets hold of you.

And boredom in a short gap changes if you stay in it more than a few seconds. Given nothing, attention goes looking, and drifts to what you'll cook tonight or something you forgot to do. If the phone comes out at the first twinge, all you ever get of an empty gap is its first five seconds, which are the worst ones. I suspect, without a study to show it, that filling every gap also lowers your tolerance for an empty one, so two minutes starts to feel long. Test that on yourself. Once a day for a week, leave the kettle gap empty, with the phone in another room. Compare the first day with the seventh.

"It keeps me in touch." Phones carry real contact. A group chat with your brothers, a video call with a parent abroad, the photo of the grandchildren at lunchtime. Those are errands, with someone on the other end.

Going round the loop is a different thing. You look at what people posted, say nothing, and they never know you were there. One research team found that passive browsing on Facebook was followed by a fall in mood, through envy, while posting and messaging didn't show the same effect. That was one platform, a decade ago. But what people post is the best tenth of what happened to them, and looking at it feels like contact and has the content of a newsletter. The reach also costs the contact you're already in. In one experiment, people out for a meal with friends who kept their phones on the table enjoyed it less, because they felt distracted.

So when you see something from someone you care about, turn it into an errand. Send them two lines. Ring them on the way home. If you wouldn't bother, you've learned how much you needed the post.

The last version is the reach at the hard point. You're writing a reply to a complaint, the first two paragraphs went fine, and now you've reached the part where you have to say no, politely, and you don't know how. You read your last sentence again. Your hand goes to the phone. Four minutes later you come back, read the sentence again, and still don't know how to put it.

A phone break here refreshes you less than other breaks, as the puzzle study showed, and loads you with new material just when you need a clear head. My own reading is that the point where a task gets hard is often where it's about to move. Not knowing how to put the refusal is the work. Stay in it another minute or two and a clumsy first version usually turns up, and a clumsy version can be fixed. Leave at that moment every time and the hard part of every task becomes the signal to reach. If you really are stuck, take the break people took before phones. Get a glass of water. Look at the car park. When you sit down again, the last thing in your head is still the sentence.

Twenty steps

Most reaches start with you.

You'll have read that none of this is your fault, because the apps are built by clever people paid to keep you looking. A good deal of that is true. The feed has no bottom, the next video starts by itself, and the red badge is red for a reason. That explains why a reach, once begun, runs on.

It explains much less about why the phone got into your hand. Researchers at the London School of Economics had 37 people wear small cameras through their days. Of 1,130 phone uses recorded, 89 per cent were picked up unprompted. Only 11 per cent began with a notification. The authors concluded the disruption came mainly from learned habits, more than from the devices. So if you've switched off notifications and still reach as often, that's why. Switching them off deals with about one reach in nine.

I find that encouraging. You can't redesign an app. A habit lives in your routines and your pockets, and those you can change.

It's also why I don't use the word addiction. Two researchers in Barcelona reviewed the studies and concluded the label wasn't earned, since the harm doesn't reach the severity the word implies in medicine. Not every researcher agrees. My reason is practical. If you believe you're addicted you'll expect cravings, quitting and relapse. If you see a habit, you'll look at cues and routines.

Most people who've tried to cut down resolved to use the phone less, meant it, and lasted until about eleven the next morning. They concluded something about their character.

Willpower was the wrong tool. Resisting by willpower would mean catching an action that begins below awareness, eighty times a day, and winning every time. Nobody does that with anything. A habit runs on a cue, an easy action and a small reward, and with enough repeats it runs without a decision in between, so it barely cares what you think of it. What it responds to is whether the cue turns up and how easy the action is.

Angela Duckworth and two colleagues sorted the ways people control themselves along a timeline. The late method is gritting your teeth with the temptation in front of you. The early methods change the situation before the impulse forms, like a student going to the library and leaving the phone at home. They argue the early methods work better, and get undervalued because there's no struggle in them. A person who doesn't keep biscuits in the house isn't weaker than one who keeps them and resists. She thought about it earlier, when thinking was easy.

For the phone that comes down to distance and friction. A phone in your pocket is in your hand before any thought. A phone on the shelf in the hall is twenty steps away, and twenty steps is long enough to notice what you're doing and ask what for. Inside the phone, apps on the first screen and logged in cost three taps. In a folder on the last screen, behind a password, each reach costs a little more, and some won't seem worth it.

"People have to be able to reach me." Then they need to hear it ring, and a phone on the hall shelf with the ringer on does that. You'll still feel the urge with the phone twenty steps away. It'll be weaker, you'll notice it, and willpower can handle that one.

Then there's the fear underneath. If you stop filling every gap, what will you do with dozens of empty ones a day, and what might come up in them?

Honestly, empty moments aren't always pleasant. Two Harvard researchers found people's minds wandered almost half the time, and that they were less happy when it did. Sometimes your mind will drift to the argument with your brother or the state of your savings. But that thought is still there at eleven at night when the phone goes off and the room goes dark, which is a poor time to meet it for the first time that day. Two minutes of it by the kettle, in daylight, is cheaper, and it's when "I should just ring him" tends to occur to people.

A drifting mind also does work that doesn't feel like work. In one lab study, people given an easy, mind-wandering task during a break came back better at creative problems they'd already seen than people who'd done a demanding task, rested, or had no break. It matches the old observation that answers arrive in the shower. A kettle gap is close to the easy task. With the phone in it, it's more like the demanding one.

And in a gap you find out how you are. You notice you're thirsty, or your shoulders are up by your ears. You remember the form that has to be back by Friday. The conversation you've just had settles and you realise what she meant. You see what's in front of you, which sometimes includes your own children. None of that happens on demand. It happens when nothing else is happening.

So you don't need to do anything with the gaps. Don't fill them with a language app instead. A person waiting for a kettle doesn't need a project.

The phone has a home

The phone comes out for an errand, and it goes away when the errand is done.

It doesn't limit errands or ban apps, and it doesn't ask you to give anything up for good. In a German experiment with 619 people, a week without smartphones and a week of an hour less a day both reduced anxiety and low mood, and four months later the gains had held up better in the group that cut down. Going without isn't necessary, and for a device that holds your train ticket it isn't sustainable either.

Six things help, though nobody has tested them together.

  • Name the errand. Before you unlock the phone, say what it's for, in your head or aloud. "Train times." "Answer Dan." If nothing comes, it was a reach, so put it down with nothing lost. If you keep only one part, keep this.
  • Give the phone a home. At home it lives in one place that isn't your pocket, like a shelf in the hall, ringer on. You go to it for errands and leave it there after. At work, a bag or a drawer. This does more than anything else here.
  • Leave short gaps empty. Anything under about five minutes stays empty, so the kettle, the lift, the queue and the adverts. The first week they'll feel longer than they are.
  • Have sittings. If you like the football or the videos, sit down at a time you chose, enjoy them, and stop at a time you chose, maybe twenty minutes after lunch and half an hour at nine. When a reach comes at eleven in the morning, "at lunch" is far easier to accept than "never".
  • Sort notifications once. Things that can't wait an hour may make a noise, usually calls and messages from a few named people. Everything else is silent, with no badge.
  • Add friction. Move the loop apps into a folder on the last screen. Log out of the worst one. If one app eats most of your time, use it only on a computer.

Then attach new actions to the old cues, decided in advance.

  • When I put the kettle on, I leave the phone where it is and look out of the window.
  • When I find the phone in my hand and can't name the errand, I put it back in its home.
  • When I finish an errand, I lock the phone before I look at anything else.

That third one catches the errand turning into a reach, at the moment the phone is already open in your hand.

For a couple of weeks your hand will go to your pocket and find nothing. That's the habit running without its object, and for most people it fades, though I can't say how fast. You'll break the rule most days at first, and I can't promise more energy. Within a week or two you'll know whether your evenings feel different, and that's the measure.

Some places are harder. Bed is the big one, because the phone is the alarm clock. Buy an alarm clock. They cost a few pounds, and they let the phone spend the night in the hall, which removes the first and last reaches of the day, usually the two longest. If you need to be reachable at night for a parent or a teenager, leave the ringer on and the door open. The bathroom isn't the phone's home either.

A forty-minute train is a fair place for a sitting, or better, for a book or a podcast, which can absorb you in a way the loop can't. When the person across the table picks up theirs, leave yours where it is. If your work comes through the phone, decide which channels are urgent, let those make a noise, and treat the rest like everything else. Being on call means you can be reached, which is different from checking every four minutes whether you have been.

The car is where my tolerance stops. A phone while driving is dangerous and in most places illegal. It goes in the glovebox or the boot before the engine starts.

The habit will come back in force some week, when you're ill on the sofa, or following a big story hour by hour, or grieving. An old habit sits under a new one for a long time, and unusual weeks bring it up. Put the phone back in its home tonight and name the next errand. Nobody was counting days, and I'd advise against starting, since a streak turns one bad Tuesday into a collapse. Do ask what the week was about, though. If it came back because something painful did, it may have been a useful painkiller for a few days. You can thank it and still put it back on the shelf.

For some people the reach is holding something down. Talk to a GP, or refer yourself to a talking therapy service if your area has one, if any of these fit.

  • With the phone away, what comes up is dread or a persistent low mood, and it doesn't ease after a couple of weeks.
  • You've been using the phone to avoid nearly all time alone with your thoughts for months.
  • Your sleep, work or relationships are suffering badly and you can't change the pattern even with the steps above.
  • The time is going into gambling, spending you can't afford, or pornography you've tried and failed to cut back. A gambling helpline or your GP is the place to start.
  • You have thoughts of harming yourself. That needs urgent help the same day, from your GP, an emergency service or a crisis line.

None of these means you've done anything wrong. Better tools exist for a problem that size. Keep taking any prescribed medication, and raise changes with whoever prescribed it.

Back to the kitchen. You fill the kettle and switch it on. Your hand goes to your pocket, because it's been doing that for ten years, and the pocket is empty. The phone is on the shelf in the hall with the ringer on.

So you stand there. For a few seconds there's the itch. It passes. Next door's cat is on the shed roof again, and you remember you've been putting off ringing the dentist. The kettle clicks off, and you make the tea while it's hot.

The next time the phone is in your hand, ask what you picked it up for. If there's an answer, carry on, and put it down when you've finished. If there isn't one, put it down now.