The 20-minute version
It's ten past nine and you've been at your desk for forty minutes. Your hand goes to your pocket, comes out with the vape, and you have a draw while you read the first line of an email. You put it down next to the keyboard. Twenty minutes later you have another. You don't remember having it. You remember the email.
At eleven, in the cubicle at work, three or four draws, because it's the one place nobody's looking. One at the lights on the way home. The car smells faintly of mango. On the sofa the vape sits on the arm and goes to your mouth during the adverts, and sometimes during the programme. In bed it's on the bedside table. The last thing before the lamp goes off is a draw, and if you wake at three there's another, and the first thing in the morning is your hand going out before your eyes are open.
That's an invented day. I'd be surprised if you didn't recognise most of it.
If someone asked how many cigarettes you used to smoke, you'd have said twenty, or thirty on a bad day. Ask how many draws you had today and you have no idea. Not roughly. No idea. And you'd say the vape helps. It takes the edge off, and dozens of times a day you feel a small settling, and you couldn't say what it's settling.
So before anything else, count. Tomorrow, keep a tally on your phone or a scrap of paper, one mark for every draw. If you can, make a second mark for each draw you actually decided to have, meaning you noticed you wanted it before your hand moved. Don't change anything. A study of young adult vapers in America found that four in five vaped within thirty minutes of waking, one of the standard signs of dependence on nicotine. I'd expect your first mark to be earlier than that. Most people who count are shocked by the first column and find the second nearly empty.
I'm not arguing that vaping is as bad as smoking. It isn't, by a long way, and the NHS is clear about that. I won't tell you what device to use. And I will never tell someone who used to smoke to stop vaping if a cigarette would follow.
Some cautions before you go on.
- If you're under eighteen, this isn't written for you. The NHS says children and non-smokers should never vape, and your GP or school nurse can help you stop.
- If you're pregnant, talk to your midwife. The NHS says vaping is likely to be safer than smoking in pregnancy, and that licensed nicotine replacement products are the recommended option. Don't change anything on the strength of something you read.
- If you used to smoke and you know, honestly, that without the vape you'd be on cigarettes within a week, the vape is doing a job, and the NHS advice is to keep it until you're confident you can stop without smoking. The first steps here are safe for you. Never swap the vape for a cigarette. That's the one outcome worse than where you are.
- If your mood has been low most of the day for two weeks, or nothing has felt good, that's a change in your health and not a nicotine question. See a GP.
A cigarette with the ending taken off
Let me be fair to the vape first, because you're not a fool for having kept it.
If you used to smoke, it may be the best thing you've done for your health in years. The NHS says vaping is less harmful than smoking and one of the most effective tools for stopping, and that people who switch are roughly twice as likely to stop smoking as people using patches or gum. It costs about a third of what smoking did. Nobody sends you outside into the rain. It fills the hand. And it calms you, and I'm not going to tell you that you imagined that.
All true, or near enough. But one of those things, that it's allowed everywhere and always on you, has quietly changed what the vape is.
Think about what a cigarette was, as an object. It had a start, the lighter. It had an ending, the filter, five or six minutes later. It had a place, usually outside, and a small cost you could feel each time the packet got lighter. Between cigarettes there was a gap whether you wanted one or not, because you were at your desk and the cigarettes were in the car park.
The vape has no start and no ending. It doesn't burn down. It's allowed nearly everywhere, and used in plenty of places it isn't. No cost per draw that you'd notice. So no gap. What used to be twenty doses a day with spaces between them has become one dose spread thin across every waking hour. Nobody chose that. It's what happens when you take the ending off a habit and put it in a pocket.
You got rid of the smoke, which was the harm. You lost the ending by accident, and a habit with no shape can only grow.
Now the calm, because that's the part you'd defend.
Nicotine leaves the body fast. Its half-life in blood is about two hours, from a review of its chemistry by Neal Benowitz and colleagues, so between doses the level is always falling. As it falls, certain feelings arrive. John Hughes reviewed the research on stopping tobacco and found the ones that reliably appear are anger, anxiety, low mood, difficulty concentrating, impatience, insomnia and restlessness. In someone who has stopped, they peak in the first week and last two to four.
But you don't need to have stopped to feel the start of them. You only need to have gone a while without.
That was the argument the psychologist Andy Parrott made about cigarettes in 1999, and this whole case rests on it. Smokers say cigarettes relieve stress, yet smokers as a group are slightly more stressed than non-smokers, teenagers get more stressed as they take up regular smoking, and people who stop end up less stressed than they were. Smokers' moods are normal while smoking and worse in between. His conclusion was that the calming effect is mostly the reversal of a tension that built up as the nicotine ran down. Each cigarette was mostly removing an irritability the last one had set up. Parts of his argument were disputed at the time, but the shape of it has held.
Put that next to a vape with no ending. A smoker had twenty falls a day, each big enough to notice. You have a hundred, or two hundred, each so small you never see it as a fall. The day's draws hold your nicotine at a steady line. It dips a fraction, something in you tightens a fraction, your hand reaches, the tightening goes. You call that the vape calming you. Parrott studied smokers, and stretching it to vapes is my own reasoning, but it's the same molecule with the same half-life, and the loop runs more smoothly without smoke because nothing makes you wait.
So yes, you feel calmer after a draw than before. The question is what "before" was. It was the fall, made by the draw before that. The whole transaction leaves you where a non-vaper is all the time, for nothing.
The obvious objection is that you'd feel the falls. You've never had the anger and restlessness Hughes describes. You just quite like a draw now and then.
You never feel withdrawal because you never leave a gap long enough for it to arrive. A smoker at a desk had forty-five minutes between cigarettes and felt the fall begin. You have the vape by the keyboard, and the reach happens at the first flicker, before the flicker becomes anything you could name. The steady line hides the loop, which is why all-day vaping is harder to see than smoking ever was.
There's a way to see it, and it takes forty minutes. Put the vape in another room, with a door. Not a bag by your feet. Then carry on with what you were doing and notice what happens at twenty minutes, and at forty.
My expectation, and it's mine rather than a finding, is that something arrives. A restlessness. A slight edge in how you react to the next email. A thought about the vape that comes back every couple of minutes, a little more insistent each time. That's the fall, seen for the first time. It isn't unbearable. If you sat with it another twenty minutes you'd find it stops climbing. It's a small slice of what stopping feels like, and you've been paying to avoid it a hundred times a day.
Do the forty minutes once this week.
Only six milligrams
"I'm only on six." Or three. The people with a problem are the ones on twenty.
Lynne Dawkins and colleagues tested this with eleven experienced vapers. Each vaped freely for an hour twice, once on six milligrams and once on twenty-four. On the low strength they took more puffs and longer ones, and got through about twice as much liquid. At the end of the hour their craving and withdrawal ratings were the same both times. They'd puffed their way to the same comfort. It was eleven men in a laboratory, so hold the numbers lightly, but it's exactly what you'd expect if the draw is there to reverse a fall. The hand keeps reaching until the fall is reversed, however much each draw carries. The number on the bottle isn't the dose. A low strength raises the day's count.
"I've cut down loads since cigarettes." You did the hard part. But twenty a day was a number you knew, and the vape has none, so "cut down" compares a known figure with an unknown one. The NHS tells people switching to vape as much as they need, which is good advice for the weeks when the alternative is a cigarette. It was never meant as a permanent licence, and the same page says to aim to stop vaping too, eventually. Look at your tally. Under twenty draws and you really have cut down. Over a hundred, and you've spread twenty cigarettes so thin they look like nothing.
"It's the deep breath that helps." You're partly right. A slow breath out does settle people, and a draw is mechanically a slow inhale and a slower exhale. So try this once at the desk when the reach starts. Leave the vape where it is and take the same breath, in slowly through the mouth, hold a second, out slowly as though there were vapour. Twice. Notice whether some of the settling arrived, which for most people it does. Then notice whether the reach went away, which mostly it doesn't, or not for long. The breath doesn't reverse the fall. Only nicotine does. The vape has bundled the two together, and the breath is the part worth keeping, because you can have it anywhere for nothing.
"It keeps my hands busy." Granted. There's a hand-and-mouth habit running alongside the nicotine one, and you can find out how much of your reach it is. Try a zero-strength liquid for a day. Most all-day vapers who do report that it's fine for an hour and then isn't, and that tells them the proportion. The hand is the easy part anyway. A pen, a cold glass, sugar-free gum, a walk. It complains for a few days and then takes what it's given. The fall is what makes the complaint feel urgent.
"It's basically harmless." The NHS says vaping is less harmful than smoking, and a 2022 review by UK experts found that in the short and medium term it poses a small fraction of the risks. The same page says it isn't risk-free, the long-term effects aren't known, and the healthiest option is neither. That's the whole health case I'll make. If you have a cough, a dry throat or headaches, it says to get advice from an adviser or a specialist retailer before you stop using a vape to stay off cigarettes, because small changes to the product usually fix them. But health is the smaller reason. Even if vaping carried no long-term harm at all, you'd still be someone whose hand goes to their pocket two hundred times a day to undo what the last draw did.
Then there's the one that might make you close this page.
"It got me off cigarettes and I'm not touching it." I agree with you. If the alternative to a draw is ever a cigarette, have the draw. The NHS says to stop vaping only when you're confident you can do it without smoking, and that going back to a vape is much better than starting to smoke again.
What I'd ask you to separate is a vape you use from a vape you carry. The one you use is the loop. The one you carry is insurance, and insurance doesn't need to be in your mouth to work. Keep it in a drawer at home and a bag at work, charged, never run dry. On the day a gap produces a real pull towards a cigarette, you go to it, and the cigarette doesn't happen.
The first stage of what follows is safe for you, because nothing in it is stopping. If a real gap brings an actual pull towards the shop, rather than a restlessness, that's useful to know. Don't buy cigarettes and don't push through. Keep the vape as it is and ring a stop smoking service. They work with people in exactly this position, and the NHS says you can use a patch with a vape for steady background nicotine and top up with the vape for cravings. A gap that wants a cigarette isn't a failure. It means the switch isn't finished yet.
Two more, quickly.
The bedside. Nicotine is a stimulant, so the draw before the lamp goes off is a stimulant before sleep. The three o'clock draw is the loop showing itself, because by then the line has been falling for hours. A lot of people who never feel withdrawal feel it at three and call it a bad night.
"Everyone does it now." A smoker had to leave the room, and leaving was a decision, and a decision is a gap. Nobody asks you to step outside, so the gap has to come from you. And if a teenager in your house is watching you vape at the kitchen table, they're learning what normal looks like.
Add it up and the bill looks like this.
- A day with no gaps, shaped by a line that has to be held.
- A hundred small edges and a hundred small reliefs, which is a day spent slightly on edge with the remedy in your pocket.
- Nights with a stimulant at eleven and a fall at three.
- A throat and a cough you've started calling normal.
- Money. A third of smoking still comes to a figure over a year that would surprise you. Work it out.
- A hand that's never quite free.
- Not knowing your own number, because the habit has arranged itself so it can't be measured.
A drawer at home
Tonight, take the vape out of your pocket and give it somewhere to live that isn't you.
A drawer at home. A zipped bag at work, not your jacket. The glovebox, not the cup holder. A draw should mean going to get it, and going to get it is a decision, and a decision is the ending put back. None of this is stopping. It's making the vape a thing you use, instead of a thing that uses your hand.
For the first week, that's the whole job.
- When you decide to have a draw, have one or two, then put the vape back where it lives. Not on the desk, not on the sofa arm. This single change does most of the work, because every draw gets a start and an ending again and the gaps come back on their own.
- Choose three places or times where it doesn't come. The NHS suggests vape-free spaces, widened slowly. I'd start with the bedroom from an hour before bed, the car, and the first hour of the working day. Between them they cover most of most people's count.
- Keep the tally and write the total down each evening. It's the only measure of the habit that exists.
- When the reach finds nothing, do the breath twice, then decide whether you're going to the drawer. In the first week you often will. Sometimes the reach passes while you're deciding, and that's your first evidence that it can.
- Don't change the strength and don't try to stop yet.
The first two days are irritating. By the end of the week, and this is my expectation rather than a finding, the reach has thinned, because a hand learns fast when there's nothing there, and the tally has dropped by about half without your trying to cut anything. Somewhere in that week you'll meet the fall properly and learn its size. If you're an ex-smoker and a gap wants a cigarette, ring the stop smoking service. That's what the week was for.
The bedside is the easiest place to start if that's where your vape lives. It stays downstairs. For a few nights the reach finds an empty table and you do the breath. By the end of a week most people find the three o'clock draw has gone, because there was nothing there to have, and the waking went with it.
After that week there are two routes. Pick one before you start, and write down a date.
The first is bringing the line down. It suits people who'd like the vape to fade, and ex-smokers who want the insurance in the drawer right to the end. The NHS says to check the milligrams on your liquid and lower it gradually, paying attention to how you feel. On its own that won't work, for the reason Dawkins found. Drop from twelve to six and let your hand do as it likes, and it will make up the difference. So drop the strength and hold the number. If yesterday was forty draws at twelve, today is forty or fewer at six. If you find yourself vaping more, the NHS says you've cut too fast, so go back a step. Once the number is steady, widen the vape-free places to four, then five.
Each step down is a small first week. The falls get a little bigger because there's less on the line to hide them, and you'll feel a version of what you felt at forty minutes. It's the same version each time, and it passes each time. When one comes and you've decided not to go to the drawer, do the breath and then move. The NHS lists a walk among ways to manage cravings. You don't have to outlast the fall by will. You just have to be somewhere else when it peaks.
The weakness of the fade is that without a date it becomes a place to live. Six milligrams, twenty draws a day, for three years. So set the day the line reaches zero, two months off for most people. At the bottom, some go to a zero-nicotine liquid for the hand and let the device die, some go straight to nothing, and some ex-smokers keep the drawer stocked as insurance and never open it. Any of those is fine. A zero that never arrives isn't.
The second route is stopping on a day. It suits people who never smoked, people who find the fade becomes a home, and people whose first week showed the falls were smaller than they feared.
The NHS suggests asking a pharmacist or a stop smoking adviser about switching to a fast-acting nicotine product, which eases the cravings as you stop. It names a mouth spray as the only replacement product currently approved for stopping vaping, with a patch for steady background. I'm not recommending a product. Stop smoking services take vapers, and they know the products.
There's less evidence here than for stopping smoking. A Cochrane review updated in 2025 by Ailsa Butler and colleagues found fifteen trials, nearly all American. The medicine varenicline and, for people aged thirteen to twenty-four, text message support may help, both on low-certainty evidence. For combination nicotine replacement the evidence was too uncertain to conclude either way. Nobody has a proven method yet. What evidence there is points towards support of some kind over going it alone.
Pick a day a week or two out, after the drawer week. On the day the vape goes somewhere less reachable, or in the bin if you never smoked and you're sure, and whatever the adviser suggested goes in your pocket instead. The first week is the hardest. You'll be more restless, more irritable and hungrier, and sleep worse for a few nights. On Hughes's timings it's gone within two to four weeks. And once the line is at zero, a single draw sets up a fall and restarts the loop, so not one. If you're an ex-smoker keeping the vape as insurance, that insurance is for a cigarette, not for a bad afternoon.
Whichever route, the decision fits in a sentence. The vape lives in a drawer, not on me, I decide each draw, and I'm bringing the line to nothing by a date I've set.
Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran reviewed ninety-four studies of plans in the form "when this happens, I'll do that", and found people who plan that way follow through much more often than people who only hold the intention. So write three.
When my hand goes to my pocket and finds nothing, I'll breathe out slowly twice and then decide whether I'm going to the drawer.
When I've had a draw, I'll put the vape back before I do anything else.
When a fall comes and I've decided not to go to the drawer, I'll get up and walk for five minutes.
If you used to smoke, add a fourth. When a gap makes me want a cigarette rather than a draw, I'll have the draw, and I'll ring the stop smoking service that week.
Six draws on a Thursday
It will happen. Someone at a party hands you theirs, or you find one in an old coat, or a bad afternoon sends you to the drawer that was meant to be insurance. You have a draw, or six.
Then a thought arrives, and the thought does more damage than the draws. "I've blown it." It's the sentence that turns one draw into a day of them and a day into the old pattern, because if it's blown there's no reason to stop.
One draw is one draw. The line went up a fraction and will come down within hours, and what happens next depends on what you do next. Put it back and work out which gap failed. Maybe a place you hadn't made vape-free yet, or a person or a row, or a fall that came bigger than usual because you stepped the strength down too fast. Each has a small adjustment, not a fresh start, and if you've been counting, the tally shows you exactly where in the day it sits.
If you used to smoke, hold on to the NHS line. Going back to a vape is much better than starting to smoke again. A draw on a bad day is the insurance being claimed, and you can claim it and carry on. And if one day it's a cigarette, go back to the vape the same day. One cigarette isn't starting to smoke again.
Don't count days since your last draw. A streak makes the first slip feel like losing everything. Count draws in the last week, or vape-free days in the last thirty, and let a slip be one mark in a long row of empty ones. Then carry on that evening, not on Monday.
Some situations need their own word.
If you smoke and vape, the cigarettes are the problem, and the NHS advice is to use the vape as much as you need to get them to zero. Come back to this when you've been smoke-free a couple of months.
If you never smoked, there's no insurance question, and the NHS position that non-smokers shouldn't vape applies to you directly. Either route is open to you. Never-smokers often started young and on strong liquid, so the line may be higher than you'd guess. Count first.
If it's your partner who vapes all day, the drawer works for the person who chose it, not for the one it was chosen for. You can ask that it doesn't happen in the car or the bedroom, and say why. If it's your child, the NHS has a page for parents, and their GP or school nurse can help. A teenager can follow the argument, but the plan assumes an adult with a drawer of their own, and a teenager needs someone alongside.
If you're pregnant, none of these steps should happen without your midwife. The NHS also says to avoid liquorice-flavoured nicotine products in pregnancy.
If a gap brings panic rather than restlessness, don't push through alone. An adviser or pharmacist can put a steady product alongside, and a GP should know if the panic is new. And low mood is on Hughes's list and should lift within two to four weeks. If it doesn't, or it was there before you changed anything, or nothing has felt good for a fortnight, that's your health, not nicotine. See a GP.
It's ten past nine, some weeks on. You've been at your desk for forty minutes. Your hand goes to your pocket and finds your keys. It rests there a second, and you notice, and you breathe out slowly, and you read the first line of what you're meant to be doing. The vape is in a drawer at home. You haven't thought about it since you left the house.
The reach still happens sometimes, especially at the lights. There was a bad Thursday with six draws in it, and you put the vape back, counted them and carried on. The calm is still there too. It turns out to be what a morning feels like when there's no line to hold.
Tonight, put the vape in a drawer. Tomorrow, when your hand goes to your pocket and finds nothing, breathe out slowly and then decide.