The work will still be there

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 56 min

It's ten to seven on a Tuesday evening and the office is nearly empty. The cleaner is doing the far end. You're at your desk with a cold half cup of tea, and you've just finished rewording the second paragraph of a report that was already fine.

You manage the planning team at a housing association, eight of you. Your contract says thirty-seven and a half hours a week. You're in by eight and leave around seven. After dinner, at about quarter past nine, you open the laptop at the kitchen table to clear a few emails, and close it at twenty to eleven. On Sunday afternoons you do two or three hours to get ahead. It comes to about fifty-five hours, though you've never added it up.

Since five o'clock you've reread the report, answered fourteen emails, which produced nine replies, six of which you also answered, and tidied a spreadsheet only you look at. You started next month's rota, got stuck, and decided to come back to it in the morning. If a fire alarm had cleared the building at five, tomorrow would look exactly the same.

Your daughter Ellie is nine, and she swims on Thursdays. The galas start at half past five. You've been to one this year. Your partner Sam goes and sends you a video, and you watch it at your desk.

There's a man on your team called Tom who leaves at quarter past five every day. His work is good and always on time. Somewhere in your mind you've marked him down as not quite committed. Last year your own manager, Helen, said in passing, "You're always here. I don't know how you do it." You've thought about that more often than you'd admit. It felt like being seen.

You're tired in a way that's become normal. Three colds this winter. On holiday last summer it took until the second Wednesday to stop checking your phone, and you flew home on the Saturday. It'll ease off after the restructure, you've told yourself, as you told yourself after the audit, and the merger before that.

Nobody ordered these hours. There was a busy period once, they went up, and they never came down. I'll argue that they deliver far less than they seem to, that the late ones lower the quality of the early ones, and that they cost your health and your family more than you've counted. The practical part is plain. You choose a time to stop, you stop at it, and the work is still there in the morning and gets done. Nothing here is against the occasional long day for a real deadline. The target is the permanent long week nobody decided on.

For one ordinary week, write down when you start and stop, evenings and weekend included, and add it up. On two evenings, note what the last two hours contained. Most people find both surprising.

Four cautions.

This is for people whose long hours are at least partly a habit. Many people work long hours because they must. They hold two jobs, or the hours are what feed the family, or they're caring for someone as well as working. If that's you, what follows about what long hours do to a person still applies, and I'm sorry that the parts about choosing to stop may not.

If you're exhausted most of the time, or dread work, or feel numb about things you used to care about, take it seriously. The NHS advice is to see a GP if you're struggling to cope with stress or what you're trying yourself isn't helping. If you need help urgently and it isn't an emergency, call 111. If you've had thoughts of harming yourself, call 999 or go to A&E.

If long hours are being demanded of you, the law gives you some protection. In the UK you can't be made to work more than 48 hours a week on average unless you've chosen to opt out, and you're entitled to 11 hours' rest between working days and a full day off each week, or two each fortnight. Some jobs are exceptions. I'm not a lawyer, and Acas or your union can advise you properly.

And if work is a refuge from something painful at home, the hours may be doing a job I can't fully address. There's a word on that near the end.

The flat part of the curve

The central belief is so obvious it hardly seems like a belief. Fifty-five hours gets more done than forty.

The best evidence I know comes from the First World War. Britain was desperately short of shells, and munitions factories ran seventy hours a week and more. The government worried that the hours were damaging the workers and the output, and set up a committee whose researchers kept careful week-by-week records of hours worked and shells produced. A century later the Stanford economist John Pencavel analysed those records with modern methods. Up to about forty-nine hours a week, output rose in step with hours. Beyond that, each extra hour added less than the one before. Output peaked at around sixty-three hours and then fell. A seventy-hour week produced barely more than a fifty-six-hour week. Fourteen extra hours at the machines, and almost nothing to show.

Nobody could say these workers lacked commitment. Most of them were women making shells for husbands and brothers at the front, in a war the country thought it might lose. If motivation could beat fatigue, it would have done it there.

You don't make shells. I can't point to an equally clean study of planning managers, though Marion Collewet and Jan Sauermann found that call centre agents in the Netherlands got slower at handling calls as their hours rose, and most of them were part-timers. My own view is that mental work probably suffers more than machine work. A tired machinist is slow. A tired planner decides worse, misses things, and writes emails that need a second email to correct them.

"I'm fine, I can handle it."

The trouble is that tiredness damages the very faculty you'd use to notice. Two Australian researchers, Williamson and Feyer, tested thirty-nine people on mental and physical tasks, once while keeping them awake for hours and once at rising levels of alcohol, which let them express tiredness in units of drink. After seventeen to nineteen hours awake, performance on some tests was as bad as or worse than at a blood alcohol level of 0.05 per cent, the legal driving limit in much of Europe. Do the sum for your Tuesday. Up at half past six, and the laptop closes at twenty to eleven, just over sixteen hours later. You wouldn't go back to the office after three glasses of wine to finalise the rota. You feel perfectly clear-headed writing those emails.

One late night does no lasting harm. The question is years of them. Marianna Virtanen and colleagues tested the reasoning, vocabulary and memory of more than two thousand British civil servants, and again five years later. Those working more than fifty-five hours had lower vocabulary scores at both points, and their reasoning scores declined more, after allowing for age, education, income, health and sleep. It's observational, so it can't prove the hours did it. It does run against the idea that long hours keep you sharp. And Dembe and colleagues, following nearly eleven thousand Americans over thirteen years, found jobs with overtime schedules had a 61 per cent higher rate of work injuries and illnesses. At a desk, the same lapse of attention that causes an injury is a wrong figure or a reply to the wrong person.

So the mistakes of the late hours get repaired in the early hours of the next day, which are your best ones. Tomorrow morning, reread what you sent after nine tonight. Most people would have done a fair part of it differently.

Then the objection that feels unanswerable. There's too much to do.

It was too much at thirty-seven and a half hours, so you went to forty-five. Too much at forty-five, so you went to fifty-five. At sixty-five it would still be too much, and you know it. In a job like yours there's no number of hours at which the work is finished.

Think of the last working day before a holiday. Same amount of work, a long list, and an immovable finishing time. You were brisk. You decided things quickly, skipped what didn't matter, wrote short emails, said no to a meeting, and probably got through more than in any two ordinary days. Then you left on time. On an ordinary Tuesday, with the evening sitting there as overflow, nothing forces a choice. The report can be polished because there's time to polish it. The writer C. Northcote Parkinson joked in the 1950s that work expands to fill the time available for its completion, and I offer it only as an observation. None of your two hours between five and seven would have made the cut on the day before a holiday.

Some workloads really are too big. If you've cut the low-value work and still can't do what's required in something like your contracted hours, the organisation has a staffing problem, and your evenings are hiding it. While you absorb the excess quietly, nobody above you has any reason to know the job is too big for one person. You won't know how much of your "too much" is drift until the day has an end.

You're always here

Look at what Helen praised. She didn't say your plans were excellent or your team well run, though both may be true. She remarked on your presence, because presence is what she can see from her office. When promotion or pay or the new project is decided, "was here a lot" won't be on the list.

Erin Reid, then at Boston University, studied a demanding consulting firm whose culture expected total devotion. She interviewed more than a hundred people there and looked at their performance reviews. Some consultants had quietly arranged to work far fewer hours than the culture demanded, keeping local clients and avoiding travel, while letting it be assumed they were as devoted as everyone else. As I remember the paper and its write-ups, they were rated as highly as the colleagues who really worked the punishing hours, and people who openly asked for lighter schedules were marked down. The published summary confirms only the outline. I'm not recommending deceit. But the firm couldn't tell eighty hours from fifty when the work was good.

Malissa Clark and colleagues pooled the research on workaholism, the feeling of being driven to work excessively. If long hours came from conscientiousness, workaholics should score high on it. They didn't. Workaholism went with perfectionism, burnout, job stress, conflict between work and home, and poorer health. Tom may be every bit as committed as you. His shows in work that's good and on time, and in having arranged things so he can do this job for another twenty years.

Some workplaces do crudely reward presence. Check yours before assuming it's one. Look for the Toms and see how they're doing.

"Everyone here works like this." You know that because you know what you've thought about Tom. What everyone else thinks, you've inferred from what they do, and they've inferred what you think from what you do. Psychologists call it pluralistic ignorance, when most of a group privately doubt a norm but go along because they assume the others believe in it. Christin Munsch, Cecilia Ridgeway and Joan Williams asked people to judge an employee who'd requested flexible working, and to say how others would judge them. People consistently believed others would be harsher than they were themselves. When people were told that most senior staff worked flexibly, the bias against flexible hours shrank.

Picture your office at half past six. Five people at their desks, each staying partly because the other four are. You've been one of the four for each of them. And you're the senior person to eight others, which makes you the obvious first exception.

Perhaps you love the job, and the evening session is often the best part of your day.

That's real good fortune, and I've no wish to talk you out of it. Researchers separate working long because you're drawn to it from working long because you're uneasy when you don't. Clark's review defined workaholism by that compulsion, the guilt and restlessness when you aren't working, and that's what went with burnout. Try this. Picture a free Sunday with no laptop. If it's pleasant and you'd pick up work on Monday with interest, that's love. If you're already finding reasons this particular Sunday needs a quick look at a few things, something else is in it too.

Your body doesn't much care which. Mika Kivimäki and colleagues pooled studies of more than six hundred thousand people followed for about eight years. Compared with thirty-five to forty hours a week, fifty-five or more went with a 33 per cent higher risk of stroke and a 13 per cent higher risk of coronary heart disease. The World Health Organization and the International Labour Organization estimated that in 2016 about 745,000 deaths worldwide from stroke and heart disease could be attributed to working fifty-five hours or more. These are observational studies, and a 33 per cent rise in a risk that's small for any one person in any year is still a small risk. Long hours also travel with less sleep and more drinking. I'm not telling you your job will give you a stroke. Your body registers the hours whether you're enjoying them or not.

Last comes the feeling that you hold the place together. You know how the rota works and spot problems before they land, and you feel things would slip without you there in the evenings.

You were off for a week with flu in February, and in Portugal for two weeks last summer. The department didn't collapse. Some things waited, others got done differently and turned out fine. If it survives Portugal, it survives a Thursday gala. Meanwhile, every problem you catch at seven in the evening is one nobody else on your team learns to catch, so after a few years you really are indispensable, because nobody else has had the practice. And someone who can't be spared from their job can't easily be promoted out of it.

Here's a test. Pick one thing you keep hold of because nobody else does it right. Hand it to someone on your team properly, with the authority to decide, expect it done differently, and watch for a month.

Sunday at eleven

Sunday afternoon is when you get ahead. The house is quiet and two or three hours at the kitchen table take the edge off Monday.

The wartime committee had a view on this. Its verdict, which Pencavel quotes, was that seven days' labour only produces six days' output. He tested it with their own data, comparing weeks of the same total hours with and without a rest day, and the weeks with no rest day produced about 10 per cent less. Same hours. The only difference was a day off.

The modern term is psychological detachment, which means switching off in your head as well as leaving the building. Sabine Sonnentag and colleagues followed 309 employees in demanding service jobs for a year. Among those with high demands, the ones who detached in their off-hours were protected against the rise in physical complaints, and against the fall in engagement with their work, that the others showed. The people who switched off stayed keener on their jobs.

What the Sunday session really means is that you never have a whole day without work in it. From about eleven on Sunday morning you're aware the session is coming, and your mind turns towards Monday. A mind that hasn't switched off for years takes more than a week of holiday to learn how. Twenty minutes on Friday afternoon, writing down Monday's first three things, gets most of the benefit. What Sunday mainly relieves is the unease of not working, which the habit created in the first place.

Then the evening emails. It feels light and useful. You answer fourteen, some reach people who are also clearing their inboxes, they answer, you answer back, and by twenty to eleven you've handled thirty messages and the inbox is as full as when you sat down. Evening email mostly produces more email, written sixteen hours after you woke.

Liuba Belkin, William Becker and Samantha Conroy surveyed 570 working adults about email out of hours. When people felt expected to monitor it in their own time, they were less able to switch off, more emotionally exhausted, and less satisfied with the balance of their lives. The time actually spent on email wasn't the main driver. The expectation was. A person who might have to deal with work at any moment never fully stands down, even on evenings when nothing comes. Helen has never asked you to answer at ten at night. You built that expectation one prompt reply at a time, which means you can unbuild it. If your replies start arriving at nine in the morning, within a few weeks that's when people will expect them.

"It's only for now" deserves one look from the outside. The audit, then the merger, then the new housing system, now the restructure. Six years of temporary periods laid end to end. Each was truly busy. But the week after the audit was signed off, you didn't go home at half past five. Other work had flowed into the space and you'd forgotten what leaving on time felt like. There'll be a next thing after the restructure, and you could probably name it.

Ellie is nine. The stretch of her life in which she looks for you at the side of the pool is perhaps five years long, and one of them has just gone. It runs at its own pace, and it can't be postponed until after the restructure.

Now the bill.

  • Money. You're paid for thirty-seven and a half hours and work fifty-five, so your real hourly rate is about a third lower than your contract says. Over a year you've given your employer more than twenty working weeks free. You wouldn't accept a one-third pay cut put to you in those terms.
  • Home. On a day you leave at seven and open the laptop at quarter past nine, your time with Ellie is perhaps forty minutes, mostly getting her to bed. Sam has run the evenings alone for six years. "Home by half six," then a text at quarter past saying another hour, repeated across years, teaches the people at home to stop counting on you. They plan as though you won't be there. That isn't punishment. It's sensible.
  • Your team. When you email at half past ten, the person who gets it learns what time their manager works and wonders whether a reply is expected. The person who'd like to leave at half past five has to walk past you to do it. Some of your team are almost certainly working longer than they need to because of you, and working in the flat part of the curve.
  • Everything else you used to be. A sport, a group of friends you saw every month, a course you meant to take. They went one at a time in busy periods and didn't come back.

You've had things from the hours too, Helen's good opinion among them. Would you have taken this trade if anyone had offered it to you plainly at the start?

Half past five

Choose a time to stop. Then stop at it.

I stop at a time I've chosen in advance. The work will still be there tomorrow, and I'll do it then.

A stop gives every day a mild version of the day before a holiday. Within a fortnight you'll see which parts of your work were real and which were filling time. If the real work truly doesn't fit, you'll know the size of the staffing problem, with evidence. And the evening becomes definitely yours, so the part of you that was on duty can stand down. That's the detachment that protected Sonnentag's employees, and you won't get it while the boundary is soft.

  • Choose the time. I'd suggest the end of your contracted day plus no more than half an hour. If that feels impossible from where you are, choose a time an hour earlier than you leave now, hold it for a month, then move it again. What matters is that it's fixed before the day begins.
  • End the day on purpose. Spend the last ten minutes writing where you've got to and the first three things for tomorrow. Check tomorrow's diary. Then close everything. Your mind can let go of something once it's on paper.
  • After the stop, no work. No laptop at the kitchen table and no work email on your phone. Take it off your personal phone if you can, or turn off its notifications out of hours. A thought about work at nine in the evening goes on a piece of paper for the morning.
  • Keep one full day a week with no work in it, preferably two. On Pencavel's evidence it's worth about a tenth of your output.
  • Make exceptions deliberately. An exception is for something specific, decided in advance, with an end date. A board paper due on Friday fits. "It's a busy time" doesn't, because it always is. If you're making an exception most weeks, the long hours are back.
  • Tell people. Tell your manager what you're doing in terms of the work. Your late hours aren't productive, you'll finish at half past five and protect your mornings, and you'd like to be judged on results. Tell your team you don't expect replies outside working hours. If you must write an email in the evening, schedule it for nine the next day.

Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran pooled 94 tests of "when this happens, I'll do that" plans and found they made people a good deal more likely to follow through. When it's ten minutes before my stop, I'll write tomorrow's first three tasks, whatever I'm in the middle of. When I think "I'll just finish this first", I'll write down where I've got to. When I reach for the laptop after dinner, I'll write the thought on paper and go and find Ellie.

At half past five on the first day, with things undone, stopping will feel like walking out of a shop without paying. It's the feeling of a habit breaking, and it usually fades within two or three weeks as the evidence comes in that nothing has fallen apart. Someone will say "off already?" once. After that your hours are just your hours.

You'll slip. You'll stay until eight one Wednesday without having planned to. When you notice, go home, and keep to your time the next day. One late night doesn't bring the old hours back. And put something in the space, or the evening will fill with work or the phone. The gala on Thursdays is an obvious start.

Some situations need more. If your manager really does expect long hours, put it on the ground of output and ask to be judged on what you deliver. If the answer is still that you must be seen at your desk until seven, you can accept it with open eyes, push back with a union or Acas, or look for a better employer. If the essential work still won't fit after an honest month, take a list to your manager. "I can do A, B and C in the time. D and E won't fit. Which matters most, or can we get help?" If you teach or nurse, set a limit on the hours you'll give at home and put them at fixed times. In a real crunch, a year-end close or a court date, work the hours under the exception rule, keep your day off even then, and return to your stop the day after it ends. If you need the overtime money, the hours aren't a habit, but protect your sleep and your day off as far as you can, and take special care driving or with machinery after long shifts.

If work is where you hide, because home is hard, cutting your hours will bring you face to face with whatever you've been avoiding, so line up some support first, a friend, your GP or a counsellor. And if you're exhausted beyond what a weekend fixes, detached from work you used to care about and struggling to function, a stop isn't enough. See your GP. If time off is offered, take it.

It's a Tuesday some months on, and at twenty past five you're writing three lines on a pad. Finish the north team's rota. Ring the contractor about the Elm Road voids. Give the board paper draft to Tom for comment. You close the laptop and put it in your bag, where it stays until morning now. At half past five you say goodnight to the cleaner, who's just arriving.

The first Monday you stood in the car park at twenty-five to six feeling like a truant, with eleven emails unanswered. On Tuesday morning you'd dealt with all of them by ten, and nobody had noticed. By the third week you were sharper at nine in the morning than you'd been in years. You handed the weekly figures to Priyanka, who does them differently and at least as well. The compliance returns really didn't fit, so you took them to Helen with a list, and she moved them to another team. She'd had no idea how long they took. When you told her about the stop, you'd rehearsed a long justification. She heard two sentences and said, "Good. I've been worried about you."

In April you slid for a week and caught it when you noticed the laptop on the kitchen table again. You put it back in the bag.

You're at the pool on Thursdays. Last week Ellie came third in the backstroke and looked for you in the seats before she looked at the clock. Two others on the team have started leaving on time, and the numbers haven't suffered. Tom still leaves at quarter past five. You've revised your opinion of Tom.

Decide what time you'll stop tomorrow. Write it down now, with the first three things you'll do the morning after, and tell one person.