You didn't want it yesterday

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 51 min

It's Tuesday, ten past nine in the evening, and you're on the sofa.

The day wasn't terrible. A meeting was moved twice, someone sent an email that could be read two ways, and dinner was something reheated. You pick up your phone, and there's a weekend bag. Tan canvas, leather handles, sixty-eight pounds.

You have no weekend away planned. You look anyway. You read the reviews, compare the pockets on two similar bags, and for ten minutes the choice between tan and olive is the most interesting thing that has happened to you all day. You pick tan. Your card is saved, so paying takes one tap, and you put the phone down feeling brisker, like someone who has dealt with something. On Wednesday the dispatch email is a small pleasure. On Thursday you check the tracking twice at work, and when you get home it's on the mat. It's a nice bag and it smells of new canvas. You carry it upstairs and put it on top of the wardrobe, next to a milk frother from last month that's still in its box.

By the following Tuesday you couldn't say where the bag is without stopping to think. And you're on the sofa again, looking at something else.

None of this is a disaster. I'd only like you to look at one odd fact. On Monday you didn't want a weekend bag. You hadn't thought about weekend bags in years, and if someone had offered you sixty-eight pounds or the bag on Monday you'd have taken the money without a pause. The want turned up on Tuesday evening, along with the tiredness and the two-way email, and it happened to land on a bag. A week earlier it landed on a milk frother.

Here's what I'm going to argue. The lift you get from buying is real, and researchers have measured it. Nearly all of it sits in the wanting and the choosing and the waiting, so you're paying the full price of an object for a feeling the object doesn't supply. One question, asked before you pay, sorts most purchases into the right pile, and there are cheaper ways to get what the evening was short of.

I'm not making a case for owning less or feeling guilty about nice things. You need to buy things, and some of what you buy will give you years of pleasure. There are no spreadsheets here either.

Some cautions first. If you're missing payments, borrowing to cover food or rent, or afraid to open your statements, don't wait until the end. Free debt advice exists for exactly this, and in the UK the NHS points people to Citizens Advice, StepChange, National Debtline and MoneyHelper. Ring one of them this week. If your buying feels out of your control, takes up hours of most days, or is something you hide, the last section describes what doctors call compulsive buying and where to get help. Reading alone may not be enough, and that isn't a failing in you. If your spending comes in bursts along with feeling unusually high, confident and energetic and needing very little sleep, please talk to a GP, because the NHS lists extravagant spending among the signs of mania in bipolar disorder. And if your trouble is that there isn't enough money for the things you need, I'm not writing for you here. Going without is a different problem.

Before you read on, take five minutes. Open the order history of the shop you use most, or last month's bank statement. For each thing that wasn't food or a bill, ask whether you'd wanted it the day before you bought it. Don't judge the answers. Just count.

Four minutes in the hall

The usual advice says shopping doesn't make you happy. You know that's false. On Tuesday it made you feel better within a quarter of an hour, and anyone who denies that has lost the argument on page one.

In a 2011 paper called "Retail therapy", Selin Atalay and Margaret Meloy found that people in a bad mood bought more unplanned treats for themselves. Then came the part the scolds wouldn't expect. The treats worked. Mood improved, the improvement lasted, and the buyers didn't report regret or guilt afterwards.

Scott Rick, Beatriz Pereira and Katherine Burson looked at why. Sadness goes with a sense that circumstances are running your life, and shopping is full of choices. In three experiments, making shopping choices reduced lingering sadness, and a restored sense of control explained it.

Go back to the sofa with that in mind. All day things had been done to you. The meeting was moved by someone else and the email was written by someone else. Then for twenty-five minutes you were the one deciding, and nobody could overrule you. Add some novelty on an evening that was short of it, something to look forward to on Thursday, and a sense of reward after a day that paid you very little. Those are real needs. A person who wants some say over their day is in good working order.

So I won't tell you the lift is fake. The questions are narrower. Where does it sit, how long does it last, and is the object needed for it at all?

Follow your mood through the week, and ignore the parcel. Flat at nine. Absorbed by twenty past. A small high point as you pay. Echoes on Wednesday and Thursday from the dispatch email and the tracking page. A second, smaller peak in the hall as you open the box. Then the line drops back to wherever your week was anyway.

Nearly all the pleasure came before you owned the thing. After you owned it there were about four minutes in the hall.

Marsha Richins, a marketing professor, measured this. In three studies she tracked the feelings products stirred up before and after purchase. In people who expect that getting things will change their lives, she found a clear rise before buying and a decline after, and concluded that for them wanting may be more pleasurable than owning. People low in materialism didn't show the pattern, so this isn't a law about all shoppers. My own reading, and it's only mine, is that on a Tuesday night like that one you've joined the high scorers for the evening, because you're expecting a purchase to change how you feel.

That changes what the sixty-eight pounds bought. It's closer to the truth to say you bought a nice feeling and got a bag thrown in. The feeling was used up by Thursday. The bag is what's left, and it's the part you paid for. And because the pleasure is in the run-up, the only way to have it again is to start another run-up.

The bag didn't change between Thursday and the next Tuesday. You got used to it, which is one of the most reliable things people do, and you know that perfectly well. Jing Wang, Nathan Novemsky and Ravi Dhar found that shoppers hold the right beliefs about getting used to things and simply don't think of them while deciding.

At ten past nine you pictured the bag on its best day, new, on your shoulder, on the way to a train. You didn't picture week three. So before you pay, move the picture forward. Don't ask how you'll feel when it arrives, because the answer is always "pleased". Ask what it will be in its third month, where it will live and how often you'll pick it up. For the kettle you'll use four times a day, the third-month picture is good. For a lift purchase it's usually a cupboard.

A mood with a shopping list

Thirty-three people watched a film clip. Some saw a sad scene about a boy whose mentor dies, and the rest saw a neutral one. Then, in what they were told was a separate task, each could buy an insulated water bottle, naming the most they'd pay out of a ten-dollar fee.

The neutral group offered 56 cents on average. The sad group offered $2.11.

Cynthia Cryder and colleagues ran that experiment in 2008, and a later study repeated it and confirmed that the effect happens even when people are unaware of it. Nobody thought, I'm sad, so I'll pay more for a bottle. They thought the bottle was worth two dollars. A low mood doesn't announce itself as a reason to shop. It makes things look more worth having, so from the inside all you notice is a nice bag.

It's the supermarket on an empty stomach, without anyone to warn you.

If a want is produced by the state you're in tonight, it has no history. It wasn't there yesterday. A want that comes from your life usually has one, because you've noticed the lack before, on good days as well as bad. So there's a question that sorts the two well enough.

Did I want this yesterday?

It isn't proof. Now and then you'll see something for the first time that you really need. But a real need will still be there on Friday, so waiting costs nothing, and a want made by Tuesday evening mostly won't outlast Tuesday evening. The question never tells you not to buy. At most it tells you to hold off for tonight. You can turn it round, too. When the urge to browse arrives, ask what happened today. Most evenings the answer comes quickly, and that answer is what you were shopping for.

Now say the lift works as advertised. You're flat at nine and better at half past. The email is still in your inbox. You're as tired as before, and you still haven't spoken to anyone since lunch. The lift went over the top of the evening for an hour.

I want to be fair here. The shop didn't move your meeting. Your bad days come from your life, and buying doesn't cause them. What it does, by my own reckoning, is leave things behind that make later evenings a little heavier.

  • Money. A lift purchase most weeks is a few thousand pounds a year, which for many households is the difference between a cushion and no cushion. A UK survey of more than a hundred thousand people found impulsive buying went with worse financial outcomes, and not only among the heaviest buyers.
  • Stuff. Everything you own has to be stored, cleaned round and one day got rid of, and the unused things are small reminders of money gone.
  • A slight wince when another parcel arrives, or the habit of getting to the door before anyone else. You don't get that about things you bought on purpose.

The bigger cost is quieter. The evening needed something and didn't get it. Maybe rest. Maybe a moan to someone who'd laugh in the right places, or the feeling of having finished something of your own after nine hours of doing what others asked, or just something in the next fortnight to look forward to. Buying is a quick general answer to all of those, which is why it tempts, and also why it answers none of them well. Twenty-five minutes of looking at bags doesn't rest you or connect you to anyone. What you finish is a transaction, and what you look forward to is over by Thursday. The need is back next week.

So are you.

And the shop is ready for you. Drazen Prelec and George Loewenstein pointed out that spending hurts a little at the moment you do it, and called this the pain of paying. That small hurt is useful, because it's when your mind weighs the thing against the money. Cash ties the two closely and cards loosen the tie. Your card was saved and paying was one tap. It may have offered three instalments, cutting one small pain into three you'll barely feel. My reading is that the moment of weighing has been taken out of the process on purpose.

Then there's hurry. In 2019 a Princeton team led by Arunesh Mathur sent a crawler round about eleven thousand shopping sites and found 393 countdown timers. When they checked back, 157 of them were false, and the clock reset or reached zero while the offer carried on. A countdown exists to stop you asking whether you'll want the thing tomorrow.

None of this needs a villain. Thousands of businesses have each tested what works, and what works is whatever reaches you when your guard is down. You're a tired person on a sofa up against a system that never gets tired, so losing says nothing about your character. And the pauses can be put back, one saved card at a time.

Three things said at the checkout

"It was reduced." Suppose the bag had been down from a hundred and ten. For a lot of us that would have settled it, and we'd tell the story afterwards as saving forty-two pounds. The economist Richard Thaler suggested that a purchase gives two pleasures, one from the thing and one from the deal, and he called the second transaction utility. It can attach to anything, a bag you don't need as easily as a boiler you do. The arithmetic is plain. You have sixty-eight pounds less. Whether you saved anything depends only on whether you'd have bought the bag at full price, which is the yesterday question again. If the coat you've wanted since last winter drops by a third in January, buy it and enjoy both pleasures. With a lift purchase the discount comes first, and the wanting is put together on the spot to fit it.

"I deserve it." It's Friday, you've had a hard week, and there's a jumper you've been shown twice. You probably have earned something, and if you came away thinking that spending on yourself is a weakness, I'd have done you harm. The trouble is the join. "I've earned something" is about your week. "So I'll have this jumper" is about whatever happened to be on the screen. Uzma Khan and Ravi Dhar found in five studies that after people had done something virtuous, or only committed to it, they were more likely to choose an indulgence next, and it didn't need to be related in any way. A hard week works like a voucher you can spend on anything. Nobody says "I deserve it" about a new kettle when the old one breaks. The phrase turns up when part of you knows the purchase needs defending.

Try to remember what you rewarded yourself with three Fridays ago. If nothing comes, the week's effort went on something that was gone within days. A reward that works, I think, is chosen in advance by your rested self, tied to the effort and enjoyed at the time. A meal out on Friday that you booked on Monday does all of that.

"I can always send it back." In the UK, if you buy online or by phone, you generally have fourteen days from receiving the item to cancel and another fourteen to return it, with no reason needed, though there are exceptions. That's a good right to have. The trouble is what the thought does at ten past nine. You aren't really buying, you tell yourself, only having a look at home, and the last of the pain of paying goes. The undoing falls to you on some later flat evening, finding the box, reprinting a label and queuing in your lunch hour for money you've already stopped missing. So the bag stays. Nobody decides to keep it. On day fifteen the question closes by itself.

If you hear yourself thinking it as you're about to pay, treat it as information, because people don't say it about things they're sure of. And when something you bought on purpose turns out wrong, put the box by the front door the day you decide and send it that week.

Under all three sits the person you pictured carrying the bag. Station platform, Friday afternoon, somewhere to go and someone to go with. That person was what you were buying, and the bag was the part of them that could be delivered.

The running shoes arrive, and the person who opens the box still doesn't run. Ordering the bag feels like a step towards weekends away, and it's the only step that takes one tap. The real ones are finding a free weekend, asking someone and booking a train, and the small satisfaction of having acted makes them a little less likely.

So reverse the order. Go away for a weekend with the holdall you've had since college. Run three times in the trainers you've got. If you keep doing the thing, you'll soon know what kit you lack, and you'll buy it with a history of wanting behind it. If you find you only wanted the idea of being that person, you'll have found out for nothing.

"But I like nice things." Good. Nothing here asks you to stop. The argument is about one kind of purchase, and it usually ends in buying better things and enjoying them more. The purchases that pay share one feature, which is that the pleasure is still going after the delivery.

  • Things you use often. A sharp knife is nice every time you cut an onion.
  • Things you've wanted for a long time. A want that has lasted six months of good moods and bad is real, and you get months of the enjoyable waiting as well.
  • Time. Ashley Whillans and colleagues found that people who spent money on time-saving services were more satisfied with their lives. A chore that sours every Saturday may be worth paying to be rid of.
  • Experiences, modestly. The research finding that doing beats having has held up, though more weakly than it was first reported, and less so for people with less money. A meal with friends is often a better use of sixty-eight pounds than a bag nobody needs, and that's as far as I'd take it.
  • Other people. Elizabeth Dunn, Lara Aknin and Michael Norton found that people assigned to spend money on someone else reported more happiness than those assigned to spend it on themselves.

"I can afford it." Perhaps you can, and I won't invent a crisis. But money was never the main cost, only the easiest one to count. A well-paid person who's lonely on a Tuesday is as lonely after the parcel, and being able to afford it means no statement ever forces the question, so the habit can run for twenty years. The phrase also hides the total, because it's always about one purchase and one purchase is always affordable. So do the sum once. Add up everything unplanned from the last three months and multiply by four. Hold that figure up against the list above. It might be the very good chair, a week away with someone you like, or a cleaner for a year of Saturdays. The lift purchases never added up to more nice things. Mostly they were bought in place of the nicest ones, a bit at a time.

Not on the day you want it

The decision is one sentence. You stop buying things on the day you first want them.

A want that arrives tonight can't be paid for tonight. It goes on a list with a date, and it can be bought on a later day if it's still wanted. A real want comes through a wait easily. For a want made by a mood, the wait is usually the end of it.

First, one finding I've been saving. In Rick's experiments, shopping choices reduced sadness whether they were real or hypothetical, so people who chose and didn't buy got the benefit too. The sense of control came from the deciding, and paying added nothing to it. So you can still browse. Compare the pockets, pick tan over olive, have the whole twenty-five minutes. Then, where you'd normally tap to pay, write it down and close the tab. If the finding holds outside the laboratory, you've had a good share of the lift for nothing.

Here's how it runs in the moment.

  • When you catch yourself browsing, say "I'm after a lift." It isn't an accusation. It moves your attention from the bag to the evening. Then ask what happened today.
  • Ask whether you wanted it yesterday. If yes, and you'd planned it, go ahead with a clear mind.
  • If no, put it on the waiting list. One list, on paper or your phone, with the thing, the price and today's date. Enjoy the choosing as much as you like, then close the tab.
  • Give the evening what it needed. Put a date in the diary, because people look forward to dates, and a blank fortnight may be the whole reason you're looking at bags. Ring someone, since a ten-minute call does more for a lonely day than any parcel. Do one small job of your own that you can begin and finish inside half an hour, like the drawer that sticks. Or go to bed.
  • Once a week, on a rested morning, read down the list. For anything a few days old, ask whether you still want it and what it'll be in its third month. I'd wait a week for small things and a month for anything that would make you wince, and those periods are my suggestion, nothing more scientific. Cross off whatever has gone cold.
  • Buy what survives, without guilt. It's a planned purchase now, so watch for it in the sales.

Then spend one evening putting the pauses back. Delete your saved cards from the shops you use most, so that paying means fetching your wallet. Unsubscribe from every marketing email in one sitting. Take shopping apps off your phone. Keep pay-later schemes for planned purchases, if you use them at all. Each of these gives you back a few seconds, which is all the question needs.

Plans of the form "when this happens, I'll do that" have a good record in research on habits. Make two. "When I notice I'm browsing in the evening, I'll ask what happened today." "When I see a countdown timer, I'll leave the page."

The urge to browse will keep arriving on flat evenings, probably for good, because flat evenings keep arriving. An urge is only a feeling. I'd expect the list to take the heat out of most of them within minutes, and I'd expect fewer parcels, more money at the end of the month and more pleasure from what you do buy. That's my expectation and I can't promise it, because the method hasn't been tested as a package. A month is long enough to test it on yourself.

Some times are harder. Late evening, when your judgement is at its lowest, so keep a rule that the list is open at night and the checkout isn't. Payday, when the balance looks healthy, so move what you mean to save on the day it arrives. The big sale weeks in November and January, when the list is your best defence and also how you get real bargains. And bad weeks, after a row or a bereavement or a run of poor sleep, when the pull is stronger because there's more to lift. Be kinder to yourself then, and stricter with the checkout.

You'll lapse. One night you'll buy the thing and remember all this on Thursday when the box comes. If it's unwanted, send it back that week. Ask what the evening needed. Put the next want on the list. One lapse only becomes a habit again if you decide it proves something.

For some people the difficulty is a different size. Compulsive buying is a preoccupation with shopping, with tension building beforehand and relief on buying, to a degree that causes distress or damages a life. The psychiatrist Donald Black notes that it often goes along with depression and anxiety, and one pooled analysis put it at about one adult in twenty. Talk to a GP if any of these is true.

  • Thoughts of shopping take up much of most days, or you shop to get rid of a tension that keeps building.
  • You hide purchases, lie about what you've spent, or have debts that someone close to you doesn't know about.
  • You've tried several times to stop and couldn't, and it's harming your money, your work or your relationships.
  • Your spending comes in bursts when you feel unusually high and energetic and need little sleep.
  • You've felt low, worried or hopeless for more than a few weeks, whatever your spending is doing.

In England you can also refer yourself to NHS talking therapies without seeing a GP first. If you take prescribed medication, keep taking it. If you ever feel you can't cope or that life isn't worth living, get help the same day through NHS 111, an urgent GP appointment or 999. The debt services named at the start help people every day who are in far more of a tangle than they'd like to admit, and Black mentions Debtors Anonymous as something that helps some people. Going to any of them is nothing to be ashamed of.

Here's that Tuesday once more.

Ten past nine, the sofa, the moved meeting, the reheated dinner, the tan bag. You look, because looking is fine, and spend ten pleasant minutes on tan against olive. Somewhere in there you think, without any scorn, that you're after a lift, and you ask what happened today. The answer takes about four seconds. You were pushed around all day, and the next fortnight is empty. Your card isn't saved any more, so paying would mean fetching your wallet from your coat, and in that small gap you ask the question. You didn't want it yesterday. You write "weekend bag, tan, £68" on the list with Tuesday's date and close the tab. Then you message the friend you keep meaning to see about the Saturday after next, and she says yes before the kettle has boiled.

Ten days later, on a Saturday morning, you read down the list. The bag is there and you feel nothing much about it. You cross it off, along with a desk fan and a set of glasses. A good pair of walking boots you've thought about since the spring still appeals, so they stay on. In January they're reduced by a quarter and you buy them.

They're by the door now, with mud on them.

Today, before the feeling of having read something wears off, delete the saved card from the shop you use most. It takes a minute. Next time you'll have to get up and find your wallet, and that's long enough to ask whether you wanted it yesterday.