You were tired at ten

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 48 min

You get in from work at half past six. Dinner to make, eat and clear away. Children to bath and read to and put back to bed twice. A load of washing, tomorrow's packed lunches, a form for the school that's due in the morning. At a quarter past nine you sit down for the first time since lunch.

At ten you yawn, and your eyes are heavy. If you went up now you'd be asleep in ten minutes and get eight hours. You know this.

You stay. It's an episode of something, then another, with your phone in your hand. At some point you notice it's twenty to one. You go up, annoyed with yourself, and the alarm goes at half past six. You get through the next day on coffee and a short temper, and by nine that evening you're looking forward to the only good part of the day, which starts when everyone else has gone to bed.

Without children the evening looks different and the pattern often doesn't. The demands come from a job that follows you home, or a parent who needs a call every night. Some people live alone and do it anyway, because the day belonged to work and the evening is the only part that doesn't.

People have started calling this revenge bedtime procrastination, revenge on a day that left you nothing. The name gets something right. There's a note of defiance in it. It feels like a small refusal.

I'm not going to lecture you about sleep. You know you should get more, and knowing hasn't helped. Nor will I tell you that wanting time to yourself is self-indulgent. It's a real need, as real as food, and people who get none of it for long stretches become worn and resentful. I'll call it your own time.

What I'll argue against is the method. You get your own time by staying up past the point where you're tired, which I'll call the tired point. Here it's ten o'clock. The stretch from there to lights out is the late stretch. It buys your own time with sleep, at the end of the day, after everything else has been paid, and it delivers that time at the hour when you're least able to use it. The next day pays, which makes the next evening's need bigger. And it lets the real problem, a day with no room in it for you, carry on untouched.

Three cautions. This is for people who could sleep if they went to bed. If you lie awake for a long time, or wake in the night and can't get back to sleep, that's insomnia, a different problem, and spending longer in bed isn't how it's usually treated. Some people stay up precisely because bed has come to mean lying awake. If that's you, start with a GP. Second, if you sleep enough and are still very tired every day, see a GP. Some tiredness has medical causes no bedtime will touch, and there's more on that at the end. Third, if you work nights or shifts, have a baby who wakes, or care for someone through the night, your hours were taken from you, and nothing here is aimed at you. And if you take medication for sleep, mood or anything else, nothing here is a reason to stop it or change the dose.

For one week, write down two times each morning. When you first noticed you were tired the evening before, and when you turned out the light. A scrap of paper by the bed will do.

A good wine and a heavy cold

The late stretch pays, or you wouldn't keep doing it.

It gives you time with no demands, when nobody needs feeding or answering or helping to find their shoes. It gives you control after a day of other people deciding, and researchers who study recovery from work count control as a basic ingredient of it. It's a refusal, a way of saying the day doesn't get all of you. It keeps tomorrow waiting. It's quiet, the house at half past eleven a different place from the same house at seven. And it's easy, because going to bed takes effort and staying put takes none.

The first two matter a great deal.

The costs start with tomorrow, when you'll be shorter with the people you live with. Then the loop. A tired day is a harder day, tasks take longer, the chores run later, and by nine you're more worn than you'd have been, so the need is stronger and you stay up later still. Saturday morning goes on sleeping in. You go to bed cross with yourself most nights, and that's the last feeling of the day. And the cost I'd worry about most is the least visible. As long as midnight is there, the day doesn't have to change. You can go on giving every hour of it to other people, and the late stretch works as a pressure valve that lets an unworkable arrangement keep working.

"It's the only time that's mine." That may be true. In the evening above, every hour from half six in the morning to a quarter past nine at night belonged to an employer, a child or the household. If that person's own time doesn't come after nine, it doesn't come.

You're far from alone, either. A team of Dutch psychologists surveyed 2,431 adults and reported that a large share of the population regularly goes to bed later than they meant to, with nothing outside them stopping them. When the same group interviewed seventeen people who did it often, one of the main patterns was deliberate. Those people knew they were delaying, and did it because they felt they deserved time for themselves after the day they'd had.

They do deserve it. The word I'd question is "only".

At midnight you're more tired than at any other point in the day. Your attention is poor, your mood flat, and the part of you that chooses well is worn down. You can't concentrate on a book, so you don't pick one up. There's nobody awake to talk to. It's like saving your best bottle of wine for a night when you've got a heavy cold. You do get to drink it. You can barely taste it.

And look at who pays. The hour between midnight and one comes out of tomorrow, and tomorrow's you gets no say, though they're the one who has to be patient with a toddler at seven and sharp in a meeting at ten. If anyone else treated them that way, you'd be angry on their behalf.

"There isn't any other time. I've looked." For some people that's close to true. But notice how the timetable was drawn up. Everything else was given its place first, and you got whatever was left. Your own time ended up at midnight because every other hour had been handed out before anyone got to you.

So stop calling the late stretch your own time, even in your head. Call it staying up. Keep "my own time" for something better.

What do you actually do between ten and lights out on an ordinary Tuesday? I don't mean what you'd like to do, like the guitar untouched since March. I mean what happens. For most people it's television half watched and a phone half read, and often food they didn't much want. None of it was chosen exactly. It was what needed least effort from someone with no effort left.

The Dutch interviews found this as well. Their second pattern was mindless. People lost track of time and looked up to find it was one o'clock. A common evening is both, deliberate at ten and mindless after. You decide you deserve another half hour, and then nobody decides anything for two hours. One survey found that the more drained people were, the more guilty they felt about their evening television, and the guilt went with getting less recovery from it. That matches the background hum of "I should be in bed" that makes the late stretch hard to enjoy.

Some late hours have been lovely, I'm sure. A film you chose, a long talk with your partner that ran on. Those aren't the default. The default happens because it's Tuesday and you sat down.

For that same week, add one line each morning. What did you do between the tired point and lights out, and how good was it, out of ten? Not how badly you needed it. How good it was. My guess is a lot of fours.

Six hours and a second wind

Most people who stay up late have done a private sum. Eight hours would be nice, six is enough, and years of six haven't made them crash the car.

There's something in it. People do differ, the usual adult range of seven to nine hours is an average, and one bad night does little harm. The problem is the evidence you're using, which is how you feel.

At the University of Pennsylvania, 48 healthy adults lived in a laboratory for two weeks on eight, six or four hours in bed a night, doing tests of attention and thinking every day. The six-hour and four-hour groups got worse on every test, and kept getting worse for the whole fortnight. By the end, the six-hour group was performing about as badly as people kept awake for up to two nights running.

Their sleepiness ratings rose for a few days and then flattened.

They felt a bit sleepy and thought that was the extent of it, while their performance went on falling. The researchers concluded people were largely unaware of how far they'd slipped. The judgement is being made by the instrument that's affected. And after years of short nights, what feels like your normal self may be your six-hour self. You may not have met the other one since your last long holiday.

It isn't only concentration. A large review pooled 154 experiments in which people's sleep was cut short or broken, and across every kind of sleep loss people felt less positive emotion and more anxiety. After a short night, the day is greyer and more worrying, and that's the day you'll want revenge on by evening.

The Pennsylvania volunteers were young, healthy and few, and you may need less sleep than they did. The test is simple, though. People who need only six hours aren't tired at ten. And if you sleep two or three hours longer every Saturday, six wasn't enough.

"I'll catch up at the weekend." You do sleep longer and feel better for it. In a small study at the University of Colorado, young adults who had five short nights followed by a weekend of sleeping as much as they liked got only about an hour more than normal over the whole weekend, a fraction of what they'd lost. Their body clocks also shifted later, so Sunday night came at what their bodies now treated as evening. You sleep until ten on Sunday, aren't tired at eleven, and Monday starts short.

The bigger cost is what the lie-in replaces. Rested, you'd be awake at half seven on Saturday with a clear head and the day's demands not begun, two hours of your own time in the best condition it ever comes in. So from Monday to Thursday you take five or six poor hours late at night, and at the weekend you pay them back with four or five of your best hours, asleep.

A lie-in you choose, rested, with tea and the paper, is your own time well spent. The costly one is the lie-in you can't help, surfacing at half ten feeling as if you've been hit.

"I'm not tired any more." At ten you could barely keep your eyes open, and by half eleven you feel fairly awake, as if going up at ten would have been a mistake.

I don't doubt the feeling. Look at where it came from. A research team in Boston had people read before bed, some evenings on a device that gives off light and some from a printed book. On the screen evenings they felt less sleepy at bedtime, took longer to fall asleep, and were less alert the next morning. How big the effect is in ordinary homes is argued over, but in the study the light covered the tiredness, and the tiredness was still there when the alarm went. A drama ending on a hook, or a feed with something new every few seconds, does the same job in my view. An interested mind is an alert mind for a while.

The doze at nine, when you nod off in front of the television and wake with a stiff neck, has spent some of your tiredness early, on a sofa. If you catch yourself going under at nine, that's the tired point arriving early, and the useful response is to go up. And in one study, a large dose of caffeine taken six hours before bed still disturbed sleep. If you drink coffee after lunch, try stopping at noon for a fortnight.

So at ten, in a quiet moment, your body reported that it was tired. At half eleven, under bright light and halfway through a plot, it reported it wasn't. Trust the ten o'clock reading.

Going upstairs doesn't always end it. In a survey of young adults, people who spent more than an hour in bed before trying to sleep, much of it on screens, were about nine times as likely to be poor sleepers. Bedtime means lights out.

Some people really aren't sleepy at ten. Body clocks differ, and evening types put off bed more on work nights for reasons that have nothing to do with self-control. If that's you, your sleep is set to a different timetable from your job. Light in the morning, a steady getting-up time and, where you can get it, a later start are the usual remedies, and a GP or sleep clinic can help if it's severe. But a true night person isn't fighting to stay awake on the sofa.

Then there's the belief nobody says aloud. Going to bed ends today, and the next thing you'll know is the alarm. While you're up, tomorrow hasn't happened.

Tomorrow starts at half past six whatever you do tonight. All you can change from the sofa is the state you'll be in. It's like trying to delay a train by arriving late at the station. The train keeps its timetable, and you board it out of breath. Sleep loss raises anxiety, as that review found, so the dread of tomorrow is partly made by the short nights already behind you. My own view, with no study of the whole loop, is that the more you put tomorrow off, the more frightening it gets.

If your tomorrows really are that bad, take it seriously, in daylight, perhaps with a friend, a union rep, a GP or a counsellor. Decisions about changing a life get made on good sleep. For the ordinary Sunday-night kind of dread, write one line before you go up, the first thing you'll do at work. It gives the shapeless lump a first step, and the step is usually smaller.

The closing time

You're on the sofa, warm and heavy. Between you and sleep are the lights, the doors, the dishwasher, the stairs, your teeth, your face, the alarm. Ten minutes of chores at the moment of the day when you have least energy for chores. Staying put needs nothing, and the television will start the next episode without being asked.

You're too tired to go to bed.

Research tying this to willpower is mixed. I'd build on something plainer. An action gets done more often when it's easy. Right now staying up is as easy as an action can be, and going to bed is an obstacle course. You don't need more willpower at ten. You need going to bed to be less work at ten.

Almost none of those chores has to be done at bedtime. They're done then out of custom. At nine, or whenever the children are down, lock up, set the dishwasher going, put out tomorrow's clothes, brush your teeth, and get into whatever you sleep in. Then sit down. When the tired point comes, going to bed means one lamp and a flight of stairs. Pyjamas at nine may feel childish for a few evenings, and with your teeth brushed, the eleven o'clock snack goes too. And decide what you're watching, and how much, before you start. Turn off the setting that plays the next episode by itself. Left on, it makes stopping a thing you have to do and carrying on a thing that just happens.

"It's the only time we get together." For couples, the late stretch is often the two of you on the sofa after the house goes quiet, and going up at ten can feel like choosing sleep over the relationship. Time together is a real need too. But often it's the same programme from two ends of a sofa, each with a phone, both too tired to talk, and two tired people are also shorter with each other. Sometimes one of you would go up at ten and stays for the other.

So talk about it at a sensible hour. You may find you both want more sleep and each has been staying up for the other. Half an hour at half past eight with the television off and the phones in another room is more contact than two hours of parallel scrolling. If your partner is a night owl, you can still go up at your own tired point, saying so beforehand. "I'm going to start going up when I'm tired. It isn't about you. Can we have the first half hour after the kids are down instead?"

Which leaves the real question. If the late stretch is a poor way to get your own time, where else can it come from?

I can't add hours to your day, and a single parent with two jobs, or someone caring from waking to sleep, has a shortage no rearranging will close. But time of your own sometimes hides in these places.

  • The early evening, with the order turned round. Household jobs never finish, so if your own time waits for them it waits until you're too tired to use it. Give it a fixed start. If the children are down by eight, eight until a quarter to nine is yours, the best hour the evening has. The jobs fit round it.
  • The jobs themselves. Tired people often keep house to a standard set by someone more rested. Packed lunches can be the same four days running. Folding can replace the ironing. A kitchen left untidy overnight is fine. Give chores a closing time, the way a shop has one, and after that the kitchen is shut.
  • Other people. If you share a home with an adult, try an evening off each. On Tuesday one of you is off duty from half seven while the other does bedtimes and whoever comes down wanting water. On Thursday you swap. Alone, the same idea might run through a grandparent or a swap with another single parent, though I know that's easier to write than arrange.
  • The working day. A lunch break away from the desk is your own time in daylight.
  • The morning, once you're sleeping enough. The house is as still at six as at midnight. This only works if bedtime moves as well.
  • The word no. A committee, a favour or an extra shift you didn't have to take on. One fewer is an evening back.

"If I take an hour at eight, I'll feel guilty the whole time, with the kitchen like that." You may, at first. You already take two hours at midnight and feel guilty for being up. At eight, the guilt at least buys you an hour you can use.

Some people love the night itself, the dark and the quiet and being the only one awake. People have written books and worked out their lives in those hours. I'm not asking you to give them up. I'm asking you to choose them. On a Friday with no alarm on Saturday, you decide to stay up with a film or a project and enjoy it with a clear conscience. On a Tuesday you were tired at ten and you're still there at one because nobody decided anything. One or two chosen late nights a week can sit inside a life of enough sleep.

Eight o'clock is yours

My own time comes first in the evening, and the evening ends when I'm tired.

The order matters. If you only do the second half, you'll go to bed at ten feeling robbed and be back on the sofa at midnight within a week, which would be a fair response to having something taken away with nothing in its place. So don't move your bedtime until your own time has somewhere else to be. Here's how I'd do it, though the combination is mine and untested as a whole.

  • Give your own time a start. Pick a time early in the evening, eight in the example, and treat it like an appointment with someone else. Decide beforehand what you'll do, because a tired person with no plan ends up on the phone. Make it something you'd give more than a four.
  • Close the kitchen. After a set time, no more household jobs. Whatever's left waits.
  • Get ready for bed early, about an hour before your notes say the tired point comes.
  • Decide the ending before you begin. One episode, said aloud if someone's with you. Automatic play off.
  • Keep the phone out of the bedroom. Buy a cheap alarm clock and charge the phone downstairs. If you need to be reachable at night, leave the ringer on and the door open.
  • Choose your late nights. One or two a week, with no early alarm after, when you stay up as long as you like and put something good in them.

For the moment itself, two trials with university students tested a short exercise against going to bed late, and those who did it overran their bedtime by fewer minutes. Picture the best result of going to bed on time, as vividly as you can. Name the main obstacle inside you, such as "I feel I haven't had any time to myself". Then make a plan for it. They were short trials, but it costs five minutes. Three plans are worth writing out now.

  • When I notice I'm tired, I turn off the lamp and go up, because I've already had my hour.
  • When the episode ends, I turn the television off before I look at my phone.
  • When I think "I've had no time to myself today", I write down where tomorrow's hour is going to be.

That third one is for the evenings when the hour at eight didn't happen, because the boiler broke or a child was sick, and the old logic says you're owed the late stretch. What you're owed is tomorrow's hour, protected harder.

The first week, the hour at eight will feel wrong with the kitchen in that state, and going up at ten will feel like a loss for several nights before the mornings start to show a difference. I can't say how large it will be or how soon. Give it two weeks, then check your marks out of ten. Is your own time scoring higher than it did? More sleep is the side effect.

The late nights will come back, in a deadline week, on holiday, with an illness or a series everyone's talking about, and one Tuesday you'll be on the sofa at ten to one as if the last two months hadn't happened. That undoes nothing. Tomorrow, take the hour at eight, close the kitchen, and go up when you're tired. Don't count nights, because a streak makes one slip feel like a collapse. Ask what brought it back. Often your own time quietly vanished from the early evening, and the late stretch came back to fill the space. Move the hour, shrink it or defend it. Twenty minutes that really happen beat an hour that usually doesn't. And if every day leaves you emptied out, the problem is the load and not the bedtime, and those decisions go better on enough sleep too.

See a GP if any of these apply.

  • You go to bed at a sensible time and lie awake for a long while, or wake and can't get back to sleep, and it's gone on for months, or is making life hard, or changing your habits hasn't helped. The usual treatment is a form of cognitive behavioural therapy designed for insomnia.
  • You stay up because you dread lying in the dark with your thoughts. That often goes with anxiety or low mood, which are treatable.
  • You sleep a reasonable number of hours and are still very tired every day, or you've been told you snore loudly, gasp, or stop breathing in your sleep. Those can be signs of sleep apnoea, which needs testing.
  • Your mood has been low for weeks, or you've lost interest in things.
  • You've had thoughts of harming yourself. That needs urgent help the same day, from your GP, an emergency service or a crisis line.

If tiredness is making you unsafe to drive, treat it as seriously as drink. Keep taking prescribed medication as directed, and if you think a medicine is affecting your sleep, raise it with whoever prescribed it before changing anything.

So here's the evening again, with a few things moved. The children are down by eight. The kitchen isn't finished, and you walk past it. From eight until a quarter to nine you sit in the good chair with a novel you've meant to read for a year. Someone comes down once for water. At a quarter to nine you do the lunches, leave the washing, lock up and brush your teeth, then watch one episode with your partner, having said it's one.

At ten you yawn. There's a brief pull to stay, and it has less behind it than it used to, because the day did have something of yours in it. You turn off the lamp and go up. The phone is charging in the kitchen.

Tomorrow, find where your hour is going to be, and take it before you're tired.