Ask the price of the evening

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 53 min

You're at a restaurant with five friends. You had a main course and a glass of wine. Someone at the far end had a starter, two cocktails and the fish, someone else ordered a second bottle for the table, and when the bill comes somebody says "shall we just split it?" and everyone says yes. Your share is sixty-eight pounds. You'd have paid thirty-five for what you ate. You pay it and say nothing, because saying something would make you the person who says something.

In the group chat there's a hen weekend in Lisbon. Flights, two nights, a boat trip, a dinner, matching outfits. Nobody has mentioned a number. You've said "count me in", because everyone else has, and the number will arrive later, in pieces.

Next door has a new kitchen. Yours is fine, and you've started looking. A colleague has a new car, and you've noticed yours is seven years old. The school has sent a letter about a ski trip, and you've said yes to that too.

None of these is a problem on its own. The sixty-eight pounds bought a nice evening, and the hen weekend is for a friend's wedding. The habit is something else. In each case the decision was made by the table and not by you, the price was never asked, and at the end of the month there's less than there should be and you can't say where it went, because it went in twenty places and each of them was fine.

I'll call the habit keeping up, and whichever group is setting the pace, friends, neighbours, colleagues or the school gate, I'll call the table.

Keeping up makes sense from the inside, and I'll be fair to it. But the price of an evening is set by whoever chose the place. The table is keeping up with somebody above it. Nobody at the table knows anyone else's finances, and friendships don't run on matched spending. The way out is one question. Before you say yes, you ask the price, and you only pay it if you'd have chosen it on your own.

I'm not asking you to be frugal, stop going out, lecture your friends or think less of people who spend. I'm asking for one question before each yes, and a clear line between what you'd have chosen and what you matched.

Two cautions. If the spending has become debt you can't keep up with, or you're using cards to stay at the table, that's a different problem, and it may need help now. StepChange, Citizens Advice and National Debtline are free and they don't judge. And if your income doesn't cover the essentials, this isn't about you. It's about people who can afford the evening and are spending on evenings they didn't choose. The same three services are the place to start.

Before you go on, do one thing. For a month, keep a list. Every time you spend money on something because the table did, write down what it was and the price. The split, the round, the weekend, the gift you matched, the thing the other children have. Don't change anything yet. At the end of the month, add it up. Most people find the total is a number they'd have called impossible, made entirely of items they'd have called fine.

The back of the queue

The table is your people. Going where they go is part of what being one of them means.

So keeping up has good reasons behind it. You've watched what happens to the one in every group who's difficult about money, and they get invited less. You like buying a round and you like your friend's wedding being lovely. Your friends manage the restaurants, the neighbours managed the kitchen, and if they can, it seems you should be able to. Sitting out feels poor. And after a hundred tables, the yes comes out before the price does, because that's the order it has always come in.

Those needs are real. Belonging, generosity, not being thought mean, not falling behind. The trouble is that keeping up meets them badly, at a pace that was set by nobody in particular.

Start with the belief that turns the table's spending into a fact about incomes. They can afford Lisbon, so it must be affordable, and if it's a stretch for you, that's your problem.

What you can see at the table is what people spend. What you can't see is what it costs them. Nobody announces their salary, their mortgage, their overdraft or the balance on the card the sixty-eight pounds just went on. The spending is public and the finances are private, and you're inferring one from the other, for six people, none of whom you'd dare ask.

Robert Frank and colleagues, in 2014, set out a model they called expenditure cascades. People's sense of what's normal to spend is set by the people just above them. When that group spends more, the standard shifts for the group below, who spend more to keep up, which shifts it for the group below them, and so on down. They tested the model against how savings respond to changes in people's own income and in other people's, and it predicted patterns the standard models couldn't. It's a model, and models simplify. The mechanism is the thing to hold. The table isn't the top of anything.

Think of a queue. Each person watches the one in front and steps forward when they do, and nobody can see what's at the front.

The friend who ordered the second bottle is keeping up with her sister's friends. The neighbour chose the kitchen after a dinner at a house with a bigger one. What you take for everyone's ease is the back of their heads. I'm not saying your friends are struggling. I'm saying you don't know, and they don't know about you either.

Then there's the price itself, which arrives looking like arithmetic. An evening costs sixty-eight pounds. Lisbon costs four hundred.

It's a decision. Whoever chose the restaurant made it, whoever ordered the second bottle adjusted it, and whoever said "shall we just split it?" finalised it. At each step someone made a choice, and you weren't that person, and you paid as though it were the weather. The same six friends could have had the same conversation for thirty pounds each somewhere else. The hen party could have had a cottage two hours away for a third of the cost. The conversation, which is what you were paying for, costs the same at every price. Only the setting changes, and the setting was picked for reasons that had nothing to do with your month.

The split does the most expensive work of all, because it turns a decision into a courtesy, and declining a courtesy feels churlish in a way that declining a bill doesn't. But a split is a transfer. It moves money quietly from the people who ordered less to the people who ordered more, and the people who ordered less are often the ones who were watching the price. If you had a main and a glass and paid sixty-eight, thirty-three pounds of that was a gift to the far end of the table, made without your deciding to make it.

Underneath it all sits position, and here I want to say plainly that it isn't a flaw in you.

Sara Solnick and David Hemenway, in 1998, offered people choices between two worlds. In one you earn fifty thousand a year and others earn twenty-five. In the other you earn a hundred thousand and others earn two hundred. Half chose the first. They'd take half the real income to be ahead of the people around them. The pull was strongest for attractiveness and praise from a boss, and weakest for holiday time, where most people just wanted more. It was a survey of hypothetical choices, and surveys aren't life. Still, caring about relative position is normal, and half of people will say so out loud when asked plainly.

The kitchen gets bought because next door's is newer. The preference for position is real, and the kitchen is twelve thousand pounds.

But position relative to whom, and in what? Solnick's respondents cared about income, looks and praise. Nobody was asked about restaurants. Nobody at the table is ranking you by what you ordered. The position you protect with the split is in a ranking that nobody is keeping.

What you'd want with nobody looking

Here is the question that sorts everything you buy. Would you have wanted this if nobody were going to see it?

Some of what you keep up with is things. The kitchen, the car, the coat. Good things are a pleasure, you'd say, and the pleasure is worth the money. Sometimes it is. But the thing you wanted and the thing you matched go on the same card, and they're different purchases.

Leaf Van Boven and Thomas Gilovich, in 2003, found across surveys and experiments that people got more happiness from buying experiences than from buying things. The matched kitchen is a thing. The dinner with five friends is an experience. Then Jordi Quoidbach, Elizabeth Dunn and colleagues, in 2010, found that wealthier adults reported less ability to savour ordinary pleasures, and that this undercut the happiness their money might have bought. Even a picture of money did something similar. People shown one spent less time eating a piece of chocolate and enjoyed it less.

So the matched kitchen arrives with next door built in. It's a thing, bought as a reminder of position, and reminders like that seem to blunt enjoyment. You get a room that's newer than next door's for about a year, until they do theirs, and a cup of tea in it that tastes exactly as it did in the old one.

The coat you saw, wanted, saved for and wear every day is yours. The coat you bought because it's the brand at the school gate is a different object with the same label.

"I've earned it" gets the same test. Rewards are fine, and most people could do with more of them. The holiday somewhere you've always wanted to go passes. A car that does something your old one doesn't passes. A car that does what the old one did, only newer and parked at work, doesn't. The test is about where the want came from, and some expensive things pass easily.

Children are the hardest case, because keeping up for them feels like care. And some of it is. A child whose every possession is visibly cheaper than every classmate's has a harder time at school, and I won't pretend otherwise. But the ski trip is a thousand pounds for a week, and the child who doesn't go spends it at school with the others who didn't go, of whom there are always several. A party at a venue is three hundred pounds for two hours. A party at home is a hundred for four, and the children there seem to have a better time. Often the keeping up is for the parents at the gate, and the child is the reason given.

What a child learns from the gate is the pace. A child who hears "we're not doing the ski trip this year, but we're doing the cottage at Easter" learns that a family chooses. Keep one rule. Nothing that would leave them alone. If every child in the class is going and yours would be the only one left behind, that's different, and the price might be worth paying. That's rare, though the letter makes it sound like every time.

"But we can afford it."

Yes. Every line on your list is affordable. That's exactly the trouble, because the habit lives in the month. For most readers on an adequate income, the month's kept-up spending comes to several hundred pounds, and for some it's over a thousand. Each item was a decision about one thing, made at a table, with the price out of view. None of them was a decision about several hundred pounds. The splits go on the card, the deposits go by transfer, the presents come out of cash, and the month ends short with no single place to look. Affordable doesn't mean free. It means you had the money, and now the far end of the table has it.

The card helps keep it hidden. Drazen Prelec and George Loewenstein, in 1998, described the pain of paying, the small unpleasant feeling of handing money over, and argued that cards weaken it by separating the buying from the paying. Priya Raghubir and Joydeep Srivastava, in 2008, found across four studies that people were willing to spend more when a card logo was in view, and spent more with tokens than with cash. Six cards go on the saucer and each takes sixty-eight pounds without a twinge, because the paying happens three weeks later on a statement with forty other lines. If you counted out three twenties, a five and three pounds, you'd feel it, and that feeling is what makes "I'll just put in for mine" come out. For a month, try taking the cash for the evening out beforehand and paying with that.

Living on credit is a different habit, with its own help. If a split goes on a card you don't clear, you pay for it twice.

"Money isn't the point of life," you might say, and asking the price sounds like making it the point.

Look at what keeping up requires. Knowing what everyone at the table spends. Noticing the neighbour's kitchen, the colleague's car, the trainers at the gate. In practice it means thinking about money nearly all the time, in the form of what other people have. Tim Kasser and Richard Ryan, in 1993, found across three studies that people for whom financial success was a central aim had lower wellbeing. Helga Dittmar and colleagues, in 2014, pooled over two hundred and fifty samples and found that a materialist outlook went with lower wellbeing, most strongly with risky spending and how people felt about themselves. Both are correlational, and the unhappiness might come first. But materialism in those studies means having money and possessions near the centre of what you want and measuring yourself by them. Keeping up does exactly that, while calling it friendship.

Asking the price puts money in view for ten seconds so it can be dealt with and dropped. Never asking makes it the weather.

The bill also carries things that aren't money. Evenings spent doing sums. A low, constant question about whether you can, which lights up with the group chat. A friendship in which the price has never been discussed, though half the people in it are worried about it. And every split and every "count me in" was a decision about your money made by somebody else, so the deciding has quietly moved out of your house.

Roughly what will it come to?

Before the yes, get the number.

When a plan arrives, in the chat or at the table or at the gate, find out what it costs before you reply. Once you've said yes, the price is something you're stuck with. Before, it's something you're deciding about.

  • Ask the organiser. "Sounds lovely, roughly what's it likely to come to all in?" It's warm, it assumes you're interested, and it asks for a number.
  • Look it up when you can. Menus are online, hotels have prices, trip letters have figures. Two minutes on your phone covers most evenings.
  • Get the all-in figure. Lisbon is the flight, the two nights, the boat, the dinner, the outfit, the drinks, the taxi and the present. The habit lives in the pieces.
  • Say the number to yourself. "Four hundred and twenty pounds." Said plainly, it becomes a decision.

Then hold it against your own list. Sit down once and write what you'd actually spend money on this year if no table existed. The holiday you keep talking about, the thing for the house you've wanted for three years, time off, a course, savings that would let you sleep. Put the month's matched list beside it. For most people, a year of the matched column would pay for a good part of the wanted one. So when the organiser gives you the number, ask whether you'd rather have this evening or that much of the thing you actually want. Sometimes the evening wins, and then it's a yes you made. The money you don't spend needs somewhere to go on payday, before it drifts back to the table.

Asking will feel rude for a fortnight. It isn't. You'd ask the price of a car, a holiday, a plumber, and think someone odd who didn't. The taboo only exists at the table, where the language is built to keep money out of view. "Shall we just", never "can I have thirty-three pounds". "Count me in", never "four hundred and twenty plus spending money". Most organisers are relieved to be asked, because they've been wondering whether it's too much and haven't liked to say.

"They'll think I'm tight."

Kenneth Savitsky, Nicholas Epley and Thomas Gilovich, in 2001, found that people in an awkward moment expect far harsher judgement than observers actually give. Observers barely registered what the actors were sure would define them. Your forecast of the exchanged look is made from inside the awkward moment, and those forecasts run harsh. What I've seen when someone says "I'll just pay for mine" is mostly nothing, because everyone's looking at their own share. A couple of people at the table are quietly relieved. Occasionally whoever had the fish is briefly put out, until they've worked out the new number. And a reputation for being tight belongs to people who are tight with others, who never buy a round and forget their wallet. Ordering what you want and paying for what you had is ordinary.

"It's for the friendship." Erica Boothby and colleagues, in 2018, found that after conversations people consistently underestimated how much the other person had liked them, between strangers, between new flatmates over months, and among members of the public. The thing you're paying to protect is sturdier than you think. Generosity is a different matter, and I'm all for it. Elizabeth Dunn and colleagues, in 2008, found that spending on other people made people happier than spending on themselves. So buy the round, and pay for the friend who's skint. The split isn't that. Being charged for someone else's fish because declining would be awkward is just money leaking away.

"Saying no means missing out." Usually the no doesn't have to cover the whole evening, because what you'd miss is the people, and the people will come to the corner place. When you do sit one out, the chat carries on and the next invitation arrives, and you hear the stories anyway, because stories are for telling to people who weren't there. The fear never counts what you gain, either. An evening at home that you chose, the early night, the call to a friend who isn't in this group. The wedding itself is once. The seventh hen weekend isn't, and it borrows the seriousness of the wedding to seem unmissable.

"It's just how our friends are." One person suggested the first expensive restaurant, probably because they'd been somewhere nice. One person said "shall we just split it?" once, and it stuck because nobody objected. The pace drifted up a suggestion at a time, and it can drift back the same way.

And somebody at your table can't afford it. There nearly always is someone. They haven't said, because nobody does, and they're paying the split on a card. When you say "count me in" before the price is known, the two people who were hoping someone would ask see that nobody will. Your yes is a vote for the pace, cast in front of people waiting to see how you'd vote. A counter-offer opens a door for whoever couldn't say it.

Once you know the price and wouldn't have chosen it, there's the saying so.

  • Make the counter-offer, once. "I can't do Lisbon but I'd love to do the day in town." "Can we do the corner place? I've been wanting to go back." Offer it as something you'd like, because you would. If it's repeated, it becomes a position.
  • If it isn't taken, the quiet no. "I'll skip this one, have a great time." No reason given, said warmly. The moment you explain, it's about your finances, and the table will reassure you or argue.
  • At the bill, "I'll just put in for mine, if that's all right", said as your card comes out. Often someone else says "me too" within seconds.
  • Buy your round. You don't have to stay for six. "I'm off after this one" is a quiet no with a pint in it.

The decision fits in one sentence.

Before I say yes, I ask the price, and I only pay it if I'd have chosen it on my own.

Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran, in 2006, reviewed ninety-four studies of plans made in the form "when this happens, I'll do that", and people who plan that way follow through much more often than people who only intend to. So write three.

  • When a plan arrives in the chat, I'll ask the organiser roughly what it'll come to before I reply.
  • When the bill comes and someone says "shall we split it?", I'll say "I'll just put in for mine" while getting my card out.
  • When the price is more than I'd have chosen, I'll offer the cheaper version once and then say "I'll skip this one" if it isn't taken.

What I'd expect, and this is my expectation and not a finding. The first time you ask, it'll feel like a small transgression, and the organiser will answer within a minute and nothing will happen. After your first counter-offer, taken or not, someone will probably message you to say they'd been thinking the same. After the first "I'll put in for mine", the split tends to retire itself at that table within a few dinners. You'll still say yes to plenty. Most of it will be things you'd have chosen, and those evenings will be better, because you won't be watching the bill.

For a wedding, go, and ask the price of everything around it separately. Work drinks feel risky to skip, and mostly they aren't, so come, buy a round, leave at a reasonable hour, and bring lunch on the day of the ninety-pound one. If you live with someone who says yes before the price arrives, the month's total is shared, and the two lists make a better conversation than "we spend too much", because they start from what you both want.

If the keeping up has turned into debt you can't service, if you're paying one card with another, or if the month's total has been coming out of money meant for essentials, the question is still right but it isn't enough. StepChange, Citizens Advice and National Debtline are free, confidential and used to this. Please don't wait for the total to shrink on its own.

The corner place

You'll be at a table, tired, and the split will come, and you'll pay it without a word, and only in the car will you remember. Or Lisbon lands in the chat at eleven at night and you've said "count me in" before reading the second message.

One split isn't the month. You noticed in the car, which is sooner than you used to notice. You can ask the price late, too. Find out what Lisbon comes to now, after the yes, and if it isn't yours, "I've looked at the dates and I can't make it work, have a wonderful time" is available for about a week after any yes. Then work out which table got through. If it was the late chat, plans that arrive after nine get answered in the morning. If it was one friend's enthusiasm, ask them the price first, before their next idea. If it was the moment the card came out, say the sentence as the card comes out, every time, until it's a habit. Don't keep a streak. Count prices asked.

Some months on, you're at the corner place with the same five friends, because when the plan came round you suggested it and two people said yes before anyone could suggest the other one. When the bill comes, someone starts to say "shall we just", and you say "I'll put in for mine" as your card comes out, and the person next to you says "me too". Your share is thirty-one pounds. You weren't watching anything.

Lisbon happened without you. The organiser said "about four-fifty all in, I think, is that OK?", and you said you'd love to do the day in town instead. Four of the eight came to both, two came only to the day, and the bride was at both.

The kitchen is fine. When you held twelve thousand pounds against your list, the list had a fortnight in Italy on it that you'd talked about for six years. You're going in May. The ski trip letter came, and you said not this year, and your daughter spent the week at school with four others and did a project on volcanoes she still talks about.

The friend from the corner place told you a few weeks ago that she'd been dreading the expensive restaurant for a year and hadn't known how to say so. When you asked what Lisbon would come to, she felt something loosen. Her plans have prices in the first message now.

You paid a split last month at a work dinner, because you were tired and it was easier, and you noticed in the taxi and put it on the list. The matched column has four things on it this month. In the first month there were nineteen.

The next time a plan arrives, ask what it's likely to come to before you say yes, and hold the number against the thing you actually want this year.