The 20-minute version
On Friday afternoon your manager stops at your desk and says, "Can we have a quick chat on Thursday? Nothing urgent." Then she goes into a meeting and you go home for the weekend.
By Sunday evening you've had the chat about thirty times. In most versions it's about the report that went out late in March. In some it's redundancy, because there was that email about costs. You've worked out what you'd say, what she'd say back, and how your voice would sound. You've got as far as telling your partner you've lost your job and working out how long the savings would last. You were at your nephew's birthday on Saturday, and you couldn't now say what was in the sandwiches.
On Thursday she asks whether you'd mind covering for someone in the Leeds office for two days in June.
Relief, and an hour of feeling foolish. Then by Thursday evening something else has moved into the space. The noise the boiler has started making. Your daughter driving back on the motorway late on Sunday.
If worrying were caused by the things you worry about, it would stop when they were settled. It finds a new subject instead, which is the first sign you're dealing with a habit.
So I want to split two things that travel under one name. The first is the concern. Your manager might be unhappy with you, the boiler might be on its way out, and motorways at night carry some risk. Concerns like these are often reasonable, and someone with none would be careless. I've no quarrel with them. The second is the worrying, which is what you do with a concern once you've got it. You run the scene, run it again with a small change, then follow it three steps further into a future that needs three things to go wrong. It's mostly words, a conversation with yourself that usually opens with "what if", and it never reaches an end, only a pause when something interrupts it. I'll call one spell of it a round.
How much of it you do has very little to do with how serious the concern is. You've probably lost a weekend to something trivial and been oddly calm about something serious.
I won't tell you to stop worrying, or that everything will be fine. Some things won't be. Worrying and getting ready feel alike from the inside, and they're different activities. Getting ready is worth your time. The rounds mostly aren't, and the useful part of them can be had in a few minutes with a pen.
Two cautions. This is about things that haven't happened. A lump you've found needs a doctor. Letters about a debt need a debt adviser. A partner who frightens you is a reason to ring a domestic abuse helpline. Those are problems, and problems are dealt with by action and other people's help. And if you've worried on most days for months, about many things, and find it hard to control, especially with poor sleep, tense muscles, tiredness or trouble concentrating, it may be what doctors call generalised anxiety disorder. It's common and treatable, and a GP is the place to start. Read this as well, not instead. If you take medication for anxiety or low mood, nothing here is a reason to stop it or change the dose.
Before going on, write down three things you're worried about now, each as a prediction with a date that could turn out true or false. "My manager will criticise my work on Thursday" is a prediction. "What if work goes badly" isn't, because nothing could ever prove it wrong. Keep the paper.
Paid in feelings
Nobody keeps a habit for years unless it pays, and worry pays in five ways.
It gives you the sense of doing something. Thursday is four days off, you can't act yet, and waiting with nothing to do is miserable. Worry fills the gap with what feels like work, and it tires you out, so at the end of an evening of it you feel a shift has been put in.
It makes you feel responsible. Somebody ought to be thinking about the boiler and the mortgage rate, and you're the one doing it, so relaxing looks like negligence.
It dulls the fear a little. Worry is mostly made of words, and Thomas Borkovec, who found that, speculated that talking to yourself about a fear is a way of not quite feeling it. A picture of your daughter's car on the hard shoulder goes straight to your stomach. A sentence about it is duller.
It ends in relief, when Thursday turns out to be about Leeds. And it guards against shock, since nobody can spring on you something you've already lived through.
Every one of these is a feeling. None of them changes what happens on Thursday.
The costs you know better than I do. Hours, adding up to days a month, spent in a future that mostly won't occur. You were at the birthday party and you weren't. Sleep goes, because rounds start easily in bed. Your jaw stays tight, since your body can't tell a rehearsed disaster from a real one. And decisions get put off, oddly, because the worrying takes the place of the phone call. You can worry about the boiler for a month without ringing the engineer, because ringing might bring bad news.
The belief holding all this up is "I'm just being prepared". People who check the tyres and read the contract do have fewer disasters. If worrying were that, I'd have nothing to say.
So watch someone prepare for a job interview. They read about the company. They write down five questions they might be asked and sketch an answer to each. They check the train times and pick an earlier one in case of delays, and they iron a shirt. That takes an evening at most, and at the end of it there's nothing left on the list. Now the same person worrying about it. What if I go blank? What if they ask about the gap in my CV? What if I'm just not good enough? That can run for a fortnight, and at the end of it no shirt has been ironed.
Preparation is concrete. It asks "how" and "when", and it deals in shirts and trains. Worry asks "what if" and drifts upwards from this interview to your career to what kind of person you are. Preparation runs out and leaves something behind, a list or a booking. Worry never runs out, because every answer raises another question.
There's an experiment on exactly this. In 2020 Sandra Llera and Michelle Newman asked 185 people to describe a real problem, then had some of them think about it in a worrying way and some think about it objectively. Judges who didn't know who was in which group rated the worriers' solutions as less effective, and the worriers finished more anxious. A worrier often has the answer by minute three and spends two hours checking it against imagined cases.
Sometimes a round does throw up something useful. Fretting about the holiday, you remember the passport expires in May. That thought arrived early, took seconds, and a calm five minutes with a checklist would have found it too. The hour after it is what I'd question.
Treat the first "what if" as an alarm, and a good one. The mistake is keeping it ringing in the belief that the ringing is the work. When it goes off, ask what you'd do about it with a pen in your hand. If something goes on paper, a call to make or a date to look up, you're preparing. If nothing can, what follows will be a round.
The tipster's record
It might happen. Every worry carries that small, fair point, and nobody can promise you otherwise.
The question worry never asks is how often. In 2020 Lucas LaFreniere and Michelle Newman did the counting. They took 29 university students whose worrying was severe enough to meet the criteria for generalised anxiety disorder. For ten days the students logged specific worries that would clearly come true or not within a month, and for thirty days they tracked what happened. About 91 per cent of the worries didn't come true. For seven of the 29, not one thing they'd worried about happened, and even the unluckiest person was wrong more often than right.
It's a small study, nearly all young women at one American university, judging their own outcomes, and it leaves out slow worries like "what if my pension isn't enough". But it agrees with what most people find when they check their own record.
And people almost never check. When a worry doesn't come true, nothing marks it. Within an hour of hearing about Leeds you've forgotten you were frightened. The one time in ten the fear was right, you remember for years. "I knew it. I had a feeling." So your memory holds a short list of hits and no list of misses.
A racing tipster who was wrong nine times in ten would lose your custom within a month, if you could see his record. Your worrying has never had to publish one.
One in ten isn't nothing. If an engineer told you there was a one in ten chance of a gas leak, you'd have it fixed that afternoon. That's a job with an end. Nothing about the odds tells you to rehearse it forty times.
The students who watched the most of their worries fail also improved the most. So turn your three predictions into a running log. Each new worry gets one line with a date. Once a week, mark the ones that have come due with a tick or a cross, and a word on whether it was as bad as you thought. Don't argue yourself out of anything. You're only keeping score, which is more than your worrying has ever done.
Some people hold a quieter belief, that it didn't happen because they worried. Said aloud it sounds like magic, so it's rarely said. You can feel it if you imagine deciding, today, not to worry about your daughter's drive home. There's a faint dread, as though you'd be tempting fate.
You were trained into that. You worry for a week, the thing doesn't happen, because most things don't, and relief floods in straight after the worrying. Anything followed by a reward gets repeated, and the mind never asks whether the worry caused the good outcome. Nine times in ten you get paid. Borkovec and others called the pattern superstitious. A football fan wears the same socks to every home game because his team won the first time. He doesn't really believe in the socks. He just feels uneasy leaving them in the drawer.
Look at what you forgot to worry about, like your son's school trip in the spring when you were busy moving house. Those went fine at about the same rate as the things you did worry about. And the three or four real blows of your life mostly weren't on your list. They came on an ordinary Tuesday from a direction you weren't watching.
Then there's bracing. Some people expect the worst so the worst can't ambush them. Somewhere back there is a phone call or a diagnosis that knocked them flat, and they've decided it's better to stay low than be dropped from a height. Michelle Newman and Sandra Llera have built a theory of chronic worry on that idea. It's the most sympathetic of the reasons, and the trade is still a poor one. You pay every day, in low mood and spoiled weekends, for a softer landing on something that mostly won't come.
There is evidence on the other side. Kate Sweeny and her colleagues followed 230 law graduates through four months of waiting for their bar exam results, and those who spent the wait anxious and pessimistic did respond better when the news came. But nothing they tried made the waiting itself easier. My own reading, not theirs, is that if bracing helps, it helps at the end. Walk into the room expecting the worst if you like. You don't have to live that way for the four months before.
Inside almost every worry there's a second prediction. The bad thing will happen, and you couldn't cope.
Worry runs the film to the worst moment and stops. The manager says "we're letting you go", and the frame freezes on your face, then rewinds and plays again. It never shows the next morning, when you ring two people you used to work with, or month four in a new job. In that frozen frame nobody is coping yet, so of course you conclude you couldn't.
Daniel Gilbert and his colleagues ran six studies comparing what people expected to feel after a bad event, such as a break-up or a job rejection, with how people who'd been through it felt. Every time, people expected to feel bad for longer than they did, perhaps because the quiet ways we recover after a blow go unnoticed and get left out of the forecast. Some losses are terrible and stay for years. Your forecast of your own collapse is still unreliable, and it errs towards the dark.
Think of the hard things you've already been through. You got the news and then did the next thing, often capably. A real event gives you particulars, a date, a sum, a name to ring. A what-if gives you fog, and nobody can cope with fog. When you catch the frozen frame, run the film on. What would you do the next morning? That week? Who would you ring? Write three lines, then stop. Once per fear. Done nightly, it's a round.
Ten at night, no text
Your daughter said she'd text when she got in. It's ten o'clock and she hasn't. You check the phone, then the traffic news for the M6, then the phone again, then when she was last online. Your partner says she's probably gone straight to bed, and that helps for about four minutes. Then you ask him again.
You know an accident is unlikely. What you can't stand is not knowing.
Michel Dugas, Robert Ladouceur and their colleagues in Quebec call this intolerance of uncertainty, and in their studies it separated people with severe chronic worry from others better than anything else they measured. Seen like that, a round is an attempt to reach certainty by thinking. It can't work, because the future isn't available for inspection. The checking can't either. Each check brings a drop of relief that lasts minutes and teaches you to check again. Reading about symptoms at midnight is the worst, because every search turns up a frightening possibility you hadn't thought of, and you close the laptop less certain than when you opened it.
Yet you tolerate uncertainty well almost everywhere else. You drive through green lights trusting the other road is on red, and let a surgeon you met once put you to sleep. The demand for a guarantee applies to a few subjects, usually the ones that matter most.
If the scan result is ready, ring for it. Information is good when it would change what you do. But the fifth check of the phone in ten minutes isn't for information. There was none at the fourth.
If checking has become a large part of your day, with routines you feel compelled to finish, or fears about your health take up hours and visits to the doctor don't settle them, that goes beyond the everyday habit. Tell a GP, because there are specific treatments.
For the everyday version, their treatment includes practice at leaving small things uncertain on purpose. Start with what barely matters.
- Send an ordinary email without rereading it a third time.
- Order something and don't look at the tracking.
- Go to a restaurant you haven't looked up.
- When you want reassurance, ask once, take the answer, and don't ask again that day.
You'll feel an itch of not knowing. Leave it alone. It fades, usually within minutes.
In a good many families, worry is how love gets said. "Text me when you get there." "I couldn't sleep until I heard the door." Grow up with that and worrying less about your children can feel like a plan to love them less.
Caring and worrying have been welded together by habit, and they come apart cleanly. Caring is what reaches the other person. You ring your father on Sundays, go with him to the hospital appointment and write down what the consultant says. You teach your daughter to check her tyres and pay for breakdown cover. Worrying happens in your head at two in the morning, and your father's heart gets nothing from it. If your daughter could see you sitting up, she'd feel guilty more than loved, and the children of heavy worriers often learn to edit what they tell you. When worry does reach them it tends to arrive as pressure, and "you're not going to cycle in this weather, are you?" can be heard as "I don't think you can manage".
"My mother worried constantly, and that's how I knew she loved me." I believe it. But what you remember with warmth is probably the kettle on when you got in late, or the parcel to your first flat. Those were acts. The hours she lay awake did nothing for you. When a worry about someone you love turns up, ask whether there's anything you could do for them this week. If there is, do it. If there isn't, because they're an adult and it's their drive home, the caring thing may be to trust them.
"I've always been a worrier. My mum was the same." Part of that's true. People differ in temperament, anxiety runs in families, and you may well have a more sensitive alarm than most. But what you do in the hour after the alarm goes off is another matter, and it looks learned. It's made of words, so you're producing it. It has favourite times, in bed, in the car, in the shower. It has favourite subjects, and your sister's are different from yours. And it can be interrupted. When the phone rings with something absorbing, the round stops.
In 2013 Sarah Kate McGowan and Evelyn Behar gave 53 heavy worriers one of two instructions for two weeks. Half confined their worry to a thirty-minute period each day at a set time and place, postponing anything that turned up outside it. The other half let it run. The first group had larger drops in worry, anxiety and insomnia. The authors call it preliminary. Still, you can't give a fixed trait an appointment and have it turn up on time. A habit, it seems, you can.
You've also been told to stop thinking about it, tried, and got worse. In 1987 Daniel Wegner asked people not to think of a white bear for five minutes. They couldn't, and afterwards they thought about it more than people who'd never been asked to suppress it. Later work found the rebound is real, if modest. So you didn't fail through lack of willpower. Nothing that follows asks you to push a thought away.
Six o'clock at the kitchen table
When a what-if arrives, you either take a step or give it an appointment.
Neither option is a round. You don't argue with the thought or follow it. Most of this is adapted from standard cognitive behavioural work on worry.
- Catch it and write it down. Put the worry into one line as a prediction in your log. Vague and endless in your head, it becomes one sentence on paper.
- Ask whether there's a step. Is there anything you can do about this, today or on a day you can name? "Think about it more" isn't a step. A step is a physical act you could tick off, like ringing the engineer, asking the manager what the chat is about, booking the GP, or moving two hundred pounds into savings.
- If there's a step, take it or date it. Do the smallest version now, or write "Ring engineer, Monday 9am", and if it comes back before then, it's dealt with on Monday. If the worry is a symptom in your body, the step is a doctor's appointment. One will settle more than forty evenings of reading.
- If there's no step, give it an appointment. Choose a fixed fifteen to thirty minutes each day, not in bed or the hour before. A kitchen table at six is good. When a what-if turns up outside it, tell yourself "not now, at six", add it to the list and turn back to what's in front of you. Your mind lets go of something it knows it'll come back to.
- Keep the appointment. At six, go through the list with a pen. Half the items will have gone flat, so cross them off. For the rest, write the worst that could happen, what's most likely, and what you'd do the next morning if the worst came. When time's up, stop, even mid-thought.
- Check the log weekly. After a month you'll have your own percentage.
Here's Thursday's chat again. On Friday afternoon the first what-if fires, and you write, "She'll criticise my work on Thursday." Is there a step? Yes. "Happy to. Is there anything I should bring or think about beforehand?" Fifteen seconds. Either she says it's about Leeds and the weekend is yours, or she says "no, nothing", and that's fine too. No further step, so the worry goes on the list. At the birthday party it comes back, and you tell it "six o'clock". At six you write that the worst is a formal warning, the most likely is a routine request, and if it's a warning you'll ask for the specifics in writing and talk to a colleague you trust. Four minutes. On Thursday you mark the log with a cross.
Rounds start at predictable moments, and plans made in advance in a "when, then" form seem to help follow-through.
- When I notice a what-if in bed, I'll write one line on the pad beside me and leave it for the slot.
- When I want to check the phone or look up a symptom a second time, I'll write the worry down and won't check.
- When I catch myself halfway through a round, I'll ask whether the last ten minutes produced anything I can do, and get up and do one physical task.
Give your attention something with grip, like the washing-up or the conversation in front of you.
The first week feels artificial and some worries won't wait. Keep postponing them. The alarm won't change. What usually changes over a few weeks is how long each worry stays, though nobody has tested this as a package and I can't promise a figure. Your log will tell you.
Sooner or later one of the ticks will be a big one. The scan isn't clear, or the redundancy is real. About one worry in eleven came true in that study, and over a life that's a fair number of bad days. The habit will say, "See? I was right to worry."
The concern was valid. Was the worry useful? Ask what you used when the blow landed. The savings, the friend who knew an employment lawyer, the early appointment that caught it while it could be treated. Each was a step, taken in minutes. How many of the hundred rehearsed conversations did you use? Usually none, because the meeting was in a different room, with different words. Often the blow wasn't even on the list. You worried about your job for a year and it was your knee that went. Someone with some savings, a few good friends and the habit of dealing with things promptly is ready for a great many events they never imagined.
Once it's happened, it's a problem with particulars and plenty of steps, and many worriers are surprised to find they're good in a real crisis.
The long wait is harder. The biopsy result takes two weeks, or the names come out next month. Take whatever steps exist early, and keep the slot, because a long wait breeds more what-ifs than anything. Dread during a real wait for serious news is normal and doesn't mean the method has failed. Aim for some hours each day spent in your own life and not in the waiting room. Afterwards, "I should have worried more" is almost never true. "I should have gone to the doctor sooner" sometimes is, and that regret is about a step.
The worrying will come back. One week the slot gets skipped and you're on the fifteenth lap at two in the morning, usually after tiredness, illness, drink, a big change, or a friend's diagnosis. Write the current worries down, one line each, date the steps, and put the rest in tomorrow's slot. There's no streak to lose, so don't count worry-free days, because then one bad night feels like a collapse. And if you start worrying about the worrying, a round is unpleasant and costs time, and it ends. It isn't a sign you're losing your mind.
At night your judgment is at its worst and nothing can be done until morning anyway. Keep a pad by the bed. If you're still going round after a while, get up, sit somewhere else with a dull book, and go back when you're sleepy.
Self-help is a reasonable first step. See a GP, or refer yourself to a talking therapies service if you live in England, if any of these apply.
- You've worried most days for six months or more and can't control it.
- It's affecting your work, your sleep or your relationships.
- You have troubling physical symptoms, such as a racing heart, dizziness, stomach problems or constant tension, or you've had sudden attacks of intense fear.
- Your mood has been low for weeks.
- You've given this an honest month and nothing has moved.
If you've had thoughts of harming yourself, don't wait for a routine appointment. Get urgent help the same day. Cognitive behavioural therapy and applied relaxation are well established, and medication helps many people. If you already take it, keep taking it as prescribed and talk to your doctor before changing anything.
Now find the paper with your three predictions. Mark any that have come due with a tick or a cross. If one still has a step you haven't taken, take it today or write down the day you will. Whatever's left goes to six o'clock.