The 20-minute version
It's Sunday, late afternoon, and you're hanging out washing.
Your hands know the job, so your mind is free, and into the free space comes the photocopier. It was eleven years ago. A colleague's father had died, and on her first morning back you met her at the photocopier. You wanted to say something kind. What came out was, "Well, at least it was quick."
Her face didn't crumple or harden. It went blank, in the way of someone deciding to be polite. She said, "Yes," picked up her copies and went.
At the washing line you go through it from the start. The corridor, her coming towards you, the half-second in which you chose the words. You try out what you might have said. "I'm so sorry about your dad." It was there to be said. You get to her face again, and to "Yes", and you make a small noise out loud, something between a groan and a word, and peg a towel harder than it needs. Then the washing's done, you go inside, and it fades. She left the firm nine years ago. You've no idea where she is. If you had to put a number on it, you've been through that scene about four hundred times.
Yours might be a wedding speech, an email sent to the wrong person, a thing you shouted at your mother. It might be much larger, like the flat you sold two years before prices doubled, the relationship you let go, or something you did to another person that was plainly wrong. The large ones get their turn. For now the small one will do, because it shows the habit most clearly. Nobody could say a clumsy sentence from eleven years ago needs four hundred hearings. It gets them anyway.
Replays arrive uninvited, mostly when your mind is idle, and the shame is fresh each time. And they never finish. A replay doesn't end with "right, that's settled". It ends because the phone rings or the washing's done, and an interruption leaves the thing open for next time.
Here's my case. The replays feel useful, as if they're how you learn from the mistake, pay for it and guard against doing it again. They do none of those jobs. Whatever the mistake had to teach, you got early, and what prevents a repeat is a lesson you can state and a plan you can follow. Each old mistake can be gone through once, properly, on paper, and after that it's owed no more of your evenings. This is no case for shrugging off what you've done. Some mistakes still have something in them to mend.
Some cautions first. If you've been low for weeks, with little interest in things, poor sleep and a sense of hopelessness, the replaying may be part of depression, so please see a GP. In England you can also refer yourself to NHS talking therapies. If what comes back is a frightening or violent event such as an accident, an assault or a death, and it comes as flashbacks, nightmares or vivid images, that's a different thing. The NHS lists those as the main symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder, which has treatments of its own, and a GP is the place to start. If the thoughts are about harm you fear you've done or might do, and you find yourself checking, confessing or repeating things in your head to cancel them out, that may be obsessive compulsive disorder, which is treatable. And if any of this comes with thoughts of ending your life or harming yourself, get help today, through NHS 111, an urgent GP appointment, or 999 if you're in immediate danger.
Before you go on, make a short list. Write the three or four events that come back most often, roughly how long ago each happened, and a guess at how many times you've been through it. Then beside each, write anything the most recent replay told you that you didn't already know.
I expect that last column to be empty.
The lesson took a day
If replays were plainly useless you'd have stopped long ago, so take their side for a moment. They seem to be how you learn. They seem to be how you pay, a small instalment at the washing line. They seem to keep you careful, a warning sign you keep freshly painted. And they seem to prove you aren't callous. Every one of those is a real need. If the replays met them, I'd tell you to carry on.
The feeling of usefulness has been studied. Sonja Lyubomirsky and Susan Nolen-Hoeksema found that people in a low mood who spent a while dwelling on themselves, which psychologists call rumination, reported gaining insight into their problems, and became less willing to do something pleasant. The sense of insight comes with the dwelling whether or not any insight has arrived. You'll know it. Partway through a replay there's a feeling of getting close, as if this time you'll see why you did it. Then you reach her face and "Yes", and you're where you were.
Start with learning, the most respectable reason. Thinking about how things might have gone differently is one of the useful things a mind does. Kai Epstude and Neal Roese, reviewing a large body of experiments on these "if only" thoughts, concluded that they exist to improve future behaviour. "If only I'd left ten minutes earlier" turns into "next time I'll leave ten minutes earlier". The thought does its work by handing you something specific to do.
So what does the photocopier teach? When someone has been bereaved, say you're sorry and then stop talking. Don't reach for a silver lining.
That's one sentence. You had it within a day, and you've probably followed it ever since. Replays four to four hundred can't have been for learning it, since you already had it.
They yield nothing because of the kind of thinking they are. Edward Watkins and Michelle Moulds found that in depressed patients, dwelling concretely on how things happened, step by step, improved problem solving compared with dwelling abstractly on why things are as they are and what it all means. Now listen to a replay once it's past the opening scene. Why did I say that? What is wrong with me? Why do I always do this? None of those has an answer you can act on. What happened, in order, and what would I do in the same spot now, do have answers, which is why that version is over quickly.
Understanding that arrives years later usually comes from something new, a conversation, a second relationship, being older. A replay has no new information in it. So when one starts, ask what it's told you that the last one didn't. If nothing, it isn't study, whatever it feels like.
Some replays are about decisions. You sold the flat in 2016 and watched the street double in price. You turned down the job at the small company everyone's now heard of. You didn't push your father to see a doctor in March. These come with their own refrain. I should have known. The signs were there.
You're looking back from a place where the ending is known, and that changes what the past looks like. Neal Roese and Kathleen Vohs, reviewing fifty years of research on hindsight bias, describe the belief, once you know an outcome, that it was more predictable than it really was. Once you know the ending you recall the facts that fit it and lose the ones that didn't, and the story becomes easy to tell, and that ease gets mistaken for how likely it was beforehand.
In 2016 you had some facts. Prices had been flat for two years, you needed the money for a move, the agent called it a fair offer, and a newspaper you respected said the market had peaked. You also had a friend who said "I'd hold on if I were you", and she's the only one your replays ever visit. Marking that decision now is like failing a student for not knowing something discovered after the exam. Your friend being right shows the outcome was possible. It doesn't show it was knowable.
Sometimes you really did ignore a bad feeling. Then that's a lesson, and it fits in a sentence. "When I have a bad feeling early on, I'll slow down." Just remember the many bad feelings that came to nothing, which hindsight has quietly dropped.
The question that undoes most of this is what you knew then. Write it down as though you were making the case for your earlier self, including the facts that pointed the wrong way. Usually you find a reasonable decision that went badly. In a way that's sadder than "I was a fool", because the world is less controllable than you'd like. It's also true, and it doesn't need going over four hundred times.
Four hundred showings
Think back eleven years and list the clumsy or tactless things other people said to you, or in front of you, that year. Ordinary gaffes, of the kind you're replaying.
For most people the list is empty. Other people said foolish things most weeks, and you kept none of them, because other people's gaffes aren't interesting enough to store. Your colleague's memory works the same way.
I can't tell you she's forgotten. Bereaved people often do remember who said what. But in those weeks she'll have heard a dozen clumsy things from people who meant well, and if yours stayed with her at all, I'd guess it's filed with the others under "people were awkward, bless them". The blank face you've replayed was probably a tired woman on her first day back who'd already heard three of these and had copying to do. And the version in your head isn't a neutral recording. Research on social anxiety ties going over a conversation afterwards to negative biases in memory. Applying that to an eleven-year-old scene is my step, but her expression has had years of touching up.
If people really do remember, the replays don't change what they remember. An apology might.
You're the only one who was at all four hundred showings.
Then there's the sense that you deserve it. You hurt someone, and it seems wrong that you should hang out washing on a sunny afternoon with a quiet mind. There's something right in this. Feeling bad after doing harm is how a conscience works, and research on guilt finds that it pushes people towards repair. The first "oh no, what did I say" was your conscience doing its job.
But guilt is a prompt, and it points at actions. Go after her and say you're sorry. Or, if that moment has gone, do better next time. Once those are done, it has nothing more to get you to do. The replays are the prompt going off long after every action has been taken or has expired. And who receives the payment? Your colleague gets nothing from your bad quarter of an hour. She doesn't know about it. Her father is no less dead.
Suffering doesn't seem to make you better, either. Juliana Breines and Serena Chen asked some people to take a kind, understanding attitude towards a weakness or a recent wrong. You'd expect complacency. Those people were more motivated to make amends and to avoid repeating the wrong, and after failing a test they studied longer for the next one.
"That's convenient," you might say. "I do something bad, and I'm told to be kind to myself." Being held to account means facing what you did, putting right what can be put right, and changing. The replays do none of it. Someone who stops replaying and writes the apology has gone further than someone who replays for another eleven years.
The quietest belief has the firmest grip. As long as it stings, you'll never do it again.
You haven't done it again. You've spoken to bereaved people since, and been gentle and brief, and no replay was running while you did. Replays happen at washing lines, when nobody bereaved is anywhere near. And think of the mistakes you made once and never replay. You backed into a gatepost and now you check the mirror. You sent an angry email and now you wait till morning. Those lessons hold with no pain keeping them fresh.
There's a reason the replays keep coming that has nothing to do with guarding. E. J. Masicampo and Roy Baumeister gave people goals and left them unfulfilled, and those people had intrusive thoughts about them during unrelated work. When they were allowed to make a specific plan, saying when, where and how, the intrusions stopped. Their studies were about tasks, so applying them to old mistakes is my interpretation, but it fits. The photocopier behaves like an open item. Some part of your mind brings it up whenever there's spare attention, hoping this time it'll be settled, and a replay can't settle it, because it contains no verdict and no plan.
Meanwhile the costs pile up. A review by Nolen-Hoeksema and colleagues found that rumination makes low mood worse, impairs problem solving and predicts the onset of depression. That work is about dwelling in general, and I'm not suggesting the photocopier will make you ill. In my own reckoning, the ordinary replayer pays like this.
- Hours a month, taken from the shower and the walk and the washing line, the times your mind was free to rest.
- A greyer background mood, from coming in a little lower than you went out.
- A picture of yourself built from your worst moments, when you've had thousands of conversations that went fine and replayed none of them.
- Avoidance. After the photocopier you may have started sending cards in place of speaking, and dodging the colleague with the sick wife. Other people pay that one.
- The present, half heard, while you stand in a corridor from eleven years ago.
Something left to do
Go back to your list. For each event, ask the question the replays never ask. Is there anything here that can still be done?
Often there isn't. The colleague left years ago, the moment was small, and tracking her down to apologise for one sentence would be more for you than for her.
Sometimes there is. You owe someone money, or an apology that would mean something. There's a rift with your sister that began with something you said. My impression is that replaying gets in the way of mending, because the replay produces a feeling of having dealt with it. In some inner ledger the debt is being serviced. Your sister can't see the ledger. She's had seven years of silence.
If something can be mended, mending it is the most effective thing you can do about the replays, and also the right thing. What follows on apologising is my own view.
- Keep it short. "I've thought for a long time about what I said at Dad's seventieth. It was unkind and it wasn't true, and I'm sorry." A long apology starts to be about you.
- One sentence of context at most. Reasons shade into excuses.
- Ask for nothing, including forgiveness or a reply. "You don't need to reply to this" is a generous line.
- Expect it to land smaller than it feels. "Oh, I'd forgotten all about that" is the best result there is.
Don't contact someone if it would disturb or frighten them, like an ex-partner who has asked for no contact, or if it would mainly unload your guilt onto someone better off not knowing. Your need to apologise doesn't outrank their peace. Then the mending goes elsewhere, to the next person who needs what you didn't give. And if the person has died, some people find it helps to write the letter anyway and keep it. I can't promise it will help you, but it gets done once and it has a last line.
If something on your list can be mended, put a date next to it now.
Some of what people replay is a real loss they had a hand in. You let a good relationship go out of pride. You spent your thirties in the wrong career. You were short-tempered with your mother in her last year because you were exhausted, and then she died.
Regret is the proper response to that, and I don't want to talk you out of it. What I'd like to do is pull apart two things that have got wound together. Regret is a feeling about a fact. "I wish I'd been kinder to her that year." It's quiet, it visits on anniversaries, and it leaves you a little more tender towards the people you still have. A replay is an activity, the going back in to search for a version that comes out differently. From what people describe, the replay can get in the way of the regret. While you're trying to edit that last year, you aren't grieving her. When the replays ease, what often comes in their place is plain sadness, and sadness moves over time in a way replays don't.
Hindsight applies with more force here. You didn't know she had a year left. You remember the three times you snapped and have lost the two hundred ordinary visits, the lifts to the hospital, the evening you sat with her till she slept. She had all of it. And there's still something to do, though it won't change the past. There are people alive now who'd benefit from the patience you wish you'd had.
One technique makes the rest possible. A written account could easily be a replay on paper, with you back in the corridor and your face burning. What separates them is where you stand. Ethan Kross, Özlem Ayduk and Walter Mischel had people recall a time they'd been furious, either through their own eyes or from a few steps back. The ones who went back in relived it, and the ones who stood back could think it through without the feelings flooding in. Later Kross and colleagues found that simply using your own name or "she" in place of "I" when thinking about a stressful situation left people less distressed, and they did less going over it afterwards.
Those studies were about anger and short-term stress, so carrying them to old mistakes is my application. It matches what everybody knows, though. You're far more sensible about a friend's mistakes than your own.
So here's the photocopier told the other way.
"She was twenty-nine and had been at the firm a year. A colleague she liked but didn't know well came back after her father's death. She met her by surprise at the photocopier and felt she had to say something. She hadn't prepared anything and had very little experience of bereavement. She said the first consoling thing that came into her head, which was a cliché and the wrong one. The colleague said 'Yes' and left. She knew straight away it had been clumsy, and she didn't follow it up because she was embarrassed. She has never done anything like it again."
The unflattering facts are all there. And the verdict comes easily. A clumsy moment from someone inexperienced who meant well, and long over.
Five headings and a date
Each event gets one write-up. Twenty minutes to an hour, on paper or in a document you keep, one event per sitting, the smallest first.
Joanne Frattaroli pooled 146 randomised studies of people writing about upsetting matters and found it helped overall, though the average effect was small. Its real advantage is that it gives you something a replay never does, which is a finished object.
- What happened. Third person, past tense, starting a little before the event. Who was there, what was said and done, in order, as a fair witness would give it. Include what you did wrong, plainly, without softening it or piling on.
- What they knew then. What the person in the story knew and didn't, and the state they were in, tired or young or frightened. Include the facts that pointed the wrong way. This is the case a fair-minded friend would make.
- What it cost, and to whom. Honest in both directions. For the photocopier, "she had an uncomfortable ten seconds on a hard day" is about right. For a large event this section is longer and sadder, and it's where the regret goes.
- The lesson. One or two sentences you could act on, with a plan in the form "when this, then that". If there isn't one, write "there's no lesson here beyond the fact that reasonable decisions sometimes go wrong".
- What's left to do. A specific act with a date, or "Nothing", with your reason.
Then a last line. "Written up on the 14th of June." Put it away somewhere you could find it.
Here's the end of the photocopier write-up.
"What it cost. She had an awkward moment on her first day back, one of several that week, I'd guess. I've had eleven years of wincing. I've also avoided a few bereaved people since, when I could have been kind, and I regret that more than the remark. The lesson. When someone's grieving, I say I'm sorry, ask how they're doing, and stop. And when someone at work has had bad news, I go and find them. What's left. Nothing, as far as she's concerned. But there's a man in accounts whose wife is ill, and I've been dodging him. I'll speak to him this week."
Four hundred replays missed that second lesson, because they were all spent staring at her face.
If the write-up overwhelms you and you can't keep the observer's distance, stop. The event may need more than you can do alone, and a therapist would be a sensible choice. Otherwise, don't polish it, don't do more than one a week, and reopen it only if new information arrives. Another replay isn't new information.
It will come back. Eleven years of groove doesn't go in a week, and that isn't failure. You also can't order it out. In Daniel Wegner's experiments, people told not to think of a white bear thought of it more, and "stop thinking about the photocopier" contains the photocopier. What you control is the small gap between the scene arriving and the replay proper beginning. That gap widens with practice, and in it you do three things, which take about ten seconds.
Name it, in the tone you'd use for a bus going past. "That's the photocopier."
Remind yourself of its status. "It's been written up. Say sorry and stop." It's like an email you've already answered turning up a second time. You recognise it and leave it.
Then put your attention on something specific and physical outside your head, like the wet cotton, the pegs, the blackbird on the fence, or how to fit two more shirts on the line. In Lyubomirsky and Nolen-Hoeksema's studies, a few minutes with attention turned outward restored low people's mood and problem solving, where dwelling made both worse. Since the work is done and in the folder, you aren't running from it.
If it comes back thirty seconds later, do it again, without irritation if you can. For a few weeks, give your idle moments something to hold, like the radio while you cook. In bed, after naming it, give your mind a dull concrete task, like walking through the rooms of a house you used to live in. Arguing with a replay is going in.
So here's the decision. Each old mistake gets one write-up, and after that you don't go back in.
Where the last heading names something to do, date it and do it, and expect to want to put off a seven-year-old apology for one more week. Send it anyway. For new mistakes, give them two days to do whatever needs doing, apologising or fixing or owning up, and if one is still coming round after that, write it up within the week, so nothing new joins the rotation. Plans in the form "when this happens, then I'll do that" have a good record in research. "When I notice I'm halfway through a replay, I'll finish the sentence I'm on, say 'written up', and look at what my hands are doing." Leaving halfway counts.
I can't promise an outcome. My expectation is that the scenes keep arriving about as often at first, and what changes is how long you stay, ten minutes, then two, then twenty seconds. Over a few months the arrivals themselves should thin out, faster where you've also mended something. Some large ones may visit for years. A brief visit is something you can live with. And some tired evening you'll spend forty minutes in the corridor as thoroughly as ever. Notice what set it off, since tiredness, drink and a bad day are the usual causes, and carry on. Nothing new happened, so there's nothing to write up again.
Please talk to a GP, or in England refer yourself to NHS talking therapies, if any of these applies.
- Weeks of low mood, loss of interest, poor sleep or hopelessness.
- The event was traumatic and returns as flashbacks, nightmares or vivid images.
- The thoughts are about harm you fear you've caused or might cause, and you're checking, confessing or mentally cancelling them out.
- The replaying takes up hours of most days despite your best efforts.
- Thoughts of harming yourself. Get help the same day, through NHS 111, an urgent GP appointment, or 999 in an emergency.
Therapists also work on this habit directly, with a form of cognitive behavioural therapy aimed at rumination.
Some months on, it's Sunday and the washing line, and into the free space comes the corridor.
"That's the photocopier. It's written up. Say sorry and stop, and don't dodge people."
The scene hangs there a moment. You look at your hands. A pillowcase, inside out. You turn it and peg it. There's a blackbird making a racket on the fence. There isn't enough line left for the sheets, so you fold one double, and by the time that's solved the corridor has gone. There was nothing left open for it to do.
You did speak to the man in accounts, the week you wrote it up. You said you were sorry about his wife and asked how he was managing. He talked for ten minutes, and at the end he said most people had been avoiding him.
Take the smallest event on your list and write it up this week, five headings, third person, a date at the bottom. Then go and hang out the washing.