The 20-minute version
Your partner is telling you about a meeting. It's a story with a build-up. Somebody said something, somebody else reacted, and the point is coming. Your phone is on the table beside your plate and it lights up, and your eyes go to it. The notification is nothing, a delivery update, and your eyes come back. Your partner has paused. You say "go on", and they go on, but shorter, and the point when it comes is delivered flat. You say "that's mad". They say "yeah". The story is over.
Or you're on a bench at the park and your daughter is on the climbing frame. "Watch this." You look up, and she does the thing. "Did you see?" You saw the end of it. "Watch this." This time you're mid-message, and you say "I'm watching" without looking, and she does the thing, and she doesn't ask if you saw.
Or a friend you haven't seen for months is across a cafe table, telling you their marriage is in trouble. Your phone buzzes on the wood. You turn it over without reading it. They saw you turn it over. "Anyway," they say, and change the subject.
You'd say you were listening, and in a sense you were, because you could repeat the last thing they said. And yet the person talking saw your face change, adjusted what they were saying, and the evening went slightly differently because of it.
Here's what I'm going to argue. The glance makes sense from the inside. It's quick, it might be important, you can hear perfectly well with your eyes down, and everyone at the table does it. But the glance is different from the outside, and there's research on why. People who use their phones while with friends, partners and children feel more distracted and get less from the time. People talked to by someone looking at a phone, even part of the time, rate the conversation and the relationship lower. Young children whose parent is on a phone try harder for attention, and then some stop trying. And the second you think you spent on the screen isn't the second the other person timed. The practical part is one rule. When someone is talking to you, the phone goes out of your hands and out of your sight, and if you really need it, you say so before you look.
I have nothing to say here about how much you use your phone in general. This is only about the moments when a person is talking to you.
Two cautions. If checking your phone feels like something you can't stop, if you feel anxious when it's out of reach or check it in a loop that doesn't end, the habit here is the smaller part of what's going on, and near the end I say where to go. And if the person who won't look up is your partner, most of this still applies, and there's a part written for you.
Before you go on, count for one evening. Every time someone talks to you and your eyes go to a screen, that's one. Separately, count every "sorry, what?" and every time someone has to say your name twice. Change nothing yet. Just notice which number surprises you most.
The person timed it too
Nobody looks at a phone while their child is talking because they've decided the child doesn't matter. The glance has reasons.
- It's quick. It feels like checking a clock.
- It might be the school, a parent, work.
- You can hear perfectly well with your eyes down.
- Everyone does it, including the person telling the story.
- The story is ordinary, or one you've heard.
- You've worked all day, and the phone is the one small thing that's yours.
Each of these is true in its way. Each one also misses something about what the glance is doing.
Take hearing first, because it holds up the others. You can repeat what was just said, so you were listening, so the glance cost nothing. But repeating the last sentence is a low bar. Words go in whether or not you're attending, the way you can name the song that was just on the radio. The person talking wants your attention on them, and that's exactly what goes to the screen.
The research doesn't measure listening directly. It measures what people get from time together with a phone in play, and it points one way. Ryan Dwyer, Kostadin Kushlev and Elizabeth Dunn had over three hundred people share a meal with friends or family, some with phones on the table and some with phones put away. The ones with phones out felt more distracted, and enjoyed the meal less because of it. Kushlev and Dunn then took parents to a science museum with their children and told some to use their phones a lot and some a little. The heavy users felt more distracted, and through that felt less connected to their children and got less meaning from the visit. Nobody told them to stop listening. The distraction came with the phone. And Adrian Ward and colleagues found, in two experiments, that just having your own phone nearby, unused, reduced the attention people had available for a task, most of all in people who relied on their phones heavily.
My reading is that you keep the words and lose the person. And the person can tell which half they got.
"It was only a second."
Possibly it was, by your clock. You're timing from the moment you decided to look to the moment you looked back. They're timing something longer. Faces change before eyes move. The pull arrives and something goes out of your expression, and the person watching sees it go. Then your eyes drop. Then they come back, and for a moment they're on the person while your mind is still finishing the thing on the screen. They see that too. As I see it, the glance is only the middle third of what they saw, which I'll call the drop.
Varoth Chotpitayasunondh and Karen Douglas had people watch a short animation and imagine themselves in a two-person conversation where the partner looked at a phone a lot, some of the time, or not at all. More phone use made the conversation feel worse and the relationship feel worse, and the effect ran through feeling less that they belonged, and through worse mood. It was an animation, and real dinners may differ. But it fits the restaurant and the museum, and adds that what counts is how much looking away the other person sees. They see all of it.
"They didn't notice."
They did. Talking to someone means watching their face, and every sentence is shaped by what that face is doing. Children make this visible because they haven't learned to hide it. Jenny Radesky and colleagues watched fifty-five caregivers eating with young children in fast food restaurants. Forty used a phone during the meal. The observers saw how absorbed the adults were, and the children responded along a range. Some entertained themselves. Others escalated, louder, more insistent, climbing, until they got a look. The most absorbed adults, when the child finally got through, often responded harshly.
That's noticing at four. At fourteen it's one-word answers. At forty it's "anyway". Nobody says "you're on your phone", because it feels petty, and feeling petty is worse than feeling ignored. They just tell you a little less next time.
"It might be important." It might. But think about what actually arrives in a day. A delivery, a group chat, a headline, three emails you didn't want, a like, and once in a long while something that can't wait. The glance during a story checks all of it in case one is interesting. The things that can't wait ten minutes tend to ring, and keep ringing.
One interruption can matter more than it looks. Jessa Reed, Kathy Hirsh-Pasek and Roberta Michnick Golinkoff had thirty-eight mothers each teach their two-year-old two new words. During one of the two teaching periods the mother's phone rang and she took the call. The children learned the word from the uninterrupted teaching and didn't learn the one from the interrupted teaching, though the mothers said each word just as often. It's a small study of one narrow thing. What changed was the thread.
"They're only telling me about their day." Andrew Przybylski and Netta Weinstein ran two experiments in which a phone simply in view hurt closeness and conversation quality, most clearly when the topic was personally meaningful. Shalini Misra and colleagues had a hundred pairs talk for ten minutes, and conversations with no phone on the table or in a hand were rated better. I should be plain that the mere-presence part is disputed. John Crowley and colleagues tried to repeat Przybylski and Weinstein's study and found no effect, and thought changing norms might be why. I mention it for the meaningful-topic result. The ordinary story is how people stay known to each other. Nobody opens with the thing that matters. They open with the queue and watch your face, and decide from that whether to go on. The ordinary story is the audition for the meaningful one. Glance during it, and the meaningful one doesn't get told.
A face that should answer
There's a well-known experiment with babies. A parent plays with their baby, then on a signal keeps looking at the baby but goes still and unresponsive for a couple of minutes, then resumes. The parent never leaves the room, and the babies hate it. They protest, look away, try to get the parent back, and take a while to recover.
Sarah Myruski and colleagues ran a version with fifty infants aged seven months to two years, and made one change. During the still phase, the mother used her phone. The infants showed more negative feeling and less positive feeling then than during play, and made the most attempts to get her back. Infants whose mothers said they used their phones more often were less exploratory and less positive in that phase, and recovered less when their mothers came back.
A baby isn't your partner, and this is one study. But the shape seems to hold at every age. Presence is responsiveness. A face that's right there and doesn't answer is a particular thing, and the other person feels it as being with someone who isn't there. Nobody feels ignored by a person in another city.
"Kids need to learn I'm not always available." True, and worth keeping apart from the glance. "Not now, I'm on a work call, I'll come in ten minutes" is a clear boundary with an end, and a child who hears it learns that people have limits. The glance says "yes, go on" with a face that says "not really". That's harder to make sense of than a closed door, and it's what produced the climbing in Radesky's restaurants.
Brandon McDaniel and Jenny Radesky followed a hundred and eighty-three couples with a young child over six months. A child's difficult behaviour predicted more parenting stress, the stress predicted more turning to the phone during time with the child, and that predicted more difficult behaviour later. They're careful to say the direction isn't settled, and so am I. From the inside, though, it feels like this. The child is hard, so you take a moment's relief in the phone. The child gets harder. You retreat further. Each step makes sense. If they need to learn you're not always available, tell them in words, with a time.
"They do it too." They probably do, and part of the reason is that you did it while they were talking last week. Norms like this are never agreed. They pile up, one glance making the next easier, and one person can start unpiling them. You also know exactly what it's like to talk to a lit face, which is the best argument here, and you already own it. So do your half without announcing it. Either they notice in a week or a month, because people who are fully listened to tend to look up more, or they don't, and you've still had the better evening. If after a few weeks you want them to look up too, ask once and plainly. "When I'm telling you something, could you put the phone down? I've started doing it and it's made a difference to me."
"It's how I switch off after work." The need is real. The trouble is timing. Your slack twenty minutes with the feed has landed on the twenty minutes when your partner has things to say and your children haven't seen you all day. So neither happens. You don't rest, because you're half answering, and they don't get you. Give the phone its twenty minutes on its own, in the car, at the end of the platform, on the bench outside. Then go in. Or have it once the children are down, with the sofa and your partner both agreed on what's happening. What doesn't work is having both at once and calling the result listening.
"I need it for what we're talking about." Then it isn't a glance. Looking up the train time together, showing the photo, the other person can see the screen and knows why you're on it. It goes wrong at the edges. You check the train time, a notification is there, you read it, and the train time was found twenty seconds ago. They saw the moment the errand ended and the drift began. So say it out loud first, "hang on, let me find it", and put the phone away when it's found.
Now the cost, starting with the message. You don't mean anything by the glance, but it's received as one. When someone is talking and your eyes go to the screen, your face says that whatever is on the screen outranks what's being said. For a second. But rank is measured in who gets looked at when there's a choice, and every glance is a choice made in front of the person who lost it. Remember that the effect in Chotpitayasunondh and Douglas's study ran through belonging. "I was listening, honestly" arrives after the face has already spoken.
Then people adjust. When your face drops halfway through, they learn that this kind of story loses you. The next telling is shorter. The build-up gets cut and the point comes early and flat, to get it out before the drop. Then the tellings get rarer. A child's "watch this" turns into doing the thing without asking, and the quiet child at the table isn't always a content one. A partner's meeting story becomes "work was fine". The thing that happened on the bus doesn't get mentioned, and the meaningful story that would have followed gets told to a sibling, or nobody.
You won't see it happen, because what's missing is a story that never started. One year you just notice you're not sure what your partner's week was like.
It costs you too. In the restaurant and the museum, it was the phone users who enjoyed the time less and felt less connected. McDaniel and colleagues measured phone use through the phones of two hundred and sixty-four parents of infants over eight days. On days when parents used their phones more around their baby, their mood was lower, except on days when they felt they'd been responsive anyway. One study, and careful authors. But you may know the feeling, the small flatness at the end of an evening spent half in the feed. You spent the evening with people and didn't get them.
And think about what you missed. The thing the teacher said was funny. The meeting story was your partner trusting you with a bad day. The friend's marriage was the friend needing you. Each glance traded one of those for a delivery update.
Out of reach
Before the method, meet the thing you're up against. I'll call it the tug.
It's the pull towards the phone that arrives while someone's talking, and it rarely comes at the interesting part. It comes in a pause, a lull, when the build-up runs long, when you think you know where this is going, when the phone lights, or when it doesn't and you wonder. It's a small restlessness in the hand and the eyes, and it presents itself as a good idea. I'll just check.
It isn't news from the world. It turns up whether there's a message or not, because it's a habit's cue. And it has nothing to do with the person talking. It comes with your partner, your child and your closest friend alike. Treat it as a sensation. It shows up, lasts a minute or less, and if you don't act on it, it goes, usually before the story does.
That's much easier when the phone is somewhere else. A phone in your pocket gives you a tug you can ignore. A phone on the table gives you a tug with a screen attached. So here's the first part of the method.
When someone is talking to you, the phone is away. Out of your hands and out of your sight. Face down on the table doesn't count. The restaurant study's phones were on the table, and that's where the distraction came from. Face down still buzzes against the wood and lights at the edge. Away means a pocket, a bag, a drawer, the hall, the kitchen counter when you're in the living room. Somewhere your hand can't reach without your legs.
- At meals, it goes in the bag or the hall before the food is down. Meals have a start, which makes this the easiest fixed rule, and it's the one children see most.
- In the evening, it lives somewhere that isn't the arm of the sofa.
- At a child's bedtime, it doesn't come into the room.
- In the car with a child, it's in the glove box.
- With a friend in a cafe, it stays in the pocket or the bag.
In the first days you'll notice the tug more, because the phone used to answer it before you'd felt it. That's the habit becoming visible, and a visible habit is one you can decline. Within a week you'll probably notice something else. Conversations get longer. Nobody decided to talk more. The drop stopped happening, and stories that were being cut short started reaching their ends.
The second part is for when the phone is already in your hand as someone starts talking, or when you catch yourself mid-glance. Phone down, eyes to their face. Don't finish the sentence you were reading. It'll be there in ten minutes. If you were caught, say so once. "Sorry, go on." Skip "I was listening", which turns a small drop into an argument about whether it happened, and skip explaining what was on the screen. Admit it, hand the turn back, stop.
Then the real exception. You're waiting for the hospital, or the builder, or a child's lift home. Say so first. "I'm expecting a call from the builder, so if the phone goes I'll take it." Or in the moment, "I need to check this, it's the hospital, give me a minute." Said first, the other person can hold the story across the pause, because they know what it is and when it ends. Having to say it out loud also keeps the exception rare. You'll find you can't bring yourself to say it for a delivery update. My guess is the real rate is once or twice a week, against fifty glances a day.
Once the phone is gone, your eyes need a job, or the tug will offer one. Look at the person, mostly at their face, with the ordinary drifting away and back, and let your face answer. A face that's spent years half in a screen can forget it's the other half of the conversation. Have something ready for the end of a stretch of their talking. A question about the last thing they said, or "so he just didn't turn up", or just a nod if they're still going. For most people the listening comes back on its own. The attention that was going to the screen has nowhere else to go.
The first week can feel intense, for you and for them. A partner used to talking to a lit face may be briefly thrown by being looked at. Let it be odd for a day or two.
So, the rule in one sentence. When someone is talking to me, the phone is out of my hands and out of my sight, and if I really need it, I say so before I look.
There's some evidence that plans in the form "when this happens, I'll do that" get followed through more often than plain intentions. So here are three for the moments the rule is likeliest to break.
- When we sit down to eat, my phone goes in the bag or the hall before the food is on the table.
- When I'm on my phone and someone starts talking to me, it goes down and my eyes come up before I've decided whether to.
- When the tug comes mid-story, I notice it and let it pass, and if the phone lights, I let it light.
My expectation, from habits in general and from no study of this one, is that the tug stays loud for about a fortnight and then thins. A child who'd been escalating escalates less. A child who'd gone quiet may take longer to start again, because trust comes back more slowly than it goes. A partner will notice inside a month, or won't say, and either is fine. And one evening you'll look up from a story you've heard all of and realise the phone has been in the hall for two hours and you never once thought about it.
Lit by nothing
Some situations need their own word.
Feeding a baby is long and repetitive, and the phone is a natural companion to it. But the still-face research is about exactly this age, and the baby is reading your face during the feed. I won't say never. Feeds are long. I'd keep the first minutes and the last, when the baby is looking at you, for the two of you, and let the middle have the phone if it needs it.
Teenagers are on their phones more than you are, and you'll want the rule to apply to them. It should. Keep it yourself for a month first, without mentioning it, because a teenager can spot a rule that isn't kept by the person aiming it from across the house. Then raise it as a house rule for meals, with you included.
If you're on call for work, that's a real exception and the method covers it. Say so at the start of the evening and take the calls. On call means calls. It doesn't cover the email and the chat and the "just checking" that fill the evening in its name.
If it's your partner with the lit face, do your own half without announcing it, then after some weeks ask plainly and once. If that doesn't land and the glance is part of a wider sense of not being listened to, that's bigger than the phone, and the conversation it needs is about the relationship.
And sometimes it's more than a habit. If you feel anxious when the phone is out of reach, if you check it in a loop that doesn't end, if you've tried to cut down and couldn't, or if the checking is tied to a worry that something has gone wrong, this rule will feel like being asked to hold your breath. If the phone use sits inside a low mood that's been there most days for a fortnight or more, or an anxiety that's affecting your daily life, the NHS advice is to see a GP. I'd put that before any rule about the dinner table.
You'll glance again. A fortnight in, or a year. The phone lights and your eyes go, and you catch yourself, or they catch you.
One glance you noticed is the opposite of the old habit, which was fifty a day you never saw. Look up and say "sorry, go on". That's the whole repair. If you've had a full evening of the old pattern, phone on the sofa arm, the "mm", something put it back within reach, usually tiredness, or a day that needed its twenty minutes and didn't get them. Give the phone its twenty minutes tomorrow before you walk in, then put it in the hall. Find which reason got through. "It might be important" is the commonest, and the answer is that it'll ring. Don't keep a streak, because one glance would spoil it and a spoiled record makes the next glance easier. And don't apologise more than once. They need your face back so they can finish the story.
Your partner's telling you about a meeting. The phone's in the hall, where it went before you sat down, and for all you know it's lit up out there. Somebody said something, somebody else reacted, and you can see the point coming on their face, and they can see you seeing it. The point lands. It's a better story than you expected, because you got all of it.
At the park, your daughter says "watch this", and you're watching. She doesn't ask if you saw. She saw you seeing. Across the cafe table your friend says the thing about their marriage, and nothing buzzes on the wood, because the phone is in your bag on the floor, and they don't say "anyway".
The effort was in putting the phone down. Everything after was just a conversation.
Before the next meal, put the phone where you'd have to stand up to reach it. Then sit down and look up.