The 20-minute version
It's a Sunday evening in late February. The laptop is open on the kitchen table, and on it is a spreadsheet called Options. You made it fourteen months ago.
It has three tabs. Course is a part-time diploma in garden design at the college across town, two evenings a week for two years, three thousand two hundred pounds a year. Move is a firm like yours, twenty minutes further away, that advertises every few months for the job you already do at about three thousand a year more. Stay is the accounts team at the builders' merchant. It's fine, which is the word you always use for it.
Each tab has the same rows, money, evenings, security, interest, where it leads, each scored out of ten and weighted. Tonight the totals are 7.4, 7.1 and 7.2. Last month you gave security more weight and Stay came out on top. In November you read an article about people retraining in their forties and Course led by a full point for a fortnight.
Applications for September close on the thirtieth of June. You know the date well. You've missed it twice.
On the windowsill behind you are six squares of sofa fabric that came in January. The old sofa has a broken spring on the left, and everyone sits on the right. You've had it narrowed down to two since the week the samples came.
The going round is what this is about. I'll call it the loop, and one trip round it a lap. You sit down, concentrate, and finish tired. The facts are the same as they were in November, and only your mood about them has changed. You're nearly settled, often, usually late in the evening, and by morning a doubt has arrived. And it isn't only large decisions. The person with the spreadsheet is often the person reading the whole menu twice while the table waits.
My argument runs like this. The loop makes sense from the inside, because you're trying to avoid a mistake and waiting feels careful. But waiting is a choice too, with results of its own, and most of the going round produces nothing new. The practical part is short. You write down what the choice has to do, set a date, pick the first option that does it, and stop looking.
I won't tell you which option to pick. I don't know your situation, and the going round is much the same whatever the decision is.
Three cautions.
- Finding it hard to make decisions can be a symptom of something else. The NHS lists "finding it difficult to make decisions" among the psychological symptoms of depression, next to continuous low mood, no motivation and not getting any enjoyment out of life. If that sounds like your last few weeks, the decision isn't your main problem, and a GP is the place to start. If you have thoughts of harming yourself, ask for an urgent GP appointment or call 111 today.
- Some decisions need an expert, and the expert's view counts as real information. If the choice is medical, legal or financial, take advice from someone qualified. What follows is for after you have that advice and still can't choose.
- If the decision you're circling is whether to leave someone who frightens or controls you, this is the wrong tool. The freephone National Domestic Abuse Helpline is open day and night on 0808 2000 247, and the people there can talk through your options and your safety with you.
Before reading on, write down every decision you have open, large and small. Next to each, write roughly when you started deciding it, and the date you last learned a fact about it that you didn't know before. If the last new fact is months old, keep reading.
The tab called Stay
The loop isn't foolish, and most of the instincts behind it are sound.
Some decisions do get better with a week's wait. The survey on the house arrives, a friend who did the course calls back. Some questions answer themselves when an option disappears. Mistakes are expensive, and the people who decide everything in ten minutes aren't obviously doing better. And a wrong move does sting more than a missed one, at first. Thomas Gilovich and Victoria Husted Medvec, reviewing the research on regret, found that in the short term people regret their actions more than the things they didn't do.
The psychologist Christopher Anderson gathered the research on this whole family of behaviour in a review called "The psychology of doing nothing". People defer choices, stick with what they have, prefer a harm from not acting to the same harm from acting, and once they've passed up one good chance, tend to pass up the next. Two things drive it, in his account. One is anticipated regret. The other is the plain difficulty of telling which option is better.
Underneath, I think you want four things. You want to avoid a mistake, to feel sure before you move, to not be the one to blame, and to stay free while every option is still yours. All reasonable. The loop delivers none of them.
Start with the spreadsheet. It has three tabs, and you've been living in one of them the whole time. You've gone to the builders' merchant every weekday. A September intake started without you, and it wasn't the first. Stay has won every day for fourteen months and never once held the highest score for longer than a month.
Waiting is one of the options, and it's the one you've been picking. It just never needed picking on purpose.
William Samuelson and Richard Zeckhauser called the pull of it status quo bias. Whatever you have gets an advantage in your mind simply because you have it. Anderson sets a second habit beside it. People judge a bad result from doing nothing more kindly than the same result from doing something. Take the course and hate it, and you made a mistake. Never take it and spend ten years wondering, and nobody seems to be at fault, though the cost is as big or bigger.
So Course and Move justify themselves row by row, and Stay never has to. It might still be the best of the three. Plenty of people look hard at a fine job and decide fine is worth a great deal. Then it should win a fair contest, once, and the spreadsheet can be deleted. For each decision on your list, write the default in plain words and what another year of it will cost. For the sofa, another year on the right. For the course, a third missed September, and being a year older when you qualify, if you ever do.
"I just need a bit more information." Sometimes true, which is what makes it the most respectable reason for another lap.
Anthony Bastardi and Eldar Shafir gave people decisions with a piece of information missing. It looked relevant. But people given the same decision with that information already supplied chose the same way whatever it said. The people who lacked it still often waited for it. Then, having waited, they used it, and made choices they wouldn't otherwise have made on the strength of a fact that wouldn't have mattered at the start. In October you spent two evenings finding out what garden designers earn in their fifth year. The figures ranged so widely they told you nothing, and Course dropped half a point anyway.
The test is simple. Before you look something up, ask what you'd do if the answer came back one way, and what you'd do if it came back the other. Same thing either way, and you don't need it. Different things, and you should go and get it, usually with a phone call and an answer within the week. You'd ring the college and ask how many of last year's students are working in the field. Some of what you want to know can't be found at all, because it doesn't exist yet. How you'll feel on a wet Tuesday in the second year, whether you'll be any good. The search for that never comes up empty, and that's the trouble with it.
So write the question first, as one sentence with a question mark, and under it who could answer and by when. If you can't, the evening ahead is another lap.
Then there's the extra option. A colleague mentioned a shop and for a week there were four sofas. The college led you to a distance course, then to a one-year certificate. Each felt thorough and left you further from choosing.
Amos Tversky and Shafir found that when options conflict, adding a good one makes people more likely to put the decision off or fall back on the default. It happens to experts too. Donald Redelmeier and Shafir sent a scenario about a patient with osteoarthritis to family doctors in Ontario, and 287 replied. With one medication available, 72 per cent prescribed it. With two to choose between, only 53 per cent prescribed either.
You may have heard that shoppers offered six jams bought more often than those offered twenty-four. When Benjamin Scheibehenne and colleagues pooled fifty experiments like it, the average effect was almost exactly zero. A later analysis by Alexander Chernev and colleagues found more choice does harm when the decision is difficult, the options are hard to compare, and people aren't sure what they want. That last condition is why you're in the loop.
So cap it at three. A new option can come in only if one goes out. If you can't bring yourself to delete a tab, the new one wasn't better. It was somewhere to go instead of choosing.
Waiting to feel sure
Here is the eleven o'clock feeling.
Several times in the last fourteen months you've nearly been there. Late in the evening the course has seemed obviously right, and you've gone to bed settled and relieved. By breakfast it's gone. You take that as a sign you weren't really sure yet, that when the decision is ripe the feeling will hold. So you wait for it to be ripe, and go round again, and the scores move by a tenth of a point.
I think this belief keeps the loop going more than any other.
It rests on an assumption you may never have said aloud, that one of these options is correct, the rest are mistakes, and enough analysis will show which. It's mostly false. A decision is hard because the options are close, and 7.4, 7.1 and 7.2 are close. When options are that close, picking the second-best costs you very little. The decisions you find hardest are often the ones where the choice matters least.
Barry Schwartz and colleagues drew a line between people who look for something good enough and people who feel they must find the best, whom they called maximizers. Across seven groups, the maximizers were less happy and less satisfied with life, and reported more regret. That's a correlation and could run the other way. In a second study, Sheena Iyengar, Rachael Wells and Schwartz followed students through a year of job hunting. The maximizers' starting salaries were 20 per cent higher. They were also less satisfied with the jobs they got, and felt worse the whole way through. Searching hard can pay. Past a point, it stops improving the choice and starts spoiling your enjoyment of it, and fourteen months is well past that point.
How a choice turns out also depends on what you do once it's made. A course you commit to and work at isn't the course you sit through wondering about the other firm. No spreadsheet can score that.
Then there's the scene the loop runs every Sunday. Second year of the course, tired, fees gone up, and you've just understood you don't much like designing other people's gardens. It's sharp, it seems as if it would last, and it's your fault.
Daniel Gilbert, Timothy Wilson and colleagues studied predictions about bad events like a break-up or a rejected job application. People expected to feel bad for much longer than they did. We're good at coming to terms with things once they've happened. We just don't expect to be. And Gilovich and Medvec found the pattern in regret turns round over a lifetime. Asked about their biggest regrets, people mostly name things they didn't do. A recent attempt to repeat this found the same pattern in most tests, more weakly, and not in one. So it has some support and isn't settled.
Put together, and this is my reading, the loop protects you from a sharp regret that would last months, and builds the slow kind people carry for decades. The slow kind never gets pictured, because there's no single scene for it. It's made of all the Septembers that went by.
And a wrong choice would give you something the loop can't, which is an answer. A year of the course and you'd know.
Keeping your options open has its own trap. Daniel Gilbert and Jane Ebert ran a photography course where each student chose one of their prints to keep. Some were told the choice was final. Others could swap later. Beforehand, students said the chance to swap wouldn't change how much they liked their print. It did. Those who could change their minds liked their prints less. Once a choice is closed, your mind gets on with finding what's good about it. Leave it open and you go on comparing, and notice every flaw.
That explains the eleven o'clock feeling. For an hour you'd chosen, in your head, and felt the relief of it. By morning you hadn't filled in a form or told anyone, so the question was open and the comparing started again. The feeling wasn't wrong. You'd done nothing to fix it in place.
So the sureness you're waiting for mostly comes after the choice. The students with a final choice liked their print more once it was closed. Your doubts aren't a sign of an unripe decision either. The future is unknown and will stay unknown however many laps you do, and anyone with good judgement in your position would have doubts.
A bad feeling can still carry information. If your stomach drops every time you picture moving firms, over weeks, that's worth attention. Yours moves around. When Course leads you worry about money, and when Stay leads you worry about wasting your life. A doubt that follows whichever option is ahead is about choosing. It tells you nothing about the options.
So stop asking whether you feel sure. Ask whether the option does what you need, and whether you can live with its known drawbacks. You can answer that on an ordinary Sunday with the doubt still there.
Other people's flats
You've talked the course over with your partner, your sister, two friends, a colleague and a man at a wedding who turned out to be a landscape gardener. Each conversation felt like progress. None of them changed anything.
One conversation with someone who's done the course is worth a month of laps, if you've got a question for them. "What do you wish you'd known before you started?" is a good one. "What do you think I should do?" usually isn't, because they can't weigh your life, and what you're collecting then is votes or reassurance. Votes split. Your sister says go for it, your colleague says the job market is terrible. Reassurance lasts as long as the conversation. And the people who love you, by the fifth time round, have noticed nothing they say makes a difference. When the decision is shared with a partner whose life it changes, their view isn't a vote. Part of the decision is theirs.
Now the evidence against "I'm just an indecisive person".
At work you decide things all day, which invoices to query, which supplier to chase. When your friend couldn't choose between two flats, you listened for ten minutes and said, "The second one. You keep coming back to the light in the kitchen." You were right, and it cost you nothing. Your judgement is fine. It goes cloudy when the result will land on you and the blame will be yours.
Laura Kray and Richard Gonzalez gave people a choice between two jobs. Some chose for themselves and some advised another person facing the same choice. The advisers tended to recommend the job that was better on the thing that mattered most. People choosing for themselves spread their attention more evenly, giving weight to minor features. The spreadsheet has twelve rows and the minor ones all get a say, so of course the totals come out level. If a friend showed it to you, you wouldn't look at the rows. You'd ask what they really wanted from the change and whether they could afford it.
So write it out as if a friend had sent it to you, in the third person, five or six lines. "She's been in the same job eight years and calls it fine. She's wanted to do this course for three years. They can cover the fees if they skip a holiday. She's worried she'll be no good." Then write your reply. It usually comes quickly, and it goes to one or two things and ignores the rest.
Think about the big decisions you have made. The landlord wanted an answer by Friday. The offer was good for a week. You knew no more and felt no surer than you do about the course, and you chose, and mostly it was fine. What the course lacks is a Friday. Nobody will ever require an answer on whether to retrain, or move nearer your family, or see someone about your knee.
People in the loop often hope events will supply one. Redundancies, a collapsing sofa, a partner who loses patience and books the holiday. There's relief in that, because a choice made by events isn't your fault. But events decide late, after the best version of the option has gone, and usually hand you the default. The redundancy comes at forty-nine, and the course you could have finished is still two years away.
Meanwhile the loop is costing you.
- The default's results. Another fourteen months at the builders' merchant and a winter on a broken spring.
- Options that expire. Anderson's review describes inaction inertia. Once people have passed up a good chance, they become less likely to take a similar one, because taking it means admitting what they missed. After two Septembers, the third gets harder.
- The evenings. At a lap a fortnight for fourteen months, that's about eighty hours, roughly a term of the course you're deciding about.
- Other people. Your partner has spent fourteen months unable to plan around you, and has probably said less about it than they feel.
- Your trust in yourself. Each near-decision that doesn't stick teaches you that your decisions don't stick, and you start the next one expecting to go round. That's how the habit spreads from the career to the sofa.
After all that, you aren't sure, nobody else is taking the blame, and you've been free to become a garden designer for fourteen months without using the freedom once.
A Friday of your own
Size the decision first. Two questions do it. How much will it matter in a year, and can you undo it?
- Small and reversible. Menus, paint, most purchases under a sum you can name. Minutes. Pick the first that would do, and change it if it's wrong. Below, say, fifty pounds, don't compare at all.
- Small and irreversible. A haircut before a wedding, a non-refundable weekend. An evening at most.
- Large and reversible. Moving firms, a course you could leave after a term. Days, or a few weeks. Treat it as a trial. You don't have to know whether you'll love garden design, only whether to find out, and a term will tell you more than another year of the spreadsheet.
- Large and irreversible. Rare, and the only kind that earns a long process, outside advice, and more than one night's sleep. It still needs a date, months away if necessary. If the date arrives and you still can't choose, you may not want any option on the table, and the real decision is a different one.
Most of your list will turn out small, reversible, or both. The course feels like a decision about your whole life. It's a decision about two evenings a week and three thousand two hundred pounds for the first year, and you could leave after that. Give each item a time allowance. For anything open longer than its allowance, more thinking won't help.
Then the method. It takes about an hour for a large decision and minutes for a small one.
- Write the musts, four at most, the things the choice has to do as distinct from what would be nice. The sofa has to fit the alcove, survive the dog, cost under nine hundred pounds and be comfortable to lie on. For the course an honest list might be that my work interests me on most days, we can still pay the mortgage, and I'm home at least three evenings a week. A fifth must means one of the four goes out.
- Three options at most, with the default as one of them, written out with its costs.
- Check each against the musts with a yes or a no. No scores. An option that fails a must is out, however attractive. If Stay fails "my work interests me" and you've known that for two years, it's between the other two.
- Look things up only with a written question whose answer could change the outcome.
- Set the date to fit the size, write it down, and tell someone, so there's a person who'll ask. Tie it to something real if you can. The college closes on the thirtieth of June, so your date can be a month earlier.
- On the date, if one option passes, you've finished. If two pass, both are good enough by your own standard, and the gap between them is small next to the cost of another year.
- If it's level, toss a coin and notice how you feel in the second after it lands. Disappointment or relief tells you what you wanted. If you feel nothing, do what the coin says.
On that last one, the economist Steven Levitt ran a large experiment in which volunteers stuck on a decision, some of them major, like quitting a job, let a coin toss advise them. Those whose coin said make the change were more likely to make it, and six months later they reported being happier than those told to stay as they were. The volunteers chose to take part and rated their own happiness, so it isn't proof. Levitt's conclusion was that people may be too cautious about choices that would change their lives.
Sleep on a large choice once. If a new fact turns up overnight, look again. Doubt alone doesn't count, and a second night would be another lap. Then within a day do something that makes it real. Send the form.
The wobble will come within two or three days, often at night. The old job will suddenly seem warm and safe. You'd have felt it whichever way you'd gone, because the doubt that used to follow whichever option was ahead now has only one place to go. So decide on the day you choose what would reopen the question, and write it down. "I'll reopen this only if one of my musts turns out not to be met." A bad night isn't a new fact. Nor is an article, or a friend's raised eyebrow.
Close the other options properly. Delete the bookmarks, unsubscribe from the job alerts, put the samples in the recycling, move the spreadsheet somewhere you don't look. Tell the people you consulted, in a sentence, without asking what they think. Spend the freed evenings making the choice work. Then set one review at a sensible distance, the end of the first term for a course, six months for a job, and ask then whether your musts are being met, using what you've learned by living it.
If the decision is shared, write your musts separately and compare them, because long disagreements are often about musts nobody has said aloud. If every option is bad, the question is which loss you can best live with, and the default is often the worst because it lasts longest. Money and legal trouble often have more options than you can see from inside, and Citizens Advice is free. If someone else sets your date for you, a salesperson with an offer that ends today, walk away. A date helps when you set it yourself.
If a choice goes badly, ask whether it was a poor decision given what you knew, or a reasonable one that turned out badly. A course that closes after a year was bad luck. Take the lesson, usually a must you didn't know you had, and add it to the next list.
And if you can't choose anything at the moment, including what to eat or wear, and you feel flat, tired and hopeless, see your GP. The same goes if the going round feels less like weighing and more like a checking you can't stop, with a dread that something terrible will follow a wrong choice. Anxiety and obsessive problems can look like indecision, and they respond to treatment. In England you can refer yourself to NHS talking therapies.
You'll slip. You'll be three laps into a kettle with eleven tabs open before you notice. Close the tabs, write the musts, set the date for tomorrow.
A year on, it's a Sunday in late February and the laptop shows a planting plan for a north-facing border, due Tuesday. You're not happy with the back row. Last February you wrote four musts on an envelope, Stay failed the first, and the coin said Move. Your heart sank, and that settled it. The wobble came on the Wednesday, at about three, and you checked it against what you'd written and went back to sleep, eventually. The sofa took twenty minutes. It's the grey one, and everyone sits wherever they want.
Start smaller than that. Take the smallest item on your list and write down what that choice has to do for you, in four lines or fewer. Then pick the first option that does it, tonight, and close the tabs.