The 20-minute version
It's a Tuesday evening and your partner has just come off the phone with the school. The call was about your son and it wasn't a good one, and you listened from the kitchen. They didn't get defensive. They asked two questions you wouldn't have thought to ask, got a date for a meeting out of it, and thanked the teacher at the end in a voice that meant it. On the stairs you think, that was handled really well. I'd have lost my temper by the second minute.
Then you go up to find a towel, and the thought goes wherever those thoughts go.
It isn't only Tuesday. A colleague you barely know presents eight slides and for once you can follow what's being asked. Your dad, on the floor with the grandchildren, is more patient at seventy than he was at forty. A woman on the platform is wearing a coat you'd have chosen yourself. Each time it's the same. A clear, favourable, true thought about a person, formed in full, and put away.
I'll call where it goes the drawer. I'd guess yours is full.
Nobody decides to keep their good opinions to themselves. It's what happens by default when saying it would cost something and not saying it costs nothing you can see. The drawer gives you real things. A thought kept in can't be misread or laughed at. You're spared the squirm, the awkwardness that arrives the moment you imagine opening your mouth. You're spared the wording. Nobody thinks you want something, and you stay the person you think you are, someone who doesn't gush.
Most of the reasons for keeping it in rest on a guess about how the other person will take it. That guess has been tested in a run of experiments over the last few years, and it's wrong in the same direction for almost everyone. People underestimate how good a compliment makes someone feel, overestimate how awkward it'll be, and grade their own wording while the other person hears something else entirely. Once you see that, the fix is small. A good thought said out loud has two parts, takes ten seconds, and is best said within the hour.
This isn't about thanking people for what they've done for you, which is a different habit. It's about the opinion that has nothing to do with you. Nobody did you a favour. You simply thought well of them. And it won't ask you to say anything you don't think.
Two cautions. If the silence is part of a wider fear, if you worry before, during and after most social situations, avoid them where you can, and it's been that way a long time, the NHS says that's more than shyness and worth seeing a GP about. You can also refer yourself to an NHS talking therapies service without going through a GP. And if you've felt low most of the day, most days, for a fortnight or more, and the quiet is part of that, see a GP. This will keep.
Before you read on, try something for three days. Every time you think a good thought about a person, however small, note it on your phone and mark whether you said it. You'll end up with two numbers, and the gap between them is what all of this is about.
The squirm doesn't cross the room
They don't know.
That's the belief that empties most of the drawer before anything else gets a look in. Your partner knows you think they handled it well, surely. You've been together eleven years. Your colleague knows the slides were good, because the meeting went fine.
What do they know it from? Your partner has eleven years of what you've said, and what you've said is mostly not this. They have the sigh at the bins and the question about the car. They don't have the sentence from the stairs, because it was thought on the stairs. The meeting going fine could mean the slides were clear or that nobody was listening.
Xuan Zhao and Nicholas Epley ran nine experiments in which people wrote a genuine compliment for someone and predicted how the recipient would feel. Then the compliment was delivered and the recipient said how they actually felt. The writers consistently underestimated how good it made the other person feel. If the recipients had already known, the compliment would have told them nothing. It moved them more than the writers expected. People know what's been said to them. What's been thought about them, however obvious it seems from inside your head, isn't anywhere they can see it.
Then there's the moment itself. You picture saying "you handled that really well" and your whole body objects. There'd be a pause, they'd look at you, and one of you would have to say something next.
Zhao and Epley measured that too. The writers overestimated how awkward the recipient would feel. Erica Boothby and Vanessa Bohns found the same in five studies of their own, and in one of them the givers still overestimated the awkwardness looking back, after the compliment had been given. But the detail I'd keep from their work is this. When people who weren't giving the compliment were asked to predict how the recipient would feel, they got it about right. The ones who got it wrong were the givers, and what threw them off was their own anxiety and their worry about doing it well.
So the squirm is a reading of you, and it stays with you. What crosses the room is the sentence. If there's a pause afterwards, let it be. It's the sound of the thing landing, and it's much shorter from their side than from yours.
The wording worry works the same way. "Good job" sounds like a manager. "That was amazing" sounds like a teenager. You go round the options, none sounds like you, and the moment passes while you're still choosing. In those studies, givers were marking their own competence, while recipients were reading for warmth. When Zhao and Epley told people to think about the warmth of their compliment instead of how well it was put, that alone made them more willing to give it.
Think about the last handwritten letter you got. You didn't grade the handwriting.
"That was amazing" and "I admired the way you handled that call" carry the same news, which is that you noticed and thought well of it. The only test the wording has to pass is whether it's true and whether it's specific.
Some people's worry is about character instead of nerves. You've met the person who tells everyone their haircut is wonderful, and you've watched what it does to the value of anything they say. Flattery is a compliment with a motive. It's said to get something, and it's said whether or not it's true. The difference lives in the speaker. Your drawer is full of specific, accurate, unrepeated observations about particular people, which is about as far from flattery as a sentence can get. Oddly, the evidence suggests that even flattery gets a warmer reception than you'd fear. The Dutch psychologist Roos Vonk found that people who were flattered liked the flatterer more than onlookers watching the same flattery did. I'm not recommending it. My rule is never to say it to get something and never to say it if you don't think it, and anything that passes both isn't flattery.
The suspicious reading is the next worry. You tell your manager the restructuring was handled fairly and watch them wonder what you're after. Some compliments are opening bids, and people tell from what comes next. If it's followed by "and about my hours", it was a bid. If it's followed by nothing, it was a report. James Dungan, David Munguia Gomez and Epley found that people sending messages of support, the "thinking of you" kind, underestimated how warmly they'd be received, for the same reason. The sender worried about how competent the message looked, and the recipient read it for warmth. Nobody was scanning for the angle.
So don't attach anything. Keep any request for that person for another day. And don't add "I'm not saying this because I want anything", which puts the idea in the room. A compliment with nothing after it shows what it was.
"It'll go to their head" is the oddest defence of the drawer, because the evidence points the other way. Deci, Koestner and Ryan, three researchers on motivation, pooled 128 experiments on rewards. Money and prizes tended to reduce how much people kept at a task by choice. Being told you'd done well raised it, along with how interested people said they were, though less for children than for students. In a field experiment by Christiane Bradler and colleagues, some workers on a three-hour data-entry job were unexpectedly recognised in public after two hours. Performance went up in the third hour, and most of the rise came from the workers who hadn't been recognised. A lab review and a three-hour job aren't your team. What they rule out is the idea that a good word makes people stop.
And the brush-off. You said something to your partner once and they said "don't be daft" and changed the subject. Denise Marigold, John Holmes and Michael Ross studied partners with low self-esteem, who tend to wave compliments away. When those people were asked to describe a recent compliment in terms of what it meant and why it mattered, they felt as good about it, and about the relationship, as people with high self-esteem, and the effect was still there two weeks later. The person who says "don't be daft" is often the one who's had the fewest good thoughts to work with.
You can borrow their move. After the brush-off, ask about the thing. "What made you think to ask the teacher that?" Then they're describing it, and you've given them a minute with the compliment instead of pushing it on them.
Rare currency
A quiet person, the sort who speaks once in a meeting, turns to a colleague afterwards and says "those slides were the clearest we've had this year", and goes back to their desk. No warmth in the voice beyond the words, and no follow-up.
Everyone in that room believed it at once, because this person doesn't say things they don't mean.
That's why "I'm not that sort of person" deserves a closer look. Reserve is a style. It's how much you say and how loudly, and I'm not asking you to change it. Silence about what you admire is a habit you've repeated so often it's stopped feeling like a choice. Plenty of reserved people say the good thing, in a reserved way. Your good opinion is rare currency, and the drawer has made sure nobody gets any of it.
It's also a very convenient trait, since it excuses you from every awkward moment in advance. If it really is who you are, the plain version, one sentence with no performance, will feel fine. If even that feels impossible, the style probably wasn't what was stopping you.
Then there's saving it up. You'll say the big thing at the wedding, in the card, at the retirement do. For most of the people you think well of, the occasion never comes. There's no speech for the colleague with the slides. The occasion that does come, eventually, is the funeral, and the good things said at funerals are very often the ones nobody said before. Everyone in the room can feel it.
An occasion also gets in the way of the words. A compliment at a wedding has an audience and a slot in the running order. A compliment on a Tuesday in the kitchen has nothing in between. And a good thought is worth most on the day it's true. "You handled that call well" on the night is about that call. Six years later it's a verdict with the detail gone, and verdicts are the part that gets brushed off. Give the speech. It's for saying again the things you've already said.
"It'd be odd after all this time." Fourteen years married, and your dad seventy-three, and you've never once told him you admire anything about him. The first one will be noticeable. Noticeable is a long way from odd. He won't think you've been to the doctor. He'll think you noticed him with the children. Keep it small. Don't sit anyone down, don't say "I've been meaning to tell you". Say the true thing about today in passing, "you were good with them this afternoon", and then talk about the football. The first one after fourteen years should be the same size as the ones after it. The same goes for a friend you've drifted from. "Saw a garden on Sunday and thought of yours" is a message, and a compliment, and it needs no reply.
So why hasn't the guess corrected itself, when you've been making it for years?
Epley and four colleagues reviewed findings like these and called the pattern undersociality. People are less social than would be good for them, because they expect their overtures to go down worse than they do. In plain terms they give three reasons. You and the other person are looking at different things, you at a performance you're grading, them at news about what you think. You don't know how they'll respond, so you assume the worse case and avoid it, and never find out the worse case wasn't coming. And you only learn from what you do. A compliment kept in gives you no landing and no correction. The rare one that goes badly is the one you remember. It's like an archer who never sees where the arrows go and only hears about the one that missed.
And one good go won't fix it.
Suppose you say it tonight and it lands, and you see it land. Stav Atir and Epley looked at what happens to people's expectations after a good conversation with a stranger. Having one did make them more optimistic, but within a week or two their expectations had drifted back to the same pessimistic level as people who'd never had the conversation. That study is about strangers, and I'm extending it to compliments because the guess comes from the same place. If it holds, the squirm will be back at full strength a week after the kitchen, as though the kitchen never happened. That isn't weakness. It means the fix has to be a standing rule that runs whether or not you currently believe it'll be fine.
Meanwhile the drawer is costing you. Boothby and Bohns found that people felt better after giving a compliment, despite the anxiety beforehand. In one small lab study, people who wrote to someone they loved after a stressful task saw their cortisol come down faster. The NHS lists giving to others among its five steps to mental wellbeing, with examples as small as asking someone how they are. And the people around you never see the drawer. They see what comes out, which is the question about the car and the sigh. You can be the most admiring person in the house on the inside and someone who never says a kind word on the outside, and the second one is who everybody meets.
It costs them more. Your partner's picture of what you think of them is built entirely from what you've said. Sara Algoe, Barbara Fredrickson and Shelly Gable found that when couples expressed gratitude to each other in a lab, how understood and cared for the receiving partner felt predicted the relationship improving over the next six months. That's thanks, and I'm extending it, because what the partner responded to was being seen and thought well of. Your partner handled the call and heard nothing. From inside your head, nothing meant "so obviously good it needs no comment". From inside theirs, nothing means nothing. Over fourteen years a person can build a fairly complete picture of not being seen, out of nothing but the sentences you thought.
There's a second drawer for strangers. The man at the deli counter who's cheerful at eight in the morning. The bus driver who waited. They're the easiest case, with no history and nothing anyone could think you're after. Gillian Sandstrom and Elizabeth Dunn found that people's wellbeing went along with contact with acquaintances and near-strangers as well as close friends, though that's interaction in general and can't show which way the cause runs. With strangers, keep it to something they chose or made. "That's a great coat," as you pass.
Then watch their face. That's the landing you've been missing, and it costs you one sentence on a platform.
The detail and what it did
Name the specific thing you noticed. Then say what it did for you. Then stop.
The detail comes first. "You didn't get defensive with the teacher." "Those slides had one idea each." "The roses up that wall." You can only notice a detail if you were paying attention, so it makes the compliment true. There's nothing in it to disagree with, so it's hard to brush off. And flattery deals in verdicts and has no details to offer. Once there's a detail in it, the wording almost doesn't matter.
The second sentence says what it did for you. "I'd have lost my temper by the second minute." "It's the first time this quarter I've understood what we're being asked." "I never got that from you at that age, and it's lovely to see." That's what turns an observation into a compliment. Without it, "you didn't get defensive" could be a note.
Some things to leave out.
- "I just wanted to say", which turns it into an announcement.
- "Honestly", which suggests you aren't usually.
- Comparisons like "you're much better at that than me", which move the subject to you.
- The verdict at the end, "you're brilliant", which is the bit that gets waved away.
If you can't find a detail, you haven't got a compliment yet. You've got a warm feeling. Wait a minute. The feeling was caused by something, and the something is the detail.
Timing is most of the rest. If you're in the room, say it before you leave it. Your partner puts the phone down and you say it from the kitchen doorway. The meeting breaks up and you say it while people gather their things. Ten minutes later you'd have to go and find them, and going to find someone makes it an event. Within the hour is the outer edge. If the moment's gone, send a message the same evening, the detail and the effect line, and don't redraft it. If a whole day has passed, don't apologise for the delay. "Been thinking about that call yesterday" turns the delay into proof that it stuck with you. And keep the card for extras. Cards are where good thoughts go to be generic.
The squirm grows with time. In the moment it's a thing you saw and said. An hour later it's a thing you decided to say, and a day later it's a thing you've been meaning to say, and each is heavier than the one before.
At home, the thoughts about a partner tend to be about how they are, which makes them feel bigger. Keep them small anyway. "You didn't rise to it with him tonight. I would have." If the first one gets a strange look, say the next one two days later at the same size. What builds the picture is that the said version exists at all.
With children, the detail matters even more. Mueller and Dweck found that fifth graders praised for being clever cared more about looking good than learning, and after a failure they persisted less and did worse than children praised for their effort. It's old and about one kind of task, so hold it loosely. "You're so clever" is a verdict. "You kept going at that when it wouldn't come out" is something they can do again.
With your parents, the drawer has the oldest contents and the plainest deadline. Say one this Sunday, in passing, as small as you can make it. "You're good with them. You've got more patience than I have." He'll pretend it wasn't noticeable. It'll have been said.
At work, a colleague who doesn't report to you is the easy case, because nobody is grading anyone. "One idea a slide. First time I've followed one of these." Then go. With someone who reports to you, say it in the moment, not saved for the review, where compliments become grades. And don't wrap it around a correction. Everyone who's had the good thing put first to soften the bad thing has learned to brace when the good thing starts, so keep them apart, by a day if you can. With a boss, nothing after it, and if that still feels exposed, say what the team noticed. Don't say it to a third person and hope it gets back. As far as they're concerned, a good opinion of their work said to someone else in the kitchen doesn't exist.
Now the rule. One a day. One good thought said out loud to the person it's about, with the detail in it, within the hour if you can. Most days you'll have five or six and you're only letting one out, so the drawer keeps most of what it's used to.
Put three things in place tonight. First, plans in the form "when this happens, I'll do that", which Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran's review found people act on more reliably than a general intention. When I think a good thought about someone in the room, I say the detail before I leave. When they're not there, I message it that evening. When they brush it off, I ask one question about the thing and let it go. Second, keep the three-day count going for a fortnight. You're collecting the landings the drawer never let you see, and the guess needs a lot of them because it comes back. Third, the shape. Detail, effect line, stop.
The first few will feel just as awkward as you thought, in your chest, and land better than you thought, on their face. You'll notice the first part more, because it's loud and the other is quick and quiet. Phillippa Lally and colleagues found that new daily habits became automatic over weeks rather than days, and that missing a day didn't set things back much. Expect weeks.
And soon somebody will say something good back. Take it. You know now what a brush-off does.
Five quiet days
Some cases aren't ordinary.
- The ex. If it's a report with nothing attached and you can both take it that way, it may be one of the more generous things you do this year. If any part of you hopes it starts something, it's a bid, and you know it. If the split is recent or they're still hurt, keep it in.
- The colleague who'd take it wrong. Keep it about the work, short and once. "That was a clear set of slides" can't be spun. If even that feels unsafe, leave them out. The drawer is the right place for a good thought that would be used against you.
- Families that never say it. That's a shared rule, and breaking it shows. The small version, in passing, about one specific thing, survives a family rule best, because it can be taken as a remark. Go slowly, and let them set the pace of what comes back.
- The person who's died. There may be a backlog nobody heard until the funeral. I've no research for this. If it helps, write the things down in the two-part shape, for the record that you noticed. Then say one to someone living, today.
- When it's more than shyness. If what stops you is a fear of most social situations and of being watched and judged, the NHS calls that social anxiety. It's common, it often doesn't go away on its own, and treatments help. See a GP or refer yourself to NHS talking therapies. The one-a-day rule is still usable, but it isn't a treatment.
Somewhere around the third or fourth week you'll notice you've said nothing for five days. The count stopped and you didn't clock it.
That's the guess coming back on schedule, the way it did for the people talking to strangers. The difference is that you caught it this time. Lally found a missed day didn't materially affect a habit forming. A week is more than a day and I'm stretching the finding, but the habit is paused, not lost.
Don't come back with a speech to make up for it. That's the occasion again, and it'll feel the wrong size because it is. Come back at the size you left. One detail, one effect line, to whoever's nearest, today. Then ask which belief did it. Usually there's a particular brush-off in the quiet week, or a landing you didn't see, or a day the wording wouldn't come. The beliefs come back with the guess, and the answers haven't changed. Keep the count without turning it into a score. The drawer's whole trick is that it can't be seen, and a mark on your phone shows you what it took.
It's a Tuesday a few weeks on, and your partner has just come off the phone with the school. It wasn't a good call. They asked the two questions, got the date, thanked the teacher. You're on the stairs with the towel and the sentence arrives as it always did.
This time you come back down. You say it from the doorway in the plain voice you use for everything. "You didn't get defensive with her. I'd have been shouting by the second minute." Your partner looks up. There's a pause of about a second, which you notice and let be. They say "well, somebody had to keep it together", and you ask what made them think to ask about the timetable, and they tell you, a bit pleased, and you go up for the towel.
It took ten seconds. You'll have forgotten the squirm by the top of the stairs, and neither of you will forget that it was said.
Your dad will go on being patient. The colleague will present again. The coats will keep going by on the platform. Say one today, the nearest one, to the nearest person, with the detail in it, and then talk about something else.