The feeling will pass without help

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 53 min

It's twenty past three on a Wednesday and you're at your desk. The morning went fine. Now there's a stretch of something that isn't quite a task, and something in your chest has gone slightly slack, and your hand is in the biscuit drawer before you've decided anything. You eat one at the desk. It's fine. The slack thing is still there.

At half past five you're in the queue at the post office, it isn't moving, and the phone is in your hand showing you something you've already seen today. The first half hour at home is the flat part, the part before dinner where nothing happens, and the glass of wine is poured for that half hour and not for the meal. On Sunday a friend cancels, the afternoon opens up in front of you like a field, and by four there's a jacket in a basket on a website and you're looking at delivery options.

An invented day. I'd be surprised if you didn't recognise most of it.

It's one habit, not four. Biscuit, phone, wine, jacket, in different rooms at different hours, and the same move every time. A feeling arrives, bored, flat, tense, awkward, sad, restless, and before you've named it your hand has gone somewhere. The feeling is covered for a while. Then it's back, sometimes with a second feeling on top, the small verdict on yourself about the biscuit or the jacket.

You'd say the remedy works, and it does seem to. What I'd like you to consider is whether the remedy changed the feeling, or whether the feeling was changing anyway and the remedy happened to be standing next to it when it did.

I'm not going to ask you to give up biscuits, wine, your phone or shopping. I'm going to ask you to stop using them as a cure for feelings that don't need one, and to find out, for the first time, what those feelings do when nothing is done about them.

Tomorrow, each time your hand goes towards one of these, write down the feeling it was going from. One word. If you can, score it out of ten, ten being the worst thing you've felt this year. Don't change anything else. Most people who do this find two things. The list is longer than they expected, and the scores are lower. Twos and threes, mostly.

Four cautions, and please read them even if you're sure they don't apply.

  • If you drink every day and feel shaky, sweaty or sick when you don't, don't cut down suddenly because of something you read. Stopping heavy daily drinking without medical advice can be dangerous. See a GP first and let them help you plan it.
  • If the reach is for food in large amounts, with a feeling of being unable to stop, that's a different thing. The eating disorder charity Beat and your GP are the right places, and they're used to being asked.
  • If the feeling you reach from has been there most of the day for a fortnight, or nothing has felt good for that long, that's a change in your health. See a GP. In England, if you're eighteen or over, you can also refer yourself to NHS talking therapies without going through a GP.
  • If the discomfort is panic, or you've had thoughts of harming yourself, that's urgent and not a habit. Talk to a GP or call 111, and call 999 if you're in immediate danger. Samaritans are on 116 123 at any hour.

Twos and threes

Every feeling has a shape. It rises, it peaks, it falls, and how long that takes is set by what caused it.

Philippe Verduyn and colleagues had people record, day by day, how long their episodes of fear, anger, joy, gratitude and sadness lasted and what was going on when each began. Three things set the duration, across all five. How important the cause was. How intense the feeling was at the start. And whether the cause came back, in reality or in the person's mind, while the feeling was running. Important causes, strong starts and returning triggers made feelings last. Trivial causes, mild starts and triggers that stayed away made them short.

Hold that against twenty past three. The cause was a lull. The intensity was a two. It mattered not at all. And a lull doesn't come back, it just ends. On every one of Verduyn's predictors, that feeling was built to be brief. A small rise, a low peak, a fall, all over in a few minutes.

I'm not talking about grief, or the tall slow feelings that take months. I'm talking about the flickers you reach from thirty times a day. The reason you believe they won't pass on their own is that you've never once watched one to the end. The remedy always got there first.

Now think about when the reach happens. Not at the first flicker, usually. A few seconds or a minute in, once the feeling is noticeable enough to move your hand, which is near the top of a small wave. You eat the biscuit, and over the next couple of minutes the feeling falls. The biscuit was there when it fell, so the biscuit gets the credit. But the fall was coming anyway, and you'd already spent most of the feeling before you reached. A passer-by who turns up as a fight is ending doesn't get to say they stopped it. The remedy is that passer-by, thirty times a day.

There's a study that pulls the two apart. Sarah Bowen and Alan Marlatt took a hundred and twenty-three student smokers who wanted to change and exposed them to cues that provoke the urge to smoke. Half got brief instructions in what Marlatt called urge surfing, attending to an urge as it rises and falls without acting on it. The other half got nothing. The urges were no different between the groups. The surfers felt theirs just as much. But over the following week they smoked significantly fewer cigarettes. The instructions didn't shrink the urge. They changed what people did with it, and the urge, unfed, went on its way. That was students and cigarettes, and stretching it to biscuits and jackets is my step, but an urge is a wave like any other.

The fear underneath all this is that the feeling would climb. That the reach isn't about the two at all, it's about stopping the two becoming a nine.

That's a forecast, and you've never tested it. You don't know what the flicker at twenty past three does at minute eight, because you've never been at minute eight without a biscuit. Bowen and Marlatt's surfers felt their urges in full, and the urges peaked and passed. A two from a lull has nowhere to climb to. What makes feelings climb, on Verduyn's findings, is the cause coming back, and a lull doesn't come back. It's replaced by the next thing.

So run the test. It's the most useful thing in this whole argument.

Next time the flicker comes and your hand moves, don't. Score the feeling. Set a timer for ten minutes and carry on with whatever you were doing. Pick one small piece of the job, ten minutes' worth, and do it with the feeling sitting there. You've worked through a slight cold, a stiff neck, a room that's too warm, and a flat feeling at twenty past three is smaller than any of them. Don't try to make it go. When the timer goes, score it again.

Most people find the second number is lower than the first, and that nothing was done to make it so. If yours went up, that's worth knowing too, and I'll come to what it means. But once you've seen a feeling fall with nobody helping it, the biscuit's alibi stops working. You've watched the fight end with no one there.

Ten thousand lessons

Thirty reaches a day is two hundred a week and ten thousand a year.

Any one of them is nothing. A biscuit, five minutes on a phone. I agree, and I'm not interested in the biscuit. I'm interested in what ten thousand of them teach, which is that discomfort is an emergency. Every time the hand moves at a two, you learn again that a two must be dealt with now, and the line for what counts as unbearable comes down a little. Over years that's a person who can't sit through a queue, a lull or a cancelled Sunday, and doesn't know it, because they've never been without a remedy long enough to find out.

There's research on this under the name experiential avoidance, the habit of trying not to have unwanted feelings and doing things to get away from them. Todd Kashdan and colleagues ran two studies on it. In the second, people tracked over three weeks who leaned on avoidance had fewer positive experiences and events, more negative events, and more negative feeling day to day, and avoidance predicted how their days went better than the particular strategies they used to manage emotions. It's correlational work, probably with students, so it can't say which causes which. But it points the way you'd expect. People whose policy is to escape discomfort have worse days, not better ones.

"At least it's not something worse." A biscuit, not a bottle. Look at how interchangeable the four remedies are, though. The lull at twenty past three gets a biscuit or the phone, depending which is nearer. The flat half hour gets wine or a screen. People who give up one nearly always find another, and not because they chose it. The hand goes where the remedy is. The habit is the move from flicker to hand, and the move doesn't care what it lands on. The NHS says not to use alcohol, cigarettes, gambling or drugs to relieve stress, because they give temporary relief and in the long run create new problems, and I'd say the same of the smaller remedies at a smaller scale. The good news hiding in this is that you don't have to give up biscuits. You have to change the move.

"Everyone does it." The tin goes round the office at eleven, the family evening is four people on four phones. The room supplies the remedy. It doesn't supply the flicker, and you can keep the company and decline the remedy. Nobody notices who didn't take a biscuit. The awkwardness you're picturing is a flicker of its own, awkward, two, and it passes before anyone has noticed anything.

"I've had a hard day, I deserve it."

You do deserve things, and I'm not selling a life without rewards. What I want to separate is a reward from a remedy, because they wear the same clothes and do different jobs. A reward is chosen, for its own sake, and enjoyed. A remedy is reached for, to make the flicker stop, and you don't so much enjoy it as get through it. The wine at half past six because you'd like to celebrate is a reward. The same wine at half past six because the kitchen feels flat is a remedy.

The test is simple. Would you choose this on a good day, in this form, at this time? A glass with dinner, yes. A glass in an empty kitchen at half past six, on a good day, probably not. A biscuit with tea at four when you're pleased with the afternoon, yes. A biscuit from the drawer at twenty past three, staring at the screen, no. Keep your rewards. Have more of them, in fact. Just stop letting the flicker pick them for you.

"Distraction works, everyone says so." It does, for a while. But Verduyn found that what most extended a feeling was its cause coming back to mind, and distraction is a way of making sure it comes back, because nothing was done about it and it's still there when the phone goes back in your pocket. Sometimes it comes back with the verdict about the twenty minutes on top.

Katharina Kircanski, Matthew Lieberman and Michelle Craske tested something else against distraction, with people afraid of spiders. During short exposures to a live spider, some put their feelings into words, and others reappraised, distracted themselves, or did nothing extra. A week later, with a different spider, the namers had lower fear on a body measure, skin conductance, than the other groups. On how afraid they said they felt, there was no difference, so I hold it lightly. But the direction fits. The feeling you look away from returns. The feeling you name has been attended to.

If "sit with your feelings" makes you wince, fair enough. This isn't meditation, you don't need an app, and it doesn't replace therapy. It's ten minutes of not reaching. The one word I'd keep is surfing, because it's accurate. A surfer doesn't stop the wave and doesn't jump off. They stay on while it does what waves do, and it puts them down on the beach.

"I'd just be miserable all the time." That picture assumes the feeling stays, and it doesn't. It also runs backwards from Kashdan's finding. The avoiders had fewer good experiences, not more. Avoidance bought them a narrower life, because the good things in a day are mostly on the far side of some small discomfort. The conversation that starts awkward. The walk in the cold. The empty afternoon that turns into something.

Add up what the move costs and most of it is paid in small coins.

  • Days made of small escapes, never quite in the room for the flat bits, and the flat bits are most of any day.
  • Time. The flicker would have passed in ten minutes. The phone takes as long as you'll give it.
  • Thirty small verdicts a day, adding up by bedtime to a low opinion you'd never have formed from any one of them.
  • Never knowing your own weather. You've had feelings all your life and never watched one through, so each flicker arrives as a stranger with no known end, and that's what makes it frightening.

That last one turns into a loop. Researchers call the capacity to bear discomfort distress tolerance. Teresa Leyro, Michael Zvolensky and Amit Bernstein reviewed the work on it and found links between low distress tolerance and a range of psychological problems, along with a lot of muddle over how to measure it. A capacity that's never used doesn't grow. Every reach keeps the feeling strange and the capacity small, so the next flicker is a bit more frightening. Every wave you ride makes the next one a little easier.

Ten minutes before anything

Learn what your flicker looks like in your body. That's the first job, and everything else depends on it.

"But I don't even notice. The biscuit's in my mouth before there's been any feeling." The reach isn't faster than the feeling. It's faster than your attention to it. The flicker was there and the hand answered. What was missing was you, in the half-second between, and trying harder to notice in the moment doesn't widen that. Knowing the body sign in advance does. For most people it's a slackening in the chest, a set jaw, restless hands, or the eyes going to the drawer before the mind catches up. Spend a day watching for yours, after the fact if you have to. Each time you find the biscuit half eaten, ask what your body did just before. Most people find one or two signs that come every time, and once known, they start arriving a second earlier. A second is enough.

Then, when it comes, five steps.

  • Name it. One word, in your head or under your breath. Bored, flat, awkward, tense, sad, restless, lonely. If the word is "hungry", ask whether an apple would do. If not, it wasn't hunger.
  • Score it out of ten. Two seconds. A formless discomfort becomes a number, and a number is smaller.
  • Say the sentence. "This will pass without help." Say it as a prediction, because you're about to test it.
  • Give it ten minutes. Carry on with what you were doing. Don't reach and don't fight it either. Then score it again.
  • Write the word and both numbers down, every time, for the first week. A page of "flat 3, 1" and "bored 2, 0" and "tense 4, 2" is the most persuasive document you'll ever read about yourself.

Inside the ten minutes there's a way of being with it that helps. Find where it sits. Chest, throat, stomach, behind the eyes. "There's a tightness under my ribs" is a smaller thing to be with than "I feel bad". Expect it to rise a little in the first minute or two, because waves go up before they come down, and this is exactly where the hand usually moves. You've never seen the down because you always left at the up. Breathe out slowly, twice, because bracing is what makes a rise feel like a climb. Don't fight it by telling yourself it shouldn't be there, and don't feed it. Let it be there the way you let weather be there while you get on. Somewhere in the ten minutes it'll be as bad as it gets. Notice that, and notice it's a three at worst. Give your hands something that isn't a remedy, a pen or a glass of water.

And when it's fallen, stop for a second and notice how you are. Nothing was used. There's no verdict, because there's nothing to have a verdict about. It's a small quiet that isn't there after a biscuit, and I'd like you to feel it on purpose the first few times so you know it exists.

If you still want the biscuit after all that, have the biscuit. It's a choice made at the end of a wave now, and that's the whole difference.

Not every feeling is weather, though. This is the objection that matters most. The tension at six might be about the conversation you're not having with your partner. The flat Sunday might be about a job you should have left two years ago. Sitting with those isn't wisdom. It's doing nothing about something real.

Yes. And this is where the remedy does its most expensive work, because it covers everything at a two, including the twos that were the start of a thought you needed to have. The wine at six covers the flat half hour and the conversation together.

So there are two lists. The first is feelings to ride, the flicker from a lull, the awkwardness in a queue, the flatness of an empty hour. No information in them. The second is feelings asking for something. They come back at the same time with the same cause, which is Verduyn's returning trigger, so ten minutes won't settle them. Two questions sort them. Does it keep coming back in the same place? And when you name it, is there a second word behind the first? "Flat" on its own is the first list. "Flat, about work" is the second. The second list is much shorter, and the remedy buries it among the first.

For the second list, ask what it wants, not how to make it stop. Flat about work wants a decision or a conversation. Lonely on a Sunday wants a person. Tense at six wants the thing you haven't said. Tired at twenty past three wants rest, not sugar. Then make the answer small, because it's competing with a remedy that's fast and small and right there.

  • Restless or tense, a walk.
  • Lonely, a two-line message to a friend, sent now.
  • Flat about work, one sentence on a pad about what you'd do if you left.
  • Tense at six, one true sentence at dinner.
  • Tired, lie down for fifteen minutes.
  • A low that comes with a situation you've been putting up with, a decision written down with a date beside it.

Sometimes you ask and the honest answer is nothing, it's just a bad afternoon, and then it's on the first list after all. Sometimes the second word is big. A marriage, a job, a parent. That's the method working, because you've found the thing, and finding it is the first step towards whatever help it needs, a conversation, a friend, a GP, a therapist. NHS talking therapies take self-referrals.

All of it fits in one sentence. When I feel the flicker and my hand moves, I name the feeling, and I give it ten minutes before I give it anything.

Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran reviewed ninety-four studies of plans in the form "when this happens, I'll do that", and found that people who plan that way follow through much more often than people who only hold the intention. Write three.

When my hand goes towards the drawer or the phone or the bottle, I'll stop, say one word for what I'm feeling, and score it.

When I've scored it, I'll set ten minutes and carry on with what I was doing.

When the ten minutes are up and the score hasn't fallen, I'll ask what the feeling wants and do one small thing towards it.

My expectation, and it isn't a finding, goes like this. The first two days feel like a lot of stopping, because the flickers are more frequent than you knew. Around day three or four one of them is gone before the timer, and you realise you rode it without trying. By the end of the week you've found a feeling or two with a second word and done one small thing about one of them, and that feels like more of a change than any number of biscuits not eaten.

Half a biscuit

You'll find the biscuit half eaten. Or the phone in your hand in the queue, or the glass already poured, and you'll realise you never caught the flicker. Then the thought comes that you're back where you started.

You're not. That was a flicker getting past the catch, which is what flickers have done all your life.

Name it late. The word works after the reach as well as before. "That was flat." Score what's left, and notice the remedy didn't do much. The feeling's about where it would have been, and now there's a verdict as well. Then work out which flicker you missed. A place where the remedy was already in your hand, an hour of the day that's always a reach, a feeling you don't have a word for yet. Each has a small fix. Move the phone. Watch that hour. Find the word.

If it was a whole evening, sofa and bottle and phone and the delivery app, name that too, in the morning. What's usually left is the feeling that started it, unchanged, and a bigger verdict than usual. The first is the one to ask what it wants. The second you ride, because a verdict is a wave and passes like one. Read the list of what you reached for as a list of flickers that didn't get named, which is all it is.

Don't count reach-free days. A streak makes one biscuit feel like the end of something. Count waves ridden, if you count anything, and carry on the same afternoon. The next flicker will be along within the hour.

A few remedies and situations need their own word.

The six o'clock glass is the commonest evening remedy and the one most worth looking at, because alcohol has costs the others don't. Name the flatness, give it ten minutes, and pour the glass with dinner if you want it. And once more, because it matters. If you drink every day and feel shaky, sweaty or sick without it, don't cut down alone. See a GP and plan it together. That's what the body does after regular heavy drinking, and it needs medical care.

The phone is always in your hand already, which makes the ten minutes hardest with it. Put it in a different pocket or a bag for a week, so the reach has a step in it, and the step is where the word goes. The flat Sunday that ends in a shopping basket nearly always has a second word. Find it before you find the jacket. With food, the apple question does the sorting. If the reach is for large amounts with a feeling of being unable to stop, that's Beat and a GP. If the remedy is a bet, that bill can run away in a way the others can't. There are NHS gambling services and a GP route, and it's outside what I can cover here.

Some weeks are made of sevens. A death, a diagnosis, a job lost. Those flickers aren't flickers and the ten minutes aren't the point. Be kind to yourself, keep the remedies moderate, and let the week be what it is. The ordinary days come back.

If the flatness has sat there most of the day for two weeks, or nothing has felt good for that long, ten minutes won't shift it and shouldn't be asked to. See a GP or refer yourself to talking therapies. If the discomfort is panic, heart going, breath short, a sense that something terrible is about to happen, that has its own treatment and a GP is the route. If you've had thoughts of harming yourself, that's urgent. A GP, or 111, or 999 if you're in danger. Samaritans are on 116 123.

It's twenty past three on a Wednesday, some weeks on. Something in your chest goes slack and you notice it, which you never used to. Flat. Two. You say the sentence under your breath, because it's become a small joke with yourself, and go back to what you were doing with the flatness sitting under your ribs like weather. When you look up at half past, it's gone. You didn't see it go.

At half past five the phone is in the other pocket. Your hand goes to the usual one, finds nothing, and you stand in the queue and are bored. The queue moves. A man in front says something about the weather and you say something back.

On Sunday a friend cancels. Lonely, and behind it nobody in particular, just an empty afternoon. You message someone else, and they're free. The jacket is still in the basket from three weeks ago. You might buy it, on a day you want a jacket.

You reached twice on Thursday and named them both late. The remedies are all still in the house.

Next time your hand moves, say one word for what you're feeling, and give it ten minutes.