The next move is yours

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 51 min

On Monday the head of department announces that the team leader job has gone to a colleague who joined two years after you. Nobody warned you. By Thursday you've told the story to your partner, two friends, your sister and the person at the next desk, and each telling has picked up a detail. The way the head of department didn't look at you. The lunch those two had in March.

You haven't asked your manager why you weren't chosen. Asking would be pointless, you've decided, and anyway it's their job to explain themselves to you.

Or it's eight years since your parents helped your brother with the deposit on a flat and didn't help you. You've never said so to them plainly, and it decides how long you stay at Christmas. Or your ex left, some of the debts were in your name, and three years on there's an envelope from the bank on the hall shelf that you haven't opened. Or a friend has rung you twice since you moved away, and you're not going to ring her, because it's always you who rings.

In every one of these I think the person has a fair complaint.

"Victim mentality" is mostly used as an insult, often to end a conversation with someone whose complaint is real. If it's been said to you, you were probably right to be annoyed. I don't mean that nothing bad happened to you. I'm going to assume it did. You were passed over, lied to, left, cheated, or treated worse than the person next to you for no good reason, and I won't ask you to decide it wasn't so bad or to be grateful for the lesson.

Look at how each example went, though. First there was a wrong. Then came the sense of being wronged, which I'll call the grievance, a thought or a hot feeling in the chest that arrived without your permission and was probably accurate.

Then you did something.

You gave the next move to someone else. It became the manager's job to explain, the parents' job to notice, the ex's job to pay, the friend's job to ring. Until they do, you go over it, you tell it, and you wait, and the part of your life it touched stays where it was. I'll call this handing over. You don't choose a feeling. Handing over is something you do, a habit, and it can change without anybody pretending the wrong was all right.

You probably don't do it everywhere. When the boiler breaks you ring someone, and if your child were treated badly at school you'd be in the office by nine. It turns up where you were hurt worst, or where a move feels most dangerous, and something that selective was more likely learned than born in you.

One thing comes before all of that. If a partner or relative hits you, threatens you, or controls your money or who you see, that's abuse, and the first job is your safety. A domestic abuse helpline will talk through your options in confidence, and in an emergency you should call the police. If you're being harassed or discriminated against at work, a union rep, an employment adviser or a solicitor will be more use to you than a change of attitude. Nothing here argues for putting up with mistreatment. And if what happened still comes back as nightmares or flashbacks, or your mood has been low for weeks, that's something for a doctor.

Now pick a grievance that's more than a month old. Write down what happened in two lines, with the date. Underneath, write one line saying what you've done about it since, apart from thinking and talking. Don't judge the answer. You'll use it.

The envelope on the shelf

Habits last because they pay, and this one pays every time.

Each time the person with the envelope walks past it, they could open it. Or they could think "this is his mess" and keep walking, and feel the dread about the number inside go quiet for a while. That easing is the wage, and it comes in several currencies.

  • Innocence. If the next move is someone else's, nothing that happens now is down to you. For anyone who was blamed a lot, as a child or in a marriage, that's a place of safety.
  • A rest from risk. Ask the manager and you might get an answer you don't want. While the move is theirs, you don't have to find out.
  • Sympathy. Tell the story well and people are warm to you, and the warmth is real.
  • The high ground. In the account, you're the one who behaved properly, which is often true.
  • An explanation. "My career stalled because of what they did" is simpler than the real mixture of causes, and kinder.

What's the relief actually relief from? The discomfort of having an uncertain move to make, which handing over ends in a second or two. The debt is still in the envelope. You've bought a gap before you next have to think about it, and during the gap the debt usually gets harder to deal with.

The costs come slowly. The waiting has no end date, and the person you're waiting on may not know they're being waited on, or may have forgotten the whole thing. Moves go out of date, so a conversation that would have been awkward in the first year is a much bigger thing after eight years of silence, and job openings close and friendships cool past the point one call would mend. The sympathy runs down too. By the tenth telling, people change the subject, and that goes on the list as one more wrong.

Two costs deserve a slower look.

You've put the person who treated you worst in charge of your timetable. You wouldn't trust your ex to choose your curtains, but whether your finances get sorted out this year now depends on his conscience.

And after enough practice, the question "what could I do about this?" stops coming up. You stop noticing moves even when they're in front of you, and from inside that doesn't feel like a habit. It feels as though life doesn't offer you any openings.

So how do you tell a fair grievance from the habit, when the grievance is usually true? Ask whether there's something you could do about it that you're not doing, because you think someone else ought to be the one to do it. If yes, the habit is at work, however right you are about the facts.

Some waiting is correct. The firm has twenty-eight days to answer your formal complaint, or your sister has asked for time before you talk. You chose those waits and you know when they end. The habit is the other kind, which nobody agreed to.

Go back to what you wrote. What would a move have looked like in the first month, and what were you afraid would happen if you'd made it? That second answer names the payment you've been collecting.

The car with the crushed wing

Someone drives into your parked car in the night and leaves no note. It's entirely their fault. You were asleep. The car with the crushed wing is still yours, and if you want it repaired, you're the one who rings the garage.

Nobody finds that confusing with a car. With a marriage, a childhood or a career the two things run together, and "it wasn't my fault" starts to mean "so it isn't mine to deal with". The principle underneath is decent. Whoever caused the damage should repair it, and where you can make that happen, you should. But when they won't, or can't, or have died, you're left holding a rule only the other person can carry out.

So split one question into two. Whose fault was it? Whose move is it? The first looks back and the second looks forward, and they have different answers more often than we'd like. In 1982 Philip Brickman and his colleagues set out a framework along these lines, treating responsibility for a problem and responsibility for its solution as separate, and they favoured the version where a person isn't blamed for the problem and is still in charge of the solution.

Making the move feels like pleading guilty. English doesn't help, because "take responsibility" means both "admit you were to blame" and "deal with it". I only ever mean the second. Two people can disagree for ever about who wrecked a marriage, and the envelope from the bank can still be opened this evening.

Yes, it's unfair, and I won't argue that it's fair underneath. Their behaviour already took the fair options away. What's left is an unfair situation with the damage repaired, or an unfair situation with the damage still there. You can still ring the garage and report the driver to the police on the same day. The habit is what happens when the fault question stalls and you let your own move stall with it.

The next belief is usually earned.

In her last job a woman complained twice about a supervisor who bullied her. Nothing was done, and she found out later she'd been written down as difficult. She works somewhere else now. The rota there is unfair to her in a small, fixable way, and she hasn't mentioned it. There's no point, she says. They never listen.

If you learned that trying gets you nowhere, the chances are someone taught you. In the 1960s Martin Seligman and Steven Maier gave dogs shocks they could do nothing to stop, and later, when escape was made easy, many of them didn't try. They called it learned helplessness. Fifty years on, looking over the brain research since, mostly in rats, the same two men said they'd had it backwards. Passivity appears to be the built-in response to bad events that go on and on, and what has to be learned is control. Rats are a long way from your career, and I don't want to lean on this harder than it will bear. Still, it suggests nobody trained you to be helpless. More likely you spent a long time somewhere that trying didn't work, and you haven't since had enough experience of trying that did. The remedy is that experience, in small amounts, and being argued with by me won't supply it.

The belief travels, and you can hear it travel. Lyn Abramson, Seligman and John Teasdale argued in 1978 that explanations which are permanent and cover everything predict giving up. Listen for "always", "never", "everyone" and "nobody". "My last manager ignored two complaints" is a fact about one manager. "They never listen" is a forecast about every manager you'll ever have.

Sort a grievance into three piles. First, what you can't change, which is what already happened, other people's characters, and decisions that are final. Second, what you can influence by asking, applying, complaining or proposing, though the outcome isn't yours. Third, what you can simply do, such as opening the envelope. Helplessness puts everything in the first pile. The opposite mistake, that your life is whatever you decide, is false and cruel to people up against poverty, illness or prejudice. Even a tight situation usually has one or two moves, often through other people, like a union or an advice service.

Then test it. Pick something from the second pile, small enough that a no won't flatten you, and write down what you expect. "They'll brush me off." Ask about the rota. Write down what happened. Some of these will fail. The aim is to swap "never" for an actual count, and my guess is the count will be better than you expect.

The deposit is the hardest kind. Eight years on, that person could tell you the amount, the month, and what their mother said on the phone, and keeping hold of it feels close to a duty, as if stopping being angry would mean agreeing it was fine. Wanting wrongs to count is a good instinct. But the parents don't know Christmas is hard work for you, and the ex has no idea how you spent Tuesday evening. You're the one serving the sentence.

Holding someone to account happens outside your head. You tell them plainly what they did and what it cost you, or you complain formally, use the small claims court, go to a solicitor or the police, or end contact. Each has a start and a finish, and afterwards something in the world is different. Carrying happens inside your head and has neither. The people who carry the most have often done the least holding to account, because one is frightening and the other is familiar. If there's a way to hold them to account you haven't tried, that may be your next move. If none is left, carrying still won't do that job for you.

You may expect me to say forgive. I won't. Laura Luchies and colleagues found that people who forgave a partner who made amends gained self-respect, and people who forgave a partner who didn't lost some, which they called the doormat effect. Forgiveness work with a therapist can help, too. It's slow, and whether it's wise depends partly on how the other person behaves.

What I'm asking is narrower. Stop making your next move depend on theirs. If you're afraid there'd be no record, make one. Write down what was done, when, and what it cost you, and keep it somewhere safe. A fact on paper stays true without being rehearsed.

Then picture the day after the apology arrives. What would you do differently that day? Could you do it without the apology?

The tenth telling

Telling it again doesn't let the pressure out.

Being heard and believed once is worth a great deal, and I'd never tell you to keep a wrong to yourself. The steam-valve idea is another matter. In a 2002 experiment Brad Bushman made students angry and had some of them hit a punchbag while thinking about the person who'd angered them, and they ended up angrier and more aggressive than students who sat quietly. A 2024 review of 154 studies by Sophie Kjærvik and Bushman found that venting didn't reduce anger, while activities that calm the body did. Susan Nolen-Hoeksema's work on rumination found that going over things again and again deepens low mood and makes people less likely to act.

Why does the tenth telling still feel like relief, then? Partly the old payments. Partly something sneakier. You come off a ninety-minute call with your sister tired, as if you'd put in a shift, and no move has been made.

Did this round produce anything new, a new way of seeing it or a request you'll make? If the tenth telling matches the second, it's a replay. Tell it properly once, to someone who listens well, or write it down. Joanne Frattaroli pooled 146 experiments on writing about upsetting experiences and found a small benefit on average. Small is about right, and you can collect it in one or two goes. After that, give the complaint an address, meaning someone who can act on it, with a request. "I'd like to understand why I wasn't considered, and what I'd need to show next time" has an address. Told to the next desk, it doesn't. At three in the morning, when the scene replays and this time you say the perfect thing, name it as a replay and turn your attention to the weight of the blanket. It will come back, and you can do the same again.

You walk into the kitchen at work and two colleagues stop talking. An email about your own project goes to six people and you aren't one of them. Someone who has been badly treated reads these instantly. They were talking about me. I was left off on purpose. It feels like something you saw, and it was a guess.

Being warier after a hurt is sensible, and sometimes the quick reading is right. Rahav Gabay and colleagues in Israel found in 2020 that people high on what they called a tendency for interpersonal victimhood were more likely to expect harm in unclear situations, though the links were modest and it's a first sketch. The mechanism is easy to follow all the same. The worst reading gets filed as another wrong, and the fuller the file, the more obvious it seems that the next unclear event belongs in it. Meanwhile you've been cool with those two colleagues, and now they really are cooler with you. A referee who watches only one team finishes the match sure that team committed every foul. He didn't invent any of them. He never looked at the other half of the pitch.

Patterns are real, though, and this is exactly where "victim mentality" gets misused, to tell people bullying or discrimination is in their heads. If the same thing keeps happening from the same person or organisation, and not to colleagues who differ from you in sex, race, age or health, that's evidence. Keep a written log with dates, what was said and who was there. A union rep or a solicitor will ask for it first. What I mean is narrower, the single unclear event that never gets checked. Write your first reading, then two others at least as likely. Then, where it matters, ask. "I noticed I wasn't on the email. Was that deliberate?" Usually the answer is dull. And "you forgot me, and I minded" opens a far better conversation than "you wanted to hurt me".

A hard year can turn into a credit note. After a redundancy and a parent's long illness, your partner asks if you could do the school run on Thursday and the first thought is "after the year I've had?" People going through it do need allowances. But a credit note is only good at the shop that issued it, and the people who wronged you aren't around, so it gets presented to your partner, your children, the man on the till, none of whom did it. If you need slack, ask plainly and in advance. "I'm having a bad week. Could you do the school run on Thursday?" Someone can say yes to that, and you can thank them.

Some grievances have nobody at the other end. A colleague your age buys a house with family help you never had, and you think "it's all right for some". Starting points really are unequal. Shai Davidai and Thomas Gilovich found across seven studies that people notice their barriers far more than their advantages. You feel a headwind every second it blows. When it's behind you, you notice for a minute and then just feel you're riding well. Your count of your own luck is probably tilted, and your count of other people's is tilted the other way, because you see their results and not their private troubles. An honest count still won't come out equal. Your start goes in the first pile, probably its biggest item, and the other two piles are where they were. Pick one person you've envied and ask them one question about how they did it.

Over years, a grievance can become how you explain yourself, so that a stranger at dinner knows about the divorce within twenty minutes. Giving that up brings real fears.

  • That it would mean the wrong didn't matter. What happened stays true either way.
  • That you'd lose the explanation. It can stay, for the past. It explains the next five years only if you let it.
  • That you'd lose people. Some friendships run on a shared grievance. Most have plenty else. A few won't, and that's a real loss.
  • That you'd have to try without cover, and be turned down in your own name. That's the true price, set against costs you've paid for years.

The habit usually made sense where it started, in a home or a marriage where you really were powerless. Nobody went back to check whether it still fits. And under a long grievance there's often a loss not yet grieved. The marriage isn't coming back, and the childhood you ought to have had can't be given to you late. If sadness arrives when you stop waiting, I'd take it as a sign the waiting is over.

Two lines and an email

Decide this once, now, so you aren't deciding it afresh in the heat of every new grievance.

Whoever's fault it was, I ask what my next move is, and I make it.

It doesn't say the fault was yours, or ask you to stop feeling wronged. It says your life doesn't wait on them. Take these in order for your first grievance. After that you'll mostly need the second and the fourth.

  • Write the wrong down once, in plain facts, with a date and what it cost you. That's your record.
  • Ask the two questions on separate lines. If the first leaks into the second, "theirs, so they should", start the second line again.
  • Sort it into the three piles. Be strict about what you can't change and generous with the other two.
  • Pick the smallest move and make it within a day. Small means under half an hour and not dependent on anyone's reply.
  • Give every complaint an address. If what you want is sympathy, say so and have it once. Otherwise take it to someone who can act, with a request.
  • Put a date on any waiting. "I'll give them until the 14th, then write to the director" is a plan.
  • Decide what you'd do if the apology never comes, and begin doing it.

Here's Monday's promotion run through it. The record is the job, the date, and the cost, which is a pay rise and a good deal of pride. The fault is the department's. The move is theirs. The decision is final, so it goes in the first pile. The second holds asking the manager for the reasons and what they'd need to show next time. The third holds updating the CV. The smallest move is a two-line email asking for half an hour. The sister gets a shorter version, once. If there's no meeting in two weeks, they ask again in person. Nobody apologises for a promotion decision, so that wait gets dropped.

If your list is long, start where a move is still open and cheap, not with the biggest. Where no move involving the other person is left, the moves are all yours, the record, the grieving, the debt and the friendships that lapsed.

Tie plans to moments, decided in advance.

  • When I start the story with someone who's heard it, I'll say what I'm going to do about it, or change the subject.
  • When I think "they should", I'll ask what I could do.
  • When something unclear stings, I'll write two other explanations before I respond.

If your move means confronting someone who has been violent or threatening towards you, don't do it alone. A domestic abuse service or a solicitor can tell you how to do it safely, or whether to do it at all.

The early moves will feel wrong. Opening the envelope will feel like letting him off. That's the old principle objecting, the one that says whoever broke it should mend it. Let it object.

Some moves won't work. You get a vague answer and an uneasy smile, or the friend is pleasant and distant and doesn't ring back. "See? Nothing works."

One move failed, and it told you about that move and that person. A manager who won't give a straight answer has told you something about your future in that team, and now you could go to the manager's manager or start looking elsewhere. Before you asked, you were in the same job knowing less. A failed move also closes a question, which is sad and frees the attention you were spending on it. Where the walls are real, find allies, or go outside to an ombudsman, a tribunal or your elected representative. Or leave. Leaving is a move, as long as you chose it and stopped waiting.

At some point you'll find you're a fortnight into replaying something and have done nothing. You haven't gone back to the start. Ask the question again, today, and notice what set it off, an anniversary or a fresh wrong that looks like the old one. Don't count days of doing well. A count turns one bad fortnight into a broken record.

See a doctor or a therapist if any of these apply.

  • The event was frightening or violent, and more than a month later you have nightmares or flashbacks, avoid reminders, or feel constantly on edge. These can be signs of post-traumatic stress, and there are talking therapies designed for it that a doctor can refer you to.
  • Your mood has been low most days for more than two weeks, or you've lost interest in things you used to enjoy.
  • You have thoughts of harming yourself. Speak to a doctor or a crisis line today. If you think you might act on them, call the emergency services.
  • You were abused or neglected as a child, which is work better done with a good therapist.
  • You feel wronged in nearly every relationship, you can see it, and nothing you try makes a difference.

If you take prescribed medication, don't stop or change it because of anything here.

Somebody will treat you unfairly in the next few weeks. Plan that first day now. Feel what you feel, tell one person who listens well, write it down with the date, ask the two questions, and make the smallest move before bed.

For today, take the grievance you wrote down at the start and find the smallest move on the page. Open the envelope. Send the two-line email. Ring her. It will probably feel unfair while you do it. It is unfair, and I'd do it anyway.