The same argument again

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 60 min

It's Tuesday, about half past eight. You come into the kitchen and the dishwasher is open, full and clean, and the dirty things from dinner are stacked on the side next to it. You say something small. "You didn't empty it, then." From the sofa, your partner says they were going to. You say that's what they said on Sunday. They say they did it on Sunday, you just didn't notice, and actually they do it more than you do. You say that's not the point. They ask what the point is, then, and now they've got the tone, and so have you.

Four minutes later it isn't about the dishwasher. It's about how you always have to ask and how they can never do anything right, how you were on your own with the children all Saturday and how they work every hour they have. Then one of you says the thing from March, the other says that's typical, and it's over. Nothing is resolved. You're in different rooms, the dishwasher is still full, and some tired part of you knows you've had this exact evening before.

Not a similar one. This one.

Yours may wear something else, the in-laws at Christmas or the phone at dinner. Each time it arrives as a new argument with its own facts, and each time it ends with the same two sentences and the same two people not speaking on the same sofa. I'll call it the one row, and whatever it's about tonight I'll call its costume. The habit I'm interested in is the fresh case, fighting a row you've had fifty times as though it were the first.

The fresh case makes sense from the inside, because tonight's topic is real. I'll argue that it's a costume all the same, and that solving it has never once ended the row. Then there's a way of handling it in about ten minutes. I won't tell you to stop arguing, or that the row will go away, or who's right.

Two cautions. If your rows come with contempt, threats, control or fear, or if one of you isn't free to leave the room or the house, that isn't a habit and none of this applies. The NHS page on domestic abuse lists who to call. The National Domestic Abuse Helpline, run by Refuge, is free and open day and night on 0808 2000 247, and the page gives the lines for men and for LGBT+ people. In an emergency, call 999.

And if the rows sit on top of a low mood in either of you, low most of the day for a fortnight or more, the NHS says that's a conversation for your GP. The rows will be easier once it's been had.

One thing before you go on, on your own for now. Write down the last five rows you can remember with your partner, and for each one the first sentence anyone said and the last. The five first sentences will be five different topics. The last ones, I'd expect, will be about two, and you'll have heard both before.

The stain on the ceiling

Nobody fights the dishwasher row as if it were the first because they've chosen to. That's how it arrives. It arrives as a dishwasher.

And the fresh case pays. A topic made of facts feels winnable. It spares you saying "here we go again" out loud, which would feel like admitting something is wrong with the two of you. And each new instance might be the one where it finally gets said properly and goes in, which, to someone tired, is worth a lot.

So it is about the dishwasher, in the sense that someone should empty it. The belief worth questioning is that the dishwasher is the row, so that answering it would end the row.

Test that on your list. The dishwasher got emptied, eventually. The in-laws came and went. The phone spent a week in a drawer. And the row came back in a fortnight, wearing something else. If the topic were the row, solving it would have ended things at least once in all these years.

Lauren Papp, Mark Cummings and Marcie Goeke-Morey had a hundred married couples keep diaries of every conflict at home for a fortnight. Money rows turned out to be more recurrent than the others and more often left unresolved, and they contained more attempts at problem solving, not fewer. That's what a costume looks like from outside. It attracts solutions and isn't changed by them.

A stain on a ceiling can be painted over. It comes back, because the leak is above it.

Somewhere in you there's also a final version of this row, where you say it clearly enough, your partner hears it properly, and it never comes back. Every instance is another attempt at it, and fails.

Kristen Johnson and Michael Roloff surveyed people in dating relationships about an argument that kept recurring, and asked which mattered more for the relationship, how often it came back or whether the person believed it could be resolved. The belief mattered more. And the things that went with believing it couldn't be resolved made a specific list. Rows that came from expectations being let down. Complaining back when complained at. One partner pushing while the other backed off. Being able to predict when the row would happen. Mulling it over in between. Pulling away from each other afterwards.

I'd guess you can tick most of that. It's a survey, so it can't say what causes what. But it points at something the final version can't see. The weight you carry is the sense that the row is unresolvable and ought to be resolved, and every instance that fails to be the final version adds to it. Your partner has understood you many times, on Tuesdays and on Sundays and once, at length, in a car park. What they can't do is make the row not exist.

Under that sits a quieter belief, that having one row for years means you picked wrong. It's why "here we go again" is so hard to say. It sounds like a confession.

I think it's the wrong way round. One of you wants the kitchen clear before sitting down and the other wants to sit down first. One grew up in a house where family came for four days, the other in a house where nobody came. One handles worry by talking and the other by going quiet. Those aren't disagreements to settle. They're the two of you, and they'll keep producing a row for as long as you share a kitchen. A couple with no recurring row is either very new or not telling you.

Andrew Christensen and colleagues ran a trial with a hundred and thirty-four married couples who'd been seriously distressed for years. Half got a traditional therapy aimed at changing behaviour, and half an integrative version whose distinctive addition, as its designers describe it, is acceptance, helping each partner live with differences that aren't going to change. Both groups improved, seventy-one per cent of the acceptance group and fifty-nine per cent of the other, and five years on about half of each were still clinically improved. Those couples were far worse off than I'm assuming you are. The point is that a whole branch of couple therapy rests on the idea that some differences don't resolve and the work is living with them.

The couples who look easy with each other have a dishwasher too.

Four inches down

Every instance carries the record with it. The thing from March, how it's always you who asks, how they promised last time. It feels like evidence.

Bradbury and Fincham, reviewing research on how married people explain each other's behaviour, found that dissatisfied spouses tended to read their partner's actions in a negative light, and there was evidence those readings helped cause the dissatisfaction. The same full dishwasher can mean "they forgot" or "they don't think it's their job". The record decides which, and the record is made of earlier readings, each taken at the angriest moment by a witness who was upset every time. Some are fair. It's still a file of readings, consulted as if it were facts. And your partner has one too, so when you open yours they open theirs, and there are two files on the table and no dishwasher.

"We've talked about it a hundred times." Papp's money rows had the most problem solving and stayed unsolved. A hundred careful conversations about the dishwasher are a hundred conversations about the stain. They start from the topic, drift within minutes to the last sentences on your list, and stop there, because neither of you has a way of talking there.

If you're the one who raises it, you'll believe nothing changes unless you push. You have some evidence. The dishwasher got emptied on Sunday because you said something on Saturday.

Andrew Christensen and Christopher Heavey watched thirty-one couples discuss a change one partner wanted, then a change the other wanted. Whoever wanted the change pushed, whoever was asked backed off, and the roles swapped when the topic swapped. They called it demand and withdraw. It wasn't a trait of either person. It's what wanting something from someone unsure they want to give it looks like.

So the push is half the row. You push because they've gone quiet, they've gone quiet because you're pushing, and pushing harder only deepens the shape. If you're the pusher you probably have the fairer point on the topic, and the topic still isn't the row. The push is doing two jobs. It asks for a real thing, which a plain request on a calm day gets done more often than a push at half past eight. And it tries to get something underneath heard, which can't be pushed into anyone.

If you're the other one, you've learned that answering back makes it longer. So you go quiet, agree with things you don't agree with, empty the dishwasher, and later get told you went quiet. That's your move in the row. To the pusher it reads as "I don't care", and it brings more push. The instance blows over. The row doesn't. Quiet with a time on it is fine, "I can't do this properly now, can we talk at eight tomorrow", because it says you're still in. Quiet with no time looks like a door closing.

You could probably set a clock by it. Sunday evening, bath time, the drive home from their parents'. Johnson and Roloff found predictability went with hopelessness, but I'd turn that over. An instance goes the way it goes mostly because it starts before anyone has decided anything. If you know it's Sunday at seven, you can have the thought at six.

At some point one of you says, "We need to get to the bottom of it." That assumes the bottom is deep and hidden, reachable only by a long, late dig, which is exactly why you don't do it.

Keith Sanford asked married people, in two studies of about twelve hundred and then twenty-three hundred, to think of a specific row and rate a long list of words for how they'd felt and how they'd seen their partner. Two patterns came out in every group he checked. He called them perceived threat, the feeling that your partner is blaming you and trying to control you, and perceived neglect, the feeling that your partner isn't putting in what they should. Each went with how satisfied people were.

In plainer words, being blamed and being left to it. Two ordinary worries, sitting in the first sentence of the instance in the wrong words. "You didn't empty it, then" is "I feel like I'm doing this on my own", said as a dishwasher. "I do it more than you do" is "I feel like I can't do anything right", said as a dishwasher. The bottom is about four inches down, and it's the same bottom every time.

You may react fast to that. You've always known what's underneath. You're left to it, and they won't admit it.

Sanford measured people one at a time, so this next part is my own reading. In most recurring rows I think the two of you are in different worries. The pusher usually feels left to it and the quiet one usually feels blamed, and each worry is produced by the other's behaviour. When you say "you leave me to do everything", they hear blame and defend, and their defending sounds to you like being left on your own with it. Each of you is right about your own underneath and wrong about the row, because the row has two.

Now the cost, which was never the four minutes the dishwasher takes.

  • The evening, every time, and it was the only time you had together.
  • The days between, spent going over it, which writes new entries in the record.
  • The sense that you're stuck. After fifty unresolved cases the conclusion is "we can't sort things out", and it spreads well beyond the kitchen.

And it trains the row. Two people who've walked the same line across a lawn a hundred times don't decide to walk it again. Their feet know it. After enough fresh cases an instance can run from the first sentence to March in under two minutes, with nobody deciding anything. That speed feels deep-rooted. It's only practised, which means a new first step can be practised too.

A name and two sentences

You may not want to say any of this out loud. "This is the same row" can sound dismissive. A named row sounds like a diagnosis. And you might fear that watching for it will bring it on.

Eli Finkel and colleagues followed a hundred and twenty married couples for two years. In the first year everyone's marital quality declined. In the second year, half the couples were asked three times to spend seven minutes writing about their latest big disagreement from the point of view of a neutral outsider who wanted the best for both of them. Twenty-one minutes in all. Those couples stopped declining, and what carried the effect was how distressing they found their conflicts. They didn't argue less. They minded less.

A name does something like that in a word. When you can say "it's the on-my-own row again", you've stepped to the side of the instance, and you can't be fully inside a row you've just named. What brings it on is the unwatched days, when the underneath builds and the record gets consulted.

The other fear is that a named row becomes a project with a chart on the fridge. Nickola Overall and James McNulty, reviewing when it helps to push for change in a relationship, found it helps when the problem is serious and the partner can actually change it, and does harm when the problem is minor or the partner can't. So after naming comes sorting. Some of the one row can change. Whoever's up first empties the dishwasher, the phone goes in a drawer at dinner, and agreed on a calm day those mostly happen. Some can't, because it's the two of you. One of you will want the kitchen clear before sitting down in twenty years' time. That part gets lived with.

Now the method. Two parts happen once, on a calm day. The third happens every time.

First, find the row and name it. On your list, the first sentences were costumes. Among the last ones you'll probably find a left-to-it sentence, "it's always me", and a blamed one, "I can't win". Those two are the row. Give it a name that's plain, short and neither clever nor an accusation. "The on-my-own row" is a name. "The row about you never helping" is one side's underneath dressed up as a title. Some couples call it after the first costume it wore, "the dishwasher", said with a slight smile. If one of you winces at the name, it's the wrong one.

Do this on a Sunday afternoon or a walk, never during an instance or the evening after one. Say beforehand that you want ten minutes about the row you keep having, not the last instance of it, and that you won't mention the dishwasher. If it starts sliding into an instance, one of you says "this is turning into the row" and you try another day. That shows you where the row's first step is.

Then each of you says which worry you carry, which takes some nerve. "When it starts, I feel I'm on my own with this." "When it starts, I feel I'm being told I'm useless." It may be the first time you've heard the row from their side.

Second, agree what it's about, in two sentences, one each, in the form "when this happens, I feel this". "When the kitchen's left and I'm the one who notices, I feel like I'm on my own here." "When I'm told about the kitchen the moment I sit down, I feel like nothing I do counts." The other doesn't answer it. They say "all right", or say it back, and the first says "yes". Both are true at once. You'll feel a pull to decide which is the real underneath and which only a reaction. Don't. The row is what happens when the two worries meet over a dishwasher.

It's worth adding a sentence you already know. "We've had this for six years and we're still here."

Write the name and the two sentences down once, on a card or a phone. A row that fits in two sentences is smaller than one that lives in the record.

Then it's Tuesday and the dishwasher's full, and the third part takes ten minutes.

Whoever notices first says the name. "This is the dishwasher." Flat, as a fact about the room, with none of the edge of "here we go again". Four minutes in still works, as long as the record hasn't opened.

Answer tonight's costume as the small, literal thing it is. Someone empties it, or you agree who will in the morning. For the in-laws, which dates and how many nights. For the phone, the drawer.

Then one sentence each, about tonight. "I felt on my own when I saw it." "I felt got at when you said it." The other says "I know". No "but", no "you always", no March. This is where the ten minutes go, and it's what fifty fresh cases never managed.

Leave the record shut. If you catch yourself reaching for Sunday, say "that's the record, I'm not opening it". If your partner opens theirs, don't answer the entry. Say the name again.

Then stop, in the same room if you can. You're still two different people, and next month there'll be another costume. But nothing's been added to the record, and the evening is still there.

The decision, made by both of you, fits in one sentence. When the one row turns up in a new costume, we say its name, deal with tonight's costume, and leave the record shut.

Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran reviewed ninety-four studies of plans made in the form "when this happens, I'll do that", and people who plan that way follow through much more often than people who only intend to. So each of you writes three. When I notice the row starting, I'll say its name before anything about the topic. When my partner opens the record, I'll say "that's the record" and give my one sentence instead of answering. When the ten minutes are done, I'll stay in the room.

What to expect is only my guess. The first time, one of you will say the name and the other will say "don't do that", and you'll have a short row about the name, which is the row in a new costume, and you can say so. Around the fifth time the name will come on its own, from whichever of you is less tired, the whole thing will take eight minutes, and you'll feel slightly cheated that it was that simple.

Thursday, the old way

Real life won't always offer two people and a calm day.

If only one of you will read this, you can still do most of it. Name the row for yourself, work out your worry, and take a fair guess at your partner's. At the next instance say the name anyway, "I think this is our on-my-own row again", answer the costume, say your sentence, and keep your own record shut. You can't shut theirs. An instance where one person won't open the record is much shorter, and after a few your partner may stop hearing the name as a trick.

If the costume is the children, you may believe they don't notice because you keep it down. Mark Cummings, Marcie Goeke-Morey and Lauren Papp had parents in a hundred and sixteen families, with children aged eight to sixteen, keep diaries of conflicts and how the children reacted. The children were reacting to how the row was done. Threats, insults, hostility, defensiveness and a parent walking off distressed them. Calm discussion, support and affection made them feel more secure. The ten-minute version, with you both in the same room afterwards, is on the secure list. If you can, agree the costume answer away from them, and let them see the ending.

The in-law row doubles the blamed worry, because one of you is also defending your family. Name it as the in-law row, answer the costume in dates and nights, and keep your sentence about the two of you. Once it's about your mother-in-law, there's a third person in the row who isn't in the room.

If money is the costume, keep it strictly apart. The budget is real and needs a calm-day conversation with numbers in it. The row underneath isn't a money question, and no budget will settle it.

If you're the quiet one, your sentence is the thing to practise, because it's what you've been leaving out. "I felt got at" isn't agreement. It's the position you've been holding silently, said once, out loud.

If it's been worse since the baby, you may be waiting for things to calm down. Brian Doss and colleagues followed two hundred and eighteen couples through their first eight years of marriage. Those who had a first child showed a sudden drop in how well the relationship worked, small to medium in size, and it tended to last for the rest of the study. Circumstances change the costume and how often it comes, and the row travels from house to house, so it's worth handling now, with the baby monitor on the side. The calm day will be a calm twenty minutes you have to arrange. Most costumes will be about who's more tired, which has no answer, so the costume answer is "we're both wrecked" and the underneath gets the sentences. If either of you has been low most of the day for a fortnight or more since the birth, the NHS says to see your GP, and NHS talking therapies take self-referrals for postnatal depression. Work on that before the row.

If you can't get through the calm-day conversation without it becoming an instance, a third person would help, and counselling isn't a last resort. The NHS says counselling can help with relationship problems, but it only offers counselling itself for certain conditions, such as depression, so you'll usually be looking at a charity or paying. If you pay, the NHS says to check the counsellor is on a register accredited by the Professional Standards Authority, and names the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy as one. Some employers offer a few free sessions.

And if it's more than a row, none of this applies. Contempt, fear, one of you controlling the money or the phone or who the other sees, one of you unable to leave. Call 999 in an emergency, and tell someone, including your GP. The National Domestic Abuse Helpline, run by Refuge, is on 0808 2000 247, free, day and night. The Respect Men's Advice Line is on 0808 8010 327. Galop, on 0800 999 5428, is for LGBT+ people. If you've tried this in good faith and your partner uses the name against you, or the instances are getting worse, James McNulty's study of seventy-two new marriages is worth knowing. Being forgiving kept people satisfied when their partner rarely behaved badly, and went with steeper declines when their partner behaved badly often. Handling an instance well is for a partner who's also trying.

Then there'll be the Thursday. You're both tired, the costume is one you didn't recognise, and by the time anyone thought of the name you were four minutes in with March on the table. It ran the old way and ended in different rooms, and afterwards comes the thought that the name didn't work, or that the row is just what you are.

The name wasn't said. That's all that happened. Phillippa Lally and colleagues, following people forming a new daily habit, found that a missed day didn't materially set it back, and I think a missed instance is the same. Four good instances aren't undone by a fifth. The path's still there. Of course it is.

The next morning, one sentence. "That was the dishwasher last night, and I didn't see it in time." That puts the instance back in the row, and tells your partner the method's still on. If they use it to reopen things, say the name again and leave it.

Then ask what caught you. Usually the costume looked new, so add it to the list of things the row wears.

Don't count lapses. Judge by the days between. If Wednesday isn't spent going over Tuesday, it's working, whatever Thursday did.

A Tuesday, some weeks from now. The dishwasher is full and clean and the dinner things are on the side, and you feel the old sentence coming. You say to the sofa, "Dishwasher's clean and I can feel the row coming." Your partner says, "Oh, that one," and gets up, and you empty it together, which takes four minutes. Somewhere in the middle you say you felt on your own with it when you walked in, and they say they know, they were going to and then sat down and felt like they were about to be told off. You say, "Yeah." The kettle goes on.

In March there'll be a costume neither of you has seen yet.

On a calm day this week, tell your partner you'd like ten minutes to talk about the row you keep having, not the last instance of it. Find it on your list, and give it a name.