The treat that became the habit

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 59 min

It's ten to six. You're in, or nearly in, and there's a small pull towards a cupboard that has nothing to do with hunger. The day is done, or done enough, and the thing that says so is a glass. You pour it. The first mouthful is good. The second is fine. By the third you're not really tasting it, you're holding it, and the evening has begun.

You'd have poured it if the day had been dreadful. You'd have poured it if it had been the best in a month. You poured it yesterday and you'll pour it tomorrow, and if anyone asked you'd say you'd earned it, and you'd mean it.

For you it may be a bar of chocolate once the children are finally down, eaten standing at the counter in about ninety seconds while looking at your phone. Or an order placed on a Tuesday that went badly, for something you'll have forgotten by the time it arrives. Or the next episode, or the scroll in bed, or the takeaway that was Friday's and is now Thursday's as well. The thing changes and the shape doesn't. It arrives at the same hour, in the same form, with the same sentence. I've earned it. I deserve this. I need this.

The daily treat makes sense from the inside. The day was long, there was nothing in it that was for you, and here's something that is. But a reward given every day regardless of the day stops being a reward. It turns into a routine, and a routine can't do what a reward does. Most of what it gives you now is the relief of its arriving, and "I've earned it" gets found after the decision, which is why it's said every day and has never once turned you down. There are two ways out, and neither of them means giving up the treat.

I'm not against pleasure, and I won't tell you to give up wine or chocolate or television, or to feel bad about any of them. I'm writing about the daily, the one that comes at the same hour whether you earned it or not.

Three cautions, and they matter here more than usual.

If your treat is alcohol and it's every day, don't change anything until you've read the part about wine near the end. The NHS says someone who has become physically dependent on alcohol can come to harm by stopping overnight, and should get advice from a GP about cutting down and whether medicine is needed. If a day without it makes you anxious, or you've noticed shaking or sweating in the morning, see a GP first.

If your treat is food and eating feels out of your control, or you eat and then try to undo it, or you spend much of the day thinking about your weight and shape, this isn't the help you need. The NHS says to see a GP as soon as you can, and the charity Beat has a helpline.

And if the treat is the only good thing in your day because nothing has felt good for weeks, most of the day, most days, the NHS says to see a GP. An empty fortnight is something different from an empty evening.

If your treat is a cigarette or the vape, nicotine brings a withdrawal of its own, and that needs its own handling before anything here.

One thing before you go on, and give it a fortnight. Each day, write down the treat, and next to it one letter. C if you chose it, meaning that before the hour you'd decided today would have one and could say why. A if it arrived, meaning the hour came and the treat came with it and you can't remember deciding. Be honest about the A's. They aren't a fault, and you'll need them later.

Same glass either way

Nobody sets out to have a glass of wine every night of the year. It starts as an occasional thing on a hard day. Then hard days are most days, and then the glass is there on the easy ones too, because six o'clock has learned to expect it.

It gives you plenty. A line under the day. A pleasure, and the first mouthful of a cold glass is good, I won't pretend otherwise. Something for you in a day that was mostly for other people. A shape to an evening that would otherwise be a shapeless stretch before bed. And the earning, the feeling of having been paid, which on some days is the only pay you get.

Start with the earning, because it's the most convincing part. It's even true. You did work, and something at the end of a day is a reasonable thing to want. The trouble is when the sentence arrives.

Cat Taylor, Thomas Webb and Paschal Sheeran at Sheffield collected the reasons people give for eating something they'd meant not to, and deserving it came first. Ran Kivetz and Yuhuang Zheng found that when they raised the effort a task took, or told people falsely that they'd done excellently, more of them picked the indulgent reward over the sensible one. The effect was larger in people who felt more guilty about indulging. Researchers call the wider pattern moral licensing, and when Irene Blanken and colleagues pooled 91 studies of it they found a real but modest effect. A tendency, then. It's the tendency the earning runs on.

Here's my reading of it. A verdict on the day would sometimes come back no, and a judge who has never once turned down an application isn't really judging. "I've earned it" gets said on the day the report went in and on the day you watched the clock, in the same words and with the same confidence. It licenses the glass, whatever the day was, and it gets said after the hand has started moving.

Then there's the word reward. A reward marks. It says this day, or this effort, was different from the others, and here's the sign. A prize handed to everyone for turning up is a place setting, and a treat at six every day can't tell the days apart. Wendy Wood and Dennis Rünger, reviewing the psychology of habit, note that people tend to infer from how often they do something that they must have meant to. The habit produces the doing, and the doing gets read backwards as a choice.

Think of a bell that rings every hour. After a week you don't hear it. If it rang once on a Tuesday afternoon you'd stop and look up.

There's a simple test for which kind of bell you've got. Wood, with Jeffrey Quinn and Deborah Kashy, had people report every hour on what they were doing and thinking. During habits, the almost-daily things done in the same setting, their thoughts were usually elsewhere. During things done less often, their thoughts were on the thing. So where's your mind at six? If it's on the glass and the taste of it, it's still a reward. If it's on the phone or tomorrow or nothing much, and the glass is just what your hand does at six, it's a routine.

"But it's the best bit of my day." It may be, and I won't call that nothing. I'd only ask how much of the best bit is the treat and how much is the looking forward. Jeff Galak and Joseph Redden, reviewing what happens when people repeat the same pleasant thing, describe the usual result, which is that enjoyment typically falls. Part of what wears it down is knowing you had it yesterday and will have it again tomorrow. The glass on day three hundred can't taste like the glass on day one. The wine didn't change. You did.

What hasn't worn down is the wanting. From about four o'clock the treat comes into view, and the day starts to lean towards six. Things get done a little faster, or not at all, because six is the point. Then six comes, the treat arrives, the leaning stops, and the stopping feels like pleasure. It would feel the same whatever was at the end, as long as it was what you'd been expecting.

David Neal, Wendy Wood and colleagues gave cinema-goers popcorn that was either fresh or a week old. People with a strong cinema-popcorn habit ate as much of the stale as the fresh, and their hunger and how much they liked it made little difference. In a meeting room, with the same popcorn, the same people ate by taste like everyone else. The cue was the cinema. Liking had left the building.

Your cue is six o'clock, and six o'clock doesn't ask whether you fancy it tonight. It's a parcel you've waited for all afternoon, better as a parcel than as whatever's inside.

Only small

The daily has an answer for everything. These are its best ones.

"It's only small." It is. One glass, one bar, two taps on an app. Small is why it can be daily, because something large would get noticed. Since wine is the commonest version, here's the count once, using the NHS formula of strength times millilitres divided by a thousand. A medium 175 millilitre glass at thirteen per cent comes to about 2.3 units. Seven of those is about sixteen a week. The NHS advises no more than fourteen a week on a regular basis, spread over three or more days, with drink-free days if you want to cut down. So one small glass a night is over the line on its own, before the weekend. That's a count, not a lecture. Small also means it never has to be justified, and it can be topped up without the sum ever looking big.

"I'd be miserable without it." You'd be flat for a while, and I'd rather say so. Jordi Quoidbach and Elizabeth Dunn had people eat a piece of chocolate and then sent them off for a week. Some were told to give chocolate up, some to eat as much as they could, and some were told nothing. A week later the ones who'd given it up savoured the next piece most and reported better mood afterwards, and the ones who'd eaten as much as they could enjoyed it least. One week and one chocolate is a small finding. It has the right shape, though. Going without didn't make the treat worse. It made it better.

The flat evening is the expecting with nothing at the end of it. The day leaned towards six, and at six the lean has nowhere to go. It's the discomfort of an unanswered message, and it fades, because it was learned. The first blank evening is flat. The fourth one is an evening.

"It's how I cope." This deserves more respect than the others, because it's often true. Tanja Adam and Elissa Epel have proposed a model, built largely on animal work, in which pleasant food eaten under stress damps down the body's stress response. Take that at face value and it says the treat does something to you. It says nothing about the treat doing anything to the stress. The glass copes with the day and leaves the day alone, so the day comes back tomorrow the same shape and gets the same glass.

I think of the daily as a lid. It goes on at six and keeps the day in. On a day with a real deadline or a real worry under it, a lid is fair enough, and you can still choose it. On a day with nothing much under it, the lid goes on anyway, because that's what the hour does.

"A bad day needs one." Yes. A bad day should end with something that recognises it was bad. But look at the week. Monday was ordinary and got a glass. Tuesday was the worst day in a month and got a glass. Wednesday was fine and got a glass. The bad day got nothing extra, because what was meant for hard days had been spent on easy ones. So on the bad day you either have the usual, which marks nothing, or you have more, a second glass, three episodes, and excess becomes your marker for a hard day. The daily can't scale. And if it's alcohol, going past the level on the hard days is exactly the pattern worth watching.

"Taking it away would be punishing myself." Kivetz, this time with Itamar Simonson, found that when a reward took more effort to earn, people leaned from the useful option towards the luxury, and their explanation was that effort reduces the guilt of choosing a luxury. So the treat was a pleasure with a debt on it all along, and the earning pays the debt off every evening. As for punishment, most people you know don't have a glass on most Tuesdays, and nobody is punishing them. Going without only feels like a deduction because the daily has become the default. If you skip it to be hard on yourself, because you've decided you're weak or greedy, then it really is punishment, and it won't last. A blank day is a look at the evening, and you're allowed the treat the next day.

The guilt does more than you'd think. Kelly Goldsmith, Eunice Kim Cho and Ravi Dhar found that switching guilt on made a pleasant thing more pleasant, and other bad feelings didn't do the same. The word "naughty" is on the label of every pudding in the shop for a reason. Guilt is part of the flavour. My guess is that it props the daily up from the other end as well. Last night's treat leaves a small bad feeling at bedtime, and at six tomorrow there's a thing that's good at quietening bad feelings.

"It sets me up for tomorrow." The idea is fuel, that the day empties a tank and the treat refills it. There was a theory behind that, called ego depletion, which held that self-control runs down with use and needs restoring. In 2016 Martin Hagger and a large group of colleagues repeated the standard experiment in 23 laboratories with over two thousand people, and the effect was so small its range included zero. That doesn't settle every version of the idea, but the tank the glass refills has less behind it than it seemed to. What sets you up for tomorrow is dull. Sleep, food at a sensible hour, a stop to the working day you can feel. The daily tends to get in the way of all three.

What the daily eats

The report goes in. The difficult conversation gets had. The month you've been dreading ends. And there's nothing to mark it with, because the thing you'd use is what you had on Tuesday.

That's the first cost, and you only feel it when you need it. The daily has spent your currency at the rate of one a day.

The second is the hour. Six o'clock belongs to the glass, so you don't go for a walk at six, or ring someone, or start anything, and by half past the evening has taken the shape the glass gives it, which is sitting down. The afternoon goes too, leaning towards six. Money and health are real costs and you've heard about them already, which tells you they aren't where the daily lives.

The cost I'd put first is that it stops you looking at the day. Every evening ends the same way, so no evening asks what kind of day it was. An empty day ends like a full one.

And many days are empty, in the plain sense. Up, out, work or the children or both, back, and then the hour. Nothing in between that was chosen or for you, nothing you'd mention if someone asked. That's how a lot of adult days go, and it's no failing. But it means a glass of wine is being asked to be all the good in a day, and it's too small for the job, which is why it gets repeated and topped up. It sits on the empty day like a lid and works well enough that you never have to notice what's underneath.

The NHS lists five things the evidence suggests help mental wellbeing. Connect with other people, be physically active, learn new skills, give to others, and pay attention to the present moment. None is a treat, and all five put something into the day instead of at the end of it. A day with a walk or a call or twenty minutes at something you're learning doesn't need the treat to be the good bit, because it already had one.

Last, the daily eats the treat itself. Leif Nelson and Tom Meyvis found across six studies that breaks made pleasant experiences, music and a massage chair among them, more enjoyable, because the breaks interrupted the wearing-down. People avoided the breaks anyway, since a break in a nice thing feels like a loss. Kennon Sheldon and Sonja Lyubomirsky, following 481 students for three months after a good change in their lives, found the good feeling lasted longer for those who kept appreciating it and kept getting variety out of it. The daily has neither. It's the same glass every day, and the wearing-down has had a year to work.

So here's my claim, and it's mine, not theirs. Three treats a month are better than thirty, and better each time. The Friday glass after a dry week is a different drink from the Friday glass after six others. Same bottle, different evening.

Thursday's glass

Get the fortnight's record out. If you didn't keep it, start now and come back in two weeks, because guessing won't do.

For each day, ask three things, and be strict. Did I decide before the hour that today would have one? Could I say why in a sentence I'd say to another adult without it sounding like an excuse? Did I notice it while I was having it? Three yeses is a C. Anything less is an A. Most people find a fortnight of A's with one or two C's, and the C's are usually a Friday, or a day that had something in it. Study those, because they show you what a chosen treat looks like for you. And look out for the day you wrote a C in the morning, didn't fancy it by six, and had it anyway. That's the hour running without you, and it's the most useful entry you've got.

Then pick one of two ways out.

The first is to keep the treat and drop the earning. You like a glass at six, so have one. But stop saying you've earned it, because you haven't checked and you'd say it either way. Say "I'm having a glass because I like one", and let that be the whole reason. Two things tend to follow. The treat gets a little less nice, because the guilt went with the licence. And you start noticing evenings when you don't actually want it, because there's no sentence telling you that you do. On those evenings you don't have it, and over a month or two the daily thins out without a rule.

The second is to keep the earning and make the treat rare. The earning has to pass the three questions, and if it can't, there's no treat that day. It's stricter, there are more blank days, and the marker comes back faster.

If your record had some C's and you can see what made them, take the second. If it was all A's and the thought of a rule makes you want the glass right now, take the first, which is gentler and lets the hour follow. If it's alcohol and the count came out well over, take the second, and read the cautions below before you start.

Either way you'll have blank days, and the first one decides whether the rest happen. Pick an ordinary Tuesday or Wednesday, decided the day before, not a bad day and not a Friday. Fill the hour with something that uses it. A walk, the call you've been meaning to make, cooking instead of ordering, twenty minutes of something you're learning. A different drink in the same glass doesn't count, and neither does the phone in place of the episode.

Somewhere between six and eight the evening will go hollow, and you'll hear "I could just have one", and it'll sound like reason. Let the evening be flat. It's showing you how much the lid was covering, and it usually passes before bed. Don't count blank days, because a streak is a thing you break. Then do another. The second is easier, and after three or four the hour stops expecting.

When you do have a treat, make it a proper one.

  • Chosen ahead, in the morning or the day before, so the looking forward is honest.
  • For a reason with a fact in it. The report went in. It's someone's birthday. I fancy one and haven't had one since Sunday. Liking a thing counts.
  • Rare enough to mark something. Two or three times a week at most, and once is better.
  • Noticed. The glass without the phone. The bar sitting down, not at the counter. If it isn't worth ten minutes of your attention, it isn't a treat.

The rule under all this is short. Nothing daily gets called a treat. You can keep a routine as a routine if you want to. If you want the word, the thing has to be rare and chosen.

Plans of the form "when this happens, I'll do that" are well supported by research on planning, so write three.

When it's six o'clock and my hand goes to the treat, I ask whether I decided this morning, and if I didn't, I do the hour's other thing and the treat can be tomorrow, chosen.

When I hear myself say "I've earned it", I say what I actually did today in one sentence, and if it's a reason I have the treat, and if it's just a day I don't.

When the evening goes flat, I let it, and I don't fill it with a substitute.

What I'd expect, and it's my expectation and not a finding, is three or four flat evenings in the first week, and one or two treats better than any you've had this year. Phillippa Lally and colleagues found that a daily behaviour in a fixed setting became automatic over weeks, and I'd guess unlearning runs on something like the same clock. Somewhere in the second month, six o'clock is just six o'clock.

Some cases need more care.

  • Wine, or whatever the glass is. If your count was well over fourteen units, the NHS advice is to cut down, spread drinking over three or more days and have drink-free days, which is the blank day. But if you're physically dependent, if a day without makes you anxious or you get sweating, shaking or nausea in the morning, the NHS says stopping overnight could be harmful and to get a GP's advice on how to cut down and whether you need medicine. That comes before any blank day. The NHS alcohol support page names a free national helpline, Drinkline, and local services.
  • The cigarette or the vape. The relief is largely the relief of a need the last one created, so a blank day is withdrawal, and it needs its own plan.
  • Food. If eating feels out of control or you undo it afterwards, that's the NHS eating disorders page and Beat, not a method.
  • The only hour alone. If the glass after the children are down is the only time that's yours, keep the hour. Sit in the quiet without the glass a few times and find out which part you were protecting.
  • The bag from the shop. If your partner brings it in, ask them not to bring yours on your blank days, and to have theirs if they like.
  • The children's treat. The ice cream after tea is theirs. Leave it alone and work on the glass beside it.
  • A treat that's genuinely harmless, a square of chocolate, good coffee at four. Keep it and drop the earning. If you don't need the word back, there's nothing to change.
  • A daily that replaced a bigger habit you gave up. If blanking it brings the old habit back into view, leave the new one alone.
  • Bleak. If the blank days weren't flat but heavy, and the heaviness was there before six and on treat days too, for a fortnight or more, the NHS describes that as something to take to a GP. Wait until you've had that conversation.

One Tuesday the glass will be in your hand at six before the question got asked, and you'll have a second, and on Wednesday you'll think you're back where you started. You aren't. Lally found that a missed day didn't do much to a habit being formed, and I'd extend that to one evening. It's the run of evenings that trains the hour, and you've already broken the run. Work out which belief it was. Maybe a bad day. Maybe an empty one, in which case the fix is tomorrow's afternoon. Maybe just the hour, because you hadn't decided anything that morning. Don't make tomorrow a blank day as penance. Say what happened in a sentence with a fact in it. I had two glasses because the hour reached and I let it. If one evening becomes a week, start the record again.

A few weeks on, it's ten to six on a Tuesday. Your hand knows where the cupboard is for a moment, and then the moment passes, because this morning you didn't decide on a treat, so there isn't one. You put the pan on, or ring your sister. Around seven there's a flat ten minutes, shorter than last week's.

Thursday you decided on Wednesday night, because Thursday is when the thing you've been dreading at work gets done. At six you pour the glass, sit down with it, and leave the phone in the other room. It's cold and good and you taste all of it, because it's the first since Sunday and it's Thursday's glass, not the hour's.

Tonight, whatever the hour brings, ask whether you decided this morning. If you didn't, do the hour's other thing, and let tomorrow morning decide tomorrow.