They meant well, probably

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 43 min

You sent a message on Tuesday. Nothing much, a question about a plan, or a link you thought they'd like. It's Thursday now. The two blue ticks turned up on Tuesday evening, so they've read it, and nothing has come back.

By Thursday afternoon you've decided a few things. That they're not that bothered about you. That they'd have answered anyone else. That the friendship has been running on your effort for a while, and this is what it looks like when you stop pushing.

Or it's the meeting, where you were three sentences into a point when a colleague came in over the top of you and the conversation moved on without you. Or the brother who forgot your birthday, the first time in years. Or the email from your manager. "Please send the figures by Friday." No greeting, no thanks. Or the car at the roundabout.

Each one produced a sentence about why. They're ignoring me. They don't rate me. They did it on purpose. The sentence arrived fast, it felt like knowing something, and it's usually wrong.

I'll call the clumsy act the slip, and the motive you pin on it the charge. This is about the charge. I'm not going to ask you to think well of everyone, because some people do mean it, and I'll come to them. I'm asking you to stop deciding before you've looked. The method is small. Before you settle on a motive that needs malice, name three that don't. If the slip matters, ask one plain question. And when you object, object to what they did and leave out what you've decided they meant.

Before you go on, think of the last slip that stung and write down the charge in one sentence, in the words you used in your head. Then write down whether you've checked it. Whether you've asked, I mean, which is a different thing from whether you're sure. Most people find they've never asked about any of them. All the certainty came from the sentence.

Two cautions. If the person whose motives you're reading belittles you, controls your money, keeps you from friends or family, checks where you are, or frightens you, the charitable reading here is the wrong tool, and near the end I say where to go instead. And if you distrust most people most of the time, if the suspicion is there before anyone has done anything and it's making you miserable or costing you relationships, that's worth talking to a GP about. It can be part of anxiety or low mood, and there's help for both.

The only complete sentence in the room

The charge doesn't feel like a guess. It feels like seeing clearly.

And it gives you things, which is why it lasts. It's fast, for a start. You can't investigate every interruption, and a motive is a summary that lets you move on. It feels protective, because if you decide they meant it, you can't be caught out later finding that they meant it. Wrong in the suspicious direction costs you an evening. Wrong in the trusting direction makes you a fool. Now and then it's right, too. Some interruptions are power and some silences are a decision, and I'd be wasting your time if I pretended otherwise.

The last thing it gives is harder to admit. The charge makes you the one who was wronged, and the wronged party knows where they stand. The other possibility, that they didn't think about you at all and your message is sitting under forty others, gives you nowhere to stand. You're just someone whose message hasn't been answered. I think a fair amount of charging is a way of avoiding that.

Two psychologists, Daniel Gilbert and Patrick Malone, reviewed thirty years of research on this in 1995 and called it the correspondence bias. It's the tendency to read someone's lasting character into behaviour that the situation fully explains. Somebody is rude in a queue and you conclude they're a rude person, when they may just have had a morning. It's one of the most reliable findings in social psychology, and they describe several ways it happens. The one that matters most here is the last. You do start to correct for the situation, and you stop early, because correcting takes effort and the first answer was already there.

So the charge is the start of a thought, cut short. Your mind produces "they don't rate me", begins to allow for the fact that they're in the middle of a house move, and gives up halfway. The charge is finished and the correction isn't, which is why the charge feels like a conclusion. It's the only complete sentence in the room.

Underneath it sits a comparison you don't notice making. I'd never leave someone hanging like that.

Look at your own week, then. There's a message you haven't answered, and one you answered a week late with "sorry, this got buried". There's an email you sent with no greeting because you were writing four at once. You interrupted someone, probably today, and it didn't register, because from the inside interrupting feels like joining in. There was a birthday you remembered at nine in the evening. What did those mean? That you were busy, tired, and thinking about something else. They meant nothing about the other person at all.

Bertram Malle went through 173 published studies in 2006 on the old idea that people explain their own behaviour by circumstances and everyone else's by character. Across everything, the gap barely existed. It did hold for negative events, though. When something bad has happened, people put their own version down to the situation and the other person's down to the person. So the lean turns up exactly when someone has done something you didn't like, which is when the charge gets made. Your own week is the best evidence you have about what slips mean, and it says busy.

Written slips are the worst, because they arrive with no face and no voice and you supply both. "Please send the figures by Friday." In a flat voice it's an instruction. In a cold voice it's a rebuke. Read it as the fortieth email of someone's day and it's a person typing as fast as they can.

Justin Kruger, Nicholas Epley and their colleagues ran five experiments in 2005 on how well tone survives email. Senders were confident their sarcasm or humour or seriousness would come across, and it came across much less often than they thought. They heard their own message in the tone they meant and assumed the reader would too. So the manager who wrote that email heard it as brisk and ordinary, and has no idea it's being read as cold. You've sent that email as well, dozens of times, and some of them landed in ways that would startle you.

My own view is that tone in writing gets assigned at the reader's end, and a reader who's already made a charge assigns the tone that fits it. Here's the test. Read it once in the most boring voice you can manage. If it still stings, it might mean something. If it doesn't, it didn't.

Then the message with no reply, the slip people carry longest. Replying takes ten seconds, they've had two days, so the ten seconds weren't worth spending on you. It's tidy reasoning, and here's what it leaves out. They read it on their phone in a shop, meaning to reply properly at home. At home there was a child and a meal and a call from their mother. By the time they thought of it again it was a day old, so now the reply needs an apology, and the apology needs a reason, and the reason is that they forgot, which is embarrassing enough to need another day. The ten seconds have to happen at a moment when they remember, have the phone, aren't in the middle of something and know what to say. Two days of silence is far more likely to be two days of not being reminded.

You know this already. There's a message like that on your own phone right now, from someone you like.

A file that fills itself

"But it's a pattern with them." Sometimes it is. One interruption is a slip. Ten from the same colleague, always when you're speaking and never when the director is, is something else. I'm not asking you to go blind. I'm asking you to know what a pattern looks like.

It needs the same act, from the same person, more than once, with the situation varied. The charge skips that last part. If the Monday meeting is twenty minutes for an hour's agenda and everyone talks over everyone, you have a pattern about the meeting. If a friend has been quiet for the two months since their father got ill, you have a pattern about their father.

Patterns also get built by the charge itself. Benjamin Karney and Thomas Bradbury followed newlywed couples across eight waves of data and found no sign that people have a fixed way of explaining their partner's behaviour. The explanations moved with how happy people were. As spouses grew less satisfied they explained the same acts less generously, and the harsher explanations went on to predict falling satisfaction. Once you've decided a colleague is dismissive, every short reply goes in the dismissive file, and the thickness of the file starts to feel like evidence. Mostly it's filing.

So before you call it a pattern, list the instances you can actually name, with dates, and write the situation next to each. Then look for one the situation doesn't explain. If there are none, you haven't got a pattern. If there are three, you might, and then you ask. You still don't conclude.

The next belief goes deeper. Being suspicious keeps me safe, and people who take things at face value get used.

The research isn't kind to it. Reading hostile intent into ambiguous behaviour is called hostile attribution bias, and a 2019 review of 25 studies by Klein Tuente, Bogaerts and Veling found that in adults it goes with more aggression, small to medium links, in samples ranging from students to psychiatric patients. The studies were mostly snapshots, so they can't say which causes which. Nobody in them came out looking safer.

Picture how it plays. You decide the colleague talked over you on purpose, so in the next meeting you're clipped with them and you don't back their idea. They never knew they'd interrupted you. From where they sit, you've gone cold for no reason, so they get wary, and their next slip has a real edge to it. Your charge has come true, and you take that as proof. You made the evidence yourself.

The danger you were watching for, the one person who does mean you harm, is found by watching what someone does over time in situations that don't excuse it. Suspecting everyone is noise, and noise hides the one signal you wanted.

"I'm just being realistic" has a quieter flaw. You never find out when you were wrong. You charged the friend with not caring, you cooled, the friendship faded, and the fade looked like confirmation. You charged the manager with coldness, and they left for another job, and you never learned they'd thought you were one of the good ones. The hits get remembered because something happened. The misses vanish because nothing did. A sense of your own accuracy built only from hits is a filing system that throws away the misses.

Then there's the softer charge. They didn't mean it, but they should have known. A thoughtful person would have remembered.

That's the same verdict in a more reasonable coat, and it assumes people can tell how their acts land, which mostly they can't. The colleague didn't experience talking over you. They experienced saying their thing. If the act needs avoiding next time, tell them, once. People who don't know can be told. People who've been silently judged thoughtless can't do anything at all.

The fear that keeps all of this going is that if you stop charging, you'll become a doormat. The interrupter will keep interrupting and you'll smile and take it.

That mixes up two things, the motive and the act, and you can object to the act without deciding the motive. Say "you talked over me because you don't take me seriously" and you'll get "that's not true", and now you're arguing about their character while the interruption quietly drops out of the conversation. Say "I hadn't finished, can I pick that up?" and there's nothing to argue with. Someone who's stopped charging says "hang on, I'll finish this" on the day, every time, without heat. That person is far harder to walk over than the one seething in silence. The habit usually delivers the charge and skips the objection, so it ends up producing the very doormat it was afraid of.

Last comes "I can't help what I think", which is partly true. The sentence arrives before you've decided anything, and telling yourself not to have it won't work. But there are two steps. The sentence arrives, and then you treat it as a conclusion or as a guess. The second step is yours. You can't stop the charge turning up, though you can finish the correction your mind already started and dropped. It also helps to notice, honestly, that you'd quite like the charge to be true, because it gives you a position. Enjoying a thought tells you nothing about whether it's right.

Three causes and a plain question

Add up an ordinary month. The message cost you a Thursday evening and a slight cooling towards someone you like. The interruption cost you a week of being short in meetings and an idea you never put forward. The email cost an afternoon of writing replies in your head, and the roundabout cost ten minutes of driving angry. None of it large. All of it spent on sentences you never checked.

Where it adds up is in the relationships that last. Thomas Bradbury and Frank Fincham reviewed the marriage research in 1990 and found that unhappy spouses consistently explained their partner's behaviour in a negative light, and that the explanations seemed to shape satisfaction as well as reflect it. A later study by Fincham and colleagues, following couples over eighteen months, found it ran both ways. Harsher explanations predicted lower satisfaction, and lower satisfaction predicted harsher explanations. Those studies are about marriage and I'm stretching them, but I'd expect any long relationship, with a sibling, a colleague or a friend of twenty years, to collect a file the same way, until the file is the lens.

Meanwhile the colleague who talked over you has noticed you've been short with them since Monday. They've gone back through the week looking for what they did, found nothing, and decided you're moody or don't like them. They've made a charge about you, with no access to your reasons, because you made one first. You cool, they notice, they cool, and soon there's a real coldness that both of you can point to. Nobody remembers it began with a message under a stack of others.

And they never get the chance to explain, because you never asked. Told "I thought you'd ignored me on purpose", most people would be startled and a bit hurt, and then they'd explain, and the explanation would be a Tuesday. Convicting someone in private is the thing you'd least like done to you.

At work the price is a reputation for being touchy. The person who's clipped after every terse email becomes someone people handle carefully, and being handled carefully is a long way from being trusted. Short emails at work mostly mean load. The people who write the shortest ones tend to be the busiest, which often means the most senior, which is why "they think they're too important to say hello" is so easy to believe. They've got eleven minutes.

Why does charging feel so reasonable while you're doing it? Nicholas Epley, Kenneth Savitsky and Thomas Gilovich showed in 2002 that observers who could easily imagine themselves in someone's position judged that person less harshly. You have the inside view of every slip you've made, which is why yours look innocent, and the outside view of every slip made to you, which is why theirs look aimed. The slips are the same. Where you stand differs.

So the first move is to stand somewhere else. Take the slip and imagine you did it, on a bad Thursday, the one you actually had last week. You read a message in a shop. You blurted in a meeting because you'd been holding the point for ten minutes. You sent the figures email at five to six with your coat on. What did you mean by any of it? Nothing. What would you want the other person to think? That it was a Thursday. This is the most accurate view you have, because you know far more about what slips mean from the inside than from the outside.

Then the method, which is small.

When a slip stings and the charge arrives, name three causes for it that don't need the person to have meant anything. Three, because one alternative sounds like an excuse and three sound like an ordinary week. They don't have to be true. They have to be plausible, and things you've done yourself.

  • The unanswered message. They read it somewhere they couldn't reply. The proper reply got harder as the days passed. Something's going on with them that they haven't told you.
  • The interruption. They thought you'd finished. They'd been holding a point and lost track. They were watching the clock.
  • The email. They wrote it on a phone between meetings. They write all their emails like that. Someone above them wants the figures and they passed the pressure on without noticing.

Once the three are named, the charge has to compete. It doesn't disappear. It becomes one guess among four, which is all you're after. It takes about twenty seconds, and those seconds count most before the evening starts, while the charge is still a sentence and hasn't yet hardened into a position. If you only manage it late, do it late. A charge that's had an evening to set still loosens, just more slowly.

Most slips stop there. Some matter more. The friend's silence is the fourth in a row, or the interruptions are costing you standing. Then you need to know, and the only way to know is to ask.

The plain question is one sentence, to the person, about the act, with the charge left off. "You've gone quiet, is everything all right?" "Did you mean to cut in there, or had I run on?" "That email felt a bit sharp, was it just speed?" Each one names the act, offers the innocent cause, and leaves room for any answer. "Why did you ignore me?" is the charge with a question mark on it, and it gets a defence back.

Asking feels exposing, because it admits you noticed and that it mattered. You've already shown both, by being cool since Monday. Asking replaces a coolness nobody understands with a question anyone can answer. And the answers are nearly always a Tuesday. "Sorry, saw it in the shop and forgot." "Did I? I'd been waiting ages to say that." Now and then it's "Actually, I've been a bit hurt since Easter", which is the best outcome of all, because now it's out where it can be dealt with.

When the slip needs an objection, object to the act. "You don't take me seriously" will be denied, because from the inside it isn't true. "I've been talked over three times this week and I'd like to finish my points" can only be agreed to, queried or explained. Keep the innocent cause in if you can. "I don't think you mean to, but I keep getting cut off." People will change an act they didn't know they were doing far more readily than they'll accept a motive they know they don't have.

Here's the decision, in one sentence. When someone's clumsy act stings, I name three causes that need no malice before I settle on one that does, and if it matters, I ask them.

Plans help, in the form that research on intentions says works best, a specific cue paired with a specific action.

  • When I notice "they did that because" forming, I say three other causes before I finish the sentence.
  • When a slip is still with me at the end of the day, I ask a plain question tomorrow or drop it. It doesn't get a third day.
  • When I need to raise something, I name the act and what I'd like instead, and leave the motive out.

The first week you'll catch about half the charges, mostly late. The second week you'll catch them earlier. Somewhere around then you'll ask a plain question for the first time and get a Tuesday back, and that Tuesday will teach you more than anything I've written, because it'll be yours. You won't stop charging. You'll stop believing the charge on arrival.

Two blue ticks, read again

Sometimes they did mean it.

The plain question gets an answer that confirms the charge, or no answer, or the pattern survives every situation you vary. Then the charge was right and nothing here has failed, because the method was never to assume the best. It was to look before concluding. You've looked. Now you can act on it, by objecting to the act, sharing less with that person, or stepping back, and you didn't spend the year before treating twenty other people as if they were this one.

Keep the conclusion the size of the evidence, though. "They interrupt me" is a fact you can work with. "They have no respect for me" is a charge again, wider than anything you've seen, and it'll make the next meeting worse.

There's one situation where the charitable reading is exactly wrong, and I want to be plain about it. If a partner belittles you, blames you for arguments, keeps you from friends or family, controls the money, checks your phone or where you are, or frightens you, the NHS describes those as signs of domestic abuse. Abuse is about power and control. It has nothing to do with clumsiness, and three innocent causes are the wrong tool for it. You can talk to your GP. The National Domestic Abuse Helpline, run by Refuge, is free on 0808 2000 247 at any time, and the Men's Advice Line is on 0808 8010 327. In an emergency, call 999. People in that situation have often been told for years that they're reading too much into things. I'm not telling you that.

Family is harder in a gentler way. A forgotten birthday from a brother carries thirty years of file, so the charge arrives pre-loaded. The method holds, but the three causes take more effort, and the plain question works best kept to this one time. "You forgot this year, was it just a busy week?" "You always forget" is the file talking, and nobody can answer it.

And if the charge arrives before anyone has done anything, if most people seem to be against you most of the time and you catch yourself rehearsing slights that haven't happened, that's more than a habit, and it's worth taking to a GP. Persistent suspicion can be part of anxiety or low mood. Both can be treated, and having it isn't a fault in your character.

You'll charge someone again, of course. Probably soon.

Maybe a message goes unanswered and by Thursday you've spent an evening deciding what it meant before you remember there was a method. Or you say it out loud in a meeting, "you clearly don't want my input", and know as it lands what it was. One charge doesn't mean the habit's back. The habit was believing every charge on arrival, and you've just believed one, late, and noticed, which you wouldn't have done two months ago.

Do the three causes anyway. They still work after the charge has set, more slowly, because a case built on one sentence can be loosened by three more. Then decide whether the slip earns a plain question. If it does, ask it tomorrow as though the evening hadn't happened. If it doesn't, drop it. Saying "that was a Tuesday" out loud helps.

If you said the charge to their face, repair it with one sentence about the act. "I said you didn't want my input, that was unfair, I was annoyed about being cut off." Most people will take that, having said much the same themselves at some point. Then find the belief that let the charge through. Usually it's "I'd never do that" on a day you'd done exactly that, or a pattern of two instances in the same meeting. Don't count clean days.

It's Thursday. The message you sent on Tuesday still shows two blue ticks and no reply, and the sentence arrives. They're not that bothered.

This time, before it sets, three more turn up beside it. They read it in a shop. It went under. They've got something on. The first sentence is still there, but it's one of four now, and the evening doesn't happen. You put the phone down and make dinner.

On Saturday the reply comes. "Sorry! Saw this in Tesco and it went straight out of my head. Yes to the 14th, what time?" And you notice, with some interest, that it's exactly the reply you'd have sent, for exactly the reason.

Now take the charge you wrote down at the start, the one that stung and that you never checked. Name three causes for it that need no malice. If it still matters, ask the person one plain question this week. If it doesn't, cross it out.