What did you expect it to fix?

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 62 min

It's nine in the evening and the day is done. You're on the sofa with the phone, and you've opened the property site again. You aren't planning to move. You've got a search saved, though. Three bedrooms, a garden, twenty minutes further out than where you are now. You stop on one with a kitchen that opens onto the garden and look at the photographs twice, and for about a minute and a half you live there, and the version of you who lives there is calmer than the one on the sofa.

Then you close it. The sofa is the same sofa.

For you it might be the job board, or the friend who moved to the coast, or the thought on a bad day that things would be different with a different person, or a child, or the kind of money that makes a bad day cost nothing. Underneath all of them is the same thing. A low, steady discontent that has been around for a while and isn't about anything in particular. It isn't a crisis. Most days it's just a hum, and you've got an answer for it. Once the next thing has happened, the hum will stop.

The next thing changes over the years. A job, then a house with one more room, then a different town, a partner, a baby, a promotion, the day you can stop working. What stays the same is the shape of the expectation. When I've got that, this feeling will go.

The relief when the next thing arrives is real, and I won't pretend otherwise. What the research says happens after it is fairly consistent, though, and it isn't what the expectation promises. There's a question you can ask about any next thing that tells you whether it's a fix or a hope, and there's a way of improving the life you've got that doesn't wait for anything to arrive.

None of this is against changing your life. If your job is making you ill, your home is damp or unsafe, or your partner is unkind to you, those are things to leave, and nothing here tells you to stay and work on your outlook. I'm writing about the discontent that has survived two or three next things already, and the one you've got lined up now.

Two cautions. If the flatness has been there most of the day, most days, for a fortnight or more, and you've lost interest in things you used to enjoy, the NHS says that's a reason to see a GP. Do that before you decide anything about jobs or houses. And if your next thing is usually something you can order, a coat, a phone, a bag, you've got a smaller cousin of this habit, and it works a little differently.

One thing before you go on. Write down the last three next things you had. The job you took, the flat you moved to, the person. Next to each, write how you felt in the first month, honestly, and what the hum was attached to a year later. If you can't remember a year later, that tells you something too.

The magic of the new

Nobody keeps a property search open at nine at night because they've weighed it up. They keep it open because the hum is there and the listings answer it.

The next thing gives you a lot. A hum about nothing is hard to live with, and a hum about the kitchen or the manager or the town is a problem with a solution, which is a better thing to carry than a mood. It turns a flat stretch of years into a run-up. It gives you somewhere to put the evening. And when it finally arrives, it gives you a season of feeling better that is entirely real. The first month in the new house, the first weeks in the new job, you did feel different.

Some next things are fixes, too. If you're bullied at work, the new job removes the bullying. If there's mould on the bedroom wall, the new flat has a dry one. A change that removes a cause you can name changes what happens on a Thursday afternoon, and it keeps changing it, because the cause is gone. So I won't tell you that everything wears off. I'll tell you how to tell the changes that do from the changes that don't.

Look at your list. If it has three next things on it, then three times you believed this particular change was the answer, and three times, if the year-later column is honest, the hum turned up again attached to something else. The odd thing is that it never feels like a pattern from the inside. The house was a mistake because of the commute, and the next house won't have that commute. The job was wrong because of the manager, and the new job has a different manager. Each failure was specific, and each next thing is specific in a different way, so the pattern never gets to show itself.

Researchers have watched it show itself. Wendy Boswell and colleagues followed managers through voluntary job changes and found low satisfaction before the move, a rise straight after, and then a decline, in the same people. They called it the honeymoon-hangover effect. Adrian Chadi and Clemens Hetschko found the same shape in German panel data, in a paper called "The magic of the new". Workers who chose to change employer reported unusually high job satisfaction afterwards, "in the short term only". Then they looked at people who changed job because their workplace closed. For them, the new job brought no rise at all.

Read that again slowly, because it's the most useful finding I know of on this. My reading is that the season isn't a property of the next thing. It's a property of having chosen and got something. The new house isn't the old house, but the feeling of having got the new house is the feeling of having got the old one, and it wears off on the same schedule.

Then there's the if-only. "I'd be fine if only I had a garden." It sounds like a description of your situation, but it's a forecast, and forecasts about how a different life would feel go wrong in a known way. David Schkade and Daniel Kahneman asked students in the American Midwest and in Southern California how satisfied they were with their lives, and how satisfied someone like them would be in the other region. The two groups were equally satisfied. Both expected Californians to be happier, and the reason was the weather. Climate mattered far more when they rated someone else's life than when they rated their own.

They called it the focusing illusion. When you think about a different life, you think about what's easy to see and different from yours, and that one feature takes over the forecast. On a Thursday in California the sunshine is just the weather, and the person under it is thinking about work and family and whether they've replied to that email. The garden is what you can see from the sofa. Thursday afternoon in the garden, with the same job and the same tiredness, is what you can't.

The friend on the coast seems to prove you wrong. She seems calmer, and if you asked, she'd say her life is good. But in 2006 Kahneman and four colleagues looked at the belief that richer people are happier and called it widespread and mostly illusory. People with higher incomes rated their lives as relatively satisfying, yet in their moment-to-moment experience they were barely happier than anyone else, and they tended to be more tense. A rating looks at the outline, and the outline is where the coast shows. Her Thursday afternoon is a Thursday afternoon. She isn't secretly miserable. The gap between you is smaller than the listings make it look, and the part that's real isn't the sea.

The preview has one more trick, which is how clear it is. You can see the kitchen, the walk to the shops, yourself at the table. Timothy Wilson and Daniel Gilbert, who spent years on how people predict their own feelings, call the main error the impact bias. People overestimate how strong a future feeling will be and how long it will last. Partly that's because the preview has been emptied of everything else that will be going on. Partly it's because people don't anticipate how quickly the mind makes sense of whatever happens and files it as ordinary. Gilbert and colleagues found that people expected bad news, a relationship ending or a job turning them down, to hurt for longer than it did. The same machinery that makes a rejection bearable in a month makes the new kitchen ordinary in six.

You can picture the first morning exactly. Nobody can picture the two hundredth, and that's where you'll be living.

Weather you carry

The belief that holds the others up is this one. If you feel a steady dissatisfaction, something must be causing it, and the cause must be in your circumstances, because that's what dissatisfaction is for.

Sometimes, yes. But Ed Diener, Richard Lucas and Christie Napa Scollon, reviewing the evidence on how happiness behaves over years, made two points that matter here. People have different baseline levels, depending partly on temperament. And where each person sits is partly a fact about them and not about their circumstances. The same review says baselines can change. Still, the hum might be your level, a place your mood returns to that's a bit lower than you'd like and has been for years, across two jobs and three flats and at least one relationship. If so, it isn't a signal about the kitchen, and moving doesn't change the weather you carry.

Here's a test, and it's my suggestion, not a finding. Ask whether the hum has a shape. A signal about circumstances is specific. It's worse on the days you see the manager and better when you don't. It lifts when you leave the flat. It arrived when something changed and would end if that thing changed back. A level doesn't behave like that. It's roughly the same in the new place as the old one once the season ends, and it attaches to whatever's nearest.

"But it worked last time."

It did. Maike Luhmann and colleagues gathered the long-term studies on well-being after big life events, 188 publications covering nearly sixty-six thousand people, and found that events changed how people rated their lives more consistently than how they felt day to day. The days are where the hum lives. And when Lucas, Andrew Clark, Yannis Georgellis and Diener followed more than twenty-four thousand people in Germany for fifteen years, through weddings and after, the average person rose at marriage and then adapted back towards where they'd been.

A new coat is warm and it's also new, and for the first fortnight you notice it every time you put it on. By spring it's your coat. It's exactly as warm as it was. What wore off was the noticing, and the noticing was the part that felt like the hum going.

At this point the argument can tip into something bleak. If everything wears off, why bother? But Lucas, summarising the panel studies, concluded that adaptation isn't inevitable. Some events go with lasting changes, years later. His list was divorce, the death of a spouse, unemployment and disability. People hit by unemployment, in the same German panel, shifted back partway and on average never got all the way back, even after they'd found work again.

Look at that list. The changes that stick are mostly losses, and the gains tend to wear off. It isn't a perfect split, and people differ a great deal, but as a rough shape, bad things can move your level down and keep it there, while good things lift you for a season. So you bother about the right things. Leave the job that's harming you and expect the leaving to keep working, because you've removed a cause. Don't leave a merely ordinary one for a rise that has a season.

Then the word that keeps the search open at nine, which is settling. You know people who settled, in the job they had at twenty-eight and the house they bought at thirty, and part of you feels a little sorry for them. Settling is real and it's sad. It means accepting a life you didn't choose because you couldn't get the one you wanted. But there's another position, choosing the life in hand, and it looks the same from outside and is nothing like it from inside. The settler is still comparing, every day, and losing. The chooser has decided this is the life and put the effort into it instead of into the search for its replacement.

On a Thursday afternoon the settler has the listings open. The chooser is doing something to the garden they've got.

By content I don't mean happy. Happy is the season, a high that can't be held. Content is lower and steadier. It's not needing the situation to be different in order to get on with the afternoon, and it sits comfortably with ambition and plans. What it doesn't sit with is the if-only. The next thing promises happy, and what most people want, when they look closely, is content, which isn't the sort of thing a delivery can bring.

A fix or a hope

A fix removes a cause you can name. A hope is expected to remove a feeling. The preview looks the same for both, which is why the hum can ride on any of the usual objects.

  • The job. If the tiredness has a shape, the job is a cause and a new one is a fix. If it was there in the last job too, the new one gives you the season and then hands the tiredness back with a new logo on it. And if the cause is how you work, the long hours or the work carried home in your head, it'll follow you to the next employer.
  • The house. I have less research for this one, and I couldn't find a good study following people through a move to a better house, so this is reasoning. The kitchen and the garden are the Californian sunshine. A garden on a Thursday in November is a wet rectangle you can see from the kitchen. The damp, the noise, the third flight of stairs with a pushchair, the forty-minute commute that would become ten, those are causes. Watch the commute in both directions. A move that adds twenty minutes each way for a spare room adds a cause to your Thursday to buy a feature for your outline.
  • The person. In the German marriage study the average hid a lot. Some people rose and stayed up for years, and others went down through the marriage. So the person can matter, slowly and in both directions, depending on what happens between you. But in Lucas's study of divorce, people who would go on to divorce were already less satisfied before they married. Some of what looks like the relationship was the person, carried in. A relationship with unkindness or contempt in it has a cause. An ordinary one, where the hum is present the way it's present at work, won't be fixed by its replacement. I'd add that a new relationship's season is intense enough to feel like proof, and its wearing off is when people decide they chose wrong.
  • A baby. The research is mixed, and the people who did it say so. Katherine Nelson, Kostadin Kushlev and Sonja Lyubomirsky concluded that parents are less happy to the extent that parenthood brings negative emotion, money trouble, lost sleep and a strained marriage, and happier to the extent it brings meaning and positive emotion. One of their own studies found parents, especially fathers, reporting more happiness and meaning than non-parents. A German panel found the rise in life satisfaction at a first child came and went, and an Australian one found a slight dip in positive feeling afterwards. My reading is that a child can fix an absence of meaning, but not a level. If the hum is a level, it'll be in the nursery at three in the morning, with less sleep to fight it.
  • Money. Kahneman's 2006 paper found richer people barely happier moment to moment. Matthew Killingsworth, with nearly two million phone reports from over thirty-three thousand working adults, found that feelings rose steadily with income. Then the two of them and Barbara Mellers reanalysed together and found both were right, for different people. For the least happy, the gains flattened out above a certain income, while for everyone else happiness kept rising. Money matters. But if the hum is a low level, that was the group it stopped helping.

Meanwhile, the waiting costs something. While the hum is pinned to the next thing, the life in hand is a waiting room, and nobody improves a waiting room. You don't put shelves up in a flat you're leaving or make friends in a town you'll be gone from in two years, and then it's five years. The move gets chosen for its hum-fixing features and not for the school or the commute, so you buy the outline and live in the rest. And the people around you live with someone who's always quietly leaving.

The hope even spoils what it gets. Kennon Sheldon and Lyubomirsky followed 481 students for three months after a good change in their lives, and found the gains eroded two ways. The good feelings faded, and aspirations rose, so the gap between having and wanting reopened from the wanting side. My own reading is that the bigger the hope, the faster that happens. A house chosen for a shorter commute is judged on the commute and passes. A house chosen to end the hum fails within the year and gets the blame.

So before any big change, and for the one you've got lined up now, take ten minutes and a pen. It has to be written, because in your head it slides straight back into the preview.

Write what, exactly, will be different at four o'clock on a Thursday afternoon. Not the first morning, and not a Sunday. Thursday at four, in the third month, when the season is over and the thing is just the thing. Where will you be, what will you be doing, and how is that different from four o'clock this Thursday?

A fix produces sentences with facts in them. "I'll be home by half past four instead of half past five." "I won't be in a room with the person who shouts." "I'll be able to walk to see the friend I now drive forty minutes to." A hope produces feelings. "I'll feel more settled." "It'll feel like a fresh start." Or the pen stops, because all you can find is the garden, and a garden at four on a Thursday in the third month is the thing outside the window while you do what you'd be doing anyway.

Then underline every fact and ask of each one whether it was true in the last two places or the last two jobs. A cause that follows you isn't a cause of the place.

Last, write one honest paragraph that puts back what the preview left out. The same job, if you're moving house. The same tiredness, if you're changing job. The same argument, the same phone. If the change still looks worth it with your whole life written back in, it probably is. This is my method and it hasn't been tested as a package, but what it's built on has been, and the whole design is to force the forecast to contain a Thursday.

Four o'clock on a Thursday

If it's a fix, go towards it as clearly as you like. Then help it last. Sheldon and Lyubomirsky found two things that slowed the erosion. People who kept appreciating the change, and people who kept getting variety out of it, held their gains longer. Once a week, on a Thursday at four, say what's different because of the change. "I'm home already." A garden where something new gets planted or someone gets invited stays a garden. A job where you take the odd task or sit with a different team stays new for longer.

If it's a hope, close the search for a month and give the month to the life you've got.

Start with the ordinary causes, the ones that don't need a van. The commute you could change without changing house. The sleep you're not getting. The friend in the next town you haven't seen since spring. The work you bring home in your head. The phone that eats the evening the listings live in. The NHS lists five things the evidence supports for mental wellbeing, and none is a purchase. Connecting with people, being active, learning something, giving to others, and paying attention to the present moment. The hum has an answer to each of them, "I'll do that when things are settled", and the list is what you do instead of waiting for things to be settled.

Pick one, whichever would change the most Thursdays, and do it for a month. Ask about the earlier train. Book the friend. Put the month's end in the diary with the Thursday question next to it.

The decision under all of it is short. No next thing gets to be a hope. That doesn't mean you stop wanting things or stay put forever. It means any big change has to pass the Thursday question on paper before it gets another evening of your attention. A real fix answers easily. Only the hopes can't, and the hopes were never going to work.

Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran reviewed ninety-four studies of plans in the form "when this happens, I'll do that", and found that people who make them follow through far more often than people who only intend to. So write three.

"When I notice I've opened the listings or the job board, I'll ask out loud what four o'clock on Thursday looks like there, and then decide whether to keep reading."

"When I catch the if-only, I'll finish the sentence with a fact or drop it."

"When someone tells me about their next thing and I feel the hum stir, I'll ask them what a Thursday's like."

The first Thursday question will probably be uncomfortable, because the thing you've got lined up has likely been a hope for a while and the page will show it. Expect the listings to pull at nine for weeks. That's an urge, and you can have it without acting on it. Phillippa Lally and colleagues found that new behaviours become automatic over weeks and months, and that a missed day didn't set people back much.

Some situations bend the rules.

If you've already committed, the offer accepted or contracts exchanged, write the Thursday anyway for where you're going. It gives you a list of what will and won't change, and that list stops the season souring into blame. Start the noticing and the variety in the first week, not the third month.

If it's your partner who wants the move, make the Thursday a conversation. Each describe yours, and look for facts. Often one of you has a cause and the other a hope, and that's worth finding before the van comes.

If you're in a genuinely bad situation, a job that's harming you, an unsafe home, a partner who's unkind or controlling, those are causes and the change is a fix. Go. If there's fear in the relationship, the NHS has a page on domestic abuse with the national helpline on it, and that comes before any question about Thursdays.

If you haven't had a first job or a first flat yet, those are fixes for causes you can name, no money and no door of your own. The warning is for the second and third, when the first didn't end the hum.

If retirement is the next thing, write its Thursday in detail, because most people never do. The walk, the grandchild, the thing you'll build are facts. If the page only says "not working", the hum will be there at four with more room.

If it's more than the hum, low most of the day for a fortnight or more, lost interest, sleeping badly, unable to get going, the NHS lists those as symptoms of depression and says to see a GP. Depression makes every next thing look like the answer. Get seen first.

One evening, a month or three from now, you'll catch yourself on the listings at nine, twenty minutes in, with the bedrooms and the garden in the search. You haven't undone anything. The rule was never that you'd stop looking. Looking isn't hoping. Hoping is the sentence "if only I lived there", and you can look at a kitchen without saying it. Write the Thursday for the house on the screen, there and then. If it has facts in it, you may have found a fix. If it has a feeling, close it. Don't count the evenings.

Then, one Thursday, nothing has arrived. The job is the job and the flat is the flat. You're on the earlier train and home at half past four, which was a fact on the page a month ago. The friend is coming on Saturday, and she said yes in four minutes. There's a chair in the garden now, and the wall outside the window turns out to get a bit of sun at this hour. The hum is still there, lower, and it's weather now, not an address.

Before you close this, write the Thursday for the next thing you've got lined up. Four o'clock, third month, facts underlined. Then decide from the page.