The 20-minute version
It's Thursday evening and you're putting the bins out.
The woman from number fourteen is doing the same. You know her to nod to. She comes over and says the residents' association has its summer fair a week on Saturday and they're short of people. Could you run the tombola? Eight till four, in the church hall. "You couldn't, could you?" she says, and smiles, and waits.
You know the answer before she's finished. That Saturday is the first in five weeks with nothing in it, and you'd been looking forward to the nothing. What you say is, "Yes, of course. Happy to." It takes about four seconds. She says you're a star, and for a minute you feel rather good.
A week on Saturday you're in the church hall by eight. There's a trestle table with bubble bath, tinned peaches and a bottle of sherry on it, each with a raffle ticket taped to the side, and tickets ending in a five or a nought win. You explain this about two hundred times. The tea from the urn tastes of the urn. You get home at half past four with sore feet and a jar of chutney, too flat to do anything with the evening, and on Sunday you do Saturday's washing and shopping. Your next free Saturday is three weeks off.
Nobody here is a villain. The fair is a good thing, and your neighbour asked a fair question.
But suppose she hadn't caught you at the bins. Suppose a slip of paper had come through the door. "Could you run the tombola on Saturday the 14th, eight till four? Please tick yes or no." You'd have ticked no. Same request, same person, same Saturday. On paper the answer is no, and on the pavement it's yes. The only thing that changed was a person standing in front of you, smiling and waiting.
That's the habit I'm writing about. An unwilling yes is one you'd have ticked as a no on the slip of paper. A willing yes is any other kind, and that includes plenty of things you don't feel like doing. You might not fancy driving your brother to the airport at five in the morning, but you'd tick yes, and I have no quarrel with that.
My case runs like this. The pull towards yes is strong, it's been measured, and you aren't feeble for feeling it. The yes buys very little, and you make the trade on a forecast about what a no would do that is mostly wrong. And nearly all the pull lives in the moment of being asked, so you can move your answer out of that moment with one sentence. I'm not arguing for helping less, and there are no clever scripts here. The words are short and dull on purpose.
Some cautions. I'm writing about tombolas, spare rooms and committee jobs. If you went along with something because someone frightened, threatened or forced you, that was never this habit and it wasn't your fault. If saying no to a partner or someone you live with leads to threats, punishment or fear, please don't treat that as a problem with your phrasing. The NHS describes domestic abuse as being about power and control, and says you can speak to your GP. In the UK the freephone National Domestic Abuse Helpline is open day and night, and in an emergency you ring 999. If the dread goes well beyond requests, to ordinary conversations, phone calls or being watched while you do things, that may be social anxiety, which is common and treatable. And if the person asking is your manager, a flat no may not be on offer. I'll come to that. Nothing here tells you to risk your job over a rota.
A hundred phones out of a hundred and three
Roseanna Sommers and Vanessa Bohns brought people into a laboratory one at a time, and an experimenter asked each of them something outrageous. Would they unlock their phone and hand it over, so the experimenter could look through it while they waited in another room? A second group was only asked to imagine this, and most of them said a reasonable person would refuse. I expect you'd say so too.
Of the 103 people asked for real, 100 handed their phones over.
A stranger, no threat, no reward. In a second study they were told plainly that they had the right to say no, and it made no significant difference. In other studies, people about to ask strangers for favours underestimated how many would agree by as much as half. The askers were thinking about what a yes would cost. The person being asked was busy feeling what a no would cost.
So you aren't unusually weak. The you who'd tick no on the slip of paper is like the people who imagined the request, and the you on the pavement is like the people who got it. Both are you. And the pull sits in one place, which is the moment, with a person present. Hold on to that.
Now slow the pavement down. At one minute to seven you're wheeling a bin and you feel fine. Your neighbour comes over and you still feel fine. Somewhere around "eight till four" a small tension arrives in your chest, made of her hopeful face, the silence that's about to need filling, and a picture of how her face would change if you said the wrong thing. You say "Yes, of course", and the tension goes. She beams.
What did the yes buy? The end of that tension. And the tension wasn't there at one minute to seven. The request produced it and the yes removed it, so at five past seven you're back where you started, except that you owe somebody a Saturday. Her thanks are real, though you were generous with a Saturday you hadn't looked at yet. Most of what you felt was relief, and relief only takes away something unpleasant. It gives you nothing you didn't have ten minutes earlier.
Look at the price. A no would have cost ten or twenty seconds of awkwardness and a slightly stiff goodbye. The yes cost eight hours in a church hall, a Sunday that had to absorb Saturday's jobs, and a fortnight of mild dread whenever the fair crossed your mind. Nobody would make that trade on paper. You make it on the pavement because one side of the scales has a weight you can feel, with a face attached, and the other side is an idea.
The idea is also lighter than it should be, because a week on Saturday always looks empty. Gal Zauberman and John Lynch found in seven experiments that people expect to have more spare time later than they have now, more strongly than they expect it of money. Next month things will have calmed down. They don't, of course. Next month turns out as full as this one, with work and shopping and a relative's birthday and a cold, none of which you could see from four weeks off because they hadn't arrived yet. A car park at six in the morning is empty too.
So before you answer anything with a date on it, ask one thing.
Would I say yes if it were tomorrow?
Tomorrow is a day you can feel. If someone asked you to spend tomorrow on a tombola from eight till four, you'd know at once, and "Tomorrow? I can't, I'm sorry" comes out without a struggle. A week on Saturday will be tomorrow when it arrives. If something really will be different, say a house move that ends on the 20th, you'll be able to name it. "It should be quieter by then" is the car park.
One more thing about that Saturday. You had a plan for it, and the plan was rest. "I've got something on" is one of the easiest sentences in English when you have tickets. The first slow Saturday in five weeks is something on, and you're allowed to defend it in the same words.
What a no actually does
The usual defence of the yes is that it doesn't only end a few seconds of tension. It saves you from what a no would cause. She'd be hurt. She'd think you selfish. You'd feel guilty for a week.
That's a forecast made in four seconds, and researchers have checked forecasts like it. Julian Givi and Colleen Kirk compared what people expected when they turned down an invitation with what the person who'd invited them actually felt. The decliners overestimated how angry the inviter would be, how much the no would look like not caring, and how likely it was to cost them future invitations. The inviters thought about the decliner's circumstances, and saw a busy person.
As for the week of guilt, Daniel Gilbert and colleagues showed that people overestimate how long they'll feel bad after things go wrong, even after events as large as a break-up or a rejected job application. Carrying that over to a tombola is my step, but I'd guess you overestimate how long you'll brood over one.
Givi and Kirk studied invitations to nice things, and a request for help isn't quite the same, since your no leaves her with the problem. So check it from your own side. Think of the last time you asked someone for something and they said no. A flicker of disappointment, "fair enough", and you asked someone else. I doubt you thought them selfish, and I doubt you remember it without effort. You were one of fifteen doors to your neighbour. It only felt like the only conversation in the world because it was the only one happening to you.
Some people do take it badly. Your sister may sulk for a fortnight. But the habit treats everyone as if they were your sister, and gives the mild neighbour and the reasonable colleague the same automatic yes, insuring you against a reaction most of them would never have.
Some requests carry an extra weight, because a no seems to say something rude about the person. The colleague who wants your car for the weekend. The friend with a new skincare business who'd like you to host an evening. The man at the door with a clipboard. Sunita Sah, George Loewenstein and Daylian Cain called a version of this insinuation anxiety. When a doctor disclosed a conflict of interest, people trusted the advice less and yet felt more pressure to follow it, because turning it down would have implied the doctor was biased. Applying that to favours is my step, but the same thing seems to happen. The request gets tangled up with the person, and a no to the car feels like a verdict on his driving.
The best way I know to untangle them is a policy.
"I don't lend the car to anyone. It's nothing personal, it's the insurance." "We don't do anything at the door, but good luck with it." A policy is a decision made before this person turned up, so it can't be about him. It's also easier to say, because you're only reporting something already settled. Most people have three or four areas, like lending money, having people to stay or joining committees, where the considered answer is always the same. Work out yours one quiet evening. You can still make exceptions. If your brother's car is off the road and he has a funeral to get to, he gets yours, and that's you choosing.
Now look at the yes from the asker's side. If you agree to everything, your agreeing tells nobody anything, like a reference from an employer who gives everyone a glowing one. "Are you sure? You're not just saying that?" is what people ask once someone's yes has stopped carrying information. A yes only means something from a person who also says no.
Unwilling yeses also go off. You agreed on Thursday with a smile, and by Wednesday you're looking for a way out. Perhaps on Friday night your neighbour gets a text saying something's come up, and she has twelve hours to find someone where a no at the bins would have given her nine days.
And she never sees Sunday. As far as she knows you were happy to, because you told her so. If she asks again next year, and mentions you to the man who does the Christmas lights as someone always glad to help, none of that is unfair of her. She's acting sensibly on false information that you supplied. Then, quite often, the habit resents her for it, the favour done with a smile and the week of being short with her afterwards. From her side that's baffling. She asked a question, got a warm yes, and was punished for believing it.
This is also how you became the person they ask. Linda Babcock and three colleagues studied the work jobs nobody wants, such as the report or the committee seat, and found that women were asked to do them more and said yes more, largely because the askers expected them to agree. Their study was about men and women at work. My reading is that the mechanism applies to anyone. People ask where they expect a yes, the way walkers cut the corner of a lawn, and after enough feet there's a path. Somebody at some meeting said "try number nine, they're always obliging".
Paths can grow over. Three or four friendly nos over a few months, with no announcement, and you'll hear it in how people ask. "I know you've got a lot on, so do say if not." That's people taking your time into account, which they couldn't do while they thought it was free.
The casserole and the van
"But I like helping."
You're someone people can rely on, and you like being that. The people you admire turned up with a casserole and a van. If this is a case for weighing every request and asking what's in it for you, you'd sooner keep the tombola.
It isn't, and the research is on your side. Netta Weinstein and Richard Ryan ran four studies on helping and found that it went with better wellbeing for the helper when it was done willingly. Help given because people felt they had to didn't show the same benefit. The telling part is that the same held for the people being helped. Help from someone who chose to give it did them more good than help from someone pressed into it. Caring about people was never the trouble. Leaving yourself off the list is.
Take every unwilling yes out of your last year and you're still the person with the casserole. You've dropped a committee, two leaving collections nobody else would organise, a weekend minding someone's dog, and the tombola. I think you'd be a better helper for it, and this is my own view. On the Sunday after the fair you were too flat to ring your father. The month you ran the collection was the month you never visited the friend who'd just had a baby. Neither of them asked. The people who matter most often don't, so a habit of giving your time to whoever asks hands it to the askers and takes it from everyone else.
That doesn't mean doing only what you feel like. Your friend is moving out after a separation and needs a hand on Saturday. Your mother has a hospital appointment and doesn't like going alone. You don't feel like either, and you'd be right to be ashamed to refuse. Run them through the slip of paper and you'd sigh and tick yes. That's a willing yes. It doesn't need to be eager. It's what you'd choose with time to think and no face in front of you.
"They'd do it for me" is worth checking, because the feeling of owing isn't choosy. It goes off for the friend of twenty years and for the neighbour who once took in a parcel. When it's close, a few questions sort it, and none of them can be answered in four seconds.
- Who is asking, and what are they to me?
- What does it cost, with the date moved to tomorrow?
- What is it for?
- Would I be glad afterwards that I'd done it?
The friend's move passes the last one even though the day is grim. The tombola didn't, for you. Someone on your street loves a tombola, and your no would have left the job open for them.
One limit. If the reluctance is nerves, about a party where you'll know nobody or a talk you've been asked to give, the slip of paper won't help, because the you at the kitchen table is nervous too. Ask whether you'd want it with the fear taken away. If yes, the no is protecting the fear, and fear grows when it's protected. That's a different habit, and nothing here should be used as cover for it.
Then there's the dentist you don't have. "I've got a thing that day." "I think we've got family coming." An invented excuse feels safer than a bare no, and it works badly. It invites a solution, so a helpful person moves the date and you need a second excuse, weaker than the first. You have to remember it and not be seen in the garden that afternoon. And the favourite one lands worse than people expect. Grant Donnelly, Anne Wilson, Ashley Whillans and Michael Norton found across six studies that "I don't have time" was judged less trustworthy than "I don't have the money", and left people feeling less close afterwards. Everyone knows time is something you allocate, so they hear it, correctly, as "I've chosen something else".
The maybe is the same habit. "I'll try." "Let me see how the week goes." The message left unanswered. One group of researchers has argued, as theory and not yet tested, that a clear no hurts less than an ambiguous one or silence. It fits being on the other end. You can do something with a no, and a maybe stops you asking anyone else.
You don't owe anyone a reason. If you give one, make it true and about you. "I'm working the next three Saturdays and this is my one day off" tells her something real, and nobody can offer to move it.
Let me check and come back to you
Learn that sentence. It's most of the method.
Mahdi Roghanizad and Vanessa Bohns had people make the same request of strangers face to face or by email, and later by phone and video call too. People were far more likely to agree in person than in text, with the other channels in between, and the askers hadn't expected the channel to matter. Some of that gap was suspicion of emails from strangers, so I'd expect it to be smaller between neighbours. Read it from the other side. Change the channel from a face to a screen and the person being asked gets a good deal of their freedom back.
You can't stop people asking you things in person. You can stop answering in person. Call this the holding line. The moment barely registers it, because nothing has been refused, nobody's face falls and no silence needs filling. And it moves you to the kitchen table, where you stop being the person in the laboratory and become one of the people imagining the request.
Here's the decision. Nothing that will cost you more than an hour gets an answer in the moment.
- Small things carry on as before. Passing the salt, a lift when you're going that way. Say yes as freely as ever. If you can't tell how long something will take, or it has no end date like a committee, the rule applies.
- For anything over the hour, whoever asks and however nicely, say the holding line and name a time. "Let me check and come back to you tomorrow evening." Say it even when you expect to say yes, so it doesn't signal a no. You'll be glad of that when it's your manager.
- If someone presses you, say, "If you need to know now, I'll have to say no. If it can wait till tomorrow, I'll check." An answer forced on the spot leans towards yes for reasons unrelated to what you want, so you correct for the lean.
- At home, move the date to tomorrow, picture the slip of paper, and if it's close, run the four questions. Most cases are clear inside a minute.
- Reply by the time you said, in writing if that's easier, and come back especially when it's a no. A holding line never followed up is just a maybe with a delay.
- Write down your three or four policies, and keep the list where you'll see it.
- Look through the next two months for unwilling yeses already given. Honour most of them, because people have planned around you, and let them be the last of their kind. For the commitment with no end, send one clear message with a date. "I'm going to step down from the committee after the September meeting. I wanted to give you plenty of notice."
A phone call counts as a face. A request by message doesn't need an instant reply either.
The no itself should be short. Something warm that's true, then the no in words that can't be read as a maybe, then, if you like, a smaller thing you'd be glad to do. "Thanks for thinking of me for the tombola. I can't do it this year, I need that Saturday. I hope it goes really well." One sorry at most. No invented reason. No "maybe next time" unless you'd welcome next time. No "I hope that's OK?", because you're telling her your answer, and she isn't being asked to approve it. Check the offer against the slip of paper too, or you've given an unwilling yes to half the job. If she comes back with "Are you sure? We're really stuck", say the same thing again, a little shorter. "I know, and I'm sorry you're stuck. I can't do it." A new reason only gives her something new to answer, and it almost never goes past the second round.
Plans of the form "when this happens, then I'll do that" have a good record in research on following through. Say one aloud. "When someone asks me for something that would take more than an hour, I'll say, let me check and come back to you tomorrow."
The first few nos will feel bad, even by message. Then most replies say something like "No problem, thanks for letting me know", and after a few of those the dread shrinks, because the forecast is finally meeting evidence. I can't promise more than that.
Some places are harder. With your manager a plain no often isn't available, and that's a fact about employment and no failure of yours. What you can nearly always do is show the cost. "Yes, I can take that on. It'll mean the quarterly report moves to the following week. Is that the right way round?" For the minutes and the leaving collection, the ordinary method works. If the workload is unmanageable whatever you say, that's bigger than this habit, and it calls for a proper conversation with your manager, human resources or a union representative.
Families are where the path is worn deepest. If you've always hosted Christmas, your first no will surprise people, so expect a rough conversation or two. Use the same words, stay friendly, and don't get drawn into defending your whole character. "I can't do it this year. I'll happily bring the pudding." And a few people push, ask a third time, go quiet, list what they've done for you. Stay with the repeated sentence. Someone who can hear a no and stay friendly was asking you a question. Someone who can't was giving an instruction, and that's worth knowing when you decide how much of your time they get.
You'll be caught off guard, and "yes, of course" will be out before the holding line. Go back, and soon. "I spoke too soon yesterday. I've looked at my diary and I can't do it after all. I'm sorry to mess you about." The next morning that's a small nuisance. Nine days later it's the Friday night text.
Please talk to a GP if ordinary conversations, phone calls or being watched fill you with dread and you arrange your life around avoiding them. The NHS says social anxiety often doesn't go away without treatment, and in England you can also refer yourself to NHS talking therapies. If a partner, relative or someone you live with meets your no with threats, punishment, control or violence, that isn't a communication problem. Tell someone, such as your GP. The National Domestic Abuse Helpline, run by Refuge, is free and open day and night, men can ring the Respect Men's Advice Line, and in an emergency ring 999. And if you've been low, anxious or exhausted for weeks with no way to put anything down, see a GP about that too. Therapists also teach this as a skill, called assertiveness training, which one review describes as well researched and rather neglected. Asking for it isn't failing.
A year on, it's Thursday and the bins. The fair is a week on Saturday, they're short again, and you were so good on the tombola last year. She smiles and waits, and the tension arrives exactly as before. Nothing makes it go away. You just know it started five seconds ago and tells you nothing about the Saturday.
"Let me check and come back to you tomorrow evening."
"Course," she says. "No rush."
At the kitchen table you ask whether you'd run a tombola tomorrow, and you wouldn't. But you like the street. So you write, "Thanks for asking me again. I can't do the day this year, I need that Saturday. I could come at eight and help put the tables out for an hour, and I'll bring a cake." Twelve minutes later, "No problem at all. Tables at eight would be brilliant, nobody ever wants to do that bit."
On the Saturday you carry trestle tables for fifty minutes, buy five tickets from a man who is plainly having a lovely time, and win a tin of peaches. You're home by half past nine with the whole day ahead of you.
Say the sentence aloud now, once, so it's been in your mouth before you need it. Let me check and come back to you.