You only saw the good bits

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 51 min

It's Saturday, a little after eight in the evening, and you're driving home from a housewarming.

The house was lovely. The kitchen had an island and a long window onto the garden, and the garden had a tree with a swing on it. Your friend showed you round with a glass in her hand, apologising for the state of rooms that were in no state at all. Her husband did something clever with lamb. Their children said please. At some point she mentioned, lightly, that she'd been made a director in the spring.

You like her. You've known her for fifteen years, and you were glad for her and said so and meant it. But somewhere on the ring road a different feeling has arrived. Your flat was fine at four o'clock, and now it seems small and a bit tired. You catch yourself working out how old she was when she bought her first place, and how old you are now.

Nothing in your life changed between four and eight. Same flat, same job, same people who love you. The only thing that changed is what you'd seen, and what you'd seen was four hours of one household on a day they'd spent a week getting ready for.

Later, on the sofa, the phone adds three more. A man from two jobs ago is thrilled to announce something. Your cousin has run a half marathon. A couple you met once on holiday are on a beach you'll never find. By ten you've come second four times, and you go to bed feeling behind, though if someone asked what in, you couldn't say.

I'll call that feeling the dip, the small drop in the stomach after a comparison you've lost. It's quick, and you don't choose it. It turns up only where you care and feel unsure, and it's set off by people who started roughly where you did, never by a billionaire's yacht. And it passes itself off as information. It says "I'm behind", in the flat voice you'd use to report the time, so you take it seriously and start planning round it, sometimes at one in the morning.

That last habit keeps the whole thing going. I don't think the dip is a fact, and I think that can be shown without pretending your friend's kitchen isn't nice. I won't ask you to stop comparing, either. You couldn't. What I can offer is a question worth asking in the second after the dip lands, and something better to measure your life against.

Three cautions.

  • If you've felt low or hopeless most of the time for weeks, and everything you see seems to prove you've failed, that may be depression rather than a comparing habit. Low self-esteem and feeling hopeless are among the symptoms the NHS lists, and a GP should hear about it.
  • If most of your comparing is about your face, your body or your weight, and it's taking up a lot of your day, that deserves more than a book too.
  • If your life is hard in ways that are plain fact, money that doesn't cover the month, poor health, nobody to talk to, I won't tell you it's all in how you look at it. This is about the extra weight comparing adds. It can't remove the weight that's really there.

For the next few days, when the dip comes, note who set it off and what it was about. "J, the house." "Cousin, running." Don't argue with it. You're only collecting.

Four hours in a kitchen

Suppose you sit an exam and get 64 per cent. You can't tell whether that's good until you hear what everyone else got.

In 1954 Leon Festinger built a theory on that ordinary fact. People have a drive to evaluate their abilities, and where there's no objective test, they look at other people. Most of adult life has no objective test. Nobody tells you whether you're doing all right for thirty-eight, so you look sideways and read your position off the nearest people. There's nothing vain in that, and it's often useful.

It's also automatic. Daniel Gilbert and his colleagues found that people compared themselves with someone even when they knew the comparison could tell them nothing, and corrected for it afterwards only when they were able to. You don't decide to compare. You compare, and then, if you get the chance, you decide what to make of it.

The trouble is the direction. Ladd Wheeler and Kunitate Miyake had 94 students record every comparison they made for two weeks. Looking upwards lowered how they felt, and a bad mood beforehand steered them upwards more often. A 2018 review of sixty years of experiments found people strongly prefer to look upwards, and usually come away feeling further from the other person than before. I think looking upwards feels like finding out. The question is how much you're really finding out.

Some comparisons are ones you run. You wonder whether your salary is in line with the market, you get real figures, you get an answer, and it's over. The dip is a comparison that runs you. Its question was how your whole life is going against hers, its evidence was four hours in a kitchen, and it didn't end when you got home.

Start with where the evidence comes from. You see other people when they're with other people, at dinners and at the school gate and online. You almost never see them alone at the kitchen table with a letter from the bank. You're present for every minute of your own life.

In 2011 Alexander Jordan and colleagues ran four studies with students at one American university. In the first, students described recent bad and good experiences. About 29 per cent of the bad experiences had happened with nobody else present, against 15 per cent of the good ones, and the students said they'd tried to hide 40 per cent of their negative emotions from the people who could see them, against 13 per cent of the positive. Bad moments mostly happen in private, and the ones in company get hidden. So, in a second study, students underestimated how common bad experiences were among their peers.

It's like judging a country's weather from its postcards. Every postcard is a real photograph of a real day, and nobody's lying to you. Nobody prints a postcard of the rain.

"My real friends tell me the truth." In the third study, the people who knew the students best still underestimated their bad feelings and overestimated their good ones. "How are you?" is a greeting, and "Good, thanks" is what people say back. In the fourth, students who thought others had fewer bad moments reported more loneliness, though a single survey can't show which causes which.

None of this says your friend is secretly unhappy. The kitchen is real and the children really did say please. The good bits persuade you because they're true. The mistake is treating four chosen, prepared hours as a fair sample of a life.

So here's the question for when the dip comes. What didn't I see? You don't have to answer it, and you certainly shouldn't invent a hidden misery for your friend, which would be a different mistake and a slightly mean one. The question only marks the evidence as partial.

Then there's the other side. You have a complete record of your own life. The argument in the car on the way there. What's in the overdraft. The evening last week you ate cereal standing up. That's your full version, and it's what you hold against your friend's Saturday, a life known from the inside with every dull minute included, against a life seen from outside at its most prepared. It's the estate agent's photographs of their house against a walk round yours on a Tuesday night with the big light on.

"I'd settle for the outside of her life, thanks." In 1998 David Schkade and Daniel Kahneman found that students in the American Midwest and in Southern California were equally satisfied with their own lives, yet both groups expected Californians to be happier, mostly because of the climate. They called it a focusing illusion. Judging a life from a distance, you give most weight to whatever is visible and different, and sunshine is both.

The kitchen is your friend's sunshine. You didn't see her commute, her boss, her back, her marriage on a Wednesday or her three o'clock in the morning. I've no idea how those are going, and neither have you. The ring road went from "her kitchen is better" to "her life is better" to "I'm failing". The first link is a fact, the second a guess from a thin slice, and the third doesn't follow even if the second were true.

Think of the last time you had people over. You tidied, cooked the thing you're good at, and were funny because you like these people. You didn't mention the overdraft. I'd bet at least one person has driven home from your place feeling the dip.

A committee of specialists

Look at your list of dips. If you haven't kept one, make it from memory. Write down the person who comes to mind for money, then for career, home, fitness, marriage, children and friends.

You've probably written a different name on nearly every line. The friend with the house isn't the one with the enviable marriage, and the colleague whose career you watch isn't the cousin who runs. You've been measuring yourself against a committee, each member picked for being the best you know at one thing. It's a decathlon where every event is run against a different specialist. You lose the sprint to the sprinter and the javelin to the javelin thrower, and go home believing you're a poor athlete.

People really do pick this way. In twelve studies with about 2,500 people, Shai Davidai and Sebastian Deri found that people measured themselves against standards well above average, because high performers are the ones who come to mind. With Thomas Gilovich they found the same with social lives. Most people believed others had richer ones, because the most sociable people they knew sprang to mind, and when those people were made less available the bias disappeared.

Impressive people generate news. A promotion gets announced, and so does a house or a marathon. Your friend who's still renting and reasonably content hasn't produced a piece of news in four years, so she never makes your list. So count the quiet ones. When the dip says everyone has a house like that, run through the people you know. "Everyone" usually turns out to be three people.

"But it keeps me going." There's something in that. Penelope Lockwood and Ziva Kunda found that a star in a field you care about inspired people when the success seemed attainable, and left them, if anything, deflated when it seemed out of reach. Hold the dip up against that. "I'd like a garden" would have been specific. "I'm behind" is a score for your whole self, and there's no next step from it. My guess is that's why it deflates you. Go down your list and ask what each dip led you to do the following week. For most lines, I'd guess, it's an hour on a property site at midnight and a slightly cooler text to the friend.

When someone's success really did move you, it looked different. You saw a particular thing, thought "I could do that", and your next thought was about how. So ask envy two questions. What exactly do I want from that? And how did they do it? The first shrinks it, because you don't want her life, with her commute and her boss. You want a garden. The second turns the person you envied into your best source.

Then there's the ranking itself. You get a decent pay rise and you're pleased for a month, until you learn a colleague at your level earns two thousand more. Your pay hasn't dropped a penny. Your satisfaction with it has collapsed.

That's been measured. When a website began listing University of California salaries, economists told a random set of employees about it. Those who found they earned less than the median for their unit reported lower satisfaction and were more likely to look for another job. Those who found they earned more were unaffected. Checking your rank costs you when you lose and pays you nothing when you win. Christopher Boyce, Gordon Brown and Simon Moore found that life satisfaction followed where people's income ranked in their group, more than the income itself, and that people gave more weight to those above them. A rise then helps only if it moves you up, and every place you gain is one someone else loses.

There's no top. There's always someone above you, and the people you measure against change as your life does. The reward for winning the league is a harder league. I'd bet your friend has been to a housewarming with a bigger kitchen and driven home quiet. If you'd been shown your present life ten years ago you'd probably have taken it gladly. A ranking that could never have paid out is one you lose nothing by ignoring.

The phone didn't invent any of this. People drove home quiet from housewarmings long before anyone photographed the lamb, and if you blame the apps for the whole habit, deleting them won't cure it. What the phone does is raise the volume, from a housewarming a few times a year to thirty good bits before breakfast, and bring in strangers who look effortless for a living.

The research is less settled than the headlines. A survey of 425 students in Utah by Hui-Tzu Grace Chou and Nicholas Edge found that more time on Facebook went with believing others had better lives, especially when people's "friends" included more strangers. The less you know of someone's full version, the more their good bits weigh. Ethan Kross and colleagues found that the more young adults had used Facebook since their last check-in, the worse they felt, and a follow-up traced it to passive scrolling and envy. In 2018 Melissa Hunt and colleagues randomly limited students to ten minutes a day on each of three apps, and loneliness and depression fell more in that group. But a 2022 review by Adrian Meier and Benjamin Johnson found newer studies increasingly contradict the earlier ones, with effects that differ from person to person. The honest summary is that feeds are bad for some people some of the time.

For a week, notice how you feel in the minute after you close each app. Ignore how you feel while scrolling, since a feed is built to be pleasant during.

The fact without the score

Some people really are doing better than you.

They are, and nothing I've said denies it. Some people have more money, better health, easier children or better luck. Your friend may well be happier than you this year. All I've shown is that you can't tell from a housewarming.

So separate two things that arrive together. "She earns more than I do" is a fact. "I'm behind" is a score, and a score needs a race you both entered, with the same start, the same finish and an agreed way of counting. Lives have none of those. Starts are among the most heavily edited bits of all, and nobody announces the help with the deposit or the illness they never had. You've wanted different things and chosen accordingly. You may have picked work you cared about over work that paid, and it makes no sense to choose meaning over money and then mark yourself on money. And the unit keeps changing. At the housewarming it counted in houses, with your cousin in kilometres, at the school gate in reading levels.

Sometimes the difference comes from a choice you'd now make differently. That hurts, and I won't wave it away. But regret points at something specific you can act on, and "behind" doesn't.

And if the fact is simply true, owes nothing to your choices, and she's content? It was just as true at four o'clock, when your life was fine. Her house takes nothing out of yours. The only thing that made your evening worse was the score, and the score was your own contribution. Try saying the fact on its own. "She has a bigger house than I do." It's surprising how little that sentence weighs once "and therefore" is taken off the end.

A birthday does the same thing without any housewarming. You're thirty-four, or forty-six, and by now you should own somewhere, be senior, be settled. Nobody handed you that timetable. I think you assembled it from announcements. People announce arriving, an engagement, keys, a baby, a title. Nobody posts "still renting, quite like it" or "third year of trying". And your timetable takes the earliest date from each member of the committee, so no real person has kept to it, including the people it was built from.

Some clocks are real, fertility and pensions among them, and those are comparisons to run, with facts from a GP or an adviser. The feeling of being late for your whole life is another matter. When you catch "by now I should have", ask whether you want it, and if so, what the next step is.

Now go back to the housewarming. At some point your friend asked how you were. You said "Yes, all good" and told her about the one project that's going well. You didn't mention the overdraft, the row in the car, or that you've slept badly since February.

You edited. That's what people do at parties, and it means you're somebody else's good bits. To a few people you look calm, solvent and on schedule, and they're coming second to you. The loop runs both ways, and in Jordan's study, the more students hid their bad feelings, the rosier the picture their friends formed. Everyone in a circle can be struggling and hiding it, each believing they're the only one.

I think this is the largest cost of the habit. When you keep score against a friend, there's a small tax on every piece of her good news, and you start holding back your own. You can know someone fifteen years on those terms and know less of her life each year.

So go first with one true thing. Leave public posts about your troubles alone, since that's editing of a different kind. Tell one friend, in person or on the phone, something from the full version. "Work's been rough since the restructure, to be honest." I can't promise how it goes. What usually happens, I think, is that you get one back, and she tells you about her boss, or the mortgage that keeps her awake. You can't see anyone's full version until they show it to you, and they generally won't until someone goes first.

And when a friend has good news, congratulate early and specifically, before the dip settles in. Envy pulls you away from the person, and a warm message sent quickly pulls the other way.

If the ranking can't tell you how your life is going, something else has to, because you do want to know. You already have two better measures.

The first is your own past. Yours is the only full version you've seen at two different dates, so comparing yourself now with yourself five years ago is the one comparison where both sides are complete. Ask whether you're better at your work, or less frightened of things that used to frighten you. Some answers will please you and some won't, and all of them are about your life.

The second is your own wants. For each area on your list, write down what you want in your own terms and what would count as enough, as if nobody would ever see it. A second bedroom and some outside space, and you don't care about islands. More say over your week and no more travel. Getting up the station stairs without puffing. Without a list like that, whatever you saw last becomes the target. You drove to the housewarming with no opinion about kitchen islands and drove home needing one. The test for a borrowed want is whether you wanted it before you saw it.

There's some support for this. Sonja Lyubomirsky and Lee Ross found that happy students working alongside a peer who did better were largely unmoved, while unhappy ones were strongly affected either way. The studies can't say why. My reading is that the happy students were measuring against something of their own.

Looking downwards won't do the same job. It keeps you in the ranking business from a more flattering angle, one that turns as soon as someone impressive walks in. Appreciating what you have is a different act, and it needs nobody else to be doing badly.

That's a dip

You can't decide to stop comparing. You can decide to stop treating the dip as information, and treat "I'm behind" the way you'd treat a rumour, as a claim to be checked. Here's how, in six parts. The first four take under a minute.

  • Name it. When the drop comes, say "That's a dip." It moves the thing from facts about your life to events in your evening.
  • Ask the question. What didn't I see? You don't have to answer.
  • Say the fact without the score. "He's been promoted." Then stop, with no "and therefore".
  • Check it against your list. Do I want that, and did I want it before I saw it? If not, you're finished. If so, write one next step where you'll find it again. Look up what the course costs, ask her how she did it, move fifty pounds.
  • Do something for the person. Send the congratulations promptly and make them specific.
  • Arrange the supply. Mute the accounts that reliably leave you lower, which you can do and still ring them. Drop the strangers whose job is to look good. Stay off feeds when you're tired or low. Gilbert found people undid a pointless comparison when they were able to, and you're least able at eleven at night.

Plans of the form "when this happens, then I'll do that" have a good record in research on habits, so make three. When I feel the drop, I'll say that's a dip and ask what I didn't see. When a friend tells me good news, I'll congratulate them the same day. When I notice I've opened a feed in a low mood, I'll close it and do something else for ten minutes.

The comparisons will keep coming, and if Gilbert is right they always will. What I'd expect to change is the gap between the dip landing and you setting it aside, from an evening to a few minutes, and for many dips a few seconds. You'll still get the odd bad drive home.

Weddings and reunions show everyone's edited version at full strength, yours included. Expect more dips and settle nothing about your life in the taxi home.

Some news lands on a real wound. If you've been trying for a baby for three years and a friend announces she's pregnant, that's grief, and nothing here asks you to talk yourself out of it. Send a short, kind message, because the friendship matters, and then look after yourself, leaving early if you need to. At work, rank has real consequences. If a colleague gets the job you applied for, ask what decided it, and be sore for a while, without sliding from "they chose her for this post" to "I'm behind in life".

In a bad week, tired or ill or short of money, the dips come thicker and the method seems to stop working, exactly as Wheeler and Miyake's diaries would predict. Name the dips, stay off the feeds for a few days, and see one person who knows your full version. Don't count good evenings. Pick it up at the next dip.

Sometimes the comparing is a sign of something that needs more than a method. A 2020 review found that seeing yourself unfavourably against others was strongly associated with depression and with anxiety, probably in both directions. Speak to a GP if any of these apply.

  • You've felt low, hopeless or worthless most of the time for weeks, and everything you see seems to confirm it. The NHS lists continuous low mood, low self-esteem and feeling hopeless among the symptoms of depression.
  • You spend a lot of time worrying about a particular part of your appearance, comparing your looks with other people's and checking or avoiding mirrors. Those are among the signs the NHS gives for body dysmorphic disorder, which it says can get better with treatment.
  • Worry about your weight or shape has started to change how you eat, eating very little, making yourself sick or exercising too much. Those are among the NHS's signs of an eating disorder, and its advice is to see a GP as soon as you can.
  • You've had thoughts of harming yourself or that people would be better off without you. That needs help the same day. In England, call NHS 111, ask your GP surgery for an urgent appointment, or call 999 if you're in immediate danger.

In England you can also refer yourself to NHS talking therapies without seeing a GP first. If you take prescribed medication, keep taking it and raise any changes with your doctor. When the mood is doing the comparing, the mood is the thing to treat.

A few months on, it's a different friend's housewarming, and the house is nicer. There's a garden room. Over the lamb, he mentions the business has had its best year. On the ring road the drop comes, because yours is a normal mind.

"That's a dip," you say, possibly out loud.

You saw four hours, and they'd been tidying for a week. They have a lovely house and the business is doing well, full stop. You don't want a garden room. Outside space is on your list, with a next step you've been putting off, so when you get in you give it ten minutes and close the laptop. It's a quarter to nine. You send a message saying the garden room is wonderful and you know what the last two years took. You mean it, and sending it makes you mean it a little more. The phone stays on the arm of the sofa.

Today, think of the friend whose life you most often measure yours against. Ring them, or see them, and tell them one true thing from your full version. Then listen to what comes back.