You were waiting to talk

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 55 min

It's ten past six on a Sunday and your daughter has rung, as she does most weeks. Hannah is twenty-four and lives in Leeds. You're in the kitchen with the phone against your shoulder, peeling carrots.

She's telling you about her flatmate, Beth, whose boyfriend now stays four nights a week. He uses the hot water, eats Hannah's food and sits in the living room every evening. Hannah says she tried to bring it up and Beth got prickly.

About twenty seconds in, you know what you think. She should call a house meeting and get the boyfriend to contribute to the bills. You had exactly this in your own shared house in 1994, with a man called Gareth who ate everyone's cheese, and a house meeting sorted it out. You can feel both of them lined up, the advice and the Gareth story. You go on saying "mm" and "oh dear" in the right places, mostly waiting for her to draw breath.

She does. "You know what you need to do? Call a house meeting. We had this in Headingley with a chap called Gareth." The story takes about three minutes. It's quite a good story.

"Yeah. Maybe," says Hannah. A short pause. "Anyway. How's Dad's knee?"

The call lasts eleven minutes. They used to last forty.

Three weeks later your sister says she was sorry to hear about Hannah and Tom. You don't know what she means. Hannah and her boyfriend of two years split up a month ago, and she told her aunt and not you. You're hurt and puzzled. You ring every week. You've always been there for her.

Here's what you didn't hear on that Sunday, because it came after your reply had formed. "And honestly, I think it's getting to me more because everything's a bit much at the moment." It was the last thing she said before she drew breath, and it was an invitation. Someone listening would have asked what else was a bit much. You told her about the cheese.

That's the habit. Someone is talking, and a few sentences in you've worked out your reply, whether it's advice, a story, a reassurance or a point against. From then on part of you is holding it ready and watching for a gap, and the rest of what they say becomes background. Over the years, without anyone saying why, people have started telling you less.

My argument is that preparing a reply while someone talks is normal, and everyone does some of it. The excess costs more than it seems, because you miss the end of what people say, and the end is usually where the point is. They often can't tell in the moment that you drifted, but they register how your replies land, and over time they tell you less. The fix is practical. Listen to the end, take a beat, and make your first response about what they just said. Nothing here asks you to go quiet or stop contributing. Your stories and views and advice are still wanted. This is about when they arrive.

Three cautions.

If you often mishear people or ask them to repeat themselves, that may be hearing and not listening. The NHS advice is to see a GP about hearing problems, because the cause may be easily treated.

If you've always found it hard to stay with what people say, in every kind of conversation, and you're easily distracted and restless in the rest of your life too, this may be more than a habit. The NHS lists being very talkative or interrupting conversations among the signs of ADHD in adults, and a GP is the place to start.

And if you're only half there because you're exhausted, low or preoccupied with something serious, be gentle with yourself. A mind taken up by a worry has less left for anyone else.

For your next three conversations, change nothing. Just notice when your reply arrives, and afterwards try to recall the last thing they said before you spoke.

A fifth of a second

The first piece of evidence in your defence is a stopwatch.

Tanya Stivers and colleagues timed the gaps between turns in ordinary conversation in ten languages, from major world languages to those of small traditional communities. Everywhere, people kept the silence between turns to a minimum, a small fraction of a second, and the languages differed by only about a quarter of a second at most. Stephen Levinson and Francisco Torreira set that beside another figure. The gap is of the order of 200 milliseconds, and getting even a single word ready to say takes more than 600. If people waited until the other person finished before planning, the gaps would be three or more times as long. So listeners must be predicting how a turn will end and preparing their answer in advance.

Everyone drafts, then. The question is how much and how early. Shaping a response in the last second of someone's turn is one thing. Having a three-minute anecdote loaded by their third sentence is another.

The excess has its attractions, and they're real.

  • You want to help. You can see a solution, and holding it back feels almost unkind.
  • You want to connect. A matching story says "me too".
  • You want to hold up your end and not let a silence fall.
  • You don't want to lose the thought, so you grip it.
  • You'd like to come across as quick, wise or funny.

Underneath are needs nobody should be ashamed of, to be useful and close and good company. I'll argue that drafting works against all of them.

"I can do both at once," you might say. In a sense you can. But understanding speech and producing it draw on many of the same mental resources, as Levinson and Torreira point out, so overlapping them can't be free. In the last fraction of a second the cost is small. Over most of someone's turn it isn't.

There's an old finding that fits. In 1973 Malcolm Brenner described what he called the next-in-line effect. In the textbook account, which is all I've been able to check, people took turns reading words aloud in a group and afterwards remembered the words others had read reasonably well, except those read just before their own turn. The usual explanation is that a mind preparing to speak doesn't store what's being said at that moment.

If that's right, it explains the phone call rather exactly. You heard the boyfriend and the hot water perfectly well. That's what set your reply going. What you lost was the stretch just before you spoke, and that stretch contained "everything's a bit much".

This matters because of how people talk. They rarely lead with the important thing. They start with the safe, concrete part, the flatmate and the hot water, watch how it's received, and if it's going all right they move towards what's really on their mind. The weightiest sentence tends to come late, often last, and often in an offhand voice. That's exactly the part drafting costs you.

"They can't tell, though." In the moment, you're largely right. Hanne Collins and colleagues ran studies with more than twelve hundred people in live conversations, telling some listeners to attend and others to let their minds go elsewhere. Speakers found it hard to tell the difference and consistently overestimated how attentive their listeners were, because attentive and inattentive listeners both nod and smile and say "mm". In the same studies people reported that their minds wandered about a quarter of the time anyway, before any drafting.

So why do people stop telling you things? A nod can't cover two things.

One is the small responses. Janet Bavelas, Linda Coates and Trudy Johnson had people tell a stranger about a close call, with some listeners given a distracting task. They separated generic responses, like nodding and "mhm", from specific ones, like wincing at the frightening bit. The distracted listeners made far fewer specific responses. And the storytellers told their stories measurably less well, worst of all at what should have been the dramatic ending, where they tended to falter or trail off. They didn't think "this person isn't listening". The story just stopped working, and they ended it. I think Hannah's "Yeah. Maybe. Anyway" was the same thing.

The other is your reply. Once you speak, what you say gives you away. She said "everything's a bit much" and got back a story about cheese in 1994. Nobody keeps a tally. But after some dozens of conversations a person forms a settled sense that telling you things doesn't quite work, and that the serious things go better with someone else. There was never an incident, which is why it's so puzzling from your side.

Gareth and the cheese

Three sentences in, you've placed it. A flatmate problem, a difficult boss, a child who won't sleep. You know how these go.

You're often right about the category. But nobody phones a parent to report that flatmates can be inconsiderate. What they want you to know is how this one is landing on them, what it's tangled up with, what they've already tried and what they're afraid it says about them. None of that can be predicted from the type. It's in the particulars, and the particulars arrive late.

Doctors do the same, which is some comfort. Naykky Singh Ospina and colleagues analysed 112 recorded consultations. Clinicians asked what the patient had come about in only about a third of them, and when they did ask, they interrupted in two thirds of cases after a median of eleven seconds. The patients who weren't interrupted took a median of six seconds to finish. There were few of them, so I wouldn't lean on the figure, but it matches what people find when they start listening to the end. Most people, left alone, finish sooner than you'd expect.

Advice is the commonest early reply and the hardest to give up, because the motive is so plainly good. The house meeting was a reasonable idea. The trouble was when it came. Early advice is advice about the first third of the problem. Hannah had already raised it with Beth and been rebuffed, and she'd said so, so a suggestion to raise it told her you hadn't taken that in. And often people want to think aloud more than they want a solution.

Harry Weger and colleagues had 115 people talk with a trained partner who either gave advice, gave simple acknowledgements, or put what they'd said back to them in other words and asked about it. People who got the third felt more understood than those who got advice. Those who got advice were just as satisfied with the conversation, though, and liked their partner as much. So advice isn't poison. It just doesn't make people feel understood, and I'd expect someone who rarely feels understood by you to take the things that most need understanding elsewhere. Natalya Maisel and Shelly Gable found, in 67 cohabiting couples keeping daily records, that support went with less sadness and anxiety only when it fitted what the person needed at the time. They studied days and not sentences, so applying it to one conversation is my step. You can still only find out what someone needs by listening.

Reassurance forms just as early. "I'm sure it'll be fine." Someone has just begun to say they're frightened about a scan, and before they've said what exactly frightens them, they're told there's nothing to fear. What they hear is that the subject is closed. The same words after you've heard the whole worry can be a real comfort.

So put three things first. Hear the whole thing. Show you've heard it. "So you've already tried talking to her and she got defensive, and it's all landing at a bad time." Then ask. "Do you want ideas, or do you mainly want to get it off your chest?" It may feel artificial. People nearly always know which they wanted, and they're often touched to be asked.

Then there's the matching story. Your bad back, your holiday in Portugal, your Gareth. The sociologist Charles Derber, whom I'm quoting from memory, distinguished support responses, which keep attention on the speaker, from shift responses, which move it to you. "My back's been terrible." "Oh no, what's happened?" is support. "Mine too, I could hardly get up on Tuesday" is a shift. It's sympathetic and on topic, and the conversation has quietly changed owner. One shift does little harm. A pattern of them teaches people that bringing you a subject means handing it over. Within a minute Hannah's flat had become your house in 1994, and she was the audience. People rarely fight to get the conversation back. They say "Yeah. Maybe," and change the subject.

Timing fixes most of this. Twenty minutes later, after she'd said what she needed to, the Gareth story might have made her laugh.

Part of why the reply has to be ready is the fear of the gap. If they finish and you have nothing, there'll be a silence, and it'll be your fault. The fear has a basis, since we're tuned to fast handovers. But a pause of one or two seconds, which is all I'm going to suggest, feels enormous only to the person inside it. I think the other person reads it as you thinking about what they said, though that's my reasoning and not a finding. A reply that arrives the instant they stop was obviously composed while they were talking.

And the pause is useful to them. People often haven't finished when they stop. They've paused to see how it's going down, or to decide whether to say the harder thing. If you wait, a good share of the time they carry on, and what they add is often the real matter. You can fill the beat with a slow "Mm" that commits you to nothing.

Drafting is at its most intense when you disagree. Your partner is explaining why you should both go to their parents for Christmas, and by the second sentence you've spotted the flaw, which is that you went there last year. From then on you're composing, anticipating their answer and preparing yours. In the next two minutes they explain that the reason is their father's health, not whose turn it is. Your rebuttal, delivered on schedule, answers an argument they're no longer making, and the rest of the evening is about "That's not what I said."

A person who feels unheard doesn't move on to your view. They repeat theirs, louder, and you hear stubbornness. Many long arguments are two people each waiting to say again what the other didn't take in. The quickest way to be heard is to show you've heard. "So the main thing for you is that your dad's not been well and this might be one of the last Christmases he can host. Have I got that right?" Understanding isn't agreeing. Once they've said "Yes, exactly," they can stop repeating themselves and listen to you, and you know what you're actually arguing with.

The joke you're holding has the same cost. If someone was working up to something serious, the laugh closes the opening. They laugh too, because it was funny, and go home without saying what they meant to.

In a meeting, write your point down in one word. Across a kitchen table, trust that a point worth making will still be there in ninety seconds.

Why they stopped

Start with what it costs you.

You miss the date they mentioned at the end, and the condition attached to the yes. At home that sounds like "I told you that on Tuesday", and some people with this habit think their memory is going when the information was never taken in. At work, Avraham Kluger and colleagues pooled several hundred results and found that how well people felt listened to went with better outcomes, more strongly for working relationships than for performance. Most of those studies relied on people's own reports, and when those were set aside the link with performance was modest but still there. "You never listen" gets met with a hurt denial, because the accused partner can repeat the gist. Both are telling the truth.

You're wrong more often, because you decided what the situation was by the third sentence. You learn less, because a reply built from what's already in your head can only contain what you already knew. And people go flat. You may have concluded that your colleagues are dull or your teenager has nothing to say. They may have plenty to say and have stopped saying it to you.

Now what it costs them.

Monisha Pasupathi and Ben Rich had a hundred pairs of friends where one told the other about a recent experience. Some listeners were secretly told to attend, some to be distracted, and in one study some to disagree. A speaker who started out believing "that event was typical of me" held on to that belief less well after telling a distracted friend. The friends who disagreed didn't have that effect. The authors conclude that what people need from a listener to feel confirmed in who they are is responsiveness, and not agreement. It was the friend who was only half there who did the damage.

Good news suffers too. Shelly Gable and colleagues found across four studies that telling someone close about something good boosted the teller's positive feeling beyond the event itself, but only when the listener responded actively, with interest and questions. "That's nice, dear" didn't do it. Your son says he's been picked for the team. "Well done! You know, I was captain of the second eleven at your age." His news has become your reminiscence before he's finished enjoying it. One question, "What position?", would have given him another minute of it.

Teenagers get it worst. A parent's drafted reply to a teenager is nearly always correction. "Jake got caught vaping," and before the sentence is over the parent has a speech ready. The teenager learns that mentioning things produces speeches. A parent who can say "Oh? What happened?" will hear a great deal more, and sooner.

Put together, there's no punishment and seldom a decision. Telling you things has simply become unrewarding. The story doesn't land, the subject gets taken over, good news shrinks, and advice arrives on the part they'd already dealt with. None of it is worth complaining about. They just find, over time, that they'd rather tell their aunt.

It reverses, though. People notice quickly when someone has started listening properly, and most of them are simply glad.

Their last sentence

"But if I stop preparing, I'll have nothing to say."

You've assumed replies have to be manufactured in advance from your own stock. There's a much nearer supply, which is what the person just said. If you've listened to the end, you're holding their last sentence, and it nearly always has everything your first response needs.

  • A follow-up. "What else has been a bit much?" "What did Beth say?" A follow-up can't be drafted early, because it depends on hearing the end, so it's the clearest sign you did. It needs no wisdom, only curiosity.
  • A reflection. "So it's not really the hot water. You've got no space that's yours." If you're wrong, they'll correct you, and the correction moves things on. If you're right, they usually go further.
  • A plain acknowledgement. "That sounds exhausting." "I'm so sorry." After a beat, it's often all that's wanted.

You do all of this already when someone tells you gripping gossip. You don't draft. You say "No! And then what?" The method only asks you to do on purpose what you do without thinking when you're fascinated. You don't have to do it with everyone.

Here's the method in order.

Notice the reply arriving. There's a click of "I know what to say", a slight lean forward, and your attention shifts from them to the gap. Noticing is most of the skill.

Put it down. Don't argue with it. Think "later, if at all", and go back to their exact words and the word they chose for how they feel. It'll come back several times in a long turn, and you'll put it down several times. That's the practice working.

Take the beat. When they stop, breathe in or say a slow "Mm", and allow a second or two. They may carry on. You take in the last sentence. And your answer forms from what they said.

Make your first response about them. This rule does the most work, because you can't obey it without listening to the end.

There's no listening face in this. Collins's listeners could nod and hold eye contact while thinking of something else entirely. If your attention is on their words, you'll wince and laugh in the right places without trying, and those were the specific responses Bavelas found mattered.

After that, the conversation is open. Give advice if it's wanted. Tell your story, and disagree if you disagree.

So, the Sunday call again. Twenty seconds in, the house meeting and Gareth arrive. You notice the click, think "later", and go back to her voice. She says Beth got prickly. "And honestly, I think it's getting to me more because everything's a bit much at the moment." She stops.

You take a breath. "Mm." A second passes. "What else is a bit much, love?"

There's a pause at her end, longer than yours. "Tom and I have been having a rough time, actually."

The call lasts fifty minutes, and Gareth never comes up. Near the end she asks what you'd do about Beth, and you say, "You've already tried the direct route, so I wouldn't push that again yet. Could you suggest he chips in for bills, as a practical thing, and leave the rest?" She says that's not a bad idea.

The decision is this. I listen to the end, take a beat, and make my first response about what they just said. Start with one conversation a day, with someone who matters, and put the phone face down or in another room for it, because you can't listen to the end while glancing at a screen. Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran pooled 94 tests of "when this, then that" plans and found they made people a good deal more likely to follow through. When I feel the click, I'll think "later" and go back to their words. When they stop, I'll breathe in before I speak. When I'm about to say "you should" or "that happened to me", I'll ask about what they just said first.

In the first week you'll catch the reply late, often after you've delivered it. That counts. Over months I'd expect people to tell you more, slowly, since they spent years learning otherwise. I can't promise any particular person will open up. That's theirs to decide.

Some cases are harder. With someone who talks in unbroken stretches, interrupting kindly is fine. "Can I stop you there, because I want to make sure I've got the first part." One accurate reflection sometimes shortens them a lot, and when it doesn't, you're allowed to have somewhere else to be. In a fast group, a one-second beat loses you your turn, so jot your point down, connect to the last speaker when you get the floor, and drop the point if the discussion has overtaken it. For an interview or a negotiation, prepare your points beforehand on paper, so that in the room you're free to listen. On calls that matter, sit down and do nothing else.

If you mishear people in noisy places and keep asking them to repeat themselves, see a GP. People with untreated hearing loss often fall back on guessing and doing most of the talking, and no change of habit helps with that. If holding attention on speech has been hard for you since childhood and in every part of your life, a GP can discuss assessment for ADHD. Writing one word down may still help. Please don't read the difficulty as a failure of caring.

When you start listening properly, someone may tell you something heavy, such as a bereavement, a diagnosis, or that they've felt hopeless. You don't need to fix it or have training. Stay with them, don't change the subject, and don't rush to reassure. "I'm so glad you told me. Tell me more." If someone tells you they've been thinking of ending their life, take it seriously, stay with them, and help them get same-day help through NHS 111 or their GP, or 999 if they're in immediate danger.

If someone has stopped telling you things, one short sentence is enough. "I've noticed I jump in with advice a lot. I'm trying to do less of that." Then show it, week after week. On a tired day you'll launch into a story over someone's last sentence. Mend it on the spot. "Sorry, I cut across you. You were saying it's all been a bit much."

Some months later it's Sunday again, a little after six. The phone is on speaker on the kitchen table, and you've sat down next to it with the carrots left for later.

She's telling you about a colleague given a project Hannah thought was hers. Fifteen seconds in, you feel the click, and there's a story about your own job in 2003 that fits perfectly. "Later."

"I don't know. Maybe I'm not as good as I thought I was."

"Mm." One second, two. "That's a big thing to think. Where's that come from?"

She talks for ten minutes. It's mostly about a friend who's just been promoted, and whether she's in the right career at all. When she asks what you'd say to the manager, you tell her in three sentences, and it's better advice than the version you had at fifteen seconds. The 2003 story comes right at the end, and it makes her laugh.

Before she rings off she says, "I'm seeing someone, by the way. It's early. His name's Dan." You take the beat, and you manage not to ask eleven questions. "That's lovely. What's he like?"

Tomorrow, pick one conversation with someone who matters to you. Put your phone in another room. When they finish, breathe in before you answer, and make the first thing you say a question about the last thing they said.