You wouldn't say it to a friend
The 20-minute version
It's twenty-five past eight on a Wednesday and you've just parked at work. You reach into your bag for your pass and your fingers find a folded sheet of paper. It's the consent form for Sam's school trip. It was due back yesterday.
The commentary starts before you've unfolded it. "You idiot. You absolute idiot. One form. Every other parent managed it. What is wrong with you?" It's fast and fluent, and it's in your own voice. You ring the school office. The secretary says it's no problem at all, send it in with him tomorrow. The call takes ninety seconds. The commentary carries on across the car park regardless. "You got away with it. You always leave things. You're a mess."
At eleven you give one wrong figure in a presentation. A colleague corrects it pleasantly and nobody else seems to notice. Inside, it's "Stupid. They all saw that." At ten to midnight you're awake and it's doing a review. The form, the figure, the remark it made at the hall mirror, and something you said at a party in 2016.
Now a different memory.
A month ago your friend Anna rang you, upset. She'd forgotten her daughter's dentist appointment for the second time, and the surgery had been sharp with her. You said, "Oh, love. You've had so much on. Ring them tomorrow and rebook, it happens to everybody. You're a good mum." You meant all of it. If you'd said "you idiot, what's wrong with you", she'd have been right to put the phone down.
You have one way of speaking to people you care about when they fail, and another for yourself. Point that out and you'd have an answer ready. Anna needed kindness. You need keeping up to the mark, or you'd let everything slide.
That answer is what I want to take apart. The habit was learned, usually early and from somebody else, and you keep it because you believe it keeps you in line. It doesn't. The research on people who are hard on themselves finds that they make less progress towards their goals, judge their own performance less accurately, and find it harder to face their mistakes. The practical part is easy to say. When you get something wrong, you talk to yourself the way you'd talk to a friend who'd done the same.
Nothing here asks you to lower your standards or tell yourself you're wonderful. If you've hurt someone, you should feel it and put it right. What matters is the difference between correcting yourself and attacking yourself, and how the attack gets in the way of the correction.
Four cautions.
- If you've felt low, hopeless or worthless for most of the day, every day, for more than two weeks, that may be depression, and harsh self-criticism is one of its symptoms as well as one of its causes. The NHS advice is to see a GP. A book isn't a treatment for depression.
- If the things you say to yourself include wanting to hurt yourself, or that others would be better off without you, please seek help now. Call 111, or 999 in an emergency. The Samaritans are on 116 123 at any hour.
- This is about your own thoughts, in your own inner voice. If you hear a voice that seems to come from outside you, or that other people can't hear, that's a different thing, and you should talk to your GP about it.
- If the harsh voice is recognisably that of someone who mistreated you, a parent or a former partner, a short book may not be enough. A therapist can help with that.
One thing to try first. For two days, keep a tally of remarks, and write a few down word for word. Then read them back as if one person had said them to another.
Somebody else's words
Nobody is born calling themselves an idiot.
A two-year-old who drops a cup looks surprised, or upset about the cup. The idea that it says something shameful about the person who dropped it has to come from outside, often in the exact words that later become the commentary. "What is wrong with you?" is a question people ask other people, usually children. "You always leave things" sounds like something said across a kitchen.
Koestner, Zuroff and Powers used a study that had followed 156 people from early childhood into their thirties. Children whose parents had been restrictive and rejecting were more self-critical at twelve, and for the women, self-criticism at twelve strongly predicted it at thirty-one. Most parents who criticise do it out of love and worry, the way it was done to them, and teachers, coaches and siblings join in. A child takes in the critical voice and keeps it running after the critic has left the room. For a child that's sensible. Criticise yourself first and you may avoid the mistake, or at least be ready for the telling-off.
So it began as protection, and you keep it for reasons that still feel sound. It makes you better, you think. It keeps you humble, it tells you the truth, and it gets the blow in before anyone else can. The question is whether it does any of that.
Start with the belief holding the rest in place. Only the threat of a roasting keeps you performing.
That can be tested. If harsh self-criticism drives achievement, people who do more of it ought to get more done. Theodore Powers, Richard Koestner, David Zuroff and their colleagues ran five studies that measured how self-critical people were and then followed their progress on goals they'd set themselves. In all five, the more self-critical people were, the less progress they made. The researchers also measured how high people's standards were. The two usually travel together, which is why people take them for the same thing. Separated statistically, high standards went with more progress, and self-criticism went with less.
These are observational studies, and it might be that failing makes people self-critical. But the central prediction fails. If the harshness were the engine, the harshest people should have been out in front. They were falling behind.
My guess at why is one you'll recognise. If every failure is followed by a savaging, the surest protection is to attempt nothing you might fail at. You put off the difficult task, leave the draft unshared, and when something goes wrong you hide it, from others and from yourself. Picture a manager who met every slip with "You idiot, what's wrong with you?" Her staff would work hard for a while, out of fear, then hide their mistakes and leave when they could. You've managed yourself that way for thirty years and given the method credit for everything you've achieved.
What sorted the form was a ninety-second phone call. The commentary delayed it while your heart was going, and carried on when there was nothing left to fix. You're conscientious. That's what made the call.
You might still say the commentary is accurate. Other people flatter you, and you know the truth.
Then treat it as a witness. "You always leave things." You returned the last dozen forms on time, which is why this one stands out. "Every other parent managed it." You've no idea, and the secretary sounded like she takes these calls daily. "You're a mess," said to someone who holds down a job, is raising a child, and rang the school within two minutes. It remembers the one wrong figure and none of the forty right ones. It argues one side, like a prosecutor.
Mark Leary and colleagues at Duke University filmed people making up a children's story aloud in front of a camera. Afterwards participants rated their own performance, and independent observers rated the same recordings. People who were habitually hard on themselves rated themselves lower than the observers did. The kinder ones came closer. So much for clear sight. Their picture was off, and off in one direction only.
Real honesty sounds like this. "The form was a day late. It was in my bag under the pass. I've been putting school letters in there and forgetting them. I should deal with them the evening they arrive." Every word is true, and it ends in something to do. It doesn't mention your character, because the facts don't require it to.
Inside information
There's a defence of the double standard you may have been rehearsing since Anna's phone call.
Her mistake was an honest slip by a good person under pressure. Yours wasn't, because you know more. You noticed the form on Sunday and thought "I'll do it later". You know how lazy you can be, how distracted. She got kindness because she was innocent, and you have inside information.
It's persuasive because it's built on something true. But Anna has the same inside information about herself. She'd probably seen the appointment card on the fridge and thought "I must put that in my phone", and hadn't. If she'd told you, you'd have said, "Everyone does that. I do that." You take it for granted that ordinary people are disorganised sometimes and are still good people doing their best. You make that assumption about every adult you know except one. What you see of anyone else is their outside, which looks competent. You compare it with your own inside, which looks a mess, as everyone's does to them.
Underneath all of it is a fear. If you spoke to yourself the way you spoke to Anna, you'd shrug the mistake off, and with no pain there'd be nothing to make you do better.
This is the most tested question in the area, and the results run against the fear.
In another of Leary's studies, people recalled a real failure or loss that had made them feel bad about themselves, and some were led through a short exercise in responding to it kindly, writing to themselves as they would to a friend. Afterwards they were more willing to acknowledge their own part in what had happened, and felt less overwhelmed by it. Jia Wei Zhang and Serena Chen, at Berkeley, found that people who wrote about a regret from a compassionate point of view reported more acceptance of it and more personal improvement than comparison groups. The people who could admit the regret without flinching were the ones who changed.
To learn from a mistake you have to look at it closely. If looking sets off an attack on your whole worth as a person, you glance and flinch away, or blame someone else. When a mistake costs you only the mistake, you can afford to examine it.
Then there's the second form of the fear. The attack afterwards may not help, you'll say, but the dread of it beforehand gets you out of bed.
Fear does mobilise people in the short run. The question is what kind of effort it buys. Kristin Neff, Ya-Ping Hsieh and Kullaya Dejitterat found that students who were kinder to themselves were more likely to be aiming to master their material, and harsher ones to look good or avoid looking bad, partly through fear of failure. After a midterm grade they saw as a failure, the harsher ones were more likely to avoid the subject. These were surveys, so they show associations. They fit, though. Fear puts the effort into not failing, which favours the safe task and turns you away from the subject when failure comes anyway. You have another fuel, which is that you mind about the work and about the people who depend on you. My expectation is that when the fear quietens you'll work about as hard as now, and choose harder things.
Now the distinction everything else depends on.
Paul Gilbert, a clinical psychologist at the University of Derby, asked 246 students how and why they criticised themselves. Some of it came from a wish to improve and correct errors. Some came from a wish to punish, to take revenge on the self for failing. The researchers called these self-correction and self-persecution, and it was the persecuting kind, along with self-hatred, that was most strongly tied to depression.
Call them correction and attack. Both arrive as a critical thought after something goes wrong, so they feel alike. Four marks tell them apart.
- Correction is about the act, and attack is about you. "The figure on slide six was last quarter's" against "Stupid".
- Correction is specific, and attack is sweeping. "I didn't check the slides against the final spreadsheet" against "You always mess up".
- Correction ends in something to do. Attack ends in a verdict, and you can't act on a verdict.
- Correction stops when the matter is dealt with. Attack follows you across the car park.
On Wednesday, "ring the school" was correction. Everything else was attack. You've noticed that a critical thought sometimes leads to a fix, and concluded that self-criticism works. The correcting part did the fixing, and the attack took the credit.
Sometimes the commentary claims to be justice. You snapped at your son, and hating yourself for a while feels like the least you owe. When you've hurt someone you should feel bad. That's guilt about the act, "I did a bad thing and I need to put it right", and it belongs to correction. What the commentary supplies is mostly "I am a bad person".
Ask who receives the payment. If you snapped at Sam this morning, he's owed an apology, an explanation that it wasn't his fault, and a parent in a better state this evening. An hour of calling yourself a terrible mother gives him none of those. If anything he gets less, because a parent busy hating herself is brittle, and more likely to snap again. Having suffered, you can even feel the account is settled, and the urge to apologise fades.
After something that matters you owe three things, in order. Acknowledge it plainly, to yourself and to the person affected. Repair what can be repaired. Work out what you'll do differently. Once that's done, the debt is paid.
Thirty a day
Get out the tally. Suppose it came to thirty remarks a day.
That's more than ten thousand a year, from one voice, all pointing the same way. If a colleague made thirty disparaging remarks to you every day, you'd call it bullying. It doesn't matter less because the colleague is in your own head, where you can't get away by going home. Anything rehearsed that often becomes convincing, until "I'm useless at this" stops feeling like a thought and starts feeling like a fact.
The bill runs on.
- Mood. Angus MacBeth and Andrew Gumley pooled twenty samples and found a large association between being hard on yourself and depression, anxiety and stress. The arrow runs both ways, since depression makes people self-critical too. A habit that keeps such company isn't harmless.
- Accuracy. You decide what to apply for and what to say in meetings on the basis of a biased report.
- Energy. In the car park, with nobody there, your heart was going. This part is interpretation, a view Gilbert and others have argued for, but the body's threat systems may not distinguish sharply between an attack from outside and one from inside.
- Sleep. The midnight review comes at the hour when you're least able to answer back.
And there's what you never tried, which is hardest to see because it's made of things that didn't happen. The promotion you didn't go for. An evening class you'd have been worst in, and you knew what you'd say to yourself about that. Someone savaged for every failure learns to stay inside what she can already do, and from outside it looks like modesty.
Maybe the commentary drove you to achieve a good deal. I'd say you achieved it because you care and work hard, carrying a heckler the whole way. But if Sam grew up to talk to himself the way you talk to yourself, I doubt you'd be pleased he'd learned discipline.
He might, because it doesn't stay private. "I'm so stupid." "God, I'm useless." These slip out when you drop something, and children learn how to respond to a mistake by watching adults make them. You'd never call Sam an idiot for forgetting his PE kit. If he hears you call yourself one over a form, he's learning what to say when he forgets it.
Others pay too. A partner who hears you run yourself down has to reassure you, and again tomorrow, because reassurance doesn't last against a voice that runs all day. Someone who praises your work and hears that you made a mess of the ending learns their judgement was wrong, and stops offering it. And a person going back over the slip in the meeting isn't fully present at dinner.
Two beliefs keep it going even once you can see the bill.
The first is that it's armour. Say it before anyone else does and nobody can ambush you. But in the meeting the blow you braced for never came. Look back over the last month and you'll probably find dozens of verdicts delivered in advance of criticism that never arrived, because other people are busy with their own performance and their own commentary. And when criticism does come, a person who's spent the morning telling herself she's useless hears her manager's mild comment as confirmation of everything. Someone steadier hears it as information about the report.
The second is the recoil. Being kind to yourself sounds soft, scented candles and bubble baths, and dangerous, as if any kindness would let the standards drop. Gilbert and colleagues measured that fear and found it strongly linked to self-criticism. The people hardest on themselves were the most afraid of stopping. So if you recoil, that's typical of the habit, and it doesn't show that kindness is unsafe for you.
The kindness I mean doesn't ask you to think highly of yourself. When Anna rang, you didn't tell her she was the most organised mother in the county. A good friend doesn't say "it wasn't your fault" when it was. She says, "Yes, you forgot. It's fixable."
Nor does it let you off what you've decided to do. Fuschia Sirois and colleagues pooled fifteen samples, more than three thousand people, and in every one the people who were kinder to themselves reported more healthy behaviour. The link was modest, and self-reports at one point in time can't show cause. But they point away from the fear. Wanting good things for someone means having standards for them, and going on caring when they fall short.
What you'd say to Anna
Next time the commentary starts, ask one question. What would I say to a friend who'd done exactly this?
The NHS gives the same advice on its page about raising low self-esteem. Be gentle with yourself when you feel like being self-critical, it says, and think what you'd say to a friend in a similar situation.
It asks for no new skill. You responded well to Anna without effort. You were warm and honest, put the thing in proportion, and turned straight to what could be done. You've had years of practice. You've just never used it on yourself.
- Notice the remark. This is hardest at the start, because it's so familiar you hardly hear it. Listen for the tone, contemptuous and exasperated, an impatient adult talking to a child.
- Name it. Silently, "That's the commentary." It turns "I'm an idiot" from a fact into a remark someone made, and a remark can be questioned.
- Ask the question. Picture a particular friend in this exact situation and hear what you'd say.
- Say that to yourself, in those words. It'll feel false the first few dozen times, like reading someone else's lines. It's only unfamiliar.
One refinement has good evidence behind it. Ethan Kross and colleagues at the University of Michigan ran seven studies on the language people use when they talk to themselves under stress. Some reflected in the first person. Others used their own name and "you", as in "Why is Sarah nervous about this? You've done it before." Then came something stressful, such as a speech with little preparation. Those who'd used their name performed better by independent judges' ratings, felt less distress, and brooded less afterwards. Your own name puts in a little distance, so you stand where a friend would stand. So try it by name. "Sarah, it's one form. Ring the office." The commentary has been saying "you" all along. You only need to change what it says.
The mirror is different, because nothing went wrong. If a friend said about her face what you said about yours, you wouldn't offer advice. You'd say, "Don't talk about my friend like that." Some remarks are attack with nothing to correct, and the only reply they need is that you won't speak to a person that way.
When something is really bothering you, write down what happened, then a few lines to yourself as you'd write to a friend. It takes a few minutes.
Here's the rule. When I've got something wrong, I talk to myself the way I'd talk to a friend who'd done the same. I say what happened and what to do about it, and I leave my character out of it.
- Catch the remark and name it. In the first weeks you'll catch perhaps one in five, usually late.
- Keep the correction. State plainly what went wrong, without always or never, and decide the next step. If it's the kind that recurs, decide what you'll change. This is the part that serves your standards.
- Repair what needs repairing. If someone else was affected, tell them, apologise if it's due, and put right what you can.
- Then stop. One mistake gets one hearing. If it comes back at midnight, the answer is "That's been dealt with."
- Stop the out-loud version first. "I'm so stupid" is the easiest to catch, because you can hear it. Swap it for "I forgot that". If there are children in the house, this one's for them too.
- Don't attack yourself for attacking yourself. A friend would say, "You've been doing this for thirty years, of course it's still happening. You noticed. That's the skill."
The commentary is quick, so decide in advance. Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran pooled 94 tests of "when this happens, I'll do that" plans and found they made people a good deal more likely to follow through. When I hear "you idiot", I'll say "that's the commentary" and ask what I'd say to a friend. When the review starts at night, I'll say "that's been dealt with", and if it hasn't been, I'll write down one step for the morning.
For the first fortnight, expect mostly to notice, and to be dismayed by how often and how viciously it happens. That's progress, because you couldn't hear it before. The friendly replies will feel wooden. Over a month or two they come more easily. The commentary won't vanish. It gets quieter, you believe it less, and it still speaks up when you're tired. I can't promise your mood will lift. If it doesn't, or things get worse, go back to the cautions at the start.
Some cases need more.
If you've really done something bad, the rule asks more of you. A full acknowledgement, a real apology, whatever amends are possible, and a hard look at how it happened. A friend who loved you would say, "That was wrong, and you know it. Now what are you going to do?" Hating yourself isn't part of what you owe. If it can't be repaired, carry the regret honestly and be different from now on. A counsellor can help with regrets of that weight.
If the voice is recognisably a parent's or a former partner's, say so when you name it. "That's Dad." The judgement was never yours. If that person was abusive, changing the voice may stir painful memories, and that's work for a therapist. Your GP can refer you, and in England you can refer yourself to NHS talking therapies.
If you really are bad at something, say spreadsheets, the friend test doesn't make you deny it. "Spreadsheets aren't your strength. Do you want to get better, or arrange things so it matters less?" The commentary slides from "I did this badly" to "I am bad". You can accept the facts and decline the slide.
If your feelings about your appearance or your eating are taking over your life, take that to a GP. The same goes if your mood is low and the commentary relentless, with poor sleep and a loss of interest in things. Therapies that work directly on self-criticism exist on the NHS.
It's a Wednesday some months on, and in the car park you find an envelope in your bag. The cheque for Sam's music lessons, due on Monday.
"You idiot" arrives on schedule. You almost smile, because it sounds so exactly like your father. That's the commentary. You ask what you'd say to Anna, and say it, using your own name. "It's a cheque. It's two days late. Ring the office."
You ring, and it's fine. It's the second time something's got lost in that bag, so at your desk you set a reminder to go through Sam's school bag with him on Sunday evenings. Nothing follows you inside.
Last Tuesday Sam knocked a full glass of juice over his homework, and you heard him say, "Oops. Okay. Kitchen roll."
Think of the last thing you called yourself an idiot for. Write down, in two or three sentences, what you'd have said to a friend who'd done the same. Then read it back to yourself, using your own name.