You've checked already

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 53 min

It's twenty past eight on a Tuesday morning. You've locked the front door and you're halfway to the car when you stop. Did you lock it? You remember the key going in. You think you remember the click. You go back and push the handle, and it's locked, and you walk to the car again, and as you put your seatbelt on you find the memory of pushing the handle is already less clear than it should be. You look at the door from the driver's seat. It looks locked. Doors do.

At the lights it's the straighteners. You turned them off. You can see yourself doing it, sort of, and you can also see yourself doing it yesterday, and the two pictures are hard to tell apart.

At eleven you send an email to a client. It took twenty minutes to write and you read it through before sending. Afterwards you open it in the sent folder and read it again. A comma that could have been a full stop. You read it a third time, looking for something worse, find nothing, and don't feel better. In bed you check the alarm is set. It's set. A minute later you pick the phone up again, because you can't quite remember whether the little bell was there or you just expected it to be.

Nothing has gone wrong. Nothing has gone wrong for years. Oddly, that's part of what keeps the habit going, because every check has confirmed that checking was sensible, and none has confirmed that it was needed.

You know it's excessive. You've said so to yourself on the way back to the door. Knowing hasn't helped, because the doubt feels like information, and you can't argue with information.

My argument runs like this. Checking makes sense from the inside, because the things you check matter, a check costs seconds, and memory does fail. But repeated checking does the opposite of what it's for. The research here is unusually clear. Checking something again doesn't make you more accurate. It makes your memory of the first check dimmer and less detailed, and the dimness is what you feel as doubt. So the doubt you're trying to remove is made by the checking. The practical answer is to check once, slowly, with attention, and then let the doubt arrive and pass without going back. A locked door and a cold hob matter. The first check does the job and the rest undo it.

Three cautions before anything else.

If checking takes up a lot of your time, if you can't leave the house or get to sleep until rituals are complete, or if it causes real distress or gets in the way of work or relationships, that may be obsessive compulsive disorder. It's common, it's nobody's fault, and it's treatable. The NHS says you can see a GP or refer yourself directly to an NHS talking therapies service. The ideas here come from the same research the treatment is built on, but a book isn't treatment, and if that description fits you, please get the real thing.

If your checking is about a baby, such as repeatedly checking they're breathing, and it comes with unwanted, frightening thoughts, the NHS describes this too and says to speak to a GP or health visitor.

And if you check because you really have been leaving things, the hob on, the door open, more than once in recent months, mention it to a GP, especially if it's new. The habit I'm describing is one where the checks keep finding everything fine.

One request before you read on. For a week, keep a tally. Each time you recheck anything, make a mark and note whether it was fine. At the end of the week, count the marks and count the times something wasn't. Keep both numbers.

What the fourth look does

The doubt after a check is made by the check.

That sounds too neat, so here is how it was found. Marcel van den Hout and Merel Kindt, in Maastricht, were puzzled by something about people who check a great deal. If checking worked as evidence, the most thorough checkers should be the most certain, and they're the least. So the researchers built a computer animation of a gas stove and had healthy volunteers, people with no diagnosis, check it. One group checked the stove over and over. A comparison group checked light bulbs over and over, and the stove only at the start and end. Then everyone was asked about their last stove check.

Across three experiments with about a hundred people, the repeated checking did nothing to accuracy. People who'd checked many times knew the state of the stove as well as everyone else. What changed was the memory itself. It became less vivid and less detailed, and their confidence in it dropped. The light bulb group showed none of this.

Adam Radomsky and colleagues in Montreal then tried it on a real kitchen stove. Fifty students turned it on and off and checked it nineteen times in a set routine, while another group did the routine on a tap. After the stove checking, confidence, vividness and detail all fell, and after the tap they didn't. The paper is called "Repeated checking really does cause memory distrust", and the "really" is there because the first finding had seemed too strange to believe.

Walk back to the door with that in mind. The first check gave you one clear picture. Pushing the handle made it two pictures, both a little dimmer. A third check would have made it dimmer again, and by the fourth you'd have a vague sense of having checked, with no particular check in it. That vagueness is the doubt. You made it. The lock was never in question.

"But I really can't remember doing it."

I believe you, and the researchers have an account of why. The first time you do something, you take in its particulars, the feel of the key, the click, the light on the door, and particulars are what make a memory vivid. Do it again and it's familiar, so the mind stops storing details and files the act as a concept, "locked the door". A memory made of a concept feels thin. You reach for it and find a label with no picture, and an empty space where a picture should be feels like no memory at all.

Meredith Coles, Radomsky and Betty Horng found that after repeated checking, people relied more on knowing they'd checked and less on remembering it. Knowing is "of course I did". Remembering is "I did, and here's the click". The checkers kept the first and lost the second, and it took only a fairly small number of checks on one occasion. That's you at the lights. You know you turned the straighteners off, you can't picture it, and the knowing is the reliable part.

You didn't go back for them, though. You replayed it instead. The bathroom, the plug, your hand on the switch, three or four times, hunting for the detail that would settle it. That felt like a compromise.

It isn't one. Radomsky and Gillian Alcolado had sixty-two students check a stove either physically or in their heads, over and over, and the mental checking faded confidence, vividness and detail just as the physical kind did. There was even a slight drop in accuracy in both. Going over it in your head is checking. And the replay goes everywhere with you and has no handle at the end, so you can run it all the way to work and arrive as unsure as if you'd gone back four times. By the fourth run you aren't remembering this morning. You're building a plausible morning out of all the mornings, and you know it.

Underneath much of this is a belief about yourself. My memory's just bad.

Look at the tally. If your memory were bad, the rechecks would sometimes find the door open, and I'd guess they never do, or once. That's a memory you've stopped trusting, which is a different thing. And the belief does harm on its own. Alcolado and Radomsky gave ninety-one students a memory test and then false feedback, telling some they'd done well and some badly. Afterwards, the ones told their memory was poor wanted to check their answers more. Nothing about their memories had changed. The belief alone produced the urge. So the belief makes you check, the checking fades the picture, the faded picture looks like proof of a bad memory, and round it goes.

A fairer description is that you have an ordinary memory which has been told thousands of times that it can't be trusted, and has handed every decision to the recheck. Some people do have real memory difficulties, from illness, injury, medication or age, and if yours is new or spreading beyond the door, that's for a GP. For everyone else, the trust comes back by using the memory, once, and letting it turn out to have been right.

Ten seconds against a house fire

This is the defence that sounds most like adult sense. Even if the recheck almost always finds nothing, the one time it would matter is so bad that ten seconds is a bargain.

Rachman, who spent a career on compulsive checking, proposed that how much a person checks is set by three things. How responsible they feel for preventing harm, how likely the harm seems, and how bad it would be. He was writing about clinical checking, but I think you'll recognise all three in an ordinary morning. The straighteners aren't just a fire. They're a fire that would be your fault, that seems quite possible on a tired day, and that would take the house.

Now see what the recheck does to each one. Nothing to the probability, because pushing a locked door doesn't lock it more. Nothing to how serious a fire would be. It touches only the feeling of responsibility, briefly, which is why it brings a moment's relief. Then, on Rachman's account, checking feeds back on itself and raises both the sense of responsibility and the sense that the harm is likely. Van den Hout and Kindt found some indications of this too, that repeated checking left people feeling less like they'd acted responsibly. The person who has checked five times feels less like someone who has dealt with it than the person who checked once.

So "better safe than sorry" is right, and it's an argument for the once. The safe act happened at twenty past eight.

Some mornings it doesn't feel like enough. You push the handle and wait for something inside to say done, and some days that takes four pushes. The feeling of certainty is a state in you, and it moves with your night, your mood, the meeting at ten. The lock doesn't move. If the feeling were measuring the door, it would be the same every day. And you're waiting for clarity while doing the one thing that removes it, so on a bad morning the eventual leaving is exhaustion. Let the check decide. You saw the door lock, you heard it, and that evidence was complete when it happened. The doubt is allowed to come with you in the car. It isn't allowed to turn the car round.

That's also why the habit is worse when you're tired or stressed. Tiredness makes every threat feel closer and every duty heavier, so the doubt is louder, and the loudness is a report on your night. You're also distracted, so the first check happens on autopilot and leaves a thin picture. So on tired mornings, do the once more carefully, two seconds longer at the door and the sentence said slowly. "I'm tired, so the doubt is loud today" puts the cause where it belongs. If stress has made the checking spread quickly and take up real time, that's worth mentioning to someone.

And it does calm you. Hand on the locked handle, doubt gone, and you're fine. For about ninety seconds. Then you're at the lights and it's the straighteners, and the doubt has grown, because the picture it feeds on is fainter. The calm also travels. The doubt learns that checking soothes it and finds new things to check, so the front door becomes the windows, the taps, the car, the sent folder.

"Everyone checks." Nearly. Muris and colleagues asked a hundred and fifty ordinary people about their rituals, and more than half had them. They were less frequent and less distressing than clinical compulsions, but much the same in content, checking, ordering, counting, washing. It's a matter of degree, and experts shown the two lists often couldn't tell them apart. So you're not odd. What matters is whether your checking answers the doubt or feeds it. If you check once and the thought at the lights passes, you're fine. If it comes back bigger every time you check, you're in the loop, and the loop doesn't care that it's common.

The email feels like a stronger case, because reading again might really find something. Reading before you send is the once, the very check I'm defending. Reading after can't change anything, because it's gone. Read with a suspicious eye, any piece of writing turns up something, and by the third reading the words have gone flat and strange and you've lost the ability to read it as the client will, once, quickly, on the way to something else. If something really was wrong, someone will tell you and you'll send a correction. The fourth reading doesn't prevent that.

Then there's the one time.

Every rechecker has the story. Years ago you went back and the iron was on, or the door was open. It's vivid, and it's retold every morning as the case for the defence.

Ask why the iron was on. Because you hadn't turned it off, which means there had been no real first check, or one done while thinking about something else. The recheck caught a missing once. In my observation that's what the story nearly always turns out to be. Set it against the tally, too. One vivid morning against thousands of locked doors you don't remember, because clean checks aren't memorable. The one time is a reason to check once, well, every time.

Some rechecks don't look like rechecks. "Did I lock the door?" to your partner in the car. A photo of the hob to look at later. The app that shows the lock. Chris Parrish and Radomsky found that reassurance-seeking and repeated checking go together, aimed at the same kinds of threat. Asking is checking by proxy, and it pulls your partner into the loop. They start watching you lock up so they can answer tomorrow, and your doubt becomes their job. The photo has to be looked at, the look fades like any other, and soon you're squinting at whether the dial says zero or nearly zero. The app is a handle you can push from your desk. All of them keep the question open, and an open question is somewhere the doubt can always go back to.

Add up what all this costs and it comes to more than a minute a day. The first hour of the morning goes on the door and the drive goes on the replay. Other people get drawn in, like the colleague who gets "did you get my email" when you mean "was my email all right", or the child who watches you go back three times and learns that leaving the house is dangerous. And somewhere along the way you became, in your own eyes, a person who can't be trusted with a door. That's true of the habit. It was never true of you.

Once, then nothing

Make the first check worth trusting. A check done with attention leaves a vivid memory, and a check on autopilot leaves a thin one that invites the recheck. Everything from here is my own method, built on the research above.

  • Slow down at the moment. At the door, the hob, the straighteners, the send button, stop for two seconds. Not to worry. To look.
  • Use your senses on purpose. Look at the lock, feel the key turn, listen for the click. Those are the details the later doubt goes looking for, and they're only there if you took them in.
  • Say it aloud, with the time. "Door locked, twenty past eight." "Hob off, all four." "Straighteners off, unplugged." A spoken check is an event with a sound in it, and it gives you a sentence to hold. When the doubt comes, you reach for the sentence, which won't fade, instead of the picture, which will.
  • Check while you do it. Locking the door is the check of the door, and reading the email before sending is the check of the email. There's no separate checking stage.
  • Then leave, without looking back.
  • If there was no once, go back and do it. This is the one exception. If you locked the door while on the phone and have no sentence and no picture, that's a missing check. Go back, do it properly, say the sentence, leave. One attentive check, never zero.

Then the doubt arrives, in the car or at the desk, and this is the part that changes everything.

Expect it. For the first couple of weeks it will come as strongly as ever, because it isn't about the door. Name it. "That's the doubt." Reach for the sentence once, and don't try to picture the check, because picturing it is the replay. Then do nothing. No walk back, no photo, no app, no asking, no sent folder, no going over it. Let it be uncomfortable. It rises, holds and falls, and in my observation most people find it noticeably smaller within ten minutes and gone within twenty, if nothing feeds it. Turn to the next thing, the radio, the road, the first job of the day, because the door is finished and the day isn't.

Then notice what happens when you get home. Nothing. The house is as you left it. That's real evidence, because it comes from the world, and you should let it count. "I did the once, didn't go back, and it was fine." Keep the tally going with two columns, one for mornings you did the once and left and one for mornings you went back. Over a fortnight you'll have a record of how many times the once was enough.

Some checks have no door to go back to.

  • The sent email. The once is before sending. Read it for facts and figures, then for tone, aloud if you can, as the person receiving it. Send, and the sent folder is closed for that email. If you keep opening it, move it out of sight. Making the recheck harder is fair, because its availability is what keeps the doubt going.
  • The alarm. Set it, look at it, say it. "Half past six, tomorrow." Phone face down, and it stays down. If you can't trust a phone alarm, a plain clock with a physical switch makes the once easy to feel.
  • The bag, passport and tickets. Pack once from a list, ticking each item as it goes in. At the station you read the list. You don't open the bag.
  • Things you can't check at all, like whether you said the wrong thing in a meeting. The replay is the only recheck on offer, so they get the same treatment. If something really needs saying to someone, say it once, plainly.

Night is harder than morning. There's no car to take you away, the door is fifteen feet from the bed all night, and the dark is perfect for the replay. So the circuit before bed needs a firmer once. Make a card with the four or five things on it in the order you meet them. Back door, hob, plugs, front door. Do the walk once with the card, saying each one. Then go up, and don't come down. Not to look, not to stand at the top of the stairs listening. When the replay starts, say "that's a recheck" and turn over, put the radio on low, or run through the plot of a film. If you find yourself doing the card twice, that's the recheck wearing the card's clothes. In my expectation the circuit is the last part to go quiet. The first night you fall asleep without going over the back door, you'll notice in the morning that you slept and the house is fine.

All of it comes down to one rule, which you can put in your own words.

I check once, with attention, and then I let the doubt be a feeling and not an instruction.

The moments when the habit will try to restart are easy to predict, so decide them now. Peter Gollwitzer and Paschal Sheeran pooled ninety-four tests of plans in the form "when X happens, I'll do Y" and found they make people more likely to follow through.

  • When I'm halfway to the car and the doubt arrives, I'll say the sentence aloud and keep walking.
  • When I notice myself replaying the check, I'll say "that's a recheck" and turn the radio on.
  • When my hand goes to the sent folder, I'll close the program and start the next job.

The first week will feel careless and slightly frightening. You'll go back a few times. Note it and make nothing of it. Within a fortnight, in my expectation, the doubt gets shorter and fainter, because nobody is feeding it. You may also find you can remember locking the door again, because you're doing it once with attention instead of four times on autopilot.

The third column

If the checking has taken over, if it eats a lot of your time, causes real distress, or gets in the way of work, relationships or leaving the house, the NHS calls that obsessive compulsive disorder and says it's unlikely to get better without treatment. The main treatment is a talking therapy, usually cognitive behavioural therapy with exposure and response prevention, which means facing the doubt without doing the compulsion, starting with the easiest situations. It's the same principle as this method, with a trained person and proper support, and it works for many people. You can see a GP or refer yourself to NHS talking therapies, and medicine can help too, which is a conversation with a GP. Nothing here should delay that.

Checking a baby's breathing again and again, with frightening thoughts that won't leave, is something the NHS describes specifically. Speak to a GP or health visitor. It's common and treatable, and it says nothing about you as a parent.

If things really have been left on or open lately, do the once with extra care and mention the forgetting to a GP if it's new or spreading. A changed memory deserves a look.

If you've been asking your partner, tell them what you've learned and agree a sentence together. Something like "I'm not going to answer that, because you know the answer and answering makes it worse." They say it kindly and mean it. The first few days are hard for both of you, and it's the most useful thing they can do. If you're the partner, the same goes. Don't check for them, don't mock, and if it's taking over their life, suggest once that they talk to a GP.

Hotel rooms, other people's houses and hire cars offer new things to check. Do the once, say the sentence, and treat the rest exactly as you would at home.

A high-stakes email, a contract or a resignation, can have more reading before it goes, and a night's sleep if it warrants one. The stakes raise the care in the once. They don't change what comes after.

Occasionally the doubt holds longer than twenty minutes. Let it, and do the next thing. If doubt like this is with you most of the day, most days, see a GP.

And you'll slip. You'll go back to the door or open the sent folder or ask. Note it, note that the door was locked, and do the once tomorrow. One recheck doesn't restart the habit. Deciding the recheck proved something does.

It's twenty past eight on a Tuesday, some weeks on. You lock the front door and stand for a second with your hand on it. "Door locked, twenty past eight." You walk to the car and get in.

At the lights the doubt arrives, as it does. Straighteners. "That's the fade." You reach for the sentence you said in the bathroom with your hand on the plug, and you put the radio on, and by the roundabout you're thinking about the meeting.

It wasn't like that at first. The first week you went back to the door four mornings out of five and wrote every one down. The second week, twice. In the third week you sat through a doubt at the lights that lasted the whole drive, did the day, came home to a house that was fine, and the doubt was smaller after that. Your partner stopped answering in week two, with the sentence you'd agreed. It was awful for about three days, and then you stopped asking.

There have been slips since. A morning after a bad night when you did the whole circuit twice. An email to your manager read four times after sending. Each time you noted it, nothing had been wrong, and the next day was ordinary.

The tally on the fridge has three columns now. The mornings you did the once and left, which is long. The mornings you went back, which trails off after the third week. And the times something was actually wrong, which is empty. It was always going to be empty. You just hadn't been counting.

If you've read this far and changed nothing yet, try one thing. Tomorrow morning, lock the door, look at it, and say aloud that it's locked and what time it is. Then walk to the car without turning round, and see what the doubt does when you don't feed it.