Go anyway

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 53 min

It's twenty to five on a Thursday, and you've been composing a message for ten minutes. Tomorrow at six there are leaving drinks for a colleague at the pub round the corner. You've sat opposite her for three years and you like her. When the email went round a fortnight ago you replied "Count me in" within a minute.

The dread started on Monday as a small weight, and it's grown each day since. You've pictured the evening a dozen times. You walk in and don't see anyone you know well. You're at the edge of a group with a drink and nothing to say. Someone asks what you've been up to and your mind goes white, and you can feel your face going red, as it does.

The message says, "So sorry, something's come up at home and I won't be able to make it tomorrow. Have a brilliant night, and I'll catch you before you go." You read it twice and send it.

Your shoulders come down. The weight that's been there since Monday is gone, and the rest of the afternoon is easy.

Friday evening is less good. You're home by six with nothing in particular to do. Around eight there's a photo in the work chat, eleven people round two tables pushed together, your colleague in the middle laughing. You feel a drop in your stomach, and it isn't relief. You tell yourself you'll go to the next one.

On the fridge is an invitation to a friend's fortieth, three weeks on Saturday. When you look at it the weight starts up again.

Staying in makes sense from the inside. The nerves are unpleasant and real, and the message makes them stop. But that relief is what keeps the habit going and makes it grow. The dread you feel beforehand tells you very little about how the evening would go, other people can see far less of your nervousness than you think, and the things you do to get through an evening mostly make it harder. The rule I'll suggest is short. When the only reason to say no is nerves, you say yes, you go, and you stay at least an hour.

I don't think you should accept everything, and some invitations deserve a no. And if you like a quiet life and you're content in it, you don't have this habit.

Three cautions.

  • Social anxiety can be more than nerves. The NHS describes social anxiety disorder as a long-term and overwhelming fear of social situations, one that affects everyday activities, self-confidence, relationships and work. It says it's a good idea to see a GP if you think you have it, especially if it's having a big impact on your life, and that for many people it doesn't go away without treatment. If that fits, read on by all means, and see someone as well.
  • If you've lost interest in seeing people because you've lost interest in most things, and your mood has been low for a couple of weeks or more, that may be depression, and the first step is a GP.
  • If you stay away from a gathering because someone there treats you badly, or because the evening revolves around drinking and you're trying not to, that isn't nerves. Staying away is sound judgement, and nothing here is meant to talk you out of it.

Before going further, write down the last ten things you were invited to. Next to each, put what you replied, and the real reason if you said no or cancelled. For the ones you missed, add a word for how the evening in felt.

An hour of relief

Cancelling works. That's the difficulty.

I won't tell you to pull yourself together. The nerves are physical, the weight in the stomach, the dry mouth, the heat in the face, and wanting to avoid them is as reasonable as wanting to avoid a headache. Some events are dull. You may be tired. And a single refusal does very little harm. Julian Givi and Colleen Kirk compared what people declining an invitation expected with what the person who'd invited them actually felt. The people declining consistently overestimated the damage. They thought the inviter would be more annoyed and hurt than they were, and less likely to ask again. One no is forgiven easily.

Whatever this habit costs you, then, it costs through the pattern, and through what the pattern does to you.

Look at Thursday afternoon. Four days of building dread, one message, and within seconds it was gone. Few things in ordinary life remove a bad feeling that fast or that completely, and anything that reliably removes a bad feeling gets repeated. You weren't weighing the evening's merits at twenty to five. Some part of you had learned from every previous occasion that the message makes the weight go away.

The relief teaches something worse as well. When you escape a thing and feel better, your mind concludes the thing was dangerous, since it wouldn't have felt so good to get away otherwise. So each excuse confirms that leaving drinks are a threat, and the next invitation arrives already marked as one. That's interpretation, though it's close to how therapists who treat social anxiety explain avoidance.

Then there's Friday night, which the habit never learns from. The relief lasted perhaps an hour. After it came a flat evening, a twinge of guilt about the invented problem at home, and the photo at eight. The habit learns from the first hour, because that's when the feeling changes sharply. The cost is larger, but it's spread across the evening, the weekend and the next invitation, too thinly for the habit to notice.

A year ago you went to most things, with some nerves. Now a drink round the corner feels like an ordeal, and it's natural to read that as your nerves getting worse. I'd read it as what refusing does, in four ways.

  • The relief marks the event as dangerous, and the mark accumulates. After ten escapes, social evenings carry ten layers of it.
  • You never get the evidence that would correct the picture. Because you didn't go, the imagined evening, blank and blushing at the edge of a group, is the only version you have, and it sits in your memory almost as if it had happened.
  • You get out of practice. Small talk with a half-stranger four months after the last time is stiffer, and you take the stiffness as proof that you're bad at it.
  • The group moves on. Every evening you miss produces jokes you weren't there for and a bit more ease between the people who were.

All four run in reverse too. An evening attended leaves one less layer, a real memory, some practice and a shared joke. The difficulty you feel is mostly a measure of how much avoiding you've done lately, and that can change.

What the dread doesn't know

Next time you cancel, watch your energy for the half hour afterwards.

If you were tired, you'd still be tired. Tiredness doesn't care whether you have plans. You'd go home, eat, and be asleep by ten. What usually happens is that within minutes you feel lighter. You cook something proper, or stay up late watching a series. The exhaustion has gone without any rest at all. Only the plans have changed.

As far as I can see, exhaustion that vanishes on cancellation was the dread. Being braced against something for four days is tiring in a real way, so your body is right that you're worn out. It's wrong about the cause. A second test is to imagine your closest friend ringing to say, "I'm outside, come for one drink." If you'd go, tired as you are, tiredness isn't the obstacle. People with demanding jobs, small children or health problems really do run out, and being truly worn out is an honest reason to decline. Then say so at the start, not on the day.

By Thursday the dread was strong, and you took its strength as a forecast. The research doesn't support that.

Hendrik Hinrichsen and David Clark looked at what goes through people's minds before a social event. The socially anxious dwelt on how it might go wrong, recalled past failures, and pictured how they'd look to others. In a second study, people asked to do exactly that kind of thinking before giving a speech stayed more anxious through the wait, and their anxiety peaked higher during the speech, whether they were socially anxious or not. So Monday to Thursday wasn't a preview of Friday. It was producing the dread. Anyone who spent four days picturing themselves blank and blushing would feel dreadful by Thursday.

John Zelenski and colleagues asked people to predict how they'd feel about behaving sociably, talking and joining in and being a bit bold, and then had them do it. Introverts predicted less pleasure and more self-consciousness than extraverts. Then they enjoyed it about as much as the extraverts did. These were lab tasks, and a lab isn't a fortieth birthday party. But the direction matches what people with this habit say when they do go. It was all right. I don't know why I got so worked up.

So before your next event, write a number from nought to ten for how bad you expect it to be. The day after, write how bad it was. Do it five times.

Much of the dread is about being seen. Your red face, your hand on the glass, the pause before you answer, all of it as plain to everyone as it is to you. Thomas Gilovich, Kenneth Savitsky and Victoria Husted Medvec called this the illusion of transparency. Across several experiments, people overestimated how far others could read what was going on inside them. Your own heart is pounding so loudly to you that it seems it must show. Those studies weren't about social nerves in particular, so I'm extending them. To someone across a pub table in evening light, a blush is a slight change of colour on a person they're half looking at. The blank moment that feels like ten seconds is a short pause, and conversations are full of pauses. When Savitsky, Nicholas Epley and Gilovich had people commit small social blunders, observers judged them more kindly than they predicted.

You have the evidence already. Think of the last gathering you went to and try to name who seemed nervous, or blushed, or said something slightly off. Most people can't come up with one. You were busy with your own evening. So was everyone else.

Then there's the mind going white. It does happen, but the cause isn't that you have nothing to say. When you're nervous, your attention goes inward, to how you're standing, what your face is doing, whether that last remark was stupid. A conversation needs that attention. If it's on your own face, you miss what the other person said, and a reply has to be a reply to something. The NHS's self-help advice puts it simply. Try to focus on what people are saying rather than just assuming the worst. It sounds too simple to help. I think it helps more than anything else here.

Conversation at a leaving do is mostly questions and listening anyway. Where are you going next, how did you find the job, what will you do with the week off. Anyone who asks a real question and listens to the answer is good company, and people with this habit are often better at the listening half than the confident talkers.

Last, the ways you get through it. Arriving forty minutes late so nobody sees you come in. Staying beside the one person you know. The phone in your hand when a gap opens. Rehearsing sentences before saying them. Planning your exit before your coat's off. Therapists call these safety behaviours. Freda McManus, Catarina Sacadura and David Clark found that people with high social anxiety used more of them, and that both anxious and less anxious people thought they helped. When the researchers compared a social task done with the props and an inward focus against one done without, the version with them came off worse.

My reasons, and those of clinicians who write about this, though the experiments didn't measure them, run like this. Rehearsing a sentence means you aren't listening. Someone looking at their phone and giving short, careful answers looks uninterested, so people leave them alone, which feels like the rejection they feared. And if the evening goes fine, the props take the credit. You never learn it would have gone fine anyway. If you can't face a room without drinking quickly first, the drink is a prop too, with the same fault and some of its own. Carrying plates for ten minutes is fine. What matters is whether you're doing it to join in or to hide.

The kinder conclusion

Maybe you're just an introvert.

Introversion is real and it isn't a fault. Some people prefer small groups, one long conversation to six short ones, a quiet evening after a busy day. You can build a social life out of dinners for four and walks with one friend and never go to a loud party again. But introversion is a preference, and nerves are a fear. There are nervous extraverts who long for company and dread it, and calm introverts who enjoy an hour at a party and leave because they've had enough. You can tell which is operating by the evening in. When an introvert turns down a party to read, the evening is a pleasure. When nerves turn it down, you get Thursday and Friday. Go back to your list of ten and ask which pattern followed each refusal. And remember that you said yes to the leaving drinks within a minute.

Let introversion choose the kind of event and how long you stay. When you wanted to be somewhere and nerves are the reason you're not, that's something else.

Maybe you'll go when you feel more confident. That has it the wrong way round. Nobody felt confident on their first morning with L-plates. They were frightened, drove anyway with someone beside them, and the confidence built up behind them as the miles did. The person who walks into a room easily has walked into a great many rooms that went fine. While you wait, the imagined bad evenings pile up and the real good ones don't, so each month of waiting leaves you with less confidence, and you take that as a sign to wait longer. The NHS says that for some people social anxiety gets better with age, but for many it doesn't go away on its own without treatment.

You don't need confidence to go. You need a willingness to feel nervous for an hour, and you've shown it at the dentist, in job interviews and on first days at work. You can also start small. A coffee with one friend counts.

Maybe they won't miss you. Givi and Kirk would partly agree. Your colleague read Thursday's message, thought "that's a shame", and went back to her packing. But "they won't be angry" isn't the same claim as "they won't miss me". Someone made a list, and you were on it. Your friend sat down and chose who she wanted in the room for her fortieth, and she wanted you.

What happens after three or four refusals in a row is the part I'd worry about, and I've no study for it, only observation. People don't usually take offence. They draw a kinder conclusion, which does more harm. You don't enjoy that sort of thing, or you're very busy. So they stop asking, meaning to be considerate. From where you sit the invitations just thin out, and it looks like proof nobody wanted you there. They did. You taught them to stop. Thirty people at a pub can absorb a gap, but a dinner for six can't, and people often remember for years who came to the wedding, the funeral, the last night before someone moved away. Your colleague wouldn't have remembered what you said on Friday. She'd have remembered that you were there and gave her a hug.

Maybe you went last time and it was awful. You said something clumsy to someone's husband, there was a silence, and you've thought about it most days since.

Two things are mixed up in that memory, the evening and the going-over. Rachman and colleagues found that going over an awkward event afterwards is common, that the more socially anxious people were the more of it they did, and that people who did more of it also avoided similar situations more. The evening lasted three hours, with perhaps six conversations, most of them pleasant. One had a clumsy remark and a pause of a few seconds. You haven't replayed the three hours. You've replayed the few seconds, perhaps a hundred times, until they're most of what you remember. If someone had filmed the evening, you wouldn't recognise it.

So before bed on the night, write down three things that happened, plain facts and no judgements. "Talked to her brother about his allotment. Laughed at the story about the hire car. Left at half nine." Then your number out of ten. When the remark comes back at two in the morning, you have something to put beside it. Some evenings really are bad, for everyone. A bad evening tells you about that evening. A disappointing meal wouldn't convince you you're unfit to eat out.

Meanwhile the bill keeps running. Friendships thin when you see someone twice a year because you cancelled the other four times. At work, people get thought of for the interesting project because someone chatted to them at the summer party. The wedding you found a reason to miss doesn't come round again. A partner has been going alone and explaining you, or has stopped going. And avoidance spreads, from big parties to small ones, then to phone calls that become texts, then the chatty shop and the school gate. The NHS list of signs of social anxiety begins with worry about everyday activities such as meeting strangers, starting conversations, speaking on the phone, working or shopping. People get there in stages, and each stage seemed reasonable at the time.

Your first hour

Ask one question when an invitation comes. If I could be certain of feeling comfortable there, would I want to go?

If not, nerves aren't the reason, and you should decline promptly and truthfully. Maybe you don't much like the people, or you're truly worn out, or you can't afford it. Crowded rooms may overwhelm you for reasons that have nothing to do with fear of people, or you'd simply rather spend the evening another way. "Thanks for asking, I won't be able to come" is a complete reply. A no on the day the invitation arrives costs the host nothing and spares you four days of dread.

If yes, nerves are what stand between you and something you want. Then the rule applies. When I've been invited to something and the only reason to say no is nerves, I say yes, I go, and I stay at least an hour.

If you're unsure, notice the weight. An invitation you don't care about gets a shrug. One that matters, and frightens you, gets the weight, and it's strongest before the events that matter most.

Getting through the door is the worst part of almost any evening, so plan it.

  • Reply the same day, put it in the calendar, and tell someone you're going, so backing out means an awkward conversation.
  • When a picture of the evening going badly arrives, turn to something practical. What you'll wear, which train, what time you'll leave.
  • Arrive near the start. At ten past six the pub has five people in it, the host is free and pleased to see you, and no circles have formed yet. By seven you're already in a group and newcomers are joining you. Arrive at seven and you walk in alone and have to break into a circle.
  • Know your first three minutes. Go to the host or the person whose occasion it is. "Congratulations, how are you feeling about it all?"
  • Carry three plain questions. "How do you know her?" works at any party.
  • Have a drink in your hand, of any kind.

Then give it an hour. Nerves are highest as you walk in, and if you stay they come down, usually a long way. Clinicians who treat anxiety explain that the body doesn't keep an alarm at full strength when nothing bad is happening. Leave after fifteen minutes and you leave while they're still high, having learned that it was as bad as you feared and escape fixed it. Stay an hour and you leave when they're low, having learned it got easier. The hour is my figure. After it, go whenever you like.

While you're there, bring your attention back to the person in front of you every time it drifts to your face. You'll do this dozens of times, and that's not failing. Let pauses be pauses, since the other person is as responsible for them as you are. "I'm going to get another drink, can I get you one?" ends any conversation. Drop one prop per event, starting with the easiest. Leave the phone in your coat. Next time, spend twenty minutes away from the friend you came with. Five minutes in the garden is fine, as long as you come back.

If the nerves surge, stay where you are, breathe slowly, keep listening, and let it pass. The NHS suggests breathing exercises as one of its self-help tips. It also notes that some people with social anxiety have panic attacks, with an overwhelming sense of fear that usually lasts a few minutes, and if that's what happens to you, talk to a GP.

When you go, find the host, thank them and say goodbye. That night, write the three facts and the number next to your prediction. When the going-over starts in bed, call it that, remind yourself the evening's written down, and turn to a book or a podcast. After five events, read the log.

The first two or three will be hard. The dread beforehand has been trained for a long time and will be as strong as ever. What should change first is the evening itself, which ought to ease after twenty minutes. The dread shrinks more slowly, over a run of events, and I can't tell you how many. Plenty of sociable people feel a flutter before every party for life. They go regardless.

At a wedding, the structure does a lot of the work, with a ceremony to watch, a seat chosen for you and speeches to listen to, so set the minimum at staying until the speeches are over. If you won't know anyone, arrive early and ask the host to introduce you to one person, or find someone else standing alone. If it's been a year or more, start with forty-five minutes of coffee with the friend you find easiest, then two people, then a small gathering, a couple of weeks at each step. If the invitations have stopped, tell one or two friends, "I've been bad at coming to things, and I'd like to be asked again," and do some inviting yourself.

The urge to cancel peaks in the last few hours. It will offer you reasons. You're tired, there's a bit of a headache, it's raining. Ask whether you'd have accepted those as reasons to miss something you were looking forward to. If you're actually ill, stay home. Otherwise get dressed, go, and start your hour. And when you slip, as you will, write down what happened in the hours before, then say yes to the next thing, soon and small.

If the NHS description fits your life, with fear of embarrassment, trouble doing things while others watch, and physical symptoms like sweating, trembling or a pounding heart, self-help may be a useful first step but is unlikely to be enough. See a GP, or in England refer yourself to NHS talking therapies. Evan Mayo-Wilson and colleagues pooled 101 trials with more than thirteen thousand participants, and one-to-one cognitive behavioural therapy had the largest effect of any treatment, psychological or medical. If your mood is very low, or you have thoughts of harming yourself, ask for an urgent GP appointment or call 111.

A Thursday in June, and the summer party is tomorrow on the roof terrace. You said yes the day the email came. A draft excuse got as far as "So sorry" at three o'clock, and you deleted it.

At twenty-five to six on Friday there are nine people on the terrace. Your stomach is tight and your face is warm. You go straight to the woman from facilities who organised it and ask how long it took to set up, and she tells you about the saga of the gazebo. At ten to six you say something about the finance director that comes out wrong. There's a small pause, someone laughs, and the talk moves on. You'd meant to leave at half six. At twenty past seven you realise you haven't looked at the time in a while.

That night you write it down. "Gazebo story. New starter used to live two streets from my sister. Stayed nearly two hours." You'd predicted seven. You write three.

It's the sixth event in your log. The fortieth, in March, was the second. Your friend said "You came!" when she saw you, and you hadn't known until then that she'd expected you not to.

Look at what's on your fridge or in your inbox. Pick the invitation you've been putting off, ask the question, and if the answer is yes, reply now.