Ring them first

The 20-minute version

20 min read · the full book is 53 min

It's Sunday afternoon, about four, and you're on your phone.

You're looking for a plumber's number, and on the way down the list your thumb passes a name. Your friend from the old office. For six years you had lunch together most Thursdays. You knew each other's bosses by their faults and each other's families by name, and when you left you both said it wouldn't change anything.

You open the conversation. The last message is from you. "We must catch up soon!" Underneath it, a thumbs up. Fourteen months ago.

A small pang, and then several thoughts at once. It's been over a year, and they haven't been in touch either. If they'd wanted to meet they could have said so. They've got the new job and the children, so they're probably busy. It would be odd to message now, out of nowhere, and you'd have to explain the gap. Anyway, you sent the last proper message. It's their turn.

You close it and find the plumber. You make something to eat and watch two episodes of something. It's a perfectly all right Sunday, and at the end of it you haven't spoken to anyone since Friday. You notice that, briefly, and then don't think about it.

Nothing has gone wrong between you. If you passed each other in the street you'd stand there talking for twenty minutes. The friendship is still there, switched off, waiting for somebody to switch it back on, and each of you believes that somebody should be the other one.

That's the habit. You wait. It feels like politeness or dignity, never like avoidance. It treats silence as a message. It gets stronger with time, because after two months a message is easy and after fourteen it seems to need an explanation. And nobody sees you not sending a message, so it costs nothing on the day. After enough weeks, across enough people, the quiet stops feeling like a gap and becomes how life is.

Here's what I'll argue. The waiting makes sense from the inside, because it protects you from feeling like a nuisance and from a cool reply. It also rests on a misreading. Your friend's silence feels like information about how they see you, and it's nearly always the same hesitation you have. Researchers have measured how much people appreciate being contacted, and it's more than the person making contact expects. And one small rule changes most of it. When you think of someone, you get in touch that day.

This isn't a push to be more sociable than you'd like. If you enjoy your own company and have as much contact as you want, you don't have this habit. Nor is it a reason to chase anyone who treated you badly. If you ended something for a good reason, leave it ended.

Some cautions. If you've been low for more than a couple of weeks, with little energy or interest in anything, the withdrawal may be part of depression. The NHS advises seeing a GP if you've had a low mood for more than two weeks, and in England you can refer yourself to NHS talking therapies. If any social contact at all fills you with dread, so that phone calls, conversations and being looked at are all frightening, that may be social anxiety, which is common and treatable, and a GP is the place to start. And if you're isolated more by circumstance than habit, because you're caring for someone round the clock, or housebound, or new to a country, this will help less. You may not have many names to ring. There's a route through your GP for that, near the end.

Before you read on, two small lists. Write the names of people you've thought of in the past month and didn't contact. Then look at your last ten exchanges with friends or family and note who started each one. The second list may surprise you in either direction.

Two people at a doorway

The wait isn't laziness or coldness. People who wait are often the most considerate people in any group, and they have four good-sounding reasons.

  • They don't want to intrude on a busy life.
  • The silence seems to be evidence. People do what they want, and your friend has had fourteen months in which a message would have taken thirty seconds.
  • Fairness. You sent the last real message, and you usually said "lunch?" in the first place.
  • Protection. While you don't ask, the friendship might still be fine.

Each rests on a guess about what's in your friend's head, made alone on a Sunday afternoon with no information from them at all. Researchers have gone and asked the people on the other end.

Take the evidence first, because it sounds the most hard-headed. The same argument is available to your friend. You haven't rung either, for the same fourteen months, and you know perfectly well you'd love to see them. You thought of them warmly this afternoon. So you already have a full explanation for fourteen months of silence from someone who cares, because you're living it.

Lara Aknin and Gillian Sandstrom ran seven studies on exactly this, with more than two thousand people. In two of them they picked the most favourable case. People said they wanted to reconnect with an old friend and believed the friend would appreciate hearing from them. They had the contact details to hand. The researchers gave them time, there and then, to write and send a message.

Fewer than a third did.

So silence is what most people produce even when they feel warmly and want contact. It's what you'd see if your friend had gone off you. It's also what you'd see if your friend passed your name on their own sofa, felt a pang, thought that you haven't been in touch either, and went back to looking for a plumber. Two polite people at a doorway, each waiting for the other to go through. Neither is being cold, and if neither moves they'll be there a long time. Some people really have moved on. But both kinds are silent, so the silence can't tell you which kind your friend is. Only a message can.

Then there's the fear of bothering them. Peggy Liu, SoYon Rim, Lauren Min and Kate Min had people send someone in their social circle a short hello or a small gift, predict how much it would be appreciated, and then asked the recipients. Across the experiments, and the authors call the result robust, the senders underestimated it. The sender was thinking about whether the message was awkward or needed a reason. The recipient was thinking, how nice, I haven't heard from them in ages. And the gap was biggest when the message came out of the blue, from someone less close. Those are the cases where you'd hesitate most, and they're where you're underestimating by the most.

Check it from your own side. The last time someone you'd lost touch with got in touch with you, a cousin, an old school friend, a former neighbour, what did you feel when you saw the name? I'd bet it was pleasure, and that you told someone. "Guess who I heard from today."

The tally is about fairness, and it does protect against one-sided friendships, which exist. But it only measures who starts things, and starting isn't the same as caring. Some of your friends are starters. They organise and send the first message, with everyone, because that's how they are. Others almost never start anything, and they'd drive two hours to help you move, and they remember your mother's name. That's my observation, and you could probably sort your own friends that way in a minute. If you wait for a non-starter to start, you'll wait indefinitely and conclude something false. If fewer than a third of willing people will send the message, being able to do it is a knack most people lack, and whoever finds it least hard might as well be the one. A better test than the tally is whether they're glad when you get in touch and turn up pleased when you arrange something. If they are, you put in the first thirty seconds and they match everything after.

And then the gap itself becomes the obstacle. At two months you'd have sent "lunch next week?" At fourteen you start drafting an apology in your head, "I'm so sorry I've been useless, things have been mad, I kept meaning to", and it's exhausting before you've typed a word. Next month the gap will be fifteen months and the imagined preamble longer. Three things the embarrassment hides, by my own reasoning. The gap belongs to both of you, so any apology cancels out, and the likeliest reply to one is "don't be daft, I've been just as bad". Long gaps are normal in adult life, and your friend will read fourteen months as life, because that's what their other gaps have been. And the explanation isn't wanted. "I walked past that sandwich place today and thought of you. How are you?" is a pleasure to get. A long apology makes the other person do the work of reassuring you.

Eleven years, since her wedding? The same holds, and the surprise may make it more welcome. And the gap only goes one way. It will never be easier to send than today.

The suspended friendship

The last reason is the one people rarely say aloud. While you don't get in touch, nothing can go wrong. The friendship hangs in a state where it might still be as good as ever. A message tests it. It might come back warm. It might come back as "Hi! Good to hear from you, all fine here, mad busy, hope you're well x". It might not come back at all.

That fear deserves respect. Anyone who says a text can't hurt has forgotten watching the screen after sending one that mattered. So look at the actual risk.

Erica Boothby, Gus Cooney, Gillian Sandstrom and Margaret Clark had pairs of people talk and then rate how much they liked each other and how much they thought the other liked them. People consistently underestimated how much they were liked. They called it the liking gap, and among first-year students getting to know their hall it lasted for months. Those were new acquaintances, so they don't speak directly to your friend. But your estimate of how much people like you is what drives the fear of a flat reply, and if it's like most people's it's set too low. Your friend spent six years of Thursdays with you by choice.

A brisk reply is mostly about their week. Take it at face value and try once more in a few weeks with a specific date. No reply stings. But compare it with now. Today you have a friendship you're not using and a small pang whenever you pass the name. After an unanswered message you'd have the same friendship, unused, plus some information. The suspension preserves a possibility you never draw on, and it costs you the large chance of getting your friend back to avoid a small chance of a mild disappointment. You already know how to get over a message that falls flat. It takes an evening.

Now the part I think matters most. The wait doesn't stay a string of separate decisions. Go on long enough with enough people and it changes the person waiting.

John Cacioppo and Louise Hawkley spent years studying loneliness, which they define as perceived isolation, the feeling that your connections fall short of what you need. You can have it in a crowd and lack it in a lighthouse. In their reviews they report that feeling isolated heightens vigilance for social threat. A lonely person gets quicker to notice signs of rejection, more likely to read an ambiguous signal as a bad one, and more inclined to expect poor treatment and then find it. They call it self-protective and paradoxically self-defeating, because the wariness makes others keep their distance, which confirms the expectation.

After a sociable month, a slow reply looks like a busy friend. After three months of seeing nobody, the same slow reply looks like proof. "Nobody ever rings me" starts to feel like a fact about the world, when it's partly the result of your own silence, matched by theirs. And each time you pass the name and don't write, you're spared a small dread, while the thing causing the dread grows. The habit relieves, minute by minute, a discomfort it's building over months.

There's a hopeful side. Christopher Masi, with Hawkley, Cacioppo and another colleague, pooled studies of ways to reduce loneliness, which taught social skills, gave support, created chances for contact, or addressed what the authors call maladaptive social cognition, the habits of thought I've been describing. Among the properly randomised studies, that last kind worked best. So the usual problem is misreading the signals, and people who wait are mostly fine at friendship.

One fact, said once. Julianne Holt-Lunstad and colleagues pooled long-term studies and found that loneliness, social isolation and living alone each went with a higher risk of early death, by roughly a quarter to a third, which the authors call comparable with well-established risk factors. These are observational, and ill health can cause isolation too. I mention it only because people who wait often treat their social life as a luxury. It belongs with the important things.

"I'm fine on my own." You may be, and I mean that without hedging. Chosen solitude is one of the good things in life, and some people need a lot of it. If you see as many people as you'd like and feel no pang about the ones you don't, nothing here applies to you. Cacioppo and Hawkley's distinction is the useful one. Being alone is a fact about your diary. Loneliness is a gap between what you have and what you want. So check by the pang, not the label. Was there one when you passed the name? When a friend does ring and you talk for forty minutes, do you put the phone down feeling better? Plenty of people who call themselves introverts love seeing a few people, in small numbers, somewhere quiet. If the wait has taken you below even that, the label is covering a shortfall.

"I'd rather stay in" is a forecast, too. Nicholas Epley and Juliana Schroeder asked commuters to talk to a stranger on the train or keep to themselves. People predicted solitude would be nicer, partly because they underestimated how much the person next to them wanted to talk. The ones who talked enjoyed the commute more and got no less done. Those were strangers, which isn't your case. The forecast is sometimes right. It's wrong often enough to test, and on your own terms. You can ring one person, suggest a walk that has a natural end, or see someone for ninety minutes and go home.

Forty seconds in the paper shop

If you're not ready for the name in the list, start smaller.

Gillian Sandstrom and Elizabeth Dunn studied weak ties, the people you know slightly. The man in the paper shop, the woman at the bus stop, the neighbour two doors down. Students who talked to more classmates than usual on a given day reported being happier and feeling they belonged more, and in wider studies, everyday chats with slight acquaintances went with wellbeing alongside time with close friends and family. Those are associations, so they can't prove the chats caused the better days. They fit ordinary life, though. "Morning. The usual? Did you get that fence sorted?" Forty seconds, and you walk out feeling slightly more like someone who belongs somewhere.

Weak ties are low risk, since no friendship is at stake if he grunts. They're available daily. And they're practice against the loop. Each small exchange that goes fine is evidence that people are mostly pleased to be spoken to.

They're also where friends come from. Jeffrey Hall looked at people who'd recently moved, and at first-year students, and found that the hours people spent together were associated with how close they became. Every friend you have was once a weak tie who got enough hours, and that only starts with somebody saying something over the hedge.

So tomorrow, say one sentence more than the transaction needs, to one person you half know. Ask the man in the paper shop how his week's been. Tell the neighbour her roses have done well.

Then there's the hearts. You put one on the picture of the new kitchen and know they went to Portugal, and it feels like keeping up. My own view, untested, is that this takes the edge off the pang that might have got you to ring. You know their news. They don't know yours, and nothing has passed between you.

Which kind of contact does the most good runs against most people's instincts. Amit Kumar and Nicholas Epley had people get back in touch with an old friend by phone or by email. People expected the call to be more awkward. It wasn't, and the ones who'd talked felt a stronger bond. In other studies, any channel with a voice in it created more connection than typed text, with no extra awkwardness. We choose text because it feels safe, and it gives us less.

A message is still the right first move after fourteen months, because it lets them reply in their own time. It's there to open the way to a voice or a face. Four friendly texts ending in "we must catch up properly soon!" leave you where the thumbs up did. If people in your circle think an unexpected call means someone's died, set it up. "Are you around for a ring on Thursday evening?" Parents and older relatives you can simply ring. A voice note, a walk side by side, or "could I drop in for half an hour on Saturday?" all work too.

People stall at the empty message box. Here's what I think works, and it's my view, not research. Up to three sentences.

  • Why you thought of them, specifically. "I walked past the sandwich place on Thursday." It explains why today, and it carries the real news, which is that they have a place in your head.
  • One question about now that they can answer in a line. "How's the new job turned out?"
  • If you like, a concrete suggestion with a date. "Are you free on Saturday the 14th? I could come to you."

Leave out the long apology, your own news, and anything that hands them a project. Above all, leave out "we must catch up soon". It sounds like a plan and contains none. "Are you free on the 14th?" gets yes, no, or "not then, but the 21st?", and any of those moves things on. If they're stretched or grieving, ask nothing. "No need to reply, I just wanted you to know I was thinking of you."

When you do talk, don't stay in the shallows. Michael Kardas, Amit Kumar and Nicholas Epley found that people expected deeper conversations to be far more awkward than they were, and felt more connected afterwards. Most of their pairs were strangers, and predictions were more accurate between close friends, so the gap may be smaller for you. Still, if your year has been rough, say so. "It's been a rough year, to be honest. Mum's not been well." Something real usually gets something real back.

That day

When I think of someone, I get in touch that day.

That's the rule. It sets no target for nights out. It takes something that already happens several times a week, a person crossing your mind because of a song or a street or a name on the way to the plumber, and attaches one action to it. At the moment those thoughts arrive, produce a pang and go away. Under the rule each becomes three sentences, sent before the day is out. Late at night, write it and send it in the morning.

Start with a warm-up, because of Aknin and Sandstrom's last study. Trying to change people's attitudes hadn't got more of them to message an old friend. Practice did. One group spent three minutes messaging current friends and acquaintances. The other spent three minutes browsing social media. Afterwards, offered the chance to message an old friend, 31 per cent of the browsers did and 53 per cent of the practice group did. So before the name in the list, send something friendly to three people you spoke to last month.

Then, for a month, follow the rule without weighing whose turn it is or how long it's been. Once a week, make one move towards a voice or a face, such as a coffee with a date in it, a call, or a neighbour in for tea. Over a year that's fifty occasions that otherwise wouldn't have happened. And keep up the extra sentence in shops.

Plans of the form "when this happens, then I'll do that" have a good record in research. Two worth saying aloud. "When I catch myself thinking it's their turn, or it's been too long, I'll take that as the signal to write." "When someone says we must catch up, I'll reply with a date." The thoughts that stopped you become the cue.

I can't promise an outcome. My expectation is that most messages get a warm reply, often quicker than you predicted, and several will include "I've been meaning to get in touch for ages". Some replies will be slow. Not every revived contact becomes a revived friendship, and that's fine. After two or three months I'd expect more conversations on your phone and a weaker sense that nobody rings, partly because people ring those who've recently rung them.

When there's no reply, the loop will offer the unkind explanation first. More likely they saw it at a bad moment and it slid down the screen, or they're in something hard you don't know about, or they feel bad about the gap and are putting off answering for exactly your reasons. Use a rule of two. Wait three or four weeks and send one more, light, with no reproach. "Thinking of you again. No pressure, but the coffee offer stands." If that gets nothing, let it rest without a grudge and without deleting the number. Some come back a year later.

The friend who's always busy is usually disorganised or has small children. Offer to go to them, offer forty minutes, offer to join the walk to the park with the pram, or fall back on the phone. If they're glad and would see you if they could, that counts. If instead the replies stay short, plans always fall through from their end and they show little interest when you meet, accept what that shows and put your effort where it's returned. Making first moves freely is how you find out quickly which friendships are alive.

Starting from nothing is different. If you've moved, been widowed, retired or spent years caring for someone, the rule can't produce names. You need settings where the same people turn up week after week, so hours can build, like a class, a choir, a walking group or a volunteering shift. The NHS suggests joining a group around something you enjoy, and says you could ask to go along and just watch the first time. It also describes social prescribing, where your GP may refer you to a link worker whose job is to help you find local groups and support. Ask about it.

You'll go quiet again in a bad week. Don't make up for lost time. Do the warm-up, send one message, and you're back.

Please talk to a GP, or in England refer yourself to NHS talking therapies, if any of these sounds like you.

  • A low mood for more than two weeks, or struggling to cope.
  • A general, strong fear of contact, of calls and conversations and being observed. The NHS says social anxiety often doesn't go away without treatment.
  • Loneliness after a bereavement that isn't easing.
  • Thoughts of harming yourself. Get help the same day, through NHS 111, an urgent GP appointment, or 999 in an emergency.

The approaches to loneliness that worked best were the ones that worked on habits of thought, and therapists know how to do that.

Sunday afternoon, about four, the plumber, the name. The pang, and the old thoughts on time. Over a year. Their turn. You recognise them now as the cue. Under the thumbs up you type, "I walked past the sandwich place on Thursday and thought of you. It's been far too long. How's the new job turned out? If you're free on Saturday the 14th I'd love to buy you a coffee." Your thumb hovers, because understanding a fear doesn't make it vanish. You press send, put the phone face down, and ring the plumber.

Forty minutes later it buzzes. "Oh I'm SO glad you messaged. I've been meaning to for months and felt worse about it every week. Can't do the 14th, but are you free on the 21st? I'll come to you."

On the 21st you sit in a café for two and a half hours. Their job is a long story. So is their father's health, which you knew nothing about, and so is your own year, which you hadn't planned to talk about and do. At the end they say, "Why did we leave it so long?" Neither of you has a good answer, and you put the next date in your phones before you leave the table.

They won't all go like that. Some will get a line back and no more, and one or two will get nothing. But your friend was never waiting for a better message or a shorter gap. They were waiting for the other one to go first.

Now send three friendly messages to people you spoke to last month. Then find the name you thought of while reading this, and write to them.