Let them do it badly

Before you start

2 min read

This is a short book and you can read it in two or three sittings. It's about one habit, which is doing things for your children that they could do for themselves, not because you've decided they can't, but because it's quicker, and cleaner, and easier to watch than letting them do it badly. The shoes. The zip. The cereal. The bag. The form for the trip. The phone call. At every age there's a version, and at every age the reason is the same. You've got four minutes and they'd need twelve.

I'm going to argue three things. The first is that the hand goes out for good reasons and that you shouldn't feel bad about it. Time is short, mornings are short, mess is real, and watching a child fail at a zip is hard in a way that nobody warns you about. The second is that the reasons are true on any given morning and false over a childhood. Quicker today means the same job again tomorrow, and the twelve minutes you save are twelve minutes your child doesn't spend learning the thing, so that next year you're still saving them. There's research on what children learn from being allowed to do things, and from being stopped, and it points the same way. The third is practical. Pick one job. Decide what done looks like for a child that age, not for you. Give them the minutes it needs. Then keep your hands to yourself. Chapters 19 to 23 cover how.

This book isn't about chores as punishment, or about making children useful, or about toughening anyone up. It's about the bad version of a job being the only version a child can start with, and what happens when they never get to start.

Three cautions.

Some jobs stay with you. Anything at the hob, anything on a road, medicines, the bath for a small child, the front door. This book is about the zip and the cereal, and nothing in it means handing a six-year-old the kettle.

If your child finds a task much harder than other children of their age, and it isn't one task but most of them, that may be more than age. The NHS pages on ADHD and autism describe what to look for, and the first person to talk to is usually their teacher, who can involve the school's special educational needs coordinator. A GP is the next step. Chapter 24 is written with that child in mind and some of the method changes.

And if your child has a disability that means a task genuinely isn't theirs to do, the method still applies to the tasks that are. The question is never whether to do everything for them. It's which things.

The notes at the back give my sources and their limits. Where I'm giving my own reasoning and not a finding, I'll say so.